With a whole deer to enjoy, as well as the guts and bones the humans didn't want from the second, he had better have been grateful. Caiaphias was the first to notice Whisper having returned, though she was probably smug it had taken him a minute or so to notice her. Still, once they had the extra meat smoking, he left Murphy with the stew, and headed over to Whisper. He sat down beside her, and started giving her scratches, starting at the back of her neck, a place she always enjoyed.