success
bool 1
class | result
stringlengths 202
1.67k
| good_image
stringlengths 89
286
| bad_image
stringlengths 89
286
| prompt
stringlengths 19
2.48k
| id
stringlengths 1
5
| analysis
stringlengths 119
1.45k
| better_image
stringclasses 3
values | instructions
stringlengths 0
440
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the tranquil essence of fall with a warm color palette, high contrast, and a visually balanced composition. The foliage gradient from green to vivid orange is more pronounced, and the reflection in the stream is clearer and more vibrant. The right image has additional grassy elements in the foreground that detract from the serene and contemplative mood, and the reflection in the stream is less vivid.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reduce the prominence of the grassy elements in the foreground. Enhance the vibrancy and clarity of the stream's reflection to better mirror the warm hues of the foliage."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49947_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49947_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Landscape photo of a vibrant autumn forest reflecting in a clear stream. The scene features dense foliage on a hillside in the background, with trees displaying a gradient of green to vivid orange leaves. The foreground includes a stream running through a lush, grassy area, its surface mirroring the warm hues of the leaves above. The image captures the tranquil essence of fall with rich textures and colors. Underexposed, natural lighting, shallow depth of field, warm color palette, high contrast, serene and contemplative mood, vibrant, visually balanced, ethereal ambiance, soft focus on edges enhancing depth. | 14335 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the tranquil essence of fall with a warm color palette, high contrast, and a visually balanced composition. The foliage gradient from green to vivid orange is more pronounced, and the reflection in the stream is clearer and more vibrant. The right image has additional grassy elements in the foreground that detract from the serene and contemplative mood, and the reflection in the stream is less vivid. | left | Reduce the prominence of the grassy elements in the foreground. Enhance the vibrancy and clarity of the stream's reflection to better mirror the warm hues of the foliage. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a hand holding five identical cards with a minimalist illustration of a dog-like character, spread out widely. The textured grey wall is visible with soft shadows, and the natural light creates a clean, modern aesthetic. The right image has inconsistencies: the dog illustrations on the cards are not identical, and the wall texture appears less detailed and irregular. Additionally, the lighting in the right image is harsher, creating a less soft and natural look.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the dog illustrations on all cards identical to match the minimalist design. Adjust the lighting to create softer shadows and a more natural, diffused look."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49952_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49952_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Close-up photo of a hand holding a fan of five identical cards against a textured grey wall. The hand, occupying the left lower corner, holds the cards spread out widely. Each card features a minimalist illustration of a small, stylized black and grey dog-like character, centered on a white background. The cards' uniform design creates a repetitive pattern. Natural light casts soft shadows on the wall and hand. The image has a shallow depth of field with focus on the cards, capturing detailed texture of the wall which has subtle, irregular patterns. Minimalistic, modern aesthetic, clean composition, neutral color palette, soft matte finish. | 14340 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a hand holding five identical cards with a minimalist illustration of a dog-like character, spread out widely. The textured grey wall is visible with soft shadows, and the natural light creates a clean, modern aesthetic. The right image has inconsistencies: the dog illustrations on the cards are not identical, and the wall texture appears less detailed and irregular. Additionally, the lighting in the right image is harsher, creating a less soft and natural look. | left | Make the dog illustrations on all cards identical to match the minimalist design. Adjust the lighting to create softer shadows and a more natural, diffused look. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a two-toned circular ring with a clear silver and gold contrast, positioned centrally on a textured checkered surface. The checkered background has alternating light and dark grey squares, resembling a chessboard, and the lighting highlights the ring's reflective properties. The right image, while featuring a similar ring, lacks the textured checkered surface and has a smoother, less defined background. Additionally, the lighting in the right image creates shadows that detract from the clean and symmetrical aesthetic described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a textured checkered surface with alternating light and dark grey squares as the background. Adjust the lighting to eliminate harsh shadows and create a more uniform, studio-lit appearance."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49953_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49953_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | A minimalist photograph featuring a two-toned circular ring positioned centrally on a textured checkered surface. The ring is crafted from both silver and gold, with the silver part comprising most of the visible surface and the gold adding a striking contrast. The background displays a pattern of alternating light and dark grey squares, resembling a chessboard, contributing to a modern and sophisticated ambiance. The image captures the ring in sharp detail against the softly textured surface, highlighting its sleek, metallic finish. Studio lighting is used to accentuate the ring's reflective properties, while the grid-like pattern in the background provides a structured, geometric complement. The overall mood is contemporary and stylish, with muted tones and a focus on clean lines and symmetry, high contrast, sharp focus, product photography, elegant design. | 14341 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a two-toned circular ring with a clear silver and gold contrast, positioned centrally on a textured checkered surface. The checkered background has alternating light and dark grey squares, resembling a chessboard, and the lighting highlights the ring's reflective properties. The right image, while featuring a similar ring, lacks the textured checkered surface and has a smoother, less defined background. Additionally, the lighting in the right image creates shadows that detract from the clean and symmetrical aesthetic described in the prompt. | left | Add a textured checkered surface with alternating light and dark grey squares as the background. Adjust the lighting to eliminate harsh shadows and create a more uniform, studio-lit appearance. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features teapots with a squat, geometric form and stubby tripod-like feet. The teapots are positioned correctly, with the black teapot slightly to the left and the cream teapot centrally aligned. The spouts are directed towards each other, and the high-key lighting enhances the glossy ceramic texture. In contrast, the right image has teapots with a more rounded form, lacks the stubby tripod-like feet, and the spouts are not aligned closely towards one another.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the teapots to have a squat, geometric form with stubby tripod-like feet. Align the spouts of the teapots to face closely towards one another."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49950_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49950_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | A photo of two modern, minimalist teapots on a vibrant orange background. The teapot on the left is ceramic with a sleek, smooth body, featuring a dark, matte black lid and handle angled outward, positioned slightly to the left of the frame's center. On the right, a similar ceramic teapot with a subtle cream-colored lid is aligned centrally, its handle mirroring the left teapot's design. Both teapots exhibit a squat, geometric form with stubby tripod-like feet, spouts aligning closely towards one another. The stark contrast between the black lid and cream tones adds a crisp aesthetic to the pieces. High-key lighting, minimalistic design, contrasting colors, balanced composition, glossy ceramic texture, bold and clean modern style. | 14338 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features teapots with a squat, geometric form and stubby tripod-like feet. The teapots are positioned correctly, with the black teapot slightly to the left and the cream teapot centrally aligned. The spouts are directed towards each other, and the high-key lighting enhances the glossy ceramic texture. In contrast, the right image has teapots with a more rounded form, lacks the stubby tripod-like feet, and the spouts are not aligned closely towards one another. | left | Adjust the teapots to have a squat, geometric form with stubby tripod-like feet. Align the spouts of the teapots to face closely towards one another. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a textured paper surface with interlocking organic shapes in shades of red and pink at the center, bordered by white outlines. However, the central shapes are not puzzle-like, and the torn edge at the top revealing a subtle grid pattern is missing. The right image has interlocking organic shapes with white outlines that better resemble a puzzle-like appearance, but it lacks the torn edge at the top and the subtle grid pattern. The intricate black contour lines radiating outward are present in both images, but the right image better captures the prompt's description of the central shapes and their outlines.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a torn edge at the top of the paper, revealing a subtle grid pattern across the top border. Enhance the texture of the paper surface to emphasize a mixed media appearance."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49951_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49951_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Abstract art piece showing a textured paper surface, featuring interlocking organic shapes in shades of red and pink at the center. These shapes are bordered by white, irregular outlines that create a puzzle-like appearance. Surrounding the central shapes, intricate patterns of black contour lines radiate outward, reminiscent of topographic maps. The paper's torn edge at the top reveals a subtle grid pattern across the top border, suggesting notebook perforation. The contrast between the vibrant, warm colors of the central shapes and the monochromatic, detailed linework surrounding them gives the artwork dynamic tension. The style is mixed media, combining elements of watercolor and ink illustration, with a focus on natural, flowing forms and meticulous linework, emphasizing a harmonious balance between chaos and order in abstract expressionism. | 14339 | The left image features a textured paper surface with interlocking organic shapes in shades of red and pink at the center, bordered by white outlines. However, the central shapes are not puzzle-like, and the torn edge at the top revealing a subtle grid pattern is missing. The right image has interlocking organic shapes with white outlines that better resemble a puzzle-like appearance, but it lacks the torn edge at the top and the subtle grid pattern. The intricate black contour lines radiating outward are present in both images, but the right image better captures the prompt's description of the central shapes and their outlines. | right | Add a torn edge at the top of the paper, revealing a subtle grid pattern across the top border. Enhance the texture of the paper surface to emphasize a mixed media appearance. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better matches the prompt as it features a modern, institutional building with a stark, minimalist aesthetic. The facade has alternating brick and concrete surfaces, rectangular windows in two rows in the upper wall sections, and a double glass door entrance slightly to the right. The top section includes a repetitive pattern of small, rectangular windows, and the recessed area to the left with visible utility fixtures adds depth. The foreground displays an empty concrete area with faint circular markings resembling a sports court, and the dramatic sky with scattered clouds enhances the composition. The right image lacks the alternating brick and concrete surfaces, the repetitive pattern of small windows at the top, and the recessed area with utility fixtures. Additionally, the windows and entrance placement do not align with the prompt's description.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a repetitive pattern of small, rectangular windows to the top section of the building. Introduce a recessed area with visible utility fixtures on the left side of the building."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49954_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49954_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Black and white photograph of a modern, institutional building with a stark, minimalist aesthetic. The building is centrally positioned, featuring a facade with alternating brick and concrete surfaces, rectangular windows in two rows in the upper wall sections, and a double glass door entrance located slightly to the right. The top section of the building showcases a repetitive pattern of small, rectangular windows, adding geometric visual interest. To the left, a recessed area offers depth perception, with visible utility fixtures on the wall. The foreground displays an empty concrete area with faint circular markings, resembling a sports court. Overhead, a dramatic sky filled with scattered clouds enhances the composition. High contrast, sharp focus, architectural photography, structured symmetry, monochromatic palette, stark lighting, minimalistic, institutional feel. | 14342 | The left image better matches the prompt as it features a modern, institutional building with a stark, minimalist aesthetic. The facade has alternating brick and concrete surfaces, rectangular windows in two rows in the upper wall sections, and a double glass door entrance slightly to the right. The top section includes a repetitive pattern of small, rectangular windows, and the recessed area to the left with visible utility fixtures adds depth. The foreground displays an empty concrete area with faint circular markings resembling a sports court, and the dramatic sky with scattered clouds enhances the composition. The right image lacks the alternating brick and concrete surfaces, the repetitive pattern of small windows at the top, and the recessed area with utility fixtures. Additionally, the windows and entrance placement do not align with the prompt's description. | left | Add a repetitive pattern of small, rectangular windows to the top section of the building. Introduce a recessed area with visible utility fixtures on the left side of the building. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image lacks the angular perspective and intricate window designs in the top panel, which are present in the right image. The left image also does not feature large, bold Japanese sound effect characters in the foreground of the top panel. Additionally, the bottom right panel in the left image does not include a spectral, floating head, which is a key element of the prompt. The right image better captures the dynamic action sequence, supernatural theme, and dramatic angles described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add large, bold Japanese sound effect characters in the foreground of the top panel. Replace the bottom right panel with a spectral, floating head above characters to enhance the supernatural theme."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49955_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49955_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Manga page in black and white with dynamic action sequence elements, set in a corridor populated by stylized characters. The top panel shows an angular perspective of a long hallway with intricate window designs and motion lines suggesting speed, featuring large, bold, Japanese sound effect characters in the foreground. Four smaller panels below depict a continuous scene of characters running down the corridor, each with expressive faces and varied clothing styles, indicating a sense of urgency. The bottom left panel showcases close-up character expressions of surprise and determination in a crowd. The bottom right panel features a spectral, floating head above more characters, enhancing the supernatural theme. High contrast, detailed linework, dramatic angles, strong use of motion lines, exaggerated features, typical manga art style, intense and dynamic composition, monochrome color palette, focus on speed and emotion. | 14343 | The left image lacks the angular perspective and intricate window designs in the top panel, which are present in the right image. The left image also does not feature large, bold Japanese sound effect characters in the foreground of the top panel. Additionally, the bottom right panel in the left image does not include a spectral, floating head, which is a key element of the prompt. The right image better captures the dynamic action sequence, supernatural theme, and dramatic angles described in the prompt. | right | Add large, bold Japanese sound effect characters in the foreground of the top panel. Replace the bottom right panel with a spectral, floating head above characters to enhance the supernatural theme. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has a curved white sofa positioned against the left wall, but the sofa design is slightly different from the prompt's minimalist aesthetic. The right image better matches the prompt with a more minimalist curved white sofa. Both images include two plush chairs with gold bases, but the left image has a white chair that is not plush, while the right image correctly features both plush chairs. The coffee table in both images is centered on a gray rug and holds a plant and magazines, aligning with the prompt. The left image has a black console with wooden accents and a decorative mirror, but the mirror is not orange and silver as specified. The right image correctly includes the orange and silver mirror. Both images feature cream-colored walls with decorative molding, a chandelier, and tall windows with sheer gray curtains. However, the right image better captures the overall serene and contemporary elegance described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the white chair with a plush white chair with a gold base. Change the decorative mirror to an orange and silver round mirror."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49956_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49956_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Elegant, sunlit living room interior with a minimalist aesthetic, featuring a curved white sofa positioned against the left wall, and two plush chairs in the right foreground: one pink, one white, both with gold bases. A low marble coffee table with gold legs is centered on a gray rug, holding a plant and scattered magazines. The left background includes a black console with wooden accents, topped by a decorative orange and silver round mirror. Delicate, decorative molding adorns the cream-colored walls, with a pair of modern, spherical lights mounted on the far wall. A grand ceiling medallion with a luxurious chandelier hangs overhead. Tall windows on the left with sheer gray curtains stream soft, natural light into the room. Warm wooden parquet flooring, soft shadows, serene atmosphere, high-key lighting, clean lines, sophisticated, balanced composition, inviting, contemporary elegance. | 14344 | The left image has a curved white sofa positioned against the left wall, but the sofa design is slightly different from the prompt's minimalist aesthetic. The right image better matches the prompt with a more minimalist curved white sofa. Both images include two plush chairs with gold bases, but the left image has a white chair that is not plush, while the right image correctly features both plush chairs. The coffee table in both images is centered on a gray rug and holds a plant and magazines, aligning with the prompt. The left image has a black console with wooden accents and a decorative mirror, but the mirror is not orange and silver as specified. The right image correctly includes the orange and silver mirror. Both images feature cream-colored walls with decorative molding, a chandelier, and tall windows with sheer gray curtains. However, the right image better captures the overall serene and contemporary elegance described in the prompt. | right | Replace the white chair with a plush white chair with a gold base. Change the decorative mirror to an orange and silver round mirror. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes the whimsical and playful tone, the boy's surprised expression, the rabbit's dynamic movement, and the colorful, cartoonish style. The right image has notable issues: the boy's expression in the top left panel is less surprised, the rabbit in the top right panel lacks the purple jacket and green-striped shirt, and the rabbit in the bottom right panel does not exude confidence as described.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the boy's expression in the top left panel more surprised. Add a purple jacket and green-striped shirt to the rabbit in the top right panel."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49960_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49960_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Four-panel comic strip with a whimsical and playful tone. Top left panel: young boy with short dark hair sitting under a large tree on the left, reading a book, wearing a yellow and green striped shirt, blue jeans, and brown shoes. His facial expression is one of surprise. Behind him, grassy ground with scattered yellow flowers and a backdrop of stylized pink trees, fluffy clouds, and a blue sky. Top right panel: large yellow rabbit with a fluffy texture, wearing a purple jacket and a green-striped shirt, exuberantly running to the right, showing dynamic movement. Bottom left panel: boy now standing up, mouth open as if calling out, reaching his right arm forward towards the rabbit. The book lies open on the grass, no longer held. Bottom right panel: rabbit stands tall on the right, chest out, arms akimbo, exudes confidence; same floral and sky background. Comic strip style, colorful, textural surface with fine black outlines, cartoonish and exaggerated expressions, bright pastel color palette, light-hearted and humorous tone. | 14348 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes the whimsical and playful tone, the boy's surprised expression, the rabbit's dynamic movement, and the colorful, cartoonish style. The right image has notable issues: the boy's expression in the top left panel is less surprised, the rabbit in the top right panel lacks the purple jacket and green-striped shirt, and the rabbit in the bottom right panel does not exude confidence as described. | left | Make the boy's expression in the top left panel more surprised. Add a purple jacket and green-striped shirt to the rabbit in the top right panel. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the character in a dynamic pose with hands extended forward, surrounded by multicolored glowing orbs and light trails, effectively suggesting energy manipulation. The spiky black hair, pink-tinted visor glasses, red cruciform earrings, and bright yellow coat with a high-collared purple shirt featuring a green 'X' emblem are all present. The background has a deep purple tone with glowing specks and colorful lights, enhancing the action and motion. The right image, while visually appealing, lacks the dynamic pose and energy effects around the hands, making it less aligned with the prompt's emphasis on power manipulation and action.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add multicolored glowing orbs and light trails around the character's hands to suggest energy manipulation. Adjust the character's pose to make it more dynamic, with hands extended forward."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49961_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49961_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Vibrant digital illustration of a character with a futuristic flair and a dynamic pose, occupying the center of the frame. The character has short, spiky black hair and wears large, pink-tinted visor glasses with red cruciform earrings. The clothing consists of a bright yellow coat, open to reveal a high-collared, purple shirt featuring a green "X" emblem on the chest. The character's hands are extended forward, surrounded by multicolored, glowing orbs and light trails, suggesting energy or power manipulation. The background is a deep purple, sprinkled with small, glowing specks and larger, soft-focus colorful lights, enhancing the sense of action and motion. Bold, cartoonish style with thick outlines and glossy texture, high contrast, neon color palette, dynamic and visually stimulating composition, digital comic art style, superhero theme, energetic and futuristic ambiance. | 14349 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the character in a dynamic pose with hands extended forward, surrounded by multicolored glowing orbs and light trails, effectively suggesting energy manipulation. The spiky black hair, pink-tinted visor glasses, red cruciform earrings, and bright yellow coat with a high-collared purple shirt featuring a green 'X' emblem are all present. The background has a deep purple tone with glowing specks and colorful lights, enhancing the action and motion. The right image, while visually appealing, lacks the dynamic pose and energy effects around the hands, making it less aligned with the prompt's emphasis on power manipulation and action. | left | Add multicolored glowing orbs and light trails around the character's hands to suggest energy manipulation. Adjust the character's pose to make it more dynamic, with hands extended forward. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the horizontal slatted dark panels, the white 'Greenfort' text with the green circular logo resembling a recycling symbol on the left midsection, and a visible airplane in the upper right quadrant. The perspective is slightly left-leaning, and the background structure has vertically-oriented dark glass windows. The right image lacks the horizontal slatted panels and has a less prominent urban, corporate atmosphere due to the absence of visible background structures with large glass windows.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add horizontal slatted dark panels to the building facade. Include a background structure with large, vertically-oriented dark glass windows to enhance the urban, corporate atmosphere."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49958_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49958_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Modern architectural photo featuring a dark, sleek office building with a visible facade in the foreground. The building is adorned with horizontal slatted dark panels and positioned centrally with a slight left-leaning perspective. Prominently displayed is the white text "Greenfort" alongside a green, circular logo resembling a stylized recycling symbol, located on the left midsection of the building. In the upper right quadrant, a small airplane is faintly visible against a cloudy, overcast sky, adding a subtle dynamic element. The structure in the background showcases large, vertically-oriented dark glass windows contributing to an urban, corporate atmosphere. High contrast, industrial and minimalist design, professional commercial architectural photography, muted color palette, subdued natural lighting, clean lines, modern and corporate aesthetic. | 14346 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the horizontal slatted dark panels, the white 'Greenfort' text with the green circular logo resembling a recycling symbol on the left midsection, and a visible airplane in the upper right quadrant. The perspective is slightly left-leaning, and the background structure has vertically-oriented dark glass windows. The right image lacks the horizontal slatted panels and has a less prominent urban, corporate atmosphere due to the absence of visible background structures with large glass windows. | left | Add horizontal slatted dark panels to the building facade. Include a background structure with large, vertically-oriented dark glass windows to enhance the urban, corporate atmosphere. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a crystal chandelier with intricate details and candle-like bulbs emitting a soft glow, but the portrait is not positioned slightly to the rear and right as described in the prompt. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the chandelier, the portrait of a man in period attire mounted slightly to the rear and right, and the wall sconce above the portrait. Additionally, the right image captures more of the decorative molding and intricate woodwork, enhancing the opulent ambiance described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Reposition the portrait to be slightly to the rear and right of the chandelier. Add more visible decorative molding and intricate woodwork to the upper portions of the walls and ceiling."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49959_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49959_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Black and white photograph of an ornate crystal chandelier hanging from the ceiling, centrally positioned in an opulent room. The chandelier is intricately detailed with glass arms, candle-like bulbs emitting a soft glow, and numerous hanging crystals. To the rear, slightly right, a framed portrait of a man in period attire is mounted on a wood-paneled wall, illuminated by a wall sconce just above. Decorative molding and intricate woodwork trim the upper portions of the walls and ceiling, creating a lavish and classic ambiance. The image exhibits high contrast with a focus on light and shadow interplay, capturing a historical and elegant atmosphere. Monochromatic tones, soft diffused lighting, luxurious setting, classic interior design, fine craftsmanship, timeless, sophisticated. | 14347 | The left image features a crystal chandelier with intricate details and candle-like bulbs emitting a soft glow, but the portrait is not positioned slightly to the rear and right as described in the prompt. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the chandelier, the portrait of a man in period attire mounted slightly to the rear and right, and the wall sconce above the portrait. Additionally, the right image captures more of the decorative molding and intricate woodwork, enhancing the opulent ambiance described in the prompt. | right | Reposition the portrait to be slightly to the rear and right of the chandelier. Add more visible decorative molding and intricate woodwork to the upper portions of the walls and ceiling. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a concrete island with a sleek faucet and integrated sink, three black pendant lights above the island, a back wall clad in dark wood panels with vertical lines, and an illuminated wine rack on the right holding bottles arranged horizontally. The left wall has a wooden-handled tool mounted decoratively, and the floor is covered in light, patterned wood. The right image deviates from the prompt as the wine rack spans the entire back wall instead of being on the right, and the wooden-handled tool is missing. Additionally, the back wall lacks the vertical wood paneling described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Move the wine rack to the right side of the back wall and arrange the bottles horizontally. Add a wooden-handled tool mounted decoratively on the left wall, casting a shadow on the concrete surface."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49957_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49957_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Modern interior design of a minimalist kitchen with a concrete island in the center foreground, featuring a sleek faucet and integrated sink. Above the island, three black pendant lights hang from the ceiling. The back wall is clad in dark wood panels, emphasizing vertical lines. To the right, an illuminated wine rack holds numerous bottles, arranged horizontally and backlit to enhance their shapes. On the left wall, a wooden-handled tool is mounted decoratively, casting a shadow on the concrete surface. The floor is covered in light, patterned wood, adding warmth to the space. A glimpse of an outdoor scene with green foliage is visible through a glass door on the right. Two modern white bar stools are tucked under the right side of the island. High contrast, contemporary aesthetic, clean lines, soft ambient lighting, neutral and earthy color palette, minimalist, natural textures, sophisticated atmosphere. | 14345 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a concrete island with a sleek faucet and integrated sink, three black pendant lights above the island, a back wall clad in dark wood panels with vertical lines, and an illuminated wine rack on the right holding bottles arranged horizontally. The left wall has a wooden-handled tool mounted decoratively, and the floor is covered in light, patterned wood. The right image deviates from the prompt as the wine rack spans the entire back wall instead of being on the right, and the wooden-handled tool is missing. Additionally, the back wall lacks the vertical wood paneling described in the prompt. | left | Move the wine rack to the right side of the back wall and arrange the bottles horizontally. Add a wooden-handled tool mounted decoratively on the left wall, casting a shadow on the concrete surface. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it provides a closer and more detailed view of the lower half of the face, emphasizing the bold red sequined lips and the coppery eyeshadow. The lighting highlights the contours of the nose and creates a luminous effect on the skin. The right image, while also high-quality, is slightly more angled and does not focus as closely on the lips and nose, reducing the prominence of the makeup details and the dramatic effect described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Crop the image to focus more closely on the lower half of the face, emphasizing the lips and nose. Adjust the lighting to create a more luminous effect on the skin and enhance the contrast on the sequined lips."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49962_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49962_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Close-up, high-definition beauty photograph of the lower half of a female face, focusing on striking makeup details. The subject's skin is smooth and luminous, occupying the left side and center of the frame, with a warm and even complexion. Her lips are the focal point, covered in bold red sequins that catch the light, providing a dramatic and textured visual contrast. Just above, the nose is clearly defined with soft lighting highlighting its contours. The eye on the left side is partially visible, detailed with coppery eyeshadow that enhances the brown iris, framed by thick, brushed-up eyebrows. The dark background ensures that the facial features are prominently highlighted. Studio lighting, high contrast, vibrant red color palette, glossy texture, sharp focus, beauty and fashion photography, clean and minimalistic composition, modern, glamorous aesthetic, captivating attention to detail. | 14350 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it provides a closer and more detailed view of the lower half of the face, emphasizing the bold red sequined lips and the coppery eyeshadow. The lighting highlights the contours of the nose and creates a luminous effect on the skin. The right image, while also high-quality, is slightly more angled and does not focus as closely on the lips and nose, reducing the prominence of the makeup details and the dramatic effect described in the prompt. | left | Crop the image to focus more closely on the lower half of the face, emphasizing the lips and nose. Adjust the lighting to create a more luminous effect on the skin and enhance the contrast on the sequined lips. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a centered white icon and text on a black background, with the text in lowercase sans-serif font and properly spaced below the icon. The right image has a slightly off-white icon, the text is smaller, and the spacing between the icon and text is less balanced, which detracts from the minimalist and balanced composition described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the icon color to pure white. Increase the size of the text and adjust its spacing to align it more centrally below the icon."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49963_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49963_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Minimalist digital graphic design featuring a centered white icon and text on a black background. The circular icon is in the upper center, depicting a simple face with a downward-curved line as a mouth, resembling a frown or sad expression. Below the icon, centered, the phrase "that's all amigos!" is written in lowercase, white, sans-serif font. The design is stark and contrasts sharply with the deep black backdrop, creating a sense of closure or finality. Negative space is prominent, evoking simplicity, modernity, and a slightly somber tone. Balanced composition, flat design style, monochrome palette, minimalistic, digital art. | 14351 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a centered white icon and text on a black background, with the text in lowercase sans-serif font and properly spaced below the icon. The right image has a slightly off-white icon, the text is smaller, and the spacing between the icon and text is less balanced, which detracts from the minimalist and balanced composition described in the prompt. | left | Adjust the icon color to pure white. Increase the size of the text and adjust its spacing to align it more centrally below the icon. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a brown countertop with an integrated white sink, a sleek horizontal mirror extending across the wall, a metallic faucet, a green towel hanging to the right of the mirror, and neatly arranged toiletries. It also shows frosted glass windows with a white radiator below, and a glimpse into an adjacent room with artwork. The right image lacks the horizontal mirror extending across the wall, the adjacent room with artwork, and the seamless integration of elements described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Extend the mirror horizontally across the wall to match the width of the countertop. Add a glimpse of an adjacent room with a piece of artwork visible on the wall."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49966_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49966_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Modern bathroom design with a minimalist aesthetic. A brown countertop with an integrated white sink occupies the lower center, topped by a sleek, horizontal mirror extending across the width of the wall. Below the mirror, a metallic faucet with a modern design. A textured, green towel hangs from a hook to the right of the mirror, adding a pop of color. Several toiletries, including bottles and a soap dispenser, are neatly arranged on the counter surface. In the background, two frosted glass windows allow natural light to softly illuminate the space, highlighting the white radiator below. To the left, a glimpse into an adjacent room shows a piece of artwork on the wall. The right wall transitions from brown to a clean white, presenting a modern contrast. Matte black flooring complements the overall earthy, muted color scheme. Soft natural lighting, warm and inviting earth tones, contemporary interior design, seamless integration of elements, calm and orderly ambiance. | 14354 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a brown countertop with an integrated white sink, a sleek horizontal mirror extending across the wall, a metallic faucet, a green towel hanging to the right of the mirror, and neatly arranged toiletries. It also shows frosted glass windows with a white radiator below, and a glimpse into an adjacent room with artwork. The right image lacks the horizontal mirror extending across the wall, the adjacent room with artwork, and the seamless integration of elements described in the prompt. | left | Extend the mirror horizontally across the wall to match the width of the countertop. Add a glimpse of an adjacent room with a piece of artwork visible on the wall. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a sleek black table with a light wood trim, six light gray fabric-upholstered chairs, and an ashtray in the center of the table. The shelves on the right hold documents and a desk lamp with a white shade. The glass partition provides a view into another office space with wooden desks and chairs, and the large blue-tinted window spans the upper half of the back wall. The ceiling panels have a circular pattern with fluorescent lighting, and the left wall displays abstract artwork. The right image deviates from the prompt by including a circular ceiling light instead of fluorescent lighting, a bowl instead of an ashtray on the table, and chairs with wooden armrests that do not match the described minimalist design.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the circular ceiling light with ceiling panels featuring a circular pattern and fluorescent lighting. Replace the bowl on the table with an ashtray."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49964_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49964_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Contemporary office interior with minimalist design. The foreground features a sleek black table with a light wood trim, surrounded by six light gray, fabric-upholstered chairs, positioned towards the right center. An ashtray sits in the middle of the table. To the right, shelves built into the wooden walls hold stacks of documents and a desk lamp with a white shade. The partition between rooms consists of glass panels, giving a view into another office space filled with wooden desks and chairs in the background. A large blue-tinted window spans the upper half of the back wall, providing soft diffused light. Ceiling panels with a circular pattern house fluorescent lighting for a clean and modern ambiance. Beige and wood tones dominate the room, complemented by the cool blue hue from the windows, creating a balance between warmth and modernity. The left wall displays abstract artwork with a subdued color palette. Overall aesthetic: modern, minimalistic, professional, clean lines, neutral color scheme, open and airy atmosphere. | 14352 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a sleek black table with a light wood trim, six light gray fabric-upholstered chairs, and an ashtray in the center of the table. The shelves on the right hold documents and a desk lamp with a white shade. The glass partition provides a view into another office space with wooden desks and chairs, and the large blue-tinted window spans the upper half of the back wall. The ceiling panels have a circular pattern with fluorescent lighting, and the left wall displays abstract artwork. The right image deviates from the prompt by including a circular ceiling light instead of fluorescent lighting, a bowl instead of an ashtray on the table, and chairs with wooden armrests that do not match the described minimalist design. | left | Replace the circular ceiling light with ceiling panels featuring a circular pattern and fluorescent lighting. Replace the bowl on the table with an ashtray. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes a textured concrete wall with subtle vertical patterns, a floating bed with a dark comforter and pillows, and a strip of ambient lighting above the bed. The left side features a small side table with potted plants and a white ceramic object, illuminated by natural light through a glass wall. The right side shows a recessed hallway. The floor has a weathered metallic or concrete texture. The right image lacks the textured vertical patterns on the wall and the white ceramic object on the side table, making it less accurate to the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add subtle vertical patterns to the concrete wall behind the bed. Place a white ceramic object on the side table to the left of the bed."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49965_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49965_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Modern interior visualization of a minimalist bedroom with a central floating bed. The bed features a dark comforter and pillows, placed against a textured concrete wall with subtle vertical patterns. Above the bed, a strip of ambient lighting runs horizontally, providing a warm contrast to the cool tones of the room. The ceiling features a large skylight with blue-tinted glass, casting an ethereal glow. To the left, a small side table holds potted plants and a white ceramic object, illuminated by soft natural light entering through a glass wall. The right side reveals a dark, recessed hallway. The floor is made of weathered metallic or concrete material, reflecting the ambient colors. Hyper-realistic CGI, high contrast, balanced composition, ambient lighting, moody, minimalist aesthetic, sleek surfaces, modern architecture, industrial texture, diffused natural light, luxurious yet understated atmosphere. | 14353 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes a textured concrete wall with subtle vertical patterns, a floating bed with a dark comforter and pillows, and a strip of ambient lighting above the bed. The left side features a small side table with potted plants and a white ceramic object, illuminated by natural light through a glass wall. The right side shows a recessed hallway. The floor has a weathered metallic or concrete texture. The right image lacks the textured vertical patterns on the wall and the white ceramic object on the side table, making it less accurate to the prompt. | left | Add subtle vertical patterns to the concrete wall behind the bed. Place a white ceramic object on the side table to the left of the bed. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better matches the prompt as it features two top bento box pieces in light teal with circular, modular compartments in the upper left and right quadrants. The middle section contains two thin grey metal rods lying parallel to each other. The lower-left section has a small teal lid or accessory piece, and the lower-right section displays the dark teal base with a similar compartment layout. The right image deviates from the prompt by having irregularly shaped top pieces, a mismatched lower-right base with a different compartment layout, and an additional unnecessary element in the lower-left section.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the irregularly shaped top pieces with rectangular ones featuring circular, modular compartments. Adjust the lower-right base to match the compartment layout of the left image."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49969_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49969_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Digital rendering of a flatten bento box design with various components and layers arranged on a minimalistic grey background. Two top bento box pieces in light teal are displayed in the upper left and upper right quadrants, featuring circular, modular compartments. Below them, in the middle, two thin grey metal rods lie parallel to each other. In the lower-left section, a small teal lid or accessory piece is placed, while in the lower right, the bento box's dark teal base with a similar compartment layout is visible. Soft shadows are cast beneath each object, enhancing the three-dimensional effect. Clean, modern, minimalist design, flat lay composition, soft ambient lighting, muted color palette, precise lines, functional aesthetic. | 14357 | The left image better matches the prompt as it features two top bento box pieces in light teal with circular, modular compartments in the upper left and right quadrants. The middle section contains two thin grey metal rods lying parallel to each other. The lower-left section has a small teal lid or accessory piece, and the lower-right section displays the dark teal base with a similar compartment layout. The right image deviates from the prompt by having irregularly shaped top pieces, a mismatched lower-right base with a different compartment layout, and an additional unnecessary element in the lower-left section. | left | Replace the irregularly shaped top pieces with rectangular ones featuring circular, modular compartments. Adjust the lower-right base to match the compartment layout of the left image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a curved dark teal sofa, a round wooden side table with a candle and decoration, and a black pendant light hanging from an exposed beam ceiling. The right image has a straight green sectional sofa instead of a curved one, lacks the round wooden side table, and uses a different pendant light. Additionally, the abstract painting in the right image has a different color scheme, and the terrazzo flooring is less prominent.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the straight green sectional sofa with a curved dark teal sofa. Add a round wooden side table with a candle and decoration near the sofa."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49968_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49968_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Modern, spacious living room with mid-century aesthetic, natural light floods through a large, full-height window on the far wall, casting soft shadows. Left foreground shows a large earthen pot with a lush green plant. Nearby, a dark teal curved sofa with a round wooden side table holding a candle and decoration. In the center, a wooden coffee table with a decorative piece, flanked by a rectangular wooden table. Right side features a green sectional sofa against a wall covered with vertical green plants, above it hangs a large, red and orange abstract painting. Two geometric wooden chairs with black cushions in the right foreground. Overhead, a stylish black pendant light hangs from an exposed beam ceiling. Terrazzo flooring with colorful, patterned rugs adds texture. Natural tones dominate, with soft wood, vibrant plant life, and warm light. Photorealistic, high-resolution rendering, warm color palette, visually balanced, inviting, tranquil atmosphere. | 14356 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a curved dark teal sofa, a round wooden side table with a candle and decoration, and a black pendant light hanging from an exposed beam ceiling. The right image has a straight green sectional sofa instead of a curved one, lacks the round wooden side table, and uses a different pendant light. Additionally, the abstract painting in the right image has a different color scheme, and the terrazzo flooring is less prominent. | left | Replace the straight green sectional sofa with a curved dark teal sofa. Add a round wooden side table with a candle and decoration near the sofa. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a garage workshop with a Yamaha motorcycle on a yellow stand in the foreground. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the checkered yellow helmet against the left wall, the red rag on the workbench, and the bottle of water to the right. The right image lacks the red rag and the bottle of water on the workbench, and the checkered helmet is not positioned against the left wall. Additionally, the left image has a more cluttered and casual disarray, matching the prompt's description of a busy, utilitarian space.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a red rag and a bottle of water to the workbench in the background. Move the checkered yellow helmet to rest against the left wall beside the fabric pile."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49967_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49967_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Interior photograph of a cluttered garage workshop featuring a partially assembled Yamaha motorcycle on a yellow stand in the foreground, positioned slightly to the left. The motorcycle has chunky off-road tires and a sleek black body. To the right, another motorcycle wheel is partially visible. In the background, a wooden workbench is filled with various tools and parts, including an open toolkit on the left, a red rag, and a bottle of water to the right. Above, a bicycle tire hangs loosely, with other bike components scattered around. A checkered yellow motorcycle helmet rests against the left wall beside a fabric pile. The floor is concrete, slightly stained, with a metal drain cover under the motorcycle. The setting shows a busy, utilitarian space with functional, not aesthetic, organization. Image, sharp focus, natural indoor lighting, mundane color palette, artistic emphasis on the grit and reality of a garage environment, mechanic workshop theme, DIY atmosphere, casual disarray. | 14355 | Both images depict a garage workshop with a Yamaha motorcycle on a yellow stand in the foreground. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the checkered yellow helmet against the left wall, the red rag on the workbench, and the bottle of water to the right. The right image lacks the red rag and the bottle of water on the workbench, and the checkered helmet is not positioned against the left wall. Additionally, the left image has a more cluttered and casual disarray, matching the prompt's description of a busy, utilitarian space. | left | Add a red rag and a bottle of water to the workbench in the background. Move the checkered yellow helmet to rest against the left wall beside the fabric pile. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a large blue hand with splayed fingers dominating the frame, pressing a keyboard with 'DELETE' and 'ENTER' keys in the correct positions. The bright, jagged lightning-like lines in multiple colors emanate from the hand, creating a sense of explosive energy. The black figure with round glasses in the background has an expression suggesting focus. The right image, however, has a less dramatic perspective, the hand is not as large or splayed, and the 'DELETE' key is incorrectly positioned away from the keyboard. Additionally, the lightning-like lines are less jagged and dynamic, and the figure's expression is more neutral than focused.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the size of the hand and splay the fingers dramatically towards the viewer. Position the 'DELETE' key on the keyboard in the lower left corner."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49971_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49971_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Abstract digital illustration of a large blue hand pressing a keyboard, dominating the frame, with the fingers splayed dramatically towards the viewer. Bright, jagged lines resembling lightning bolts in yellow, red, purple, and green emanate from the hand, creating a sense of explosive energy. The keyboard keys, labeled "DELETE" on the left and "ENTER" on the right, are a vivid blue, positioned in the lower corners. A stylized, simplistic black figure with round glasses is in the background, its expression suggesting focus. The color palette is primarily blue with striking contrasts provided by the vivid, colorful lines. The composition is dynamic, with exaggerated perspective, flat style, clean lines, and vector-like simplicity, evoking a modern, tech-inspired feel. | 14359 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a large blue hand with splayed fingers dominating the frame, pressing a keyboard with 'DELETE' and 'ENTER' keys in the correct positions. The bright, jagged lightning-like lines in multiple colors emanate from the hand, creating a sense of explosive energy. The black figure with round glasses in the background has an expression suggesting focus. The right image, however, has a less dramatic perspective, the hand is not as large or splayed, and the 'DELETE' key is incorrectly positioned away from the keyboard. Additionally, the lightning-like lines are less jagged and dynamic, and the figure's expression is more neutral than focused. | left | Increase the size of the hand and splay the fingers dramatically towards the viewer. Position the 'DELETE' key on the keyboard in the lower left corner. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes the specified elements such as the round white dining table with intricate circular patterns, the metallic spherical pendant light, and the stainless steel double-door refrigerator flush with a tiled column. The left image also features the glass shelf with a silver teapot, creamer, and a vase with a single red flower, as described. The right image deviates from the prompt by including a green vase and additional items on the glass shelf, and the red flower is missing. Additionally, the refrigerator in the right image is not flush with a tiled column, and the framed photograph and portrait are not positioned as described.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the green vase and additional items from the glass shelf. Add a single red flower in a small vase to the glass shelf."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49970_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49970_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Brightly lit contemporary kitchen interior with modern furnishings, spacious setting with high wooden ceilings and geometric patterns. A round white dining table adorned with intricate circular patterns sits centrally, surrounded by four sleek black chairs. Above the table, a metallic spherical pendant light hangs from the ceiling, casting soft illumination. To the right, a stainless steel double-door refrigerator sits flush with a tiled column, providing a clean, minimalist look. On the left wall, a large framed photograph is mounted, adjacent to a smaller black-and-white portrait. Below these, a glass shelf holds a silver teapot and creamer, alongside a small vase with a single red flower. Green slate floor tiles add a natural texture, tying the room together. Photography, high key lighting, natural daylight, warm and soft color palette, contemporary design elements, clean lines, minimalist aesthetic. | 14358 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It includes the specified elements such as the round white dining table with intricate circular patterns, the metallic spherical pendant light, and the stainless steel double-door refrigerator flush with a tiled column. The left image also features the glass shelf with a silver teapot, creamer, and a vase with a single red flower, as described. The right image deviates from the prompt by including a green vase and additional items on the glass shelf, and the red flower is missing. Additionally, the refrigerator in the right image is not flush with a tiled column, and the framed photograph and portrait are not positioned as described. | left | Remove the green vase and additional items from the glass shelf. Add a single red flower in a small vase to the glass shelf. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a woman with short dark hair in a patterned dress, seated with her side profile facing left, and leaning back with her hands on a textured stone surface. The shallow water fountain with small spouts is visible behind her, and the background includes a rough-textured stone wall and tall trees silhouetted against an overcast sky. The grayscale palette and high contrast enhance the moody, timeless quality. The right image, while similar, has a few discrepancies: the woman's hair is slightly longer and styled differently, the dress pattern is less distinct, and the overall contrast and lighting do not emphasize the textures and analog film characteristics as effectively.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Shorten the woman's hair to match the description of short dark hair. Increase the contrast and sharpness to highlight the textures of the stone, fabric, and overall scene."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49972_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49972_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Black and white photograph of a seated woman with short dark hair, wearing a patterned dress, positioned with her side profile facing left. She is leaning back with her hands on a textured stone surface, close to a shallow water fountain with small spouts of water visible behind her. In the background, a stone wall with a rough texture extends across the image, with tall trees silhouetted against an overcast sky. The image is high contrast, with sharp details highlighting the texture of the stone and fabric. The composition captures a serene, contemplative mood. The grayscale palette enhances the moody and timeless quality, utilizing natural lighting, analog film characteristics, and a nostalgic atmosphere. | 14360 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a woman with short dark hair in a patterned dress, seated with her side profile facing left, and leaning back with her hands on a textured stone surface. The shallow water fountain with small spouts is visible behind her, and the background includes a rough-textured stone wall and tall trees silhouetted against an overcast sky. The grayscale palette and high contrast enhance the moody, timeless quality. The right image, while similar, has a few discrepancies: the woman's hair is slightly longer and styled differently, the dress pattern is less distinct, and the overall contrast and lighting do not emphasize the textures and analog film characteristics as effectively. | left | Shorten the woman's hair to match the description of short dark hair. Increase the contrast and sharpness to highlight the textures of the stone, fabric, and overall scene. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the young woman standing barefoot on the wooden sailboat deck, holding a rope with her right hand, and wearing a light blue oversized shirt with striped collar and cuff details. The intricate wooden patterns on the deck and the folded beige sail on the right side are clearly visible. The natural lighting, calm sea, and clear sky create a serene and balanced composition. In contrast, the right image lacks the striped cuff details on the shirt, and the woman's pose does not emphasize her holding the rope with her right hand as prominently. Additionally, the lighting and overall composition in the right image are less balanced compared to the left.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add striped cuff details to the shirt. Adjust the woman's pose to clearly show her holding the rope with her right hand in a confident manner."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49973_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49973_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Young woman standing barefoot on a wooden sailboat deck, holding a rope with her right hand, wearing a light blue oversized shirt with a stripped collar and cuff details. Positioned slightly to the left, she gazes confidently towards the camera. The boat's deck showcases intricate wooden patterns, while a folded sail dominates the right side with its beige canvas texture. The background reveals a calm sea under a clear sky, emphasizing a sense of tranquility. Natural lighting, soft shadows, bright midday atmosphere, warm earth tones, maritime aesthetic, clear blue skies enhance the serene setting, balanced composition, fashion editorial vibe. | 14361 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the young woman standing barefoot on the wooden sailboat deck, holding a rope with her right hand, and wearing a light blue oversized shirt with striped collar and cuff details. The intricate wooden patterns on the deck and the folded beige sail on the right side are clearly visible. The natural lighting, calm sea, and clear sky create a serene and balanced composition. In contrast, the right image lacks the striped cuff details on the shirt, and the woman's pose does not emphasize her holding the rope with her right hand as prominently. Additionally, the lighting and overall composition in the right image are less balanced compared to the left. | left | Add striped cuff details to the shirt. Adjust the woman's pose to clearly show her holding the rope with her right hand in a confident manner. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the dynamic and expressionistic style with bold brushstrokes, vivid colors, and a chaotic yet balanced composition. The man is positioned slightly to the left, wearing a sharp suit, and the Eiffel Tower is prominently in the middle ground. The vibrant cityscape, swirling clouds, and reflections of neon lights in the foreground create a sense of movement and energy. The right image, while visually appealing, lacks the abstract and blurred features of the man, the impressionistic style, and the chaotic energy described in the prompt. It appears more realistic and less expressionistic, with a calmer ambiance and less vibrant foreground reflections.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Blur the man's features slightly to create an abstract and harmonized look. Add more vibrant neon reflections and abstract shapes in the foreground to enhance the sense of movement and energy."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49974_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49974_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Dynamic illustration depicting a man in a suit standing near a railing with the Eiffel Tower in the background. The man is positioned slightly to the left, wearing a sharp, tailored suit and tie, with a confident posture. His features are abstract and blurred, harmonizing with the vibrant cityscape behind him. The Eiffel Tower rises prominently in the middle ground, surrounded by a colorful, impressionistic sky filled with swirling clouds and dappled sunset hues. The foreground includes reflections of neon lights and abstract shapes, creating a sense of movement and energy. Expressionistic style, bold brushstrokes, layered textures, and vivid color palette. The composition is chaotic yet balanced, with a mix of realism and abstraction, high contrast, energetic ambiance, Parisian romanticism. | 14362 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the dynamic and expressionistic style with bold brushstrokes, vivid colors, and a chaotic yet balanced composition. The man is positioned slightly to the left, wearing a sharp suit, and the Eiffel Tower is prominently in the middle ground. The vibrant cityscape, swirling clouds, and reflections of neon lights in the foreground create a sense of movement and energy. The right image, while visually appealing, lacks the abstract and blurred features of the man, the impressionistic style, and the chaotic energy described in the prompt. It appears more realistic and less expressionistic, with a calmer ambiance and less vibrant foreground reflections. | left | Blur the man's features slightly to create an abstract and harmonized look. Add more vibrant neon reflections and abstract shapes in the foreground to enhance the sense of movement and energy. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has a softer gradient in the background and a more evenly diffused studio lighting, which aligns better with the prompt's emphasis on a muted monochrome palette and minimalist composition. The chair in the left image is slightly angled to the right, as specified, and the shadow extends subtly to the right, enhancing depth. The right image has a flatter background gradient and less pronounced shadow, making it less aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a soft gradient to the background, transitioning from light gray to slightly darker gray. Adjust the shadow of the chair to extend slightly to the right, enhancing depth."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49975_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49975_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Minimalistic product photograph of a modern chair with a white metal frame and gray fabric cushions. The chair is positioned slightly angled to the right, centrally in the frame against a neutral gray background with a soft gradient. The chair's design features clean lines and a tubular construction with the backrest and seat cushioned in a textured gray fabric. The chair's shadow is visible on the floor, extending slightly to the right, enhancing the depth of the image. Studio lighting, evenly diffused, with a muted monochrome color palette, captures the sleek and modern aesthetic of the furniture, emphasizing its textures and form, shallow depth of field, sharp focus, and minimalist composition. | 14363 | The left image has a softer gradient in the background and a more evenly diffused studio lighting, which aligns better with the prompt's emphasis on a muted monochrome palette and minimalist composition. The chair in the left image is slightly angled to the right, as specified, and the shadow extends subtly to the right, enhancing depth. The right image has a flatter background gradient and less pronounced shadow, making it less aligned with the prompt. | left | Add a soft gradient to the background, transitioning from light gray to slightly darker gray. Adjust the shadow of the chair to extend slightly to the right, enhancing depth. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures a more dynamic and balanced composition. The woman in the yellow dress is positioned closer to the car, creating a stronger connection between the elements. The fog and lighting are more evenly distributed, enhancing the cinematic and misty glow described in the prompt. In contrast, the right image has the woman positioned farther from the car, reducing the sense of interaction and energy. Additionally, the lighting in the right image appears harsher and less diffused, which detracts from the soft natural light and misty atmosphere specified in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Move the woman closer to the car to create a more dynamic interaction. Adjust the lighting to make it softer and more diffused, enhancing the misty glow in the room."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49976_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49976_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | A dynamic, high-energy photo of a modern, green and black Opel SUV prominently positioned in the center of a spacious, industrial garage with concrete flooring and fog drifting through. The car's front end and side are partially visible, with stylish black alloy wheels and sleek headlights. To the right, a young Black woman in a bright yellow dress dances with arms raised, her black ankle boots adding a touch of edge. The background features large, frosted windows, allowing soft diffused daylight to filter through, filling the room with a misty glow. Industrial ductwork runs across the ceiling, adding to the setting's modern vibe. Stylistic properties include a vibrant, energetic mood, cinematic feel, medium depth of field, soft natural light, high contrast, desaturated cool tones with pops of vibrant green and yellow, clean lines, polished textures, visually dynamic and balanced. | 14364 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures a more dynamic and balanced composition. The woman in the yellow dress is positioned closer to the car, creating a stronger connection between the elements. The fog and lighting are more evenly distributed, enhancing the cinematic and misty glow described in the prompt. In contrast, the right image has the woman positioned farther from the car, reducing the sense of interaction and energy. Additionally, the lighting in the right image appears harsher and less diffused, which detracts from the soft natural light and misty atmosphere specified in the prompt. | left | Move the woman closer to the car to create a more dynamic interaction. Adjust the lighting to make it softer and more diffused, enhancing the misty glow in the room. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a vibrant studio photograph of the winter beanie with the Icelandic flag design. The beanie is centrally positioned, has a clean and minimalistic background, and the lighting is high-key with sharp focus. The right image, while similar, has a slightly darker exposure and the beanie appears less vibrant. Additionally, the pom-pom in the right image is not as prominently multicolored as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the brightness and vibrancy of the beanie and background. Enhance the multicolored pom-pom to make the red, white, and blue colors more distinct and prominent."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49980_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49980_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Vibrant studio photograph of a winter beanie with an Icelandic flag design, centrally positioned against a light blue background. The beanie is predominantly blue with a prominent red cross outlined in white, resembling the Iceland flag, and topped with a multicolored pom-pom in red, white, and blue. The scene is minimalistic with no other objects, focusing entirely on the beanie. Clean, flat studio lighting, high-key exposure, sharp focus, balanced composition, smooth texture, matte finish, cool color palette, simple and elegant presentation, product photography style. | 14367 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a vibrant studio photograph of the winter beanie with the Icelandic flag design. The beanie is centrally positioned, has a clean and minimalistic background, and the lighting is high-key with sharp focus. The right image, while similar, has a slightly darker exposure and the beanie appears less vibrant. Additionally, the pom-pom in the right image is not as prominently multicolored as described in the prompt. | left | Increase the brightness and vibrancy of the beanie and background. Enhance the multicolored pom-pom to make the red, white, and blue colors more distinct and prominent. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a sleek, cylindrical device with a vertical split panel. The left side shows a close-up of the front with a centrally aligned oval sensor in a matte white casing, and the right side displays the base with a curved metallic design, a small circular button labeled 'Geist,' and a thin power cable resting on a clean white surface. The right image deviates from the prompt by showing a different device design with an elongated oval shape and lacks the vertical split panel and proper alignment of elements described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a vertical split panel dividing the device into two distinct sections. Adjust the device design to be cylindrical with a matte white front and a metallic curved base."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49977_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49977_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Minimalist product photography of a sleek, cylindrical device divided by a vertical split panel. Left side shows a close-up of the device's front, featuring an oval sensor or camera lens enclosed in a soft, matte white casing. The lens is centrally aligned with a subtle shadow gradient surrounding it, adding depth. The right side displays the device's base, showcasing a curved design in a smooth, metallic texture. Below is a small, circular button labeled "Geist" near the bottom right, slightly out of focus. A thin power cable extends from the bottom, resting on a clean, white surface. Soft, even lighting highlights the device's smooth curves and accentuates its modern aesthetic. Product design photography, high contrast, matte and metallic textures, minimalist, white and gray color palette, sharp focus on essential details, refined and contemporary. | 14365 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a sleek, cylindrical device with a vertical split panel. The left side shows a close-up of the front with a centrally aligned oval sensor in a matte white casing, and the right side displays the base with a curved metallic design, a small circular button labeled 'Geist,' and a thin power cable resting on a clean white surface. The right image deviates from the prompt by showing a different device design with an elongated oval shape and lacks the vertical split panel and proper alignment of elements described in the prompt. | left | Add a vertical split panel dividing the device into two distinct sections. Adjust the device design to be cylindrical with a matte white front and a metallic curved base. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a dark wood slatted ceiling, polished wooden decking, and a large L-shaped white sofa with grey and white cushions. However, the coffee table is rectangular but lacks the stone texture, and the rug is not clearly textured. The lanterns are present but not grid-patterned. The right image has a more accurate stone-textured coffee table and a textured grey rug, but the lanterns are missing, and the dining chairs and table are less prominent. Both images have the brick pillar and glass wall with a forest view, but the left image better captures the overall composition and lighting harmony with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add grid-pattern wooden lanterns near the coffee table. Enhance the texture of the rug to make it more prominent and consistent with the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49978_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49978_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Modern outdoor living space featuring a sleek, open-air patio with a dark wood slatted ceiling and polished wooden decking. A large L-shaped white sofa with numerous grey and white cushions rests against a transparent glass wall to the left, offering a view of a densely wooded forest. In front of the sofa, a rectangular stone coffee table sits on a grey textured rug, with two wooden grid-pattern lanterns nearby. To the right, a set of wire-frame dining chairs and a round glass-topped metal table provide additional seating. A brick pillar with warm, red-brown tones divides the space, while the surrounding greenery cast dappled shadows across the scene. Architectural photography, natural daylight, minimalist aesthetics, soft neutral color palette, emphasizing simplicity and harmony with nature, seamlessly blending indoor and outdoor elements, airy, spacious, contemporary design. | 14366 | The left image features a dark wood slatted ceiling, polished wooden decking, and a large L-shaped white sofa with grey and white cushions. However, the coffee table is rectangular but lacks the stone texture, and the rug is not clearly textured. The lanterns are present but not grid-patterned. The right image has a more accurate stone-textured coffee table and a textured grey rug, but the lanterns are missing, and the dining chairs and table are less prominent. Both images have the brick pillar and glass wall with a forest view, but the left image better captures the overall composition and lighting harmony with the prompt. | left | Add grid-pattern wooden lanterns near the coffee table. Enhance the texture of the rug to make it more prominent and consistent with the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a cluster of blooming white flowers against a concrete surface. The left image has a more centered composition and better alignment with the prompt's description of muted colors and soft natural lighting. The flowers in the left image have long, spiky petals and vibrant yellow centers, with additional yellow buds and green leaves encircling the cluster. The right image, while similar, has a slightly less centered composition and a more vibrant color palette, which deviates from the muted tones described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the color palette to be slightly muted, reducing the vibrancy of the green leaves and yellow buds. Center the flower cluster more prominently against the concrete surface."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49981_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49981_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Cluster of blooming white flowers against a concrete surface. Predominantly centered, the flowers display long, spiky petals and vibrant yellow centers. Additional yellow buds and green leaves encircle the cluster, creating a lush appearance. The texture of the concrete provides a stark, contrasting backdrop. Soft natural lighting, medium depth of field, slightly muted colors, sharp focus on the flowers, subtle shadows, rustic, organic, serene. | 14368 | Both images depict a cluster of blooming white flowers against a concrete surface. The left image has a more centered composition and better alignment with the prompt's description of muted colors and soft natural lighting. The flowers in the left image have long, spiky petals and vibrant yellow centers, with additional yellow buds and green leaves encircling the cluster. The right image, while similar, has a slightly less centered composition and a more vibrant color palette, which deviates from the muted tones described in the prompt. | left | Adjust the color palette to be slightly muted, reducing the vibrancy of the green leaves and yellow buds. Center the flower cluster more prominently against the concrete surface. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a stylized horse head with a bold red bridle, a prominent and expressive eye, and swirling red lines accentuating its contours. The background includes a blue arched panel with white geometric shapes resembling crystals, a line-drawn bow and arrow, and a delicate branch with leaves. The abstract flower petals and stems are scattered around the horse's head, adding a whimsical feel. The right image deviates from the prompt by including a unicorn horn, which is not mentioned, and lacks the swirling red lines around the eye. Additionally, the flower petals and stems are less abstract and more uniform, reducing the whimsical effect.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the unicorn horn from the horse's head. Add swirling red lines around the horse's eye to accentuate its contours."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49982_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49982_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Illustrative drawing of a stylized horse head with a bold red bridle and abstract marks on a soft pink background. The horse's eye is prominent, large, and expressive, positioned slightly to the right, with swirling red lines accentuating its contours. Surrounding the horse are abstract flower petals and stems, scattered around the horse's head, adding a whimsical feel. Above the horse, within a blue arched panel, are white geometric shapes resembling crystals and a line-drawn bow and arrow, elements that evoke a mythological or celestial theme. This panel also features a delicate branch with leaves. The color palette is minimalistic yet striking, featuring pastel pinks and blues with accents of bright red, flat color application, and clean linework, combining digital graphic style with traditional illustrative techniques, ethereal, mystical, surreal, heavily stylized with a harmonious balance between realistic and abstract elements. | 14369 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a stylized horse head with a bold red bridle, a prominent and expressive eye, and swirling red lines accentuating its contours. The background includes a blue arched panel with white geometric shapes resembling crystals, a line-drawn bow and arrow, and a delicate branch with leaves. The abstract flower petals and stems are scattered around the horse's head, adding a whimsical feel. The right image deviates from the prompt by including a unicorn horn, which is not mentioned, and lacks the swirling red lines around the eye. Additionally, the flower petals and stems are less abstract and more uniform, reducing the whimsical effect. | left | Remove the unicorn horn from the horse's head. Add swirling red lines around the horse's eye to accentuate its contours. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a steel connector piece joining multiple blue fabric straps, but the straps do not run diagonally through the frame, and the background is slightly blurred, reducing the sharpness and contrast. The right image has a steel connector piece with etched detail joining two blue fabric straps that run diagonally through the frame, aligning better with the prompt. The background is smooth and off-white, providing a stark contrast to the vibrant blue fabric, and the lighting is bright and even, enhancing the contemporary aesthetic.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Adjust the angle of the straps to make them run diagonally through the frame. Replace the background with a smooth off-white surface for better contrast and minimalism."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49984_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49984_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Close-up image of a minimalistic, modern design resembling a triangle with intersecting lines in a sleek, elegant form. The central focus is on a steel connector piece with etched detail, joining two blue fabric straps that run diagonally through the frame. The fabric features a textured velcro-like surface, appearing both flexible and durable. The background is a smooth off-white, providing a stark contrast to the vibrant blue of the fabric. Clean lines and geometric shapes dominate, creating a sense of symmetry and precision. The image is sharp, with a high contrast between the materials, conveying a contemporary aesthetic. Bright, even lighting suggests a studio photography setup. Minimalistic, geometric, modern design, clean, sharp, high-contrast, studio lighting, contemporary. | 14371 | The left image features a steel connector piece joining multiple blue fabric straps, but the straps do not run diagonally through the frame, and the background is slightly blurred, reducing the sharpness and contrast. The right image has a steel connector piece with etched detail joining two blue fabric straps that run diagonally through the frame, aligning better with the prompt. The background is smooth and off-white, providing a stark contrast to the vibrant blue fabric, and the lighting is bright and even, enhancing the contemporary aesthetic. | right | Adjust the angle of the straps to make them run diagonally through the frame. Replace the background with a smooth off-white surface for better contrast and minimalism. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features two bronze rabbit sculptures with a glossy finish, but they are in a sitting position with their bodies appearing more compact and less elongated. The right image shows two sleek, elongated rabbit sculptures with upright ears, better matching the prompt's description of stylized abstract figurines emphasizing form and light interaction. The right image also has a more symmetrical and balanced composition, with the sculptures facing each other and positioned near the center. The lighting in the right image better highlights the reflective surfaces and smooth textures of the sculptures, creating a stronger contrast with the matte black background.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Elongate the bodies and ears of the rabbit sculptures to create a more stylized and abstract appearance. Adjust the lighting to enhance the reflective highlights and shadows on the sculptures, emphasizing their polished textures."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49983_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49983_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Two sleek, glossy, bronze rabbit sculptures facing each other set against a matte black background. These stylized abstract figurines are positioned near the center of the image, slightly to the left and right respectively, with their elongated ears pointing upwards. The reflective surfaces of the sculptures showcase soft highlights and shadows, emphasizing their smooth and polished textures. Minimalistic, elegant, low-key lighting, simple composition, high contrast between the metallic sheen and the dark background, contemporary art with an emphasis on form and light interaction, balanced and symmetrical. | 14370 | The left image features two bronze rabbit sculptures with a glossy finish, but they are in a sitting position with their bodies appearing more compact and less elongated. The right image shows two sleek, elongated rabbit sculptures with upright ears, better matching the prompt's description of stylized abstract figurines emphasizing form and light interaction. The right image also has a more symmetrical and balanced composition, with the sculptures facing each other and positioned near the center. The lighting in the right image better highlights the reflective surfaces and smooth textures of the sculptures, creating a stronger contrast with the matte black background. | right | Elongate the bodies and ears of the rabbit sculptures to create a more stylized and abstract appearance. Adjust the lighting to enhance the reflective highlights and shadows on the sculptures, emphasizing their polished textures. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a partially obscured face with the hand covering the mouth, fair skin, black hair, and a head tilted slightly downwards. The background has muted blue and grey painterly strokes, creating a sense of movement and texture. The facial expression is undefined, adding mystery, and the soft pastel color palette with pink cheeks conveys shyness. The Japanese characters and 'okamoto' logo are present in the top right corner. The right image, while similar, has a more explicit facial expression, lacks the downward tilt of the head, and the background strokes are less textured and dynamic.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Tilt the head slightly downward to create a more introspective posture. Add more painterly strokes to the background to enhance texture and movement."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49986_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49986_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Abstract digital illustration, stylized portrait of a person with fair skin and black hair, partially obscured face, hand covering their mouth, positioned in the foreground with head tilted slightly downwards. The background features broad swaths of muted blue and grey with painterly strokes creating a sense of movement and texture. The facial expression is undefined, adding an air of mystery and introspection. Use of minimal line work and soft color gradients, with slightly pink cheeks giving a sense of shyness or contemplation. The top right corner displays Japanese characters alongside the logo “okamoto,” adding an element of brand identity. The composition features asymmetry and visual balance, with emphasis on the interplay between foreground and abstract background. Digital art, minimalistic style, soft pastel color palette, subtle textures, suggestive rather than explicit in details, modern and conceptual. | 14373 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a partially obscured face with the hand covering the mouth, fair skin, black hair, and a head tilted slightly downwards. The background has muted blue and grey painterly strokes, creating a sense of movement and texture. The facial expression is undefined, adding mystery, and the soft pastel color palette with pink cheeks conveys shyness. The Japanese characters and 'okamoto' logo are present in the top right corner. The right image, while similar, has a more explicit facial expression, lacks the downward tilt of the head, and the background strokes are less textured and dynamic. | left | Tilt the head slightly downward to create a more introspective posture. Add more painterly strokes to the background to enhance texture and movement. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the man positioned towards the lower left of the frame, holding the blue designer bag in his left hand, and looking to his left. The background includes warm, dimly-lit architectural elements with a glass and metal railing, and the overall atmosphere is upscale and contemporary. The right image has the man more centered in the frame, and the lighting appears slightly brighter, reducing the dim, ambient effect described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reposition the man towards the lower left of the frame. Adjust the lighting to create a warmer, dimly-lit ambiance with soft, ambient tones."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49985_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49985_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Young Black man standing on a modern staircase, wearing a form-fitting black top and baggy grey cargo pants, holding a small blue designer bag in his left hand, positioned towards the lower left of the frame. The background features warm, dimly-lit architectural elements, including a glass and metal railing along the stairs. The setting has an upscale, contemporary vibe with soft, ambient lighting. The man is looking to his left, showcasing short hair and accessorized with a chunky silver necklace and stud earrings. The top right shows a partial figure and more stairs, while the overall scene is enclosed by rich, brown-toned walls. Fashion photography, high contrast, shallow depth of field, emphasis on texture and materiality, luxurious atmosphere, elegant, visually balanced. | 14372 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the man positioned towards the lower left of the frame, holding the blue designer bag in his left hand, and looking to his left. The background includes warm, dimly-lit architectural elements with a glass and metal railing, and the overall atmosphere is upscale and contemporary. The right image has the man more centered in the frame, and the lighting appears slightly brighter, reducing the dim, ambient effect described in the prompt. | left | Reposition the man towards the lower left of the frame. Adjust the lighting to create a warmer, dimly-lit ambiance with soft, ambient tones. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a championship ring with the word 'HEAT' in metallic letters and gold accents resembling basketball nets, as well as the word 'CHAMPIONS' in bold purple text. The gemstones are symmetrically arranged, and the background includes abstract shapes, but the shapes lack the specified variety and complexity. The right image has a more intricate and chaotic background with interlocking silver rings, spikes, and bulbous forms, aligning better with the prompt. However, the ring in the right image does not fully match the description, as the word 'HEAT' lacks the basketball net-like gold accents, and the gemstones are less symmetrical.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add gold accents resembling basketball nets to the word 'HEAT' on the ring. Arrange the gemstones on the ring in a more symmetrical, shimmering pattern."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49987_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49987_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Highly detailed 3D digital artwork of a championship ring, prominently positioned in the right foreground, featuring the word "HEAT" in large metallic letters with gold accents resembling basketball nets. The lower section displays the word "CHAMPIONS" in bold purple text. Surrounding the lettering are numerous clear, faceted gemstones arranged in a symmetrical, shimmering pattern. To the left and in the background, an intricate, chaotic assemblage of abstract, multi-colored shapes and textures. These include interlocking silver rings, purple and green spikes, yellow and blue bulbous forms, and various metallic and fabric textures creating a complex, vibrant collage. The background is a neutral gray, enhancing the vivid colors and metallic sheen of the objects. Digital rendering, close-up perspective, photorealistic textures, high contrast, vibrant color palette, intricate details, dynamic composition, reflective surfaces, abstract art style. | 14374 | The left image features a championship ring with the word 'HEAT' in metallic letters and gold accents resembling basketball nets, as well as the word 'CHAMPIONS' in bold purple text. The gemstones are symmetrically arranged, and the background includes abstract shapes, but the shapes lack the specified variety and complexity. The right image has a more intricate and chaotic background with interlocking silver rings, spikes, and bulbous forms, aligning better with the prompt. However, the ring in the right image does not fully match the description, as the word 'HEAT' lacks the basketball net-like gold accents, and the gemstones are less symmetrical. | right | Add gold accents resembling basketball nets to the word 'HEAT' on the ring. Arrange the gemstones on the ring in a more symmetrical, shimmering pattern. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a hallway with light wooden flooring, plain white walls, and a clear view of a bright room with large windows showing green trees and a clear sky. The shadows on the floor and the minimalist design are consistent with the prompt. The right image lacks the described open doorways leading to distinct spaces, and the visible outdoor area appears less natural and inviting. Additionally, the left image includes a ceiling vent at the far end, which is missing in the right image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a ceiling vent at the far end of the hallway above the left side. Adjust the outdoor view to include more natural greenery and a clear sky visible through the windows."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49990_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49990_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Minimalist architectural interior photograph of a modern, sunlit apartment hallway with light wooden flooring. The hallway extends to the center left, leading to two open doorways. The door on the right opens into a bright room with large windows that allow natural daylight to flood in, casting shadows on the light wood floor. Visible through the windows are green trees and a clear sky, suggesting an outdoor garden or yard. The doorframe on the left leads to a shadowed space, mostly obscured but showing a continuation of the wooden flooring. The hallway walls are plain white, and a small ceiling vent can be seen at the far end above the left hallway. Modern, minimalist design, high-key lighting, neutral color palette, emphasis on natural light and clean lines, crisp focus, serene, inviting. | 14376 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a hallway with light wooden flooring, plain white walls, and a clear view of a bright room with large windows showing green trees and a clear sky. The shadows on the floor and the minimalist design are consistent with the prompt. The right image lacks the described open doorways leading to distinct spaces, and the visible outdoor area appears less natural and inviting. Additionally, the left image includes a ceiling vent at the far end, which is missing in the right image. | left | Add a ceiling vent at the far end of the hallway above the left side. Adjust the outdoor view to include more natural greenery and a clear sky visible through the windows. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a central character in an acrobatic pose with sharp geometric shapes and bold colors, surrounded by oversized, stylized masks with abstract features in a semicircle. The masks have varied expressions and colors, fulfilling the prompt's description. The background includes a city skyline silhouette, a gradient sky, and neon bursts with geometric shapes, creating a vibrant and dynamic composition. The right image, while visually appealing, lacks the semicircular arrangement of masks and instead features floating heads that do not fully match the abstract, oversized mask description. Additionally, the right image has fewer geometric shapes and less visual chaos compared to the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the floating heads with oversized, stylized masks featuring abstract features and varied expressions in a semicircular arrangement. Add more geometric shapes like circles, stars, and hexagons to enhance the visual complexity and chaotic feel."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49989_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49989_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Vibrant and dynamic illustration with a surreal, pop-art style. Central figure is a stylized character, possibly resembling Spider-Man, suspended mid-motion with an acrobatic pose, against an explosive backdrop of swirling colors. The character is composed of sharp geometric shapes and bold colors, wearing a dark suit with red and blue highlights, centralized in the image. Surrounding him are a series of oversized, stylized masks with abstract features, emphasizing a connection to multiple identities or dimensions, positioned in a semicircle, with varied expressions and colors including red, blue, and white. The background features a city skyline silhouette in deep blue, beneath a gradient sky transitioning from bright yellow to green. Neon bursts and geometric shapes like circles, stars, and hexagons fill the space, adding depth and complexity. A rainbow of light beams emanates from behind the central character, converging into an epicenter of color and energy. Illustrative style, high contrast, neon color palette, flat graphic elements, dynamic composition, psychedelic, dreamlike, visually chaotic, and harmoniously asymmetrical. | 14375 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a central character in an acrobatic pose with sharp geometric shapes and bold colors, surrounded by oversized, stylized masks with abstract features in a semicircle. The masks have varied expressions and colors, fulfilling the prompt's description. The background includes a city skyline silhouette, a gradient sky, and neon bursts with geometric shapes, creating a vibrant and dynamic composition. The right image, while visually appealing, lacks the semicircular arrangement of masks and instead features floating heads that do not fully match the abstract, oversized mask description. Additionally, the right image has fewer geometric shapes and less visual chaos compared to the left image. | left | Replace the floating heads with oversized, stylized masks featuring abstract features and varied expressions in a semicircular arrangement. Add more geometric shapes like circles, stars, and hexagons to enhance the visual complexity and chaotic feel. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a luminous figure centrally positioned, glowing in white with a radiant blue aura spreading in sharp rays. The dark mountains in the foreground have smooth, undulating shapes and are depicted in shades of black and deep blue, with small white shapes and dots adding texture. The right image, while similar, has less defined sharp rays emanating from the figure, and the mountains lack the smooth, dreamlike undulations described in the prompt. Additionally, the right image's terrain appears more rigid and less ethereal, deviating from the minimalist and contemplative style.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the sharpness and intensity of the blue rays emanating from the luminous figure. Smooth out the mountain shapes to create undulating, dreamlike terrain consistent with the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49993_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49993_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Surreal digital illustration of a luminous figure levitating in the sky above a landscape of abstract, dark mountains. The figure is centrally positioned, glowing in white with a radiant, blue aura that spreads in sharp rays across the image. The mountains in the foreground are depicted in shades of black and deep blue, featuring smooth, undulating shapes that suggest a dreamlike terrain. Small, irregular white shapes and dots are dispersed across the mountains, adding texture and depth. The entire scene conveys a sense of mysticism and transcendence. Digital art, high contrast, ethereal atmosphere, minimalist style, blue and black monochrome palette, smooth gradients, vibrancy emanating from the central figure, visually striking, conceptual, contemplative. | 14379 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a luminous figure centrally positioned, glowing in white with a radiant blue aura spreading in sharp rays. The dark mountains in the foreground have smooth, undulating shapes and are depicted in shades of black and deep blue, with small white shapes and dots adding texture. The right image, while similar, has less defined sharp rays emanating from the figure, and the mountains lack the smooth, dreamlike undulations described in the prompt. Additionally, the right image's terrain appears more rigid and less ethereal, deviating from the minimalist and contemplative style. | left | Enhance the sharpness and intensity of the blue rays emanating from the luminous figure. Smooth out the mountain shapes to create undulating, dreamlike terrain consistent with the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a symmetrical sculpture resembling wings, with smooth black and beige surfaces and glossy textures. The base includes muted brown and green hues, and the background has a blurred earthy setting with mossy rocks, aligning well with the prompt. The right image depicts a more owl-like sculpture with similar materials and textures, but the base lacks the muted brown and green hues, and the background is less earthy and natural. The left image better captures the abstract and symmetrical design resembling wings, as well as the earthy color palette and natural background described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add muted brown and green hues to the base of the sculpture. Enhance the background with more earthy textures and mossy elements to suggest a natural setting."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49992_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49992_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Digital rendering of an abstract geometric sculpture resembling a stylized symmetrical owl or wings, positioned centrally against a blurred, earthy background. The sculpture features interlocking shapes composed of smooth black and beige surfaces with glossy textures, reflecting light subtly. The base of the figure includes curved segments with muted brown and green hues, adding visual balance. In the background, an out-of-focus natural setting with rough textures suggests mossy rocks or a forest floor. The overall composition conveys a harmonious blend of natural and synthetic aesthetics, sharp lines, soft focus background, earthy color palette, medium depth of field, surrealistic, calm ambiance. | 14378 | The left image features a symmetrical sculpture resembling wings, with smooth black and beige surfaces and glossy textures. The base includes muted brown and green hues, and the background has a blurred earthy setting with mossy rocks, aligning well with the prompt. The right image depicts a more owl-like sculpture with similar materials and textures, but the base lacks the muted brown and green hues, and the background is less earthy and natural. The left image better captures the abstract and symmetrical design resembling wings, as well as the earthy color palette and natural background described in the prompt. | left | Add muted brown and green hues to the base of the sculpture. Enhance the background with more earthy textures and mossy elements to suggest a natural setting. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more balanced and artistic arrangement of the elements on the plate. The curled red beet slice forms an elegant wave across the center, and the accompanying elements, such as croutons, creamy dollops, yellow cubes, green herbs, roasted root vegetables, and finely chopped nuts, are well-distributed and visually harmonious. The right image, while clean and minimalist, lacks the same level of balance and precision in the arrangement, with elements appearing more scattered and less integrated into the composition.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Rearrange the elements to create a more balanced and artistic composition, ensuring the red beet slice forms an elegant wave across the center. Distribute the accompanying elements, such as croutons, creamy dollops, yellow cubes, green herbs, and nuts, more evenly and harmoniously across the plate."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49991_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49991_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Minimalist close-up of an exquisitely plated dish on a plain white background. At the center is a smooth, white porcelain plate showcasing an artistic arrangement of various foods. A curled red beet slice forms an elegant wave across the plate's center. Accompanying elements include brown croutons, creamy dollops, small yellow cubes likely of mango, and scattered green herbs. Some beige roasted root vegetables are also visible, with a small pile of finely chopped nuts or grains near the front. The presentation is precise and balanced, with each element resting gracefully on the plate. Stylistically, the dish exhibits modernist culinary aesthetics, vibrant but soft color contrasts, and a serene, clean feel. High-key photography with soft, diffused lighting, a minimalistic and sophisticated tone. | 14377 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more balanced and artistic arrangement of the elements on the plate. The curled red beet slice forms an elegant wave across the center, and the accompanying elements, such as croutons, creamy dollops, yellow cubes, green herbs, roasted root vegetables, and finely chopped nuts, are well-distributed and visually harmonious. The right image, while clean and minimalist, lacks the same level of balance and precision in the arrangement, with elements appearing more scattered and less integrated into the composition. | left | Rearrange the elements to create a more balanced and artistic composition, ensuring the red beet slice forms an elegant wave across the center. Distribute the accompanying elements, such as croutons, creamy dollops, yellow cubes, green herbs, and nuts, more evenly and harmoniously across the plate. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a worn, orange leather dental chair with visible scratches, surrounded by dental tools with long, dangling hoses on the left and a sink with a mounted lamp on the right. The walls display an eclectic mix of objects, including an antique cabinet, a vintage clock, framed artwork, and dental implements, which enhance the nostalgic charm. The right image lacks the antique cabinet and has fewer dental tools with dangling hoses, making it less detailed and aligned with the prompt. Additionally, the lighting and textures in the left image better capture the whimsical and cozy atmosphere described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add an antique cabinet to the wall on the left side of the room. Increase the number of dental tools with long, dangling hoses on the left side of the chair."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49994_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49994_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Whimsical 3D-rendered scene of a vintage dental office with a retro aesthetic. Central focus is a worn, orange leather dental chair with visible scratches, positioned in the middle of a pastel mint green tiled room. The chair is surrounded by several dental tools featuring long, dangling hoses on the left and a sink with a mounted lamp on the right. The walls display an eclectic mix of objects: an antique cabinet, a vintage clock, framed artwork, and various dental implements hanging on hooks, adding to the nostalgic charm. Above, two small lamps provide soft ambient lighting. Two windows at the back, flanked by ruffled salmon-colored curtains, allow natural light to enhance the quirky and inviting atmosphere. The floor is a continuation of the tiled pattern, showing wear and tear, complementing the rustic vibe. Photo-realistic textures, warm lighting, pastel color palette, nostalgic, playful realism, highly detailed, cozy atmosphere. | 14380 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a worn, orange leather dental chair with visible scratches, surrounded by dental tools with long, dangling hoses on the left and a sink with a mounted lamp on the right. The walls display an eclectic mix of objects, including an antique cabinet, a vintage clock, framed artwork, and dental implements, which enhance the nostalgic charm. The right image lacks the antique cabinet and has fewer dental tools with dangling hoses, making it less detailed and aligned with the prompt. Additionally, the lighting and textures in the left image better capture the whimsical and cozy atmosphere described in the prompt. | left | Add an antique cabinet to the wall on the left side of the room. Increase the number of dental tools with long, dangling hoses on the left side of the chair. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a rugged rock formation with more visible textured layers and mossy patches, as well as a prominent vertical crack filled with pale light. The faint green glow is more pronounced, and the surrounding silhouetted trees frame the scene better. The sky in the left image has a more distinct orange-to-brown gradient with visible star trails, enhancing the atmospheric and mystical mood. The right image lacks sufficient texture on the rock surface, has a less prominent vertical crack, and the green glow is less vivid. Additionally, the trees in the right image are less defined and do not frame the scene as effectively.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the texture and detail on the rock surface, adding visible layers and mossy patches. Increase the brightness and prominence of the green glow in the vertical crack."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49995_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49995_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Nighttime long-exposure photograph of a large, rugged rock formation towering in the central foreground, illuminated with a faint green glow. The rock's surface displays textured layers and mossy patches, with a prominent vertical crack filled with a pale light. The sky in the background features an orange-to-brown gradient, likely from city light pollution, with subtle streaks indicative of star trails. Surrounding the rock, silhouetted trees with sparse foliage frame the scene on the left and right edges. Atmospheric, ethereal mood, high contrast, soft diffused lighting, natural textures, warm and cool color palette, otherworldly, mystical, serene. | 14381 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a rugged rock formation with more visible textured layers and mossy patches, as well as a prominent vertical crack filled with pale light. The faint green glow is more pronounced, and the surrounding silhouetted trees frame the scene better. The sky in the left image has a more distinct orange-to-brown gradient with visible star trails, enhancing the atmospheric and mystical mood. The right image lacks sufficient texture on the rock surface, has a less prominent vertical crack, and the green glow is less vivid. Additionally, the trees in the right image are less defined and do not frame the scene as effectively. | left | Enhance the texture and detail on the rock surface, adding visible layers and mossy patches. Increase the brightness and prominence of the green glow in the vertical crack. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a more complex and interwoven structure of metallic gold tubes, which aligns better with the prompt's description of an 'interwoven structure.' The ribbons in the left image curve dynamically and interact with the structure, creating a sense of movement, while the right image has a simpler, less interwoven structure and less dynamic ribbon placement. Additionally, the left image has a more balanced composition with scattered black spheres of varying sizes, whereas the right image lacks the same level of interaction and layering between elements.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the metallic gold structure more interwoven and complex. Adjust the placement of the black ribbons to curve more dynamically and interact with the structure and spheres."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49996_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49996_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Abstract digital artwork featuring a central, interwoven structure composed of reflective, metallic gold tubes with a polished surface, placed slightly off-center towards the lower right. The background is a textured, beige surface with scattered black speckles, adding depth and contrast. Thick, black, ribbon-like swirls curve dynamically across the composition, creating a sense of movement and flow. Shiny black spheres of varying sizes are interspersed throughout, some interacting with the ribbons, establishing a layered visual effect. The entire scene exhibits a high-gloss, surreal quality with stark contrasts. Digital art, abstract, polished metallic textures, dynamic curvilinear forms, high contrast, muted earth tones, glossy finish, modern, sophisticated, visually engaging, balanced composition. | 14382 | The left image features a more complex and interwoven structure of metallic gold tubes, which aligns better with the prompt's description of an 'interwoven structure.' The ribbons in the left image curve dynamically and interact with the structure, creating a sense of movement, while the right image has a simpler, less interwoven structure and less dynamic ribbon placement. Additionally, the left image has a more balanced composition with scattered black spheres of varying sizes, whereas the right image lacks the same level of interaction and layering between elements. | left | Make the metallic gold structure more interwoven and complex. Adjust the placement of the black ribbons to curve more dynamically and interact with the structure and spheres. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a deep blue background, a central black rectangle, and an abstract depiction of a diving figure in metallic gold positioned diagonally from the top left to the bottom right. The text 'Pablo Neruda' is centered at the top in light gold, and 'On the Blue Shore of Silence' is centered at the bottom, maintaining simplicity and balance. The right image deviates from the prompt as the figure is not in a diving pose but rather in a dynamic, acrobatic position, and the text placement is not as specified, with 'Pablo Neruda' and the subtitle both positioned at the top. The composition lacks the intended diagonal emphasis and balance.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the figure to depict a diving pose, extending diagonally from the top left to the bottom right. Reposition the text 'On the Blue Shore of Silence' to be centered at the bottom of the image."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49999_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49999_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Minimalist poster design, deep blue background with a central black rectangle, abstract depiction of a diving figure in metallic gold, positioned diagonally across the black rectangle, starting from the top left and extending to the bottom right. Geometric forms, resembling limbs and a head, create a stylized human figure. Text "Pablo Neruda" is centered at the top in a light gold, with "On the Blue Shore of Silence" centered at the bottom. Emphasis on simplicity and contrast, high contrast, minimalist art style, bold geometric lines, elegant and modern, striking use of color, balanced composition. | 14385 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a deep blue background, a central black rectangle, and an abstract depiction of a diving figure in metallic gold positioned diagonally from the top left to the bottom right. The text 'Pablo Neruda' is centered at the top in light gold, and 'On the Blue Shore of Silence' is centered at the bottom, maintaining simplicity and balance. The right image deviates from the prompt as the figure is not in a diving pose but rather in a dynamic, acrobatic position, and the text placement is not as specified, with 'Pablo Neruda' and the subtitle both positioned at the top. The composition lacks the intended diagonal emphasis and balance. | left | Adjust the figure to depict a diving pose, extending diagonally from the top left to the bottom right. Reposition the text 'On the Blue Shore of Silence' to be centered at the bottom of the image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a carbon fiber texture on the back of the phone, the 'carbon MOBILE' logo in white, and a dual-camera setup with an LED flash in the upper left. The phone is positioned diagonally, and the bottom edge is partially visible with subtle branding text. The 'Red Dot Winner 2021' logo is present in the lower left. The right image lacks the carbon fiber texture, has a different camera setup, and the phone's bottom edge is not visible. Additionally, the 'Red Dot Winner 2021' logo is misplaced and larger than required.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a carbon fiber texture to the back of the phone. Adjust the camera setup to a dual-camera with an LED flash in the upper left."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49997_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49997_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Sleek product photograph of a Carbon Mobile smartphone set against a dark gradient background. The phone is positioned diagonally, showing the back side with a carbon fiber texture and the "carbon MOBILE" logo in white. In the upper left, there is a dual-camera setup with an LED flash adjacent to it. The phone's bottom edge is partially visible, displaying subtle branding text. To the lower left of the image, the "Red Dot Winner 2021" logo and text are present in red and black. High contrast, minimalist composition, glossy texture, monochromatic color palette, professional product photography, sharp focus, luxury appeal, modern design. | 14383 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a carbon fiber texture on the back of the phone, the 'carbon MOBILE' logo in white, and a dual-camera setup with an LED flash in the upper left. The phone is positioned diagonally, and the bottom edge is partially visible with subtle branding text. The 'Red Dot Winner 2021' logo is present in the lower left. The right image lacks the carbon fiber texture, has a different camera setup, and the phone's bottom edge is not visible. Additionally, the 'Red Dot Winner 2021' logo is misplaced and larger than required. | left | Add a carbon fiber texture to the back of the phone. Adjust the camera setup to a dual-camera with an LED flash in the upper left. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a bear holding a polka-dotted mug slightly off-center, a squirrel in the left foreground engaging with another creature, and a bird with a red breast and yellow plumage under the table. The table is laden with colorful dishes, including red and green apples and a striped blue bowl. The background includes a dreamy mix of tree patterns and swirling leaf motifs. The right image lacks the bird with a red breast and yellow plumage under the table, and the squirrel in the left foreground is not engaging with another creature. Additionally, the right image does not include a striped blue bowl on the table, and the background is less whimsical and lacks swirling leaf motifs.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a bird with a red breast and yellow plumage under the table. Include a striped blue bowl on the table among the dishes."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49998_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49998_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Whimsical illustration of an animal gathering around a rustic table in a cozy woodland setting. The scene features a variety of anthropomorphic woodland creatures including squirrels, owls, and hedgehogs. They are seated and standing around a long table laden with colorful dishes of fruits and nuts. Dominant figures include a bear holding a polka-dotted mug located slightly off-center and a squirrel in the left foreground engaging with another creature. The table stretches across the midground, offering an array of vibrant food items including red and green apples and a striped blue bowl. Behind the table, a charming mix of tree patterns and colored leaves create a dreamy backdrop, with swirling leaf motifs on the ground. A small bird with a red breast and yellow plumage perches under the table, adding to the lively atmosphere. Delicate watercolor technique, earthy and pastel color palette, soft textures, vibrant yet harmonious, naturalistic fantasy, whimsical and inviting, imaginative and playful composition. | 14384 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a bear holding a polka-dotted mug slightly off-center, a squirrel in the left foreground engaging with another creature, and a bird with a red breast and yellow plumage under the table. The table is laden with colorful dishes, including red and green apples and a striped blue bowl. The background includes a dreamy mix of tree patterns and swirling leaf motifs. The right image lacks the bird with a red breast and yellow plumage under the table, and the squirrel in the left foreground is not engaging with another creature. Additionally, the right image does not include a striped blue bowl on the table, and the background is less whimsical and lacks swirling leaf motifs. | left | Add a bird with a red breast and yellow plumage under the table. Include a striped blue bowl on the table among the dishes. |
Subsets and Splits