[is that frossie frossie?  hi!]<p>i'm not sure what problem you're talking about - someone reproduced the results with separate code and data, so what's to worry about?  (i don't mean that because it was confirmed it was ok, but rather that if it had been wrong, we would have known in the end...  after all, people make mistakes all the time - science is a collective enterprise that relies on many overlapping, interlocking pieces)