I'm leaning toward interrigation on the questions brought up and using the deduced information as a standard of truthfulness. If she resist in any way, hit her with the whammy spell and question her at great length about everything from her bra size to her menstral cycle... and the bandits too. While we're at it with the whammy, ask her about her intentions.<br/><br/>If she is really repentent, ask the trading post couple if they want to take her on to pay off her debt. If she resit... there's not much choice.