I was just pointing out that &quot;specifically to torture innocent people&quot; was misleading and wrong.<p>&gt;Suspicion is not grounds for torture. Guilt is not grounds for torture either! That&#x27;s what the 8th Amendment is about.<p>Morally, you have a point. But from your mention of the 8th Amendment, it looks like you&#x27;re talking legally, in which case only US citizens and people covered under relevant international agreements have such rights.