Gilbert looks on Rose, wondering who or what told there was five heirs in here instead four? But is a mystery and he is curious but he would not had been ready, nor willing, reveal himself for the answer. But it seems his trickery has been found and he sees little to no reason to further upset Rose or others if they suspect it and replies; "Yes to both questions. But the matter which why I am hiding my heritage is something private which only other heirs should know. It was not duty what called me come here nor reason why I am hiding." He moves his hand slowly to his hand where ring is. Both Ehren and Rose sees his fingers lock on something and drag along his finger...until in finger tip suddenly there is blurring and the signet ring of Gaius appears! He inserts the ring back on his finger but this time it remains visible on his finger. All accounts wise it was exact same ring as four heirs have. Gilbert looks on Rose and says; "Now, what answer your holding back and why you would need me drag into the cave? No need drag me by the ear by the way. I got that enough done to me in monastery to know not idle when we need go somewhere."