<p>if you have 50 BTC in one address and you are about sending 10 BTC to another address, Programmatically left bitcoins(40 BTC) in this address are the transaction fee. so some wallets sent remaining bitcoins minus the fee to a new address for privacy purposes. </p>

<p>Almost all wallets don't show this transaction because its a transaction that you didn't make and it contains bitcoin change.</p>

CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-12-24T07:19:12.687Z
Let me be sure I understand you:  I have 50 bitcoins at address A.  I send 10 bitcoins to some other address that is not in my wallet.  My wallet then creates address B, and sends the remaining 40 bitcoins from A to B, for reasons that have to do with programming but not with any actual wealth transfer.  And when I look at the list of addresses in my wallet, I continue to see A but do not see B, because my wallet sees no reason to show me B.  Have I understood?
www
CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-12-24T07:22:07.427Z
Exactly, if you have bitcoin core software and you call bitcoin-cli listtransactions you will be able to see all transactions including "Change Transactions".
Tailer
CC BY-SA 3.0
2017-12-24T07:06:37.097Z
2017-12-24T07:06:37.097Z
Tailer
<p>I recently sent someone .5 Bitcoins, from the wallet on my Trezor.  </p>

<p>My Trezor wallet shows a transaction of -.5 bitcoins (actually slightly more than .5 because of the transaction fee of course).  Moreover, the balance showing on my Trezor is exactly what it should be --- that is, .5 less than it was before. And moreover, the recipient received exactly .5 bitcoins.  So it looks like everything went exactly as it should.</p>

<p>However, when I look up the transaction on the blockchain, I see this:</p>

<p><a href="https://i.sstatic.net/O00ng.jpg" rel="nofollow noreferrer"><img src="https://i.sstatic.net/O00ng.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></a></p>

<p>This appears to show 43.99 Bitcoins leaving my wallet, .5 of them going to the recipient, and the remaining 43.49 going to some mysterious other address.  </p>

<p>This almost makes it appear that somebody somehow managed to steal 43.49 of my Bitcoins, but given what's showing on the Trezor I'm not too worried about that. (As I said, the Trezor balance has been decremented by just .5, as it should be.  In case it's relevant, the total balance on the Trezor is substantially more than 43.99.)  </p>

<p>I'm guessing that somehow what happened is that for some reason the 43.49 extra Bitcoins were taken from my wallet and returned to me, but then I wonder why that doesn't show up on the list of transactions on my Trezor.  And the address to which the 43.49 were apparently sent does not match any public key that I have any record of ever having used.</p>

<p>Bottom line:  I'm not too concerned, but I'd sure like to understand this.  Can someone help?</p>

<transactions><blockchain>
Understanding a Mysterious Bitcoin Transaction
www
# Understanding a Mysterious Bitcoin Transaction

(Asked by: username_0 on 2017-12-24)

I recently sent someone .5 Bitcoins, from the wallet on my Trezor.

My Trezor wallet shows a transaction of -.5 bitcoins (actually slightly more than .5 because of the transaction fee of course). Moreover, the balance showing on my Trezor is exactly what it should be --- that is, .5 less than it was before. And moreover, the recipient received exactly .5 bitcoins. So it looks like everything went exactly as it should.

However, when I look up the transaction on the blockchain, I see this:

[![enter image description here](https://i.sstatic.net/O00ng.jpg)](https://i.sstatic.net/O00ng.jpg)

This appears to show 43.99 Bitcoins leaving my wallet, .5 of them going to the recipient, and the remaining 43.49 going to some mysterious other address.

This almost makes it appear that somebody somehow managed to steal 43.49 of my Bitcoins, but given what's showing on the Trezor I'm not too worried about that. (As I said, the Trezor balance has been decremented by just .5, as it should be. In case it's relevant, the total balance on the Trezor is substantially more than 43.99.)

I'm guessing that somehow what happened is that for some reason the 43.49 extra Bitcoins were taken from my wallet and returned to me, but then I wonder why that doesn't show up on the list of transactions on my Trezor. And the address to which the 43.49 were apparently sent does not match any public key that I have any record of ever having used.

Bottom line: I'm not too concerned, but I'd sure like to understand this. Can someone help?

**Tags:** transactions, blockchain


---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2017-12-24. Score: 0 | Accepted answer

if you have 50 BTC in one address and you are about sending 10 BTC to another address, Programmatically left bitcoins(40 BTC) in this address are the transaction fee. so some wallets sent remaining bitcoins minus the fee to a new address for privacy purposes.

Almost all wallets don't show this transaction because its a transaction that you didn't make and it contains bitcoin change.

> **Comments:**
> **username_0**: Let me be sure I understand you:  I have 50 bitcoins at address A.  I send 10 bitcoins to some other address that is not in my wallet.  My wallet then creates address B, and sends the remaining 40 bitcoins from A to B, for reasons that have to do with programming but not with any actual wealth transfer.  And when I look at the list of addresses in my wallet, I continue to see A but do not see B, because my wallet sees no reason to show me B.  Have I understood?  
> **username_1**: Exactly, if you have bitcoin core software and you call bitcoin-cli listtransactions you will be able to see all transactions including "Change Transactions".  

---

