Well, although it doesn't make you stupid, as written it<em>is</em>autobluff:<br/>"The spell does not enable you to control the charmed person as if it were an automaton, but<strong> it perceives your words and actions in the most favorable way</strong>."<br/><br/>If you do not believe the charmer's words, you are not perceiving them in the most favorable way... that should not be a choice available to the charmee.  This is, I think, why the actual effect of charm is so very DM-dependent... "as written" it's absurdly powerful for such a low-level spell.  Such as in our present circumstances, three girls really should have no alternative but to see Rafael's suggestions as the best option ... hearing an alternate suggestion and favouring it would go against the spell description.<br/><br/>Of course, if one ignores the bolded part of the spell description and just sticks with "trusted friend and ally", it's much less powerful, but that "trusted" bit still remains.  If you're saying, DM, that charmed girls can be persuaded the charmer is lying, than yes there were other options all along... and I'll have Bree try that.  I've never heard of a charmed character being talked out of their charm, however.<br/><br/><br/>The tremors, yes, I remembered them - I was just hinting that it could open a way for our escape.  :-)<br/>