3D-Scaled Playground Design Grading Rubric Elements 5 Points 4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1-0 Points Total Design brief is Design brief is 80% Design brief is 50% Design brief is less Design brief is less completed and complete. complete than 50% complete than 25% complete includes all or missing. required information, Design including client, Brief designer, problem statement, design statement, constraints and deliverables. The project The project design Some design The design process There is little or no Design includes a detailed process notes do not process notes are notes do not evidence of design Process step-by-step explain all steps missing or describe work done process notes. description of the thoroughly. incomplete. at each step of the Notes design process. design process. Sketches are Sketches are not Sketches are Sketches are not There is little or no complete and complete and are missing more than complete. Heading evidence of sketches annotated to show missing important half of the information is not in the notebook. Design all important information, such as identification of the complete and is not Sketches dimensions. measurements. components, and are accurate. Sketches missing multiple are lacking dimensions. annotations and dimensions. The decision The decision matrix The decision matrix The decision matrix The decision matrix matrix is complete does not evaluate criteria are is missing both is excessively with all criteria the required number incomplete. The criteria and incomplete or listed and each of drawings. The option selected is not evaluations of missing. The final drawing evaluated. student can justify clearly justified using drawings. The final project decision Decision The student can the final decision. the matrix. project decision cannot be justified effectively justify cannot be justified using the matrix. Making the final decision. using the matrix. Matrix The final product A slight difference A significant A significant The playground exactly matches exists between the difference exists difference exists model is excessively Prototypes the final design final product and the between the final between the final incomplete or is product and the final missing.
3D-Scaled Playground Design Grading Rubric Elements 5 Points 4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1-0 Points Total Design Brief Design brief is completed and includes all required information, including client, designer, problem statement, design statement, constraints and deliverables. Design brief is 80% complete. Design brief is 50% complete Design brief is less than 50% complete Design brief is less than 25% complete or missing. Design Process Notes The project includes a detailed step-by-step description of the design process. The project design process notes do not explain all steps thoroughly. Some design process notes are missing or incomplete. The design process notes do not describe work done at each step of the design process. There is little or no evidence of design process notes. Design Sketches Sketches are complete and annotated to show all important dimensions. Sketches are not complete and are missing important information, such as measurements. Sketches are missing more than half of the identification of the components, and are missing multiple dimensions. Sketches are not complete. Heading information is not complete and is not accurate. Sketches are lacking annotations and dimensions. There is little or no evidence of sketches in the notebook. Decision Making Matrix The decision matrix is complete with all criteria listed and each drawing evaluated. The student can effectively justify the final decision. The decision matrix does not evaluate the required number of drawings. The student can justify the final decision. The decision matrix criteria are incomplete. The option selected is not clearly justified using the matrix. The decision matrix is missing both criteria and evaluations of drawings. The final project decision cannot be justified using the matrix. The decision matrix is excessively incomplete or missing. The final project decision cannot be justified using the matrix. Prototypes The final product exactly matches the final design A slight difference exists between the final product and the A significant difference exists between the final product and the final A significant difference exists between the final The playground model is excessively incomplete or is missing.
3D_Scaled_Playground_Grading_Rubric.docx