success
bool 1
class | result
stringlengths 202
1.67k
| good_image
stringlengths 89
286
| bad_image
stringlengths 89
286
| prompt
stringlengths 19
2.48k
| id
stringlengths 1
5
| analysis
stringlengths 119
1.45k
| better_image
stringclasses 3
values | instructions
stringlengths 0
440
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the young woman centered in the frame, wearing the specified light blue textured coat, matching knee-high fishnet socks, and blue heels. The cream-colored French doors with arched transoms are visible on the right, and the intricate white latticework is present on the left. The patterned carpet in muted earth tones is also included, and the lighting is soft and natural, creating an airy and elegant feel. In contrast, the right image has the woman slightly off-center, lacks the fishnet socks, and the lighting is less soft, making the overall composition less visually balanced and elegant.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Center the woman in the frame. Replace the plain socks with knee-high fishnet socks matching the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49637_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49637_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Fashion photograph of a young woman standing in an ornate interior space, near cream-colored French doors on the right with arched transoms above. She is centered in the frame, wearing a light blue, textured coat that reaches mid-thigh and matching knee-high fishnet socks with blue heels. Her hair is styled in soft waves, and her makeup features a subtle pink eyeshadow. The background includes intricate white latticework on the left and a patterned carpet in muted earth tones covering the floor. The lighting is soft and natural, highlighting the textures and colors, giving an airy and elegant feel. Fashion photography, medium depth of field, gentle lighting, pastel color palette, sophisticated, modern, visually balanced composition. | 14036 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the young woman centered in the frame, wearing the specified light blue textured coat, matching knee-high fishnet socks, and blue heels. The cream-colored French doors with arched transoms are visible on the right, and the intricate white latticework is present on the left. The patterned carpet in muted earth tones is also included, and the lighting is soft and natural, creating an airy and elegant feel. In contrast, the right image has the woman slightly off-center, lacks the fishnet socks, and the lighting is less soft, making the overall composition less visually balanced and elegant. | left | Center the woman in the frame. Replace the plain socks with knee-high fishnet socks matching the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a starry nightscape with a mountainous landscape, the Milky Way, and a river valley filled with orange-tinted fog. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it has a more expansive and densely packed starry sky, creating a stronger celestial display. The right image has fewer visible stars, making the sky appear less dramatic. Additionally, the left image has a sharper and more defined silhouette of trees in the foreground, enhancing the framing of the scene.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the density of stars in the sky to create a more expansive celestial display. Sharpen the silhouette of trees and shrubs in the foreground for better framing."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49643_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49643_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Starry nightscape of a mountainous landscape featuring the Milky Way, spanning the upper portion of the image with countless stars densely packed in the deep blue sky. Foreground includes a dark silhouette of trees and shrubs at the bottom, framing the scene. Below the mountain peaks, a river valley is filled with orange-tinted fog or low-lying clouds, likely illuminated from below, cutting through the center of the composition. Snow-capped peaks form the backdrop, creating a dramatic contrast with the night sky. The valley is dotted with clusters of warm lights, possibly indicating a town or village, glowing amidst the fog. Photorealistic landscape, long exposure, high contrast, ethereal atmosphere, natural lighting, sharp focus, vast sense of scale, serene and awe-inspiring, expansive celestial display, dark and cool color palette with warm highlights from the lights, vast and majestic. | 14041 | Both images depict a starry nightscape with a mountainous landscape, the Milky Way, and a river valley filled with orange-tinted fog. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it has a more expansive and densely packed starry sky, creating a stronger celestial display. The right image has fewer visible stars, making the sky appear less dramatic. Additionally, the left image has a sharper and more defined silhouette of trees in the foreground, enhancing the framing of the scene. | left | Increase the density of stars in the sky to create a more expansive celestial display. Sharpen the silhouette of trees and shrubs in the foreground for better framing. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the pink ribbons being extended from the hand, which is a key detail in the description. The right image lacks the pink ribbons and the floral pillow covers on the lower bunk are not as vibrant or detailed as described. Additionally, the left image has a more whimsical and playful expression, which matches the prompt better.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add pink ribbons extending from the hand of the person on the top bunk. Enhance the vibrancy and detail of the floral pillow covers on the lower bunk to match the description."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49640_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49640_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | A whimsical portrait of a person dressed in colorful and playful attire, lying on a bright yellow bunk bed. Positioned horizontally on the top bunk, they are reaching down towards the lower bed, extending a hand with pink ribbons. The individual wears a vibrant pink satin robe and a floral hat adorned with pink feathers, with long blonde hair flowing out. Their face is framed by soft curls, and they exude a playful yet introspective expression. Yellow and multicolored feather boas drape alongside them. The background features a white wall on the left and a vivid yellow wall on the right, contrasting with the bold pink bedsheets and floral pillow covers on the lower bunk. The color palette is dominated by bright, cheerful tones. High-key lighting, sharp focus, playful and eclectic, saturated colors, harmonious composition, bold contrasts, studio photography feel. | 14039 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the pink ribbons being extended from the hand, which is a key detail in the description. The right image lacks the pink ribbons and the floral pillow covers on the lower bunk are not as vibrant or detailed as described. Additionally, the left image has a more whimsical and playful expression, which matches the prompt better. | left | Add pink ribbons extending from the hand of the person on the top bunk. Enhance the vibrancy and detail of the floral pillow covers on the lower bunk to match the description. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a group of people in a train station interacting with a ticket vending machine, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. In the left image, the person in the foreground to the right is correctly depicted wearing a blue top and yellow skirt, holding a brown handbag and a contactless card emitting payment waves. The central figures, including the person in red attire with curly yellow hair holding cash and the person in yellow pants with a tan sweater and scarf interacting with the ticket machine displaying a warning symbol, are accurately represented. The right image, however, incorrectly places the person in the blue top and yellow skirt at the vending machine instead of in the foreground, and the payment waves are missing. Additionally, the tiled floor and deep blue background are more prominent in the left image, matching the prompt better.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Move the person in the blue top and yellow skirt holding a brown handbag to the foreground on the right. Add payment waves emitting from the contactless card held by this person."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49642_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49642_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Vibrant digital illustration of a diverse group of people in a train station, queueing in front of a ticket vending machine. The scene is brightly colored with flat, bold shapes. In the foreground to the right, a person in a blue top and yellow skirt holds a brown handbag and a contactless card emitting payment waves. To the left, a person wearing a pink top and blue cap with an orange backpack stands facing away. Central figures include a person in red attire with curly yellow hair holding cash, another in yellow pants with a tan sweater and scarf interacting with the ticket machine displaying a warning symbol, and a person in a green sweater with a grey backpack holding a phone. They stand on a tiled floor under a deep blue background. Illustration style, flat design, high contrast, simplified forms, vivid color palette, stylized characters, static composition. | 14040 | Both images depict a group of people in a train station interacting with a ticket vending machine, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. In the left image, the person in the foreground to the right is correctly depicted wearing a blue top and yellow skirt, holding a brown handbag and a contactless card emitting payment waves. The central figures, including the person in red attire with curly yellow hair holding cash and the person in yellow pants with a tan sweater and scarf interacting with the ticket machine displaying a warning symbol, are accurately represented. The right image, however, incorrectly places the person in the blue top and yellow skirt at the vending machine instead of in the foreground, and the payment waves are missing. Additionally, the tiled floor and deep blue background are more prominent in the left image, matching the prompt better. | left | Move the person in the blue top and yellow skirt holding a brown handbag to the foreground on the right. Add payment waves emitting from the contactless card held by this person. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features four women lying on their backs with legs raised vertically against a pale pink backdrop. Each woman wears different colored socks as specified: polka dot on the far left, black with pink polka dots next, solid pink socks, and beige polka dot socks on the far right. The women are closely positioned side by side, covering their torsos with their arms, creating a symmetrical visual effect. The right image, however, has inconsistencies in the sock patterns and colors, with all socks featuring polka dots, and the specified diversity in sock designs is missing.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the socks to match the specified designs: polka dot on the far left, black with pink polka dots next, solid pink socks, and beige polka dot socks on the far right. Adjust the women's arm positions to cover their torsos for a symmetrical visual effect."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49639_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49639_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Minimalist photograph featuring four women lying on their backs with legs raised vertically against a pale pink backdrop. Each woman wears different colored socks: polka dot on the far left, black with pink polka dots next, solid pink socks, and finally beige polka dot socks on the far right. The women are closely positioned side by side, covering their torsos with their arms, creating a symmetrical visual effect. The floor and wall seamlessly blend in the same muted tone, enhancing the clean aesthetic. The women's diverse skin tones and hair types add a soft contrast to the serene and unified composition. Soft natural lighting, warm color palette, balanced framing, minimalistic, tranquil mood, fine art photography, emphasis on texture and form, harmonious, simple setting. | 14038 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features four women lying on their backs with legs raised vertically against a pale pink backdrop. Each woman wears different colored socks as specified: polka dot on the far left, black with pink polka dots next, solid pink socks, and beige polka dot socks on the far right. The women are closely positioned side by side, covering their torsos with their arms, creating a symmetrical visual effect. The right image, however, has inconsistencies in the sock patterns and colors, with all socks featuring polka dots, and the specified diversity in sock designs is missing. | left | Change the socks to match the specified designs: polka dot on the far left, black with pink polka dots next, solid pink socks, and beige polka dot socks on the far right. Adjust the women's arm positions to cover their torsos for a symmetrical visual effect. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image depicts a complete metallic torus with evenly spaced holes, positioned centrally against a black background, fulfilling the prompt's requirements for symmetry, isolation, and focus. The right image, however, shows an incomplete torus with a gap, breaking the symmetry and the sense of isolation described in the prompt. Both images exhibit a polished, reflective surface and high contrast, but the right image fails to meet the prompt's requirement for a complete torus structure.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Close the gap in the torus to make it a complete circular structure. Ensure the torus remains centrally positioned and symmetrical with evenly spaced holes."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49644_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49644_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Digital rendering of a metallic torus with evenly spaced holes, positioned centrally against a solid black background. The structure exhibits a polished, reflective surface with shades of silvery-grey, casting subtle highlights and shadows that accentuate the curvature. The torus's interior is visible through the holes, enhancing the three-dimensional appearance. It is nested in the center of the composition, surrounded by a void of darkness, creating a sense of isolation and focus. High contrast, photorealistic, crisp edges, smooth gradients, minimalistic, futuristic, symmetrical, abstract, glossy texture. | 14042 | The left image depicts a complete metallic torus with evenly spaced holes, positioned centrally against a black background, fulfilling the prompt's requirements for symmetry, isolation, and focus. The right image, however, shows an incomplete torus with a gap, breaking the symmetry and the sense of isolation described in the prompt. Both images exhibit a polished, reflective surface and high contrast, but the right image fails to meet the prompt's requirement for a complete torus structure. | left | Close the gap in the torus to make it a complete circular structure. Ensure the torus remains centrally positioned and symmetrical with evenly spaced holes. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has a white card with black text and Arabic text, but the text 'The Power of Dream' is missing, and the geometric black lines do not create rectangular sections. The black card has 'SIADA' in a grid format, but the letters are not aligned as described in the prompt. The right image has the correct text 'The Power of Dream' on the white card with geometric black lines forming rectangular sections, and the black card has 'SIADA' arranged in a grid format, matching the prompt more closely.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add the text 'The Power of Dream' to the white card and adjust the geometric black lines to create rectangular sections. Rearrange the letters on the black card to form a grid format with 'SIADA'."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49645_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49645_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Minimalistic product photography of two vertical business cards against a soft beige and black background. The left card is white with black text including "The Power of Dream" and additional Arabic text, embellished with geometric black lines creating rectangular sections. The right card is solid black with the letters "SIADA" in white, arranged in a grid format. Both cards are propped slightly back and create a clean, modern composition with strong linear design elements. High contrast, sleek aesthetic, sharp focus, neutral tones, professional, elegant, visually balanced, contemporary design. | 14043 | The left image has a white card with black text and Arabic text, but the text 'The Power of Dream' is missing, and the geometric black lines do not create rectangular sections. The black card has 'SIADA' in a grid format, but the letters are not aligned as described in the prompt. The right image has the correct text 'The Power of Dream' on the white card with geometric black lines forming rectangular sections, and the black card has 'SIADA' arranged in a grid format, matching the prompt more closely. | right | Add the text 'The Power of Dream' to the white card and adjust the geometric black lines to create rectangular sections. Rearrange the letters on the black card to form a grid format with 'SIADA'. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a large rectangular wooden table centered and surrounded by chairs with woven backrests, positioned slightly slanted to the right. The stainless steel outdoor grill is recessed into a countertop against a cream-colored, textured, tall wall, with potted plants including broad-leafed ferns on the countertop. The tall green trees are visible above and behind the wall, casting soft shadows. The foreground includes small white flowers and green shrubs framing the scene. The right image has a table that is not slanted, lacks woven backrests on the chairs, and has an excessive number of chairs. Additionally, the potted plants on the countertop are not broad-leafed ferns, and the overall layout is less minimalistic and serene.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reduce the number of chairs around the table to match the prompt. Replace the potted plants on the countertop with broad-leafed ferns."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49647_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49647_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Outdoor patio scene featuring a large rectangular wooden table centered and surrounded by chairs with woven backrests, positioned slightly slanted to the right, on a wooden deck. A glass vase with greenery is placed on the table. To the right, there are cushions on seats and a bench, indicating a lounge area. On the left side, a stainless steel outdoor grill is recessed into a countertop against a cream-colored, textured, tall wall. Potted plants, including broad-leafed ferns, sit on the countertop. Tall green trees are visible above and behind the wall, casting soft shadows on it. In the foreground, small white flowers and green shrubs frame the scene. The environment is minimalistic and serene. Architectural visualization, photorealistic rendering, high detail, soft natural lighting, warm earthy color palette, modern design, tranquil atmosphere, lush greenery, clean, organized layout, balanced composition. | 14044 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a large rectangular wooden table centered and surrounded by chairs with woven backrests, positioned slightly slanted to the right. The stainless steel outdoor grill is recessed into a countertop against a cream-colored, textured, tall wall, with potted plants including broad-leafed ferns on the countertop. The tall green trees are visible above and behind the wall, casting soft shadows. The foreground includes small white flowers and green shrubs framing the scene. The right image has a table that is not slanted, lacks woven backrests on the chairs, and has an excessive number of chairs. Additionally, the potted plants on the countertop are not broad-leafed ferns, and the overall layout is less minimalistic and serene. | left | Reduce the number of chairs around the table to match the prompt. Replace the potted plants on the countertop with broad-leafed ferns. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a black, rectangular device with a purple label, suspended in mid-air, surrounded by levitating dark gray rocks. The device is centrally positioned and standing upright, as specified. The white ping pong ball with 'STIGA' and three stars is correctly placed to the bottom right. The background gradient transitions from light to deep purple, and the lighting highlights the texture of the rocks, creating sharp contrasts. The right image, while similar, has a device that is not rectangular but more square-like, and the purple label is positioned differently. Additionally, the device is not standing upright, which deviates from the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the device rectangular and ensure it stands upright. Adjust the position of the purple label to align vertically on the device's front face."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49648_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49648_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Digital 3D rendering of a black, rectangular device with a purple label suspended in mid-air, surrounded by levitating pieces of dark gray rock. The device is centrally positioned, standing upright among the jagged stones. To the bottom right, there is a white ping pong ball with "STIGA" and three stars printed in black. The background features a gradient sky transitioning from light to deep purple, adding a sense of depth and dynamism to the composition. Dramatic lighting highlights the texture of the rocks, creating sharp contrasts. The scene is characterized by a surreal, otherworldly atmosphere with a focus on textures and form. Futuristic, high contrast, ethereal, and minimalist design. | 14045 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a black, rectangular device with a purple label, suspended in mid-air, surrounded by levitating dark gray rocks. The device is centrally positioned and standing upright, as specified. The white ping pong ball with 'STIGA' and three stars is correctly placed to the bottom right. The background gradient transitions from light to deep purple, and the lighting highlights the texture of the rocks, creating sharp contrasts. The right image, while similar, has a device that is not rectangular but more square-like, and the purple label is positioned differently. Additionally, the device is not standing upright, which deviates from the prompt. | left | Make the device rectangular and ensure it stands upright. Adjust the position of the purple label to align vertically on the device's front face. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a dancer in mid-air with arms outstretched, wearing the specified attire, and positioned in the center of the frame. The reflective floor, red curtains, and stained glass windows are present, and the lighting creates a dramatic and moody atmosphere. The right image, while similar, has a less detailed depiction of the stained glass windows, lacks the intricate patterns and vibrant colors, and the lighting is less dramatic, reducing the ethereal quality. Additionally, the dancer's silhouette in the right image obscures details of the attire and facial orientation, which are clearer in the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the stained glass windows with intricate patterns and vibrant red, blue, and gold hues. Adjust the lighting to create a more dramatic and moody atmosphere with high contrast and ethereal quality."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49649_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49649_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Eerie, dramatic photograph of a dancer mid-air in a gothic-style church interior. The dancer, wearing a black sweatshirt, shorts, leggings, and white sneakers, is levitating slightly off the ground with arms outstretched in the center of the frame. He faces forward, standing on a reflective, marble-like floor that captures the soft light. Behind him, rich red curtains hang from floor to ceiling, contrasting with the dark ambiance. The upper background showcases large, arched stained glass windows with intricate patterns of red, blue, and gold hues, casting dim light into the space. The church walls are composed of dark bricks, adding to the historical and reverent atmosphere. Dramatic lighting casts moody shadows, a mix of dark and cool tones, high contrast, ethereal quality, surreal, solemn, majestic setting, visually balanced composition. | 14046 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a dancer in mid-air with arms outstretched, wearing the specified attire, and positioned in the center of the frame. The reflective floor, red curtains, and stained glass windows are present, and the lighting creates a dramatic and moody atmosphere. The right image, while similar, has a less detailed depiction of the stained glass windows, lacks the intricate patterns and vibrant colors, and the lighting is less dramatic, reducing the ethereal quality. Additionally, the dancer's silhouette in the right image obscures details of the attire and facial orientation, which are clearer in the left image. | left | Enhance the stained glass windows with intricate patterns and vibrant red, blue, and gold hues. Adjust the lighting to create a more dramatic and moody atmosphere with high contrast and ethereal quality. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a stylized side profile of a person facing left, with vibrant psychedelic patterns on the face, green wavy hair with red and pink foliage-like shapes, and a prominent purple and pink flower emerging from the neck area. The background is mustard yellow, and the composition includes cubist elements with flat, interlocking shapes. The right image, while colorful, has a less prominent floral motif on the neck, lacks the yellow and red geometric cheek designs, and includes an unnecessary blue sphere in the background, which is not mentioned in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a prominent purple and pink flower emerging from the neck area. Remove the blue sphere from the background."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49650_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49650_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Colorful digital illustration depicting a stylized side profile of a person against a bold, mustard yellow background. The person is facing left, featuring an elaborate integration of vibrant colors and abstract shapes. The face is adorned with psychedelic patterns, including pink, blue, purple, and green hues. The hair is represented with green wavy patterns and accented with red and pink foliage-like shapes. The cheeks have yellow and red geometric designs with decorative elements. Abstract floral motifs, including a prominent purple and pink flower, emerge from the neck area. A branching orange leaf design extends from the top right, overlapping the background. The style is reminiscent of cubism with its use of flat, interlocking shapes and stark contrasts. The illustration exhibits vibrant color palette, flat graphic design, abstract aesthetic, expressive, dynamic, and visually engaging composition. | 14047 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a stylized side profile of a person facing left, with vibrant psychedelic patterns on the face, green wavy hair with red and pink foliage-like shapes, and a prominent purple and pink flower emerging from the neck area. The background is mustard yellow, and the composition includes cubist elements with flat, interlocking shapes. The right image, while colorful, has a less prominent floral motif on the neck, lacks the yellow and red geometric cheek designs, and includes an unnecessary blue sphere in the background, which is not mentioned in the prompt. | left | Add a prominent purple and pink flower emerging from the neck area. Remove the blue sphere from the background. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image aligns better with the prompt. It features a hand model holding a twig with green serrated leaves, a textured silver ring on the middle finger, and a soft-focus greenery background. The hexagonal logos in muted colors are correctly placed in the top left corner. The right image has a twig with fewer leaves, lacks the organic serrated leaf detail, and the logos in the top left corner are replaced with a different set of hexagonal shapes. Additionally, the studio shot on the right side of the right image has four rings instead of three, and the logos in the bottom right corner are missing.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add green serrated leaves to the twig held by the hand. Replace the four rings in the studio shot with three rings, ensuring each has a unique wrap design and a raw, handcrafted surface."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49651_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49651_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Split image showing a nature-inspired product shoot. On the left, a hand model's hand is in the foreground, fingers gently curled around a slender twig with green serrated leaves. The hand displays a textured silver ring on the middle finger, hinting at an organic design. In the background, there's a soft-focus greenery, creating a natural backdrop. The top left corner contains two hexagonal logos in muted colors. On the right, a minimalist studio shot features three silver rings, lined up evenly against a white background. Each ring has a unique wrap design, exhibiting a raw, handcrafted surface. The bottom right corner mirrors the hexagonal logos, maintaining branding consistency. Photography employs a shallow depth of field, natural lighting on the left, studio lighting on the right, earthy and neutral tones, balanced composition, tactile textures, stylish juxtaposition of organic element with contemporary product display. | 14048 | The left image aligns better with the prompt. It features a hand model holding a twig with green serrated leaves, a textured silver ring on the middle finger, and a soft-focus greenery background. The hexagonal logos in muted colors are correctly placed in the top left corner. The right image has a twig with fewer leaves, lacks the organic serrated leaf detail, and the logos in the top left corner are replaced with a different set of hexagonal shapes. Additionally, the studio shot on the right side of the right image has four rings instead of three, and the logos in the bottom right corner are missing. | left | Add green serrated leaves to the twig held by the hand. Replace the four rings in the studio shot with three rings, ensuring each has a unique wrap design and a raw, handcrafted surface. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. The left image features the toys in the correct positions and proportions, with the smaller figure sitting and the larger elephant standing upright. The background and lighting are consistent with the description. In the right image, the smaller figure is sitting correctly, but the larger elephant is also sitting instead of standing upright, which deviates from the prompt. Additionally, the proportions of the toys in the right image appear slightly off, with the smaller figure looking larger relative to the elephant.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the larger elephant figure stand upright. Adjust the proportions so the smaller figure appears smaller relative to the elephant."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49653_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49653_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Two toy figures placed on a textured, gray concrete ledge against a worn, white horizontal plank background. The left toy is a small, stylized figure with a round face resembling a cartoon character, featuring a yellow shirt, black hair, whisker-like facial lines, and large glasses. The right toy is larger, resembling a blue elephant with oversized ears, wearing red and white, featuring a helicopter hat and a circular nose. The elephant figurine has white accents and star-like patterns on its ears. Both toys are positioned side by side, the smaller one sitting and the larger one standing upright. Bright daylight casts soft shadows, highlighting the playful and vibrant yet simplistic and clean aesthetic of the toys. The overall palette is vibrant but balanced by muted, worn textures in the background. Photography, natural lighting, high color contrast, smooth plastic texture, playful, whimsical, visually balanced. | 14050 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. The left image features the toys in the correct positions and proportions, with the smaller figure sitting and the larger elephant standing upright. The background and lighting are consistent with the description. In the right image, the smaller figure is sitting correctly, but the larger elephant is also sitting instead of standing upright, which deviates from the prompt. Additionally, the proportions of the toys in the right image appear slightly off, with the smaller figure looking larger relative to the elephant. | left | Make the larger elephant figure stand upright. Adjust the proportions so the smaller figure appears smaller relative to the elephant. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more dynamic composition with a curved, futuristic interface prominently displaying the photograph. The photograph includes a group of men in a tense confrontation, with warm yellows and cool blues creating a high-contrast cinematic effect. The glowing lens flares and subtle motion blur enhance the sense of movement and depth. The right image lacks the same level of dynamic composition, as the photograph appears less central and the interface design is less prominent. Additionally, the lighting and color contrast are less vibrant in the right image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the photograph more central and prominent within the curved interface. Enhance the lighting contrast by intensifying the warm yellows and cool blues for a more cinematic effect."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49652_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49652_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Dynamic digital composition featuring a series of overlapping translucent screens displaying a photograph of a group of men in a tense street confrontation. The central photo is inset into a curved, futuristic interface. The original photograph shows around eight men; some are engaged in a struggle, while others appear to be observers, set against a backdrop of a gritty urban location with metal shutters. Surrounding the photograph are abstract reflections and distortions created by the digital interface. On the right, partially visible text elements suggest a news or documentary context. The overall color scheme includes warm yellows from the photograph and cool blues from the digital screen, creating a high-contrast cinematic effect. Glowing lens flares and subtle motion blur add a sense of movement and depth. High-tech, digital rendering, dynamic composition, contrast between analog and digital worlds, sleek interfaces, vibrant lighting effects, visual storytelling. | 14049 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a more dynamic composition with a curved, futuristic interface prominently displaying the photograph. The photograph includes a group of men in a tense confrontation, with warm yellows and cool blues creating a high-contrast cinematic effect. The glowing lens flares and subtle motion blur enhance the sense of movement and depth. The right image lacks the same level of dynamic composition, as the photograph appears less central and the interface design is less prominent. Additionally, the lighting and color contrast are less vibrant in the right image. | left | Make the photograph more central and prominent within the curved interface. Enhance the lighting contrast by intensifying the warm yellows and cool blues for a more cinematic effect. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the reflective glass surface in the lower right corner with horizontal stripes, a sharp vertical seam where light cuts through, and abstract beige forms resembling stairs in the background. The right image lacks the reflective glass surface with horizontal stripes and does not emphasize the sharp vertical seam as effectively.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a reflective glass surface in the lower right corner with horizontal stripes visible. Enhance the sharp vertical seam where light cuts through to create a more dramatic focal point."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49654_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49654_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Architectural photograph showcasing a minimalist interior space with smooth, flowing curves and sharp angles. The room is defined by its towering walls of soft beige concrete, meeting at a sharp vertical seam where light cuts through the space from above, creating a dramatic focal point. In the lower right corner, a reflective glass surface is present, partially revealing a series of horizontal stripes that add subtle texture to the composition. In the background, abstract beige forms resembling stairs are neatly aligned against the wall. The lighting is ethereal and natural, casting soft shadows that enhance the tranquil and introspective ambiance. Monochromatic palette, high-key lighting, minimalistic, serene atmosphere, architectural elegance, smooth texture, refined geometry, modernist aesthetics, contemplative, spacious, peaceful. | 14051 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the reflective glass surface in the lower right corner with horizontal stripes, a sharp vertical seam where light cuts through, and abstract beige forms resembling stairs in the background. The right image lacks the reflective glass surface with horizontal stripes and does not emphasize the sharp vertical seam as effectively. | left | Add a reflective glass surface in the lower right corner with horizontal stripes visible. Enhance the sharp vertical seam where light cuts through to create a more dramatic focal point. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a close-up of a plush toy resembling a rabbit, partially in frame, with a textured, off-white fabric face, a single circular eye opening, and a pinkish-red nose. The glossy red elements are visible on the right, and the background is a vibrant gradient of orange and yellow. The lighting emphasizes the texture and creates a cozy atmosphere. The right image, while similar, shows a full bear plush toy rather than being partially in frame, and the eye openings are not circular. The lighting and background are also less vibrant and do not emphasize the texture as effectively.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Crop the image to show only part of the plush toy, focusing on its face and one eye. Adjust the lighting and background to create a more vibrant orange and yellow gradient with soft, vivid lighting."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49655_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49655_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Close-up photo of a plush toy resembling a bear or rabbit, partially in frame, with a focus on its textured, off-white fabric face and a single circular eye opening. A pinkish-red nose is centrally located on the mask. In the foreground, glossy red elements of the toy are visible on the right, creating a contrast with the fabric. The background is a vibrant gradient of orange and yellow, providing a warm, abstract backdrop. The lighting is soft but vivid, emphasizing the texture of the plush material and creating a shallow depth of field. The color palette is dominated by warm tones, with a tactile, cozy atmosphere. The image is whimsical and playful, with a focus on textures and colors. | 14052 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a close-up of a plush toy resembling a rabbit, partially in frame, with a textured, off-white fabric face, a single circular eye opening, and a pinkish-red nose. The glossy red elements are visible on the right, and the background is a vibrant gradient of orange and yellow. The lighting emphasizes the texture and creates a cozy atmosphere. The right image, while similar, shows a full bear plush toy rather than being partially in frame, and the eye openings are not circular. The lighting and background are also less vibrant and do not emphasize the texture as effectively. | left | Crop the image to show only part of the plush toy, focusing on its face and one eye. Adjust the lighting and background to create a more vibrant orange and yellow gradient with soft, vivid lighting. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a minimalist fish tattoo in a simple black line art style with distinct scales and fins. The tattoo is centrally positioned on the forearm, which is slightly angled to the left. The background includes a visible black fabric sleeve with white horizontal stripes, matching the description. The right image, while similar, has a tattoo with slightly less sharp and clean lines, and the forearm is less angled to the left. Additionally, the sleeve in the right image appears less prominent and does not fully match the prompt's description.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Sharpen the tattoo lines to make them cleaner and more defined. Adjust the angle of the forearm to tilt slightly more to the left."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49656_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49656_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Close-up photo of a minimalist fish tattoo on a person's forearm. The tattoo is positioned centrally on the skin, depicted in a simple black line art style, featuring a stylized fish with distinct scales and fins. The person's forearm is slightly angled to the left, with visible skin texture and a natural skin tone. In the background, part of the person's sleeve is visible to the left, in black fabric with white horizontal stripes. The environment is neutral with a light, soft focus. Minimalist design, sharp edges, high contrast, clean lines, simple composition, and natural lighting. | 14053 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a minimalist fish tattoo in a simple black line art style with distinct scales and fins. The tattoo is centrally positioned on the forearm, which is slightly angled to the left. The background includes a visible black fabric sleeve with white horizontal stripes, matching the description. The right image, while similar, has a tattoo with slightly less sharp and clean lines, and the forearm is less angled to the left. Additionally, the sleeve in the right image appears less prominent and does not fully match the prompt's description. | left | Sharpen the tattoo lines to make them cleaner and more defined. Adjust the angle of the forearm to tilt slightly more to the left. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It captures the triptych format with the woman in three distinct poses as described: leaning back with her hand on her forehead, sitting upright with a faint smile, and facing forward with her arm resting on a cushion. The environment includes soft fabrics, large pillows, and a blurred background with visible reflections of trees outside the window, creating depth. The right image, while similar, lacks the clear reflection of trees in the window and the ethereal, analog film style. Additionally, the lighting and shadows in the right image are harsher, reducing the soft, intimate mood described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add reflections of trees outside the window to enhance depth. Soften the lighting and shadows to create a more diffuse, ethereal feel."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49657_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49657_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Triptych black and white portrait series of a woman with long blonde hair, seated indoors, surrounded by diffuse light and soft fabrics. In the left image, she leans back and gazes directly at the camera, her left hand resting on her forehead, wearing a light-colored tank top. The middle image shows her sitting more upright, hands in her lap, with a faint smile, looking slightly to the side. In the right image, she faces forward, with her left arm resting on a plush cushion, a serene expression on her face. The environment includes large soft pillows, creating a cozy atmosphere, and there's a reflection of trees outside in the window behind her, adding depth. The background elements are blurred, focusing attention on the subject. High contrast, soft shadows, ethereal feel, artistic composition, analog film style, natural diffuse lighting, intimate mood, visually balanced. | 14054 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It captures the triptych format with the woman in three distinct poses as described: leaning back with her hand on her forehead, sitting upright with a faint smile, and facing forward with her arm resting on a cushion. The environment includes soft fabrics, large pillows, and a blurred background with visible reflections of trees outside the window, creating depth. The right image, while similar, lacks the clear reflection of trees in the window and the ethereal, analog film style. Additionally, the lighting and shadows in the right image are harsher, reducing the soft, intimate mood described in the prompt. | left | Add reflections of trees outside the window to enhance depth. Soften the lighting and shadows to create a more diffuse, ethereal feel. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image aligns better with the prompt as it features a consistent 4x5 grid format of full-length portraits of young adults against a dark, textured backdrop. The individuals are dressed in dark attire, with a mix of casual and formal styles, and the lighting emphasizes facial features and hair textures, creating a moody and cohesive aesthetic. The right image, while similar, has inconsistencies in the grid alignment, with some individuals appearing slightly misaligned or cropped, and the lighting is less uniform, reducing the overall cohesive and minimalist aesthetic described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Align all individuals in a consistent 4x5 grid format. Adjust the lighting to create a more uniform low-key effect with controlled highlights."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49658_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49658_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Composite image consisting of individual portraits arranged in a 4x5 grid format, featuring young adults against a dark, textured backdrop. Each individual is full-length, standing in various relaxed poses with subtle variations in expressions. The dark attire of the majority enhances the moody atmosphere, with some wearing casual tops and others dressed more formally, all opting for dark trousers and shoes. The overall lighting, low-key with controlled highlights, emphasizes subtle facial features and hair textures, projecting a serious, contemplative ambiance. The image's consistent composition and unified color palette of black and muted tones create a cohesive, minimalist aesthetic. Photographic style is intimate, with a focus on individual character within a formal and controlled environment. | 14055 | The left image aligns better with the prompt as it features a consistent 4x5 grid format of full-length portraits of young adults against a dark, textured backdrop. The individuals are dressed in dark attire, with a mix of casual and formal styles, and the lighting emphasizes facial features and hair textures, creating a moody and cohesive aesthetic. The right image, while similar, has inconsistencies in the grid alignment, with some individuals appearing slightly misaligned or cropped, and the lighting is less uniform, reducing the overall cohesive and minimalist aesthetic described in the prompt. | left | Align all individuals in a consistent 4x5 grid format. Adjust the lighting to create a more uniform low-key effect with controlled highlights. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a clear portrait of a stylized woman with dark hair and a red X across her face, surrounded by intricate red decorative lines. The black ink butterflies are well-integrated on the left side, and the skin texture and slight redness are visible. The right image lacks the connected series of black ink butterflies on the left side and has an additional female portrait that is not specified in the prompt. The decorative red elements are less intricate and do not match the description as closely.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a connected series of black ink butterflies on the left side of the composition. Remove the additional female portrait on the right side to focus on the main stylized woman with the red X across her face."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49661_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49661_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Tattoo art on human skin featuring a series of detailed black and red ink designs. Centered is the portrait of a stylized woman with dark hair and an X marked in red across her face, surrounded by intricate red decorative lines. To the right, another similar female portrait in black ink shows a woman with long hair. To the left, a connected series of black ink butterflies appears to be part of the overall composition against a black background. The skin is visible, showing natural texture and slight redness around the tattoos. Close-up shot, high contrast, distinct line work, contemporary tattoo style, elements of Japanese manga aesthetics, dramatic visual impact, sharp detail, mixed black and red color palette, personal and artistic expression. | 14056 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a clear portrait of a stylized woman with dark hair and a red X across her face, surrounded by intricate red decorative lines. The black ink butterflies are well-integrated on the left side, and the skin texture and slight redness are visible. The right image lacks the connected series of black ink butterflies on the left side and has an additional female portrait that is not specified in the prompt. The decorative red elements are less intricate and do not match the description as closely. | left | Add a connected series of black ink butterflies on the left side of the composition. Remove the additional female portrait on the right side to focus on the main stylized woman with the red X across her face. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has three perfume bottles, but the leftmost bottle lacks the frosted glass with vertical grooves and instead has a clear, grooved design. The central bottle is smooth and translucent blue but lacks the intricate ribbed texture on the metallic cap. The rightmost bottle has a deep blue glossy glass with distinct angles, but its cap is not consistent with the others. The right image better matches the prompt as it features the correct frosted glass with vertical grooves for the left bottle, consistent gold and black caps for all bottles, and better captures the intricate textures and reflective surfaces of the caps. Additionally, the arrangement and lighting in the right image align more closely with the prompt's luxurious and modern aesthetic.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Change the leftmost bottle to have frosted glass with vertical grooves and a metallic gold cap with black accents. Adjust the caps of all bottles to have consistent gold and black designs with intricate ribbed textures."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49662_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49662_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Close-up product photograph of three elegant perfume bottles set against a soft blue background. The bottles are creatively arranged, two in the foreground and one in the background. The left bottle features a frosted glass with vertical grooves and a metallic gold cap with black accents. The central bottle has a smooth, translucent blue glass body topped with a similarly designed gold and black cap. The rightmost bottle displays a deep blue, glossy glass with distinct angles, and its cap shares the design consistency with the others. The image captures the intricate textures of the metallic caps, highlighting their ribbed design and gleaming surfaces. Stylistic properties include high gloss, reflective surfaces, intricate textural detail, geometric elegance, and a modern, luxurious aesthetic. The composition is visually balanced with a calm, sophisticated color palette and excellent use of soft, diffused lighting, emphasizing the bottles' aesthetic appeal and creating a sense of elegance and refinement. | 14058 | The left image has three perfume bottles, but the leftmost bottle lacks the frosted glass with vertical grooves and instead has a clear, grooved design. The central bottle is smooth and translucent blue but lacks the intricate ribbed texture on the metallic cap. The rightmost bottle has a deep blue glossy glass with distinct angles, but its cap is not consistent with the others. The right image better matches the prompt as it features the correct frosted glass with vertical grooves for the left bottle, consistent gold and black caps for all bottles, and better captures the intricate textures and reflective surfaces of the caps. Additionally, the arrangement and lighting in the right image align more closely with the prompt's luxurious and modern aesthetic. | right | Change the leftmost bottle to have frosted glass with vertical grooves and a metallic gold cap with black accents. Adjust the caps of all bottles to have consistent gold and black designs with intricate ribbed textures. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a rural village in a mountainous landscape, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. The left image has a more cohesive clustering of tan and brick-colored houses with dark slate rooftops, following the curve of the dirt road. It also features tall trees framing the scene on the edges and a more natural integration of vegetation in the foreground. The right image has a less natural arrangement of houses, with some appearing too spaced out, and lacks the framing effect of tall trees on both edges.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Rearrange the houses to form a tighter cluster that follows the curve of the dirt road. Add tall trees to frame the scene on both the left and right edges."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49660_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49660_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Aerial view of a rural village nestled in a mountainous landscape. The village features a series of tan and brick-colored houses with dark slate rooftops, clustered together in the mid-ground, surrounded by dense greenery and terraced hillsides. The buildings are positioned following the curve of a narrow dirt road running through the village, with several people walking along it. In the foreground, a mixture of green and brown vegetation, with tall trees framing the scene on the right and left edges. The background consists of tiered hill terraces ascending towards the horizon, dotted with pine trees and telephone poles. Overhead, the sky is overcast with low-hanging clouds. Photo, medium depth of field, natural lighting, cool color palette, high contrast between the earth tones of the buildings and the lush greenery, serene, pastoral, visually balanced, expansive rural landscape. | 14057 | Both images depict a rural village in a mountainous landscape, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. The left image has a more cohesive clustering of tan and brick-colored houses with dark slate rooftops, following the curve of the dirt road. It also features tall trees framing the scene on the edges and a more natural integration of vegetation in the foreground. The right image has a less natural arrangement of houses, with some appearing too spaced out, and lacks the framing effect of tall trees on both edges. | left | Rearrange the houses to form a tighter cluster that follows the curve of the dirt road. Add tall trees to frame the scene on both the left and right edges. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a clear close-up of the woman's face with detailed emphasis on her skin texture and makeup. The coral-colored eyeshadow extends beyond her eyelids, and her glossy pink lips are slightly parted. The soft pink feather is delicately placed in the bottom foreground, touching her skin. The background is neutral and complements her skin tone. In contrast, the right image has a slightly less clear focus on the makeup details, and the feather is held in her hand rather than delicately placed, which reduces the tactile and ethereal quality described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Place the soft pink feather delicately in the bottom foreground, touching her skin. Adjust the focus to emphasize the makeup details, particularly the coral-colored eyeshadow extending beyond her eyelids."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49663_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49663_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Close-up portrait of a woman's face with detailed emphasis on her skin texture and makeup, featuring smooth, glowing skin and matte, coral-colored eyeshadow that extends beyond her eyelids. Her slightly parted, glossy pink lips are visible, with soft focus on her lower face. A delicate, soft pink feather is placed in the bottom foreground, touching her skin and adding a tactile element. Her hair is styled with loose curls framing her face. The background is a neutral, pale color that complements her skin tone. The overall mood is serene and ethereal, with a focus on femininity and softness. High-resolution beauty photography, shallow depth of field, soft natural lighting, pastel color palette, intimate, refined, minimalistic backdrop, focusing on texture and subtle details. | 14059 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a clear close-up of the woman's face with detailed emphasis on her skin texture and makeup. The coral-colored eyeshadow extends beyond her eyelids, and her glossy pink lips are slightly parted. The soft pink feather is delicately placed in the bottom foreground, touching her skin. The background is neutral and complements her skin tone. In contrast, the right image has a slightly less clear focus on the makeup details, and the feather is held in her hand rather than delicately placed, which reduces the tactile and ethereal quality described in the prompt. | left | Place the soft pink feather delicately in the bottom foreground, touching her skin. Adjust the focus to emphasize the makeup details, particularly the coral-colored eyeshadow extending beyond her eyelids. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a dramatic explosion with a large plume of thick black smoke rising from vibrant orange flames in the bottom right. The birds are flying dynamically above the smoke, and the rugged beige mountains are visible in the background under a clear blue sky. The foreground has sparse green shrubs scattered across sandy terrain, and the midday lighting creates distinct shadows. The right image, while similar, has the explosion and smoke spread horizontally, which reduces the dramatic vertical plume effect described in the prompt. Additionally, the birds are less dynamically positioned, and the explosion appears less vibrant and intense.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the explosion more vertically concentrated with a large plume of thick black smoke rising prominently. Adjust the birds' positions to create a more dynamic sense of motion above the smoke and flames."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49664_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49664_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Aerial photo of a natural desert environment with a dramatic explosion in the background. The foreground features sandy terrain with sparse green shrubs scattered throughout. In the middle ground, a group of birds, possibly ducks, are flying across the scene, positioned above a large plume of thick black smoke rising from a vibrant orange explosion at the bottom right. The background showcases a range of rugged, beige mountains under a clear blue sky. The harsh midday lighting casts distinct shadows, enhancing the arid and remote feel of the landscape. High contrast between the bright flames and the dark smoke, with a muted color palette of natural earth tones. Photographic realism, dynamic composition, sense of motion with the birds in flight against the smoke and flames. | 14060 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a dramatic explosion with a large plume of thick black smoke rising from vibrant orange flames in the bottom right. The birds are flying dynamically above the smoke, and the rugged beige mountains are visible in the background under a clear blue sky. The foreground has sparse green shrubs scattered across sandy terrain, and the midday lighting creates distinct shadows. The right image, while similar, has the explosion and smoke spread horizontally, which reduces the dramatic vertical plume effect described in the prompt. Additionally, the birds are less dynamically positioned, and the explosion appears less vibrant and intense. | left | Make the explosion more vertically concentrated with a large plume of thick black smoke rising prominently. Adjust the birds' positions to create a more dynamic sense of motion above the smoke and flames. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the correct placement of the white three-seater sofa against the pale gray wall, flanked by matching white armchairs. The sculptural coffee table in metallic silver is present with a small white vase and a single flower. The abstract wall art above the sofa consists of overlapping round wooden panels in blue and brown hues. The white plush carpet has a concentric circle pattern in brown and blue, and the large window reveals artistic bare tree sculptures. The right image has discrepancies: the wall art arrangement is incorrect, and the concentric circle pattern on the carpet is not as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Rearrange the wall art above the sofa to feature overlapping round wooden panels in blue and brown hues. Modify the carpet to display a white plush texture with concentric circles in brown and various shades of blue."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49665_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49665_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Modern interior design of a bright, minimalist living room with white furniture and decorative elements. The scene is centered on a white three-seater sofa against a pale gray wall, flanked by matching white armchairs on either side. In front of the left armchair is a unique, sculptural coffee table in metallic silver with a small white vase and a single flower. A white floor lamp with a fabric shade is placed next to the sofa on the right. Above the sofa, there are three abstract wall art pieces consisting of overlapping round wooden panels in blue and brown hues. The floor is covered in a white plush carpet featuring a distinctive pattern of concentric circles in brown and various shades of blue. A large window behind the sofa reveals a view of two artistic bare tree sculptures, adding an organic contrast to the sleek and modern decor. The overall environment is serene and sophisticated with a neutral color palette, clean lines, and a balanced composition. Interior design photography, high key lighting, contemporary style, visually balanced, seamless blend of natural and artistic elements, airy and spacious feel. | 14061 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the correct placement of the white three-seater sofa against the pale gray wall, flanked by matching white armchairs. The sculptural coffee table in metallic silver is present with a small white vase and a single flower. The abstract wall art above the sofa consists of overlapping round wooden panels in blue and brown hues. The white plush carpet has a concentric circle pattern in brown and blue, and the large window reveals artistic bare tree sculptures. The right image has discrepancies: the wall art arrangement is incorrect, and the concentric circle pattern on the carpet is not as described in the prompt. | left | Rearrange the wall art above the sofa to feature overlapping round wooden panels in blue and brown hues. Modify the carpet to display a white plush texture with concentric circles in brown and various shades of blue. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images align closely with the prompt, but the left image better matches the description. The left image has a more natural and balanced lighting that highlights the facial features and skin texture effectively. The hand placement and manicured nails are more prominent and elegant. The right image has slightly harsher lighting, which overemphasizes the reflective sheen on the skin, making it appear less natural. Additionally, the hand position in the right image is less graceful and slightly obscures the face.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Soften the lighting to reduce the overly reflective sheen on the skin. Adjust the hand position to make it more elegant and less obstructive to the face."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49667_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49667_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Close-up beauty portrait of a young woman with smooth, glowing skin, centered in the frame. Her hand gently rests near her chin, showcasing manicured nails. She has long, dark brown hair cascading downwards. Her makeup includes glossy nude lipstick and warm, subtle eyeshadow complementing her brown eyes. The background is a rich burgundy, creating a luxurious contrast with her complexion. Photographic, high-resolution detail, emphasis on skin texture and makeup, soft diffused lighting, warm color palette, glamorous, polished aesthetic, portrait photography, facial features are highlighted through strategic light placement, reflective sheen on lips and forehead, contemporary fashion and beauty style. | 14063 | Both images align closely with the prompt, but the left image better matches the description. The left image has a more natural and balanced lighting that highlights the facial features and skin texture effectively. The hand placement and manicured nails are more prominent and elegant. The right image has slightly harsher lighting, which overemphasizes the reflective sheen on the skin, making it appear less natural. Additionally, the hand position in the right image is less graceful and slightly obscures the face. | left | Soften the lighting to reduce the overly reflective sheen on the skin. Adjust the hand position to make it more elegant and less obstructive to the face. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a twilight street scene in a lively shopping district with traditional East Asian architectural elements. The left image has a more balanced and symmetrical composition, with the tree in the center dividing the scene and another tree partially framing the left foreground. The right image lacks the leafy tree in the left foreground, which diminishes the framing effect. Additionally, the left image has a more subtle and natural lighting atmosphere, while the right image's lighting appears harsher and less dynamic. The left image better captures the vibrant yet subtle color palette and the blending of traditional architecture with a bustling modern ambiance.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a leafy tree partially framing the left foreground. Adjust the lighting to create a softer, more natural evening ambiance with a subtle gradient sky."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49666_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49666_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Twilight street scene in a lively, open-air shopping district with traditional East Asian architectural elements. Two main buildings flank the frame: the left one features a wooden facade with warm, inviting window lighting, while the right showcases a building with a sign reading in illuminated characters under its gable roof. A crowd of people in blurred motion occupies the pedestrian space, indicating activity and movement. A tree with sparse leaves is centrally positioned, dividing the scene and adding vertical interest. To the left foreground, a leafy tree partially frames the image. Tables and umbrellas near the right building suggest outdoor seating, and another tree mirrors the left's position, adding symmetry. The background reveals more greenery and a beautifully gradient sky transitioning from blue to subtle hues of yellow and purple as night falls. Photography, long exposure, dynamic atmosphere, soft, natural evening lighting, symmetrical composition, vibrant yet subtle color palette, blending traditional architecture with a bustling modern ambiance. | 14062 | Both images depict a twilight street scene in a lively shopping district with traditional East Asian architectural elements. The left image has a more balanced and symmetrical composition, with the tree in the center dividing the scene and another tree partially framing the left foreground. The right image lacks the leafy tree in the left foreground, which diminishes the framing effect. Additionally, the left image has a more subtle and natural lighting atmosphere, while the right image's lighting appears harsher and less dynamic. The left image better captures the vibrant yet subtle color palette and the blending of traditional architecture with a bustling modern ambiance. | left | Add a leafy tree partially framing the left foreground. Adjust the lighting to create a softer, more natural evening ambiance with a subtle gradient sky. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features four sketches of the creature in different poses and angles, but the horns are not prominently blue, and the green, leaf-like textures are less detailed. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it showcases the creature with prominent blue-hued horns, detailed green, leaf-like textures, and a vibrant earthy color palette. Additionally, the right image includes a frontal view, a side profile, and a mid-roar pose, as described in the prompt. The logos and banner are also present in the right image, matching the prompt more closely.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Make the horns prominently blue. Add more detailed green, leaf-like textures to the creature's body."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49668_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49668_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Concept art of a fantasy creature from Disney's "Kizazi Moto: Generation Fire". The image features four sketches of the creature in different poses and angles against a white background. The creature is primarily orange with green, leaf-like textures covering parts of its body. It has prominent blue-hued horns on its head and large, pointed ears. In the upper left, a side profile displays its muscular physique and texture detail. The upper right shows a frontal view, emphasizing the facial features and horns. The lower right captures the creature mid-roar, showcasing an open mouth and expressive eyes. The overall style combines loose, expressive linework with watercolor-like coloring. The bottom banner includes logos for "Disney+", "triggerfish", and "girafics". Stylized, dynamic, fantasy illustration, vibrant earthy color palette, character design, sketchy outlines, animated concept art feel. | 14064 | The left image features four sketches of the creature in different poses and angles, but the horns are not prominently blue, and the green, leaf-like textures are less detailed. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it showcases the creature with prominent blue-hued horns, detailed green, leaf-like textures, and a vibrant earthy color palette. Additionally, the right image includes a frontal view, a side profile, and a mid-roar pose, as described in the prompt. The logos and banner are also present in the right image, matching the prompt more closely. | right | Make the horns prominently blue. Add more detailed green, leaf-like textures to the creature's body. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images align closely with the prompt, but the left image better emphasizes the raised collar partially covering the face, which draws more attention to the facial features. The right image has a slightly lower collar, reducing the intended effect. Additionally, the emerald ring in the left image appears more prominent and vibrant, as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Raise the collar slightly to partially cover the face. Enhance the vibrancy and prominence of the emerald ring's green stone."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49669_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49669_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Close-up portrait of a woman with brunette hair and green eyes wearing an elegant, satin beige coat. The coat's collar is raised, partially covering her face, drawing attention to her striking facial features. Her hand, adorned with a large, intricately designed emerald ring, is positioned near her chin. The ring is visually prominent with a vibrant green stone set in an ornate silver band. Her expression is confident and engaging. The background is a soft, neutral gray, adding to the focus on her face and the ring. Fashion photography, high contrast, soft studio lighting, photorealistic texture, glossy satin fabric, subtle color palette, refined and sophisticated mood. | 14065 | Both images align closely with the prompt, but the left image better emphasizes the raised collar partially covering the face, which draws more attention to the facial features. The right image has a slightly lower collar, reducing the intended effect. Additionally, the emerald ring in the left image appears more prominent and vibrant, as described in the prompt. | left | Raise the collar slightly to partially cover the face. Enhance the vibrancy and prominence of the emerald ring's green stone. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a more realistic and less abstract depiction of a sparrow, with smooth gradients and rounded shapes, but it lacks the intertwining geometric shapes and detailed linework described in the prompt. The right image aligns better with the prompt as it uses intertwining geometric shapes, subtle gradients in brown and beige tones, and detailed linework to create an abstract and modernist representation of the sparrow. Additionally, the right image captures the sense of movement and balance more effectively, with the tail curving upwards and the feather patterns flowing in repeated arcs.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Incorporate intertwining geometric shapes into the bird's body and feathers. Add detailed linework to emphasize the abstract and modernist style."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49670_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49670_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Abstract illustration of a sparrow profile. The stylized bird is composed of intertwining geometric shapes and subtle gradients in brown and beige tones, capturing the essence of a sparrow's features through elegant curves. The sparrow's head is centrally placed, with an abstract eye and pointed beak slightly leaning left. Feather patterns flow from the head toward the back in repeated arcs. The tail curves upwards. Below the image, "SPARROW" and "PASSER DOMESTICUS" are printed in a refined serif typeface. The overall composition rests on a textured, off-white background. The illustration is organic, minimalistic, and features detailed linework with a sense of movement and balance, channeling a modernist approach to natural subjects. | 14066 | The left image features a more realistic and less abstract depiction of a sparrow, with smooth gradients and rounded shapes, but it lacks the intertwining geometric shapes and detailed linework described in the prompt. The right image aligns better with the prompt as it uses intertwining geometric shapes, subtle gradients in brown and beige tones, and detailed linework to create an abstract and modernist representation of the sparrow. Additionally, the right image captures the sense of movement and balance more effectively, with the tail curving upwards and the feather patterns flowing in repeated arcs. | right | Incorporate intertwining geometric shapes into the bird's body and feathers. Add detailed linework to emphasize the abstract and modernist style. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a dirt-streaked, four-pane window with a dimly lit forest scene outside, showing muted oranges and greens in the background. The man in the blue jacket is positioned in the lower right pane, partially obscured by the window frame, as described. The dark, moody atmosphere and grainy texture are present, enhancing the suspenseful mood. The right image lacks the muted orange tones in the forest scene, and the lighting is brighter, reducing the dark, moody atmosphere. Additionally, the man in the blue jacket is not as partially obscured by the window frame, which diminishes the enigmatic element of the scene.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add muted orange tones to the forest scene outside to create a dimly lit, moody atmosphere. Partially obscure the man in the blue jacket with the window frame to enhance the enigmatic element."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49672_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49672_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | View through a dirt-streaked, four-pane window, showing a dimly lit forest scene outside. The window is centrally positioned, with each pane offering a slightly different view of the dark, shadowy trees against a backdrop of muted oranges and greens. In the lower right pane, a man in a blue jacket lies face down, partially obscured by the window frame, adding an enigmatic element to the scene. The image is dominated by a dark, moody atmosphere. Stylistic properties include strong contrast between the shadowy interior and the outside light, a grainy texture enhancing the film-like quality, and a somber, suspenseful mood. The use of natural lighting through the window, coupled with a muted color palette, reinforces the mysterious ambiance. The composition is balanced, with emphasis on the interplay between light, shadow, and the framed segments of the view. | 14068 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a dirt-streaked, four-pane window with a dimly lit forest scene outside, showing muted oranges and greens in the background. The man in the blue jacket is positioned in the lower right pane, partially obscured by the window frame, as described. The dark, moody atmosphere and grainy texture are present, enhancing the suspenseful mood. The right image lacks the muted orange tones in the forest scene, and the lighting is brighter, reducing the dark, moody atmosphere. Additionally, the man in the blue jacket is not as partially obscured by the window frame, which diminishes the enigmatic element of the scene. | left | Add muted orange tones to the forest scene outside to create a dimly lit, moody atmosphere. Partially obscure the man in the blue jacket with the window frame to enhance the enigmatic element. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict an industrial interior with large arched windows, exposed brick, and wooden ceilings. The left image better aligns with the prompt due to its more symmetrical composition, stronger contrast in the shadows, and a clearer view of the sunlit street and trees outside the windows. The right image has less dramatic shadows, a less symmetrical composition, and the view outside the windows is less defined.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the contrast of the shadows on the floor to make them more dramatic. Adjust the view outside the windows to make the sunlit street and trees more visible."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49671_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49671_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Interior photo of an industrial building with large, arched windows on the left side. The windows cast dramatic shadows on the concrete floor, creating a pattern of light and dark lines stretching across the room. The structure has an unfinished, rustic appearance with exposed brick and a wooden ceiling, visible in the upper part of the image. Outside the windows, a sunlit street with trees is partially visible. Warm sepia tone, high contrast, long shadows, photorealistic, moody atmosphere, natural lighting, symmetrical composition, cavernous space, muted color palette, nostalgic, cinematic, introspective. | 14067 | Both images depict an industrial interior with large arched windows, exposed brick, and wooden ceilings. The left image better aligns with the prompt due to its more symmetrical composition, stronger contrast in the shadows, and a clearer view of the sunlit street and trees outside the windows. The right image has less dramatic shadows, a less symmetrical composition, and the view outside the windows is less defined. | left | Increase the contrast of the shadows on the floor to make them more dramatic. Adjust the view outside the windows to make the sunlit street and trees more visible. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a blue anthropomorphic donkey with long ears, dressed in a light blue button-up shirt and dark blue pants with patches, black boots, and positioned centrally. The background includes stars and abstract white shapes, and the border has a colorful geometric pattern with triangles, circles, and star motifs in vibrant colors. The word 'DISFARCE' is in bold red text at the bottom. The right image has some inaccuracies: the donkey's shirt lacks buttons, the pants do not have patches, and the geometric border pattern is less vibrant and detailed compared to the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add buttons to the shirt of the donkey. Add patches to the pants of the donkey."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49673_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49673_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Whimsical illustration of a blue, anthropomorphic character with long ears representing a donkey, positioned centrally. The character is walking, dressed in a light blue button-up shirt and dark blue pants with patches, black boots. Stars and abstract white shapes float around on a blue background. The border features a colorful geometric pattern with triangles, circles, and star motifs in vibrant red, green, yellow, and blue colors. The word "DISFARCE" in bold red text is at the bottom. Flat, cartoonish style, bold and saturated color palette, playful and lively composition, simple, stylized forms, graphic elements, children’s book illustration vibe. | 14069 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a blue anthropomorphic donkey with long ears, dressed in a light blue button-up shirt and dark blue pants with patches, black boots, and positioned centrally. The background includes stars and abstract white shapes, and the border has a colorful geometric pattern with triangles, circles, and star motifs in vibrant colors. The word 'DISFARCE' is in bold red text at the bottom. The right image has some inaccuracies: the donkey's shirt lacks buttons, the pants do not have patches, and the geometric border pattern is less vibrant and detailed compared to the left image. | left | Add buttons to the shirt of the donkey. Add patches to the pants of the donkey. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the pensive expression, tousled dark hair framing the face, and the softly lit environment with a turquoise hue in the background. The wooden wall is visible, and the composition emphasizes the play of light and shadow. The right image lacks the small tattoo on the left shoulder and has a slightly less natural lighting effect, which diminishes the warm, cinematic atmosphere described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a small tattoo on the left shoulder. Adjust the lighting to create a warmer, more cinematic tone with enhanced contrast and grainy texture."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49674_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49674_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Moody portrait of a young woman with a pensive expression, leaning against a wooden wall in a softly lit environment. Her dark hair is tousled, framing her face, and she is wearing a thin-strapped top. A small tattoo is visible on her left shoulder. The background is softly blurred, casting a turquoise hue, contributing to the intimate and contemplative atmosphere. Her hand rests delicately against the wall. The composition emphasizes the play of light and shadow across her skin, highlighting the serene and introspective mood. Cinematic, shallow depth of field, soft natural lighting, warm color palette, high contrast, grainy texture, evocative, visually balanced. | 14070 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the pensive expression, tousled dark hair framing the face, and the softly lit environment with a turquoise hue in the background. The wooden wall is visible, and the composition emphasizes the play of light and shadow. The right image lacks the small tattoo on the left shoulder and has a slightly less natural lighting effect, which diminishes the warm, cinematic atmosphere described in the prompt. | left | Add a small tattoo on the left shoulder. Adjust the lighting to create a warmer, more cinematic tone with enhanced contrast and grainy texture. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a young woman with vibrant red hair cascading over her shoulders, a black turtleneck sweater, and a calm, contemplative expression. Her body is turned slightly to the right, and her arms are crossed gently over her chest. The lighting is soft and concentrated on her face, creating subtle shadows and enhancing her features. The right image, while similar, has less vibrant hair, a slightly less refined lighting setup, and the pose is less aligned with the prompt as her body is more frontal rather than slightly turned.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the vibrancy of the red hair to match the striking color in the other image. Adjust the body position to be slightly turned to the right with arms crossed gently over the chest."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49677_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49677_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Portrait of a young woman with long, vibrant red hair cascading over her shoulders, set against a dark green backdrop. Positioned in the center, she wears a black turtleneck sweater, her body turned slightly to the right, with her arms crossed gently over her chest. Her expression is calm and contemplative, with her eyes directed towards the camera. The lighting is soft and concentrated on her face, creating subtle shadows and enhancing her features. High contrast between her pale skin and the dark clothing, minimalist composition, studio photography, smooth texture of the skin, a striking use of color contrasts, elegant and refined mood, full focus on the subject, isolated background for emphasis, intimate and engaging. | 14073 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a young woman with vibrant red hair cascading over her shoulders, a black turtleneck sweater, and a calm, contemplative expression. Her body is turned slightly to the right, and her arms are crossed gently over her chest. The lighting is soft and concentrated on her face, creating subtle shadows and enhancing her features. The right image, while similar, has less vibrant hair, a slightly less refined lighting setup, and the pose is less aligned with the prompt as her body is more frontal rather than slightly turned. | left | Enhance the vibrancy of the red hair to match the striking color in the other image. Adjust the body position to be slightly turned to the right with arms crossed gently over the chest. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image captures the lighthouse on a cliff edge with a winding path leading to it, but it lacks the grazing sheep on the slope to the right, which are present in the right image. The right image includes the sheep, enhancing the pastoral tranquility described in the prompt. Additionally, the right image has a more dynamic sky with warmer golden hour tones, aligning better with the prompt's description of a dramatic sky and natural lighting. The left image appears slightly underexposed, which matches the prompt, but the absence of sheep and less dynamic sky make it less aligned overall.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add grazing sheep on the slope to the right of the path. Enhance the sky with more dynamic, sweeping clouds transitioning from warm hues near the horizon to cooler blues at the top."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49678_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49678_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Expansive landscape photograph of a coastal scene with a lighthouse in the distance. The lighthouse and its adjoining white buildings are positioned on a cliff edge at the left-center, overlooking the vast ocean with gentle waves. A narrow, winding path leads the viewer's eye from the foreground to the lighthouse, starting in the bottom right corner and meandering toward the horizon. The foreground is characterized by a mixture of rocky and grassy terrain with scattered stones and patches of green-brown grass. A few sheep graze on the slope to the right, adding a sense of pastoral tranquility. The sky is vast and dynamic, filled with soft, sweeping clouds that transition from warmer hues near the horizon to cooler blues at the top. Metal barriers and fences line the path, providing a rustic touch to the setting. Photo, wide depth of field, dramatic sky with natural lighting, golden hour tones, high contrast between land and sea, serene and contemplative atmosphere, panoramic composition, earthy color palette, slightly underexposed, coastal and rural charm. | 14074 | The left image captures the lighthouse on a cliff edge with a winding path leading to it, but it lacks the grazing sheep on the slope to the right, which are present in the right image. The right image includes the sheep, enhancing the pastoral tranquility described in the prompt. Additionally, the right image has a more dynamic sky with warmer golden hour tones, aligning better with the prompt's description of a dramatic sky and natural lighting. The left image appears slightly underexposed, which matches the prompt, but the absence of sheep and less dynamic sky make it less aligned overall. | right | Add grazing sheep on the slope to the right of the path. Enhance the sky with more dynamic, sweeping clouds transitioning from warm hues near the horizon to cooler blues at the top. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the woman wearing the specified outfit, including the lavender scarf, and holding the black handbag in her left hand and the smartphone in her right. The modern office background includes the wooden desk with a pink flower arrangement, two wooden chairs, and the angled floor lamp near the window. The skyscraper view and natural lighting are also present. In the right image, the woman’s pose and accessories are correct, but the scarf is less prominent, and the background lacks the soft, professional atmosphere due to the absence of curtains and a less visible skyscraper view.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the lavender scarf more prominent by draping it more visibly over the shoulders. Add beige curtains near the window to enhance the soft, professional atmosphere."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49675_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49675_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Fashionable photograph of a woman taking a mirror selfie in a chic office environment. She stands in the left foreground, holding a smartphone in her right hand and a black handbag in her left. She wears a beige trench coat, white top, beige pants, and a lavender scarf draped over her shoulders, along with black high heels. The modern office space in the background features a wooden desk with a central flower arrangement in pink hues, flanked by two wooden chairs. A contemporary floor lamp with an angled design is situated near the window, which offers a view of a skyscraper against a partly cloudy sky. The flooring is light wood, and a beige carpet lies under the desk. Natural lighting, modern interior, stylish, sleek aesthetics, soft color palette, professional yet relaxed atmosphere, vertically oriented photo. | 14071 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the woman wearing the specified outfit, including the lavender scarf, and holding the black handbag in her left hand and the smartphone in her right. The modern office background includes the wooden desk with a pink flower arrangement, two wooden chairs, and the angled floor lamp near the window. The skyscraper view and natural lighting are also present. In the right image, the woman’s pose and accessories are correct, but the scarf is less prominent, and the background lacks the soft, professional atmosphere due to the absence of curtains and a less visible skyscraper view. | left | Make the lavender scarf more prominent by draping it more visibly over the shoulders. Add beige curtains near the window to enhance the soft, professional atmosphere. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a visible white panel beneath the wooden window seat, which is explicitly mentioned in the prompt. The right image lacks this white panel, making it less accurate. Both images feature a large rectangular window frame made of light-colored wood, a view of a mountainous landscape with beige and green hues, and lush green pine trees at the mountain's base. The interior space in both images is minimalistic and warm-toned, with natural lighting and a serene atmosphere.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a visible white panel beneath the wooden window seat. Ensure the wooden textures and lighting remain consistent with the rest of the interior."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49676_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49676_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Large rectangular window frame made of light-colored wood, centered in the image, presenting a view of a mountainous landscape. The mountain, with soft hues of beige and green, occupies most of the background, showcasing rugged terrain. Lush green pine trees partially cover the mountain's base in the middle ground. The wooden window seat runs across the bottom of the frame, with a visible white panel beneath it. The interior space surrounding the window is minimalistic and warm-toned due to the wood textures. Natural lighting, neutral and soft color palette, minimalist architecture, expansive and serene view, sharp focus on landscape, calm and inviting atmosphere. | 14072 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a visible white panel beneath the wooden window seat, which is explicitly mentioned in the prompt. The right image lacks this white panel, making it less accurate. Both images feature a large rectangular window frame made of light-colored wood, a view of a mountainous landscape with beige and green hues, and lush green pine trees at the mountain's base. The interior space in both images is minimalistic and warm-toned, with natural lighting and a serene atmosphere. | left | Add a visible white panel beneath the wooden window seat. Ensure the wooden textures and lighting remain consistent with the rest of the interior. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features four identical characters with elongated heads, exaggerated features, and distinctive mustaches. The characters are holding gift boxes with alternating blue and orange colors, and their socks and shoes match the head colors, maintaining the alternating pattern. The background is flat beige, and the overall design is clean, minimalist, and symmetrical. The right image deviates from the prompt as the characters are not identical, their heads are not elongated, and their features are inconsistent. Additionally, the socks and shoes do not match the head colors, and the overall symmetry and playful tone are less pronounced.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the characters identical with elongated heads and exaggerated features. Ensure the socks and shoes match the head colors, alternating between blue and orange hues."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49680_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49680_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Cartoon illustration featuring a stylized row of four identical characters with elongated heads and exaggerated features, positioned centrally, facing right. Each character is holding a gift box with a ribbon, alternating between blue and orange. The characters have distinctive mustaches and are dressed in striped socks with shoes matching their head color. The pattern alternates between blue and orange hues, creating a playful symmetry. The background is a flat beige, providing contrast to the vibrant colors. Digital illustration, minimalist design, bold color palette, flat shading, playful and quirky style, symmetrical composition, whimsical tone, clean and simple aesthetic. | 14076 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features four identical characters with elongated heads, exaggerated features, and distinctive mustaches. The characters are holding gift boxes with alternating blue and orange colors, and their socks and shoes match the head colors, maintaining the alternating pattern. The background is flat beige, and the overall design is clean, minimalist, and symmetrical. The right image deviates from the prompt as the characters are not identical, their heads are not elongated, and their features are inconsistent. Additionally, the socks and shoes do not match the head colors, and the overall symmetry and playful tone are less pronounced. | left | Make the characters identical with elongated heads and exaggerated features. Ensure the socks and shoes match the head colors, alternating between blue and orange hues. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image includes most elements from the prompt, such as the large tree in the left midground, the black power pole with three wires in the left foreground, and the red fox near the fence in the right midground. However, it lacks the body of blue water near the man on the hill, and the clusters of orange and white flowers in the lower foreground are sparse. The right image includes the body of blue water and more vibrant clusters of flowers in the foreground, but it misses the man on the hill, and the power pole wires are inaccurately depicted. Additionally, the placement of the fox and the cats on rooftops is less accurate compared to the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a body of blue water near the man on the hill in the right midground. Increase the density and vibrancy of orange and white flowers in the lower foreground."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49679_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49679_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Whimsical illustration of a rural countryside landscape. Central focus on quaint cottages with gabled roofs, scattered across rolling green hills. A large tree occupies the left midground, its textured leaves providing contrast. A black power pole with three wires stands in the left foreground. Seven black birds are in flight in the upper portion, adding dynamic movement against the white sky. Several wooden fences create boundaries and depth throughout the scene. A red fox is depicted walking near the fence in the right midground. To the right, a man stands on a hill near a body of blue water, looking into the distance. The lower foreground features clusters of orange and white flowers, and small, scattered plants. Two cats rest on rooftops of the central and rightmost houses. Stylized, digital illustration, naive art style, bright and flat color palette, textural brush strokes, airy composition, playful, calm, idyllic, pastoral. | 14075 | The left image includes most elements from the prompt, such as the large tree in the left midground, the black power pole with three wires in the left foreground, and the red fox near the fence in the right midground. However, it lacks the body of blue water near the man on the hill, and the clusters of orange and white flowers in the lower foreground are sparse. The right image includes the body of blue water and more vibrant clusters of flowers in the foreground, but it misses the man on the hill, and the power pole wires are inaccurately depicted. Additionally, the placement of the fox and the cats on rooftops is less accurate compared to the prompt. | left | Add a body of blue water near the man on the hill in the right midground. Increase the density and vibrancy of orange and white flowers in the lower foreground. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a shiny silver screw with a Phillips head, centrally located and embedded in a rough, textured gray surface with multicolored specks. The surface texture and the wooden element in the background are visible, aligning well with the prompt. The right image, however, shows a hex-head screw instead of a Phillips head, which does not match the prompt. Additionally, the screw in the right image is not firmly fastened into the surface, and the wooden element is less prominent.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the hex-head screw with a shiny silver Phillips head screw. Embed the screw firmly into the surface at a slight downward angle."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49681_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49681_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Close-up photograph of a metal screw firmly fastened into a rough, textured surface. The screw, a shiny silver color with a Phillips head, is centrally located in the image, angled slightly downward. The surface it's embedded in appears to be a gray, pressed fiber material, displaying a rough, fibrous texture with small multicolored specks scattered throughout. In the background, there's a hint of a wooden element visible at the bottom, suggesting an underlying structure the screw is securing. The image showcases a shallow depth of field, causing a soft blur on the surrounding areas, emphasizing the screw and texture of the material in sharp detail. Natural lighting, high contrast, industrial photography, utilitarian focus, subtle, muted color palette. | 14077 | The left image features a shiny silver screw with a Phillips head, centrally located and embedded in a rough, textured gray surface with multicolored specks. The surface texture and the wooden element in the background are visible, aligning well with the prompt. The right image, however, shows a hex-head screw instead of a Phillips head, which does not match the prompt. Additionally, the screw in the right image is not firmly fastened into the surface, and the wooden element is less prominent. | left | Replace the hex-head screw with a shiny silver Phillips head screw. Embed the screw firmly into the surface at a slight downward angle. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features an open book on a dark surface, oriented at a diagonal angle. The left page includes black and white photography of tightly packed fish with text on the left margin, and the right page displays two black and white images: a closeup of sliced fish and hands preparing food. The page numbers 17 and 18 are correctly placed. The right image, however, does not fully meet the prompt as the left page lacks tightly packed fish and the right page does not display the specified images of sliced fish and hands preparing food. Additionally, the page numbers are not correctly positioned on the bottom right corner of the right page.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the left page's image with tightly packed fish against a light grey background. Adjust the right page to display a closeup of sliced fish on the top and hands preparing food on the bottom."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49682_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49682_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Open book laying on a dark surface, oriented at a diagonal angle. The left page features black and white photography of tightly packed fish, set against a light grey background with text on the left margin, reading in a foreign language. The right page displays two black and white images: the top one showcases a closeup of sliced fish, while the bottom depicts hands preparing food. The bottom right corner of the page shows page numbers 17 and 18. High contrast, artistic photography, monochromatic palette, minimalist composition, textured page finish, dynamic angle, editorial design, focus on artisanal food preparation, moody and intimate atmosphere, clean layout, matte black background creates stark contrast, subtle shadows and highlights. | 14078 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features an open book on a dark surface, oriented at a diagonal angle. The left page includes black and white photography of tightly packed fish with text on the left margin, and the right page displays two black and white images: a closeup of sliced fish and hands preparing food. The page numbers 17 and 18 are correctly placed. The right image, however, does not fully meet the prompt as the left page lacks tightly packed fish and the right page does not display the specified images of sliced fish and hands preparing food. Additionally, the page numbers are not correctly positioned on the bottom right corner of the right page. | left | Replace the left page's image with tightly packed fish against a light grey background. Adjust the right page to display a closeup of sliced fish on the top and hands preparing food on the bottom. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a transparent exterior revealing the interior mechanics and compartments, including a centrally positioned helm with a mounted control panel and steering system. The blue MG branded battery system is clearly visible below, with a circular emission pattern overlaying the battery area. The beige cushioned seating is centrally positioned at the front deck. The right image lacks the circular emission pattern over the battery area and has a less prominent display of the interior mechanics, making it less aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a circular emission pattern overlaying the blue MG branded battery system to suggest power distribution. Enhance the visibility of the interior mechanical components to match the technical precision and clarity of the superior image."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49685_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49685_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Cutaway illustration of a futuristic boat with transparent exterior revealing interior mechanics and compartments. The boat is oriented from left to right, set against a stark black background. The front features a deck with beige cushioned seating, centrally positioned. A helm with a mounted control panel and steering system positioned centrally behind the seating at mid-ship. Below, a visible blue MG branded battery system is highlighted, encased in clear structural components. The circular emission pattern overlays the battery area, suggesting power distribution. The rear contains additional mechanical components, enclosed by the boat's sleek lines. Digital rendering, high-tech, concept art, clean aesthetic, sharp details, glossy and matte textures, monochromatic with accents of blue and beige, minimalist, technical precision, futuristic marine design. | 14081 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a transparent exterior revealing the interior mechanics and compartments, including a centrally positioned helm with a mounted control panel and steering system. The blue MG branded battery system is clearly visible below, with a circular emission pattern overlaying the battery area. The beige cushioned seating is centrally positioned at the front deck. The right image lacks the circular emission pattern over the battery area and has a less prominent display of the interior mechanics, making it less aligned with the prompt. | left | Add a circular emission pattern overlaying the blue MG branded battery system to suggest power distribution. Enhance the visibility of the interior mechanical components to match the technical precision and clarity of the superior image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a central narrow wooden desk with a black metal frame on the left wall, small decorative items on top, and a light beige plush ottoman in front of the desk. The frameless glass doors separating the hallway from the living room are present, and the living room includes a sleek grey armchair and a large sectional sofa on a wooden floor. The right image has a similar setup but deviates in key details: the desk is missing decorative items, the ottoman is not light beige, and the frameless glass doors are less prominent. Additionally, the lighting and atmosphere in the left image better reflect the warm tones and natural sunlight described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add small decorative items on top of the wooden desk. Change the ottoman in front of the desk to a light beige color."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49684_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49684_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Modern interior photograph showcasing a hallway leading into a bright living room. Central narrow wooden desk with a black metal frame on the left wall, with small decorative items on top. A light beige plush ottoman sits in front of the desk. Frameless glass doors separate the hallway from the living room. Living room features a sleek grey armchair on the right, a large sectional sofa behind it, both on a wooden floor that extends from the hallway. Floor-to-ceiling windows with sheer curtains present a cityscape view. Walls and ceiling are light-colored, complementing the minimalist aesthetic. Highly realistic rendering, natural lighting, soft neutral color palette, sharp focus, glossy textures on surfaces, clean, modern, minimalist style, inviting and open atmosphere, warm tones from natural sunlight diffused throughout. | 14080 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a central narrow wooden desk with a black metal frame on the left wall, small decorative items on top, and a light beige plush ottoman in front of the desk. The frameless glass doors separating the hallway from the living room are present, and the living room includes a sleek grey armchair and a large sectional sofa on a wooden floor. The right image has a similar setup but deviates in key details: the desk is missing decorative items, the ottoman is not light beige, and the frameless glass doors are less prominent. Additionally, the lighting and atmosphere in the left image better reflect the warm tones and natural sunlight described in the prompt. | left | Add small decorative items on top of the wooden desk. Change the ottoman in front of the desk to a light beige color. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has a more detailed and vivid depiction of the inner structure of the flower, with the yellow and orange pollen-covered anthers clearly visible and supported by green filaments. The background has a soft pink hue, but the depth of field is not as shallow, and the focus is slightly less sharp on the anthers. The right image has a sharper focus on the anthers and a more pronounced shallow depth of field, creating a dreamy bokeh effect. However, the filaments are not green, and the background lacks the ethereal blend of pink and purple hues described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Change the filaments to green. Add a soft blend of pink and purple hues to the background to enhance the dreamy effect."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49683_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49683_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Macro photograph of the inner structure of a flower, showcasing vivid details of the stamens and pistils. Dominating the central portion are the yellow and orange pollen-covered anthers, with a textured surface that appears almost velvety. These anthers are supported by slender, green filaments, curving upwards. The background displays a soft, dreamy blend of pink and purple hues, indicating the petals of the flower, rendered with a smooth, blurred effect due to the shallow depth of field. The image is sharply focused on the anthers, with bokeh creating a striking contrast against the vibrant colors in the background. Macro photography, high contrast, vibrant color palette, soft natural lighting, shallow depth of field, photorealistic detail, ethereal, botanically intricate. | 14079 | The left image has a more detailed and vivid depiction of the inner structure of the flower, with the yellow and orange pollen-covered anthers clearly visible and supported by green filaments. The background has a soft pink hue, but the depth of field is not as shallow, and the focus is slightly less sharp on the anthers. The right image has a sharper focus on the anthers and a more pronounced shallow depth of field, creating a dreamy bokeh effect. However, the filaments are not green, and the background lacks the ethereal blend of pink and purple hues described in the prompt. | right | Change the filaments to green. Add a soft blend of pink and purple hues to the background to enhance the dreamy effect. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as the man is facing left, which matches the specified direction. The right image shows the man facing slightly to the right, which deviates from the prompt. Both images have a plain grey background, a black leather jacket with a prominent zipper and collar, and a stylus pen held to the lips, but the left image adheres more closely to the specified composition and direction.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the man's pose to face left. Ensure the lighting remains soft and even across the subject."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49686_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49686_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Profile portrait of a young Caucasian man with short dark hair and a beard, facing left, set against a plain grey background. The man is wearing a black leather jacket with a prominent zipper and collar, creating a sleek and slightly edgy appearance. He holds a stylus pen to his lips with his right hand, suggesting contemplation. The image has a minimalist composition with an emphasis on the subject, showcasing a clean, modern aesthetic. Stylistic elements include a soft, even lighting, which is diffused gently across the subject, creating a smooth texture on the skin and jacket. The color palette is neutral with monochromatic tones. The depth of field is shallow, focusing on the face and upper body, enhancing the contemplative mood. Photographic, sharp focus, balanced composition, professional portraiture. | 14082 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as the man is facing left, which matches the specified direction. The right image shows the man facing slightly to the right, which deviates from the prompt. Both images have a plain grey background, a black leather jacket with a prominent zipper and collar, and a stylus pen held to the lips, but the left image adheres more closely to the specified composition and direction. | left | Adjust the man's pose to face left. Ensure the lighting remains soft and even across the subject. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a large overhanging concrete wall dominating the upper half of the image, composed of textured, segmented concrete panels in light gray shades. It also includes a streamlined vent embedded in the curved wall on the right side, which matches the industrial aesthetic described. The pool in the foreground has a subtle cracked texture and reflects the structural elements above. The right image lacks the curved wall with the embedded vent and instead has a flat wall with a small circular opening, which deviates from the prompt. Additionally, the pool in the right image does not exhibit the cracked texture described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a curved wall on the right side beneath the overhang and embed a streamlined vent into it. Add a subtle cracked texture to the surface of the pool water to match the description."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49687_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49687_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Minimalist architectural photograph of a modern, angular structure featuring a large overhanging concrete wall dominating the upper half of the image. The wall is composed of textured, segmented concrete panels in light shades of gray, creating a geometric pattern. Beneath the overhang, there's a streamlined vent embedded in the curved wall on the right side, suggesting an industrial aesthetic. The foreground is defined by a pool of still, pale blue water with a subtle, cracked texture on its surface, reflecting the structural elements above. The pool's edge is visible, lined with a simple, narrow border. The entire scene is bathed in soft, diffused lighting, contributing to a serene and tranquil atmosphere. Monochromatic color palette with hints of muted blue and gray, high-key exposure, clean lines, modernist architecture, minimalist composition, tranquil, understated elegance, balanced visual symmetry. | 14083 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a large overhanging concrete wall dominating the upper half of the image, composed of textured, segmented concrete panels in light gray shades. It also includes a streamlined vent embedded in the curved wall on the right side, which matches the industrial aesthetic described. The pool in the foreground has a subtle cracked texture and reflects the structural elements above. The right image lacks the curved wall with the embedded vent and instead has a flat wall with a small circular opening, which deviates from the prompt. Additionally, the pool in the right image does not exhibit the cracked texture described in the prompt. | left | Add a curved wall on the right side beneath the overhang and embed a streamlined vent into it. Add a subtle cracked texture to the surface of the pool water to match the description. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it accurately depicts a diagonal line of people on a light gray stone-paved plaza, with the specified individuals and their actions matching the description. The right image has discrepancies, such as the arrangement of people not forming a clear diagonal line, and some individuals are missing or incorrectly positioned. Additionally, the background in the right image is less expansive and does not emphasize the stone paving as much as described.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Rearrange the individuals to form a clear diagonal line as described in the prompt. Ensure the background emphasizes the expansive light gray stone-paved plaza with minimal urban elements."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49689_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49689_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Overhead photo of a diverse group of people standing in a diagonal line on a large, light gray stone-paved plaza. Each person is holding a smartphone, capturing photos or videos. Starting from the left, a woman in a checkered coat and sneakers is crouching, a bald man in a brown jacket with a blue backpack stands next to her. In front of him, a woman in a black puffer coat stands with her phone raised. Adjacent is a red-haired woman in a black coat. Beside her, a man in a dark coat holds his phone up. A young man in a long black coat and black sneakers holds a phone, standing beside a woman in a pink coat with a cross-body bag. Next, a middle-aged woman with red hair in glasses wears a black coat, followed by a man in a gray hoodie holding his phone low. Finally, a woman in a long brown coat stands at the right edge, facing away. The background is a simple expanse of stone paving, minimal urban setting, neutral colors. Natural lighting, medium depth of field, documentary-style, slightly high-angle perspective, candid moment capture, emphasis on the theme of modern technology and urban life. | 14085 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it accurately depicts a diagonal line of people on a light gray stone-paved plaza, with the specified individuals and their actions matching the description. The right image has discrepancies, such as the arrangement of people not forming a clear diagonal line, and some individuals are missing or incorrectly positioned. Additionally, the background in the right image is less expansive and does not emphasize the stone paving as much as described. | left | Rearrange the individuals to form a clear diagonal line as described in the prompt. Ensure the background emphasizes the expansive light gray stone-paved plaza with minimal urban elements. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a luxurious bar interior with a modern industrial aesthetic, but the right image better aligns with the prompt. The right image features a more intricate and geometric gold-colored shelving unit behind the bar, which matches the description. Additionally, the bar stools in the right image have metal frames as specified, while the left image's stools lack visible metal frames. The lighting in the right image also appears softer and more ambient, enhancing the sophisticated atmosphere described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a more intricate and geometric gold-colored shelving unit behind the bar. Replace the bar stools with ones that have visible metal frames."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49688_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49688_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Luxurious interior of an upscale bar with a modern industrial aesthetic. Central large bar counter with rustic, weathered wood paneling extending across the middle ground. To the right, a row of high-back bar stools with metal frames are neatly aligned along the length of the bar. Behind the bar, an intricate grid of geometric, gold-colored metal shelving unit fills the background, housing a variety of liquor bottles and decorative items. Foreground features an opulent black leather Chesterfield sofa with deep button tufting on the left, accompanied by a high-gloss black table. Herringbone parquet flooring in light wood adds warmth to the space. Ceiling adorned with black metal grid patterning and suspended modern pendant lights with exposed bulbs, casting ambient light across the setting. Entire environment exudes a sophisticated and chic atmosphere. Stylistic properties: high-end, industrial chic, modern minimalist, soft ambient lighting, muted color palette, luxurious textures, geometric patterns, visually balanced. | 14084 | Both images depict a luxurious bar interior with a modern industrial aesthetic, but the right image better aligns with the prompt. The right image features a more intricate and geometric gold-colored shelving unit behind the bar, which matches the description. Additionally, the bar stools in the right image have metal frames as specified, while the left image's stools lack visible metal frames. The lighting in the right image also appears softer and more ambient, enhancing the sophisticated atmosphere described in the prompt. | right | Add a more intricate and geometric gold-colored shelving unit behind the bar. Replace the bar stools with ones that have visible metal frames. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the contemporary beige electric car parked on the patio, the woman seated with her back to the camera, and the round glass table with a yellow flower in a vase. The arched windows with cream curtains tied back are also present, and the natural lighting is soft and balanced. The right image, while similar, has the woman facing slightly sideways instead of having her back to the camera, and the car's positioning is less prominent in the composition. Additionally, the patio lacks the lush greenery on the left side as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the woman's pose so her back is fully to the camera. Add lush greenery to the left side of the patio near the palm tree."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49691_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49691_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Luxurious lifestyle scene featuring a contemporary beige electric car parked on a sleek, polished patio overlooking a scenic ocean view. In the right foreground, a woman wearing a sheer, sequined dress is seated with her back to the camera, gazing at the car. Her high-heeled silver shoes rest elegantly on a modern, cushioned chair. A small, round glass table with a single yellow flower in a vase is positioned in front of her. The setting is framed by large arched windows with soft, cream curtains tied back, allowing abundant natural light to flood the space. A palm tree and lush greenery decorate the patio on the left. The clear blue sky with scattered clouds adds to the serene atmosphere. High-end, photorealistic, soft natural lighting, balanced composition, modern architecture, sophisticated, tranquil, aspirational mood. | 14087 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the contemporary beige electric car parked on the patio, the woman seated with her back to the camera, and the round glass table with a yellow flower in a vase. The arched windows with cream curtains tied back are also present, and the natural lighting is soft and balanced. The right image, while similar, has the woman facing slightly sideways instead of having her back to the camera, and the car's positioning is less prominent in the composition. Additionally, the patio lacks the lush greenery on the left side as described in the prompt. | left | Adjust the woman's pose so her back is fully to the camera. Add lush greenery to the left side of the patio near the palm tree. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the man lying diagonally in the water with his head slightly tilted to the right, a calm expression, and a visible dark earring in his left ear. The lighting highlights his facial features dramatically, and the water has a smooth, reflective texture with light reflections creating an ethereal effect. The right image lacks the earring, and the water surface appears less reflective and smooth, reducing the ethereal quality described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a dark earring to the man's left ear. Enhance the water surface to appear smoother and more reflective with light reflections creating an ethereal effect."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49690_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49690_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Portrait photo of an Asian man with wet hair lying on his back in dark water, captured from a profile view. The man is positioned diagonally across the frame, with his head slightly tilted towards the right. His facial expression is calm, and he wears a dark earring in his left ear. The water around him has a smooth texture with light reflections creating an ethereal effect on the surface. Dramatic light highlights his facial features, providing a serene and contemplative atmosphere. Photo, medium depth of field, soft diffused lighting, cool color palette, high contrast, glossy texture, reflective water surface, tranquil, intimate, visually balanced composition. | 14086 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it captures the man lying diagonally in the water with his head slightly tilted to the right, a calm expression, and a visible dark earring in his left ear. The lighting highlights his facial features dramatically, and the water has a smooth, reflective texture with light reflections creating an ethereal effect. The right image lacks the earring, and the water surface appears less reflective and smooth, reducing the ethereal quality described in the prompt. | left | Add a dark earring to the man's left ear. Enhance the water surface to appear smoother and more reflective with light reflections creating an ethereal effect. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it prominently displays the rear of the BMW M340i in the left foreground, with the M340i badge and UK license plate clearly visible. The red taillights are illuminated, casting a subtle glow, and the background features the repetitive concrete paneling and fluorescent lighting of the parking garage. The right image, while similar, does not position the car as prominently in the left foreground, and the lighting and reflections are less dramatic, reducing the moody atmosphere and high contrast described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reposition the car to the left foreground for a more prominent display. Enhance the lighting to create a higher contrast and a more dramatic, moody atmosphere."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49692_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49692_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Photo of a white BMW M340i parked in a dimly lit underground parking structure. The rear of the car is prominently displayed in the left foreground, with its distinct M340i badge and UK license plate visible. The car's red taillights are illuminated, casting a subtle glow. The background features a low-ceilinged parking garage with repetitive concrete paneling and fluorescent tube lighting, receding into the distance. The floor is a textured dark surface, reflecting the greenish ambient light. High contrast, minimal depth of field, moody atmosphere, subdued color palette with greenish tint, automotive photography, urban setting, sleek, modern design, sharp focus on car details, soft ambient lighting, industrial aesthetic, reflective surfaces. | 14088 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it prominently displays the rear of the BMW M340i in the left foreground, with the M340i badge and UK license plate clearly visible. The red taillights are illuminated, casting a subtle glow, and the background features the repetitive concrete paneling and fluorescent lighting of the parking garage. The right image, while similar, does not position the car as prominently in the left foreground, and the lighting and reflections are less dramatic, reducing the moody atmosphere and high contrast described in the prompt. | left | Reposition the car to the left foreground for a more prominent display. Enhance the lighting to create a higher contrast and a more dramatic, moody atmosphere. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the Egyptian queen's profile in the bottom right with the correct stylized makeup, headdress, and attire in purple, gold, and black tones. It also features the Assyrian lamassu in pink in the lower left, the Mayan calendar disc in the top right, and the Egyptian musician playing a flute above the letters against a lilac hieroglyphic backdrop. The composition is balanced, and the vibrant color palette is well-executed. The right image lacks the Assyrian lamassu and does not prominently feature the Mayan calendar disc in the top right. Additionally, the Egyptian queen's profile is less detailed and not as prominent in the bottom right.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a pink Assyrian lamassu to the lower left corner. Enhance the Egyptian queen's profile in the bottom right with more detailed makeup, headdress, and attire in purple, gold, and black tones."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49693_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49693_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Illustration featuring a collage of ancient art elements intersecting with large, white capital letters "FEV" against a textured, beige canvas. A prominent Egyptian queen's profile occupies the bottom right, with stylized makeup, headdress, and attire in purple, gold, and black tones. An Assyrian lamassu depicted in pink occupies the lower left. Above the letters, an Egyptian musician plays a flute, set against a lilac hieroglyphic backdrop. A round, detailed Mayan calendar disc in grey, adorned with intricate carvings, appears on the top right. The imagery includes symbolic objects like the Eye of Horus, a winged sun disk, and a Greek-style figure in the center. A mix of purple and yellow hues creates a vibrant, historical fusion. The phrase "Arte da Antiguidade" is subtly placed in the white space below, signifying "Art of Antiquity". Stylized illustration, paper texture, culturally diverse motifs, balanced composition, vibrant color palette, historical reverence, intricate details, visually intertwined. | 14089 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the Egyptian queen's profile in the bottom right with the correct stylized makeup, headdress, and attire in purple, gold, and black tones. It also features the Assyrian lamassu in pink in the lower left, the Mayan calendar disc in the top right, and the Egyptian musician playing a flute above the letters against a lilac hieroglyphic backdrop. The composition is balanced, and the vibrant color palette is well-executed. The right image lacks the Assyrian lamassu and does not prominently feature the Mayan calendar disc in the top right. Additionally, the Egyptian queen's profile is less detailed and not as prominent in the bottom right. | left | Add a pink Assyrian lamassu to the lower left corner. Enhance the Egyptian queen's profile in the bottom right with more detailed makeup, headdress, and attire in purple, gold, and black tones. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a cat-like character with large, glossy eyes seated at a wooden table in a cozy kitchen setting. The character is centrally positioned and eating a green cookie. The background includes a stainless steel stove with red dials on the left and olive-green tiled walls. The table has the required elements: two eggs in a wooden basket on the left, a metal can in the foreground, and a Turkish tea glass with a saucer and ornate spoon on the right. The right image, while similar, has the character biting the cookie instead of holding it with delight, and the ornate spoon is missing from the tea glass. Additionally, the lighting in the right image is slightly less warm and inviting compared to the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add an ornate spoon to the saucer of the Turkish tea glass. Adjust the character's expression to show delight while holding the green cookie instead of biting it."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49697_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49697_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | A digital 3D render of a cute anthropomorphic cat-like character with large, glossy eyes, seated at a wooden table in a cozy kitchen setting. The character is centrally positioned, eating a green cookie with a look of delight. The background features a stylish kitchen with a stainless steel stove on the left, adorned with red dials. Above, there are olive-green tiled walls. On the table, close to the character, there are two eggs in a small wooden basket on the left, a metal can in the foreground, and a Turkish tea glass with a saucer holding an ornate spoon on its right. A glass teapot with amber liquid and a plunger sits further right, next to a piece of bread. The ambient lighting is warm and inviting, casting soft shadows and creating a play of highlights, exemplifying a whimsical and charming aesthetic. High level of detail, smooth textures, vibrant color palette, cozy and inviting, fantasy setting, playful atmosphere. | 14093 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a cat-like character with large, glossy eyes seated at a wooden table in a cozy kitchen setting. The character is centrally positioned and eating a green cookie. The background includes a stainless steel stove with red dials on the left and olive-green tiled walls. The table has the required elements: two eggs in a wooden basket on the left, a metal can in the foreground, and a Turkish tea glass with a saucer and ornate spoon on the right. The right image, while similar, has the character biting the cookie instead of holding it with delight, and the ornate spoon is missing from the tea glass. Additionally, the lighting in the right image is slightly less warm and inviting compared to the left image. | left | Add an ornate spoon to the saucer of the Turkish tea glass. Adjust the character's expression to show delight while holding the green cookie instead of biting it. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image shows the belt with a smooth tan leather strap and padded brown fabric squares, but the padded section is not clearly positioned towards the left as described in the prompt. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it clearly shows the padded brown fabric squares on the left and the smooth tan leather strap looping across the center towards the foreground. Additionally, the right image captures the rustic wooden surface and blurred wooden elements in the background more effectively, enhancing the vintage and tactile feel.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Reposition the padded brown fabric squares towards the left side of the belt. Adjust the background to include blurred wooden elements for a more rustic and aged atmosphere."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49694_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49694_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Close-up photo of a leather and fabric belt laid out on a rustic wooden surface. The belt has two distinct sections: padded brown fabric squares and a smooth tan leather strap with numbered holes ranging from 1 to 16. The padded section is positioned towards the left, while the leather strap loops across the center towards the foreground. The wood surface has a weathered texture and a medium brown tone, offering a natural backdrop. In the background, there are blurred wooden elements, contributing to the rustic and aged atmosphere. Shallow depth of field, soft natural lighting, warm color palette, photorealistic texture, earthy tones, focused on materiality, tactile and vintage feel. | 14090 | The left image shows the belt with a smooth tan leather strap and padded brown fabric squares, but the padded section is not clearly positioned towards the left as described in the prompt. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it clearly shows the padded brown fabric squares on the left and the smooth tan leather strap looping across the center towards the foreground. Additionally, the right image captures the rustic wooden surface and blurred wooden elements in the background more effectively, enhancing the vintage and tactile feel. | right | Reposition the padded brown fabric squares towards the left side of the belt. Adjust the background to include blurred wooden elements for a more rustic and aged atmosphere. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the described abstract mural art with organic shapes in teal, orange, white, and pale green on the left wall, and a continuation of abstract forms with a prominent teal wave-like shape, pastel peach section, bright yellow area, and a white circle near the bottom on the right wall. Additionally, the rectangular air vent is centrally mounted on the right wall above the colored forms, and the exposed electrical conduit runs along the walls, adding the industrial element. The right image lacks the described depth and dimension created by the two walls meeting at an angle and has a less balanced composition.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a visible angle where the two walls meet to create depth and dimension. Adjust the composition to include a more balanced arrangement of shapes and colors as described in the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49696_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49696_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Abstract mural art on a concrete wall in an urban setting. The mural occupies two adjacent walls divided vertically, with the left wall featuring large, organic shapes in teal, orange, white, and pale green, intersecting and overlapping. On the right wall, there’s a continuation of abstract forms with a prominent teal wave-like shape, a pastel peach section, and a bright yellow area, accompanied by a white circle near the bottom. A rectangular air vent is centrally mounted on the right wall above the colored forms. The two walls meet at an angle, creating a sense of depth and dimension. Exposed electrical conduit runs along the walls, adding an industrial element. Minimalist, geometric abstract, vibrant color palette, high contrast, play of form and color, urban art, clean lines, and balanced composition. | 14092 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features the described abstract mural art with organic shapes in teal, orange, white, and pale green on the left wall, and a continuation of abstract forms with a prominent teal wave-like shape, pastel peach section, bright yellow area, and a white circle near the bottom on the right wall. Additionally, the rectangular air vent is centrally mounted on the right wall above the colored forms, and the exposed electrical conduit runs along the walls, adding the industrial element. The right image lacks the described depth and dimension created by the two walls meeting at an angle and has a less balanced composition. | left | Add a visible angle where the two walls meet to create depth and dimension. Adjust the composition to include a more balanced arrangement of shapes and colors as described in the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has a vibrant neon-lit ambiance with purple and pink hues, glitter on the eyelids and surrounding areas, and glossy lips. However, the choker is less prominent and lacks the sparkling bead or gem detail described in the prompt. The right image has a more prominent sparkling choker, glossy lips, and glitter on the eyelids, but the glitter appears less vibrant and textured compared to the left image. Additionally, the lighting in the right image is slightly less dramatic and ethereal than in the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the glitter on the eyelids and surrounding areas to make it more vibrant and textured. Adjust the lighting to create a more dramatic and ethereal neon-lit ambiance with predominant purple and pink hues."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49695_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49695_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Close-up portrait of a person with closed eyes, head tilted slightly to the right. Their face is adorned with vibrant blue, purple, and pink glitter. The eyelids and surrounding area are heavily decorated with glitter, creating a dramatic and textured appearance. The lower half of their face, from the nose down, includes subtly glossy lips. The person wears a choker made of sparkling beads or gems visible along the bottom edge of the frame. The entire image is enveloped in a neon-lit ambiance, predominantly purple and pink hues, creating a striking and ethereal visual effect. The lighting is soft yet intense, highlighting the sparkling elements on the face. High contrast, intimate composition, ethereal, futuristic, and glam photography style, visually captivating, dreamy atmosphere, neon color palette. | 14091 | The left image has a vibrant neon-lit ambiance with purple and pink hues, glitter on the eyelids and surrounding areas, and glossy lips. However, the choker is less prominent and lacks the sparkling bead or gem detail described in the prompt. The right image has a more prominent sparkling choker, glossy lips, and glitter on the eyelids, but the glitter appears less vibrant and textured compared to the left image. Additionally, the lighting in the right image is slightly less dramatic and ethereal than in the left image. | left | Enhance the glitter on the eyelids and surrounding areas to make it more vibrant and textured. Adjust the lighting to create a more dramatic and ethereal neon-lit ambiance with predominant purple and pink hues. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a modern office interior with an industrial loft design aesthetic, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. The left image includes three wooden desks with metal frames, ergonomic black office chairs, potted succulents, and a grey backpack near the bottom left desk. The right image has four desks instead of three, which deviates from the prompt. Additionally, the right image lacks the hazy skyline effect in the cityscape visible through the windows, which is specified in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove one desk and its associated chair to leave only three desks in the workspace. Add a hazy effect to the cityscape visible through the windows to match the described atmosphere."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49699_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49699_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Modern office interior with an industrial loft design aesthetic, view from an elevated angle capturing an open-plan workspace. Three wooden desks with metal frames are arranged centrally, each equipped with large computer monitors, keyboards, and office accessories neatly placed. Small potted succulents and green plants line the center of the desks, adding a touch of nature. Ergonomic black office chairs with metal arms are positioned at each desk. A pair of grey sofas are visible in the mid-ground, placed against large floor-to-ceiling windows offering a panoramic view of a cityscape under a hazy skyline. Open shelving units with books and decorative items are located against the windows and to the left. Industrial-style pendant lights hang from the ceiling, casting soft shadows. A grey backpack is placed on the floor near the bottom left desk. Minimalist, natural lighting, neutral color palette with earthy tones, polished concrete flooring, sleek and spacious, modern urban atmosphere. | 14095 | Both images depict a modern office interior with an industrial loft design aesthetic, but the left image better aligns with the prompt. The left image includes three wooden desks with metal frames, ergonomic black office chairs, potted succulents, and a grey backpack near the bottom left desk. The right image has four desks instead of three, which deviates from the prompt. Additionally, the right image lacks the hazy skyline effect in the cityscape visible through the windows, which is specified in the prompt. | left | Remove one desk and its associated chair to leave only three desks in the workspace. Add a hazy effect to the cityscape visible through the windows to match the described atmosphere. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a more intricate and fragmented rocky terrain, glowing symbols in red, orange, and blue scattered across the surface, and a vibrant blend of red and green hues in the environment. The celestial patterns in the sky are more pronounced, and the misty clouds enhance the ethereal feel. The right image lacks the fragmented terrain detail, has fewer glowing symbols, and the celestial patterns are less intricate, making it less visually complex and atmospheric.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add more fragmented details to the rocky terrain to enhance complexity. Increase the number of glowing symbols, including blue star-like emblems, scattered across the terrain."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49698_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49698_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Abstract digital art of a mystical, floating landscape with a central towering structure surrounded by fragmented, rocky terrain. The scene is dotted with various glowing symbols, including red and orange circular icons, and blue star-like emblems placed across the terrain. The environment blends dark, shadowy areas with vibrant hues of red and green, creating a high-contrast atmosphere. Celestial patterns form in the sky, adding a cosmic element. Misty clouds envelop the lower region, enhancing the ethereal feel. Digital art, fantasy landscape design, surreal, otherworldly, high contrast, dramatic lighting, dark and mysterious tones, intricate textures, visually complex, atmospheric, celestial motifs. | 14094 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a more intricate and fragmented rocky terrain, glowing symbols in red, orange, and blue scattered across the surface, and a vibrant blend of red and green hues in the environment. The celestial patterns in the sky are more pronounced, and the misty clouds enhance the ethereal feel. The right image lacks the fragmented terrain detail, has fewer glowing symbols, and the celestial patterns are less intricate, making it less visually complex and atmospheric. | left | Add more fragmented details to the rocky terrain to enhance complexity. Increase the number of glowing symbols, including blue star-like emblems, scattered across the terrain. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The right image better aligns with the prompt as it features the angular, fragmented panels on the shoulders and sleeves, creating the desired three-dimensional, sculptural texture. The left image lacks these angular, sculptural elements on the shoulders and sleeves, making it less consistent with the prompt's description of the avant-garde dress. Both images have the correct geometric abstraction and color scheme, but the right image captures the sculptural fashion design more effectively.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add angular, fragmented panels to the shoulders and sleeves to create a three-dimensional, sculptural texture. Enhance the lighting to better highlight the texture and color of the attire."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49700_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49700_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Portrait of a young woman with fair skin and straight, shoulder-length brown hair, positioned centrally in a studio setting against a smooth, dark gray background. She wears a striking avant-garde dress composed of geometric shapes, primarily fashioned from folded paper-like materials in bold colors such as white, yellow, red, and blue, interspersed with black lines resembling a Mondrian painting. The dress features angular, fragmented panels on the shoulders and sleeves creating a three-dimensional, sculptural texture. Her facial expression is confident with vivid red lipstick providing a sharp contrast to the overall color scheme. The lighting is even, highlighting the texture and color of her attire while maintaining a high contrast between the subject and the background. Fashion photography, studio shot, high contrast, minimalistic backdrop, sculptural fashion design, geometric abstraction, strong focal emphasis on the model, contemporary art influence. | 14096 | The right image better aligns with the prompt as it features the angular, fragmented panels on the shoulders and sleeves, creating the desired three-dimensional, sculptural texture. The left image lacks these angular, sculptural elements on the shoulders and sleeves, making it less consistent with the prompt's description of the avant-garde dress. Both images have the correct geometric abstraction and color scheme, but the right image captures the sculptural fashion design more effectively. | right | Add angular, fragmented panels to the shoulders and sleeves to create a three-dimensional, sculptural texture. Enhance the lighting to better highlight the texture and color of the attire. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the required components of the sneaker, such as the mesh-like light grey upper with black lace eyelets and three translucent stripes, the pastel green midsole with intricate patterns, and the darker wavy outsole. It also features abstract swirls and strips of material floating around the shoe, suggesting dynamic motion. The right image lacks the translucent stripes on the upper, and the outsole design is less wavy and textured. Additionally, the floating elements in the right image are less dynamic and abstract compared to the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add three translucent stripes to the side of the shoe's upper. Enhance the outsole design to include a darker tone with a wavy, textured pattern."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49701_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49701_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Exploded view of a sneaker, showing individual components suspended in mid-air against a gradient blue background. The central focus is the disassembled shoe which includes the upper, laces, tongue, midsole, and outsole. The shoe's upper is a mesh-like texture in a light grey tone with distinct black lace eyelets and three translucent stripes on the side. The midsole is a soft, pastel green with intricate pattern detailing, positioned below the upper. The outsole, located at the lower section, is in a darker tone with a wavy, textured design. Several abstract swirls and strips of material, floating around the shoe, suggest dynamic motion. 3D rendering, high contrast, sharp focus, minimalistic background, modern aesthetic, product design visualization, ethereal, lightweight impression, technical elegance, dynamic composition. | 14097 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the required components of the sneaker, such as the mesh-like light grey upper with black lace eyelets and three translucent stripes, the pastel green midsole with intricate patterns, and the darker wavy outsole. It also features abstract swirls and strips of material floating around the shoe, suggesting dynamic motion. The right image lacks the translucent stripes on the upper, and the outsole design is less wavy and textured. Additionally, the floating elements in the right image are less dynamic and abstract compared to the left image. | left | Add three translucent stripes to the side of the shoe's upper. Enhance the outsole design to include a darker tone with a wavy, textured pattern. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the can labeled 'Bliss' in bold black script, suspended midair in the upper right quadrant with droplets glistening on its surface. The shadow is cast to the left, and a single hand with yellow-painted nails reaches towards the can from the bottom left in a graceful gesture. The right image, while also featuring the can and droplets, has the can positioned centrally rather than in the upper right quadrant, and the hands are not as elegantly posed, with two hands reaching instead of one. The composition in the right image lacks the balance and modern aesthetic described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Move the can to the upper right quadrant and adjust its shadow to the left. Replace the two hands with a single hand with yellow-painted nails reaching gracefully from the bottom left."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49703_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49703_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Minimalist product photography of an orange can labeled "Bliss" in bold black script, suspended midair against an orange background. The can, droplets glistening on its surface, is positioned in the upper right quadrant, casting a shadow to its left on the vibrant backdrop. Below, elegant hands—one with yellow-painted nails—reach towards the can, from the bottom left, displaying a graceful gesture. High-key lighting, vivid monochrome color scheme, shadows create depth, crisp shadows and edges, modern and fresh aesthetic, balanced composition, energetic and vibrant feel, commercial and conceptual style. | 14099 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the can labeled 'Bliss' in bold black script, suspended midair in the upper right quadrant with droplets glistening on its surface. The shadow is cast to the left, and a single hand with yellow-painted nails reaches towards the can from the bottom left in a graceful gesture. The right image, while also featuring the can and droplets, has the can positioned centrally rather than in the upper right quadrant, and the hands are not as elegantly posed, with two hands reaching instead of one. The composition in the right image lacks the balance and modern aesthetic described in the prompt. | left | Move the can to the upper right quadrant and adjust its shadow to the left. Replace the two hands with a single hand with yellow-painted nails reaching gracefully from the bottom left. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images align well with the prompt, featuring a monstrous face with exaggerated features, bulging misaligned eyeballs, a stitched chain on the forehead, and a large mouth with sharp teeth and green slime. However, the left image better captures the playful yet grotesque tone with its more dynamic composition, vibrant color palette, and glossy, wet skin texture. The right image lacks the same level of vibrancy and has less pronounced droplet patterns and sparkles on the skin, which diminishes the glossy, wet appearance described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the vibrancy of the colors, especially the electric blues, vivid pinks, and greens, to match the intense saturation of the prompt. Add more droplet patterns and star-like sparkles to the skin to enhance the glossy, wet appearance."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49702_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49702_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Vibrant cartoon illustration of a monstrous face with exaggerated features. The creature's oversized head fills the frame, dominated by bulging, misaligned eyeballs—one green and one white with a pink tint—both dripping with fluid, positioned centrally but skewed. The forehead is stitched with a metal-looking chain, adding an element of industrial horror. A large mouth below sports sharp, uneven teeth with green slime dripping from them, occupying the lower section of the image. The palette is intensely colorful, featuring electric blues, vivid pinks, purples, and greens combining with thick, black outlines creating a comic-like effect. The skin is textured with droplet patterns and star-like sparkles, providing a glossy, wet appearance. The style is reminiscent of modern street art and pop surrealism, cyberpunk aesthetics, high contrast, dynamic composition, intense saturation, playful yet grotesque tone, digitally illustrated with a carefully textured finish, frenetic energy. | 14098 | Both images align well with the prompt, featuring a monstrous face with exaggerated features, bulging misaligned eyeballs, a stitched chain on the forehead, and a large mouth with sharp teeth and green slime. However, the left image better captures the playful yet grotesque tone with its more dynamic composition, vibrant color palette, and glossy, wet skin texture. The right image lacks the same level of vibrancy and has less pronounced droplet patterns and sparkles on the skin, which diminishes the glossy, wet appearance described in the prompt. | left | Increase the vibrancy of the colors, especially the electric blues, vivid pinks, and greens, to match the intense saturation of the prompt. Add more droplet patterns and star-like sparkles to the skin to enhance the glossy, wet appearance. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. The gold Honor smartphone is centrally placed on a raised platform and angled slightly to the right, as described. The black sunglasses are positioned to the left with their arms spread open, and the cylindrical blue object is correctly aligned parallel to the sleek blue pen. The blue wallet with a visible zipper is partially visible at the bottom left. The blue Sony headphones are partially framed in the top right corner, and the light blue book titled 'THE TRAVELER' is below them, with the blue ruler adjacent to the book. The right image has inaccuracies: the smartphone is not angled slightly to the right, the wallet is fully visible instead of partially, and the cylindrical blue object is not parallel to the pen.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Angle the gold Honor smartphone slightly to the right. Partially obscure the blue wallet at the bottom left so only a corner is visible."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49704_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49704_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Flat lay product photography featuring a neatly arranged composition of technology and lifestyle objects on a vibrant blue backdrop. A gold Honor smartphone lies centrally on a raised platform, angled slightly to the right. To the left, a pair of black sunglasses rests with their arms spread open. Below the sunglasses is a cylindrical blue object aligned parallel to a sleek, blue pen with metallic accents. Further below, a corner of a blue wallet with a visible zipper is positioned at the bottom left. On the right, blue Sony headphones are partially framed in the top right corner. Below them is a light blue book titled "THE TRAVELER". Adjacent to the book lies a blue ruler. The image utilizes bright, diffused lighting to accentuate the rich spectrum of blue hues, creating a high-contrast, modern, minimalist aesthetic, with glossy textures and a cohesive color palette that emphasizes luxury and style. | 14100 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. The gold Honor smartphone is centrally placed on a raised platform and angled slightly to the right, as described. The black sunglasses are positioned to the left with their arms spread open, and the cylindrical blue object is correctly aligned parallel to the sleek blue pen. The blue wallet with a visible zipper is partially visible at the bottom left. The blue Sony headphones are partially framed in the top right corner, and the light blue book titled 'THE TRAVELER' is below them, with the blue ruler adjacent to the book. The right image has inaccuracies: the smartphone is not angled slightly to the right, the wallet is fully visible instead of partially, and the cylindrical blue object is not parallel to the pen. | left | Angle the gold Honor smartphone slightly to the right. Partially obscure the blue wallet at the bottom left so only a corner is visible. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a player in a red jersey with number 10 dribbling the ball with his right hand, crouched low, with his left hand extended for balance. The white sneakers are visible, and the background includes a dimly lit audience in a stadium, creating depth. The court's green and beige tones dominate the bottom third, with subtle reflections. The shadowy form of an opposing player partially obscures the ball handler, adding contrast. The right image lacks the shadowy opposing player in the foreground, which is a key element of the prompt, and the composition is less dynamic and intense.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a shadowy form of an opposing player in the foreground, partially obscuring the ball handler. Enhance the lighting contrast and blur the edges slightly to create a more dynamic and intense composition."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49705_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49705_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Anime-style still of a basketball game, focused on a player in a red jersey with number 10 dribbling the ball with his right hand. The player's body is crouched low, his left hand extended for balance, wearing white sneakers. In the foreground, a shadowy form of an opposing player provides contrast, partially obscuring the ball handler. The background is dimly lit, featuring an audience sitting in a stadium, mostly in shadow, creating a sense of depth. The court's green and beige tones dominate the bottom third of the image, with subtle reflections. Dynamic composition, strong contrast between light and shadow, soft lighting, slightly blurred edges, capturing a moment of action and intensity, vibrant color accents, stylized, energetic, classic sports anime aesthetic. | 14101 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a player in a red jersey with number 10 dribbling the ball with his right hand, crouched low, with his left hand extended for balance. The white sneakers are visible, and the background includes a dimly lit audience in a stadium, creating depth. The court's green and beige tones dominate the bottom third, with subtle reflections. The shadowy form of an opposing player partially obscures the ball handler, adding contrast. The right image lacks the shadowy opposing player in the foreground, which is a key element of the prompt, and the composition is less dynamic and intense. | left | Add a shadowy form of an opposing player in the foreground, partially obscuring the ball handler. Enhance the lighting contrast and blur the edges slightly to create a more dynamic and intense composition. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a rugged, open-frame off-road vehicle in a natural setting with visible trees and shrubbery in the background. The composition is balanced, and the monochrome palette is well-executed. The right image, while similar, has a less natural background with fewer visible trees and shrubbery, and the framing includes a distracting branch in the upper part of the image. Additionally, the left seat in the right image is not slightly closer to the foreground as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the distracting branch in the upper part of the image. Adjust the position of the left seat to make it slightly closer to the foreground than the right seat."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49706_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49706_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Black and white photograph of a rugged, open-frame off-road vehicle situated outdoors among trees and shrubbery, suggesting a natural setting with an overcast sky. The image features two prominently displayed black leather seats with white stitching, positioned centrally with the left seat slightly closer to the foreground. A steering wheel is visible to the right of the frame, mounted on the open dashboard without a windshield. In the background, a dense line of trees and rolling hills provide depth, with leaves and branches framing parts of the image. Monochrome palette, high contrast, sharp focus, outdoor adventure aesthetic, sleek leather texture, metallic elements with a visible matte finish, serene yet rugged atmosphere, balanced composition. | 14102 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a rugged, open-frame off-road vehicle in a natural setting with visible trees and shrubbery in the background. The composition is balanced, and the monochrome palette is well-executed. The right image, while similar, has a less natural background with fewer visible trees and shrubbery, and the framing includes a distracting branch in the upper part of the image. Additionally, the left seat in the right image is not slightly closer to the foreground as described in the prompt. | left | Remove the distracting branch in the upper part of the image. Adjust the position of the left seat to make it slightly closer to the foreground than the right seat. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a modern urban plaza with high-rise buildings framing the scene, a central water fountain, and a pedestrian pathway lined with trees and streetlights. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it includes branded stores like Boss and Mexx with visible signage, a more prominent arched structure in the background, and a better-defined pedestrian pathway with sleek streetlights. The left image lacks visible branding on stores and has a less distinct arched structure in the background.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add visible branding such as 'Boss' and 'Mexx' to the stores on the ground floor. Enhance the prominence of the arched structure in the background to make it more distinct and futuristic."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49707_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49707_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Digital architectural rendering of a modern urban plaza, symmetrically arranged with high-rise buildings framing the scene. Two towering structures with horizontal metallic paneling dominate the left and right edges. The middle ground has a wide pedestrian pathway lined with trees and illuminated by sleek streetlights, leading to a central water fountain. People are scattered throughout, some strolling while others gather near cafés with outdoor seating shaded by umbrellas on both sides of the plaza. Shops and branded stores, such as Boss and Mexx, are visible on ground floors with large glass windows. In the distant background, a futuristic arched structure and more skyscrapers are visible, contributing to a skyline of glass and steel. Overhead, the sky is partly cloudy and bright, suggesting early evening or morning. Digital rendering, ultra-realistic style, high-detail, crisp resolution, balanced composition, modern urban design, light atmosphere, cool color palette. | 14103 | Both images depict a modern urban plaza with high-rise buildings framing the scene, a central water fountain, and a pedestrian pathway lined with trees and streetlights. The right image better aligns with the prompt as it includes branded stores like Boss and Mexx with visible signage, a more prominent arched structure in the background, and a better-defined pedestrian pathway with sleek streetlights. The left image lacks visible branding on stores and has a less distinct arched structure in the background. | right | Add visible branding such as 'Boss' and 'Mexx' to the stores on the ground floor. Enhance the prominence of the arched structure in the background to make it more distinct and futuristic. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a large white perforated wall adorned with multicolored rods, a sculptural white perforated staircase decorated with colorful rods, and a wall with alternating vertical yellow and white stripes. The right image lacks the perforated wall adorned with rods on the right side and has fewer multicolored rods on the staircase. Additionally, the alternating yellow and white striped wall is less prominent in the right image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a large white perforated wall adorned with multicolored rods extending perpendicular from its surface on the right side. Increase the number of multicolored rods on the staircase to match the vibrant and playful aesthetic."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49709_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49709_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Minimalist installation in a bright, contemporary interior space. A large white perforated wall, adorned with multicolored, curved and straight rods extending perpendicular from its surface, spans the right side. In front of it, a sculptural white, perforated staircase serves as a central focal point, decorated similarly with colorful rods. To the left, a wall with alternating vertical yellow and white stripes adds a bold graphic element, reaching from floor to ceiling. The floor, also white, reflects light and enhances the clarity of the design. The scene is filled with vibrant colors including orange, purple, green, and brown, contributing to a playful yet orderly feel. High-key lighting, stark contrast, modern abstract design, vivid color palette, orderly composition, immersive, interactive art installation, clean aesthetic. | 14105 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a large white perforated wall adorned with multicolored rods, a sculptural white perforated staircase decorated with colorful rods, and a wall with alternating vertical yellow and white stripes. The right image lacks the perforated wall adorned with rods on the right side and has fewer multicolored rods on the staircase. Additionally, the alternating yellow and white striped wall is less prominent in the right image. | left | Add a large white perforated wall adorned with multicolored rods extending perpendicular from its surface on the right side. Increase the number of multicolored rods on the staircase to match the vibrant and playful aesthetic. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a centrally positioned console with a sleek gear lever showcasing a carbon-like texture and metallic accents. The circular control knob and buttons are clearly visible, encased in a smooth black panel. The metallic climate control knobs are present above, and the rich brown leather upholstery with fine stitching and quilted pattern on the seat is prominent. The red seatbelt clasp is subtly visible. The right image lacks the quilted pattern on the seat and the carbon-like texture on the console is less pronounced, making it less aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a quilted pattern to the seat on the left side of the console. Enhance the carbon-like texture on the console to make it more pronounced."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49708_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49708_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Interior shot of a luxury car's center console and adjacent seats, highlighting modern automotive design. The console is centrally positioned, showcasing a sleek gear lever with a carbon-like texture and metallic accents. To its left, a circular control knob flanked by various buttons including navigation and media options, encased in a smooth black panel. Just above, a set of metallic climate control knobs are visible. Rich brown leather upholstery with fine stitching surrounds the console, while the quilted pattern on the seat to the left adds a touch of elegance. A red seatbelt clasp is subtly visible in the lower section. Crisp, sharp detail, warm color palette, photorealistic, sophisticated and luxurious ambiance, high-quality materials, focused composition. | 14104 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a centrally positioned console with a sleek gear lever showcasing a carbon-like texture and metallic accents. The circular control knob and buttons are clearly visible, encased in a smooth black panel. The metallic climate control knobs are present above, and the rich brown leather upholstery with fine stitching and quilted pattern on the seat is prominent. The red seatbelt clasp is subtly visible. The right image lacks the quilted pattern on the seat and the carbon-like texture on the console is less pronounced, making it less aligned with the prompt. | left | Add a quilted pattern to the seat on the left side of the console. Enhance the carbon-like texture on the console to make it more pronounced. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a sleek wooden sushi bar with white, leather-padded chairs along the left and bottom edges, a glass partition separating the dining area from the open kitchen, and chefs actively working in the kitchen. The kitchen includes light wood cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and a glass panel with abstract art above the counter. The right image, while modern, lacks the minimalist design focus, has a more cluttered layout with additional dining tables in the foreground, and does not emphasize the sushi bar or the glass partition as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove the dining tables and chairs in the foreground. Add a glass partition behind the sushi bar to separate the dining area from the open kitchen."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49713_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49713_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Modern interior of a high-end sushi restaurant with a minimalist design. The scene centers on a sleek, wooden sushi bar extending across the mid-ground, with white, leather-padded chairs along the left and bottom edges of the image. Behind the bar, a glass partition separates the dining area from the open kitchen, where three chefs in white uniforms and hats are at work. One chef, on the right, appears to be preparing or plating a dish. The kitchen features light wood cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and a large glass panel with abstract art above the counter. A circular, white wall clock hangs on the far-right wall. The restaurant utilizes warm, ambient lighting with a soft glow, enhancing the atmosphere of elegance and cleanliness. The ceiling is white with recessed lighting, and the floor is polished wood, contributing to the contemporary, refined aesthetic. Photorealistic, spacious, high-key lighting, modern design, clean lines, organized workspace, elegant, tranquil ambiance. | 14109 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a sleek wooden sushi bar with white, leather-padded chairs along the left and bottom edges, a glass partition separating the dining area from the open kitchen, and chefs actively working in the kitchen. The kitchen includes light wood cabinetry, stainless steel appliances, and a glass panel with abstract art above the counter. The right image, while modern, lacks the minimalist design focus, has a more cluttered layout with additional dining tables in the foreground, and does not emphasize the sushi bar or the glass partition as described in the prompt. | left | Remove the dining tables and chairs in the foreground. Add a glass partition behind the sushi bar to separate the dining area from the open kitchen. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image effectively captures the dynamic and complex environment described in the prompt, with the fragmented mirror installation creating a kaleidoscopic effect, reflections, and a busy atmosphere including signage for Starbucks and 'bills'. The right image also aligns well with the prompt, showcasing a brightly lit, circular art piece filled with colorful toy miniatures and the word 'Harajuku' below. However, the left image better emphasizes the surreal, visually intense, and chaotic yet structured elements due to the interplay of reflections, movement, and urban details, which are more dynamic compared to the static nature of the right image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add more reflective surfaces or mirrored elements to enhance the surreal and dynamic feel. Introduce additional urban details, such as signage or people in motion, to increase complexity and movement."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49710_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49710_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Two juxtaposed images with contrasting themes. The left photo features an interior shot of a large, fragmented mirror installation reflecting various angles and people on an escalator. The reflections create a kaleidoscopic effect with distorted symmetry, and the environment includes signage for Starbucks and clothing store "bills" amidst a busy atmosphere. People are captured mid-motion, creating a dynamic scene filled with movement and complexity. The right image displays a brightly lit, circular art piece filled with a chaotic array of colorful toy miniatures and figurines. The toys are densely packed and form a vibrant mosaic. Below the circle, part of the word "Harajuku" is visible, contributing a playful and eclectic feel. The piece is illuminated by a spotlight from above, emphasizing its texture and variety. High exposure, vivid colors, modern urban aesthetic, dynamic composition, reflections, playful, surreal, visually intense, chaotic yet structured, contrasting environments. | 14106 | The left image effectively captures the dynamic and complex environment described in the prompt, with the fragmented mirror installation creating a kaleidoscopic effect, reflections, and a busy atmosphere including signage for Starbucks and 'bills'. The right image also aligns well with the prompt, showcasing a brightly lit, circular art piece filled with colorful toy miniatures and the word 'Harajuku' below. However, the left image better emphasizes the surreal, visually intense, and chaotic yet structured elements due to the interplay of reflections, movement, and urban details, which are more dynamic compared to the static nature of the right image. | left | Add more reflective surfaces or mirrored elements to enhance the surreal and dynamic feel. Introduce additional urban details, such as signage or people in motion, to increase complexity and movement. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a wicker structure with a pointed top as the focal point, surrounded by clusters of white flowers and pink accents on the wooden lattice structures. The background includes larger wooden lattice cubes, creating depth. The right image lacks the intricate detailing on the wicker structure and has fewer pink flower accents, making it less harmonious and detailed compared to the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add more pink flower accents to the wooden lattice structures. Enhance the detailing on the wicker structure to match the intricate design of the focal point in the better image."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49712_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49712_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Intricately detailed photo of a decorative floral arrangement set against an outdoor backdrop. In the foreground, clusters of white flowers, possibly hydrangeas, are spread across wooden lattice structures. These lattices are decorated with small pink flowers, adding detailed accents. The focal point is a distinct wicker structure with a pointed top, centrally positioned, resembling an ornate lantern. Surrounding elements include additional wicker lanterns, hanging from above, all featuring similar craftwork and texture. The structures are layered, creating depth, with larger wooden lattice cubes in the background, stacked and draped with the same floral arrangements. Natural background of blurred foliage hints at an outdoor setting. Warm color palette, soft natural lighting, mid-morning ambiance, high contrast detail in wickerwork, textural richness, organic and handcrafted aesthetic, harmonious composition. | 14108 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a wicker structure with a pointed top as the focal point, surrounded by clusters of white flowers and pink accents on the wooden lattice structures. The background includes larger wooden lattice cubes, creating depth. The right image lacks the intricate detailing on the wicker structure and has fewer pink flower accents, making it less harmonious and detailed compared to the left image. | left | Add more pink flower accents to the wooden lattice structures. Enhance the detailing on the wicker structure to match the intricate design of the focal point in the better image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a balanced composition with tall white bookshelves lining both sides, a wooden slatted ceiling with recessed lights, and a polished wooden floor reflecting light. The labels 'Franska' and 'Tyska' are correctly placed on the upper left and right shelves, respectively. The green ottomans are positioned near the window at the end of the aisle. The right image has a misaligned label on the upper right shelf ('Tyska' is replaced with 'JiaGub'), and the ceiling lights are not recessed, which deviates from the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Correct the label on the upper right shelf to 'Tyska'. Replace the ceiling lights with recessed lights to match the wooden slatted ceiling design."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49711_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49711_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Modern library interior with tall white bookshelves lining both sides, creating a narrow aisle leading to a distant window with natural light streaming in, Wooden slatted ceiling with recessed lights, lending a warm ambiance, Books of assorted colors and sizes neatly arranged on shelves, Upper left shelf labeled "Franska" and upper right shelf labeled "Tyska" indicating language sections, On the floor at the end of the aisle, two green ottomans near the window, Polished wooden floor reflecting light, Contemporary architectural design, Long perspective emphasizes depth and invites viewer's gaze towards the window, Balanced composition, Minimalist aesthetic, Clean lines, Bright, welcoming atmosphere, Natural and artificial lighting blend harmoniously, Crisp, sharp focus, Neutral color palette with warm wood tones. | 14107 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a balanced composition with tall white bookshelves lining both sides, a wooden slatted ceiling with recessed lights, and a polished wooden floor reflecting light. The labels 'Franska' and 'Tyska' are correctly placed on the upper left and right shelves, respectively. The green ottomans are positioned near the window at the end of the aisle. The right image has a misaligned label on the upper right shelf ('Tyska' is replaced with 'JiaGub'), and the ceiling lights are not recessed, which deviates from the prompt. | left | Correct the label on the upper right shelf to 'Tyska'. Replace the ceiling lights with recessed lights to match the wooden slatted ceiling design. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features six distinct superhero characters with the specified attributes and poses, including the chubby boy in teal waving, the boy in a wheelchair with fiery aura, the bald figure with metallic gauntlets, the afro-haired character with a yellow energy glow, the leaping girl with lightning effects, and the girl with pigtails and pink energy. The right image has inaccuracies: the chubby boy is not waving, the boy in the wheelchair lacks a fiery aura, the bald figure is not wearing metallic gauntlets, and the afro-haired character lacks a yellow energy glow. Additionally, the poses and energy effects are less dynamic and vibrant in the right image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the chubby boy wave his hand. Add a fiery aura around the hand of the boy in the wheelchair."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49714_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49714_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Bright, colorful digital illustration of six animated superhero characters standing in a vivid pink and orange gradient background. From left to right, the first character is a chubby boy in a teal superhero costume and purple mask, waving his hand. The second is a boy sitting in a wheelchair with bright orange gloves and goggles, smiling with a fiery aura around his hand. The third character is a stout figure with a bald head wearing metallic silver gauntlets, assuming a strong pose. In the center, a character with an afro, wearing a green and yellow outfit, stands with a cheerful expression, surrounded by a yellow energy glow. The fifth character is a girl in purple and yellow, mid-leap, holding lightning-like effects in her hands. The final character is a smiling girl with pigtails in a blue and pink outfit, emanating glowing pink energy from her fists. The ensemble evokes a sense of playful heroism and diversity, animated style, high saturation, smooth shading, cartoonish exaggeration, dynamic poses, vibrant candy-colored palette, whimsical atmosphere. | 14110 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features six distinct superhero characters with the specified attributes and poses, including the chubby boy in teal waving, the boy in a wheelchair with fiery aura, the bald figure with metallic gauntlets, the afro-haired character with a yellow energy glow, the leaping girl with lightning effects, and the girl with pigtails and pink energy. The right image has inaccuracies: the chubby boy is not waving, the boy in the wheelchair lacks a fiery aura, the bald figure is not wearing metallic gauntlets, and the afro-haired character lacks a yellow energy glow. Additionally, the poses and energy effects are less dynamic and vibrant in the right image. | left | Make the chubby boy wave his hand. Add a fiery aura around the hand of the boy in the wheelchair. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images align closely with the prompt, but the right image better matches the description due to the more varied and concentrated sprinkles, including heart-shaped pieces, and the vibrant makeup around the eyes. The left image lacks the same level of sprinkle variety and concentration, particularly around the eyes and mouth, and the makeup is less vivid. Additionally, the trail of red makeup from the nose to the mouth is more pronounced and vivid in the right image, enhancing the surreal and artistic style described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Increase the variety and concentration of sprinkles on the face, especially around the eyes and mouth, including heart-shaped pieces. Enhance the vibrancy of the makeup around the eyes and make the trail of red makeup from the nose to the mouth more pronounced and vivid."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49715_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49715_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Close-up portrait of a young person with a face and neck covered in brightly colored sprinkles and vibrant pink and red makeup. The sprinkles vary in shape and color, including round beads and heart pieces, scattered across the entire face with concentrated clusters around the eyes and mouth. The person's eyes are open, with white eyeliner accentuating the lashes. The lips are glossy and red, appearing wet, with a trail of red makeup running down from the nose to the mouth, enhancing the vividness of the scene. The background is a soft pink, providing a complementary backdrop to the colorful foreground. The image exhibits a surreal, artistic style, with high saturation, rich textures, and a stark focus on the subject's facial features. The lighting is direct and bright, emphasizing the contrast between the skin, makeup, and sprinkles, creating a striking visual impact. | 14111 | Both images align closely with the prompt, but the right image better matches the description due to the more varied and concentrated sprinkles, including heart-shaped pieces, and the vibrant makeup around the eyes. The left image lacks the same level of sprinkle variety and concentration, particularly around the eyes and mouth, and the makeup is less vivid. Additionally, the trail of red makeup from the nose to the mouth is more pronounced and vivid in the right image, enhancing the surreal and artistic style described in the prompt. | right | Increase the variety and concentration of sprinkles on the face, especially around the eyes and mouth, including heart-shaped pieces. Enhance the vibrancy of the makeup around the eyes and make the trail of red makeup from the nose to the mouth more pronounced and vivid. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a neat grid pattern of business cards with a minimalist design in white and green. The cards include both English and Japanese text, bold green headers, and a consistent placement of the logo and company name. The right image lacks Japanese text, has inconsistent typography for the company name, and does not display the stylized character with a chef’s hat in the logo. Additionally, the layout in the right image is less systematic and does not fully match the prompt's description of clean and professional aesthetics.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add Japanese text alongside the English text on the cards. Replace the logo with one featuring a stylized character with a chef’s hat and ensure consistent placement at the top left corner."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49717_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49717_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | A collection of business cards for "Yamadai Food Corporation" arranged in a neat grid pattern on a flat surface. The cards have a minimalist design, predominantly in white and green. The cards feature both English and Japanese text, with bold green headers and sections used to highlight contact information and addresses. Each card displays the company's logo, a stylized character with a chef’s hat, at the top left corner. The logo and company name "yamadai", with playful typography, are consistently placed. Text includes names, positions, and detailed contact information such as addresses, telephone numbers, fax, and email. Locations listed include Tokyo, Nagoya, Osaka, USA, Bangkok, and more. The cards use a sans-serif font for a modern look, with a clean and professional aesthetic. Graphic design, minimalistic, corporate branding, sharp text, clean lines, effective use of whitespace, contrasting green and white color palette, systematic layout. | 14113 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a neat grid pattern of business cards with a minimalist design in white and green. The cards include both English and Japanese text, bold green headers, and a consistent placement of the logo and company name. The right image lacks Japanese text, has inconsistent typography for the company name, and does not display the stylized character with a chef’s hat in the logo. Additionally, the layout in the right image is less systematic and does not fully match the prompt's description of clean and professional aesthetics. | left | Add Japanese text alongside the English text on the cards. Replace the logo with one featuring a stylized character with a chef’s hat and ensure consistent placement at the top left corner. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a chef garnishing a square dish with microgreens and red berries in the top left, a hand sprinkling yellow powder onto a black plate with red berries in the top right, and a chef focusing on a tall glass vessel with yellow liquid and foam in the bottom left. The right image deviates from the prompt by showing a chef smiling in the bottom left and a tall glass vessel with oil and breadsticks in the bottom right, which does not match the described molecular gastronomy setup.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the smiling chef with a close-up of a chef focusing on a tall glass vessel containing yellow liquid and foam. Replace the tall glass vessel with oil and breadsticks with a setup featuring a white cloth bag containing sliced bread next to the tall glass vessel with yellow liquid and foam."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49716_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49716_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Collage of three images showcasing high-end culinary preparation, a chef meticulously garnishing a small, square dish with microgreens and red berries on the top left. His hands are positioned delicately against a clean, white background, with a dark, blurred kitchen setting visible in the background. The top right image features a close-up of a hand sprinkling bright yellow powdered substance, likely yolk or cheese, onto a round black plate; the plate also holds small red berries, with the pristine white of the background enhancing the contrast. Bottom left image captures a chef, likely in his 40s with a clean-shaven head, attentively focusing on a tall glass vessel containing a yellow liquid and foam, possibly a molecular gastronomy creation, surrounded by a white cloth bag containing sliced bread. Bright, high-key lighting, modern culinary photography, minimalistic, sharp focus on each texture, vibrant color palette, precise composition, clean aesthetic, gastronomic artistry, contrasting black and white elements, visually structured and balanced. | 14112 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a chef garnishing a square dish with microgreens and red berries in the top left, a hand sprinkling yellow powder onto a black plate with red berries in the top right, and a chef focusing on a tall glass vessel with yellow liquid and foam in the bottom left. The right image deviates from the prompt by showing a chef smiling in the bottom left and a tall glass vessel with oil and breadsticks in the bottom right, which does not match the described molecular gastronomy setup. | left | Replace the smiling chef with a close-up of a chef focusing on a tall glass vessel containing yellow liquid and foam. Replace the tall glass vessel with oil and breadsticks with a setup featuring a white cloth bag containing sliced bread next to the tall glass vessel with yellow liquid and foam. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features three capsule-shaped devices with a clean, contemporary design, a glossy finish, and the correct two-tone color scheme. The leftmost device is predominantly white with a small yellow pattern in the lower right corner, and the center and right devices are predominantly black with small red patterns in the same position. The devices are evenly spaced, symmetrically designed, and placed against a plain white backdrop with uniform lighting. The right image has incorrect details: the yellow and red patterns are misplaced, and the lighting creates shadows, which detracts from the minimalistic and evenly lit appearance described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Move the yellow and red patterns to the lower right corner of each device. Adjust the lighting to eliminate shadows and create a uniform, diffuse effect."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49720_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49720_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Minimalist product photo of three capsule-shaped electronic devices with a clean, contemporary design. Each device has a two-tone color scheme, featuring a glossy finish. The leftmost device is predominantly white with a small yellow pattern in the lower right corner. The center and right devices are predominantly black, each with a small red pattern in the same position. All three devices have a subtle logo in the upper portion, and a small lens or button centered at the top, contributing to a symmetrical appearance. These devices are evenly spaced against a plain white backdrop, emphasizing their sleek profiles. The lighting is uniform and diffuse, eliminating shadows, which enhances the clarity of the image. Modern, minimalistic, symmetrical, high contrast, glossy texture, product photography, sharp focus, evenly lit, balanced composition. | 14116 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features three capsule-shaped devices with a clean, contemporary design, a glossy finish, and the correct two-tone color scheme. The leftmost device is predominantly white with a small yellow pattern in the lower right corner, and the center and right devices are predominantly black with small red patterns in the same position. The devices are evenly spaced, symmetrically designed, and placed against a plain white backdrop with uniform lighting. The right image has incorrect details: the yellow and red patterns are misplaced, and the lighting creates shadows, which detracts from the minimalistic and evenly lit appearance described in the prompt. | left | Move the yellow and red patterns to the lower right corner of each device. Adjust the lighting to eliminate shadows and create a uniform, diffuse effect. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a geometric flower emblem with layered, intertwining petal shapes, creating depth and dimension, which aligns well with the prompt. The golden hue contrasts effectively with the dark grey background, and the text 'BIAMGROUP' is bold, white, uppercase, and centrally aligned. The right image, while featuring a flower emblem, lacks the intertwining and layered petal design, resulting in a simpler and less dimensional appearance. The central circular void is also less pronounced in the right image, making it less aligned with the prompt's requirements for depth and complexity.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Redesign the flower emblem to include layered, intertwining petal shapes that create depth and dimension. Add a more pronounced central circular void to the flower emblem."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49721_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49721_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Modern logo design featuring a stylized geometric flower emblem in a golden hue, centered against a dark grey background. Below the emblem, the text "BIAMGROUP" is displayed in bold, white uppercase letters, centrally aligned. The flower emblem consists of layered, intertwining petal shapes, creating a sense of depth and dimension around a central circular void. Minimalistic and elegant, digital vector art, high contrast between the gold and dark background, sleek and professional aesthetic, balanced composition, corporate branding style. | 14117 | The left image features a geometric flower emblem with layered, intertwining petal shapes, creating depth and dimension, which aligns well with the prompt. The golden hue contrasts effectively with the dark grey background, and the text 'BIAMGROUP' is bold, white, uppercase, and centrally aligned. The right image, while featuring a flower emblem, lacks the intertwining and layered petal design, resulting in a simpler and less dimensional appearance. The central circular void is also less pronounced in the right image, making it less aligned with the prompt's requirements for depth and complexity. | left | Redesign the flower emblem to include layered, intertwining petal shapes that create depth and dimension. Add a more pronounced central circular void to the flower emblem. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a smoother transition from cool blues and purples in the lower left to warm oranges and pinks in the upper right. The ripple-like textures are more distinct, and the composition has a more dynamic and flowing diagonal arrangement. The right image lacks the same level of contrast and vibrancy, and the transitions between colors are less smooth, making it less visually striking and harmonious.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the vibrancy and contrast of the colors, especially in the transition from cool blues to warm oranges and pinks. Enhance the ripple-like texture of the layers to create a more dynamic and flowing appearance."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49718_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49718_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Abstract digital art depicting flowing, layered waves of color, resembling delicate fabric or painted brush strokes. The composition transitions smoothly from cool blues and purples on the lower left to warm oranges and pinks on the upper right. Each layer has a distinct ripple-like texture, creating a sense of movement and depth, positioned diagonally across the frame. The gradient background enhances the fluidity of the layers, contributing to a dreamy and dynamic atmosphere. Soft gradients, vibrant color palette, smooth textures, ethereal, harmonious blend of colors, flowing lines, digital illustration, high contrast, visually striking and elegant composition. | 14114 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a smoother transition from cool blues and purples in the lower left to warm oranges and pinks in the upper right. The ripple-like textures are more distinct, and the composition has a more dynamic and flowing diagonal arrangement. The right image lacks the same level of contrast and vibrancy, and the transitions between colors are less smooth, making it less visually striking and harmonious. | left | Increase the vibrancy and contrast of the colors, especially in the transition from cool blues to warm oranges and pinks. Enhance the ripple-like texture of the layers to create a more dynamic and flowing appearance. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features more prominent undulating sand dunes with smooth, wavy lines and visible ripples in the foreground. The pastel pink hue of the sand and the turquoise gradient sky are well-balanced, and the logo is present in the bottom right corner. The right image lacks the same level of dune prominence and detail in the ripples, making it less visually dynamic and aligned with the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the prominence and smoothness of the dunes in the center and background. Add more visible ripples and patterns to the sand in the foreground."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49719_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49719_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | A serene image of expansive desert dunes stretching across the frame. The undulating sand dunes dominate the center and background, flowing in smooth, wavy lines, casting gentle shadows. The sand hue is a soft, pastel pink, adding to the surreal quality of the scene. In the foreground, the sand transitions seamlessly to meet the viewer's eye, with delicate ripples and patterns visible. The sky occupies the upper third of the image, presenting a clear, vibrant turquoise gradient without clouds. This juxtaposition of colors creates an artistic contrast between the ground and the sky. The image is marked by a logo in the bottom right corner. Stylized photography, high exposure, dreamy color palette, minimalist composition, soft lighting, tranquil atmosphere, visually balanced, ethereal, abstract landscape. | 14115 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features more prominent undulating sand dunes with smooth, wavy lines and visible ripples in the foreground. The pastel pink hue of the sand and the turquoise gradient sky are well-balanced, and the logo is present in the bottom right corner. The right image lacks the same level of dune prominence and detail in the ripples, making it less visually dynamic and aligned with the prompt. | left | Enhance the prominence and smoothness of the dunes in the center and background. Add more visible ripples and patterns to the sand in the foreground. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better matches the prompt as it depicts two pieces of a broken baguette with the left piece showing a crusty, textured surface and slashes, and the right piece smaller with its broken side revealing the soft interior crumb. Crumbs are scattered around, and the shading provides a realistic rendering. The right image, however, shows two whole baguettes stacked on top of each other, with no broken pieces or visible soft interior crumb, which deviates significantly from the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Remove one of the whole baguettes. Break the remaining baguette into two pieces, showing the soft interior crumb on one piece and scattering crumbs around."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49724_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49724_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Detailed pencil sketch of two pieces of a broken baguette on a white background. The left piece shows a crusty, textured surface with several evenly spaced slashes on top, extending diagonally from the center to the left. It is positioned with the broken end facing slightly right and downward. The right piece is smaller, with its broken side facing left, showing the soft interior crumb. It rests slightly tilted to the right. Crumbs are scattered between and around the baguette pieces. The shading technique provides a realistic rendering of the crust's roughness and the bread's soft interior. The sketch has a monochrome palette, with high contrast and detailed textures, creating a photorealistic, tactile quality. The use of light and shadow adds depth and dimension, emphasizing the artisanal character of the bread. | 14120 | The left image better matches the prompt as it depicts two pieces of a broken baguette with the left piece showing a crusty, textured surface and slashes, and the right piece smaller with its broken side revealing the soft interior crumb. Crumbs are scattered around, and the shading provides a realistic rendering. The right image, however, shows two whole baguettes stacked on top of each other, with no broken pieces or visible soft interior crumb, which deviates significantly from the prompt. | left | Remove one of the whole baguettes. Break the remaining baguette into two pieces, showing the soft interior crumb on one piece and scattering crumbs around. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it showcases a calm, introspective expression with the head resting gently on the arms positioned diagonally. The iridescent blue eyeshadow is striking and contrasts beautifully against the dark skin. The background is minimalistic and soft, and the lighting is even, highlighting the smooth texture of the skin. The right image, while similar, has a slightly less diagonal arm positioning and a less serene expression, which detracts from the calm and introspective mood described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Adjust the arm positioning to be more diagonal across the frame. Soften the expression to appear more calm and introspective."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49723_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49723_res_1024x1024_variant_8.png | Close-up portrait of a young Black woman with short hair, showcasing her calm, introspective expression. Her head is tilted, resting gently on her arms which are positioned diagonally across the frame. The focus is on her face, which is adorned with striking, iridescent blue eyeshadow that contrasts beautifully against her dark skin. Her eyes are soft and engaging, looking slightly off-camera. The background is a minimalistic, soft white, keeping the attention on her features. Subtle earrings in her left ear add a delicate detail to her appearance. The lighting is soft and even, highlighting the smooth texture of her skin. The composition is intimate, with a shallow depth of field that draws attention to her facial features. The overall color palette is cool with blue accents, high contrast, elegant, serene, ethereal, fashion photography, artistic portraiture, visually balanced composition. | 14119 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it showcases a calm, introspective expression with the head resting gently on the arms positioned diagonally. The iridescent blue eyeshadow is striking and contrasts beautifully against the dark skin. The background is minimalistic and soft, and the lighting is even, highlighting the smooth texture of the skin. The right image, while similar, has a slightly less diagonal arm positioning and a less serene expression, which detracts from the calm and introspective mood described in the prompt. | left | Adjust the arm positioning to be more diagonal across the frame. Soften the expression to appear more calm and introspective. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a more prominent tree on the left side, which is taller than the others, as described in the prompt. The footprints in the snowdrifts lead from the bottom right to the center of the image, matching the solitary journey aspect. The right image lacks a clearly taller, prominent tree and has a less balanced distribution of snow-laden trees, with fewer trees on the left side. Additionally, the footprints in the right image are less centered and do not align as well with the described path.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a taller, more prominent tree on the left side of the field. Adjust the footprints to lead more centrally from the bottom right to the center of the image."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49722_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49722_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Winter landscape photograph of a vast snow-covered field under a clear, starry night sky. The foreground features snowdrifts with visible footprints leading from the bottom right to the center of the image, suggesting a solitary journey across the field. Small, snow-laden trees are scattered throughout the field, predominantly on the left side, with one prominent tree standing taller than the rest. In the background, a dense line of snow-dusted trees forms a horizon against the deep, gradient blue sky. Faint aurora borealis hues can be seen above the tree line. The scene is illuminated by moonlight, casting a soft, serene glow over the snow. High contrast, long exposure, crispness in the stars, ethereal and calm atmosphere, wide depth of field, natural lighting, cold color palette, tranquil and expansive. | 14118 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a more prominent tree on the left side, which is taller than the others, as described in the prompt. The footprints in the snowdrifts lead from the bottom right to the center of the image, matching the solitary journey aspect. The right image lacks a clearly taller, prominent tree and has a less balanced distribution of snow-laden trees, with fewer trees on the left side. Additionally, the footprints in the right image are less centered and do not align as well with the described path. | left | Add a taller, more prominent tree on the left side of the field. Adjust the footprints to lead more centrally from the bottom right to the center of the image. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a blue slide prominently on a floating platform in the midground, slightly to the right of the center, with a clear reflection on the calm water. The grassy hills in the background are dotted with small houses and patches of forest, transitioning into darker forested mountain slopes and snow-capped peaks. The right image has a blue slide that is not as prominent, appears to be lying flat, and lacks the proper upright structure described in the prompt. Additionally, the right image has fewer visible houses and less detail in the background hills and mountains, which diminishes the idyllic atmosphere described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Make the blue slide upright and prominent on the floating platform. Add more small houses and patches of forest to the grassy hills in the background."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49726_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49726_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Tranquil landscape photograph of a serene lake surrounded by lush green hills and distant mountains, under a partly cloudy sky. A blue slide sits prominently on a floating platform in the midground, slightly to the right of the image center, casting a reflection on the calm water. The grassy hills in the background are dotted with small houses and patches of forest, transitioning into darker, forested mountain slopes and snow-capped peaks under a soft, diffused light. The foreground shows the clear, reflective surface of the lake, adding an expansive feel to the scene. Photography, natural lighting, peaceful and idyllic atmosphere, medium depth of field, crisp clarity, balanced composition, cool and muted color palette, serene and inviting environment, sense of isolation and calmness. | 14121 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes a blue slide prominently on a floating platform in the midground, slightly to the right of the center, with a clear reflection on the calm water. The grassy hills in the background are dotted with small houses and patches of forest, transitioning into darker forested mountain slopes and snow-capped peaks. The right image has a blue slide that is not as prominent, appears to be lying flat, and lacks the proper upright structure described in the prompt. Additionally, the right image has fewer visible houses and less detail in the background hills and mountains, which diminishes the idyllic atmosphere described in the prompt. | left | Make the blue slide upright and prominent on the floating platform. Add more small houses and patches of forest to the grassy hills in the background. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a tousled, dramatic hairstyle with strands flowing around the face, creating a sense of motion. The head is slightly tilted to the left, and the high-collared black garment merges with the shadowy lower portion, adding a mysterious element. The lighting is soft and directional, highlighting the contours of the face and hair texture, achieving a high-contrast, moody, and elegant look. The right image, while also featuring a high-collared garment and dramatic lighting, has a more structured hairstyle that lacks the tousled, flowing motion described in the prompt. Additionally, the head tilt is less pronounced, and the overall composition feels less dynamic and ethereal.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Tousle the hair more dramatically, adding flowing strands around the face to create a sense of motion. Slightly tilt the head to the left to match the described pose."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49727_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49727_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Black and white portrait of a young woman with an avant-garde hairstyle, her head slightly tilted to the left, eyes closed, in front of a plain grey background. Her dark hair is tousled dramatically, with strands flowing around her face, creating a sense of motion. She wears a high-collared black garment, which merges with the shadowy lower portion of the image, adding a mysterious element. Her lips are darkly colored, contrasting with the pale skin and the monochromatic theme. The lighting is soft and directional, highlighting the contours of her face, hair texture, and creating a striking, high-contrast look. Fashion photography, moody, elegant, sophisticated, minimalistic composition, deep shadows, and high contrast enhance the ethereal, artful atmosphere. | 14122 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a tousled, dramatic hairstyle with strands flowing around the face, creating a sense of motion. The head is slightly tilted to the left, and the high-collared black garment merges with the shadowy lower portion, adding a mysterious element. The lighting is soft and directional, highlighting the contours of the face and hair texture, achieving a high-contrast, moody, and elegant look. The right image, while also featuring a high-collared garment and dramatic lighting, has a more structured hairstyle that lacks the tousled, flowing motion described in the prompt. Additionally, the head tilt is less pronounced, and the overall composition feels less dynamic and ethereal. | left | Tousle the hair more dramatically, adding flowing strands around the face to create a sense of motion. Slightly tilt the head to the left to match the described pose. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has beverage cans labeled with a geometric pattern but lacks the clear 'Resonant Basil' text wrapping around the cans as specified in the prompt. The right image features a hand holding a business card, but the card's logo design does not match the described 'Resonant' logo with a gradient from orange to white. Additionally, the lighting and shadows on the card in the right image are less dramatic than described in the prompt.",
"Result": "none",
"Instructions": "Add the text 'Resonant Basil' in large, white geometric font wrapping around the beverage cans. Modify the business card to feature the 'Resonant' logo with a gradient from orange to white and enhance the lighting to create dramatic shadows on the card."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49731_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49731_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Composite image featuring two distinct sections. Left section: a close-up of sleek, black beverage cans, labeled "Resonant Basil" with large, white geometric text wrapping around each can’s surface. Positioned diagonally, the cans overlap slightly, showing metallic silver tops, occupying most of the frame, creating a modern and minimalistic aesthetic. Right section: a hand holding a business card against a solid gray backdrop. The hand is positioned palm up with fingers slightly curled, prominently displaying the card which features the "Resonant" logo in black on a subtle gradient from orange to white. The hand is dramatically lit, casting gentle shadows that enhance the card. High contrast, modern product photography, clean layout, minimalist, sleek, contemporary design, focused lighting, sharp textures, elegant, monochrome palette with a hint of color on the card. | 14125 | The left image has beverage cans labeled with a geometric pattern but lacks the clear 'Resonant Basil' text wrapping around the cans as specified in the prompt. The right image features a hand holding a business card, but the card's logo design does not match the described 'Resonant' logo with a gradient from orange to white. Additionally, the lighting and shadows on the card in the right image are less dramatic than described in the prompt. | none | Add the text 'Resonant Basil' in large, white geometric font wrapping around the beverage cans. Modify the business card to feature the 'Resonant' logo with a gradient from orange to white and enhance the lighting to create dramatic shadows on the card. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images feature a fabric with a horizontal division, a red section on top, and a blue section below. The left image better captures the subtle mesh texture and small repetitive patterns, as well as the soft natural lighting and delicate shadows. The right image lacks the same level of texture detail and appears smoother, which diminishes the emphasis on the fabric's surface characteristics described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Enhance the mesh texture on the fabric surface to create small repetitive patterns. Adjust the lighting to introduce delicate shadows and slight color variations, emphasizing the fabric's softness and flexibility."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49728_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49728_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Close-up photo of a fabric with a prominent horizontal division, featuring a vibrant red section on top and a dark, deep blue section below. The fabric's surface displays a subtle mesh texture, creating small repetitive patterns across the entire image. The lighting highlights delicate shadows and slight variations in color, suggesting a soft and flexible material. The image lacks any distinct objects or background elements, focusing entirely on the fabric's texture and color contrast. Macro photography, high detail, soft natural lighting, sharp focus on texture, bold color contrast, minimalistic composition, textile photography. | 14123 | Both images feature a fabric with a horizontal division, a red section on top, and a blue section below. The left image better captures the subtle mesh texture and small repetitive patterns, as well as the soft natural lighting and delicate shadows. The right image lacks the same level of texture detail and appears smoother, which diminishes the emphasis on the fabric's surface characteristics described in the prompt. | left | Enhance the mesh texture on the fabric surface to create small repetitive patterns. Adjust the lighting to introduce delicate shadows and slight color variations, emphasizing the fabric's softness and flexibility. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The right image better aligns with the prompt. It features a single figure on an elevated platform to the far right, wearing a dark outfit and looking straight ahead, as described. The left image has a figure on the mid-level platform instead of the far-right elevated platform. The right image also includes metal railings on the mid-level platform, matching the prompt, while the left image has wooden railings. Additionally, the right image has a symmetrical arrangement of black-and-white photos in a strip-like arrangement above, whereas the left image has an asymmetrical photo arrangement. Both images include the black doorway and industrial-style elements, but the right image captures the modernist aesthetic and symmetry more effectively.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Move the figure to the far-right elevated platform and ensure they are wearing a dark outfit. Replace the wooden railings on the mid-level platform with metal railings."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49730_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49730_res_1024x1024_variant_10.png | Stage design featuring an industrial-style set with concrete walls and minimalistic wooden railings. A single figure stands on an elevated platform to the far right, wearing a dark outfit and looking straight ahead. On the left, a set of wooden stairs leads to a mid-level platform with metal railings. The center has a black doorway, adding depth to the space. Above, there are several black-and-white photos depicting various scenes in a strip-like arrangement. Two monochromatic screens are positioned on either side, showing different images. The lighting is stark, creating dramatic contrasts and emphasizing the architectural elements. Industrial, minimalistic style, high contrast, theatrical lighting, monochrome elements, symmetrical composition, modernist aesthetic, with a sense of surveillance and introspection. | 14124 | The right image better aligns with the prompt. It features a single figure on an elevated platform to the far right, wearing a dark outfit and looking straight ahead, as described. The left image has a figure on the mid-level platform instead of the far-right elevated platform. The right image also includes metal railings on the mid-level platform, matching the prompt, while the left image has wooden railings. Additionally, the right image has a symmetrical arrangement of black-and-white photos in a strip-like arrangement above, whereas the left image has an asymmetrical photo arrangement. Both images include the black doorway and industrial-style elements, but the right image captures the modernist aesthetic and symmetry more effectively. | right | Move the figure to the far-right elevated platform and ensure they are wearing a dark outfit. Replace the wooden railings on the mid-level platform with metal railings. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the correct arrangement of objects, such as the green hardcover books with gilt titles, the vintage deep-sea diving helmet figurine, and the glass dome with rolled parchments. The middle shelf includes the black-framed photo of trees, reed diffuser, and magnifying glass, all in the correct positions. The bottom shelf has the metallic lollipop ornament and leather-bound books with metallic spheres. The right image has inaccuracies, such as the misplacement of the green books, the absence of the magnifying glass, and the incorrect arrangement of objects on the bottom shelf.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Rearrange the green hardcover books to the left side of the top shelf. Add a magnifying glass to the middle shelf, positioned to the left of the black-framed photo."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49734_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49734_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Luxurious modern interior featuring a set of sleek, metallic shelves against a backdrop of textured, diagonal wood paneling. On the top shelf, stacked green hardcover books with gilt titles sit to the left, adjacent to clear, acrylic cube sculptures and a vintage deep-sea diving helmet figurine. The middle shelf presents a glass dome enclosing rolled parchments and a magnifying glass on the left, a minimalist black-framed photo of trees in the center, and a reed diffuser in a dark bottle beside it. On the right, two metallic sand timers are placed symmetrically. The bottom shelf hosts a sculptural metallic ornament resembling a lollipop to the left, and a series of dark, leather-bound books including an encyclopedia set on the right, accompanied by reflective metallic spheres. High-gloss finish, rich brown and gold tones, soft ambient lighting, polished surfaces, modern minimalist design, sophisticated and curated aesthetic. | 14128 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features the correct arrangement of objects, such as the green hardcover books with gilt titles, the vintage deep-sea diving helmet figurine, and the glass dome with rolled parchments. The middle shelf includes the black-framed photo of trees, reed diffuser, and magnifying glass, all in the correct positions. The bottom shelf has the metallic lollipop ornament and leather-bound books with metallic spheres. The right image has inaccuracies, such as the misplacement of the green books, the absence of the magnifying glass, and the incorrect arrangement of objects on the bottom shelf. | left | Rearrange the green hardcover books to the left side of the top shelf. Add a magnifying glass to the middle shelf, positioned to the left of the black-framed photo. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a white ceramic plant pot with vertical grooves housing a lush green leafy plant on the left, a geometric white vase with a faceted texture to the right, and a tall translucent green glass bottle behind the plant. The background includes a light green sofa with a white pillow and two blurry framed artworks on a soft gray wall, all in soft focus. The right image has a plant with broader leaves that do not match the description, and the geometric vase has a different texture. Additionally, the green glass bottle is shorter and lacks the verticality described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Replace the plant in the pot with one that has smaller, more defined leaves. Adjust the geometric vase to have a faceted texture matching the description."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49732_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49732_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | Close-up render of a minimalist interior setting with a focus on decorative objects on a white table. In the foreground, a white ceramic plant pot with vertical grooves houses a lush green leafy plant on the left. To the right of the plant, a geometric white vase with a faceted texture is positioned. A tall, translucent green glass bottle is placed behind the plant, adding verticality and color contrast to the scene. Soft focus on the background reveals part of a light green sofa with a white pillow, and two blurry framed artworks hang on a soft gray wall. Natural lighting creates soft shadows and highlights, enhancing the textures of the objects. Modern, bright, clean, photorealistic 3D rendering, soft depth of field, pastel and neutral color palette, serene and aesthetically pleasing. | 14126 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It features a white ceramic plant pot with vertical grooves housing a lush green leafy plant on the left, a geometric white vase with a faceted texture to the right, and a tall translucent green glass bottle behind the plant. The background includes a light green sofa with a white pillow and two blurry framed artworks on a soft gray wall, all in soft focus. The right image has a plant with broader leaves that do not match the description, and the geometric vase has a different texture. Additionally, the green glass bottle is shorter and lacks the verticality described in the prompt. | left | Replace the plant in the pot with one that has smaller, more defined leaves. Adjust the geometric vase to have a faceted texture matching the description. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a pink upholstered bench, light wood panels, and a herringbone wood floor, but the console table and mirror setup do not match the prompt. The mirror lacks a decorative pink element, and the console table is not properly styled with a ceramic object illuminated by a pendant light. The right image includes the pink upholstered bench, light wood panels, herringbone flooring, and a properly styled console table with a ceramic object and pendant light. Additionally, the mirror has a decorative pink element, aligning better with the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Add a decorative pink element to the circular mirror. Replace the console table with one that holds a ceramic object illuminated by a pendant light."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49733_res_1024x1024_variant_6.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49733_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Contemporary interior hallway featuring minimalist design with natural materials. The environment is lit with soft, focused artificial lighting creating a cozy yet modern ambiance. Light wood panels cover the walls and cabinetry, framing the space and providing a warm tone. A pink upholstered bench is positioned along the left wall in the foreground, adding a subtle color accent. The hallway floor showcases a chic herringbone wood pattern leading to a partially open doorway in the background. A circular wall-mounted mirror with a decorative pink element is centrally placed on the rear wall above a small console table, which holds a ceramic object illuminated by a pendant light. Recessed ceiling lights provide additional targeted illumination. The overall aesthetic is clean, uncluttered, and sophisticated, featuring muted colors, smooth textures, and geometric patterns, highlighting a balance between functionality and design. | 14127 | The left image features a pink upholstered bench, light wood panels, and a herringbone wood floor, but the console table and mirror setup do not match the prompt. The mirror lacks a decorative pink element, and the console table is not properly styled with a ceramic object illuminated by a pendant light. The right image includes the pink upholstered bench, light wood panels, herringbone flooring, and a properly styled console table with a ceramic object and pendant light. Additionally, the mirror has a decorative pink element, aligning better with the prompt. | right | Add a decorative pink element to the circular mirror. Replace the console table with one that holds a ceramic object illuminated by a pendant light. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image features a lamp with a more intricate base design that does not form a simple V-shape as described in the prompt. The right image has a simpler, cleaner base that aligns with the V-shape requirement. However, the lampshade in the right image is slightly lighter in color and lacks the photorealistic texture of charcoal grey felt. The left image has a more accurate lampshade texture but deviates from the minimalist V-shaped base design. Both images include the black power cord, but the right image better emphasizes the minimalist aesthetic and geometric simplicity described in the prompt.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Darken the lampshade to a deeper charcoal grey and add a subtle felt texture. Adjust the lighting to create softer, more diffused shadows for a photorealistic effect."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49736_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49736_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Minimalist digital rendering of a modern floor lamp in a stark, white environment. The lamp is centrally positioned, featuring a charcoal grey felt lampshade with a cylindrical shape, resting atop thin metallic legs that form a V-shape at the base. A black power cord extends from the left side, curling slightly on the surface. The background is a seamless white with no visible textures or objects, emphasizing the lamp's sleek design. Photorealistic textures, soft diffused lighting, high contrast, minimalist aesthetic, clean lines, contemporary, emphasis on geometric shape and material contrast. | 14130 | The left image features a lamp with a more intricate base design that does not form a simple V-shape as described in the prompt. The right image has a simpler, cleaner base that aligns with the V-shape requirement. However, the lampshade in the right image is slightly lighter in color and lacks the photorealistic texture of charcoal grey felt. The left image has a more accurate lampshade texture but deviates from the minimalist V-shaped base design. Both images include the black power cord, but the right image better emphasizes the minimalist aesthetic and geometric simplicity described in the prompt. | right | Darken the lampshade to a deeper charcoal grey and add a subtle felt texture. Adjust the lighting to create softer, more diffused shadows for a photorealistic effect. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it clearly displays the branding 'Shelby American, Inc.' on the metal door sill plate, which is the focal point of the image. The cobra emblem is missing in both images, but the left image has a more legible and prominent branding. The dark green painted surface below the plate is visible with reflections, and the black leather car seat with textile upholstery and a textured metal bracket is partially shown in the top left. The right image has less clarity in the branding, and the cobra emblem is also absent. Additionally, the overall focus and lighting in the right image are less aligned with the prompt's emphasis on photorealistic texture and shallow depth of field.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add a cobra emblem next to the branding 'Shelby American, Inc.' on the metal door sill plate. Enhance the lighting and focus on the branding to create a shallow depth of field with photorealistic texture."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49737_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49737_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | Close-up photograph of the interior of a vintage car door, focusing on the metal door sill plate. The plate displays the branding "Shelby American, Inc." with a cobra emblem, located near the bottom center of the image. The top left of the frame shows part of a black leather car seat with textile upholstery and a textured metal bracket. Below the plate is a dark green painted surface, likely the car's outer body, with visible reflections suggesting natural light. The background includes textured dark carpeting, adding to the depth of the image. The image features a shallow depth of field, with a focus on the brand plate, creating a nostalgic and automotive-themed atmosphere. Photorealistic texture, muted color palette, natural lighting, high contrast, attention to detail, classic car elegance. | 14131 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it clearly displays the branding 'Shelby American, Inc.' on the metal door sill plate, which is the focal point of the image. The cobra emblem is missing in both images, but the left image has a more legible and prominent branding. The dark green painted surface below the plate is visible with reflections, and the black leather car seat with textile upholstery and a textured metal bracket is partially shown in the top left. The right image has less clarity in the branding, and the cobra emblem is also absent. Additionally, the overall focus and lighting in the right image are less aligned with the prompt's emphasis on photorealistic texture and shallow depth of field. | left | Add a cobra emblem next to the branding 'Shelby American, Inc.' on the metal door sill plate. Enhance the lighting and focus on the branding to create a shallow depth of field with photorealistic texture. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "Both images depict a modern two-story house in a minimalist style during twilight. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the out-of-focus branches in the upper right corner, which are missing in the right image. Additionally, the left image has a more prominent and well-manicured lawn in the foreground, as described in the prompt. The right image lacks the same level of detail in the lawn and the branches, making it less accurate to the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Add out-of-focus branches in the upper right corner of the frame. Enhance the lawn in the foreground to appear more prominent and well-manicured."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49738_res_1024x1024_variant_9.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49738_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | Modern architectural photograph of a two-story house in a minimalist style, captured during twilight. The building has a clean, geometric design with the facade featuring large, translucent glass panels on the upper level, reflecting the soft blue sky. The lower level has expansive glass doors and windows, revealing a glimpse of a contemporary interior with wooden furniture. Positioned to the right of the frame, the house is surrounded by a well-manicured lawn in the foreground. A narrow asphalt driveway leads to the left, bordered by neatly planted trees and shrubs. Overhead, electrical wires stretch horizontally across the sky. The scene is framed by out-of-focus branches in the upper right corner. Architectural photograph, wide-angle perspective, natural twilight lighting, reflective surfaces, sharp focus, crisp modern aesthetic, serene and open atmosphere, high contrast between the illuminated interior and the dimmer outdoor environment. | 14132 | Both images depict a modern two-story house in a minimalist style during twilight. The left image better aligns with the prompt as it includes the out-of-focus branches in the upper right corner, which are missing in the right image. Additionally, the left image has a more prominent and well-manicured lawn in the foreground, as described in the prompt. The right image lacks the same level of detail in the lawn and the branches, making it less accurate to the prompt. | left | Add out-of-focus branches in the upper right corner of the frame. Enhance the lawn in the foreground to appear more prominent and well-manicured. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a calm expression, vibrant green pleated high-collared blouse, and earrings with a mix of colorful stones and beads. The lighting includes soft pink and purple tones, creating depth and a contemporary flair. The right image, while vibrant, has a more intense expression with red lipstick, which deviates from the calm tone described in the prompt. Additionally, the blouse in the right image lacks the pleated texture, and the earrings are less eclectic in design.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Soften the expression to appear calm and remove the red lipstick. Add pleated texture to the high-collared blouse."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49735_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49735_res_1024x1024_variant_3.png | Close-up portrait of a bald person with light skin against a rich orange background. The individual is centered in the frame, looking slightly downward, with a calm expression. They are wearing a vibrant green, pleated high-collared blouse that adds texture to the composition. The person adorns their ears with large, eclectic earrings featuring a mix of stones and beads in various colors like yellow, pink, green, and red. The earrings are elaborate and hang down towards the collar. Soft pink and purple lighting casts shadows and highlights across the face, adding depth and a contemporary artistic flair. The overall tone is vibrant, modern, and fashion-forward, with a striking contrast between the green clothing and orange backdrop, sharp focus, glossy textures, and high color saturation, creating a bold and visually commanding image. | 14129 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a calm expression, vibrant green pleated high-collared blouse, and earrings with a mix of colorful stones and beads. The lighting includes soft pink and purple tones, creating depth and a contemporary flair. The right image, while vibrant, has a more intense expression with red lipstick, which deviates from the calm tone described in the prompt. Additionally, the blouse in the right image lacks the pleated texture, and the earrings are less eclectic in design. | left | Soften the expression to appear calm and remove the red lipstick. Add pleated texture to the high-collared blouse. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features five kayakers in white kayaks positioned in the upper-center of the frame, contrasting well with the dark water. The underwater rock formations are visible and create lighter patches, adding texture and depth. The rugged rocky cliff in the lower-left corner is sunlit and displays a mix of beige and gray hues, matching the description. The right image has the kayakers arranged in a circular formation, which deviates from the prompt's description of their positioning. Additionally, the underwater rock formations in the right image are less subtle and more prominent, and the rocky cliff lacks the same level of texture and lighting contrast as described in the prompt.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Reposition the kayakers to form a loose group in the upper-center of the frame. Adjust the lighting and texture of the rocky cliff to display a mix of beige and gray hues with a sunlit appearance."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49740_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49740_res_1024x1024_variant_5.png | Aerial photograph capturing a group of five kayakers paddling on a vast, dark body of water, positioned in the upper-center of the frame, their white kayaks contrasting starkly with the deep blue and black tones of the sea. Below them, underwater rock formations create subtle, lighter patches in the water, adding texture and depth to the scene. In the lower-left corner, a rugged rocky cliff emerges from the water, its sunlit, weathered surface displaying a mix of beige and gray hues. The contrast between the solid immovability of the rocks and the fluidity of the water creates visual tension. High contrast, aerial perspective, natural lighting, sharp focus on the distinct textures, vast and open composition, serene, slightly foreboding mood with an emphasis on nature's grandeur and scale. | 14134 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features five kayakers in white kayaks positioned in the upper-center of the frame, contrasting well with the dark water. The underwater rock formations are visible and create lighter patches, adding texture and depth. The rugged rocky cliff in the lower-left corner is sunlit and displays a mix of beige and gray hues, matching the description. The right image has the kayakers arranged in a circular formation, which deviates from the prompt's description of their positioning. Additionally, the underwater rock formations in the right image are less subtle and more prominent, and the rocky cliff lacks the same level of texture and lighting contrast as described in the prompt. | left | Reposition the kayakers to form a loose group in the upper-center of the frame. Adjust the lighting and texture of the rocky cliff to display a mix of beige and gray hues with a sunlit appearance. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a cartoonish character with a round face, purple facial markings, and yellow ears, standing on the right side of the rocky island. The character is cheerfully looking at the small tree, and the scene has a whimsical, vibrant atmosphere with realistic rock textures, foamy waves, and numerous seagulls flying dynamically. The right image, while similar, has a character with different facial markings and lacks the purple color. The character's design does not match the prompt's description as closely as the left image.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Change the character's facial markings to include purple and make the ears yellow. Adjust the character's face to be rounder to match the prompt."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49741_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49741_res_1024x1024_variant_1.png | Whimsical 3D illustration featuring a cartoonish character with a round face, purple facial markings, and yellow ears, standing on a rocky island amidst an ocean. The character is on the right side of the frame, looking cheerfully at a single small tree planted on the central rocky mound. The rocks are textured with realistic details, with foamy waves crashing against them. Numerous seagulls are dynamically flying across the bright blue sky dotted with fluffy clouds. The scene exhibits a warm color palette with a whimsical, uplifting mood, vibrant and playful atmosphere, high-quality digital rendering, soft diffused lighting, realism blended with cartoonish elements, and fluid motion in the sea and birds, vibrant blue and earthy brown contrast, ethereal and surreal ambiance, harmonious composition. | 14135 | The left image better aligns with the prompt as it features a cartoonish character with a round face, purple facial markings, and yellow ears, standing on the right side of the rocky island. The character is cheerfully looking at the small tree, and the scene has a whimsical, vibrant atmosphere with realistic rock textures, foamy waves, and numerous seagulls flying dynamically. The right image, while similar, has a character with different facial markings and lacks the purple color. The character's design does not match the prompt's description as closely as the left image. | left | Change the character's facial markings to include purple and make the ears yellow. Adjust the character's face to be rounder to match the prompt. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image better aligns with the prompt. It effectively captures the dynamic motion of the figure in mid-stride with flowing dark hair and detailed clothing. The forest is dense, with tall, textured trees extending vertically, and the high contrast between light and shadow creates a mysterious and ominous atmosphere. The right image, while similar, lacks the same level of detail in the figure's clothing and hair, and the forest appears less textured and slightly less dense, reducing the sense of depth and enclosure. Additionally, the contrast in the right image is less stark, diminishing the dramatic tension and visual impact.",
"Result": "left",
"Instructions": "Increase the texture and detail of the trees to enhance the sense of depth and enclosure. Add more detail to the figure's clothing and hair to emphasize movement and dynamic tension."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49739_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49739_res_1024x1024_variant_7.png | Monochromatic illustration of a figure running through a dense forest. The figure, positioned in the lower center, is depicted in mid-stride with flowing dark hair and detailed clothing, showing movement. The forest is composed of tall, textured trees with varied bark patterns, extending vertically throughout the scene. Shadows and light create stark contrasts, casting the figure's silhouette onto the forest floor. The environment spans the entire frame, giving a sense of depth and enclosure. The atmosphere is mysterious and slightly ominous, enhanced by high contrast, rough textures, and a limited grayscale palette. The composition is dynamic, with the vertical lines of the trees juxtaposed against the horizontal motion of the figure, stylized, illustrative, high contrast, evocative, dramatic tension, visually striking. | 14133 | The left image better aligns with the prompt. It effectively captures the dynamic motion of the figure in mid-stride with flowing dark hair and detailed clothing. The forest is dense, with tall, textured trees extending vertically, and the high contrast between light and shadow creates a mysterious and ominous atmosphere. The right image, while similar, lacks the same level of detail in the figure's clothing and hair, and the forest appears less textured and slightly less dense, reducing the sense of depth and enclosure. Additionally, the contrast in the right image is less stark, diminishing the dramatic tension and visual impact. | left | Increase the texture and detail of the trees to enhance the sense of depth and enclosure. Add more detail to the figure's clothing and hair to emphasize movement and dynamic tension. |
true | ```json
{
"Analysis": "The left image has a close-up black and white photo of a hand holding a textured object at the top left, smaller color images of a workshop and bead designs below, and two dark rectangles labeled 'M' and 'L' at the bottom right. However, the right image better matches the prompt as it includes the specified elements: a close-up black and white photo of a hand holding a textured object, smaller images of a workshop and bead designs, a large column of text on the right page, and two dark rectangles labeled 'A' and 'L' with accompanying text blocks. The right image also captures the glossy texture of the magazine paper and maintains a clean, professional aesthetic with a balanced layout.",
"Result": "right",
"Instructions": "Replace the rectangles labeled 'M' and 'L' with rectangles labeled 'A' and 'L' and add accompanying text blocks. Adjust the layout to include a large column of text on the right page, ensuring a balanced composition."
}
``` | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49729_res_1024x1024_variant_4.png | /ceph/data-bk/zl/ReflectionFlow/2M/gpt_4_caption/resolution_1024x1024/index_49729_res_1024x1024_variant_2.png | Open magazine spread resting on a light gray surface, consisting of two visible pages filled with images and text in a mix of Chinese and English. On the left page, a close-up black and white photo of a hand holding a textured object occupies the top half. Below, smaller color images show a workshop with people focusing on crafts, and a display of intricate bead designs against a black background. The right page features a large column of text with two smaller black and white images of a craftsman working at a table. Two large, dark rectangles labeled "A" and "L" with accompanying text blocks are placed on the bottom right. The photo is taken at a slight angle, capturing the glossy texture of the magazine paper, high-key lighting, minimalistic modern composition, clean, professional aesthetic, balanced layout, editorial style. | 14136 | The left image has a close-up black and white photo of a hand holding a textured object at the top left, smaller color images of a workshop and bead designs below, and two dark rectangles labeled 'M' and 'L' at the bottom right. However, the right image better matches the prompt as it includes the specified elements: a close-up black and white photo of a hand holding a textured object, smaller images of a workshop and bead designs, a large column of text on the right page, and two dark rectangles labeled 'A' and 'L' with accompanying text blocks. The right image also captures the glossy texture of the magazine paper and maintains a clean, professional aesthetic with a balanced layout. | right | Replace the rectangles labeled 'M' and 'L' with rectangles labeled 'A' and 'L' and add accompanying text blocks. Adjust the layout to include a large column of text on the right page, ensuring a balanced composition. |
Subsets and Splits