luis villa cvovtieguyorg 101607 stephen williams wrote luis villa wrote ianal etc etc 101607 stephen williams wrote rights clarified universal city studios v sony summarized nicely httpw2efforgipp2pmgm_v_groksterbetamax_20thphp feel entirely within rights time shift book bits sony betamax case didnt establish legal use vcr established legal sell vcr despite fact well might used illegal purposes extent sony said anything legality uses vcr dicta ill defer legal knowledge however eff article linked said court decided american consumers violating copyright laws timeshifted television vcrs also declared sony violating copyright laws selling vcrs even though people might use infringe copyrights words dont go crow bar makers burglars still think legality timeshifting considered settled law ive seen mentioned many cases eff agenda interpretation sony push agree agenda would love agree interpretation well play safe wouldnt copy anything ill put way keep spines like old crusty skeletons prove disposed physical source photograph books keep archive receipts make party prove receipt present simply point people give books include certificate scan part library based book cool youve given yet another instance gives standing pursue taking unlicensed practice law statutes court unconstitutional advice would useful matter unlicensed uncertified ability make informed legal decisions limited prior restraint speech prior restraint access agree unconstitutional repeal tomorrow though youre still going get much advice lawyers good lawyer like good engineers instinctively dislike saying things without deeply understanding problem first know experience realworld problems big hairy complex advice get mostly ultraconservative guy ever got fired buying ibm lawyer ever got client trouble giving conservative advice unfortunately im moving although maintain home extent virginia courts seem smalltime maybe im comfortable caught something family side california imposing aggressive im sure theres much traffic put stress system idea rough dealing circuit court california case copyright case unlicensed practice law case ca courts surprisingly notoriously procopyright idea practice law claim luis wed 06 aug 2008 105513 0400 tt fork book guillotining spine removal amateurs