success
bool 1
class | result
stringlengths 202
1.67k
| good_image
stringlengths 89
286
| bad_image
stringlengths 89
286
| prompt
stringlengths 19
2.48k
| id
stringlengths 1
5
| analysis
stringlengths 119
1.45k
| better_image
stringclasses 3
values | instructions
stringlengths 0
440
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict the scene described in the prompt, but the right image aligns better. The right image includes a more accurate representation of the green lamp with hanging tendrils, the circular purple and green table, and the stack of books on the floor. The left image has a simpler lamp design without tendrils, and the table lacks the green accent. Additionally, the stack of books in the left image is less detailed and does not match the whimsical style as well as the right image.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add green tendrils to the lamp to match the whimsical design. Add a green accent to the circular table to align with the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49742_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49742_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Colorful illustration of a young girl sitting on a teal and brown chair, engrossed in reading a blue book titled "The Twilight Under the Water." She has long, flowing orange hair and wears a yellow shirt with a vibrant green skirt adorned with large pink flowers. Her facial expression shows surprise. A cartoonish purple manta ray rests atop her head. To the right, a unique green lamp with hanging tendrils provides illumination. Below the lamp, a circular purple and green table supports a speech bubble-like shape with the word "EXCITED" in yellow text. A small stack of books titled "The Twilight Under the Water" is neatly arranged on the floor to her left. The composition is playful and whimsical with bold outlines, pastel and neon shades, smooth gradients, stylized character design, dynamic pose, vibrant color palette, soft shading, digital illustration, imaginative atmosphere. | 14137 | Both images depict the scene described in the prompt, but the right image aligns better. The right image includes a more accurate representation of the green lamp with hanging tendrils, the circular purple and green table, and the stack of books on the floor. The left image has a simpler lamp design without tendrils, and the table lacks the green accent. Additionally, the stack of books in the left image is less detailed and does not match the whimsical style as well as the right image. | right | Add green tendrils to the lamp to match the whimsical design. Add a green accent to the circular table to align with the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a centrally positioned minimalist two-story house with clean lines, a flat roof, and a mix of white walls and gray stacked stone panels. The large window with a roller blind is correctly placed on the top right, and the wooden double door is slightly left of center. The landscaping includes tall spiky green plants, red-leaf plants, and low green shrubs, and the gray paver sidewalk is present. The right image has discrepancies: the wooden double door is missing, replaced by a glass door, and the landscaping is less accurate, with the spiky green plants and red-leaf plants not properly positioned. Additionally, the roller blind on the top right window is absent.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the glass door with a wooden double door slightly left of center. Add a roller blind to the large window on the top right."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49743_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49743_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Modern architectural photo of a minimalist two-story house under a deep blue sky. The house is centrally positioned, exhibiting a sleek design with clean lines and a flat roof. The upper level features a mix of smooth white walls and a section with gray stacked stone panels. A large, single window with a roller blind is visible on the top right, while the ground floor includes a glass front with a white trim, blending indoors and outdoors. A wooden double door slightly left of center provides an entrance. The front yard is landscaped with a row of tall, spiky green plants to the left, red-leaf plants, and low green shrubs in front of the house. A short set of steps leads down to a gray paver sidewalk. To the right, a dark gray metal gate encloses the area. The background shows neighboring houses in warm hues, with orange roofs and arched windows. Sharp lighting highlights the angularity of the design, minimalistic suburban style, photorealistic textures, high contrast, vibrant colors, pristine and orderly environment, clear and bright midday ambiance. | 14138 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a centrally positioned minimalist two-story house with clean lines, a flat roof, and a mix of white walls and gray stacked stone panels. The large window with a roller blind is correctly placed on the top right, and the wooden double door is slightly left of center. The landscaping includes tall spiky green plants, red-leaf plants, and low green shrubs, and the gray paver sidewalk is present. The right image has discrepancies: the wooden double door is missing, replaced by a glass door, and the landscaping is less accurate, with the spiky green plants and red-leaf plants not properly positioned. Additionally, the roller blind on the top right window is absent. | left | Replace the glass door with a wooden double door slightly left of center. Add a roller blind to the large window on the top right. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it portrays the fencer in a more dynamic and low stance, emphasizing movement and posture. The right image has a less dynamic pose, with the fencer standing more upright, which diminishes the sense of action. Additionally, the left image includes subtle shading and a textured ground element that enhances the earthy and textured aesthetic described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Lower the fencer's stance to make it more dynamic and wide. Add subtle shading and a textured ground element to enhance the earthy and textured aesthetic."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49745_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49745_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Illustration of a fencer mid-action on a textured beige background. The fencer is portrayed from a side angle, facing to the left, positioned dynamically in the left foreground. The figure is clad in fencing gear, including a white jacket with a light olive vest, fencing mask, and black gloves. The fencer's stance is low and wide, with one arm extended forward, gripping a thin, straight saber. The other arm is bent backward for balance. The fencer's legs are robust, with white socks and black fencing shoes. The entire composition emphasizes movement and posture. Stylized, minimalist, matte texture, earthy color palette, dynamic composition, simplistic and bold shapes, soft textures resembling paper or canvas, subtle shading, illustrative art style. | 14140 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it portrays the fencer in a more dynamic and low stance, emphasizing movement and posture. The right image has a less dynamic pose, with the fencer standing more upright, which diminishes the sense of action. Additionally, the left image includes subtle shading and a textured ground element that enhances the earthy and textured aesthetic described in the prompt. | left | Lower the fencer's stance to make it more dynamic and wide. Add subtle shading and a textured ground element to enhance the earthy and textured aesthetic. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a large, imposing high-rise building with a grid-like pattern of balconies and windows dominating the background. The crowd of indistinct human figures in business attire is scattered across the foreground, blending into the shadows with an ethereal quality. The high contrast black-and-white palette, soft edges, and smudged textures evoke the intended sense of anonymity and alienation. The right image, while similar, lacks the sharply angled, perspective-driven lines of the central building and does not emphasize the grid-like patterns as prominently. Additionally, the crowd in the right image appears less integrated into the shadows, reducing the ghostly effect.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the grid-like patterns of balconies and windows on the central high-rise building to make them more prominent. Increase the blending of the human figures into the shadows to create a more ethereal and ghostly quality."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49744_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49744_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Moody monochrome illustration of a bustling urban scene centered on a large, imposing high-rise building with repetitive, grid-like patterns of balconies and windows. The building dominates the background with its sharply angled, perspective-driven lines. In the foreground, a crowd of indistinct human figures, primarily middle-aged men and women in business attire, are scattered across the scene in various states of motion, some walking, others standing. They blend into the shadows, giving an ethereal and ghostly quality. The artwork employs a high contrast black-and-white palette, with soft edges and smudged textures, evoking a sense of anonymity and alienation. Dramatic chiaroscuro, atmospheric perspective, dense, layered composition, urban isolation theme, stylistic use of light and shadow, charcoal-like strokes, stark and unforgiving architecture juxtaposed with fragile human presence. | 14139 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a large, imposing high-rise building with a grid-like pattern of balconies and windows dominating the background. The crowd of indistinct human figures in business attire is scattered across the foreground, blending into the shadows with an ethereal quality. The high contrast black-and-white palette, soft edges, and smudged textures evoke the intended sense of anonymity and alienation. The right image, while similar, lacks the sharply angled, perspective-driven lines of the central building and does not emphasize the grid-like patterns as prominently. Additionally, the crowd in the right image appears less integrated into the shadows, reducing the ghostly effect. | left | Enhance the grid-like patterns of balconies and windows on the central high-rise building to make them more prominent. Increase the blending of the human figures into the shadows to create a more ethereal and ghostly quality. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features five horses in shades of blue, grey, and brown, as described, and their forms are abstract and smoothly integrated with the background, giving a sense of motion. The white and yellow strokes resembling birds or stars are present and enhance the dynamic movement. The foreground includes brushstroke-like tall grasses in muted pink and beige, and the background gradient transitions from deep to light blue, creating depth. The right image, while visually appealing, depicts six horses instead of five, and the horses are more realistic rather than abstract. Additionally, the foreground grasses lack the painterly, brushstroke-like quality, and the overall texture is less dreamy and ethereal compared to the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reduce the number of horses to five, ensuring they are in shades of blue, grey, and brown. Adjust the foreground grasses to have a more painterly, brushstroke-like texture in muted pink and beige."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49746_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49746_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Illustration of a group of stylized horses galloping through a textured landscape. Five horses in various shades of blue, grey, and brown are depicted in the center, moving from left to right. Their forms are abstract and smoothly integrated with the background, giving a sense of motion. White and yellow strokes resembling birds or stars trail overhead, enhancing the dynamic movement. The foreground shows a field with brushstroke-like tall grasses in muted pink and beige, while the background features a gradient of deep to light blue, creating a sense of depth. Stylistically, the image is painterly, utilizing a soft, blended texture with a dreamy, ethereal quality. The color palette is cool with hints of warmer earth tones, evoking a serene, magical atmosphere. The composition is balanced, with flowing lines and harmonious color blending, creating a poetic, dreamlike visual experience. | 14141 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features five horses in shades of blue, grey, and brown, as described, and their forms are abstract and smoothly integrated with the background, giving a sense of motion. The white and yellow strokes resembling birds or stars are present and enhance the dynamic movement. The foreground includes brushstroke-like tall grasses in muted pink and beige, and the background gradient transitions from deep to light blue, creating depth. The right image, while visually appealing, depicts six horses instead of five, and the horses are more realistic rather than abstract. Additionally, the foreground grasses lack the painterly, brushstroke-like quality, and the overall texture is less dreamy and ethereal compared to the left image. | left | Reduce the number of horses to five, ensuring they are in shades of blue, grey, and brown. Adjust the foreground grasses to have a more painterly, brushstroke-like texture in muted pink and beige. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the air vent with sleek black slats and a chrome control lever in the lower left foreground, the glossy black side view mirror prominently positioned to the right, and the white stitching on the black leather dashboard. The right image lacks the Bang & Olufsen speaker grille integrated into the silver metallic section of the dashboard and does not prominently feature the glossy black side view mirror. Additionally, the fabric-covered pillar and small round speaker emerging from the dash are missing in the right image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a Bang & Olufsen speaker grille integrated into the silver metallic section of the dashboard. Include a fabric-covered pillar with a small round speaker emerging from the dash in the upper section."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49747_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49747_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Black and white photograph of a luxury car's interior focusing on the right dashboard and side view mirror. The dashboard features an air vent in the lower left foreground with sleek black slats and a chrome control lever. Above and to the right, a high-end Bang & Olufsen speaker grille is integrated into the silver metallic section of the dashboard. The side view mirror is positioned prominently to the right, showcasing a glossy black finish. A distinct seam with white stitching runs across the black leather surface of the dashboard, adding a touch of elegance. In the upper section, a fabric-covered pillar is visible, blending seamlessly into the roof, with a small round speaker emerging from the dash. Monochromatic, high contrast, minimalistic design, luxury automotive photography, sharp focus, sleek textures, modern elegance. | 14142 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the air vent with sleek black slats and a chrome control lever in the lower left foreground, the glossy black side view mirror prominently positioned to the right, and the white stitching on the black leather dashboard. The right image lacks the Bang & Olufsen speaker grille integrated into the silver metallic section of the dashboard and does not prominently feature the glossy black side view mirror. Additionally, the fabric-covered pillar and small round speaker emerging from the dash are missing in the right image. | left | Add a Bang & Olufsen speaker grille integrated into the silver metallic section of the dashboard. Include a fabric-covered pillar with a small round speaker emerging from the dash in the upper section. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a gold-colored chocolate bar being lifted from its partially opened packaging, with the hand positioned in the top left quadrant. The packaging has a combination of brown and white paper with geometric and graphic patterns, including circular designs and text. Additionally, a second, fully wrapped chocolate bar is present at the bottom right of the frame. The right image, however, has a hand positioned more centrally, the packaging design lacks the specified geometric and graphic patterns, and the second chocolate bar is partially unwrapped and not fully wrapped as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reposition the hand to the top left quadrant of the image. Replace the partially unwrapped chocolate bar with a fully wrapped one in the bottom right of the frame."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49748_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49748_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Close-up product photography of a person's hand holding a rectangular, gold-colored chocolate bar being lifted from its partially opened packaging. The hand is positioned in the top left quadrant of the image, with fingers gently grasping the top edge of the chocolate. The packaging beneath is a combination of brown and white paper with unique geometric and graphic patterns, featuring circular designs and text. A second, fully wrapped chocolate bar rests at the bottom right of the frame. The background and surface are a muted, matte brown, enhancing the earthy, warm aesthetic. The lighting is soft and diffused, highlighting the texture of the chocolate and paper wrapping, high contrast, minimalist composition, elegant, contemporary design. | 14143 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a gold-colored chocolate bar being lifted from its partially opened packaging, with the hand positioned in the top left quadrant. The packaging has a combination of brown and white paper with geometric and graphic patterns, including circular designs and text. Additionally, a second, fully wrapped chocolate bar is present at the bottom right of the frame. The right image, however, has a hand positioned more centrally, the packaging design lacks the specified geometric and graphic patterns, and the second chocolate bar is partially unwrapped and not fully wrapped as described in the prompt. | left | Reposition the hand to the top left quadrant of the image. Replace the partially unwrapped chocolate bar with a fully wrapped one in the bottom right of the frame. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image includes a toilet in the recessed section, which is inconsistent with the prompt's description of a mosaic-tiled curved surface suggesting a shower or changing area. The right image correctly features the mosaic-tiled curved surface with vertical openings, aligning with the prompt. Both images have the indoor pool, soft natural lighting, and minimalist design, but the right image better matches the described elements of the recessed section.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Remove the toilet from the recessed section. Add a mosaic-tiled curved surface with vertical openings in the recessed section."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49752_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49752_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Minimalist interior of a sleek, contemporary space featuring an indoor pool in the lower right foreground. The surface of the water reflects soft, natural lighting, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere. A gently textured gray stone floor surrounds the pool, leading up to the stark white walls that dominate the center and left background. To the left, there is a recessed section with a closed white door and sleek, white cabinetry. Three large vertical openings break the wall, revealing a mosaic-tiled curved surface behind, suggesting a shower or changing area. The recessed lighting fixture is positioned on the ceiling above the living space. The overall composition is clean and orderly, emphasizing symmetry and balance. The style is characterized by minimalist architecture, neutral color palette, soft natural lighting, high contrast between textures, serene and tranquil ambiance, modern and luxurious, sharp lines, and an uncluttered aesthetic. | 14146 | The left image includes a toilet in the recessed section, which is inconsistent with the prompt's description of a mosaic-tiled curved surface suggesting a shower or changing area. The right image correctly features the mosaic-tiled curved surface with vertical openings, aligning with the prompt. Both images have the indoor pool, soft natural lighting, and minimalist design, but the right image better matches the described elements of the recessed section. | right | Remove the toilet from the recessed section. Add a mosaic-tiled curved surface with vertical openings in the recessed section. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict the scene described in the prompt, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. In the left image, the woman and child are positioned in the right foreground, and the man in the teal sweater and scarf is clearly visible in the center background beside the small plane with a green tail. The expansive tarmac and distant treeline are also present. In the right image, the man is less prominently positioned, and the framing does not emphasize the cinematic family narrative as effectively as the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reposition the man in the background closer to the plane to make him more prominent. Adjust the framing to emphasize the cinematic family narrative by slightly shifting the focus towards the woman and child in the foreground."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49751_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49751_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Photo of a woman and child embracing in the right foreground, standing on an airport tarmac under a clear blue sky. The woman, wearing a mustard yellow sweater, gazes into the distance with a contemplative expression, while the child, in a grey sweater, looks upwards with curiosity. In the center background, a man in a teal sweater and scarf, holding a black bag, stands beside a small plane with a green tail. The expansive tarmac leads towards a distant treeline, accentuated by soft natural lighting from the left. Warm color palette, medium depth of field, high contrast, photorealistic, cinematic framing with a family narrative, serene and reflective atmosphere. | 14145 | Both images depict the scene described in the prompt, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. In the left image, the woman and child are positioned in the right foreground, and the man in the teal sweater and scarf is clearly visible in the center background beside the small plane with a green tail. The expansive tarmac and distant treeline are also present. In the right image, the man is less prominently positioned, and the framing does not emphasize the cinematic family narrative as effectively as the left image. | left | Reposition the man in the background closer to the plane to make him more prominent. Adjust the framing to emphasize the cinematic family narrative by slightly shifting the focus towards the woman and child in the foreground. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes the large, rounded creature with antennae sitting atop a geometric structure on the right, holding a small toy-like figure. The small, smiling creature with sharp teeth scurrying across a black line is present, as well as the figure with long limbs and bulbous hands reaching upwards. The legged sphere and the flower with a smiling face in the lower left corner are also depicted. Additionally, abstract shapes and faces, including one with circular eyes and a crown-like adornment, float throughout the scene. The right image lacks the diagonal piano-like structure emerging from a distorted hand and does not fully capture the whimsical, surrealistic, and detailed nature of the prompt. It also misses the exaggerated forms and clean, bold outlines seen in the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a diagonal piano-like structure emerging from a distorted hand in the background. Include more abstract shapes and faces floating throughout the scene to enhance the surrealistic and whimsical elements."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49750_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49750_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Surreal black and white illustration featuring a whimsical, abstract landscape. A large, rounded creature with antennae sits atop a geometric structure on the right, holding a small toy-like figure. Below, a small, smiling creature with sharp teeth scurries across a black line. To the left, a figure with long limbs and bulbous hands reaches upwards, while another legged sphere stands nearby. In the background, a diagonal piano-like structure emerges from a distorted hand. Various abstract shapes and faces, including one with circular eyes and a crown-like adornment, float throughout the scene. A flower with a smiling face appears in the lower left corner. High contrast, minimalist, line art, imaginative, surrealistic, whimsical, playful, detailed characters and objects, exaggerated forms, clean, bold outlines. | 14144 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes the large, rounded creature with antennae sitting atop a geometric structure on the right, holding a small toy-like figure. The small, smiling creature with sharp teeth scurrying across a black line is present, as well as the figure with long limbs and bulbous hands reaching upwards. The legged sphere and the flower with a smiling face in the lower left corner are also depicted. Additionally, abstract shapes and faces, including one with circular eyes and a crown-like adornment, float throughout the scene. The right image lacks the diagonal piano-like structure emerging from a distorted hand and does not fully capture the whimsical, surrealistic, and detailed nature of the prompt. It also misses the exaggerated forms and clean, bold outlines seen in the left image. | left | Add a diagonal piano-like structure emerging from a distorted hand in the background. Include more abstract shapes and faces floating throughout the scene to enhance the surrealistic and whimsical elements. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a door with a frosted glass panel along the right edge but lacks the central vertical frosted glass panel. The handle is not sleek and vertical but rather a standard horizontal handle. The icon of the bed and the text 'Recovery Room' are present but not positioned optimally. The right image includes a central vertical frosted glass panel, a sleek vertical handle, and a properly positioned bed icon with text in both Korean and English. However, it lacks the frosted glass panel along the right edge of the door.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a narrow frosted glass panel along the right edge of the door. Adjust the lighting to create a more subtle contrast with soft natural shadows."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49754_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49754_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Minimalistic photo of a pale beige recovery room door, featuring a sleek, vertical handle and two narrow frosted glass panels—one placed centrally, extending vertically, and the other along the right edge of the door. Positioned to the right is a stylized icon of a bed, indicating the room's function, with the words "Recovery Room" written below in both Korean and English. The door is partially shadowed, creating subtle contrast. Clean, modern design, simple composition, soft natural lighting, neutral color palette, serene, minimalist aesthetic, hospital environment, highly polished texture. | 14148 | The left image features a door with a frosted glass panel along the right edge but lacks the central vertical frosted glass panel. The handle is not sleek and vertical but rather a standard horizontal handle. The icon of the bed and the text 'Recovery Room' are present but not positioned optimally. The right image includes a central vertical frosted glass panel, a sleek vertical handle, and a properly positioned bed icon with text in both Korean and English. However, it lacks the frosted glass panel along the right edge of the door. | right | Add a narrow frosted glass panel along the right edge of the door. Adjust the lighting to create a more subtle contrast with soft natural shadows. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a minimalist style, a clean and focused composition, and a vivid green square background. The adult and child are positioned correctly, with the adult bending slightly towards the child, who is pointing at the water stream. The right image, while also depicting the scene, includes unnecessary elements such as multiple water arcs and a 3D-like elevated green square, which detracts from the minimalist and flat design style described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the multiple water arcs and retain only one arc on the left side. Flatten the elevated green square to match a flat design style."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49755_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49755_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Illustration of an adult and child engaging with a fountain. The adult, wearing a striped shirt and blue pants, stands to the right, bending slightly towards the child. The child, dressed in a blue outfit, stands to the left, pointing towards the stream of water from the fountain. They are both positioned in the center of a small, vivid green square, suggesting a garden or park setting. White water arcs are visible on the left side. Minimalist style, bright color palette, flat design, playful, simplistic, focused composition, clean lines, stylized figures, contrast between bold green background and blue clothing. | 14149 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a minimalist style, a clean and focused composition, and a vivid green square background. The adult and child are positioned correctly, with the adult bending slightly towards the child, who is pointing at the water stream. The right image, while also depicting the scene, includes unnecessary elements such as multiple water arcs and a 3D-like elevated green square, which detracts from the minimalist and flat design style described in the prompt. | left | Remove the multiple water arcs and retain only one arc on the left side. Flatten the elevated green square to match a flat design style. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a minimalist design with a glowing geometric logo in light green, the word 'Atlants' below it in the correct color, and the phrases 'YOUR' and 'NEXT STEP' positioned correctly at the top left and bottom right. The background is a muted green with soft shadows casting to the left, and the tote bag has a matte texture. The right image has inaccuracies: the text 'YOUR' and 'NEXT STEP' are misaligned and include additional words, and the shadows are less pronounced, reducing the sense of depth.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Correct the alignment and content of the text 'YOUR' and 'NEXT STEP' to match the prompt. Enhance the shadows to cast softly to the left for better depth."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49753_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49753_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | A minimalist product photo of a black tote bag with a stylized, glowing geometric logo that features an angular design in light green. The logo is centrally positioned, with the word "Atlants" below it in a similar light green color. The words "YOUR" and "NEXT STEP" appear at the top left and bottom right, respectively, in small font. The tote has two flat black handles extending upward. The bag is placed centrally against a uniform, muted green background with soft shadows casting to the left, giving a sense of depth. Natural lighting, photorealistic, high contrast, modern design, clean, matte texture, balanced composition, simplicity meets elegance, flat lay perspective. | 14147 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a minimalist design with a glowing geometric logo in light green, the word 'Atlants' below it in the correct color, and the phrases 'YOUR' and 'NEXT STEP' positioned correctly at the top left and bottom right. The background is a muted green with soft shadows casting to the left, and the tote bag has a matte texture. The right image has inaccuracies: the text 'YOUR' and 'NEXT STEP' are misaligned and include additional words, and the shadows are less pronounced, reducing the sense of depth. | left | Correct the alignment and content of the text 'YOUR' and 'NEXT STEP' to match the prompt. Enhance the shadows to cast softly to the left for better depth. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a patterned bucket hat partially shading the woman's eyes, a bright pink jacket with black trim and visible snaps on the left shoulder, and a white textured top. The hands frame the face while holding the brim of the hat, and the multicolored beaded necklace is visible. The background gradient and dramatic side lighting are also present. The right image, while similar, has a less prominent shading effect from the hat, the jacket's black trim is less defined, and the snaps on the left shoulder are missing.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add visible snaps to the left shoulder of the jacket. Enhance the shading effect of the hat to partially obscure the eyes."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49756_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49756_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Close-up portrait of a young woman with light skin wearing a patterned bucket hat partially shading her eyes, centrally positioned. She wears a bright pink jacket with black trim and snaps visible on the left shoulder, layered over a white textured top. Her hands, with manicured nails, hold the brim of the hat, framing her face. A multicolored, beaded necklace is visible around her neck. The background features a gradient from teal to pale blue, adding depth to the scene. Dramatic side lighting creates intriguing shadows over her face, emphasizing the texture of her glossy lips. Fashion photography, high contrast, sharp focus on facial features, bold color palette, contemporary style, editorial, dynamic composition, moody atmosphere. | 14150 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a patterned bucket hat partially shading the woman's eyes, a bright pink jacket with black trim and visible snaps on the left shoulder, and a white textured top. The hands frame the face while holding the brim of the hat, and the multicolored beaded necklace is visible. The background gradient and dramatic side lighting are also present. The right image, while similar, has a less prominent shading effect from the hat, the jacket's black trim is less defined, and the snaps on the left shoulder are missing. | left | Add visible snaps to the left shoulder of the jacket. Enhance the shading effect of the hat to partially obscure the eyes. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a vertical color photograph of an interior space with a wooden-framed window, blue sky visible outside, and sunlight creating geometric patterns on white walls. The opposite page includes text in the top right corner and a black-and-white architectural photograph of a building with a smooth facade on columns, casting shadows. The right image has a horizontal photograph of the window instead of a vertical one, and the black-and-white photograph lacks the smooth facade and column details described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the horizontal photograph of the window with a vertical one, ensuring the wooden frame and geometric sunlight patterns on white walls are visible. Modify the black-and-white photograph to include a building with a smooth facade on columns, casting shadows on the ground."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49757_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49757_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Open magazine spread featuring minimalist architectural photography. The left page displays a vertical color photograph of an interior space, focusing on a window with a wooden frame and blue sky visible outside. Sunlight creates geometric patterns on the white walls. On the opposite page, in the top right corner, text reads "Projeto Tiribáçá 2021" followed by a brief description in Portuguese. Below the text, a black and white architectural photograph shows part of a building with a smooth facade, positioned on columns, casting shadows on the ground. The setting suggests an interplay of light and texture with modern design elements. The overall style is clean, contemporary, even composition, neutral beige background, polished, professional layout, emphasis on architectural details, contrast between color and monochrome imagery. | 14151 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a vertical color photograph of an interior space with a wooden-framed window, blue sky visible outside, and sunlight creating geometric patterns on white walls. The opposite page includes text in the top right corner and a black-and-white architectural photograph of a building with a smooth facade on columns, casting shadows. The right image has a horizontal photograph of the window instead of a vertical one, and the black-and-white photograph lacks the smooth facade and column details described in the prompt. | left | Replace the horizontal photograph of the window with a vertical one, ensuring the wooden frame and geometric sunlight patterns on white walls are visible. Modify the black-and-white photograph to include a building with a smooth facade on columns, casting shadows on the ground. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a koi fish with vibrant orange and black patterns on a white body, set within a circular motif resembling an eye. The circular motif has a thick white outline, and the upper left includes a pattern of orange squares distributed sporadically. The lower portion includes a soft teal-colored curve, and the textured paint creates a tactile quality. The right image lacks the dynamic distribution of orange squares in the upper left, and the teal curve in the lower portion is less prominent. Additionally, the koi fish in the right image has less detailed orange and black patterns, reducing the vibrancy and contrast described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a sporadic pattern of orange squares in the upper left corner. Enhance the teal curve in the lower portion to make it more prominent and dynamic."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49758_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49758_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Abstract painting featuring a koi fish set within a large circular motif resembling an eye, occupying the center of the composition. The koi fish is detailed with vibrant orange and black patterns against a white body, contrasting sharply with the bold black of the surrounding circular design. The circular form is accentuated with a thick white outline. The upper left features a pattern of orange squares, distributed sporadically across the black background, adding a dynamic element. The lower portion hints at a soft teal-colored curve. Textured, layered paint creates a tactile quality. This piece exhibits high contrast, with a vivid color palette of orange, black, white, and teal, abstract-impressionistic style, with a focus on contrast and texture, balanced composition, strong geometric forms, and a sense of whimsy and depth. | 14152 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a koi fish with vibrant orange and black patterns on a white body, set within a circular motif resembling an eye. The circular motif has a thick white outline, and the upper left includes a pattern of orange squares distributed sporadically. The lower portion includes a soft teal-colored curve, and the textured paint creates a tactile quality. The right image lacks the dynamic distribution of orange squares in the upper left, and the teal curve in the lower portion is less prominent. Additionally, the koi fish in the right image has less detailed orange and black patterns, reducing the vibrancy and contrast described in the prompt. | left | Add a sporadic pattern of orange squares in the upper left corner. Enhance the teal curve in the lower portion to make it more prominent and dynamic. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as the flowers are arranged diagonally from the bottom left corner to the middle of the frame, matching the specified composition. The right image has the flowers arranged more horizontally, which deviates from the diagonal alignment described in the prompt. Additionally, the left image has a slightly warmer color palette and a more pronounced dreamy atmosphere, which aligns better with the ethereal and tranquil mood requested.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Rearrange the flowers to form a diagonal alignment from the bottom left corner to the middle of the frame. Adjust the color palette to introduce warmer tones for a dreamy and tranquil atmosphere."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49760_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49760_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Close-up photograph of a delicate purple flower vine resting on a rustic wooden surface. The flowers are aligned diagonally from the bottom left corner to the middle of the frame, their vibrant purple hues contrasting against the earthy tones of the wood. Behind the flowers, a blurred, arid desert landscape stretches towards distant hills under a soft blue sky with wispy clouds. The shallow depth of field keeps the flowers sharply in focus while rendering the background as a smooth bokeh blur. Dreamy atmosphere, natural lighting, warm color palette, ethereal and tranquil mood, high contrast between foreground and background, visually balanced composition with a low angle perspective. | 14154 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as the flowers are arranged diagonally from the bottom left corner to the middle of the frame, matching the specified composition. The right image has the flowers arranged more horizontally, which deviates from the diagonal alignment described in the prompt. Additionally, the left image has a slightly warmer color palette and a more pronounced dreamy atmosphere, which aligns better with the ethereal and tranquil mood requested. | left | Rearrange the flowers to form a diagonal alignment from the bottom left corner to the middle of the frame. Adjust the color palette to introduce warmer tones for a dreamy and tranquil atmosphere. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better matches the prompt. It features a central area dominated by rectangular, tan-colored buildings with complex pipework on the roofs, aligned vertically along the center-right. To the left, there are circular and dome-shaped structures resembling storage tanks with piping, and evenly spaced cylindrical stacks are adjacent to the central buildings. The terrain is grey gravel, with long shadows cast by the buildings. Roadways and pathways weave around the site, and multiple vehicles, including a yellow one, are scattered in the upper-left quadrant. Compact utility structures with visible power lines occupy the bottom-right section. The right image, while similar, has a less accurate layout of the central buildings and lacks the evenly spaced cylindrical stacks. The vehicles and utility structures are less prominent and do not align as well with the prompt's description.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Rearrange the central rectangular buildings to align vertically along the center-right. Add evenly spaced cylindrical stacks adjacent to the central buildings."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49759_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49759_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Aerial photograph of an industrial facility in a barren landscape, viewed from directly above. Central area dominated by a series of rectangular, tan-colored buildings with complex pipework on the roofs, facing vertically along the center-right, likely power station units. To the left, circular and dome-shaped structures possibly including storage tanks with piping, highlight the facility's industrial nature. Adjacent to the central buildings are evenly spaced, cylindrical stacks. Buildings cast long shadows on the adjacent grey gravel terrain. Roadways and pathways weave around the site, with multiple vehicles, including a yellow one, scattered predominantly in the upper-left quadrant. Compact utility structures, likely substations with visible power lines, occupy the bottom-right section. Surrounding environment mostly arid with sparse vegetation in the distant upper area, clear grid pattern emphasized by sharp sunlight, high contrast, overhead perspective, highly detailed, industrial scale, arid desolate setting, captured with precision, architectural photography, utilitarian visuals, linear and geometric consistency. | 14153 | The left image better matches the prompt. It features a central area dominated by rectangular, tan-colored buildings with complex pipework on the roofs, aligned vertically along the center-right. To the left, there are circular and dome-shaped structures resembling storage tanks with piping, and evenly spaced cylindrical stacks are adjacent to the central buildings. The terrain is grey gravel, with long shadows cast by the buildings. Roadways and pathways weave around the site, and multiple vehicles, including a yellow one, are scattered in the upper-left quadrant. Compact utility structures with visible power lines occupy the bottom-right section. The right image, while similar, has a less accurate layout of the central buildings and lacks the evenly spaced cylindrical stacks. The vehicles and utility structures are less prominent and do not align as well with the prompt's description. | left | Rearrange the central rectangular buildings to align vertically along the center-right. Add evenly spaced cylindrical stacks adjacent to the central buildings. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the dynamic throw maneuver with one wrestler inverted and elevated, legs pointing upward with one foot crossing the other. The muscular tension, motion lines, and swirling abstract background with splattered ink effects are well-executed. The right image, while dynamic, depicts a different wrestling action where the inverted position and crossed legs are missing, and the sense of motion is less pronounced.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the position of the elevated wrestler to be inverted with legs pointing upward and one foot crossing the other. Enhance the swirling abstract background with more pronounced splattered ink effects to emphasize motion."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49761_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49761_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Dynamic black and white illustration of two wrestlers in mid-action, engaging in a throw maneuver. The central figure on the left, a muscular individual in a grappling stance, supports another wrestler who is inverted and elevated, his legs pointing upward with one foot crossing the other's. Both wear tight-fitting singlets and lace-up wrestling shoes, showcasing detailed muscular tension and movement lines. The background features a swirling abstract pattern, accentuating the motion and kinetic energy of the scene with splattered ink effects. The style is bold, with high contrast and a graphic, almost woodcut-like texture, emphasizing raw strength and the dramatic intensity of the sport. A sense of motion and agitation is captured through the exaggerated form and dynamic composition, visually intense and striking. | 14155 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the dynamic throw maneuver with one wrestler inverted and elevated, legs pointing upward with one foot crossing the other. The muscular tension, motion lines, and swirling abstract background with splattered ink effects are well-executed. The right image, while dynamic, depicts a different wrestling action where the inverted position and crossed legs are missing, and the sense of motion is less pronounced. | left | Adjust the position of the elevated wrestler to be inverted with legs pointing upward and one foot crossing the other. Enhance the swirling abstract background with more pronounced splattered ink effects to emphasize motion. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a vibrant red cape with intricate patterns and fringed edges, matching the description. The woman's pose with her hands beside her head and her softly closed eyes is accurate. The right image lacks the intricate patterns on the cape, and the pose is less aligned with the prompt as her hands are not positioned beside her head. Additionally, the lighting and overall composition in the left image are more striking and balanced, enhancing the high-fashion editorial vibe described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add intricate patterns to the red cape to match the description. Adjust the woman's pose so her hands are raised beside her head with her eyes softly closed."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49762_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49762_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Fashion photograph of a woman standing in a snowy mountain landscape. She is centrally positioned, wearing a vibrant red cape with intricate patterns and fringed edges over a black turtleneck and a long white skirt. Her hair is styled in an elaborate topknot, and her eyes are softly closed. She holds her hands up beside her head in a poised manner. The snow-covered mountain backdrop provides a stark contrast to her outfit, adding to the dramatic effect. Bright, natural lighting enhances the vivid colors and textures of her clothing, while casting minimal shadows on the pristine white snow. The scene is serene yet striking, with a high-fashion editorial vibe. Visual emphasis on texture and color contrast, crisp and clear, visually striking, balanced composition. | 14156 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a vibrant red cape with intricate patterns and fringed edges, matching the description. The woman's pose with her hands beside her head and her softly closed eyes is accurate. The right image lacks the intricate patterns on the cape, and the pose is less aligned with the prompt as her hands are not positioned beside her head. Additionally, the lighting and overall composition in the left image are more striking and balanced, enhancing the high-fashion editorial vibe described in the prompt. | left | Add intricate patterns to the red cape to match the description. Adjust the woman's pose so her hands are raised beside her head with her eyes softly closed. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the specified floating wooden desk integrated with vertical wooden shelves filled with books, a flat-screen TV mounted beside them, and a gray upholstered chair with wooden legs. The right image deviates by having horizontal shelves instead of vertical ones, lacks the flat-screen TV, and includes additional unnecessary elements like a desk lamp. The left image also better captures the minimalist and Scandinavian design influences described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the horizontal wooden shelves with vertical wooden shelves filled with books. Add a flat-screen TV mounted beside the shelves on the wall."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49765_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49765_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Modern minimalist interior of a narrow bedroom with a workspace. The left wall features sleek, white, handleless cabinets. Towards the center, a floating wooden desk is integrated with vertical wooden shelves filled with books, with a flat-screen TV mounted beside them. A gray upholstered chair with wooden legs is tucked under the desk. A silver laptop and small potted plant rest on the desk. The right rear corner shows a large potted plant in a textured black pot next to a window with sheer curtains, letting in diffused natural light. In front of the window, a low-profile gray bed with a textured brown rug beneath it. Light wooden flooring stretches throughout, complemented by a discreet black track light running along the ceiling. Minimalist, photorealistic render, natural lighting, high contrast, neutral color palette, warm wood tones, soft textures, clean lines, airy atmosphere, Scandinavian design influences, visually harmonious. | 14159 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the specified floating wooden desk integrated with vertical wooden shelves filled with books, a flat-screen TV mounted beside them, and a gray upholstered chair with wooden legs. The right image deviates by having horizontal shelves instead of vertical ones, lacks the flat-screen TV, and includes additional unnecessary elements like a desk lamp. The left image also better captures the minimalist and Scandinavian design influences described in the prompt. | left | Replace the horizontal wooden shelves with vertical wooden shelves filled with books. Add a flat-screen TV mounted beside the shelves on the wall. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the Porsche 911 in a low-angle perspective, slightly to the right of the center, with illuminated headlights and a reflective dark body. The silhouette of a tree is visible on the left, and the hillside with earthy shrubs is present on the right. The cinematic, underexposed ambiance and natural lighting are well-executed. The right image, while having a centered composition, lacks the low-angle perspective and the car is not slightly to the right. The tree silhouette is less prominent, and the hillside textures are less defined. The overall ambiance is less dramatic and underexposed compared to the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the perspective to a low-angle view, positioning the car slightly to the right of the center. Enhance the cinematic, underexposed ambiance with deeper shadows and richer contrast."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49764_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49764_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | A striking low-angle photograph of a classic Porsche 911 parked on a winding road, positioned in the center of the frame and slightly to the right, facing forward. The car's headlights are illuminated, casting a glow against the dim environment, with the sleek, reflective body of dark paint creating a sharp contrast against the backdrop. To the left, a silhouette of a tree can be seen under the fading light of the sky, adding depth to the scene. On the right, a hillside covered with dry, earthy-colored shrubs slopes upward, exhibiting rich textures. The foreground is dominated by a shadowy pavement, emphasizing the vehicle's presence and enhancing the dramatic composition. Cinematic, underexposed ambiance, deep shadows, rich contrast, focused depth of field, natural late-afternoon lighting, subdued color palette, classic automotive photography, nostalgic, elegant, timeless aesthetic. | 14158 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the Porsche 911 in a low-angle perspective, slightly to the right of the center, with illuminated headlights and a reflective dark body. The silhouette of a tree is visible on the left, and the hillside with earthy shrubs is present on the right. The cinematic, underexposed ambiance and natural lighting are well-executed. The right image, while having a centered composition, lacks the low-angle perspective and the car is not slightly to the right. The tree silhouette is less prominent, and the hillside textures are less defined. The overall ambiance is less dramatic and underexposed compared to the left image. | left | Adjust the perspective to a low-angle view, positioning the car slightly to the right of the center. Enhance the cinematic, underexposed ambiance with deeper shadows and richer contrast. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image aligns better with the prompt as it features red dots at the inner corners of the eyes, exaggerated red lipstick, and colorful earrings on the right ear. The right image lacks the red dots at the inner corners of the eyes and instead has red streaks above the eyes, which deviates from the prompt. Additionally, the earrings in the right image are less colorful, and the lipstick outline is less exaggerated.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add red dots at the inner corners of the eyes. Replace the red streaks above the eyes with a clean, natural look."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49763_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49763_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Close-up fashion portrait of a young woman with a dramatic expression against a solid red background. Her face occupies the central frame, displaying unique makeup details with red dots at the inner corners of her eyes and exaggerated red lipstick outline. She has wavy dark hair, hanging loosely, and wears shiny, colorful earrings on her right ear. Her right hand is positioned on her cheek, emphasizing her groomed nails. She wears a dark, possibly velvet, garment with the shoulder visible in the lower left. The lighting is even, highlighting her skin texture, creating a soft sheen. Portrait, high focus, dramatic, vibrant color palette, studio lighting, artistic, bold facial expression, intimate, contemporary fashion photography. | 14157 | The left image aligns better with the prompt as it features red dots at the inner corners of the eyes, exaggerated red lipstick, and colorful earrings on the right ear. The right image lacks the red dots at the inner corners of the eyes and instead has red streaks above the eyes, which deviates from the prompt. Additionally, the earrings in the right image are less colorful, and the lipstick outline is less exaggerated. | left | Add red dots at the inner corners of the eyes. Replace the red streaks above the eyes with a clean, natural look. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes the young woman with brown hair tied in a loose bun, wearing a patterned white sweater and dark pants, sitting in a wicker chair and gazing out at the snow-covered town. The sheer curtains are lightly swaying, and the snowflakes are visible outside. The small white and orange cat is curled up on a round side table, and the red ball of yarn and knitting needles are present on the floor. The abstract paintings on the wall add warmth and creativity. The lighting and muted earth tones create a serene and contemplative atmosphere. The right image, while similar, has some discrepancies: the sweater lacks a pattern, the abstract paintings are replaced with floral art, and the snow-covered town outside the window is less detailed.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a patterned design to the woman's white sweater. Replace the floral painting on the wall with abstract paintings to match the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49767_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49767_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Digital painting of a cozy, intimate interior scene during a snowfall. A young woman with brown hair tied in a loose bun sits in a wicker chair in the left foreground, facing a window, wearing a patterned white sweater and dark pants. She appears to be lost in thought, gazing out at the snow-covered town visible through the window. The window features sheer curtains lightly swaying, with snowflakes gently falling outside. On the right, a small white and orange cat is curled up and sleeping on a round side table. In the room’s corner on the left, abstract paintings hang on the wall, adding warmth and creativity to the space. On the floor, a red ball of yarn and knitting needles suggest a hobby. The room has muted earth tones and soft textures, creating a serene and contemplative atmosphere. Lighting conveys a sense of warmth and tranquility, soft and diffused, emphasizing the calming mood. Elements of the decor are textured and painterly, with a harmonious balance of colors, creating a nostalgic and peaceful ambiance. | 14161 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes the young woman with brown hair tied in a loose bun, wearing a patterned white sweater and dark pants, sitting in a wicker chair and gazing out at the snow-covered town. The sheer curtains are lightly swaying, and the snowflakes are visible outside. The small white and orange cat is curled up on a round side table, and the red ball of yarn and knitting needles are present on the floor. The abstract paintings on the wall add warmth and creativity. The lighting and muted earth tones create a serene and contemplative atmosphere. The right image, while similar, has some discrepancies: the sweater lacks a pattern, the abstract paintings are replaced with floral art, and the snow-covered town outside the window is less detailed. | left | Add a patterned design to the woman's white sweater. Replace the floral painting on the wall with abstract paintings to match the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures a rugged off-road vehicle in motion, centrally placed, with a dramatic fan of debris being thrown up. The debris is dense and chaotic, with clumps of earth and vegetation suspended mid-air, creating a sense of energy. The expansive field and sparse trees in the background are visible, and the sun is high in the sky, casting warm light. The right image, while similar, lacks the same level of dramatic debris spray and chaotic energy. The debris is less dense and less dynamic, and the vehicle appears less rugged and imposing.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the density and spread of the debris spray behind the vehicle to create a more dramatic fan. Enhance the ruggedness of the vehicle by adding larger tires and a more imposing design."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49766_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49766_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | A dynamic photograph of a rugged off-road vehicle in motion, captured from behind as it speeds across a grassy field. The vehicle, centrally placed in the image, throws up a dense spray of dirt and grass, creating a dramatic fan of debris that frames the scene. In the foreground and midground, clumps of earth and vegetation are suspended mid-air, adding a sense of chaotic energy. The expansive field stretches out into the horizon, dotted with sparse trees in the background. The sun is positioned high in the otherwise clear blue sky, casting a warm, natural light over the landscape. The image is stylized with a grainy texture, earthy green tones, and a gritty feel, reminiscent of documentary photography. It features deep focus, capturing the intricate details of the flying debris, while also showcasing a sense of vastness and freedom in an open rural setting. | 14160 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures a rugged off-road vehicle in motion, centrally placed, with a dramatic fan of debris being thrown up. The debris is dense and chaotic, with clumps of earth and vegetation suspended mid-air, creating a sense of energy. The expansive field and sparse trees in the background are visible, and the sun is high in the sky, casting warm light. The right image, while similar, lacks the same level of dramatic debris spray and chaotic energy. The debris is less dense and less dynamic, and the vehicle appears less rugged and imposing. | left | Increase the density and spread of the debris spray behind the vehicle to create a more dramatic fan. Enhance the ruggedness of the vehicle by adding larger tires and a more imposing design. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a person peeking from behind the stack of white geometric blocks, with the red cushion placed on the right side of the larger block. The composition is minimalistic, and the person's elbow is resting on the floor with their hand forming a fist. In the right image, the red cushion is misplaced on top of the smaller block, and the person's pose does not match the description as their elbow is not on the floor, and their hand is not forming a fist.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Move the red cushion to the right side of the larger block. Adjust the person's pose so their elbow rests on the floor and their hand forms a fist."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49769_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49769_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Minimalist photo of a person peeking from behind a stack of white geometric blocks. The image is composed in a studio setting with a stark white background. In the foreground, there are three main blocks: a large rectangular white block at the bottom, a smaller white cuboid slightly offset on top of it to the left, and a red rectangular cushion placed on the right side of the larger block. Positioned on the right side, a face with short hair is partially visible, crouching, peering sideways from behind the blocks. The person's elbow rests on the floor with their hand forming a fist. Bright, even studio lighting, creating a high-key aesthetic with soft shadows, minimalistic composition, abstract architectural elements, stark color contrast with the red cushion against the white background, playful and whimsical tone. | 14163 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a person peeking from behind the stack of white geometric blocks, with the red cushion placed on the right side of the larger block. The composition is minimalistic, and the person's elbow is resting on the floor with their hand forming a fist. In the right image, the red cushion is misplaced on top of the smaller block, and the person's pose does not match the description as their elbow is not on the floor, and their hand is not forming a fist. | left | Move the red cushion to the right side of the larger block. Adjust the person's pose so their elbow rests on the floor and their hand forms a fist. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has a more detailed and textured reddish-brown hat, but the background includes a house and picket fence that are too prominent, deviating from the prompt's requirement of a flat purple background with faint outlines. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it has a flat purple background with faint outlines of a house window and picket fence, as specified. However, the hat texture in the right image is less detailed compared to the left image, and the lighting is slightly less glossy.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Reduce the prominence of the house and picket fence in the background, making them faint outlines on a flat purple backdrop. Add a glossy finish to the reddish-brown hat to enhance its texture and match the lighting effect."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49768_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49768_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Close-up 3D rendered image of a garden gnome's face with exaggerated, cartoon-like features. The gnome has a large, round nose and thick white eyebrows that are furrowed over narrow brown eyes, giving an expression of concentration or disgruntlement. Its cheeks are rosy, and a bushy white beard frames the face, leading to a slightly open mouth. The gnome wears a textured, reddish-brown hat that takes up the upper portion of the image. In the background, a flat purple color serves as the backdrop with faint outlines of a house window and a picket fence visible, partially obscured by the gnome's head. Artificial, bright lighting highlights the textures and adds a glossy finish to the gnome's hat. The color palette consists of warm tones, with primarily reds, purples, and whites, contributing to a playful and whimsical feel. Cartoonish 3D rendering, high detail, vibrant colors, exaggerated expressions, humorous tone. | 14162 | The left image has a more detailed and textured reddish-brown hat, but the background includes a house and picket fence that are too prominent, deviating from the prompt's requirement of a flat purple background with faint outlines. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it has a flat purple background with faint outlines of a house window and picket fence, as specified. However, the hat texture in the right image is less detailed compared to the left image, and the lighting is slightly less glossy. | right | Reduce the prominence of the house and picket fence in the background, making them faint outlines on a flat purple backdrop. Add a glossy finish to the reddish-brown hat to enhance its texture and match the lighting effect. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it accurately depicts the Instagram profile feed with the specified posts, including the bicycle with orange wheels, a person applying stickers, architectural elements, and text overlays with orange and black geometric patterns. The phrases 'YOU NEED MORE FREE SPACE' and 'DO YOU LOVE STICKERS AS MUCH AS ME?' are clearly visible. The smartphone interface on the right side of the left image matches the left layout and includes the account name 'nalipka' and description about stickers. The right image, while similar, has mismatched post layouts and missing key elements such as the phrase 'DO YOU LOVE STICKERS AS MUCH AS ME?' and the geometric patterns are less prominent.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add the phrase 'DO YOU LOVE STICKERS AS MUCH AS ME?' to the posts grid. Enhance the visibility of orange and black geometric patterns in the posts."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49771_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49771_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | A composite image depicting a social media layout and a smartphone interface, left side shows a grid-like Instagram profile feed with various posts, including a bicycle with orange wheels against a white wall, a person in black applying stickers to a white tiled wall, images of architectural elements, and text overlays with orange and black geometric patterns. The posts contain phrases like "YOU NEED MORE FREE SPACE" and "DO YOU LOVE STICKERS AS MUCH AS ME?". On the right, a hand holding a smartphone displaying an Instagram profile named "nalipka", account description highlights stickers, posts grid with thumbnails matching the left layout. Dark background, clean digital presentation, minimalist aesthetic, high contrast, bold typography, modern, flat UI design, focus on social media interaction, vibrant orange accents. | 14165 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it accurately depicts the Instagram profile feed with the specified posts, including the bicycle with orange wheels, a person applying stickers, architectural elements, and text overlays with orange and black geometric patterns. The phrases 'YOU NEED MORE FREE SPACE' and 'DO YOU LOVE STICKERS AS MUCH AS ME?' are clearly visible. The smartphone interface on the right side of the left image matches the left layout and includes the account name 'nalipka' and description about stickers. The right image, while similar, has mismatched post layouts and missing key elements such as the phrase 'DO YOU LOVE STICKERS AS MUCH AS ME?' and the geometric patterns are less prominent. | left | Add the phrase 'DO YOU LOVE STICKERS AS MUCH AS ME?' to the posts grid. Enhance the visibility of orange and black geometric patterns in the posts. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a young woman in a sheer black top with intricate patterns and dark plum trousers, confidently leaning on a wooden chair at the end of a long, elaborately set dining table. The table is draped in a white tablecloth and adorned with wine glasses, cutlery, napkins, decorative candles, and a loaf of bread on a plate to the left. The background includes a wooden cabinet with neatly arranged products and books, and a large vase with vibrant flowers is visible on the right. The lighting is warm, and the overall atmosphere is cozy and sophisticated. In contrast, the right image has some discrepancies: the loaf of bread is not clearly visible on the left side of the table, and the lighting appears slightly cooler, reducing the warm and intimate atmosphere described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a loaf of bread on a plate to the left side of the table. Adjust the lighting to create a warmer and more intimate atmosphere."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49770_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49770_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Elegant indoor photo of a young woman standing confidently in a warmly-lit dining room. She is wearing a sheer black top with intricate patterns and dark plum trousers, leaning on a wooden chair at the end of a long, elaborately set dining table. The table, draped in a white tablecloth, is adorned with finely arranged wine glasses, cutlery, napkins, and decorative candles, with a loaf of bread visible on a plate to the left. Behind her, a wooden cabinet holds an array of neatly arranged products and books. A large vase with vibrant flowers sits on the right, adding color to the scene. The room features beige and cream tones with dark wooden accents, soft lighting from an overhead source casts a warm glow. Photographic style includes warm color palette, medium depth of field, balanced composition, cozy and sophisticated atmosphere, slightly glossy textures, intimate dinner setting feel, subtle reflective surfaces. | 14164 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a young woman in a sheer black top with intricate patterns and dark plum trousers, confidently leaning on a wooden chair at the end of a long, elaborately set dining table. The table is draped in a white tablecloth and adorned with wine glasses, cutlery, napkins, decorative candles, and a loaf of bread on a plate to the left. The background includes a wooden cabinet with neatly arranged products and books, and a large vase with vibrant flowers is visible on the right. The lighting is warm, and the overall atmosphere is cozy and sophisticated. In contrast, the right image has some discrepancies: the loaf of bread is not clearly visible on the left side of the table, and the lighting appears slightly cooler, reducing the warm and intimate atmosphere described in the prompt. | left | Add a loaf of bread on a plate to the left side of the table. Adjust the lighting to create a warmer and more intimate atmosphere. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features multiple colorful earbuds with speckled designs, glossy finishes, and a variety of color combinations such as black with neon green, red with grey, green with black, and blue with yellow accents. The earbuds are scattered dynamically, showcasing their ergonomic design. The right image, while featuring earbuds, lacks the speckled texture, vibrant color combinations, and glossy finish. Additionally, the brand markings 'TEMPO' are missing, and the overall composition is less dynamic and vibrant compared to the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add speckled textures and glossy finishes to the earbuds. Replace the existing brand markings with 'TEMPO' in a clean, modern font."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49775_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49775_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Digital rendering of multiple colorful, speckled earbuds floating against a flat grey background. Each earbud has a unique color combination, with variations including blue, red, green, and black, along with speckles of contrasting colors for a textured appearance. They are scattered across the image in various orientations, showcasing their ergonomic design with ear hooks and multi-colored controls, some displaying brand markings named "TEMPO". The earbuds have a glossy finish, appearing in shades like black with neon green, red with grey, green with black, and blue with yellow accents. The style is clean, modern, and minimalistic with a dynamic composition, focusing on the vibrant, playful, and innovative design of the products. High resolution, digital art, seamless layout, stylized yet realistic, vibrant color palette, glossy texture, balanced composition. | 14169 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features multiple colorful earbuds with speckled designs, glossy finishes, and a variety of color combinations such as black with neon green, red with grey, green with black, and blue with yellow accents. The earbuds are scattered dynamically, showcasing their ergonomic design. The right image, while featuring earbuds, lacks the speckled texture, vibrant color combinations, and glossy finish. Additionally, the brand markings 'TEMPO' are missing, and the overall composition is less dynamic and vibrant compared to the left image. | left | Add speckled textures and glossy finishes to the earbuds. Replace the existing brand markings with 'TEMPO' in a clean, modern font. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the dynamic action shot with the man gripping the basketball with both hands, raising his knee close to his chest, and showing focus and intensity in his expression. The lighting emphasizes muscle definition, and the gradient background transitions smoothly from warm orange to cool blue. In contrast, the right image has less dramatic lighting, the man's head is not turned to the right, and the sneakers are less prominently displayed. Additionally, the gradient background in the right image appears less vibrant and smooth.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Turn the man's head slightly to the right to show focus and intensity. Enhance the gradient background to make it more vibrant and smooth, transitioning seamlessly from warm orange to cool blue."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49772_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49772_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Dynamic action shot of a muscular black man in mid-air, executing a basketball maneuver against a smooth gradient backdrop transitioning from a warm orange to a cool blue. Positioned centrally, he grips a basketball with both hands while raising his knee close to his chest. The man's head is turned to the right, showing focus and intensity in his expression. He wears a black sleeveless top with a long black sleeve on his left arm, paired with patterned leggings and black shorts. His sneakers are gray with white soles, prominently displayed as one foot is raised. Studio lighting emphasizes the definition of his muscles, casting dramatic shadows and highlighting the contours of his physique. High contrast, vibrant gradient background, studio photography, dramatic lighting, focused composition, energetic, athleticism, sharp detail, modern sportswear, seamless action capture. | 14166 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the dynamic action shot with the man gripping the basketball with both hands, raising his knee close to his chest, and showing focus and intensity in his expression. The lighting emphasizes muscle definition, and the gradient background transitions smoothly from warm orange to cool blue. In contrast, the right image has less dramatic lighting, the man's head is not turned to the right, and the sneakers are less prominently displayed. Additionally, the gradient background in the right image appears less vibrant and smooth. | left | Turn the man's head slightly to the right to show focus and intensity. Enhance the gradient background to make it more vibrant and smooth, transitioning seamlessly from warm orange to cool blue. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a green cylindrical bottle with a bronze pump nozzle centrally positioned on a textured dark gray fabric surface. The fabric exhibits a waffle-like pattern with undulations, creating depth and texture, and the lighting is soft and diffuse, emphasizing the matte finish of the bottle and the fabric's texture. The right image lacks the undulations in the fabric, making the background appear flat and less dynamic, which reduces the sense of depth and texture described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add undulations to the fabric background to create depth and texture. Adjust the lighting to emphasize the fabric's texture and create gentle contrast."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49774_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49774_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Minimalist product photograph featuring a single green cylindrical bottle with a bronze pump nozzle, centrally positioned on a textured dark gray fabric surface. The fabric exhibits a waffle-like pattern with various undulations, creating a sense of depth and texture in the background. The bottle is vertically aligned, casting a subtle shadow on the fabric below it. The lighting is soft and diffuse, emphasizing the matte finish of the bottle while highlighting the texture of the fabric with gentle contrast. Product photography, minimalist aesthetic, high contrast, soft lighting, textured background, balanced composition, monochromatic gray tones, focus on materiality, clean and modern. | 14168 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a green cylindrical bottle with a bronze pump nozzle centrally positioned on a textured dark gray fabric surface. The fabric exhibits a waffle-like pattern with undulations, creating depth and texture, and the lighting is soft and diffuse, emphasizing the matte finish of the bottle and the fabric's texture. The right image lacks the undulations in the fabric, making the background appear flat and less dynamic, which reduces the sense of depth and texture described in the prompt. | left | Add undulations to the fabric background to create depth and texture. Adjust the lighting to emphasize the fabric's texture and create gentle contrast. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features two stylized UFOs with domed tops, angled diagonally, and with orange and blue rims against a dark blue starry background. The right page shows a retro-style television with an antenna on a light blue background, positioned centrally. Both pages are secured by large black binder clips, and the book is slightly ajar, revealing the spine. The right image has inaccuracies: the UFOs lack the specified orange and blue rims and light gradient, and the binder clips are not black but metallic, deviating from the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add orange and blue rims with a subtle light gradient to the UFOs. Change the metallic binder clips to large black binder clips."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49773_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49773_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Open book on a white wooden surface with two pages featuring minimalist illustrations. The left page displays two stylized, cylindrical UFOs with domed tops, angled diagonally, against a dark blue starry background. The UFOs have orange and blue rims with a subtle light gradient. The right page shows a retro-style television with an antenna on a light blue background, positioned centrally. Each page is secured by a large black binder clip, one on either side, casting soft shadows onto the pages. The book is slightly ajar, revealing the spine and adding depth. Clean, minimalist design, bright lighting, high contrast, sharp detail, contemporary illustration style, flat colors, balanced composition. | 14167 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features two stylized UFOs with domed tops, angled diagonally, and with orange and blue rims against a dark blue starry background. The right page shows a retro-style television with an antenna on a light blue background, positioned centrally. Both pages are secured by large black binder clips, and the book is slightly ajar, revealing the spine. The right image has inaccuracies: the UFOs lack the specified orange and blue rims and light gradient, and the binder clips are not black but metallic, deviating from the prompt. | left | Add orange and blue rims with a subtle light gradient to the UFOs. Change the metallic binder clips to large black binder clips. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a smooth, undulating sand dune surface with a sharp crest line running diagonally from the bottom left to the upper right. It captures fine grains of sand with intricate textures and a stark contrast between light and shadow, creating a serene yet dramatic atmosphere. The negative space in the top left enhances the composition. The right image, while also showing a sand dune, has repetitive patterns along the crest line that detract from the minimalistic and natural aesthetic described in the prompt. These patterns disrupt the smoothness and simplicity of the dune's form and texture.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the repetitive patterns along the crest line to create a smooth, uninterrupted edge. Enhance the contrast between light and shadow to emphasize the dune's form and texture."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49776_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49776_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Black and white abstract photograph of a sand dune, displaying an undulating surface with a sharp crest line running diagonally from the bottom left to the upper right of the frame. The image captures fine grains of sand with intricate textures, highlighted by a stark contrast between light and shadow. The play of light creates subtle gradients and highlights, giving depth and form to the dune. Negative space occupies the top left, enhancing the composition. Minimalistic, high contrast, monochrome palette, natural light, textural richness, serene yet dramatic atmosphere, abstract landscape photography, high detail, emphasis on form and texture, captivatingly simple, visually balanced. | 14170 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a smooth, undulating sand dune surface with a sharp crest line running diagonally from the bottom left to the upper right. It captures fine grains of sand with intricate textures and a stark contrast between light and shadow, creating a serene yet dramatic atmosphere. The negative space in the top left enhances the composition. The right image, while also showing a sand dune, has repetitive patterns along the crest line that detract from the minimalistic and natural aesthetic described in the prompt. These patterns disrupt the smoothness and simplicity of the dune's form and texture. | left | Remove the repetitive patterns along the crest line to create a smooth, uninterrupted edge. Enhance the contrast between light and shadow to emphasize the dune's form and texture. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as the woman is positioned closer to the lower right section of the image, facing away, and her arms are extended forward with hands near the minimalist sculpture. The vibrant pink background and the colorful, patterned athletic outfit with dotted textures are accurate. In the right image, the woman is not positioned in the lower right section, and her pose does not match the description of facing away with arms extended forward. Additionally, the sculpture's placement is less aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reposition the woman to the lower right section of the image, facing away. Adjust her pose so her arms are extended forward with hands resting near the minimalist sculpture."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49778_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49778_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Aerial photo of a young woman with blonde hair, sitting on a vibrant pink background. She's positioned in the lower right section of the image, facing away. She wears a colorful, patterned athletic outfit with a sleeveless top and shorts, displaying hues of blue, purple, red, and beige with dotted textures. Her arms are extended forward, hands resting near a minimalist sculpture made of a yellow oval base and a blue angled pole, placed close to her hands. Bright, direct lighting, casting distinct shadows, enhances the vivid color palette and smooth textures. High contrast, minimalistic, graphic design influences, modern, bold. | 14172 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as the woman is positioned closer to the lower right section of the image, facing away, and her arms are extended forward with hands near the minimalist sculpture. The vibrant pink background and the colorful, patterned athletic outfit with dotted textures are accurate. In the right image, the woman is not positioned in the lower right section, and her pose does not match the description of facing away with arms extended forward. Additionally, the sculpture's placement is less aligned with the prompt. | left | Reposition the woman to the lower right section of the image, facing away. Adjust her pose so her arms are extended forward with hands resting near the minimalist sculpture. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image captures the vintage cinematic style with soft, diffused lighting and a muted color palette. The woman is centered, wearing a white dress with black prints and a black corset, but her hair is not styled in retro waves. The ornate railing is present to her left, and the background features faded murals, but the lens flare effect is missing. The right image has the woman styled with retro waves, and the lens flare effect is present, enhancing the mystical ambiance. However, the dress lacks intricate black prints, and the murals in the background are less prominent. The overall lighting and atmosphere in the right image are more aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add intricate black prints to the white dress. Make the background murals more prominent and detailed."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49777_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49777_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | A vintage-style cinematic portrait of a woman standing in a grand, opulently decorated hall. She is centered in the frame, wearing a white, floor-length dress with intricate black prints, and a black corset that accentuates her waist. Her hair is styled in soft, retro waves. The setting suggests a historical or aristocratic environment, with large, faded, but richly detailed murals visible on the walls. To her left, there is an ornate carved wood or metal railing. A bright, dramatic light source creates a pronounced lens flare effect to the right, adding to the mystical ambiance. The floor is composed of large, dark, patterned tiles. Soft, diffused lighting with a slight haze, muted color palette, shallow depth of field with the background out of focus, creating a dreamlike, romantic atmosphere. High contrast between the dim environment and the bright lighting effect, art-house, historical drama, evocative, nostalgic. | 14171 | The left image captures the vintage cinematic style with soft, diffused lighting and a muted color palette. The woman is centered, wearing a white dress with black prints and a black corset, but her hair is not styled in retro waves. The ornate railing is present to her left, and the background features faded murals, but the lens flare effect is missing. The right image has the woman styled with retro waves, and the lens flare effect is present, enhancing the mystical ambiance. However, the dress lacks intricate black prints, and the murals in the background are less prominent. The overall lighting and atmosphere in the right image are more aligned with the prompt. | right | Add intricate black prints to the white dress. Make the background murals more prominent and detailed. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the woman holding a ring near her face with her left hand and her right arm crossed over her midriff, as described. The ornate architectural column is visible on the right, and the lighting is warm and natural, creating a soft shadow on the left side. In contrast, the right image does not show the woman holding a ring near her face, and her pose does not match the description. Additionally, the ornate column is less prominent in the right image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the pose so her left hand gently holds a ring near her face, and her right arm crosses over her midriff. Enhance the prominence of the ornate architectural column on the right side of the image."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49780_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49780_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | A portrait photo of a young woman with fair skin and long blonde hair, standing against an ornate architectural column made of white and light brown stone on the right. She is wearing a white swimsuit with pink lace details and a sparkling necklace, her left hand gently holding a ring near her face, her right arm crossed over her midriff. Her gaze is softly downward, conveying a serene, contemplative mood. The background features a softly lit, warm-toned wall, adding depth and texture to the scene. The lighting is warm and natural, creating a soft shadow on the left side, enhancing the elegant and sophisticated atmosphere of the portrait. Photography, shallow depth of field, high contrast, soft ambient lighting, slightly muted color palette, intimate, elegant, polished, visually balanced. | 14174 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the woman holding a ring near her face with her left hand and her right arm crossed over her midriff, as described. The ornate architectural column is visible on the right, and the lighting is warm and natural, creating a soft shadow on the left side. In contrast, the right image does not show the woman holding a ring near her face, and her pose does not match the description. Additionally, the ornate column is less prominent in the right image. | left | Adjust the pose so her left hand gently holds a ring near her face, and her right arm crosses over her midriff. Enhance the prominence of the ornate architectural column on the right side of the image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the coffee roaster with a cylindrical body, conical hopper, digital display panel, and round cooling tray, all positioned correctly. The sandy surface, large circular window framing snow-covered mountains, and the rough-textured stone to the left of the machine are present. The lighting and textures are hyperrealistic, and the ethereal atmosphere is achieved with the turbulent sea of clouds visible through the carved-out arch. The right image lacks the digital display panel on the coffee roaster and does not show the carved-out arch revealing the sea of clouds, which are key elements of the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a digital display panel to the side of the coffee roaster facing the camera. Include a carved-out arch in the concrete wall revealing a turbulent sea of clouds."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49779_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49779_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Futuristic product visualization featuring a sleek, black coffee roaster positioned to the right on a sandy surface. The machine's design includes a cylindrical body with a conical hopper on top, a digital display panel on its side facing the camera, and a round cooling tray at the front. In the background, a large circular window pierces through a concrete wall, framing majestic mountains covered in snow, juxtaposed with a cloudy sky. To the left of the machine, a large, rough-textured stone lies on the sandy ground, adding a natural contrast to the sleek, industrial design of the roaster. A section of the concrete wall is carved out in an arch, revealing a turbulent sea of clouds, creating an ethereal atmosphere. CGI rendering, minimalist design, high contrast, natural and industrial elements, hyperrealistic textures, serene yet futuristic, dramatic lighting effects, play of light and shadow on surfaces. | 14173 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the coffee roaster with a cylindrical body, conical hopper, digital display panel, and round cooling tray, all positioned correctly. The sandy surface, large circular window framing snow-covered mountains, and the rough-textured stone to the left of the machine are present. The lighting and textures are hyperrealistic, and the ethereal atmosphere is achieved with the turbulent sea of clouds visible through the carved-out arch. The right image lacks the digital display panel on the coffee roaster and does not show the carved-out arch revealing the sea of clouds, which are key elements of the prompt. | left | Add a digital display panel to the side of the coffee roaster facing the camera. Include a carved-out arch in the concrete wall revealing a turbulent sea of clouds. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more accurate placement of the dark vases with beige pampas grass on the dark carpeted section to the left, in front of the large floor-to-ceiling window. The sleek, low-profile bed with beige bedding is correctly positioned on a wood-finished platform to the right. The lighting is uniform and warm in the upper right, and the overall atmosphere is serene and uncluttered. In contrast, the right image has the vases placed too close to the window edge, and the lighting appears less uniform, with shadows disrupting the warm and tranquil ambiance.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Move the dark vases with beige pampas grass slightly inward, away from the window edge, to align with the dark carpeted section. Adjust the lighting to create a more uniform warm glow in the upper right corner."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49782_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49782_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Modern interior photograph of a minimalist bedroom overlooking the ocean, an elevated platform with two large, dark vases filled with beige pampas grass placed on a dark carpeted section to the left, in front of a large floor-to-ceiling window framing the ocean view, a sleek, low-profile bed with neatly arranged beige bedding sits on a wood-finished platform to the right, a block of uniform warm lighting covers the upper right, light flows naturally from the large window creating soft shadows, soft natural lighting, warm neutral color palette, clean lines and uncluttered space, serene and tranquil atmosphere, luxurious and contemporary design, photorealistic, high contrast between warm interior tones and cool ocean view, spacious and open layout, subtle elegance and sophistication. | 14176 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more accurate placement of the dark vases with beige pampas grass on the dark carpeted section to the left, in front of the large floor-to-ceiling window. The sleek, low-profile bed with beige bedding is correctly positioned on a wood-finished platform to the right. The lighting is uniform and warm in the upper right, and the overall atmosphere is serene and uncluttered. In contrast, the right image has the vases placed too close to the window edge, and the lighting appears less uniform, with shadows disrupting the warm and tranquil ambiance. | left | Move the dark vases with beige pampas grass slightly inward, away from the window edge, to align with the dark carpeted section. Adjust the lighting to create a more uniform warm glow in the upper right corner. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a humanoid robot in a dark, high-tech environment with glowing red and blue accents. The left image features a more angular and intricate armor design, aligning better with the prompt's description of 'intricate, angular armor design.' The red digital visor in the left image is more prominent and helmet-like, as specified in the prompt. The right image has a smoother armor design and lacks the same level of angular detail. Additionally, the glowing blue circular elements are more pronounced in the left image, while the right image's background lighting is less symmetrical and less visually striking.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the angular and intricate details of the robot's armor, especially around the chest and shoulders. Enhance the prominence of the red digital visor to make it more helmet-like and aligned with the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49783_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49783_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Futuristic 3D render of a humanoid robot centered in a dark, high-tech environment. The robot features a sleek metallic body with intricate, angular armor design, accented by glowing blue circular elements and red lights around the chest and shoulders. Its head is adorned with a helmet-like structure, displaying a red digital visor. Background includes symmetrical panels and conduits with integrated red and green lights, enhancing the robotic and mechanical theme. High contrast and dramatic lighting highlight the robot's glossy textures, advanced technology, and symmetrical composition, digital rendering, moody sci-fi atmosphere, sharp focus, neon color palette, otherworldly, visually striking and futuristic design. | 14177 | Both images depict a humanoid robot in a dark, high-tech environment with glowing red and blue accents. The left image features a more angular and intricate armor design, aligning better with the prompt's description of 'intricate, angular armor design.' The red digital visor in the left image is more prominent and helmet-like, as specified in the prompt. The right image has a smoother armor design and lacks the same level of angular detail. Additionally, the glowing blue circular elements are more pronounced in the left image, while the right image's background lighting is less symmetrical and less visually striking. | left | Increase the angular and intricate details of the robot's armor, especially around the chest and shoulders. Enhance the prominence of the red digital visor to make it more helmet-like and aligned with the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image aligns better with the prompt as it features a city street scene with a white tiled wall occupying the upper two-thirds, a darker textured surface with posters displaying architectural imagery and text in blue, beige, and grayscale, a blurred figure walking from left to right, and a red traffic cone on the cobblestone pavement. The right image, while showing a flyer on a metal grid structure, does not fully match the description of the flyer casting a shadow or the flyer content being in Portuguese.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a shadow cast by the flyer to enhance depth. Replace the flyer text with Portuguese text to match the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49781_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49781_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | A composite image featuring two distinct visuals. On the left, a city street scene with a white tiled wall that occupies the upper two-thirds of the frame, creating a minimalist architectural backdrop. Below, a series of posters are plastered on a darker, textured surface. The posters display architectural imagery and text with a mix of blue, beige, and grayscale elements. A blurred figure of an individual, possibly a young Asian man with a backpack, walks from the left to the right foreground, creating a sense of motion against the static background. A single red traffic cone is visible on the cobblestone pavement to the right of the figure. On the right, a close-up view of a flyer featuring architectural photography is placed on top of a metal grid structure. The flyer showcases a modern architectural building against a clear blue sky, with accompanying text in Portuguese. The flyer casts a shadow, adding depth. High contrast, modern urban aesthetic, subdued color palette, minimalist design, dynamic composition with a juxtaposition of movement and stillness, clean lines, architectural focus. | 14175 | The left image aligns better with the prompt as it features a city street scene with a white tiled wall occupying the upper two-thirds, a darker textured surface with posters displaying architectural imagery and text in blue, beige, and grayscale, a blurred figure walking from left to right, and a red traffic cone on the cobblestone pavement. The right image, while showing a flyer on a metal grid structure, does not fully match the description of the flyer casting a shadow or the flyer content being in Portuguese. | left | Add a shadow cast by the flyer to enhance depth. Replace the flyer text with Portuguese text to match the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images align well with the prompt, but the right image better matches the description. The right image features the woman's hair swept to the right, as specified in the prompt, while the left image has her hair falling more naturally. Additionally, the right image has a more ethereal and high-key lighting effect, which enhances the minimalistic and editorial aesthetic described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Sweep the woman's hair to the right. Adjust the lighting to create a more ethereal and overexposed high-key effect."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49784_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49784_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | High-fashion photo portrait of a young woman with light skin and blond hair swept to the right, seated against a stark white backdrop. She wears a sleeveless, elegant white satin dress, sitting on a white bench at the lower right. Her left arm is draped over her lap, showcasing intricate silver and blue jewelry, including earrings, bracelets, and rings. The jewelry features gemstones that add a subtle color accent to the monochrome outfit. Her expression is calm and composed, looking directly at the camera. High-key photography, overexposed, minimalistic, soft even lighting, ethereal atmosphere, high contrast, glossy smooth textures, crisp and sharp focus, cool color palette, editorial fashion photo, and minimalist aesthetic. | 14178 | Both images align well with the prompt, but the right image better matches the description. The right image features the woman's hair swept to the right, as specified in the prompt, while the left image has her hair falling more naturally. Additionally, the right image has a more ethereal and high-key lighting effect, which enhances the minimalistic and editorial aesthetic described in the prompt. | right | Sweep the woman's hair to the right. Adjust the lighting to create a more ethereal and overexposed high-key effect. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better matches the prompt. It features a woman wearing a crisp white long-sleeve shirt with a high collar and ribbon ties, a long dark skirt with a decorative brooch on the right side, and high leather boots with a slight gloss. The skirt has a noticeable front slit, and the overall composition is symmetrical and minimalist. The right image has a brooch that is too large and butterfly-shaped, which deviates from the classic and timeless elegance described in the prompt. Additionally, the skirt in the right image lacks a noticeable front slit, which is a key detail in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reduce the size of the brooch and change its design to a more classic and decorative style. Add a noticeable front slit to the skirt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49785_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49785_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Black and white fashion portrait of a woman standing in a studio against a plain background. She is centered in the frame, wearing a crisp white long-sleeve shirt with a high collar and two ribbon ties. Her skirt is long, dark, and wraps around her waist with a large decorative brooch on the right side. High leather boots with a slight gloss lead into the skirt, which has a noticeable front slit. Her short hair is styled simply, framing her face as she gazes directly at the camera. Studio photography, monochrome palette, sharp focus, high contrast, minimalist style, symmetrical composition, classic and timeless elegance. | 14179 | The left image better matches the prompt. It features a woman wearing a crisp white long-sleeve shirt with a high collar and ribbon ties, a long dark skirt with a decorative brooch on the right side, and high leather boots with a slight gloss. The skirt has a noticeable front slit, and the overall composition is symmetrical and minimalist. The right image has a brooch that is too large and butterfly-shaped, which deviates from the classic and timeless elegance described in the prompt. Additionally, the skirt in the right image lacks a noticeable front slit, which is a key detail in the prompt. | left | Reduce the size of the brooch and change its design to a more classic and decorative style. Add a noticeable front slit to the skirt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images align well with the prompt, featuring a young woman in a grassy meadow wearing a sheer black dress. However, the left image better matches the prompt due to its visually balanced composition, inclusion of rocky patches, and a more natural, textured environment. The right image lacks the rocky patches in the foreground and has a less balanced composition, with the background dominated by rocks rather than grasses and wildflowers.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add rocky patches in the foreground to enhance the natural, textured environment. Reduce the prominence of rocks in the background and increase the presence of tall grasses and wildflowers."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49787_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49787_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | A fashion photography portrait featuring a young woman lying in a grassy, sunlit meadow. She is positioned diagonally across the center of the frame, supporting her head with her right hand. Her attire consists of a sheer black dress that contrasts with the lush greenery surrounding her. The background includes tall grasses, small wildflowers with yellow and orange hues, and rocky patches, creating a natural, textured environment. The lighting is soft, casting warm highlights and gentle shadows across her face and the landscape. High-fashion style, natural setting, tranquil mood, soft golden-hour lighting, earthy color palette, shallow depth of field, photorealistic, intimate and serene atmosphere, visually balanced composition. | 14180 | Both images align well with the prompt, featuring a young woman in a grassy meadow wearing a sheer black dress. However, the left image better matches the prompt due to its visually balanced composition, inclusion of rocky patches, and a more natural, textured environment. The right image lacks the rocky patches in the foreground and has a less balanced composition, with the background dominated by rocks rather than grasses and wildflowers. | left | Add rocky patches in the foreground to enhance the natural, textured environment. Reduce the prominence of rocks in the background and increase the presence of tall grasses and wildflowers. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a sleek, white racing car with green accents on the side mirrors, roof components, and lower edge panels. The aerodynamic design is emphasized with sharp lines, smooth curves, and visible splitters and vents. The Michelin-branded tires and intricate alloy wheel designs are clearly displayed, and the car's body includes recessed elements and openings for cooling and aerodynamic efficiency. The right image, while similar, has additional unnecessary elements like the number '11' on the side and lacks the same emphasis on green accents, particularly on the roof components. The green accents are less prominent and do not match the prompt's description as closely.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the number '11' from the side of the car. Enhance the green accents on the roof components to make them more prominent and consistent with the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49788_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49788_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | High-resolution digital rendering of a sleek, white racing car set against a gradient grey background. The car is positioned in profile, with its aerodynamic design emphasized by sharp lines and smooth curves. It features distinctive green accents on the side mirrors, roof components, and lower edge panels. Being a high-performance vehicle, the car includes complex aerodynamic elements like splitters and vents, evident on the front and sides. The Michelin-branded tires with intricate alloy wheel designs are prominently displayed, with the front and rear wheels aligned precisely along the horizontal plane. The car's body features multiple recessed elements and openings, likely for cooling and aerodynamic efficiency. The overall form factor suggests a futuristic and sophisticated design, perhaps intended for endurance racing. Studio lighting, sharp focus, high contrast, photorealistic, glossy texture, minimalistic backdrop, dynamic silhouette, technologically advanced appearance, emphasis on speed and precision. | 14181 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a sleek, white racing car with green accents on the side mirrors, roof components, and lower edge panels. The aerodynamic design is emphasized with sharp lines, smooth curves, and visible splitters and vents. The Michelin-branded tires and intricate alloy wheel designs are clearly displayed, and the car's body includes recessed elements and openings for cooling and aerodynamic efficiency. The right image, while similar, has additional unnecessary elements like the number '11' on the side and lacks the same emphasis on green accents, particularly on the roof components. The green accents are less prominent and do not match the prompt's description as closely. | left | Remove the number '11' from the side of the car. Enhance the green accents on the roof components to make them more prominent and consistent with the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has cabinets with two doors instead of four rectangular doors as specified in the prompt. The cabinet on the left lacks the stack of dark green plates on top, and the cabinet on the right does not have an open top-right door revealing white bowls, stacked plates, and glass jars with colorful contents. Additionally, the left image does not show the apples clustered together on top of the right cabinet. The right image aligns better with the prompt, as it features two cabinets with four rectangular doors, the correct placement of the dark green plates and apples, and the open top-right door revealing the specified contents.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the two-door cabinets with four rectangular doors framed in black. Add an open top-right door on the right cabinet, revealing white bowls, stacked plates, and glass jars with colorful contents."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49789_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49789_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Minimalist product image of two modern wooden cabinets against a white background. The cabinets are symmetrically placed side by side. Each has four rectangular doors with light wood grain finish, framed in black. The cabinet on the left has a stack of dark green plates on top, center-aligned. The cabinet on the right has an open top-right door revealing white bowls, stacked plates, and several glass jars filled with colorful contents. On top of this cabinet, there are red and green apples clustered together. The cabinets have thin black legs, lifting them slightly above the ground. Direct, even lighting, high contrast, minimalistic, clean lines, focus on texture and color contrast between light wood and black framing, contemporary design, functional simplicity. | 14182 | The left image has cabinets with two doors instead of four rectangular doors as specified in the prompt. The cabinet on the left lacks the stack of dark green plates on top, and the cabinet on the right does not have an open top-right door revealing white bowls, stacked plates, and glass jars with colorful contents. Additionally, the left image does not show the apples clustered together on top of the right cabinet. The right image aligns better with the prompt, as it features two cabinets with four rectangular doors, the correct placement of the dark green plates and apples, and the open top-right door revealing the specified contents. | right | Replace the two-door cabinets with four rectangular doors framed in black. Add an open top-right door on the right cabinet, revealing white bowls, stacked plates, and glass jars with colorful contents. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures a more dynamic and chaotic explosion of colorful liquid in mid-air. The splashes and trails of yellow, green, and blue paint are more intertwined and energetic, with a greater sense of movement and suspension. The upper half has a variety of globules and droplets, while the bottom portion features a concentrated mix of colors forming a complex texture. The right image, while vibrant, lacks the same level of chaotic movement and detail in the splashes, and the bottom portion is less textured and dynamic.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the complexity and intertwining of the splashes and trails of paint to enhance the sense of chaotic movement. Add more globules and droplets of varying sizes in the upper half to create a stronger feeling of suspension in space."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49790_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49790_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Dynamic abstract art image capturing an explosion of colorful liquid in mid-air against a neutral gray background. Vivid splashes and trails of yellow, green, and blue paint intertwine and dance across the center of the frame, creating a sense of chaotic movement and energy. Several globules and droplets of varying sizes are suspended throughout the upper half, contributing to a feeling of suspension in space. The bottom portion is a concentrated mix of colors forming a complex texture. High-speed photography, hyper-realistic texture, medium depth of field, soft lighting, vivid color palette, high contrast, meticulous detail, energetic and vibrant composition, visually dynamic and intriguing. | 14183 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures a more dynamic and chaotic explosion of colorful liquid in mid-air. The splashes and trails of yellow, green, and blue paint are more intertwined and energetic, with a greater sense of movement and suspension. The upper half has a variety of globules and droplets, while the bottom portion features a concentrated mix of colors forming a complex texture. The right image, while vibrant, lacks the same level of chaotic movement and detail in the splashes, and the bottom portion is less textured and dynamic. | left | Increase the complexity and intertwining of the splashes and trails of paint to enhance the sense of chaotic movement. Add more globules and droplets of varying sizes in the upper half to create a stronger feeling of suspension in space. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a prominent chrome RAM logo on a black leather surface with visible stitching, a clear 'AIRBAG' embossing below the logo, and a dramatic lens flare effect on the left side. The reflections and glossy textures are well-defined, and the control buttons on the right edge are visible with a metallic finish. The right image lacks the dramatic lens flare effect and has less prominent reflections, making it less ethereal and visually striking compared to the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the lens flare effect on the left side to create a more dramatic and ethereal glow. Increase the prominence of reflections on the chrome logo and leather surface for a glossy and sophisticated look."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49791_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49791_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Close-up photograph of a car steering wheel featuring a chrome RAM logo centered on a black leather surface with visible stitching. Prominent reflections and lens flares cascade over the left side of the image, creating an ethereal glow. The right edge shows part of the steering wheel control buttons in a metallic finish, adding a modern design element. The word "AIRBAG" is embossed below the logo. High contrast, soft natural lighting with a warm color palette, dramatic lens flare effect, glossy textures, sharp focus on the logo, blurred background, automotive photography, sleek and sophisticated aesthetic. | 14184 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a prominent chrome RAM logo on a black leather surface with visible stitching, a clear 'AIRBAG' embossing below the logo, and a dramatic lens flare effect on the left side. The reflections and glossy textures are well-defined, and the control buttons on the right edge are visible with a metallic finish. The right image lacks the dramatic lens flare effect and has less prominent reflections, making it less ethereal and visually striking compared to the left image. | left | Enhance the lens flare effect on the left side to create a more dramatic and ethereal glow. Increase the prominence of reflections on the chrome logo and leather surface for a glossy and sophisticated look. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image does not align with the prompt as the female dancer's leap is extended rather than tucked and compressed, and her arms are not above her head. The male dancer's leap is also not fully extended as described, with his right leg not stretched backward. The right image better matches the prompt as the female dancer's leap is tucked with arms above her head, and the male dancer's leap is extended with the correct arm and leg positioning. The composition in the right image also emphasizes symmetry and contrast more effectively.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Adjust the female dancer's leap to be tucked and compressed with her arms above her head. Extend the male dancer's right leg fully backward to emphasize the leap's power and alignment."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49792_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49792_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Dynamic photo capturing two dancers mid-leap against a stark white background, emphasizing athleticism and grace. On the left, a female dancer with dark hair in a black leotard executes a tucked, compressed leap, her arms above her head and legs bent. Her posture conveys fluidity and power. On the right, a male dancer in black shorts demonstrates a powerful, extended leap, facing right, with his left arm forward and right arm back, left leg bent and right leg fully extended toward the back. Both dancers exhibit toned, muscular physiques with precise control. The image's composition highlights symmetry and contrast between the dancers' movements. High-key lighting, sharp focus, minimalistic, celebratory of human form and expression, modern dance photography, crisp lines, and energetic. | 14185 | The left image does not align with the prompt as the female dancer's leap is extended rather than tucked and compressed, and her arms are not above her head. The male dancer's leap is also not fully extended as described, with his right leg not stretched backward. The right image better matches the prompt as the female dancer's leap is tucked with arms above her head, and the male dancer's leap is extended with the correct arm and leg positioning. The composition in the right image also emphasizes symmetry and contrast more effectively. | right | Adjust the female dancer's leap to be tucked and compressed with her arms above her head. Extend the male dancer's right leg fully backward to emphasize the leap's power and alignment. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the pink beauty device with a white top partially concealed behind a light beige fabric in the lower third of the image, positioned slightly off-center to the right. The dried branch extends diagonally from the bottom right to the top left, casting soft shadows on the blush pink background. The right image, while having a similar setup, has the device positioned too low and lacks the diagonal extension of the branch from the bottom right to the top left, which is a key element of the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reposition the beauty device slightly higher and off-center to the right. Adjust the dried branch to extend diagonally from the bottom right to the top left, casting soft shadows on the background."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49793_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49793_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Minimalist product photography. A sleek, pink beauty device with a white top partially concealed behind a light beige fabric in the lower third of the image. Positioned slightly off-center to the right. A delicate, dried branch with small leaves extends diagonally from the bottom right to the top left, casting soft shadows on the background. The backdrop is a smooth, blush pink surface. Soft natural lighting creates gentle shadows, emphasizing texture and form. Overall, the image conveys a sense of elegance and simplicity with a pastel color palette, high-key lighting, and smooth, matte textures. | 14186 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the pink beauty device with a white top partially concealed behind a light beige fabric in the lower third of the image, positioned slightly off-center to the right. The dried branch extends diagonally from the bottom right to the top left, casting soft shadows on the blush pink background. The right image, while having a similar setup, has the device positioned too low and lacks the diagonal extension of the branch from the bottom right to the top left, which is a key element of the prompt. | left | Reposition the beauty device slightly higher and off-center to the right. Adjust the dried branch to extend diagonally from the bottom right to the top left, casting soft shadows on the background. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a monochromatic portrait of a woman in an elaborately feathered costume with a headdress that has layered feathers curving around her head and cascading into broader plumes. The metallic sheen of the feathers contrasts well with her smooth skin, and the lighting highlights her cheekbone and eye, adding depth and drama. The background includes indistinct patterns, enhancing the mysterious atmosphere. The right image, while also monochromatic, has a less intricate headdress that lacks the scale-like or armor-like patterns and metallic sheen. The lighting does not emphasize the right side of the face as effectively, and the costume design is less elaborate and less aligned with the fantasy or mythological theme.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a headdress with layered feathers that curve around the head and cascade into broader plumes, incorporating scale-like or armor-like patterns with a metallic sheen. Adjust the lighting to create a beam that highlights the right side of the face, emphasizing the cheekbone and eye for added depth and drama."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49794_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49794_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Monochromatic portrait of a woman in an elaborately feathered costume, reminiscent of a fantasy or mythological character. Positioned centrally, she gazes intently to the right, her expression intense. The headdress features layered feathers that curve around her head, cascading into broader plumes at the back, with patterns resembling scales or armor. The feathers have a metallic sheen, creating a striking contrast against her smooth skin. The right side of the face is accentuated by a beam of light, highlighting her cheekbone and eye, adding depth and drama. The background is dark, partially showing indistinct patterns or script, enhancing the mysterious and otherworldly atmosphere. Portrait photography, high contrast, soft spotlighting, metallic textures, intricate costume design, surreal, dramatic, enigmatic, visually symmetrical. | 14187 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a monochromatic portrait of a woman in an elaborately feathered costume with a headdress that has layered feathers curving around her head and cascading into broader plumes. The metallic sheen of the feathers contrasts well with her smooth skin, and the lighting highlights her cheekbone and eye, adding depth and drama. The background includes indistinct patterns, enhancing the mysterious atmosphere. The right image, while also monochromatic, has a less intricate headdress that lacks the scale-like or armor-like patterns and metallic sheen. The lighting does not emphasize the right side of the face as effectively, and the costume design is less elaborate and less aligned with the fantasy or mythological theme. | left | Add a headdress with layered feathers that curve around the head and cascade into broader plumes, incorporating scale-like or armor-like patterns with a metallic sheen. Adjust the lighting to create a beam that highlights the right side of the face, emphasizing the cheekbone and eye for added depth and drama. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a cylindrical electric device with a smooth, metallic beige finish and a black base. The bottom center displays a dark blue circular section with branding and certification markings in white, labeled 'Tamper,' 'CE,' and other symbols. The black power cord exits from the bottom, extending to the right. The background is a neutral light grey, and the lighting is soft and diffused, creating a clean and sophisticated style. The right image, however, shows a rectangular device instead of a cylindrical one, which deviates from the prompt's specifications.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the shape of the device to be cylindrical instead of rectangular. Adjust the lighting to create a softer, more diffused effect for a sleek and modern aesthetic."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49795_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49795_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Close-up product photo of a cylindrical electric device viewed from the base, positioned at an angle showing the bottom and part of the side. The object's exterior features a smooth, metallic beige finish with a black base. The bottom center displays a dark blue circular section with branding and certification markings in white, labeled "Tamper," "CE" and other symbols. A black power cord exits from the bottom, extending to the right. The background is a neutral light grey, enhancing the sleek and modern aesthetic. Product photography, minimalistic composition, high contrast, soft diffused lighting, sharp focus on the object, cool neutral color palette, contemporary design, clean and sophisticated style. | 14188 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a cylindrical electric device with a smooth, metallic beige finish and a black base. The bottom center displays a dark blue circular section with branding and certification markings in white, labeled 'Tamper,' 'CE,' and other symbols. The black power cord exits from the bottom, extending to the right. The background is a neutral light grey, and the lighting is soft and diffused, creating a clean and sophisticated style. The right image, however, shows a rectangular device instead of a cylindrical one, which deviates from the prompt's specifications. | left | Change the shape of the device to be cylindrical instead of rectangular. Adjust the lighting to create a softer, more diffused effect for a sleek and modern aesthetic. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features plush grey velvet chairs with wooden legs, which match the description, while the right image has chairs with black metal legs that deviate from the prompt. Additionally, the left image has a more balanced and serene composition, with the cabinetry seamlessly integrated into the white wall, as described. The right image has a slightly cluttered feel due to the visible decor on the cabinetry, which detracts from the minimalistic and serene ambiance specified in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the chairs with plush grey velvet chairs featuring wooden legs. Remove the decor items on the cabinetry to create a cleaner, more minimalistic look."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49796_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49796_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Sophisticated interior design of a modern dining area. A round marble-topped table with four plush, grey velvet chairs is centrally positioned on a herringbone-patterned wooden floor. Above the table, a brass chandelier with cylindrical white lampshades hangs from the ceiling. The background features floor-to-ceiling grey curtains, partially open to reveal large glass doors leading to a balcony, with greenery visible outside. The walls are white and seamlessly integrated with the cabinetry on the right. The image captures a blend of elegance and simplicity, using neutral tones and clean lines. Natural light filters through the sheer curtains, casting soft shadows and reflections on the polished floor. High-end interior design photography, minimalistic, serene ambiance, balanced composition, soft natural lighting, neutral color palette, modern aesthetic, refined textures, inviting and calm. | 14189 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features plush grey velvet chairs with wooden legs, which match the description, while the right image has chairs with black metal legs that deviate from the prompt. Additionally, the left image has a more balanced and serene composition, with the cabinetry seamlessly integrated into the white wall, as described. The right image has a slightly cluttered feel due to the visible decor on the cabinetry, which detracts from the minimalistic and serene ambiance specified in the prompt. | left | Replace the chairs with plush grey velvet chairs featuring wooden legs. Remove the decor items on the cabinetry to create a cleaner, more minimalistic look. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The right image better aligns with the prompt as it features the specified geometric gold and black oversized earrings, a gold ring on the index finger, and a more accurate depiction of the sheer yellow fabric around the neck. The left image has earrings that do not match the geometric description and lacks the gold ring on the index finger. Additionally, the right image has a more polished and editorial aesthetic with vibrant color contrast and sharp details.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the earrings with oversized geometric gold and black earrings. Add a gold ring to the index finger of the right hand."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49798_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49798_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Close-up portrait of a young woman with her eyes closed, exuding a serene and contemplative expression against a white background. Her hair is slicked back, styled upward from the forehead. She wears shimmering eye makeup with glitter details and bold metallic lipstick. Her hands gently hold a sheer yellow fabric around her neck, with manicured fingers partly visible. She sports an oversized, geometric earring in gold and black, and a matching gold ring on her right hand's index finger. The lighting is bright, creating high contrast and soft shadows, with a minimalist and elegant aesthetic. Fashion photography, crisp focus, high-key lighting, vibrant color contrast, sharp details, editorial style, sophisticated and modern. | 14191 | The right image better aligns with the prompt as it features the specified geometric gold and black oversized earrings, a gold ring on the index finger, and a more accurate depiction of the sheer yellow fabric around the neck. The left image has earrings that do not match the geometric description and lacks the gold ring on the index finger. Additionally, the right image has a more polished and editorial aesthetic with vibrant color contrast and sharp details. | right | Replace the earrings with oversized geometric gold and black earrings. Add a gold ring to the index finger of the right hand. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the blue bicycle leaning against the fence near the street sign marked 'Rua da Ladeira,' which is missing in the right image. Additionally, the left image has a more prominent cobblestone street with glistening reflections, as described in the prompt. The right image lacks the cobblestone texture and instead shows a smoother street surface, which deviates from the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a blue bicycle leaning against the fence near the street sign. Replace the smooth street surface with dark cobblestones that glisten in the rain."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49799_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49799_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Animated nighttime scene of a small, rain-soaked suburban street, featuring a quaint two-story house with a red-tiled roof in the center. The house has blue walls with warm yellow light spilling from its windows, creating a cozy contrast against the dark, wet environment. Adjacent to it, a similar style house with a yellow roof. In the foreground, a red car is parked to the right, reflecting rainy street lights off its surface. To the left, a blue bicycle is leaning against a fence near a street sign marked "Rua da Ladeira." Overhead, a network of power lines connects between utility poles. The street is paved with dark cobblestones, glistening in the rain, with puddles and reflections creating a dynamic surface. The general ambiance is moody and atmospheric, with dramatic lighting and a muted color palette. The rain is heavy, adding to the somber, reflective tone of the scene. Animated style, intricate detail, balanced composition, cinematic quality, evocative of calm yet melancholic urban life. | 14192 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the blue bicycle leaning against the fence near the street sign marked 'Rua da Ladeira,' which is missing in the right image. Additionally, the left image has a more prominent cobblestone street with glistening reflections, as described in the prompt. The right image lacks the cobblestone texture and instead shows a smoother street surface, which deviates from the prompt. | left | Add a blue bicycle leaning against the fence near the street sign. Replace the smooth street surface with dark cobblestones that glisten in the rain. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a strip of yellow glue being held by hands, but the glue strip lacks texture and appears flat. The face on the paper is present but lacks detail. The glue bottle in the top right corner is correctly positioned and labeled 'Cola Plástica'. The scattered blue paper cut-outs and the pencil are present, but the overall arrangement feels less dynamic. The right image has a more detailed face on the paper and a textured yellow glue strip being held. However, the glue bottle is slightly misplaced, and the scattered blue paper cut-outs are less abundant, reducing the sense of creative clutter.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Reposition the glue bottle to the top right corner. Add more scattered blue paper cut-outs around the white sheet to enhance the sense of creative clutter."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49797_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49797_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Children's craft project on a dark surface, featuring a pair of hands on the left holding a strip of yellow glue with an image of a face on paper. A white sheet is centralized, adorned with various blue paper cut-outs like stars, hearts, houses, and abstract shapes. Positioned in the top right corner is a yellow glue bottle with a label reading "Cola Plástica". Around the white sheet are scattered pieces of blue paper. The pencil to the left of the hands suggests additional craft supplies out of focus. Soft natural lighting, high contrast, educational and playful atmosphere, texture-rich paper materials, casual clutter indicative of creative activity. | 14190 | The left image features a strip of yellow glue being held by hands, but the glue strip lacks texture and appears flat. The face on the paper is present but lacks detail. The glue bottle in the top right corner is correctly positioned and labeled 'Cola Plástica'. The scattered blue paper cut-outs and the pencil are present, but the overall arrangement feels less dynamic. The right image has a more detailed face on the paper and a textured yellow glue strip being held. However, the glue bottle is slightly misplaced, and the scattered blue paper cut-outs are less abundant, reducing the sense of creative clutter. | right | Reposition the glue bottle to the top right corner. Add more scattered blue paper cut-outs around the white sheet to enhance the sense of creative clutter. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has two incense sticks instead of one, and they are positioned vertically rather than horizontally. The background gradient is present but lacks the tranquil atmosphere due to the incorrect orientation of the incense sticks. The right image correctly features a single incense stick placed horizontally on the holder, with a glowing pink tip on the left side. The edge of the table with a natural wood cross-section is visible, and the overall composition aligns better with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Remove one of the incense sticks. Rotate the remaining incense stick to a horizontal position resting on the holder."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49802_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49802_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Minimalist photograph of a black incense holder placed horizontally on a matte black surface, positioned in the center of the frame. An incense stick, ash gray in color, is resting on the holder with a faint pink glowing tip, situated on the left side of the holder. The background is a soft, defocused gradient of light gray, creating a tranquil atmosphere. The edge of the table is visible at the bottom, showing a natural wood cross-section. Simple composition, high clarity, natural lighting, focus on minimal aesthetic, subtle contrast, tranquil and meditative mood, clean lines, contemporary design. | 14195 | The left image has two incense sticks instead of one, and they are positioned vertically rather than horizontally. The background gradient is present but lacks the tranquil atmosphere due to the incorrect orientation of the incense sticks. The right image correctly features a single incense stick placed horizontally on the holder, with a glowing pink tip on the left side. The edge of the table with a natural wood cross-section is visible, and the overall composition aligns better with the prompt. | right | Remove one of the incense sticks. Rotate the remaining incense stick to a horizontal position resting on the holder. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a red-hued sea creature with flowing hair and pearls, holding a seashell, but the figure is seated and lacks a whimsical, dynamic pose. The sea turtle is present but does not appear to be smiling or clutching a shell. The child is interacting with a sandcastle but is not reaching towards the sea creature. The lighthouse and background elements are present but lack the abstract, interconnected geometric shapes and vibrant art deco influence. The right image better captures the prompt with a standing, dynamic sea creature adorned with pearls, holding a seashell, and surrounded by crabs. The sea turtle is smiling and clutching a shell. The child is reaching towards the sea creature, and the background includes a stylized lighthouse, abstract clouds, and geometric patterns, aligning with the prompt's surreal and playful ambiance.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Make the sea creature stand dynamically and interact with the child. Add geometric shapes and abstract patterns to the background for a more interconnected and whimsical feel."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49800_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49800_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Vibrant illustration featuring an abstract, whimsical underwater and coastal scene. Central figure resembles a red-hued mythological sea creature with flowing hair, adorned with pearls and surrounded by crabs, holding a seashell, positioned mid-right. A large, smiling sea turtle with a blue eye, clutching a shell, is situated to the lower right. To the left, a smiling child with short dark hair reaching towards the sea creature from a sandcastle-adorned area. In the background, a stylized lighthouse emits light beams, set against a blue-green seascape with rolling waves and dotted patterns. Upper portion shows abstract clouds and sea life including fish and a whale. Elements interlace with geometric shapes, suggesting movement and interconnectedness. Soft gradients and bold, flat colors, warm and cool contrast, art deco influence, high saturation, dynamic composition, playful, dreamlike, surreal ambiance. | 14193 | The left image features a red-hued sea creature with flowing hair and pearls, holding a seashell, but the figure is seated and lacks a whimsical, dynamic pose. The sea turtle is present but does not appear to be smiling or clutching a shell. The child is interacting with a sandcastle but is not reaching towards the sea creature. The lighthouse and background elements are present but lack the abstract, interconnected geometric shapes and vibrant art deco influence. The right image better captures the prompt with a standing, dynamic sea creature adorned with pearls, holding a seashell, and surrounded by crabs. The sea turtle is smiling and clutching a shell. The child is reaching towards the sea creature, and the background includes a stylized lighthouse, abstract clouds, and geometric patterns, aligning with the prompt's surreal and playful ambiance. | right | Make the sea creature stand dynamically and interact with the child. Add geometric shapes and abstract patterns to the background for a more interconnected and whimsical feel. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a rectangular USB hub instead of a sleek, white one with three visible USB ports, and the hub is not positioned slightly above the center left. The right image correctly shows a sleek, white USB hub with three visible USB ports and better aligns with the prompt. However, the right image has an additional cable connected to the hub, which is unnecessary and not mentioned in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the rectangular USB hub with a sleek, white one featuring three visible USB ports. Remove the additional cable connected to the USB hub."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49803_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49803_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Close-up photo of a person's hands interacting with a sleek, white USB hub. The left hand holds the hub, positioned slightly above the center left, featuring three visible USB ports along its side. The right hand guides a gray USB cable towards a silver MacBook placed on the right side. The angle shows the MacBook's keyboard partially, with keys clearly visible, and the edge of the screen on the top right. The background is a softly blurred, light gray surface, providing a clean, minimalist setting. High resolution, crisp, natural lighting, neutral color palette, corporate and tech-focused, balanced composition. | 14196 | The left image features a rectangular USB hub instead of a sleek, white one with three visible USB ports, and the hub is not positioned slightly above the center left. The right image correctly shows a sleek, white USB hub with three visible USB ports and better aligns with the prompt. However, the right image has an additional cable connected to the hub, which is unnecessary and not mentioned in the prompt. | right | Replace the rectangular USB hub with a sleek, white one featuring three visible USB ports. Remove the additional cable connected to the USB hub. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a contemporary office interior with a juxtaposition of creative and functional workspaces. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the striking wall art installation made of clustered yellow balls resembling lemons, the modern chairs with yellow cushions, and the low round white table in the glass-walled meeting room. Additionally, the textured cylindrical pendant lamp is present, and the open office area features a woman seated at a desk with a bowl of lemons and a sleek black pendant lamp above her. The left image lacks the lemon-inspired wall art and the bowl of lemons on the desk, which are key elements of the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a striking wall art installation made of clustered yellow balls resembling lemons behind the chairs in the meeting room. Place a bowl of lemons on the desk in the open office area."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49801_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49801_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Contemporary office interior with a juxtaposition of a creative and functional workspace. On the left, a glass-walled meeting room is decorated with a striking wall art installation made of clustered yellow balls, resembling lemons, behind two modern chairs with yellow cushions and a low round white table. A textured cylindrical pendant lamp hangs from the ceiling, adding warmth to the space. Adjacent is an open office area where a woman is seated at a desk, focused on her computer, with a bowl of lemons on the desk as a decorative element. The background features a sleek, black pendant lamp providing task lighting above her. Further back, a hallway extends with white structural beams and windows placed high on the right wall, casting natural light throughout. The design is modern and minimalistic with high ceilings and polished concrete floors. Visual elements include strong geometric lines, use of bright accent colors, and a blend of natural and artificial lighting. The atmosphere is professional yet inviting, with clean contemporary aesthetics and a playful touch from the lemon-inspired decor. | 14194 | Both images depict a contemporary office interior with a juxtaposition of creative and functional workspaces. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the striking wall art installation made of clustered yellow balls resembling lemons, the modern chairs with yellow cushions, and the low round white table in the glass-walled meeting room. Additionally, the textured cylindrical pendant lamp is present, and the open office area features a woman seated at a desk with a bowl of lemons and a sleek black pendant lamp above her. The left image lacks the lemon-inspired wall art and the bowl of lemons on the desk, which are key elements of the prompt. | right | Add a striking wall art installation made of clustered yellow balls resembling lemons behind the chairs in the meeting room. Place a bowl of lemons on the desk in the open office area. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features three women arranged as described, with the woman on the left gazing contemplatively, the central woman in a prayer-like pose with elaborate jewelry, and the woman on the right with her back turned and head slightly turned. The lighting is dramatic, emphasizing contours and shadows, and the composition is poised. The right image deviates from the prompt as the woman on the left is not gazing contemplatively into the distance, and the woman on the right does not fully reveal her back or have her head turned slightly to the left. Additionally, the background in the right image is not seamless due to visible fabric folds.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the pose of the woman on the left to have her gaze contemplatively into the distance. Remove the visible fabric folds in the background to create a seamless dark backdrop."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49804_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49804_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Moody black and white portrait of three women arranged from left to right against a dark, seamless background. The woman on the left gazes contemplatively into the distance, wearing a strapless top and floral headpiece. The central woman, facing forward, has eyes closed and hands clasped in a prayer-like gesture, adorned with elaborate necklaces and bracelets. She wears a similar floral garland. The woman on the right stands with her back to the camera, her head turned slightly to the left, with another floral headdress, partially revealing her bare back. Dramatic lighting emphasizes contours and shadows, creating a high-contrast, grainy texture. Fine art photography, intimate, timeless, introspective, high contrast, monochromatic, rich gradients, poised composition. | 14197 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features three women arranged as described, with the woman on the left gazing contemplatively, the central woman in a prayer-like pose with elaborate jewelry, and the woman on the right with her back turned and head slightly turned. The lighting is dramatic, emphasizing contours and shadows, and the composition is poised. The right image deviates from the prompt as the woman on the left is not gazing contemplatively into the distance, and the woman on the right does not fully reveal her back or have her head turned slightly to the left. Additionally, the background in the right image is not seamless due to visible fabric folds. | left | Adjust the pose of the woman on the left to have her gaze contemplatively into the distance. Remove the visible fabric folds in the background to create a seamless dark backdrop. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a loop-shaped form with a hollow top, a smooth rounded base, and two protruding elements, resembling a stylized figure or knot. The material appears matte and slightly translucent, with soft shadows and a minimalistic composition. The right image, while loop-shaped, lacks the two distinct protruding elements and appears shinier rather than matte, deviating from the prompt's description of a slightly translucent and matte material.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add two distinct protruding elements to the base of the sculpture. Adjust the material to appear matte and slightly translucent instead of shiny."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49806_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49806_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Abstract sculpture, a beige, loop-shaped form standing upright on a flat surface. Positioned centrally against a plain white background, the object features a smooth, rounded base with two protruding elements and a hollow loop at the top, resembling a stylized figure or knot. The material appears matte and slightly translucent, casting soft shadows onto the surface. Minimalistic composition, soft form, neutral color palette, subtle texture, high-key lighting, minimalist art, simplistic yet intriguing, focus on shape and form, sculptural art, serene atmosphere. | 14199 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a loop-shaped form with a hollow top, a smooth rounded base, and two protruding elements, resembling a stylized figure or knot. The material appears matte and slightly translucent, with soft shadows and a minimalistic composition. The right image, while loop-shaped, lacks the two distinct protruding elements and appears shinier rather than matte, deviating from the prompt's description of a slightly translucent and matte material. | left | Add two distinct protruding elements to the base of the sculpture. Adjust the material to appear matte and slightly translucent instead of shiny. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more intricate and detailed wood-like texture on the torus, a more pronounced gradient of transparency, and better ambient light reflections. The right image lacks the same level of detail in the wood-like texture and has a less dynamic gradient of transparency, making it less visually complex and less aligned with the prompt's requirements for hyper-realistic rendering and intricate detailing.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the wood-like texture on the torus to make it more intricate and spiraling. Increase the gradient of transparency on the torus to better reflect ambient light."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49805_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49805_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | A 3D digital artwork featuring a futuristic sculpture set against a light gray textured background, centrally placed in the frame. The sculpture consists of a glossy, white and silver metallic spherical object encapsulated within a translucent, twisting torus. The torus has a gradient pattern of transparency and reflects ambient light. It is intricately detailed with a wood-like texture spiraling around its exterior. Inside the torus are small, metallic spheres of silver and copper colors, adding complexity and depth. Hyper-realistic rendering, photorealistic textures, high gloss, metallic finish, intricate detailing, harmonious color palette of whites, silvers, and warm wood tones. Balanced composition, soft ambient lighting, futuristic and abstract aesthetic, sleek and sophisticated. | 14198 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more intricate and detailed wood-like texture on the torus, a more pronounced gradient of transparency, and better ambient light reflections. The right image lacks the same level of detail in the wood-like texture and has a less dynamic gradient of transparency, making it less visually complex and less aligned with the prompt's requirements for hyper-realistic rendering and intricate detailing. | left | Enhance the wood-like texture on the torus to make it more intricate and spiraling. Increase the gradient of transparency on the torus to better reflect ambient light. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a close-up of watch gears, but the components are not predominantly silver and white as specified in the prompt, and the motion or depth effect is minimal. The right image showcases a metallic stand with cylindrical and rectangular components against a solid blue background, aligning well with the prompt's description of sleek structure and industrial design. The lighting and focus on the right side are sharp and consistent with the prompt, while the left side lacks the required blurred and softly focused effect for the watch components.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Make the watch gears predominantly silver and white. Add a blurred effect to the watch components to convey motion or depth."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49808_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49808_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Split-screen image showcasing contrasting themes of precision and structure. On the left, a close-up of intricate watch gears, predominantly silver and white, with visible components such as gears and screws, arranged in a circular pattern with blurred elements to convey motion or depth. On the right, a metallic stand or rig with cylindrical and rectangular components shown against a solid blue background, highlighting its sleek structure with black and metallic materials. High-contrast lighting between both sides, sharp focus on the mechanical stand, blurred and softly focused watch components, clean and modern aesthetic, industrial design, and mechanical precision, visually balanced dichotomy. | 14201 | The left image features a close-up of watch gears, but the components are not predominantly silver and white as specified in the prompt, and the motion or depth effect is minimal. The right image showcases a metallic stand with cylindrical and rectangular components against a solid blue background, aligning well with the prompt's description of sleek structure and industrial design. The lighting and focus on the right side are sharp and consistent with the prompt, while the left side lacks the required blurred and softly focused effect for the watch components. | right | Make the watch gears predominantly silver and white. Add a blurred effect to the watch components to convey motion or depth. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a large sheet of paper with a detailed hand-drawn map-like sketch of intricate, repetitive patterns resembling elevation lines. The paper is taped at the top left corner, and a fine-tip black marker is placed in the bottom left corner. Additionally, the floral fabric with red roses and green leaves is partially visible to the right. The right image, while similar, has the paper taped at all four corners instead of just the top left, and the patterns on the map are more three-dimensional, deviating from the flat, hand-drawn style described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the tape from all corners except the top left. Flatten the map-like sketch to remove the three-dimensional appearance, making it look hand-drawn."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49810_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49810_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Overhead photo of a large sheet of paper on a wooden desk with a detailed hand-drawn map-like sketch covering most of its surface. The paper is taped at the top left corner for stability. A fine tip black marker rests on the table in the bottom left corner, suggesting its use for the drawing. The map features intricate, repetitive patterns resembling waves or elevation lines, occupying the center with uneven edges. To the right, partially cropped, are pieces of another artwork with floral fabric featuring red roses and green leaves beneath it. The lighting is natural and even, creating a workspace feel. The perspective is slightly angled, revealing the textural quality of the paper, with a tactile, artisanal atmosphere. The setting is informal and casual, with rustic and artistic sensibilities. | 14202 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a large sheet of paper with a detailed hand-drawn map-like sketch of intricate, repetitive patterns resembling elevation lines. The paper is taped at the top left corner, and a fine-tip black marker is placed in the bottom left corner. Additionally, the floral fabric with red roses and green leaves is partially visible to the right. The right image, while similar, has the paper taped at all four corners instead of just the top left, and the patterns on the map are more three-dimensional, deviating from the flat, hand-drawn style described in the prompt. | left | Remove the tape from all corners except the top left. Flatten the map-like sketch to remove the three-dimensional appearance, making it look hand-drawn. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images align closely with the prompt, but the right image better matches the description. The right image includes the arched brick wall with a circular opening, which is missing in the left image. Additionally, the right image has a more prominent copper-toned bar counter and includes the correct number of black bar stools (two), while the left image has three stools, deviating from the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add an arched brick wall with a circular opening on the left side of the room. Reduce the number of black bar stools behind the bar counter to two."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49807_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49807_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Contemporary interior design of a rustic dining area with modern elements. Central wooden dining table with a large oval stone bowl filled with oranges. Black leather and wood chairs surround the table, creating an inviting seating arrangement. In the background, a wall clad in light wood paneling, intersected by a long copper-toned bar counter. Two black bar stools sit behind the bar. Above the table, a row of five black pendant lamps of varying shapes are suspended. Left side features an arched brick wall with a circular opening, providing a subtle contrast to the room's linear aesthetics. To the right, large, tall windows with horizontal blinds allow natural light in, illuminating a large green potted plant in a sleek black planter. The ceiling is high with exposed wooden beams, and the flooring is a muted polished concrete. The warm, earthy tones of the brick and copper contrast effectively with the coolness of blacks and greens. Modern rustic aesthetic, high contrast, natural lighting, minimalist style harmonized with industrial elements, inviting, organized, warm, and contemporary ambiance. | 14200 | Both images align closely with the prompt, but the right image better matches the description. The right image includes the arched brick wall with a circular opening, which is missing in the left image. Additionally, the right image has a more prominent copper-toned bar counter and includes the correct number of black bar stools (two), while the left image has three stools, deviating from the prompt. | right | Add an arched brick wall with a circular opening on the left side of the room. Reduce the number of black bar stools behind the bar counter to two. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more chaotic and rhythmically balanced composition with a dense, tangled mass of hands and tubes. The hands exhibit exaggerated curves and bulbous fingers, with a stippled texture that enhances their three-dimensional appearance. The background tubes are dark and smooth, creating depth and contrast. The right image, while containing similar elements, lacks the same level of chaos and density, and the hands appear less exaggerated and less textured, reducing the surreal and vintage animation style described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the density of hands and tubes to create a more chaotic composition. Add stippled texture to the hands to enhance their three-dimensional, soft appearance."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49811_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49811_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Surreal black and white digital illustration featuring a tangled mass of cartoonish, glove-like hands interwoven with thick, serpentine tubes. The hands, resembling vintage animation style with exaggerated curves and bulbous fingers, are scattered across the composition in various positions and orientations, with some palms facing outwards and others inwards. Each hand is detailed with a stippled texture, enhancing the three-dimensional, soft appearance. The background consists of intertwined, dark, smooth tubes creating a sense of depth and complexity. High contrast between the white hands and darker elements, textured surface, abstract theme, chaotic yet rhythmically balanced composition, mono-color scheme, nostalgic and playful, reminiscent of classic animation icons, visual tension between form and fluidity. | 14203 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more chaotic and rhythmically balanced composition with a dense, tangled mass of hands and tubes. The hands exhibit exaggerated curves and bulbous fingers, with a stippled texture that enhances their three-dimensional appearance. The background tubes are dark and smooth, creating depth and contrast. The right image, while containing similar elements, lacks the same level of chaos and density, and the hands appear less exaggerated and less textured, reducing the surreal and vintage animation style described in the prompt. | left | Increase the density of hands and tubes to create a more chaotic composition. Add stippled texture to the hands to enhance their three-dimensional, soft appearance. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as the book is centered and standing upright with a clean, minimalist composition. The round white label with the text is clearly visible and well-positioned. The right image, while featuring the same book, has the book slightly tilted and positioned further to the right than specified in the prompt, disrupting the minimalist and centered aesthetic.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Center the book in the frame. Adjust the book to stand upright without tilting."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49813_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49813_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Minimalist product shot of a blue hardcover book standing slightly to the right, centered against a solid pink background. The book features a round white label with the text "ETC.ASE BOOK : PERFECTION" in red, situated on the front cover. The pink backdrop creates a high-contrast environment that emphasizes the vibrant blue hue of the book. Clean lines and a sleek presentation highlight a modern and elegant aesthetic. Studio photography, well-lit, high contrast, smooth texture, minimalist composition, pastel color palette, crisp and vivid. | 14205 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as the book is centered and standing upright with a clean, minimalist composition. The round white label with the text is clearly visible and well-positioned. The right image, while featuring the same book, has the book slightly tilted and positioned further to the right than specified in the prompt, disrupting the minimalist and centered aesthetic. | left | Center the book in the frame. Adjust the book to stand upright without tilting. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image includes most of the elements from the prompt, such as the elderly couple dancing, the anthropomorphic animal band, and the whimsical atmosphere. However, it has some inaccuracies: the fish is missing, the rooster is not holding a briefcase, and the woman with voluminous black hair is not holding a small dog. The right image also captures the whimsical atmosphere but has more significant deviations: the fish is missing, the rooster is holding a briefcase but is not anthropomorphic, the woman with voluminous black hair is not present, and the cow lacks a sandwich. Additionally, the string lights in the right image are multicolored instead of plain. Overall, the left image aligns better with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a fish playing a banjo to the animal band. Make the rooster hold a briefcase in its wing."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49812_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49812_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Whimsical illustration depicting an outdoor gathering at sunset. Centered, an elderly couple with oversized eyeglasses dance joyfully, the woman wearing a pink floral dress and the man in a brown sweater. To their left, a band of anthropomorphic animals plays music: a blue rhinoceros with a clarinet, an orange lion with drums, and a fish playing a banjo, all wearing checkered jackets. In the right foreground, a rooster in a suit holds a briefcase, standing near a child in a green striped sweater. A woman with voluminous black hair drinks from a glass, holding a small dog. Colorful butterflies flit around a cow resting on the ground, the cow holding a sandwich. Overhead, string lights illuminate the scene, set against a gradient sky of orange, pink, and blue. Cartoon style, vibrant color palette, playful and lively atmosphere, dynamic composition, detailed textures, surreal and fantastical elements, whimsical, cheerful mood. | 14204 | The left image includes most of the elements from the prompt, such as the elderly couple dancing, the anthropomorphic animal band, and the whimsical atmosphere. However, it has some inaccuracies: the fish is missing, the rooster is not holding a briefcase, and the woman with voluminous black hair is not holding a small dog. The right image also captures the whimsical atmosphere but has more significant deviations: the fish is missing, the rooster is holding a briefcase but is not anthropomorphic, the woman with voluminous black hair is not present, and the cow lacks a sandwich. Additionally, the string lights in the right image are multicolored instead of plain. Overall, the left image aligns better with the prompt. | left | Add a fish playing a banjo to the animal band. Make the rooster hold a briefcase in its wing. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a man in traditional attire riding a brown horse in an equestrian setting. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a white bridle on the horse, a more natural and sunlit lighting, and a clear sandy arena. The right image lacks the white bridle and has a slightly less natural lighting tone, making it less consistent with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a white bridle to the horse. Adjust the lighting to appear more natural and sunlit, enhancing the warm color palette."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49816_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49816_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | A photo of a man wearing traditional attire with a red and white poncho and a black hat, riding a brown horse in an equestrian setting. The man occupies the left and center foreground, seated confidently on the horse, with his gaze directed forward. The horse, adorned with a white bridle and protective leg gear, stands in a sandy arena. Behind them, there is a lush line of greenery including palm trees and hedges, providing a vivid contrast to the rocky hills in the distant background. The lighting is natural and sunlit, casting soft shadows on the ground. Earthy colors dominate the scene, enhanced by a warm color palette. Photorealistic with a sharp focus on the rider and horse, medium depth of field, clear midday lighting, rugged natural landscape, pastoral, tranquil, culturally rich setting. | 14207 | Both images depict a man in traditional attire riding a brown horse in an equestrian setting. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a white bridle on the horse, a more natural and sunlit lighting, and a clear sandy arena. The right image lacks the white bridle and has a slightly less natural lighting tone, making it less consistent with the prompt. | left | Add a white bridle to the horse. Adjust the lighting to appear more natural and sunlit, enhancing the warm color palette. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It captures the woman in motion with flowing, wavy hair and a sleeveless, black, sequined dress that reflects light. Her left hand is raised, gently tousling her hair, and the background features a dark bokeh effect with white light orbs. The pink lines frame her effectively, and the lighting highlights her facial features and the dress's texture. In contrast, the right image has a less dynamic pose, with the hair appearing less flowing and dramatic. The dress has thin straps, which deviates from the sleeveless description, and the framing with pink lines is less prominent.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the dress sleeveless and ensure it reflects light dynamically. Enhance the flow of the hair to appear more dramatic and wind-swept."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49814_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49814_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Black and white high-fashion photograph of a woman captured in motion. The woman, centrally positioned, gazes directly at the camera. Her long, wavy hair flows dramatically as if caught by a breeze. She wears a sleeveless, black, sequined dress that reflects light, adding a dynamic sparkle to the garment. Her left hand is raised, fingers gently tousling her hair, while the right hand holds a small, indistinct object. The background is dark, filled with out-of-focus white light orbs creating a bokeh effect, adding a sense of movement and depth. Pink lines frame her in the image, emphasizing her position. Studio lighting is soft yet dramatic, highlighting her facial features and the dress's texture. The overall aesthetic is glamorous, chic, and energetic, evoking a sense of night-time allure. Fashion photography, high contrast, crisp focus on the subject, ethereal, lively, elegant composition. | 14206 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It captures the woman in motion with flowing, wavy hair and a sleeveless, black, sequined dress that reflects light. Her left hand is raised, gently tousling her hair, and the background features a dark bokeh effect with white light orbs. The pink lines frame her effectively, and the lighting highlights her facial features and the dress's texture. In contrast, the right image has a less dynamic pose, with the hair appearing less flowing and dramatic. The dress has thin straps, which deviates from the sleeveless description, and the framing with pink lines is less prominent. | left | Make the dress sleeveless and ensure it reflects light dynamically. Enhance the flow of the hair to appear more dramatic and wind-swept. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features the figures holding metallic spheres instead of futuristic cannon-like objects, which deviates from the prompt. The right image correctly depicts the figures holding futuristic-looking cannon-like objects with metallic surfaces reflecting multicolored light. Additionally, the lighting in the right image better accentuates the shiny textures and highlights the metallic objects with hues of blue and red, aligning more closely with the prompt's description of dramatic lighting and a bold color palette.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the metallic spheres with futuristic cannon-like objects reflecting multicolored light. Enhance the lighting to create more dramatic highlights with hues of blue and red on the metallic surfaces."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49817_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49817_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | A surreal and vibrant studio portrait of two figures, one a man with short dark hair, a goatee, and sunglasses, and the other wearing a large, realistic lion head mask. Both are dressed in matching gold sequin tuxedos with white shirts and bow ties, positioned in the center of the frame, facing each other. Each figure holds a large, futuristic-looking cannon-like object with metallic surfaces reflecting multicolored light. The background is a smooth gradient from grey to lavender, adding to the fantastical scene. Dramatic lighting accentuates the shiny textures and highlights the metallic objects with hues of blue and red, saturated, high contrast, whimsical, playful, modern, stylized, visually engaging, studio photography, extravagant, bold color palette, dynamic composition. | 14208 | The left image features the figures holding metallic spheres instead of futuristic cannon-like objects, which deviates from the prompt. The right image correctly depicts the figures holding futuristic-looking cannon-like objects with metallic surfaces reflecting multicolored light. Additionally, the lighting in the right image better accentuates the shiny textures and highlights the metallic objects with hues of blue and red, aligning more closely with the prompt's description of dramatic lighting and a bold color palette. | right | Replace the metallic spheres with futuristic cannon-like objects reflecting multicolored light. Enhance the lighting to create more dramatic highlights with hues of blue and red on the metallic surfaces. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It accurately depicts the classical portrait of Princess Dagmar in an elegant white gown with a small black dog on the chair, and the surreal version with a nebula replacing her face while keeping the background and dog unchanged. The right image deviates from the prompt as the surreal panel alters the background and introduces a glowing effect on the chest instead of replacing the face with a nebula. Additionally, the dog is different in the classical panel, and the hairstyle and jewelry are inconsistent with the description.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the dog in the classical panel with a small black dog sitting on the chair. Replace the glowing effect on the chest in the surreal panel with a vibrant nebula replacing the woman's face, using purples and pinks."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49819_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49819_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Dual panel of a classical portrait juxtaposed with a surreal version. Left panel shows a regal woman, identified as Princess Dagmar of Denmark, in an elegant white gown standing beside a chair. She holds onto the armrest where a small black dog sits. Her hair is styled in an updo and she wears a pearl necklace and gold bracelets. Behind her, a warm red-brown wall features a decorative gold-decorated pedestal and a white sculpture bust. The right panel mirrors this composition but replaces the woman’s face with a vibrant, glowing nebula, purples and pinks creating an ethereal effect. The dog and background remain unchanged. Classical oil painting style, photorealistic details, rich textures, baroque influences, dramatic contrast, elegant, seamless blend of classical and abstract elements. | 14210 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It accurately depicts the classical portrait of Princess Dagmar in an elegant white gown with a small black dog on the chair, and the surreal version with a nebula replacing her face while keeping the background and dog unchanged. The right image deviates from the prompt as the surreal panel alters the background and introduces a glowing effect on the chest instead of replacing the face with a nebula. Additionally, the dog is different in the classical panel, and the hairstyle and jewelry are inconsistent with the description. | left | Replace the dog in the classical panel with a small black dog sitting on the chair. Replace the glowing effect on the chest in the surreal panel with a vibrant nebula replacing the woman's face, using purples and pinks. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the woman in the foreground with a vibrant tie-dye sweatshirt, black-and-white checkered pants, and pointed black ankle boots, along with a dramatic hairstyle and bold red-orange makeup. The second woman is positioned slightly behind and to the left, with a serene expression and matching styling. The right image deviates from the prompt as both women are positioned side by side, and the dynamic, playful pose of the foreground woman is less pronounced. Additionally, the dramatic flow of hair is missing in the right image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the pose of the foreground woman to be more dynamic and extended, with her body crouched and hair flowing dramatically to the side. Position the second woman slightly behind and to the left of the foreground woman, ensuring her expression is serene and contrasting."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49818_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49818_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Two young women with platinum blonde hair in a dynamic, playful pose against a plain blue backdrop. The woman crouching in the foreground wears a vibrant tie-dye sweatshirt in shades of blue, pink, and yellow, paired with black-and-white checkered pants and pointed black ankle boots. Her hair is styled to flow dramatically to the side as she extends her body, with a mischievous expression enhanced by bold red-orange makeup around her eyes and cheeks. The second woman, positioned slightly behind and to the left, mirrors the hairstyle and makeup. Her expression is more serene, providing contrast to the playful pose. High fashion editorial photography, dramatic styling, vibrant color scheme, studio lighting, clean minimal background, expressive and avant-garde, strong contrast, visually striking composition, contemporary and bold aesthetic. | 14209 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the woman in the foreground with a vibrant tie-dye sweatshirt, black-and-white checkered pants, and pointed black ankle boots, along with a dramatic hairstyle and bold red-orange makeup. The second woman is positioned slightly behind and to the left, with a serene expression and matching styling. The right image deviates from the prompt as both women are positioned side by side, and the dynamic, playful pose of the foreground woman is less pronounced. Additionally, the dramatic flow of hair is missing in the right image. | left | Adjust the pose of the foreground woman to be more dynamic and extended, with her body crouched and hair flowing dramatically to the side. Position the second woman slightly behind and to the left of the foreground woman, ensuring her expression is serene and contrasting. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes a woman with curly hair dancing joyfully in a light pink dress, a waiter carrying a tray with three orange cocktails, and a woman sitting on a yellow swing holding a drink. The right image has inaccuracies: the woman dancing has straight hair instead of curly, the waiter carries two cocktails instead of three, and the woman on the swing is not crossing her legs and is not holding a drink.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the dancer's hair to curly. Add a third orange cocktail to the waiter's tray."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49820_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49820_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Illustration of a lively outdoor garden party in a stylized, flat graphic design. In the left foreground, a woman with curly hair dances joyfully, wearing a light pink dress and smiling with closed eyes. Nearby, to the right, a waiter in a black vest and bow tie walks carrying a tray with three orange cocktails. In the right background, a woman sits comfortably on a yellow swing hanging from a tree, holding a drink and crossing her legs, dressed in a light blue blouse and black pants. The setting includes white ornate garden tables and chairs scattered across a green lawn, with a large tree wrapped in strings of white lights overhead. The background fades into a hilly landscape under a clear blue sky. Vibrant, whimsical, flat color palette, stylized curves and shapes, playful and elegant atmosphere, balanced composition, festive, cheerful. | 14211 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes a woman with curly hair dancing joyfully in a light pink dress, a waiter carrying a tray with three orange cocktails, and a woman sitting on a yellow swing holding a drink. The right image has inaccuracies: the woman dancing has straight hair instead of curly, the waiter carries two cocktails instead of three, and the woman on the swing is not crossing her legs and is not holding a drink. | left | Change the dancer's hair to curly. Add a third orange cocktail to the waiter's tray. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the moody, contemplative atmosphere with a more abstracted background and a stronger emphasis on chiaroscuro. The figure is centrally positioned, wearing the described attire, and the screen emits a warm glow that subtly illuminates the figure and the bed. The right image, while similar, has a more detailed and less abstract background, which detracts from the impressionistic style. Additionally, the lighting in the right image is less diffused and dramatic, reducing the sense of isolation and introspection.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Simplify the background by abstracting or removing detailed objects and furniture. Enhance the chiaroscuro effect by increasing the contrast between the screen's glow and the surrounding darkness."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49822_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49822_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Moody digital painting of a solitary figure seated on a bed, faced away, intently watching a small screen in a dimly lit room. The figure is centrally positioned, wearing a loose, pale shirt, and dark pants, legs crossed in front. The screen, positioned at the upper center, emits a warm glow that subtly illuminates the figure's back and part of the bed. The surrounding environment is enveloped in darkness, with deep shadows and slight hints of distant objects barely visible in the periphery. Brushstroke texture, dark and muted color palette with contrasting light from the screen, evokes a sense of isolation and introspection, impressionistic style, soft, diffused lighting, dramatic emphasis on chiaroscuro, contemplative atmosphere, artistically abstracted background. | 14213 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the moody, contemplative atmosphere with a more abstracted background and a stronger emphasis on chiaroscuro. The figure is centrally positioned, wearing the described attire, and the screen emits a warm glow that subtly illuminates the figure and the bed. The right image, while similar, has a more detailed and less abstract background, which detracts from the impressionistic style. Additionally, the lighting in the right image is less diffused and dramatic, reducing the sense of isolation and introspection. | left | Simplify the background by abstracting or removing detailed objects and furniture. Enhance the chiaroscuro effect by increasing the contrast between the screen's glow and the surrounding darkness. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the floating platform accessed by a spiral staircase in the left center, a seating area with modern furniture in the center background, and a cozy reading nook with hanging wicker chairs in the lower left view. The right image lacks the hanging wicker chairs in the reading nook and does not emphasize the intricate details of the leaves and wall textures in the right view as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add hanging wicker chairs to the reading nook beneath the windows. Enhance the intricate details of the leaves and wall textures in the right view to emphasize the organic design elements."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49809_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49809_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Architectural rendering of a luxurious indoor garden space with monochrome color palette, showcasing three distinct views. The main image shows a large, open area with a floating platform accessed by a spiral staircase in the left center. Numerous large potted plants like palms and ferns are dispersed throughout the room, creating a lush atmosphere. Floor-to-ceiling windows with arched tops and vertical wooden paneling bring in ample natural light from the right side. A seating area with modern furniture is visible in the center background, adjacent to the platform. The lower left image highlights a cozy reading nook beneath the windows, with hanging wicker chairs. Overlapping rectangular stepping stones form a path on the textured floor. The right image focuses on the intricate details of the leaves and wall textures, emphasizing the room's organic design elements. Wireframe style, high level of detail, precise textures, serene and inviting atmosphere, minimalist yet complex, light and shadow play, digitally rendered, sophisticated interior design. | 14212 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the floating platform accessed by a spiral staircase in the left center, a seating area with modern furniture in the center background, and a cozy reading nook with hanging wicker chairs in the lower left view. The right image lacks the hanging wicker chairs in the reading nook and does not emphasize the intricate details of the leaves and wall textures in the right view as described in the prompt. | left | Add hanging wicker chairs to the reading nook beneath the windows. Enhance the intricate details of the leaves and wall textures in the right view to emphasize the organic design elements. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as the figure's hands are clasped together at chest level, matching the description. The right image has the hands crossed over the chest, which deviates from the prompt. Both images feature the futuristic humanoid figure with a shaved head, mechanical goggles, and a dark textured background. The lighting, monochromatic cool tones, and cyberpunk aesthetic are consistent in both images.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the hands to be clasped together at chest level. Ensure the elongated vertical lines falling from the face and chest area remain intact and symmetrical."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49824_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49824_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Digital artwork of a futuristic humanoid figure with a shaved head, positioned in the center against a dark, textured background. The figure wears intricate, mechanical goggles covering its eyes, adding a cybernetic feel. Its hands are clasped together at chest level, with elongated, vertical lines seemingly falling from the face and chest area, suggesting a surreal disintegration or transformation. The lighting is dramatic and directional, highlighting the metallic surfaces of the goggles and the smooth texture of the skin, producing a luminous and reflective quality. Monochromatic color palette with cool tones and subtle use of shadows, creating a high contrast effect. Slick, digitally rendered, futuristic, cyberpunk aesthetic, ethereal, and otherworldly. The composition is symmetrical and tightly focused, providing an intense and intimate atmosphere. | 14215 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as the figure's hands are clasped together at chest level, matching the description. The right image has the hands crossed over the chest, which deviates from the prompt. Both images feature the futuristic humanoid figure with a shaved head, mechanical goggles, and a dark textured background. The lighting, monochromatic cool tones, and cyberpunk aesthetic are consistent in both images. | left | Adjust the hands to be clasped together at chest level. Ensure the elongated vertical lines falling from the face and chest area remain intact and symmetrical. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a vibrant concert scene with a massive stage, DJs, and a dense crowd. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more intricate and geometric stage design with vivid multicolored projections and patterns. The central figure is clearly elevated and silhouetted against the stage lights, and the surrounding structures have luminous displays. The right image has a less intricate stage design and lacks the same level of geometric and psychedelic detail. Additionally, the mist and ethereal glow are more pronounced in the left image, enhancing the surreal atmosphere.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the stage design with more intricate geometric and psychedelic patterns, incorporating vivid multicolored projections. Increase the density and visibility of purple and pink mist to create a stronger ethereal glow throughout the scene."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49823_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49823_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Vibrant concert scene at an electronic music festival, characterized by a massive, intricately lit stage dominating the background. The stage features geometric and psychedelic designs, including bright, multicolored projections and patterns. Centered on the stage, two DJs, silhouettes against the vivid backdrop, manipulate their equipment. A dense crowd fills the foreground, with a central figure, possibly female, elevated above the rest, silhouetted by the vivid stage lights. Surrounding the stage are towering structures with luminous displays, adding to the immersive experience. The environment is filled with purple and pink mist, casting an ethereal glow throughout the scene. High energy, surreal atmosphere, dynamic composition, vibrant neon color palette, wide depth of field, concert photography, strong visual contrast, celebratory, immersive, night-time setting. | 14214 | Both images depict a vibrant concert scene with a massive stage, DJs, and a dense crowd. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more intricate and geometric stage design with vivid multicolored projections and patterns. The central figure is clearly elevated and silhouetted against the stage lights, and the surrounding structures have luminous displays. The right image has a less intricate stage design and lacks the same level of geometric and psychedelic detail. Additionally, the mist and ethereal glow are more pronounced in the left image, enhancing the surreal atmosphere. | left | Enhance the stage design with more intricate geometric and psychedelic patterns, incorporating vivid multicolored projections. Increase the density and visibility of purple and pink mist to create a stronger ethereal glow throughout the scene. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt due to its darker, moodier color palette and dramatic lighting, which enhances the apocalyptic and gritty atmosphere. The dense smoke and dust in the foreground create a sense of movement and tension, while the rugged terrain with sparse grass is more pronounced. The right image lacks the same level of dramatic lighting and contrast, appearing brighter and less ominous. Additionally, the smoke and dust in the foreground are less prominent, reducing the sense of tension and chaos.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Darken the overall lighting to create a moody, high-contrast atmosphere. Add dense, swirling smoke and dust in the foreground to enhance the sense of movement and tension."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49825_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49825_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Dramatic 3D render depicting a surreal, apocalyptic scene with an array of large firearms and grenades forming an archway, seen from a low angle. Positioned centrally are multiple assault rifles aimed upwards, their barrels almost touching at the top, with visible gun details and dark metallic textures. Flanking them are oversized smoke grenades, each with detailed text and pull rings, adding a sense of scale and dystopian chaos. Beneath this menacing arch lies a rugged, desolate terrain covered in sparse, dry grass, illuminated by a harsh, directional light that casts deep shadows. In the background, a heavily armored vehicle with glaring headlights looms with an ominous presence. The foreground is enveloped in swirling, dense smoke and dust, creating a sense of movement and tension across the scene. Dark, moody color palette, high contrast, photorealistic texture, cinematic, dramatic lighting, gritty atmosphere, intense, dynamic composition, digital artwork, visually balanced. | 14216 | The left image better aligns with the prompt due to its darker, moodier color palette and dramatic lighting, which enhances the apocalyptic and gritty atmosphere. The dense smoke and dust in the foreground create a sense of movement and tension, while the rugged terrain with sparse grass is more pronounced. The right image lacks the same level of dramatic lighting and contrast, appearing brighter and less ominous. Additionally, the smoke and dust in the foreground are less prominent, reducing the sense of tension and chaos. | left | Darken the overall lighting to create a moody, high-contrast atmosphere. Add dense, swirling smoke and dust in the foreground to enhance the sense of movement and tension. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a more prominent and angular skyscraper reflection with faint orange lights visible in the windows, matching the description. The puddle has an irregular shape, and the sidewalk appears uneven with small stones and debris scattered around. The black shoe intrudes into the upper left corner, adding the human element. The right image has a less defined reflection of the skyscraper, fewer visible orange lights, and lacks the irregularity and debris on the sidewalk, making it less aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the angularity and prominence of the skyscraper reflection, ensuring faint orange lights are visible in the windows. Add small stones and debris scattered around the puddle to make the sidewalk appear uneven."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49826_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49826_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Moody photograph of a cityscape reflection in a rain puddle on a dark, wet sidewalk. The reflection features a towering glass facade of a modern skyscraper, diagonally positioned from the lower left to upper right, with faint orange lights visible in some windows. The building's angular, sleek architecture contrasts with the irregular shape of the puddle. In the upper left corner, part of a black shoe intrudes into the frame, adding a human element to the scene. The sidewalk is uneven, with small stones and debris scattered around the puddle. Dark color palette, underexposed, soft, natural, diffused lighting, muted tones, cinematic, atmospheric, urban, dramatic, introspective mood, high contrast between the light within the reflection and the surrounding darkness. | 14217 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a more prominent and angular skyscraper reflection with faint orange lights visible in the windows, matching the description. The puddle has an irregular shape, and the sidewalk appears uneven with small stones and debris scattered around. The black shoe intrudes into the upper left corner, adding the human element. The right image has a less defined reflection of the skyscraper, fewer visible orange lights, and lacks the irregularity and debris on the sidewalk, making it less aligned with the prompt. | left | Enhance the angularity and prominence of the skyscraper reflection, ensuring faint orange lights are visible in the windows. Add small stones and debris scattered around the puddle to make the sidewalk appear uneven. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a large cruise ship with a red funnel docked on the right side of the frame, occupying the center background. The red and black vintage-style tram is present in the lower left foreground, and the pedestrian pathways and vehicular lanes are visible with scattered figures walking and bicycling. The muted color palette and soft, diffused light under an overcast sky are consistent with the prompt. The right image has a cruise ship with a red funnel, but the tram is not vintage-style and lacks the black detailing. Additionally, the pathways and figures are less prominent, and the overall composition feels less balanced and minimalistic.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the tram with a red and black vintage-style tram. Increase the prominence of scattered figures walking and bicycling on the pathways and lanes."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49828_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49828_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Wide-angle photograph of a bustling port scene featuring a large cruise ship with a red funnel docked on the right side of the frame, occupying the center background. Multiple pedestrian pathways and vehicular lanes lead towards the ship, with scattered figures walking and bicycling on the gray asphalt, adding a sense of scale. A red and black vintage-style tram moves along the road in the lower left foreground. In the distance, modern city skyscrapers rise along the horizon line, set against the expansive, calm waterfront extending from the left to the center. The entire scene is bathed in soft, diffused light under a pale, overcast sky. The color palette features muted grays and whites, creating a minimalist, serene atmosphere. Stylistic properties include high-key exposure, crisp lines, minimalistic composition, balanced visual elements, and a sense of calm isolation amidst urbanity. | 14219 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a large cruise ship with a red funnel docked on the right side of the frame, occupying the center background. The red and black vintage-style tram is present in the lower left foreground, and the pedestrian pathways and vehicular lanes are visible with scattered figures walking and bicycling. The muted color palette and soft, diffused light under an overcast sky are consistent with the prompt. The right image has a cruise ship with a red funnel, but the tram is not vintage-style and lacks the black detailing. Additionally, the pathways and figures are less prominent, and the overall composition feels less balanced and minimalistic. | left | Replace the tram with a red and black vintage-style tram. Increase the prominence of scattered figures walking and bicycling on the pathways and lanes. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a modern wooden chair with a geometric design, clean angular lines, and a sharp-edged backrest. The lighting highlights the natural grain and texture of the wood, and the background fades into a dark, soft-focus gradient, creating a moody and elegant atmosphere. The right image, while minimalist, lacks the dramatic lighting and emphasis on texture and structure. The chair's design in the right image appears less angular and geometric, and the lighting is less dramatic, failing to highlight the wood grain effectively.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the lighting to create dramatic highlights on the chair, emphasizing the natural grain and texture of the wood. Adjust the chair's design to feature sharper, more angular lines and a geometric backrest."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49829_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49829_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Minimalist product photograph of a modern wooden chair positioned slightly to the right on a smooth, light gray concrete floor. The chair, crafted from rich, dark wood, features a geometric design with clean, angular lines and a sharp-edged backrest, giving it a contemporary aesthetic. It stands tall with four sleek, tapering legs, each firmly planted. Background fades into a dark, soft-focus gradient that emphasizes the chair's elegant form. Dramatic lighting highlights the natural grain and texture of the wood, casting faint shadows on the floor, creating depth and contrast. The composition is simple yet sophisticated, with a focus on form and materiality. High contrast, professional product photography, minimalist design, emphasis on craftsmanship, subdued color palette, moody and elegant atmosphere, emphasis on texture and structure. | 14220 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a modern wooden chair with a geometric design, clean angular lines, and a sharp-edged backrest. The lighting highlights the natural grain and texture of the wood, and the background fades into a dark, soft-focus gradient, creating a moody and elegant atmosphere. The right image, while minimalist, lacks the dramatic lighting and emphasis on texture and structure. The chair's design in the right image appears less angular and geometric, and the lighting is less dramatic, failing to highlight the wood grain effectively. | left | Enhance the lighting to create dramatic highlights on the chair, emphasizing the natural grain and texture of the wood. Adjust the chair's design to feature sharper, more angular lines and a geometric backrest. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image aligns better with the prompt as it showcases a variety of abstract, metallic objects and mechanisms in a futuristic setting. It includes elements such as flowing metallic structures, intricate patterns, and a mix of high gloss and matte textures. The right image lacks the same level of detail, variety, and adherence to the described elements, such as the dynamic graphical elements and intricate patterns.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add more intricate and dynamic metallic patterns, such as tubular structures and circular grooves, to enhance complexity. Introduce a mix of high gloss and matte textures to create a sleek and modern ambiance."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49827_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49827_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Series of digital renderings showcasing abstract, metallic objects and mechanisms in a futuristic setting. The top row features a flowing metallic fabric-like structure in copper, unfurling elegantly against a white background, capturing movement. Adjacent is a smaller section of white metallic fabric twisted and attached to a vertical rod, creating a dynamic juxtaposition of textures. Below is a close-up of a complex, intertwined metallic wave, with a lustrous copper and silver gradient, adding depth and sophistication to the design. Nearby, abstract tubular structures intersect, casting smooth shadows across a grey surface, while circular grooves in a steel-like material form an intricate maze-like pattern. Above a dynamic starburst array of thin metallic lines radiates from a central black point, resembling a futuristic explosion or energy wave. Following are glossy spheres and cylinders resting on a horizontal slatted surface, reflecting the surrounding environment, with black cubes arranged alongside a white panel, focusing on minimalist geometrical balance. Lower images focus on metallic cylinders with cut-out sections, creating intriguing patterns; some appear as machined discs with intricate perforations, exhibiting precision craftsmanship; others are set against dark, matte backgrounds suggesting a high-tech laboratory or gallery. The last row presents an elongated cylindrical object standing upright amidst a dark grey minimalist backdrop, conveying a sense of modernity and innovation. Digital renderings, metallic and futuristic aesthetic, high gloss and matte textures, monochromatic and minimalist design, intricate patterns, dynamic graphical elements, soft yet edgy lighting, high contrast, sleek and modern ambiance. | 14218 | The left image aligns better with the prompt as it showcases a variety of abstract, metallic objects and mechanisms in a futuristic setting. It includes elements such as flowing metallic structures, intricate patterns, and a mix of high gloss and matte textures. The right image lacks the same level of detail, variety, and adherence to the described elements, such as the dynamic graphical elements and intricate patterns. | left | Add more intricate and dynamic metallic patterns, such as tubular structures and circular grooves, to enhance complexity. Introduce a mix of high gloss and matte textures to create a sleek and modern ambiance. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a shooting star streaking diagonally across the sky, a vibrant star-filled background, and a whimsical, enchanting atmosphere. The composition is visually balanced, with the storyteller gesturing animatedly and the children listening intently. The right image, while similar, has a less vibrant sky with fewer stars and a shooting star that is less prominent and not diagonal. Additionally, the right image lacks the soft focus and watercolor-like texture described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the shooting star streak diagonally across the sky and increase its prominence. Add more twinkling stars to the sky and enhance the watercolor-like texture for a softer, more ethereal background."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49830_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49830_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Digital illustration of a nighttime camping scene with five stylized characters sitting around a campfire on a hilltop, under a vibrant, star-filled sky. The figure to the right, possibly a storyteller, sits with legs crossed, gesturing animatedly. Four other characters, including two visible children, listen intently while seated on folding chairs around the warm glow of the fire. The ground is rocky, with bushes and distant silhouettes of more foliage on the horizon. A shooting star streaks diagonally across the deep blue sky, which is dotted with twinkling stars. The color palette is cool blues with contrasting warm yellows and oranges from the fire. Strong contrast, whimsical and enchanting atmosphere, soft focus on the background, ethereal, serene, visually balanced composition, digital texture mimicking watercolor paint, nostalgic and cozy mood. | 14221 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a shooting star streaking diagonally across the sky, a vibrant star-filled background, and a whimsical, enchanting atmosphere. The composition is visually balanced, with the storyteller gesturing animatedly and the children listening intently. The right image, while similar, has a less vibrant sky with fewer stars and a shooting star that is less prominent and not diagonal. Additionally, the right image lacks the soft focus and watercolor-like texture described in the prompt. | left | Make the shooting star streak diagonally across the sky and increase its prominence. Add more twinkling stars to the sky and enhance the watercolor-like texture for a softer, more ethereal background. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features six bottles arranged in an offset configuration, with the left foreground bottle having a grey strap and gold accent, and the center bottles displaying the correct attributes (light blue cap and gold accent). The reflective surface and high-key lighting enhance the luxurious and minimalist aesthetic. The right image lacks the offset arrangement, the light blue cap on the central bottle, and the embossed brand name 'RAESEN' is not clearly visible on all bottles.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Rearrange the bottles into an offset configuration. Add a light blue cap to the central bottle."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49831_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49831_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Studio product photograph of elegant, fluted design water bottles with a predominantly grey tone, positioned against a stark white background creating a minimalist aesthetic. The image features six bottles, arranged in an offset configuration. In the left foreground, a slightly transparent bottle with a grey strap attached to its neck and gold accent near the cap. The center features two more bottles; the right bottle has a gold accent, while the central one has a light blue cap. The far right bottle displays a similar ribbed texture, adorned with a gold accent. All bottles display the brand name "RAESEN" embossed vertically on their surfaces. The reflective surface beneath the bottles enhances the glossy texture, contributing to a sense of luxury. High-key lighting, sharp focus, clean and pristine composition, modern and sophisticated vibe, crisp and polished aesthetic, emphasis on texture and form. | 14222 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features six bottles arranged in an offset configuration, with the left foreground bottle having a grey strap and gold accent, and the center bottles displaying the correct attributes (light blue cap and gold accent). The reflective surface and high-key lighting enhance the luxurious and minimalist aesthetic. The right image lacks the offset arrangement, the light blue cap on the central bottle, and the embossed brand name 'RAESEN' is not clearly visible on all bottles. | left | Rearrange the bottles into an offset configuration. Add a light blue cap to the central bottle. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a surreal circus scene with the described elements, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. In the left image, the man is shirtless, the rabbit head mask is prominent, and the woman is wearing the correct outfit with a dramatic expression. The unicycle is positioned slightly behind them to the left, and the lighting creates a vibrant, whimsical atmosphere. In the right image, the man is not shirtless, which deviates from the prompt, and the lighting is less vibrant and lacks the dramatic reflections described.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the man's shirt to make him shirtless. Enhance the lighting to create more vibrant, contrasting pink and blue spotlights with colorful reflections on the stage."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49832_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49832_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Surreal circus scene with a shirtless man wearing a large rabbit head mask standing on a red ball adorned with white stars, centrally positioned. He is holding a woman wearing a vibrant pink jacket, black pants, and matching boots in his arms. The woman, holding a black top hat, has curly dark hair and a dramatic expression. Background features a stage setup with bright show lights illuminating a checkerboard floor pattern, creating a theatrical atmosphere. A unicycle is positioned slightly behind them to the left. The environment is under vibrant, contrasting pink and blue spotlights, casting colorful reflections on the stage. The overall scene has a whimsical, dreamlike quality, with a focus on circus performance elements, saturated color palette, dramatic artificial lighting, high contrast, glossy textures, and a dynamic, balanced composition. | 14223 | Both images depict a surreal circus scene with the described elements, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. In the left image, the man is shirtless, the rabbit head mask is prominent, and the woman is wearing the correct outfit with a dramatic expression. The unicycle is positioned slightly behind them to the left, and the lighting creates a vibrant, whimsical atmosphere. In the right image, the man is not shirtless, which deviates from the prompt, and the lighting is less vibrant and lacks the dramatic reflections described. | left | Remove the man's shirt to make him shirtless. Enhance the lighting to create more vibrant, contrasting pink and blue spotlights with colorful reflections on the stage. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a woman holding a staff-like object with a feathered top, which deviates from the prompt's description of a simple, long staff. The right image aligns better with the prompt as the staff is plain and vertical, matching the minimalist and surreal aesthetic. Additionally, the woman's posture in the right image appears more contemplative and serene, consistent with the prompt. Both images have a symmetrical reflection and a bright orange circular shape resembling the sun, but the right image better captures the ethereal and introspective mood described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the feathered staff with a plain, long staff. Adjust the woman's posture to appear more contemplative, with her head slightly bowed."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49834_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49834_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Minimalist and surreal image of a woman kneeling on the ground, holding a long staff-like object vertically, centered against a large, bright orange circular shape resembling a sun in the background. The reflection of the woman and the staff is mirrored perfectly on a glossy surface below, creating a symmetrical composition. The woman appears in profile, her silhouette softly illuminated by the orangish glow, casting a serene and contemplative aura. The entire scene is set against a pale, neutral background, enhancing the reflection's clarity. Stylistic elements include soft focus, ethereal lighting, a limited color palette dominated by orange and muted tones, and a dreamlike quality. The composition is centered and balanced, evoking a sense of tranquility and introspection. | 14225 | The left image features a woman holding a staff-like object with a feathered top, which deviates from the prompt's description of a simple, long staff. The right image aligns better with the prompt as the staff is plain and vertical, matching the minimalist and surreal aesthetic. Additionally, the woman's posture in the right image appears more contemplative and serene, consistent with the prompt. Both images have a symmetrical reflection and a bright orange circular shape resembling the sun, but the right image better captures the ethereal and introspective mood described in the prompt. | right | Replace the feathered staff with a plain, long staff. Adjust the woman's posture to appear more contemplative, with her head slightly bowed. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a figurine with a bright pink face, exaggerated black eyebrows, and stylized black hair, wrapped in a beige and black checkered fabric. The white gloved hands are holding the figurine in the lower foreground, and the black draped background provides contrast. The right image, while similar, has the figurine with closed eyes and lacks the exaggerated black eyebrows, which are key elements of the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add exaggerated black eyebrows to the figurine. Open the figurine's eyes to match the prompt's description."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49833_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49833_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Close-up photo of a figurine with a bright pink face and exaggerated black eyebrows, wrapped in a beige and black checkered fabric, resembling a doll or art toy in the center. The black draped background contrasts with the white gloved hands holding the figure in the lower foreground, highlighting its presentation or reveal. The figurine has stylized black hair and a red garment, adding a vibrant, artistic element to the minimalist setting. High key lighting, soft focus on the background, sharp focus on the figurine and hands, neutral color palette with stark contrasts, clean and elegant, product photography, sleek modern aesthetic. | 14224 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a figurine with a bright pink face, exaggerated black eyebrows, and stylized black hair, wrapped in a beige and black checkered fabric. The white gloved hands are holding the figurine in the lower foreground, and the black draped background provides contrast. The right image, while similar, has the figurine with closed eyes and lacks the exaggerated black eyebrows, which are key elements of the prompt. | left | Add exaggerated black eyebrows to the figurine. Open the figurine's eyes to match the prompt's description. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a crescent-shaped structure with a speckled texture and blue and coral accents, but it is a complete ring rather than crescent-shaped. The base is ribbed and sand-colored, but it appears more cylindrical than cushion-like. The driftwood with 'dribbble' is present and correctly positioned, as is the copper-colored sphere. The right image has a crescent-shaped structure with speckled texture and blue accents, aligning better with the prompt. The base is more cushion-like and sand-colored, matching the description. The driftwood and copper sphere are also correctly placed. Overall, the right image better matches the prompt due to the crescent-shaped structure and accurate base design.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Modify the ring structure to be crescent-shaped with speckled texture and blue and coral accents. Adjust the base to appear more cushion-like rather than cylindrical."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49835_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49835_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Surreal 3D illustration featuring a textured pink basketball resting within a speckled, crescent-shaped structure that resembles stone or concrete, with blue and coral accents on its ends. The basketball is centrally positioned, appearing suspended above a ribbed, sand-colored base that suggests a cushion or pedestal. To the left foreground, a realistic piece of weathered driftwood with the word "dribbble" inscribed on it rests against the base. A metallic, copper-colored sphere is partially visible on the right side of the base, adding contrast and shine. All elements are set against a soft beige background, enhancing the composition's clean and minimalistic aesthetic. Hyper-realistic texture, smooth gradients, warm muted color palette, imaginative composition, whimsical, balanced design, modern digital art style, creative and playful. | 14226 | The left image features a crescent-shaped structure with a speckled texture and blue and coral accents, but it is a complete ring rather than crescent-shaped. The base is ribbed and sand-colored, but it appears more cylindrical than cushion-like. The driftwood with 'dribbble' is present and correctly positioned, as is the copper-colored sphere. The right image has a crescent-shaped structure with speckled texture and blue accents, aligning better with the prompt. The base is more cushion-like and sand-colored, matching the description. The driftwood and copper sphere are also correctly placed. Overall, the right image better matches the prompt due to the crescent-shaped structure and accurate base design. | right | Modify the ring structure to be crescent-shaped with speckled texture and blue and coral accents. Adjust the base to appear more cushion-like rather than cylindrical. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows the woman in a stretched-out position rather than a tightly curled tuck, which does not align with the prompt. The right image captures the woman in a proper tuck position with her head facing downward and arms wrapped around her shins, as described. Both images have a pale blue sky with soft clouds, but the right image better conveys the minimalist composition and suspended motion described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Adjust the woman's pose to a tightly curled tuck position with her head facing downward and arms wrapped around her shins. Enhance the lighting to emphasize the smooth texture of her skin and the fluidity of her movement."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49836_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49836_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Aerial photo of a young woman in mid-dive against a vast open sky. The subject, in a blue swimsuit, is centered in the frame, her body curled tightly in a tuck position. Her head faces downward, and her arms wrap around her shins. The sky is expansive, filled with soft white clouds against a backdrop of pale blue. The lighting is natural, emphasizing the smooth texture of her skin and the fluidity of her movement. The image captures a moment of suspended motion, conveying grace and athleticism. Stylistic elements include high contrast, crisp focus, minimalist composition, warm color grading, photorealistic detail, and a serene, tranquil atmosphere. | 14227 | The left image shows the woman in a stretched-out position rather than a tightly curled tuck, which does not align with the prompt. The right image captures the woman in a proper tuck position with her head facing downward and arms wrapped around her shins, as described. Both images have a pale blue sky with soft clouds, but the right image better conveys the minimalist composition and suspended motion described in the prompt. | right | Adjust the woman's pose to a tightly curled tuck position with her head facing downward and arms wrapped around her shins. Enhance the lighting to emphasize the smooth texture of her skin and the fluidity of her movement. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as the sneaker is centrally positioned, oriented upwards, and slightly tilted to the right. It features hexagonal mesh patterns with circular ventilation holes, matching the described design. The text '360° BREATHABILITY' is centrally aligned and prominent. The background has geometric, three-dimensional wall textures with repeating triangular patterns, and the lighting is bright and even. The right image, while similar, has the sneaker oriented more horizontally and lacks the circular ventilation holes, deviating from the prompt's description.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Tilt the sneaker upwards and slightly to the right. Add circular ventilation holes along the sides of the sneaker to match the described design."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49838_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49838_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Futuristic digital rendering of a white sneaker floating in an abstract, geometric environment. The sneaker is at the center, oriented upwards and slightly tilted to the right. Its design features hexagonal mesh patterns with circular ventilation holes along the sides, giving it a lightweight and breathable appearance. The lace design is prominent with a sleek, modern finish. Surrounding the sneaker is a minimalist background with geometric, three-dimensional wall textures featuring repeating triangular patterns. The floors and walls are composed of the same light grey tones with subtle shadows for depth. The text "360° BREATHABILITY" is centrally aligned across the image, in simple black font, enhancing the focus on the sneaker's design. This image is characterized by a photorealistic texture with high contrast, clean lines, and a monochromatic white-grey color palette, creating a modern, futuristic aesthetic. Bright, even lighting with no direct light source visible, creating soft shadows. Clean, minimalist, digital art style, with an emphasis on form and function. | 14229 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as the sneaker is centrally positioned, oriented upwards, and slightly tilted to the right. It features hexagonal mesh patterns with circular ventilation holes, matching the described design. The text '360° BREATHABILITY' is centrally aligned and prominent. The background has geometric, three-dimensional wall textures with repeating triangular patterns, and the lighting is bright and even. The right image, while similar, has the sneaker oriented more horizontally and lacks the circular ventilation holes, deviating from the prompt's description. | left | Tilt the sneaker upwards and slightly to the right. Add circular ventilation holes along the sides of the sneaker to match the described design. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a modern minimalist house on a hillside with clean lines and geometric forms. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the house positioned to the right of the frame, a clear view of the distant lake and green fields, and the concrete stairs leading upwards bordered by a retaining wall. The right image, while similar, has the house more centered in the frame, and the stairs are less prominent. Additionally, the left image better captures the serene ambiance with a cool color palette and natural lighting highlighting the materials.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reposition the house to the right of the frame. Enhance the prominence of the concrete stairs and retaining wall in the composition."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49839_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49839_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Modern architectural photograph of a minimalist house situated on a hillside. The building features clean lines with a focus on geometric forms, using materials like dark panels and exposed concrete. Positioned to the right of the frame, the house is on an elevated location overlooking a scenic landscape, including a distant lake and sprawling green fields. Windows on the central section reflect the surrounding environment, adding to the sleek design. To the right, a set of concrete stairs lead upwards, bordered by a retaining concrete wall. The bottom left includes out-of-focus foliage, adding natural elements to the composition. Natural lighting highlights the texture of the materials and casts soft shadows. The image is characterized by a serene ambiance with a cool color palette, clear blue skies, and high contrast, showcasing modernist architectural photography. | 14230 | Both images depict a modern minimalist house on a hillside with clean lines and geometric forms. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the house positioned to the right of the frame, a clear view of the distant lake and green fields, and the concrete stairs leading upwards bordered by a retaining wall. The right image, while similar, has the house more centered in the frame, and the stairs are less prominent. Additionally, the left image better captures the serene ambiance with a cool color palette and natural lighting highlighting the materials. | left | Reposition the house to the right of the frame. Enhance the prominence of the concrete stairs and retaining wall in the composition. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image does not align with the prompt as the tubes are not arranged diagonally from top left to bottom right, and there are only six tubes instead of seven. Additionally, the tubes do not match the specified order, colors, or cap details. The right image better matches the prompt as it features seven tubes arranged diagonally with distinct labels and caps, and two uncapped tubes revealing red paint. However, the right image still has some inaccuracies, such as the incorrect order of tube colors and labels, and the lack of visible wear and crumpling on the tubes.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Rearrange the tubes to match the specified order and details from the prompt. Add visible wear and crumpling to the tubes to indicate use."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49840_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49840_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | A highly realistic 3D render of seven oil paint tubes arranged diagonally from top left to bottom right against a dark gray background. Each tube features distinct colors and labels, with varying levels of wear and crumpling, indicating use. From left to right: a green-labeled tube with a black cap; a second tube with a brown label and red cap; a red-labeled tube with a silver cap; a tube with an orange and white label with a white cap; a green-labeled tube marked by a green cap; a pink-labeled tube with a red and pink cap; a tube with handwritten text and a black cap. Two uncapped tubes toward the center, revealing a peek of red paint. Realistic lighting enhances the metallic sheen of the caps and the reflective quality of the wrinkled tubes, casting subtle shadows to convey a photorealistic appearance. The image embodies a clean, modern aesthetic, focusing on texture details and materiality, with a minimalist and organized composition. | 14231 | The left image does not align with the prompt as the tubes are not arranged diagonally from top left to bottom right, and there are only six tubes instead of seven. Additionally, the tubes do not match the specified order, colors, or cap details. The right image better matches the prompt as it features seven tubes arranged diagonally with distinct labels and caps, and two uncapped tubes revealing red paint. However, the right image still has some inaccuracies, such as the incorrect order of tube colors and labels, and the lack of visible wear and crumpling on the tubes. | right | Rearrange the tubes to match the specified order and details from the prompt. Add visible wear and crumpling to the tubes to indicate use. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better matches the prompt as it features a metallic purple vinyl art toy with cartoonish designs, including playful white cloud graphics with crossed-out eyes and abstract expressions, as well as green and white dots for contrast. The background is neutral and textured, and the figure casts a subtle shadow. The right image, while similar, lacks the crossed-out eyes and abstract expressions on the clouds, and the facial features are more simplistic and less illustrative, deviating from the prompt's description.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add crossed-out eyes and abstract expressions to some of the clouds on the figure. Remove the simplistic facial features from the figure to match the illustrative details described in the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49837_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49837_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Vinyl art toy figure against a neutral textured background. The figure, glossy and vibrant, is painted in a metallic purple with cartoonish designs. It has a rounded head, two elongated ear-like extensions, and stylized arms and legs. The body features playful white cloud graphics, some with crossed-out eyes, others smiling, and abstract facial expressions. Green and white dots add contrast across the surface. Standing centrally, it casts a subtle shadow on the light grey surface below. Pop art style, high gloss finish, medium depth of field, saturated color palette, playful and whimsical, illustrative details, compact composition. | 14228 | The left image better matches the prompt as it features a metallic purple vinyl art toy with cartoonish designs, including playful white cloud graphics with crossed-out eyes and abstract expressions, as well as green and white dots for contrast. The background is neutral and textured, and the figure casts a subtle shadow. The right image, while similar, lacks the crossed-out eyes and abstract expressions on the clouds, and the facial features are more simplistic and less illustrative, deviating from the prompt's description. | left | Add crossed-out eyes and abstract expressions to some of the clouds on the figure. Remove the simplistic facial features from the figure to match the illustrative details described in the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a cartoon duck in a sailor outfit with a prominent bow tie, holding a smaller mouse character in its left hand. The mouse is confidently holding a pistol in its raised right hand. The lighting and background gradient are consistent with the monochromatic blue hue described in the prompt. The right image, while similar, has a less prominent bow tie and lacks the polished texture and whimsical lighting. Additionally, the mouse character's pose and pistol are less defined, and the overall contrast between the characters and the background is weaker.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the bow tie on the duck to make it more prominent. Increase the contrast and polish the texture of the characters to match the lighting and whimsical style of the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49841_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49841_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | 3D-rendered image of a cartoon duck holding a smaller cartoon mouse character in its left hand. The duck, resembling an iconic animated character, stands in the center facing slightly to the left, with a cigar in its beak. The duck is clad in a classic sailor outfit with a prominent bow tie. The mouse character, also familiar in style, is positioned confidently on the duck's hand, holding a small pistol in its raised right hand. Both characters exhibit exaggerated, smooth features and minimalistic details. The image is bathed in a monochromatic blue hue, creating a cohesive, surreal atmosphere. The background is a gradient of light blue, fading to white toward the center, enhancing the focus on the subjects. Styles include digital 3D animation, soft curves, high contrast between characters and background, polished texture, whimsical, yet dramatic lighting, minimalistic detailing, and focused, imaginative composition. | 14232 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a cartoon duck in a sailor outfit with a prominent bow tie, holding a smaller mouse character in its left hand. The mouse is confidently holding a pistol in its raised right hand. The lighting and background gradient are consistent with the monochromatic blue hue described in the prompt. The right image, while similar, has a less prominent bow tie and lacks the polished texture and whimsical lighting. Additionally, the mouse character's pose and pistol are less defined, and the overall contrast between the characters and the background is weaker. | left | Enhance the bow tie on the duck to make it more prominent. Increase the contrast and polish the texture of the characters to match the lighting and whimsical style of the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the heart-patterned boxer shorts, blue pants dropped around the ankles, and the red-rimmed smartphone displaying a logo. The right image lacks the blue pants around the ankles and the red rim on the smartphone, and the boxer shorts have a different pattern (yellow hearts instead of red hearts).",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add blue pants dropped around the ankles. Change the smartphone's rim to red and ensure it displays a logo."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49842_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49842_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | 3D stylized character design of a cartoonish, humanoid figure standing in the center against a light green gradient background. The character is wearing a green hoodie with a yellow button and headphones over its ears. On its head is a dark blue cap with an orange brim. The figure holds a red-rimmed smartphone in its right hand, displaying a logo. Its left hand is raised in a waving gesture. The character has exaggerated facial features, including bulging eyes and a wide grin, showing oversized white and yellow teeth. It wears heart-patterned boxer shorts, with blue pants comically dropped around its ankles, revealing yellow and green sneakers. The character stands on a subtle shadow, giving a sense of grounding. Glossy textures, vibrant color palette, soft diffused lighting, whimsical and playful style, exaggerated proportions, digitally rendered, humorous, youthful, dynamic and engaging. | 14233 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the heart-patterned boxer shorts, blue pants dropped around the ankles, and the red-rimmed smartphone displaying a logo. The right image lacks the blue pants around the ankles and the red rim on the smartphone, and the boxer shorts have a different pattern (yellow hearts instead of red hearts). | left | Add blue pants dropped around the ankles. Change the smartphone's rim to red and ensure it displays a logo. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images feature a red muscle car in an industrial setting with concrete walls and geometric sunlight patterns. The left image has a slightly more vibrant and balanced lighting, with the car's glossy black wheels and white rear quarter panel accent clearly visible. The right image has a slightly darker tone, and the lighting on the car is less vivid, making the red color appear less vibrant. Additionally, the left image has a more polished and reflective floor, enhancing the modern aesthetic.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the vibrancy of the car's red color to make it more vivid. Enhance the floor's reflectiveness to create a polished, modern aesthetic."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49843_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49843_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Vibrant photo of a sleek, classic red muscle car, possibly a Dodge Charger, positioned centrally in an indoor industrial space with stark concrete walls. The car is viewed in full profile, facing right, with glossy black wheels and a white accent on its rear quarter panel. It features sharp, clean lines, and a low stance. The environment includes tall, minimalist concrete walls with geometric patterns of sunlight and shadow, enhancing the car's bright, vivid color. The floor is smooth, reflecting soft light, creating a modern, polished aesthetic. Photorealistic, high contrast, strong shadows, crisp natural lighting, minimal depth of field, architectural photography, modern industrial setting, clean, minimalist, and visually balanced. | 14234 | Both images feature a red muscle car in an industrial setting with concrete walls and geometric sunlight patterns. The left image has a slightly more vibrant and balanced lighting, with the car's glossy black wheels and white rear quarter panel accent clearly visible. The right image has a slightly darker tone, and the lighting on the car is less vivid, making the red color appear less vibrant. Additionally, the left image has a more polished and reflective floor, enhancing the modern aesthetic. | left | Increase the vibrancy of the car's red color to make it more vivid. Enhance the floor's reflectiveness to create a polished, modern aesthetic. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a centrally composed pendant lamp with a geometric, pleated shade that is translucent white, casting soft shadows. The glossy black fixture and vibrant red fabric cord are present, and the high-key lighting creates a clean, minimalist aesthetic. The right image, while also minimalist, has a shade that is less geometric and pleated, and the fixture design is bulkier, detracting from the contemporary elegance described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the shade with a more geometric, pleated design similar to the left image. Simplify the fixture to a sleeker, glossy black design without additional knobs or protrusions."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49844_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49844_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Minimalist product photograph of a modern pendant lamp against a white background. The lamp is centrally composed with a focus on its geometric, pleated shade, which is translucent white and casts subtle shadows. A glossy black fixture secures the shade and connects to a straight, vibrant red fabric cord that extends upwards beyond the frame's top edge. The simplicity of the layout emphasizes the lamp's design, showcasing contemporary elegance. High-key lighting, bright, clean aesthetic, sharp focus, soft shadows, stark contrast between the red cord and white background, minimalist design, functional yet artistic presentation. | 14235 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a centrally composed pendant lamp with a geometric, pleated shade that is translucent white, casting soft shadows. The glossy black fixture and vibrant red fabric cord are present, and the high-key lighting creates a clean, minimalist aesthetic. The right image, while also minimalist, has a shade that is less geometric and pleated, and the fixture design is bulkier, detracting from the contemporary elegance described in the prompt. | left | Replace the shade with a more geometric, pleated design similar to the left image. Simplify the fixture to a sleeker, glossy black design without additional knobs or protrusions. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features six panels arranged in two rows of three columns, with clear black-and-white line drawings and a muted color palette. It includes the specified elements such as labeled building levels, green-highlighted proposed developments, dashed lines for paths, and schematic maps with circular icons and connecting lines. The right image lacks the detailed thematic labeling, schematic map elements, and the clear depiction of vertical connections with circular nodes and lines.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add thematic labeling to the panels, including circular icons and connecting lines in the schematic map. Incorporate vertical connections with circular nodes and lines in the bottom-left panel."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49845_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49845_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Architectural diagram series depicting massing development, six panels arranged in two rows of three columns, black-and-white line drawings with minimalistic aesthetic, upper-left panel features a dense urban layout with labeled building levels, upper-middle panel highlights multiple buildings in olive green, indicating proposed developments, upper-right panel shows the green-highlighted areas expanded, suggesting further progression, middle-left panel indicates a path or boundary with dashed lines, middle-right panel displays a close-up with box and path annotations, bottom-left panel illustrates vertical connections with circular nodes and lines, bottom-right panel is a schematic map with circular icons and connecting lines, each icon labeled with thematic elements such as an emblem in black and white, technical drawing style, muted color palette, detailed linework with a focus on spatial relationships, structural outlines emphasizing urban planning. | 14236 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features six panels arranged in two rows of three columns, with clear black-and-white line drawings and a muted color palette. It includes the specified elements such as labeled building levels, green-highlighted proposed developments, dashed lines for paths, and schematic maps with circular icons and connecting lines. The right image lacks the detailed thematic labeling, schematic map elements, and the clear depiction of vertical connections with circular nodes and lines. | left | Add thematic labeling to the panels, including circular icons and connecting lines in the schematic map. Incorporate vertical connections with circular nodes and lines in the bottom-left panel. |
Subsets and Splits