ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN ASSESSMENT Enter rubric description Inadequate Adequate Accomplished Mastery 1 pts D 2 pts C 3 pts B 4 pts A Inadequate Adequate Accomplished Mastery Design Solution 40 % Originate successful design Does not attempt or is unable Fundamentally sound design Interesting design solution Compelling design solution solutions to fundamental to complete design solutions. solution with moderately showing consistently creative showing highly original architectural problems by Unsuccessful design solution creative use of concept, development of concept, creative development of integrating concepts, due to lack of creative use of fundamentally appropriate original development of concept, innovative application formal/visual principles and concept, limited exploration of technique, and adequate technique and original of techniques and exemplary techniques. technique and/or application of application of principles. application of principles. use of principles. Solution principles. Little effort to Solution shows some effort to Solution shows ongoing shows rigorous creative inquiry challenge creative boundaries challenge creative boundaries creative inquiry and and investigation throughout resulting in obvious or poorly with limited or uneven exploration of design potential design process with highly developed solution. success. with largely effective results. successful results. Formal & Spatial Inadequate Adequate Accomplished Mastery Principles 20 % Does not attempt or is unable functional understanding Clear understanding of Advanced understanding of Demonstrate fundamental to complete design solutions. of experiental qualtity of experiental qualtity of experiental qualtity of understanding and application Limited understanding of architectural form and space architectural form and space architectural form and of architectural formal + experiental quality of resulting in fundamentally resulting in successful resulting in exemplary spatial principles as they architectural form and space sound architectural solutions. architectural solutions. Minor architectural solutions. relate to human experience. resulting in largely Moderate problems with scale, problems with scale, Effective use of scale, unsuccessful architectural materiality, sequence, materiality, sequence, materiality, sequence, solutions. Significant problems circulation, enclosure and or circulation, enclosure and or circulation, enclosure and with scale, materiality, visual perception. visual perception. visual perception. sequence, circulation, enclosure or visual perception.
ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN ASSESSMENT Enter rubric description Inadequate 1 pts D Adequate 2 pts C Accomplished 3 pts B Mastery 4 pts A Design Solution 40 % Originate successful design solutions to fundamental architectural problems by integrating concepts, formal/visual principles and techniques. Inadequate Does not attempt or is unable to complete design solutions. Unsuccessful design solution due to lack of creative use of concept, limited exploration of technique and/or application of principles. Little effort to challenge creative boundaries resulting in obvious or poorly developed solution. Adequate Fundamentally sound design solution with moderately creative use of concept, fundamentally appropriate technique, and adequate application of principles. Solution shows some effort to challenge creative boundaries with limited or uneven success. Accomplished Interesting design solution showing consistently creative development of concept, original development of technique and original application of principles. Solution shows ongoing creative inquiry and exploration of design potential with largely effective results. Mastery Compelling design solution showing highly original creative development of concept, innovative application of techniques and exemplary use of principles. Solution shows rigorous creative inquiry and investigation throughout design process with highly successful results. Formal & Spatial Principles 20 % Demonstrate fundamental understanding and application of architectural formal + spatial principles as they relate to human experience. Inadequate Does not attempt or is unable to complete design solutions. Limited understanding of experiental quality of architectural form and space resulting in largely unsuccessful architectural solutions. Significant problems with scale, materiality, sequence, circulation, enclosure or visual perception. Adequate functional understanding of experiental qualtity of architectural form and space resulting in fundamentally sound architectural solutions. Moderate problems with scale, materiality, sequence, circulation, enclosure and or visual perception. Accomplished Clear understanding of experiental qualtity of architectural form and space resulting in successful architectural solutions. Minor problems with scale, materiality, sequence, circulation, enclosure and or visual perception. Mastery Advanced understanding of experiental qualtity of architectural form and resulting in exemplary architectural solutions. Effective use of scale, materiality, sequence, circulation, enclosure and visual perception.
architectural_design_assessment.docx