GMC completely changed combat around though. For one thing, Defense is lower of Wits or Dex + Athletics. For another, in a situation like this you'd probably want to use the Beat Down ruleset. Basically, both characters declare intent. (Daryl would say, for example 'I want to prove myself worthy of joining the Storm Lords', while Selene would pick 'I want to humiliate this chump').<br/><br/>Then you'd roll initiative, the two would fight it out. A dodge action in this case doubles defense but requires the character to roll their defense instead, removing successes on a one for one basis. The two would fight, and the first to take more than their stamina in bashing, or any amount of lethal would be 'beaten down'. They'd have to spend willpower to continue fighting, or simply give up to gain a willpower but give the other character what they want.<br/><br/>