seth johnson sethjohnsonrealmeasuresdyndnsorg tcpa palladium content control masses security experts poke jab bits pieces tcpa palladium specs get ahold tended focus work imply far concerns privacy security go alternatively terms would impact functionality general purpose logic device analysts favorable unfavorable analyzing standpoints paying much less attention proposals imply standpoint content control really means significant problem tcpa palladium whether may interfere power universal logic device whether effectual standpoint privacy security concerns though important concerns rather fundamental problem present political premises hope implement sake content industries tcpa palladium technological realization concepts embodied wipo performances phonograms treaty wppt came effect past may 20th little public notice fanfare course wppt declares unprecedented moral right authors control public uses works thats real game plan tcpa palladium simply content control masses constitute effort democratize content control concept moral rights encouraging public overlook clear public interest issues raised specter content control confuse issues private interest issues privacy security effort get public jump bandwagon without adequate consideration whats really line america never supported concept moral rights wppt professes us constitution accords congress power grant deny exclusive rights works inventions purpose promoting progress useful arts sciences purpose rewarding originality creators though result obviously consequence exclusive rights statutes copyright law supreme court explicitly articulates distinction good reason america implicitly understand distinction expression aspect works copyright statute applies facts ideas make work apply reason essential unavoidable must stated clearly unequivocally juncture information free wants always fact unassailable however unless let come pass world subscribes universal content control sake socalled moral rights implemented behest narrow content industry interests tcpa palladium initiatives hope encourage general public specifically producers information products general identify content control moral rights blithely overlooking real implications information technology free society long tradition american jurisprudence upholding freedom intrinsic information freedom prospects information technology crucially depend seth johnson cc countercopyright httpcyberlawharvardeducccchtml reserve rights restricting copying modification distribution incidentally recorded communication original authorship attributed reasonably far expectation might hold usual practice ordinary social discourse one holds claim exclusive rights httpxentcommailmanlistinfofork wed 14 aug 2002 043122 0400 tcpa palladium content control masses