Looking for Feedback
Hi everyone,
I'm looking for feedback on Consilium MCP. Please let me know what you think is good, what could be improved, what you feel is missing, or anything else related to my Hackathon submission.
Best regards,
Andreas
Hi Andreas 👋,
Wow — Consilium MCP is seriously impressive! 🧠⚙️ From what I can see, it’s a well-rounded and thoughtfully architected system. The integration of different expert models, the role system, and the real-time discussion view are very polished. I especially appreciated how you still use tools like the ArxivSearchTool — it feels so obvious in hindsight, yet I hadn’t seen it used like this before. Very smart! 🧪🔍
The platform feels both robust and elegant. Clean implementation, smooth interaction — and quite visionary in its approach to structured AI consensus. It’s clear that a lot of love and expertise went into it. 🎭
One small suggestion: in my browser, the discussion log felt a bit cramped or hard to scan. Maybe adding a few more lines of visible context or padding would improve readability. Totally optional — just if time allows for a small UI polish pass. 😊
Overall, this is one of the most advanced and complete submissions I’ve seen — hats off! 🎩 Looking forward to seeing where this goes next.
You should consider refactoring your code into smaller peaces.
Warm regards, Christof
Hi Christof,
thanks a lot for the feedback! Will try to increase the speech bubble content area and refactor the code a little, now that the Hackathon is over there is lots of time for such details :)
BR
Andreas