OpenBSD PF versus FreeBSD PF
And if you're using FreeBSD with a fast NIC, look into the pfilctl command and use a "head" input hook into your NIC driver's  ethernet input handling routine. Doing this allows the firewall input checks to happen early, before the packet has been received into the network stack, while its still in DMA-mapped, driver-owned buffers.  If the firewall decides a packet is to be dropped, the NIC can recycle the buffer with minimal overhead (skips DMA-unmap, buffer free, ethernet input into the IP stack, and the replacement buffer alloc, DMA map).<p>This allows for <i>very</i> fast dropping of DOS flood attacks.  I've tested this using ipfw up to screening and dropping several 10s of millions of packets on 2014 era Xeons with minimal impact to traffic serving.   I wrote a paper about this for a conf. that was cancelled due to COVID.  I really need to re-submit it someplace.<p>This works for Mellanox, Chelsio, and NICs that use iflib (ix, ixl, igb, bnxt, and more that I'm forgetting).