Okay, after deliberation, I've decided Nicci does have a point. For those curious, it was primarily the duration argument and the point about characters enterting the area during the 1d3 aftermath that swayed me. I do think that the spell is ambiguously written, and that it could be read either way.<br/><br/>After talking things over, here's what's going to happen: we're going to keep going with the scene.<em>From here on out</em>, hitting someone during the 1d3 rounds after<em>enthrall</em>ends will not initiate hostilities. Also, due to my misreading of the spell, I will note that the caster of enthrall<em>cannot</em>exclude anyone in the area from the effect, except herself or himself.<br/><br/>That said, until further notice, the previously enthralled will be hostile towards Astarotte until the succubus makes some personal effort to curry favor with them, personally, or as a group.