Largely speaking I agree with you.  My problem here is that I don't know what I've done wrong.  If those responsible (PG and his editors) want to communicate a message to me, they've failed.<p>I haven't gone around upvoting and downvoting excessively.  I've upvoted a few things I think are of value, and I don't remember downvoting anything recently.<p>I'm just confused.<p>Feedback works best when it's consistent in direction (but not in frequency) and clearly attached to the action that provoked it.  I think PG and friends do a great job on this.  I think this is something they get wrong.