*chuckles*<br/><br/>Let's see... Lilly is being punished for attempting to escape. Rule 7. Yes, she said she was just hiding because she was feeling shy, or some such nonsense, but we all know she was attempting to leave the grounds without permission!<br/><br/>Effie is being used as a means of punishing Lilly, with a promise of a reward if she does well....<br/><br/>Beth - Um... it would appear that Beth isn't actually being punished! You can't punish someone with something they are enjoying.<br/><br/>The case for the defence rests!