So to try and answer your question Mercurial and using H1 as an example, although  we had 7 green votes but only 3 red the game still didn't hit the top three because many of the 'grey' votes were 4s, 5s and such. I see 4s and 5s as almost as bad as red votes. It indicates a general lack of interest in that storyline I think.<br/><br/>Looking at H5 as another example (I am most comfortable pulling holes in the game ideas I proposed BTW rather than other peoples) while this one gathered 6 green votes (including a 12 and 3 11s) all six red votes were 1s and 2s - that was my basis of claiming that there is a 'love it or hate it' type of game and I don't think H5 is good material for this group. It would obviously be great material for the six people who voted it high and maybe now we can see the votes laid out we might consider running three, four or more games out of this discussion so that each is smaller but each has entirely gung-ho people playing in them.