Why even let users set their own passwords?
&gt; Often this will be combined with fallacious notions such as “remember this device”, the idea being you only have to go through all this the first time when logging in from a particular device. This idea is fallacious because the web has no notion of a “device”, and this is a very intentional design choice made for privacy purposes. We are literally living through the gradual phase-out of third-party cookies, amongst other functionality, specifically to try and prevent this sort of thing, so why do web developers persist in believing in this fiction of a “device”? My own browser erases all cookies from an origin immediately after the last tab from that origin is closed, so these sites are convinced I am logging in from a new “device” every single time, and then demand I respond to one of these challenge emails.<p>The phasing out of third-party cookies has nothing to do with the &quot;remember this device&quot; functionality, because those are almost always powered by first-party cookies, which are <i>not</i> being phased out.<p>The author has configured their browser to throw away cookies when the last tab closes, and that&#x27;s their prerogative, but anyone who is savvy enough to configure that setting is also savvy enough to understand that that will break &quot;remember this device&quot;. For everyone else, that phrasing is a perfectly reasonable abstraction on what is actually happening.