I don't understand this logic. He may have built a successful, efficient and popular service. But he still did so on the basis of other people's work and the entire basis of the site was to take away the creator's control over their own work. Sure his site itself contained nothing illegal and all that. But the fact remains that the people who create a piece of intellectual property must retain the rights to do with it as they please. They shouldn't have to be taken at the whims of the community just because a lot of people happen to like/want it. If Salinger had decided he never wanted any of his books published and no one should ever read them, that's his choice, not ours. If we can't respect the people that create and/or own the intellectual property, then we are part of a disgusting society.