Proponents of the recently introduced tax on sales of new luxury boats had argued that a tax of this sort would be an equitable way to increase government revenue because the admittedly heavy tax burden would fall only on wealthy people and neither they nor anyone else would suffer any economic hardship. In fact, however, 20 percent of the workers employed by manufacturers of luxury boats have lost their jobs as a direct result of this tax. The information given, if true, most strongly supports which of the following?
A: Before the tax was instituted, luxury boats were largely bought by people who were not wealthy.
B: The market for luxury boats would have collapsed even if the new tax on luxury boats had been lower.
C: Taxes can be equitable only if their burden is evenly distributed over the entire population.
D: The new tax would produce a net gain in tax revenue for the government only if the yearly total revenue that it generates exceeds the total of any yearly tax-revenue decrease resulting from the workers' loss of jobs.
Choose A, B, C or D as your solution.
D