john hall johnhallevergonet practical matter doubt value sold situations ever adds value lost nonpecuiary since violation loss trouble get somewhere really picky dont think considering marginal utility dollars value situation arent debating whether thief better im lawyer either played one tv didnt play good one canceled first episode situtation described came recollection epsteins takings specifically rejecting idea absolute property right found liberation theology using idea emergency life depends upon im entitled violate property rights forbidden using unreasonable force defend particularly arent around maybe get wrong particular recollection relatively strong precisely gave good reason libertarian theology needed modified also analyzing common law come might statuatory law particular jurisdiction original message forkadminxentcom mailtoforkadminxentcom behalf russell turpin sent monday august 12 2002 215 pm forkspamassassintaintorg subject david friedman mail money john hall case theft also acknowledges value thief often far less value victim stealing 1000 stereo fencing 50 result loss economy overall depends value placed fellow buys pawn shop take account marginal utility dollars thief may value lucre victim flip side common law allows breach property law precisely type scenarios net social gain recorded owners availability make contract problematic breaking isolated cabin im starving example permissible later offer restitution damage caused food ate lawyer think incorrect analysis law allows emergencies break cabin take rifle grab box ammo shoot bear mauling poor hiker without committed crimes breaking entering theft hunting season killing endangered species whether later offer pay window ammunition law simply puts higher priority saving human life emergency things yes turn around sue recompense civil issue criminal one crime requires mens rea shot bear wasnt thinking owned bullet _________________________________________________________________ msn photos easiest way share print photos httpphotosmsncomsupportworldwideaspx httpxentcommailmanlistinfofork httpxentcommailmanlistinfofork mon 12 aug 2002 143302 0700 david friedman mail money