What has happened down here is the winds have changed
&gt; 2011: Daryl Bem publishes his article, “Feeling the future: Experimental evidence for anomalous retroactive influences on cognition and affect,” in a top journal in psychology. Not too many people thought Bem had discovered ESP but there was a general impression that his work was basically solid, and thus this was presented as a concern for pscyhology research.<p>&gt; In retrospect, Bem’s paper had huge, obvious multiple comparisons problems—the editor and his four reviewers just didn’t know what to look for—but back in 2011 we weren’t so good at noticing this sort of thing.<p>I was a postdoc in a Psychology department when this was going on, and &quot;obvious multiple comparisons problems&quot; isn&#x27;t a good characterization. Any competent psychology researcher in 2011 (a) understood multiple comparisons and looked for them as a matter of course (b) knew there was something wrong with Bem&#x27;s paper (see the editorial disclaimer).<p>Here is the main takedown of it:
<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;dl.dropboxusercontent.com&#x2F;u&#x2F;1018886&#x2F;Bem6.pdf" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;dl.dropboxusercontent.com&#x2F;u&#x2F;1018886&#x2F;Bem6.pdf</a><p>That is some pretty advanced statistics, not just &quot;correct for multiple comparisons&quot;.<p>What was ongoing then, and continues now, is that psychology and social science in general is coming around to the realization that the tools of the past 50 years are flawed, and to correct them, they need to become better statisticians. But it isn&#x27;t a matter of &quot;take stats 101 noobs&quot;, these are people who have been doing statistical analysis routinely for years. I think there is anxiety that to really do things right you need to _primarily be_ a statistician.<p>So there is some defensiveness in social sciences about this, certainly not helped by the fact that every jackass on the internet whose taken an undergrad math class thinks they know better.<p>In the end I quit my psych research job to be a software engineer since all the stats hurt my head and I needed something less quantitative to do.