Ok I'm just throwing my two cents in here to help Malficent. Charisma DOES include Appearance according to the book. Now to solve this problem you could go with what the "Book of Erotic Fantasey" Suggests and make a separate Appearance Stat.<br/><br/>If However you do decide not to go that rout then Charisma INCLUDES the appearance of your character. Nuff Said. Just remember above all the GM of the game HAS FINAL SAY so why don't you bring the situation up to her and let her decide how she wants the situation to be handled.