luis villa cvovtieguyorg 10907 jeff bone wrote whole notion deleting digital data fundamentally broken fiction lawyers phbs like think level physical nearimpossibility think even secure delete methods compromised last several years id argue economic costs requiring allowing obligating deletion circumstances outweigh benefits data considered inherently immutable copyable durable notional entity described data evolve call versioning hrm one hand youre right hand lots places purposes law purposes policy safely assume deletion actually occurs line probably subject interesting paper purposes user deletion happens longer access data maybe clear definition hard drive wipingshreddingwhatever really moot user point unless want sue get access luis returnpath xoriginalto jllocalhost deliveredto user7gvcceaschallengecc received radishjmasonorg localhost 127001 radishjmasonorg postfix esmtp id ac7a5332a5 tue 9 oct 2007 214109 0100 ist xspamvirus xspamcheckerversion spamassassin 330r574664 20070911 somanfdntechcom xspamrelaysexternal ip6955232243 rdnsxentcom heloxentcom bysomanfdntechcom ident envfrom intl0 id65c36268c08 auth msa0 ip127001 rdnsxentcom heloxentcom byxentcom ident envfrom intl0 idl99kwbod021745 auth msa0 ip20985198188 rdnsrvout0910googlecom helorvout0910googlecom byxentcom ident envfrom intl0 idl99kw8ba021668 auth msa0 xspamstatus score26 required50 testsawlbayes_00 dkim_policy_signsomedkim_signedspf_helo_passspf_pass shortcircuitno autolearnham version330r574664 xspamrelaysinternal xspamrelaysuntrusted ip6955232243 rdnsxentcom heloxentcom bysomanfdntechcom ident envfrom intl0 id65c36268c08 auth msa0 ip127001 rdnsxentcom heloxentcom byxentcom ident envfrom intl0 idl99kwbod021745 auth msa0 ip20985198188 rdnsrvout0910googlecom helorvout0910googlecom byxentcom ident envfrom intl0 idl99kw8ba021668 auth msa0 xspamrelaystrusted xspamlevel xspamrbl 1 xentcom 6955232243 xoriginalto user7gvcceaschallengecc deliveredto jlmailfdntechcom received localhost 127001 radishjmasonorg imap fetchmail632 singledrop tue 09 oct 2007 214109 0100 ist received xentcom xentcom 6955232243 somanfdntechcom postfix esmtp id 65c36268c08 tue 9 oct 2007 153448 0500 cdt received xentcom xentcom 127001 xentcom 8135200603088135debian3ubuntu11 esmtp id l99kwbod021745 tue 9 oct 2007 133211 0700 received rvout0910googlecom rvout0910googlecom 20985198188 xentcom 8135200603088135debian3ubuntu11 esmtp id l99kw8ba021668 tue 9 oct 2007 133210 0700 received rvout0910googlecom smtp id c27so1153751rvf tue 09 oct 2007 133208 0700 pdt dkimsignature v1 arsasha256 crelaxedrelaxed dgmailcom sbeta hdomainkeysignaturereceivedreceivedmessageiddatefromsendertosubjectinreplytomimeversioncontenttypecontenttransferencodingcontentdispositionreferencesxgooglesenderauth bhmz4i7rmeisnvkbxfdzp4egxz4ck0sewdzuj2imkf8 ba1cugffdda7qaczlfxb0b1whfodr69i9v1astrd14tog88js8jztcudkdifywx8chitlp2r8le5beg4hxda2bfzyzv3hfzdn2ntkjhfktyjelrpadc5d3fisoti1zopfvquuvxx7uta69wlruxvtupibkmnj6lfdanhh2ta domainkeysignature arsasha1 cnofws dgmailcom sbeta hreceivedmessageiddatefromsendertosubjectinreplytomimeversioncontenttypecontenttransferencodingcontentdispositionreferencesxgooglesenderauth bepkfhcco7sitdatgwibqtpfgkam0pboqyqvvjfiu5goih8y8lx8nx1tnvabcqfnikn7uppltjv3nosyi7uksmdnaxtp632ruzjta9uyg0ss3lb6zynkecny5hmt8tlhdc4igdvy5g5lipiettxwuhplnitlatbpbadswvpv8 received 101154916 smtp id b16mr4790279wak1191961928579 tue 09 oct 2007 133208 0700 pdt received 1011511010 http tue 9 oct 2007 133208 0700 pdt messageid 2cb10c440710091332x260073e7s9bba83abe7d6a631mailgmailcom date tue 9 oct 2007 163208 0400 luis villa friends rohit khare subject fork google evil inreplyto 20071009201203ge7718syrinxpccom mimeversion 10 contenttype textplain charsetiso88591 contenttransferencoding 7bit contentdisposition inline references 49775910252802dd4977syrinxpccom 8ho41o953108035089o41o95j10kmn5u8984dott31s8mailgmailcom 851mw40c7800594lignet 92761243971088uy9276syrinxpccom xgooglesenderauth 93f404cc4e5eca47 xbeenthere wsyexentcom xmailmanversion 215 precedence list replyto friends rohit khare listid friends rohit khare listunsubscribe listarchive listpost listhelp listsubscribe sender ebupetutfesxentcom errorsto ebupetutfesxentcom 10907 aaron burt wrote win lottery im gon na hire lawyer see obvious computer nonobvious works dilute computer portion homeopathic levels fwiw obvious computer nonobvious probably longer case postksrteleflex thank gods case ruled supreme court may dont know exactly far case goes know goes pretty long way fairly good englishlanguage summary httpblogswsjcomlaw20070501ksrvteleflexthesupremecourtsbigpatentruling luis tue 05 aug 2008 234517 0400 fork open service analysis