<p>There is no such thing like 'lightning BTC'. It is the same BTC, either on-chain, or comitted to a lightning channel, which is technically a 2 of 2 multisig transaction. To receive via lightning, a lightning full node or a wallet with lightning receive capability is needed. And correct, you need to open a channel first, which takes one on-chain commit, the the associated waiting time. But it is possible to transfer value at the same time by already assigning a portion of the channel funds to the receiver when setting up the 2 of 2 multisig transaction. All later value transfers inside the channel will be an just update of this transaction, which will be instantaneous. So either way, no need for a second transaction in terms of on-chain transaction. Except for the closure of the channel, if needed - which will another on-chain transaction ( channels can stay open indefinitely, though).</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2018-07-10T13:13:24.447Z
2018-07-10T13:13:24.447Z
S van Staa
<p>You can use the wallet c-lighitning for sent bicoin to a simple wallet bitcoin with this command</p>

<pre><code>lightning-cli withdraw &lt;pubkey&gt; &lt;shatoshi&gt;
</code></pre>

<p>But you can not use the your channel, the satoshi that you use for sent bitcoin to simple wallet bitcoin are separated by the channel</p>

CC BY-SA 4.0
2019-08-27T09:41:56.860Z
2019-08-27T09:41:56.860Z
vincenzopalazzo
<p>Let's say that I have a channel opened and I want to send some lightning BTC to someone who didn't ever used lightning, is it possible or will it be? Or will I need to open a channel first then send the btc through lighthing(with 2 transactions)?</p>

<p>I know the guys from Raiden want to allow that: <a href="https://medium.com/@raiden_network/creating-an-easy-onboarding-user-experience-for-the-raiden-network-4dcdc9e2eeed" rel="nofollow noreferrer">https://medium.com/@raiden_network/creating-an-easy-onboarding-user-experience-for-the-raiden-network-4dcdc9e2eeed</a></p>

<lightning-network>
Lightning: Is it possible to send lightning BTC outside of a lightning state channel?
Narcis Ciobotariu
# Lightning: Is it possible to send lightning BTC outside of a lightning state channel?

(Asked by: username_0 on 2018-07-10)

Let's say that I have a channel opened and I want to send some lightning BTC to someone who didn't ever used lightning, is it possible or will it be? Or will I need to open a channel first then send the btc through lighthing(with 2 transactions)?

I know the guys from Raiden want to allow that: <https://medium.com/@raiden_network/creating-an-easy-onboarding-user-experience-for-the-raiden-network-4dcdc9e2eeed>

**Tags:** lightning-network


---

## 2 answers

### Answer by username_1 on 2018-07-10. Score: 1

There is no such thing like 'lightning BTC'. It is the same BTC, either on-chain, or comitted to a lightning channel, which is technically a 2 of 2 multisig transaction. To receive via lightning, a lightning full node or a wallet with lightning receive capability is needed. And correct, you need to open a channel first, which takes one on-chain commit, the the associated waiting time. But it is possible to transfer value at the same time by already assigning a portion of the channel funds to the receiver when setting up the 2 of 2 multisig transaction. All later value transfers inside the channel will be an just update of this transaction, which will be instantaneous. So either way, no need for a second transaction in terms of on-chain transaction. Except for the closure of the channel, if needed - which will another on-chain transaction ( channels can stay open indefinitely, though).


---

### Answer by username_2 on 2019-08-27. Score: 0

You can use the wallet c-lighitning for sent bicoin to a simple wallet bitcoin with this command
lightning-cli withdraw  

But you can not use the your channel, the satoshi that you use for sent bitcoin to simple wallet bitcoin are separated by the channel


---

