first film ever made workers streaming factory cycling walking moving right left along melies lumieres starting point point departure cinema  melies begins narrative fiction cinema fantasy artifice spectacle lumieres pure unadorned observation truth many intellectuals regret ossification cinema latter tired formulae formerbr br but consider short again nothing objective it film full action  static inhuman scene burst life activity quiet harmony frame ruptured decentred back right left but never course front camera is yet camera stands stock still contains energy possible subversion subordinates will cinematograph may revolutionary invention used conservative purposes  map world edit it restrict it limit itbr br worse historical reality film factory workers lumiere employees bosses spying workers unseen eye regarding faceless minions film therefore describes two types imprisonment behind gates workers confined workplace opening gate seems image freedom escape face another wall fourth wall confining them first film also first example cctv surveillance image unseen allseeing authority entrapping servants frightening prophetic movie