carthage plant imbalance forwarded ami chokshi corp enron 01 19 2000 03 51 pm dscottl com 01 19 2000 03 41 11 pm nelson ferries corp enron enron willie shannon dvn com ami chokshi corp enron enron gregory schockling corp enron enron cc williams mary subject carthage plant imbalance discussed carthage plant imbalance chad cass duke energy carthage plant operator willie shannon devon energy learned duke devon met last fall discuss imbalance according devon approximately 240 000 due duke 8 31 99 devon acknowledged imbalance existed think high parties seemed take position side needed prove wrong according duke imbalance grew 120 000 september 16 000 october another 12 000 november round numbers bringing total approximately 395 000 end november based current month estimates duke thinks january sales 1 000 2 000 day higher production would like see cut sales 4 000 day effective friday 1 21 00 order balance month january devon disagrees daily overage based production estimates since recognize imbalance exists willie devon agreed reduce volume available sale 4 000 day effective friday 21 st reduce amount excess gas gas daily priced enron available sell carthage additionally beginning february lst duke requests payback plant 5 000 day continuing imbalance worked devon reduce lst month availabe volume 5 000 accomplish enron needs verify reduction factored numbers setting february activity key point imbalance issue one believe parties agree ces enron purchases devon carthage gas tailgate plant production related imbalance devon plant duke make volumes reduce enron receives devon enron buying gas devon turning around paying back historical imbalance however since ces enron set devon agent carthage duke communicates imbalance information coordinates make arrangements enron enron turn needs verify devon devon adjusted available volumes reflect make hopefully actual make commences devon duke strive reconcile actual imbalance agree please call questions 713 693 2581 david