What does it feel like to be stupid? An anonymous Quora user explains.
Meta:<p>This, to me, is a fundamental problem with the Posterous culture.  Here we have a post on a Posterous blog <i>made by a Posterous co-founder</i> which copies, <i>in its entirety</i> and with no significant commentary, a work published elsewhere.<p>It’s attributed with a link to the source — barely, in lowercased, tiny font, at the bottom. The headline is a link to the Posterous page, not the source (unlike Daring Fireball “linked list” items, for example).  How many people will actually follow the link?  Why is this Posterous blog entry #1 on HN when a permalink to the original source on Quora is readily available?<p>Let’s be clear.  This is not “fair use.”  It’s not <i>plagiarism,</i> as Garry doesn’t claim he wrote the anecdote; but it’s a violation of copyright. It’s publishing without permission of the copyright holder.†<p>My first submission to Hacker News was an original item I posted to my own website.  It got quite a few reads — but a lot of people were re-tweeting a link to a full copy of it hosted on <i>someone else’s Posterous.</i>  That user didn’t add much (A sentence expressing “me, too”).  I was conflicted: Glad people found my writing interesting enough to duplicate and share, but disappointed that they were reading it on someone else’s site for no good reason.<p>I see now that if the company’s own bloggers consider copyright a joke, if they believe posting other people’s articles verbatim is kosher, well, can we be surprised their users do, too?<p>(Postscript: This differs from Tumblr’s “re-blogging” in one important way: You only re-blog other Tumblr posts. “Re-blogging” is part of the Tumblr system. You expect it there if you post there. You don’t “lose” anything by it. I have no problem there.)<p>† I don’t know if Quora’s terms of service mean that consent is implied, but honestly, in this case and this case only (the case of a Posterous employee), it doesn’t matter, because it’s about setting precedent for the community.