diachronica moderators note interests balanced exchange views publish following reply posting sheila embleton editor diachronica interchanges nature however best carried forums linguist thus last posting topic sure sheila embleton chose attack linguist briefly diachronica accepted publication paper attacked personally basically described idiot basis remarks made alleged made oral discussion conference ypsilanti last year repeatedly told author paper well editors diachronica consider rather dubious form scholarship think people criticized basis published statements oral remarks checked accuracy moreover criticizing print remarks made conference discussions bound chilling effect discussions diachronica chose disagree asked opportunity respond attacks told would accept rebuttal would even consider one even coauthored one others furthermore would consider submissions whatsoever period least 2 years objections journals policy allowing replies policy limiting number publications person case existing policy cited far tell folks diachronica decided nt like anymore still mean right publish stuff comes close slanderous think refuse people maligned print right reply however briefly alexis manaster ramer