You always have to add the modifier. I see that her Sharp rating is -1. So for her Read A Bad Situation roll, it would be a 5 instead of 6, and her Investigate A Mystery would be a 6, instead of 7.<br/><br/>If that's the case, both rolls are failures.<br/><br/>But how would Ashlee try to read a bad situation or investigate a mystery? Would she come out of the tent to do so? How in detail would she go about her moves?