Which logical fallacy is used in the text?
Elizabeth claims that the Kensington Ferrets' new quarterback is better than their old one. I think Elizabeth is being unfair: the Ferrets' old quarterback wasn't a terrible player.

 - straw man: a misrepresentation of an opponent's position that makes it easier to argue against
 - bandwagon fallacy: the assumption that the popular choice is automatically correct
 - appeal to nature: the assumption that natural things are always good
The text argues that Elizabeth thinks the Ferrets' old quarterback was a terrible player. But this misrepresents Elizabeth's argument. Elizabeth only claims that the Ferrets' new quarterback is better. This argument doesn't necessarily imply that the old quarterback was a bad player. This illustrates a type of logical fallacy known as a straw man.