Annex 3: Evaluation Matrix Evaluation Questions Indicators Sources Data Collection Method Evaluation Criteria: Relevance Does the Karst Level of coherence between Local government stakeholders Local level field visit Mainstreaming project’s project objective and stated interviews Local community stakeholders objective fit within the priorities of local stakeholders Desk review Local private sector priorities of the local stakeholders government and local Relevant regional and local communities? planning documents Does the Karst Level of coherence between National policy documents, Desk review Mainstreaming project’s project objective and national such as National Biodiversity National level interviews objective fit within national policy priorities and strategies, as Strategy and Action Plan, priorities? stated in official documents National Capacity etc. National legislation such as National Forest Code, etc. Karst Mainstreaming Did the Level of involvement of local and Project staff Field visit interviews project concept originate national stakeholders in project Local and national stakeholders Desk review from local or national origination and development as Project documents stakeholders, and/or were indicated by number of planning relevant stakeholders meetings held, representation of sufficiently involved in stakeholders in planning project development? meetings, and level of incorporation of stakeholder feedback in project planning Karst Does the Level of coherence between GEF strategic priority Desk review Mainstreaming project’s project objective and GEF documents for period when Field visit interviews objective fit GEF strategic strategic priorities project was approved priorities and operational Level of conformity with GEF Current GEF strategic priority principles? operational principles documents GEF operational principles Karst Does the Linkages between project CBD website Desk review Mainstreaming project’s objective and elements of the National Biodiversity Strategy objective support CBD, such as key articles and and Action Plan implementation of the programs of work Convention on Biological
Annex 3: Evaluation Matrix Evaluation Questions Indicators Sources Data Collection Method Evaluation Criteria: Relevance Does the Karst Mainstreaming project’s objective fit within the priorities of the local government and local communities? Level of coherence between project objective and stated priorities of local stakeholders Local government stakeholders Local community stakeholders Local private sector stakeholders Relevant regional and local planning documents Local level field visit interviews Desk review Does the Karst Mainstreaming project’s objective fit within national priorities? Level of coherence between project objective and national policy priorities and strategies, as stated in official documents National policy documents, such as National Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan, National Capacity etc. National legislation such as National Forest Code, etc. Desk review National level interviews Did the Karst Mainstreaming project concept originate from local or national stakeholders, and/or were relevant stakeholders sufficiently involved in project development? Level of involvement of local and national stakeholders in project origination and development as indicated by number of planning meetings held, representation of stakeholders in planning meetings, and level of incorporation of stakeholder feedback in project planning Project staff Local and national stakeholders Project documents Field visit interviews Desk review Does the Karst Mainstreaming project’s objective fit GEF strategic priorities and operational principles? Level of coherence between project objective and GEF strategic priorities Level of conformity with GEF operational principles GEF strategic priority documents for period when project was approved Current GEF strategic priority documents GEF operational principles Desk review Field visit interviews Does the Karst Mainstreaming project’s objective support implementation of the Convention on Biological Linkages between project objective and elements of the CBD, such as key articles and programs of work CBD website National Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan Desk review
2723_UNDP_TE_Terminal_Evaluation_Report_Karst_July_2013.docx