Home > node > Classical CDs Weekly: Ivanovs, Shi-An Costello, Sean Shibe
Classical CDs Weekly: Ivanovs, Shi-An Costello, Sean Shibe | reviews, news & interviews
Classical CDs Weekly: Ivanovs, Shi-An Costello, Sean Shibe
Latvian orchestral music, mischievous pianism, plus a guitarist of two halves
by Graham RicksonSaturday, 29 September 2018
Jãnis Ivanovs at work
Jãnis Ivanovs: Symphony No. 5; Juris Karlsons: Music for Symphony Orchestra 1945 Latvian National Symphony Orchestra/Andris Poga (Skani)
Jãnis Ivanovs' promising conducting career was kyboshed by the outbreak of war and the Soviet invasion of Latvia. After Riga's liberation in October 1944, it's believed that Ivanovs was responsible for broadcasting one of the five surviving records belonging to the reactivated state radio station, and his Symphony No. 5 was completed during the following spring. Asked about the symphony's meaning, Ivanovs replied that the music "contained everything that had accumulated over those years." The official reception was initially positive, though by 1948 the Soviet censors condemned the symphony: "…there are no folk melodies… elements of Western jazz are offered with delight and relish… it is against the people." Which will probably make you want to listen to it all the more.
Ivanovs 5 is indeed a terrific large-scale piece. Shostakovich is an audible influence, though Ivanovs' themes are less clear cut and his orchestration is heavier. It's a dark wartime symphony par excellence; you can understand it making the critics nervous. The fleeting glimpses of sunlight are all the more powerful as a result: I'm thinking of the blowsy trumpet motif and lopsided waltz in the scherzo, or an oddly jaunty theme in the finale, replete with offbeat percussion. The final chords sound genuinely triumphant. The coupling is Juris Karlsons's Music for Symphony Orchestra 1945. Born in 1948, Karlsons was a student of Ivanovs and completed the latter's final symphony after his death in 1983. This work was commissioned in 1985 to commemorate the ending of the Great Patriotic War, the numbers 1, 9, 4 and 5 woven into the musical material. Noisy, imposing and an unabashed crowd-pleaser, it's still impressive. Listen out for the accordion. An exemplary release: nicely packaged, well annotated and impeccably performed.
Shi-An Costello: Rounded Binary: Preludes and Fugues of Bach and Shostakovich (Blue Griffin)
Pianist Shi-an Costello's "life goal" is "to be multitudinous and unified, contrasting with and complementary to oneself." Hmm. There's not much musical information in his booklet note, but what he writes sort of makes sense, Costello aiming to link two stylistically different composers and their binary pairs of preludes and fugues with the "soft, rounded lines" of hyphens instead of oblique slashes. Maybe it's best just to listen: Costello's imaginatively sequenced disc switches between preludes and fugues by Bach and Shostakovich, sometimes repeating numbers in contrasting performances. Bach's BWV 846 Fugue in C is sliced into neat chunks, the final bars heard as the penultimate track. The results are occasionally like eavesdropping on a precocious student in a practice room, in a good way: I've rarely smiled so much during a piano recital.
Compare Costello's two readings of Bach's C major prelude, the second one twice as fast as the first. Both are deeply satisfying, the speeded-up version clearly articulated and full of life. He does the same with both halves of the Prelude and Fugue in B minor: the fast account dazzles and the slower one oozes gravitas. The Shostakovich numbers are equally good, the voices in the D major fugue ideally clear. Schumann's Traumerei pops up in the middle, like a cinematic intermission. The best is saved to the end, Bach and Shostakovich ingeniously conjoined with a brilliant mash-up of both composer's C major preludes: possibly the most enchanting little piano piece I've heard all year. Fascinating, and entertaining.
Sean Shibe: softLoud (Delphian)
Guitarist Sean Shibe's second disc would work brilliantly as a vinyl LP, each side inhabiting a very different world. He gets through five centuries' worth of material in less than an hour, and I'd recommend listening to it on CD in one sitting, without reading the notes beforehand. Shibe opens with his own transcriptions of ten Scottish pieces: a meltingly lovely Divertimento by one James Oswald and a sequence of eight numbers drawn from Scottish lute manuscripts, anonymous ditties straddling the divide between native folk culture and European art music. There are some exquisite things here: the tiny "Swit Sant Nickola" and "A Scots Tune", both from the same source, are irresistible, the latter segueing perfectly into James MacMillan's "From Galloway" and an intriguing "Motet I" taken from Since it was the day of Preparation… its mixture of old and new sounds suggesting Stravinsky's Agon.
And then it all kicks off, a multi-tracked Shibe switching to a Fender Stratocaster for an incisive reading of Steve Reich's Electric Counterpoint, the last movement's angular theme ideally clear. Reich himself describes this is as one of the work's greatest recordings. He's right; and production-wise it's near-perfect, with every strand clear. The Reich won't prepare you for what follows. Nothing will. If you're sufficiently antediluvian to still possess an amplifier and speakers, crank them up and encourage your neighbours to go out. Julia Wolfe's LAD was composed for nine bagpipes. It's unbelievably loud, Shibe gleefully recreating the massed pipes' drone, creating a stark wall of sound that's simultaneously exhilarating and terrifying. David Lang's Killer ends proceedings with a sharp, savage punch. This disc works on so many levels. Shibe's playing is predictably excellent, and it's fun to hear him electrified. It's also an expression of rage at the political events of 2016 and a celebration of quiet musical beauty. Buy the disc. Read the sleeve notes. Smile at the sleeve photo.
Read more of Graham Rickson's Classical CDs Weekly on theartsdesk
Noisy, imposing and an unabashed crowd-pleaser, it's still impressive
Ivanovs on AmazonShi-An Costello on AmazonSean Shibe on Amazon
theartsdesk in Riga - 43,290 Latvians sing and dance for their country
theartsdesk in Estonia and Latvia - Pärnu Music Festival's great orchestra goes south
Classical CDs Weekly: Sean Shibe, Morten Gunnar Larsen and Leonard Elschenbroich
Shibe, Egmont Ensemble, Wigmore Hall
more Classical music
Pick of the BBC Proms 2019 Our classical music/opera reviewers choose their favourites from the next eight weeks
Londinium, Griffiths, St John's Waterloo review - a choral Grand Tour Leading London choir demonstrate imaginative programming and committed singing
Classical CDs Weekly: Jupiter String Quartet, Bruce Levingston, Paul McCreesh Newly-commissioned chamber music, a thought-provoking piano recital and a spectacular choral anthology
Alder, The Mozartists, Page, Wigmore Hall review - a Mozart feast for eyes and ears Period-instrument thrills and a state-of-the-art soprano
'A product not only of his era but also of his travels': Ian Page on Mozart's cosmopolitan education The Mozartists' main man on how an early life moving around Europe shaped a genius
The Anvil, Royal, Purves, BBCPO, Gernon, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester - disturbing, baffling and moving This commemoration of the Peterloo Massacre is the kind of art that Manchester loves
Chetham's Symphony Orchestra, Chetham's Chorus, Threlfall, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester - a thrilling triumph Truly awesome Mahler is the highspot of Chetham's 50th anniversary year
Classical CDs Weekly: Dove, Leighton, Martin, Vaughan Williams Two very different British composers, and a pair of mass settings
theartsdesk in Treviso - cultural patronage, Italian style High-level attention to detail in the Fondazione Benetton's support for the arts
London Mozart Players, Davan Wetton, St Giles Cripplegate - rousing Shakespearean revel Summer Music in City Churches festival closes with a celebration of the bard
Classical CDs Weekly: David Matthews, José Rolón, Shirley Smart A new English symphony, Mexican piano music and a transcontinental cellist