think andrew davies admirable job taking magnificent book emulated pace styling victorian novel turning moving entertaining film im glad read twice book first usually case me know one must view novel film different media judge accordingly but still often hard read original material film gives away best partsbr br i realize davies good adapter wish producers chosen woman write screenplay davies admits commentary accompanies film dvd wanted particularly emphasis scatological bits book certainly enjoyed those film book davies missed halfdozen moments excruciatingly painfully tender could incorporated sensibility feminine br br i also would take issue use books primary symbol rosebr br as screenplay plotted davies denouement inevitable appropriate really think author waters final nod rose symbol much interesting preferred way novel let nan come age way davies chosebr br one quick comment four actors essay primary roles wonderfully talented  well except singing dancing perhaps  and moreover physical presences much minds eye sees reading novel seeing film thought terrificbr br i recommend lesbian anyone loves good fiction add book dvd tipping velvet bookshelves