Why does gigabit internet via coax cable not offer symmetrical speed like fiber?
I do quite a bit of DOCSIS consulting.<p>There are both technical and business reasons for the gap between upstream and downstream speeds<p>There are a few  technical reasons. There is less upstream frequency available in the upstream. 42 MHz is the standard upstream/downstream split, 85 MHz is a midsplit, 200 MHz is a high split, and the downstream goes up to 1Ghz or even 1.2Ghz. The upstream modulation runs at 64 QAM (~27Mbs) and downstream modulation runs at 256 QAM (~38 Mbps). The upstream is also more sustainable to interference and impairments. So the technology is inherently imbalanced.<p>From a business prospective it is very difficult to cost justify. Moving the upstream/downstream split and/or upgrading to DOCSIS 3.1 is very expensive. The reality is that the typical customer use very little upstream bandwidth. It isn't uncommon for me to see a node with 24 or 32 downstream channels at 80% usage and 4 upstream channels are at 25% utilization or less.  We see a downstream to upstream usage ratio of about 15:1.  If you move the US/DS split that means you are taking away from available downstream frequency which means less DS data bandwidth or fewer video channels. It's hard to make a business case to invest in increasing upstream bandwidth when the data says people aren't going to use it.<p>Newer technology like DOCSIS 3.1, Docsis FDX, Remote PHY and modern plant designs like N+0 or N+1 (which means fewer customers per node) will bring higher upstream bandwidth, but it will be awhile before we see anything close to symmetrical speeds.