id
int64 6
49.9k
| object1
stringlengths 3
32
| object2
stringlengths 3
28
| original_img
imagewidth (px) 1.28k
1.28k
| edited_img
imagewidth (px) 1.28k
1.28k
| sc_score
dict | min_sc_score
int64 0
10
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
16,853 | metal container | wooden crate | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The metal container in the original image has been successfully replaced by a wooden crate in the edited image. The wooden crate is clearly visible, and there is no trace of the metal container.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the metal container with a wooden crate. The person, background, and other elements remain unchanged, indicating no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
30,931 | wifi symbol | Bluetooth symbol | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The wifi symbol in the original image has been successfully replaced by the Bluetooth symbol in the edited image. There is no overlap or presence of the wifi symbol in the edited image, and the replacement is clear and effective.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the wifi symbol with the Bluetooth symbol. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
16,520 | ice cream cone table | pizza slice table | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The ice cream cone table in the original image has been successfully replaced by a pizza slice table in the edited image. The replacement is clear and follows the editing instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background, chairs, and other elements in the scene remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to the replacement of the table. There is no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
41,036 | Fireworks | Laser lights | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains fireworks instead of laser lights. The editing instruction to replace fireworks with laser lights was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
38,806 | running shoe | basketball shoe | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not successfully replace the running shoe with a basketball shoe. The shoe in the edited image still resembles a running shoe with minor design changes, and there is no clear distinction indicating it is a basketball shoe.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the shoe design and does not affect the background or other elements of the image. However, the changes to the shoe are minimal and do not fully align with the instruction, which slightly affects the relevance of the edit.",
"score": [
2,
8
],
"score for Task1": 2,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 2 |
||
7,421 | vending machine | snack dispenser | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a vending machine instead of a snack dispenser, so the editing instruction was not followed at all.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction, as the scene remains consistent with the original image apart from minor details.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
43,378 | dog | cat | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The dog in the original image has been successfully replaced by a cat in the edited image. There is no trace of the dog, and the cat is clearly visible, fulfilling the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain consistent between the original and edited images. The edit is limited to replacing the dog with the cat, and there is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
6,743 | sports car | motorcycle | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The sports car in the original image has been successfully replaced by a motorcycle in the edited image. There is no visible trace of the sports car, and the motorcycle is clearly present.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the scene remain consistent between the two images, with no significant changes beyond the replacement of the sports car with the motorcycle.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
8,396 | football players | basketball players | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains football players, and the basketball players are not convincingly introduced. The edit does not successfully replace football players with basketball players.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit introduces a basketball and changes the jersey of one player, but the background and other elements remain largely unchanged. However, the changes are not limited to the instruction, as the players' uniforms and context are altered inconsistently.",
"score": [
0,
5
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 5
} | 0 |
||
39,675 | top | dress | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already shows a dress, and there is no visible change in the edited image. The instruction to replace a top with a dress is not applicable here.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no visible change between the two images, and no overediting is observed. The edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
11,253 | sneakers | sandals | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not replace the sneakers with sandals as instructed. Instead, the sneakers are replaced with a different design of sneakers featuring cartoon characters. Therefore, the edit does not follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background has changed significantly from a plain white background to an outdoor setting, which is beyond the scope of the editing instruction. This constitutes overediting.",
"score": [
0,
2
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 2
} | 0 |
||
39,440 | beer pong table | pool table | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The beer pong table in the original image has been successfully replaced by a pool table in the edited image. There is no trace of the beer pong table, and the pool table is clearly visible and well-integrated into the scene.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses solely on replacing the beer pong table with the pool table. The background and other elements remain consistent between the two images, with no overediting or unnecessary changes.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
42,404 | toothbrush | hairbrush | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The toothbrush in the original image has been successfully replaced by a hairbrush in the edited image. The hairbrush is clearly visible, and there is no trace of the toothbrush.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the toothbrush with the hairbrush. The person, background, and other elements remain unchanged, indicating no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
22,935 | unlined jacket | leather jacket | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already features a leather jacket, so no replacement of an unlined jacket with a leather jacket was necessary or performed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no visible change between the original and edited images, indicating no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
639 | stainless steel appliances | wooden cabinets | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The stainless steel appliances, such as the refrigerator and microwave, remain unchanged in the edited image. While the wooden cabinets were successfully added, the instruction to replace stainless steel appliances with wooden cabinets was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit only changed the cabinet material and color, leaving the rest of the scene, including the stainless steel appliances, unchanged. There is no evidence of overediting beyond the intended scope.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
10,032 | Bee | Butterfly | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bee in the original image has been successfully replaced by a butterfly in the edited image. There is no bee remaining, and the butterfly is clearly distinguishable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and flowers remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the bee with the butterfly. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
11,895 | First Lady Melania Trump | Vice President Kamala Harris | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not show Vice President Kamala Harris replacing First Lady Melania Trump. The individual in the original image remains unchanged in the edited image, indicating no effective replacement.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable overediting in the second image. The background and other elements remain consistent with the original image, and no changes beyond the editing instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
10,154 | shoe | boot | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The shoe in the original image has been successfully replaced by a boot in the edited image. The boot is distinct and clearly different from the shoe, fulfilling the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the shoe with the boot. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
49,525 | wetsuit | diving gear | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the wetsuit with diving gear by adding diving equipment such as a mask, regulator, and air tanks. The wetsuit remains as part of the diving gear, but the addition of the diving equipment aligns with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image remain unchanged, and the edit focuses solely on adding diving gear. There is no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
9,
10
],
"score for Task1": 9,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 9 |
||
48,071 | Faber pencil | mechanical pencil | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a Faber pencil with minor changes to its appearance, but it has not been replaced by a mechanical pencil as per the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce significant changes beyond the pencil's appearance, and the background and other elements remain consistent. However, the pencil's eraser color has changed, which is irrelevant to the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
7
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 7
} | 0 |
||
38,051 | snowflakes | gingerbread cookies | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The snowflake in the original image has been successfully replaced by a gingerbread cookie in the edited image. There are no visible snowflakes remaining, and the replacement is clear and effective.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the snowflake with the gingerbread cookie. The background, the person, and other elements remain unchanged, indicating no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
10,371 | bracelet | necklace | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a bracelet, and no necklace is present. The editing instruction to replace the bracelet with a necklace was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no overediting as the two images are nearly identical, and no changes beyond the editing instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
42,812 | photo | painting | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a photo instead of a painting, so the editing instruction to replace the photo with a painting was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction, as the scene remains consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
116 | flowers | cacti | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The flowers in the original image have been successfully replaced by cacti in the edited image. There are no flowers remaining, and the cacti are clearly distinguishable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the image, such as the vase and lighting, remain unchanged. The edit is limited to replacing the flowers with cacti, and there is no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
7,393 | New York City Library | Central Park | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the New York City Library with Central Park. The two scenes are distinctly different, and the library is no longer visible while Central Park is clearly depicted.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce any changes beyond the replacement of the New York City Library with Central Park. The background and other elements are consistent with the editing instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
16,270 | gear | supplies | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not successfully replace 'gear' with 'supplies' as the term 'gear' is still present in the edited image. The editing instruction is not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
32,207 | bus | train | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains a train, and there is no visible bus in the original image. Therefore, the editing instruction to replace a bus with a train is not applicable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes between the two images beyond minor adjustments to the people and their positions, which are irrelevant to the editing instruction. The background and train remain consistent.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
44,993 | cake | pie | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The cake in the original image has been successfully replaced by a pie in the edited image. The pie is distinct and there is no trace of the cake, fulfilling the editing instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the cake with the pie. The background, plate, and overall scene remain consistent, with no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
31,570 | woman | man | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a woman, and no man has been introduced. The editing instruction to replace the woman with a man has not been followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are nearly identical, and no changes beyond the instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
17,348 | alphabet book | coloring book | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The alphabet book in the original image has been successfully replaced by a coloring book in the edited image. The replacement is clear and follows the editing instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the alphabet book with a coloring book. The background, layout, and other elements remain consistent, and there is no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
6,690 | speakers | headphones | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not fully follow the instruction as the speakers are still present, and the headphones are added rather than replacing the speakers.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not go beyond the instruction as the background and other elements remain unchanged. Only the addition of headphones is observed.",
"score": [
0,
9
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 0 |
||
6,328 | bride | groom | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows the bride, and the groom is already present in the original image. The editing instruction to replace the bride with the groom was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are nearly identical, and no changes beyond the editing instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
33,879 | actress | model | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image appears identical to the original image, with no discernible replacement of the actress by a model. This suggests that the editing instruction was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "Since there is no visible change between the original and edited images, there is no evidence of overediting or any changes beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
1,537 | smartphone | laptop | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The smartphone in the original image has been successfully replaced by a laptop in the edited image, and there is no smartphone visible in the edited image. The replacement is clear and effective.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background, lighting, and other elements in the scene remain consistent between the two images, and there are no changes beyond the replacement of the smartphone with the laptop.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
24,917 | kitchen | dining room | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the kitchen area with a dining room setup, including a dining table and chairs. The kitchen elements are no longer visible, and the dining room is clearly established.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce any significant changes beyond the replacement of the kitchen with the dining room. The background, lighting, and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
44,716 | plate | bowl | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not show any replacement of the plate with a bowl. The plate remains unchanged, and no bowl is introduced.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are identical, and no changes beyond the editing instruction are present.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
42,282 | driveway | garden | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The driveway has been partially replaced by a garden, but a significant portion of the driveway remains visible. The edit does not fully follow the instruction to replace the driveway with a garden.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce significant changes beyond the replacement of the driveway with a garden. The house, background, and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
5,
9
],
"score for Task1": 5,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 5 |
||
34,660 | Books | Magazines | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces books with magazines. There are no visible books remaining, and the magazines are clearly distinguishable from the original books.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain consistent between the original and edited images. The edit is limited to replacing books with magazines, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
29,463 | sloth | painting | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The sloth in the original image has been completely replaced by a painting in the edited image, and there is no trace of the sloth remaining. The painting is distinct and clearly follows the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements, such as the potted plants and wall, remain unchanged. The edit is limited to replacing the sloth with the painting, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
23,253 | floor | table | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows the floor and does not include a table. The editing instruction to replace the floor with a table was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are nearly identical, and no changes beyond the instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
9,434 | plants | books | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The plants in the original image have been successfully replaced by books in the edited image. There are no visible plants remaining, and the books are clearly distinguishable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background, table, and other elements remain unchanged except for the replacement of plants with books. The edit does not go beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
48,072 | soldier | firefighter | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not replace the soldier with a firefighter as instructed. The individual in both images appears to be the same, with no discernible change in attire or role.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are nearly identical, with no changes beyond the editing instruction.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
30,051 | people | clowns | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the people with clowns, and there are no visible traces of the original people. The clowns are distinct and clearly follow the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the scene remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the people with clowns. There is no evidence of overediting beyond the instructed change.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
47,996 | building | shop | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not replace the building with a shop. The structure and appearance of the building remain unchanged, and the edit only modifies some text on the building, which does not fulfill the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to text changes on the building and does not introduce any significant overediting or unrelated changes to the scene. The background and other elements remain consistent.",
"score": [
0,
9
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 0 |
||
43,496 | restaurant | café | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not show any noticeable change from the original image, and the restaurant remains unchanged. The instruction to replace the restaurant with a café was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are nearly identical, and no changes beyond the instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
49,882 | wallet case | notebook | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The wallet case has been successfully replaced by a notebook in the edited image. The notebook is clearly visible, and the wallet case is no longer present.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the wallet case with the notebook. The background and other elements remain unchanged, and there is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
8,088 | boxers | wrestlers | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still depicts boxers rather than wrestlers, as the individuals are engaged in a boxing match with boxing gloves and attire. The editing instruction to replace boxers with wrestlers was not followed effectively.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image does not show significant overediting beyond the original scene. The background, setting, and overall composition remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
18,937 | acoustic guitar | electric guitar | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows an acoustic guitar, and no electric guitar is present. The editing instruction to replace the acoustic guitar with an electric guitar was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes in the edited image beyond the editing instruction, as no effective edit was made. The scene remains identical to the original.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
45,821 | mosaic | painting | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The mosaic background in the original image has been replaced by a painting-like background in the edited image. The replacement aligns with the editing instruction, and there is a clear distinction between the mosaic and the painting.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses solely on replacing the mosaic with a painting. The figures and other elements in the image remain unchanged, and there is no evidence of overediting beyond the instructed replacement.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
35,241 | electric guitar effect processor | synthesizer | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The electric guitar effect processor in the original image has been successfully replaced by a synthesizer in the edited image. The synthesizer is clearly visible, and there is no trace of the electric guitar effect processor.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain consistent between the original and edited images. The edit is limited to the replacement of the object as per the instruction, with no overediting observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
9,840 | tote | backpack | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The tote in the original image has been successfully replaced by a backpack in the edited image. The backpack is clearly visible, and there is no tote present in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses on replacing the tote with a backpack without introducing significant changes to the background or other elements. The person and the setting are consistent with the original image, and there is no overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
11,973 | appliances | furniture | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains appliances such as the refrigerator, oven, and microwave, and no furniture has replaced them. The editing instruction to replace appliances with furniture was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no noticeable overediting in the second image. The scene remains consistent with the original image, and no changes beyond the editing instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
15,876 | polo shirt | t-shirt | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a polo shirt, and there is no visible replacement with a t-shirt. The editing instruction was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes beyond the editing instruction, as the images are nearly identical. However, since no editing was performed, the score reflects the lack of overediting.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
29,996 | ball | whistle | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The ball is still present in the edited image, and no whistle has been introduced. The editing instruction to replace the ball with a whistle has not been followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes in the image beyond the editing instruction. The background, person, and other elements remain identical.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
27,696 | home | office | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still depicts a home rather than an office. There is no clear indication of an office environment replacing the home, so the editing instruction is not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction. The structure and background remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
19,186 | dress | suit | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The dress in the original image has been successfully replaced by a suit in the edited image, and there is a clear distinction between the two outfits.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses solely on replacing the dress with a suit. The background and other elements remain consistent, and there are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
16,643 | suit | jacket | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not show any visible replacement of the suit with a jacket. The suit remains unchanged, and there is no evidence of the editing instruction being followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no overediting in the edited image as it is identical to the original image. No changes beyond the editing instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
22,045 | photo | painting | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not replace the photo with a painting as instructed. The scene remains a photo, and no painting is introduced.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image introduces additional people, which is beyond the scope of the editing instruction. This constitutes overediting.",
"score": [
0,
2
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 2
} | 0 |
||
6 | soldiers | knights | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the soldiers with knights, as the figures now clearly resemble knights with appropriate armor and accessories. There are no visible soldiers remaining in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit introduces additional elements, such as flags and decorative details, which go beyond the instruction to replace soldiers with knights. These changes alter the scene beyond the specified object replacement.",
"score": [
10,
6
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 6
} | 6 |
||
15,326 | fondue | stew | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The fondue in the original image has been successfully replaced by stew in the edited image. There is no trace of fondue, and the stew is clearly distinguishable.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain consistent between the original and edited images. The edit is limited to replacing the fondue with stew, without any overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
41,458 | bunk bed | sofa | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The bunk bed in the original image has been successfully replaced by a sofa in the edited image. There is no trace of the bunk bed, and the sofa is clearly visible, making the edit align perfectly with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background, including the wall, pink cloud decorations, and other elements, remains unchanged. The edit is limited to replacing the bunk bed with the sofa, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
6,783 | guitar | piano | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains the guitar, and the piano is already present in the original image. The editing instruction to replace the guitar with a piano was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are nearly identical, with no changes beyond the editing instruction.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
38,641 | tread bikes | stationary bikes | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already contains stationary bikes, and the edited image does not show any tread bikes. There is no effective replacement as the stationary bikes were already present in the original image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image does not show any significant changes beyond the editing instruction. The background, people, and overall scene remain consistent.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
47,139 | sandals | shoes | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The editing instruction was to replace sandals with shoes. However, the edited image shows one foot still wearing a sandal and the other wearing a shoe. This does not fully follow the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to the footwear. There is no overediting beyond the scope of the instruction.",
"score": [
5,
10
],
"score for Task1": 5,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 5 |
||
28,785 | tray | basket | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a tray instead of a basket, so the editing instruction to replace the tray with a basket was not followed at all.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no evidence of overediting as the two images are nearly identical, and no changes beyond the editing instruction are observed.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
643 | purse | backpack | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The purse in the original image has been successfully replaced by a backpack in the edited image. The backpack is clearly visible, and there is no sign of the purse remaining. The edit aligns well with the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses on replacing the purse with a backpack without altering other elements of the image, such as the background or the person's appearance. The changes are limited to the instructed object replacement.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
42,355 | car | bicycle | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains the car, and the bicycle has been added without replacing the car. This does not follow the editing instruction to replace the car with a bicycle.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The scene in the edited image remains largely unchanged except for the addition of the bicycle. There is no significant overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
10,417 | glasses | sunglasses | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The glasses in the original image have been successfully replaced by sunglasses in the edited image. The sunglasses are distinct and there is no trace of the original glasses.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the glasses with sunglasses. There are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
12,523 | rings | bracelets | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces the rings with a bracelet, and there are no rings visible in the edited image. The replacement is clear and effective.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background in the edited image has changed significantly, which is beyond the scope of the editing instruction. The focus on the object replacement is maintained, but the additional changes reduce the score.",
"score": [
10,
4
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 4
} | 4 |
||
9,345 | engagement ring | wedding band | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows an engagement ring with a prominent diamond, and no wedding band is present. The editing instruction to replace the engagement ring with a wedding band was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes to the image beyond the object replacement instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
39,244 | dress | suit | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The dress in the original image has been successfully replaced by a suit in the edited image. The suit is distinct and there is no visible trace of the dress in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses on replacing the dress with a suit without altering other elements of the image, such as the background or the person's appearance. The changes are limited to the editing instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
47,904 | couple | friends | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still depicts a couple embracing each other, and there is no visible replacement of the couple with friends. The editing instruction is not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There is no significant change in the background or other elements irrelevant to the editing instruction. The images are nearly identical.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
1,881 | individuals | families | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image successfully replaces individuals with families, as groups of people resembling families are now present instead of individuals. The change aligns with the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the image remain consistent between the original and edited versions, with no significant changes beyond the replacement of individuals with families.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
3,616 | man | woman | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains the man from the original image, and no woman has replaced him. The editing instruction to replace the man with a woman was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes in the edited image beyond the editing instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
45,036 | hammock | beach chair | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The hammock in the original image has been successfully replaced by a beach chair in the edited image. There is no trace of the hammock, and the beach chair is clearly visible, fulfilling the editing instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background, lighting, and overall scene remain consistent between the two images. The edit is limited to replacing the hammock with the beach chair, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
44,850 | fabric | paper | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not successfully replace the fabric with paper. The texture and appearance still resemble fabric rather than paper.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes to the image beyond the intended edit. The background and other elements remain consistent.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
20,997 | engagement ring | necklace | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The engagement ring in the original image has been successfully replaced by a necklace in the edited image. There is no engagement ring present in the edited image, and the necklace is clearly visible.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on replacing the engagement ring with a necklace, and there are no noticeable changes to the background, clothing, or other elements irrelevant to the editing instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
26,301 | dog | cat | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The dog in the original image has been successfully replaced by a cat in the edited image. There is no trace of the dog, and the cat is clearly visible, fulfilling the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and cage structure remain consistent between the two images, and there are no significant changes beyond replacing the dog with the cat. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
30,586 | shorts | skirt | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows shorts instead of a skirt, so the editing instruction to replace shorts with a skirt was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no noticeable changes beyond the editing instruction, as the background and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
26,237 | jeans | shorts | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not effectively replace jeans with shorts as the difference between the two images is minimal, and the edited image still resembles jeans rather than distinct shorts.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction, and the background and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
2,
9
],
"score for Task1": 2,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 2 |
||
33,734 | man | woman | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The man in the original image has been successfully replaced by a woman in the edited image. There is a clear and effective difference between the two images, and no man is present in the edited image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements of the scene remain consistent between the two images, with no significant changes beyond the replacement of the man with the woman. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
41,071 | air purifier | fan | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The air purifier in the original image has been successfully replaced by a fan in the edited image. The fan is clearly distinguishable, and there is no trace of the air purifier remaining.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and other elements in the scene remain unchanged, and the edit is limited to replacing the air purifier with the fan. There is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
34,665 | drawer | shelf | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The drawer is still present in the edited image, and no shelf has been added. The editing instruction to replace the drawer with a shelf has not been followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no changes beyond the editing instruction, as the images are nearly identical except for minor lighting differences. However, the edit itself was not successful.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
34,307 | chair | stool | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The chair in the original image has been replaced by a stool in the edited image. However, the stool is not in the same position as the chair, and the chair's replacement seems to have been accompanied by the addition of a desk, which was not part of the instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit goes beyond the instruction as a desk has been added to the scene, which is unrelated to replacing the chair with a stool. This constitutes overediting.",
"score": [
6,
3
],
"score for Task1": 6,
"score for Task2": 3
} | 3 |
||
7,267 | Boats | kayaks | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The boats in the original image have been successfully replaced by kayaks in the edited image. There are no visible boats remaining, and the kayaks are distinct and well-integrated into the scene.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background, lighting, and overall composition remain consistent between the two images. The edit is limited to replacing boats with kayaks, and no overediting is observed.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
38,108 | hand | chalk | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The hand in the original image has been replaced by a chalk in the edited image. The chalk is clearly visible, and the hand is no longer present, fulfilling the editing instruction effectively.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image does not show any significant changes beyond the replacement of the hand with the chalk. The background, posture, and other elements remain consistent with the original image.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
35,217 | coat | jacket | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The coat in the original image has been successfully replaced by a jacket in the edited image. The jacket is distinct and clearly different from the coat, fulfilling the editing instruction.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on replacing the coat with a jacket, and there are no significant changes to the background, pose, or other elements of the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
40,241 | Los Angeles Times | New York Times | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image already features 'New York Times,' so the editing instruction to replace 'Los Angeles Times' with 'New York Times' is irrelevant. No evidence of 'Los Angeles Times' is present in either image.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edited image introduces a completely different scene, including new people and a different layout, which goes beyond the scope of the editing instruction to replace 'Los Angeles Times' with 'New York Times.'",
"score": [
0,
0
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 0
} | 0 |
||
38,394 | vase | bowl | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The vase has been successfully replaced by a bowl in the edited image. There is a clear distinction between the original and edited images, and the vase is no longer present.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to replacing the vase with a bowl. The background and other elements remain consistent, and there are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
20,388 | sweatpants | joggers | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image does not effectively replace sweatpants with joggers as the visual difference between the two is minimal, and the edited image still resembles sweatpants.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit does not introduce significant changes beyond the replacement instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent, and the person is unchanged.",
"score": [
3,
9
],
"score for Task1": 3,
"score for Task2": 9
} | 3 |
||
36,298 | t-shirt | hoodie | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The t-shirt in the original image has been successfully replaced by a hoodie in the edited image. The hoodie is clearly visible, and there is no trace of the t-shirt.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused on replacing the t-shirt with a hoodie, and there are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image. The astronaut graphic remains consistent, and the person wearing the hoodie is appropriately integrated.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
11,296 | crib | playpen | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains the crib, and no playpen is introduced. The editing instruction to replace the crib with a playpen is not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes beyond the addition of toys in the crib, which is irrelevant to the editing instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
919 | tube | cylinder | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The original image contains a tube-like object, and the edited image successfully replaces it with a cylinder. The shape and structure have been altered to match the characteristics of a cylinder, and the tube is no longer present.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit focuses solely on replacing the tube with a cylinder. The background, lighting, and other elements remain unchanged, and there is no evidence of overediting.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
18,591 | pictures | videos | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image introduces a video advertisement in the scene, effectively replacing the concept of pictures with videos. However, the video is not seamlessly integrated into the environment, and the original image did not contain pictures to begin with.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit introduces a video advertisement panel, which is an addition to the scene but does not alter the background or other elements significantly. The change is limited to the addition of the video panel.",
"score": [
6,
8
],
"score for Task1": 6,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 6 |
||
30,628 | balloons | flowers | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The balloons in the original image have been completely replaced by flowers in the edited image, and there are no balloons remaining. The edit follows the instruction perfectly.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The background and overall composition of the image have changed significantly, going from a plain white background to a detailed green background with flowers. This goes beyond the object replacement instruction.",
"score": [
10,
3
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 3
} | 3 |
||
35,167 | graph | chart | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains a graph rather than a chart. The editing instruction to replace the graph with a chart was not followed successfully.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes beyond the editing instruction. The background and other elements remain consistent between the two images.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
15,039 | tennis shoes | running shoes | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The tennis shoes in the original image have been successfully replaced by running shoes in the edited image. The design and structure of the shoes are distinctly different, clearly indicating the replacement.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is focused solely on replacing the shoes, and there are no noticeable changes to the background or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
||
11,294 | trophy | medal | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still contains the trophy, and the medal was added without replacing the trophy. This does not follow the editing instruction to replace the trophy with the medal.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit introduced a medal but did not replace the trophy. However, there are no significant changes to the background or other elements irrelevant to the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
8
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 8
} | 0 |
||
45,049 | lens | camera | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The edited image still shows a lens instead of a camera, so the editing instruction to replace the lens with a camera was not followed.",
"reasoning for Task2": "There are no significant changes to the background or other elements in the image, indicating no overediting beyond the instruction.",
"score": [
0,
10
],
"score for Task1": 0,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 0 |
||
36,465 | white dress | red dress | {
"reasoning for Task1": "The white dress in the original image has been successfully replaced by a red dress in the edited image. The red dress is distinct and there is no trace of the white dress.",
"reasoning for Task2": "The edit is limited to the dress replacement, and there are no noticeable changes to the background, pose, or other elements in the image. The edit adheres strictly to the instruction.",
"score": [
10,
10
],
"score for Task1": 10,
"score for Task2": 10
} | 10 |
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 21