night listener better people generally saying weaknesses seems genre identity crisis doubt think creepy atmosphere intriguing performances make this whole thing feels like one fireside this happened friend friend mine ghost stories one big complaint movie pacing slow sometimes awkward pacing deliberate everything unfolds movie kept well within realm possibility real life sort plods alongno flashy endings earthshattering revelations showdown scenes thank heaven get zone watching movie forget reservations expectations makes conventionallygood movie williams terrific easily meets needs story plus character supposed somewhat generic no one everyman avatar enter story toni collettes performance nominated oscar even maybe win it give shot quality content alone night listener surely top twenty percent movies coming days