<p>I think you are thinking of the current account?</p>
<p>Neither direction of imbalance is generally desirable.</p>
<p>A current account deficit means you owe goods and services to other countries, which is bad because people in your country will have to produce them for little gain.</p>
<p>A current account surplus is also bad, because it means your country didn't receive all the goods and services it was &quot;entitled&quot; to receive from other countries. And inflation will erode the value of that surplus, so in the end, you won't receive as much as you could have.</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-09-19T19:59:17.370Z
I am not sure I agree. A country can optimally run a deficit if deficit financing is being used to invest in productive assets. Conversely, a country can run a surplus and generate foreign savings (interest payments) to insure itself against negative shocks in the future for instance. It is much the same as borrowing and saving for individuals.
Kwame Brown
CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-09-20T12:42:01.947Z
I think you are confusing the BOP with the current account.  The BOP is a wider concept.  Also a deficit does not mean you owe specifically goods or services to other countries, but generally it means the country accumulates debt with respect to the rest of the world.
BrsG
CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-09-19T19:35:43.783Z
2022-09-20T14:59:12.977Z
2022-09-20T14:59:12.977Z
Criticize SE actions means ban
<p>In general, BOPs(without taking the official reserves account into consideration( aren't balanced.
A BOP surplus is generally a good sign if the correct goods and being exported and a BOP deficit is genrally a bad thing.
However, I'm unable to find what is the outcome of a perfectly balanced BOP. Is it desirable? If so, why?</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-09-20T19:24:38.410Z
Are you sure you mean the BOP, not the current account or even trade balance?
BrsG
<macroeconomics><general-equilibrium><balance-of-trade><balance-of-payments>
Is a balanced BOP (without taking the official reserves account into consideration, desirable in the real world?
math and physics forever
# Is a balanced BOP (without taking the official reserves account into consideration, desirable in the real world?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2022-09-19)

In general, BOPs(without taking the official reserves account into consideration( aren't balanced.
A BOP surplus is generally a good sign if the correct goods and being exported and a BOP deficit is genrally a bad thing.
However, I'm unable to find what is the outcome of a perfectly balanced BOP. Is it desirable? If so, why?

**Tags:** macroeconomics, general-equilibrium, balance-of-trade, balance-of-payments

> **Comments:**
> **username_1**: Are you sure you mean the BOP, not the current account or even trade balance?  

---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_2 on 2022-09-19. Score: 0 | Accepted answer

I think you are thinking of the current account?

Neither direction of imbalance is generally desirable.

A current account deficit means you owe goods and services to other countries, which is bad because people in your country will have to produce them for little gain.

A current account surplus is also bad, because it means your country didn't receive all the goods and services it was "entitled" to receive from other countries. And inflation will erode the value of that surplus, so in the end, you won't receive as much as you could have.

> **Comments:**
> **username_3**: I am not sure I agree. A country can optimally run a deficit if deficit financing is being used to invest in productive assets. Conversely, a country can run a surplus and generate foreign savings (interest payments) to insure itself against negative shocks in the future for instance. It is much the same as borrowing and saving for individuals.  
> **username_1**: I think you are confusing the BOP with the current account.  The BOP is a wider concept.  Also a deficit does not mean you owe specifically goods or services to other countries, but generally it means the country accumulates debt with respect to the rest of the world.  

---

