Okay, so I talked with Raven to see where she was, and she just expressed a concern that the characters are leaning a bit too heavily in the "dark" side of things.  I agree with her.  I'm okay with having some angst, and you know, some darkness is good, but I want the tone of this game to be a bit more balanced, especially for the characters who were "light" characters in the books.  So I'm not saying you can't have them maturing into less than virtuous characters, but keep in mind that the things in the books, before the epilogue are canon.  So they should still have some redeeming qualities, that the canon characters had in Hogwarts, even(especially) in the face of adversity.  If you feel that your characters do have that, and maybe this isn't coming across, add some into your sheets, pm me to run ideas at me, just, add some good qualities in to balance things out.  If I was going to state how I prefer the games tone to be, I'd say I'd want it to be neither dark nor light, but somewhere grey in the middle. And if you do have a character that was a hero in the books, but is in the middle of some hard times, come up with a goal for them to work through it.