With Rapture, the question of slavery is one of choice.  If someone really doesn’t want to be a slave, it’s cruel to keep them that way, but if they do, they should be cared for and taken care of.  It’s a lot like love in that you can’t force it, but the few who stay are loyal.<br/><br/>I think everyone can agree that it should be the choice of the would-be slave…at least inasmuch as choice is a thing in Exalted.