Officially, yes, the massive ogre thingie IS magical and so counts as AC9 for one of you.<br/><br/>Willard didn't make it.  This is the usual fate of a Cthulhu Mythos investigator that goes up against something this big.<br/><br/>Soph, I took the liberty of applying your Luck result to something that it could affect.  If you would prefer I ret-con that, then I'll roll damage for Jenny.  The Big Guy does<em>not</em>roll to hit.  He just smites someone automatically for 1d12 damage.