Somewhat fair points, with a couple of key pieces of data left out:<p>&gt; one is about a device the FBI has, the other is about everyone&#x27;s device<p>Except that one Apple claim is making, whether realistic or not, is that once the &quot;device the FBI has&quot; is unlocked, it potentially exposes &quot;everyone&#x27;s device&quot; to the same exploit<p>&gt; If you want a gun analogy can the FBI force a manufacturer to tell them the proper disassembly instructions for the gun<p>Except that in the case of the gun, this is information the manufacturer already has.  In Apple&#x27;s case, they are claiming they do not currently have this information, and would need to do work to create the information being requested.