Fraser of Allander Institute Blog
FAI Publications
Scottish Economy
UK Economy
2019 General Election: a review of the manifestos from a Scottish perspective
Inevitably, the defining feature of all the manifestos this election is the spectre of constitutional change.
For the UK-wide parties this is an issue of Brexit (or stopping Brexit), whilst in Scotland there is the added question of independence.
Beyond these major constitutional debates, reading UK election manifestos can feel a strange business from a Scottish perspective. Most of the policy pledges relate to areas that are devolved, with the next Holyrood election not for another 18 months.
Nonetheless, these pledges will still have major implications for Scotland's budget, whilst also framing the view of what policies might be politically viable here. This is true for spending commitments, but it is now increasingly true of tax policy too.
The choices facing the electorate are stark, not just on the constitution but also day-to-day tax and spending choices. It is no surprise that with so much uncertainty, Derek Mackay has shelved plans for a pre-Christmas Scottish Budget
So what do the manifestos imply for Scotland and the Scottish Budget?Continue reading
Scotland's population – a talk to the David Hume Institute
Earlier this week the Director of the Fraser of Allander Institute Graeme Roy delivered a talk to the David Hume Institute on the subject of Scotland's population; specifically how demographics have shaped our country, and the challenges they present in the future.
You can see Graeme's slides, and the associated text below.
Presentation slides from the talk.
You can download the slides in PDF format here.
Text of the talk.
You can download this PDF here.
The Scottish budget 2020/21: postponed for now… but til when?
The Scottish Government had been due to publish its draft budget for 2020/21 on 12th December.
The postponement of the UK Government's budget – which had been scheduled for 6th November – had already thrown the status of the Scottish budget date into doubt. But the announcement of the General Election on the 12th December clearly necessitated a postponement of the Scottish budget. The Scottish Government announced last week that the Scottish budget will not be published until after Christmas.
But given that we don't know when the next UK budget will be, when should we expect the Scottish budget? Is it even possible for the Scottish budget to be published before the UK budget, and what would be the implications if it was?Continue reading
Presentations from Scotland's Budget Report 2019 Event
On Tuesday we published our fourth annual Scotland's Budget Report. This was accompanied by an event at the National Museum of Scotland.
Alongside the FAI analysis, Paul Johnson, Director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, Andy King from the Office for Budget Responsibility, Caroline Gardner, Scotland's Auditor General, and Charlotte Barbour, director of taxation for ICAS, also spoke at the event. All discussed the current fiscal environment which is made all the more uncertain by the General Election and the flurry of announcements by all political parties on future spending commitments.
These presentations can be found below.
FAI Scotland's Budget 2019 slides – Presented by Mairi Spowage and David Eiser, FAI
Taxation – Growing divergence? – Presented by Charlotte Barbour, ICAS
Fiscal risks in the UK – Presented by Andy King, OBR
Financial planning in uncertain times – Presented by Caroline Gardner, Scotland's Auditor General
Economic and fiscal outlook – Presented by Paul Johnson, IFS
Key points from our Scotland's Budget Report 2019
Today we published our 4th annual Scotland's Budget Report.
The latest report shows that the Scottish Government's resource budget in the past three years has evolved more healthily than was anticipated at the start of the parliamentary term in 2016, due to both UK government spending increases and Scottish government tax decisions.
Following announcements of further spending increases this year – and via the Barnett Formula – the outlook for Scotland's resource block grant from Westminster has improved even further this year and next. Real terms increases of around 2% per annum are anticipated for the next two years, the first time period of consistent real terms increases since the start of the 'austerity' period.
But two issues, both relating to devolved income tax, will offset some of this increase:
1. The block grant in each of the next two years will be reduced to take account of the fact that outturn Scottish income tax revenues in 2017/18 and 2018/19 turned out to be lower than forecast. The Scottish Government will be required to repay £200m in 2020/21 and potentially as much as £600m in 2021/22.
2. On the basis of the latest official forecasts, Scottish income tax revenues are on track to disappoint relative to the rest of the UK.
As a result, despite the block grant from Westminster growing by 2.1% in 2020/21, the resources available to the Scottish Government may still only grow by less than 1% in real terms.
All this comes at a time of heightened political and economic uncertainty. Financial responsibility for £3.5bn of social security spending will transfer to the Scottish budget in April 2020, bringing new pressures and risks.
199 Cathedral Street
G4 0QU
(Closest entrance at 130 Rottenrow)
fraser@strath.ac.uk
Copyright © 2018 The Fraser of Allander Institute