No, that's just what I mean - your posts 2-3 rounds back are also wrong, including the one where you 'made it to the surface'. You can scroll back through my several IC and OOC thread posts where I did Climb checks for her in painstaking detail (including those while taking damage); IIRC she failed one of her accelerated climb checks by 5 and thus fell and had to start over. The events for you to reconstruct everything are there in past posts. I think you may things find more clear if you try and read each of my posts as they occur; somehow you're ignoring or not noticing lots of things.  If I try to explain the timeline of what happened to Cecily in more detail, I'll end up literally copy-pasting my previous posts, so my recommendation is for you to just rescan them (which will also contain more context than if I copy-paste it all here).<br/><br/>(And incidentally, even if she had made it to the surface on her last conscious round, the total defense action wouldn't help vs the spell that felled her. I don't think the (total) defense action improves reflex saves, just AC.)