DESIRABLE SELECTION CRITERIA ACADEMIC CLINICAL FELLOWSHIP – SHORTLISTERS PLEASE SEE IMPORTANT NOTE ABOVE Section Criterion 0 points 1 point 2 points 3 points 4 points Score None BSc or BA OR None 2:1 1st Class None MSC or MRes OR None In progress Awarded None 3A PhD or MD None In progress Awarded /3 (Mark in relevant subject (Mark one (Mark one (Mark one one (Mark one only) only) only) only) only) Three or more OR 1 highly Undergraduate or 3A None One or more prestigious - - /2 postgraduate prizes e.g. University Gold Medal Three or Honors’/ distinctions 3A None One or more - - /2 (in final MB) more Regular Formal 3D Teaching experience None - - /2 participation teaching role Activities Activities relevant to relevant to Extra-curricular clinical 3B/F/G/I None clinical /2 activities academic academic career in this career specialty Evidence of Evidence of Four or more several good more than 1 as a major quality publication in a contributor publications leading (e.g. first Evidence of as a specialty author) good quality or Scientific journal or including at 3C None publication evidence of /4 publications major journal least 1 one in as a good quality inc publication a leading publication as a major journal for as a major contributor the specialty contributor (e.g. first or other (e.g. first author) major journal author) Scientific presentations at Evidence Evidence Evidence 3C None - /3 limited ample outstanding Level No of Key academic Evidence Evidence Evidence Evidence 3 /4 achievements weak limited ample outstanding Total for desirable criteria (Maximum = 22)
DESIRABLE SELECTION CRITERIA – ACADEMIC CLINICAL FELLOWSHIP SHORTLISTERS PLEASE SEE IMPORTANT NOTE ABOVE Section Criterion 0 points 1 point 2 points 3 points 4 points Score 3A BSc or BA OR MSC or MRes OR PhD or MD in relevant subject (Mark one only) None None None (Mark one only) None None None (Mark one only) 2:1 In progress In progress (Mark one only) 1st Class Awarded Awarded (Mark one only) /3 3A Undergraduate or postgraduate prizes None One or more Three or more OR 1 highly prestigious e.g. University Gold Medal - - /2 3A Honors’/ distinctions (in final MB) None One or more Three or more - - /2 3D Teaching experience None Regular participation Formal teaching role - - /2 3B/F/G/I Extra-curricular activities None Activities relevant to clinical academic career Activities relevant to clinical academic career in this specialty /2 3C Scientific publications None Evidence of good quality publication as a Evidence of several good quality publications as a or evidence of good quality publication as a major contributor (e.g. first author) Evidence of more than 1 publication in a leading specialty journal or major journal inc publication as a major contributor (e.g. first author) Four or more as a major contributor (e.g. first author) including at least 1 one in a leading journal for the specialty or other major journal /4 3C Scientific presentations at Level None Evidence limited Evidence ample Evidence outstanding - /3 3 Key academic achievements No of Evidence weak Evidence limited Evidence ample Evidence outstanding /4 Total for desirable criteria (Maximum = 22)
acf_shortlisting_scoresheet.docx