<h1>Hint</h1>

<p>By colluding, presumably the two firms would like to figure out the least costly way to produce in order to maximize profit. Treat the two firms as two production plants of a single "parent company". The total cost of the cartel can then be found by solving 
\begin{equation}
C_\text{cartel}(Q)=\min_{q_1,q_2}\;[C_1(q_1)+C_2(q_2)],\quad\text{s.t.}\quad q_1+q_2=Q.
\end{equation}
This will give you a the optimal way of distributing production across the two firms, $q_i^*(Q)$, as a function of aggregate output $Q$. Then the cartel's total cost is just the sum of the member firms' costs evaluated at the optimum: $C_\text{cartel}(Q)=\sum_i C_i(q_i^*(Q))$.</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-02-12T22:22:28.597Z
2018-02-12T22:31:54.373Z
2018-02-12T22:31:54.373Z
Herr K.
<blockquote>
  <p>Find the Nash equilibrium of Cournot’s game when there are two firms, the inverse demand function is P(Q) = α – Q when α ≥ Q and 0 otherwise, and the cost function of each firm I is Ci(qi) = qi2. If the firms collude in this situation to create a cartel to maximize their profits, how much would each firm produce?</p>
</blockquote>

<p>I'm able to find the Nash equilibrium quantities when there is no collusion - however, I'm stuck on the cartel part.</p>

<p>We want to find <em>joint</em> profit maximizing quantities under collusion here. When the marginal cost to each firm is constant this is easy to do, since $C(Q) = C(q_1) + C(q_2)$. However, in this case, $C(Q) = q_1^2 + q_2^2$.</p>

<p>Thus, our joint profits are $\pi(Q) = Q(\alpha - Q) - (q_1^2 + q_2^2) \neq Q(\alpha - Q) - Q^2$. I'm not sure how to take this first order condition (with respect to $Q = (q_1 + q_2)$) given the non-linearity of the cost functions. Any ideas as to how to solve this would be greatly appreciated (not looking for a direct answer; simply a nudge in the right direction).</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-02-12T16:46:02.233Z
How about maximizing w.r.t the decision variables?
Giskard
CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-02-12T17:02:52.670Z
@denesp you mean maximizing with respect to $q_1$ and $q_2$ separately? That is, write out the cartel profit function as $\pi(q_1, q_2) = (q_1 + q_2)(\alpha - q_1 - q_2) - q_1^2 - q_2^2$ and then maximize with respect to $q_1$ and $q_2$ separately?
mizichael
CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-02-12T17:12:30.390Z
I am not sure what you mean by seperately, but if you are uncertain you should read about multivariable function analysis.
Giskard
CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-02-12T17:38:31.683Z
@denesp I have a lot of experience with multivariable calculus and analysis - by "separately" I mean to take the partial derivatives (first order conditions) with respect to $q_1$ and then $q_2$ and set them equal (solve for $q_1$ and $q_2$).
mizichael
CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-02-12T17:53:10.993Z
If you have a lot experience that's good! Then you can easily figure this one out.
Giskard
CC BY-SA 3.0
2018-02-12T19:39:36.020Z
Hint: They both have the same cost function. By colluding, just imagine they are "one firm" now. Adding cost functions wouldn't be necessary then, would it ...
Taufi
<game-theory><profit-maximization>
Cartel profit maximizing quantity question (Cournot game)
mizichael
# Cartel profit maximizing quantity question (Cournot game)

(Asked by: username_0 on 2018-02-12)

> Find the Nash equilibrium of Cournot’s game when there are two firms, the inverse demand function is P(Q) = α – Q when α ≥ Q and 0 otherwise, and the cost function of each firm I is Ci(qi) = qi2. If the firms collude in this situation to create a cartel to maximize their profits, how much would each firm produce?

I'm able to find the Nash equilibrium quantities when there is no collusion - however, I'm stuck on the cartel part.

We want to find *joint* profit maximizing quantities under collusion here. When the marginal cost to each firm is constant this is easy to do, since $C(Q) = C(q\_1) + C(q\_2)$. However, in this case, $C(Q) = q\_1^2 + q\_2^2$.

Thus, our joint profits are $\pi(Q) = Q(\alpha - Q) - (q\_1^2 + q\_2^2) \neq Q(\alpha - Q) - Q^2$. I'm not sure how to take this first order condition (with respect to $Q = (q\_1 + q\_2)$) given the non-linearity of the cost functions. Any ideas as to how to solve this would be greatly appreciated (not looking for a direct answer; simply a nudge in the right direction).

**Tags:** game-theory, profit-maximization

> **Comments:**
> **username_1**: How about maximizing w.r.t the decision variables?  
> **username_0**: @denesp you mean maximizing with respect to $q_1$ and $q_2$ separately? That is, write out the cartel profit function as $\pi(q_1, q_2) = (q_1 + q_2)(\alpha - q_1 - q_2) - q_1^2 - q_2^2$ and then maximize with respect to $q_1$ and $q_2$ separately?  
> **username_1**: I am not sure what you mean by seperately, but if you are uncertain you should read about multivariable function analysis.  
> **username_0**: @denesp I have a lot of experience with multivariable calculus and analysis - by "separately" I mean to take the partial derivatives (first order conditions) with respect to $q_1$ and then $q_2$ and set them equal (solve for $q_1$ and $q_2$).  
> **username_1**: If you have a lot experience that's good! Then you can easily figure this one out.  
> **username_2**: Hint: They both have the same cost function. By colluding, just imagine they are "one firm" now. Adding cost functions wouldn't be necessary then, would it ...  

---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_3 on 2018-02-12. Score: 2

# Hint

By colluding, presumably the two firms would like to figure out the least costly way to produce in order to maximize profit. Treat the two firms as two production plants of a single "parent company". The total cost of the cartel can then be found by solving
\begin{equation}
C\_\text{cartel}(Q)=\min\_{q\_1,q\_2}\;[C\_1(q\_1)+C\_2(q\_2)],\quad\text{s.t.}\quad q\_1+q\_2=Q.
\end{equation}
This will give you a the optimal way of distributing production across the two firms, $q\_i^\*(Q)$, as a function of aggregate output $Q$. Then the cartel's total cost is just the sum of the member firms' costs evaluated at the optimum: $C\_\text{cartel}(Q)=\sum\_i C\_i(q\_i^\*(Q))$.


---

