<p>The S value in your scriptSig is</p>
<pre><code>00a270c846b69cdf68b0c211b67515f850663a6c448c52e6b940863b450a2bf790
</code></pre>
<p>Interpreted as a hexadecimal number, that is around 7.347395059744133e+76, or (N/2) + 1.5577905978783233e+76.</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-12-07T06:14:26.823Z
Thanks, I look into it.
Matthias Russ
CC BY-SA 4.0
2022-12-06T21:48:10.107Z
2022-12-06T21:48:10.107Z
Pieter Wuille
<p>Using the mempool app on my full node from mynode, when transmitting a raw tx with more than one output I get:<br />
<em>non-mandatory-script-verify-flag (Non-canonical signature: S value is unnecessarily high).</em><br />
I checked and<br />
<strong>s - N/2 = -2.3646232789023417e+76</strong>,<br />
so this doesn't seem to be true. Using a public block explorer like blockcypher no error is returned, however the tx is stuck and will not confirm.</p>
<p>rax tx is</p>
<pre><code>0100000001a9b1a5b978a4a6c3f7fb14f0255e2f544cb45d63ab8153b28b8b6fef2095ec3a000000006c493046022100c2036791de6d3a4592b65f180debd314f0f5fc637963711d09da3fe8529e0a2b022100a270c846b69cdf68b0c211b67515f850663a6c448c52e6b940863b450a2bf790012102a74ced31ca71800626bc4e0b317714b8700ba6a2befda55899eb66371b8b26a8ffffffff03e8030000000000001976a914655355fe75f8ef558dbb4dca8f1a38e12cb5b32d88ace8030000000000001976a9143871ad8b05aaf69d37309f319b07b8a6bf6066ae88ac18730100000000001976a9143fa2936ef54e0d47b9f63cafaac4bb9a30325cb088ac00000000
</code></pre>
<p>what could be the reason the tx gets rejected?</p>

<transactions><signature><raw>
Getting a high s value rejection although s < N/2
Matthias Russ
# Getting a high s value rejection although s < N/2

(Asked by: username_0 on 2022-12-06)

Using the mempool app on my full node from mynode, when transmitting a raw tx with more than one output I get:
non-mandatory-script-verify-flag (Non-canonical signature: S value is unnecessarily high).
I checked and
s - N/2 = -2.3646232789023417e+76,
so this doesn't seem to be true. Using a public block explorer like blockcypher no error is returned, however the tx is stuck and will not confirm.
rax tx is
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

what could be the reason the tx gets rejected?

**Tags:** transactions, signature, raw


---

## 1 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2022-12-06. Score: 1

The S value in your scriptSig is
00a270c846b69cdf68b0c211b67515f850663a6c448c52e6b940863b450a2bf790

Interpreted as a hexadecimal number, that is around 7.347395059744133e+76, or (N/2) + 1.5577905978783233e+76.

> **Comments:**
> **username_0**: Thanks, I look into it.  

---

