The specifics are important. If I said, &quot;If a police officer gives you a lawful order do you have to comply?&quot; you would immediately say, &quot;yes&quot;. Now what if I said, &quot;If a police officer demands that an entire neighborhood be subject to lengthy interrogation and be held for 24 hours in custody in order to solve a murder that took place there.&quot; You&#x27;d probably say that&#x27;s ridiculous.<p>That&#x27;s essentially what I view to be the case here. In theory the procedure may be perfectly &quot;lawful&quot; but in practice is clearly overreach. We need case law around this. I believe this is as clear a case of overreach as Apple could wish for. Finally, I believe it should be legal precedent set in public for once.