&gt; You don&#x27;t think the incoherence of the following posts 
&gt; proves the flaggers correct?<p>I lack certainty, but I think the post I vouched for is still a useful addition to the conversation.  Generally, I try to flag (and recently, unflag) individual posts rather than expected user behavior.<p>That said, I probably wouldn&#x27;t have tried to recover it if I&#x27;d read the Weimerica comment first.  The later posts have some oblique insights.  I can why one might downvote them (I didn&#x27;t), but (unless I missed something) they don&#x27;t seem flagworthy.<p>&gt; are you saying happy thanks giving to me (not a mod) or dang (a mod)?<p>I was saying Happy Thanksgiving to the moderator Dan Gackle, since Monday is the Thanksgiving holiday in Canada.  I hoped this was clear since he&#x27;s the author of the grandparent comment, but I suppose other Dan&#x27;s can share the goodwill!