"Ah, let me guess: *insert accurate description of man*, smells vaguely like he recently soiled himself?  Yeah, he was one of the ones who was abducting girls from around town and had everyone scared out of their minds, the proof of which is standing behind me barely standing from being drugged up by those guys and their 'friends' down below." she said, gesturing to the girls, then to the hole she just got out of "Now, how did I decide?  Well, the first murders were probably because they tried to jump me to abduct me, and I defended myself, like I just said.  The ones down below?  Same thing; self-defense, trying to save the girls, really I<em>just</em>explained what had happened, and if you know anything about religion maybe the little temple-thing down in the cellar will tell you what for about what was going on."<br/><br/>She paused, took a step forward, hands crossed behind her back.<br/><br/>"That, that is the truth, but let's assume it's<em>not</em>, just for speculation." she said, still smiling "The alternative is I'm someone who engages in armed robbery with a piddly little dagger, then for no apparent reason decided to murder a number of VERY tough and unsavory looking men for no reason, then wandered over here and just started mass-murdering people who just HAPPENED to be in a secret underground and likely illegal temple that nobody would normally find without having been told where it was, but decided to spare the girls behind me - again, no logical rhyme or reason to it - in order to come up here and first thing's first find the cops because they just HAPPENED to be the girls taken from the town recently... that is an AWFUL lot of coincidences, don't you think?"<br/><br/>"So, either I'm a hero who just solved a problem that has been plaguing the town for a while... or I'm a completely insane sociopath who is just amazingly<em>lucky</em>in finding out the town's problems.  Which do you think makes more sense, considering that you're talking to me and not trying to kill me out of fear?"