CommentID Subclause Page Line CommentType Comment SuggestedRemedy 2297 8.4.2.102 56 21 T Described Spatial decide for one Stream is not a solution "percentage"- part with multiplier 255. 2726 8.4.2.102 56 21 T The percentage is Replace value 1/100 while in percentage with Spatial Stream under value, or make it utilisation field the to be percentage. value is 1/255. Discussion: The description in line 18-25 is unclear and misleading. The description should instead make it clear that the parameter is defined as percentage of time and linearly scaled with 255 to represent 100% as described below. The Spatial Stream Under-Utilization is defined as the percentage of time but linearly scaled with 255 representing 100%. Proposed Response: COUNTER with the proposed text below. Proposed Resolution Text: The Spatial Stream field is defined as the fraction percentage of time, linearly scaled with 255 representing 100%, that the AP has under utilized spatial domain resources for given busy time of the medium. When more than one channel is in use for the BSS, the spatial stream under-utility value is calculated only for the primary channel. This percentage is computed using the formula, CommentID Subclause Page Line CommentType Comment SuggestedRemedy 3257 8.4.2.102 56 45, T The Forty MHz Change 51, field, "percentage" to Eighty MHz "fraction" for each 56 Utilization field and of the utilization Hundred Sixty MHz fields mentioned. Utilization field are all "defined as the fraction of time". They are not percentages, as described in the
CommentID Subclause Page Line CommentType Comment SuggestedRemedy 2297 8.4.2.102 56 21 T Described Spatial Stream is not a "percentage"- part with multiplier 255. decide for one solution 2726 8.4.2.102 56 21 T The percentage is value 1/100 while in Spatial Stream under utilisation field the value is 1/255. Replace percentage with value, or make it to be percentage. Discussion: The description in line 18-25 is unclear and misleading. The description should instead make it clear that the parameter is defined as percentage of time and linearly scaled with 255 to represent 100% as described below. The Spatial Stream Under-Utilization is defined as the percentage of time but linearly scaled with 255 representing 100%. Proposed Response: COUNTER with the proposed text below. Proposed Resolution Text: The Spatial Stream field is defined as the fraction percentage of time, linearly scaled with 255 representing 100%, that the AP has under utilized spatial domain resources for given busy time of the medium. When more than one channel is in use for the BSS, the spatial stream under-utility value is calculated only for the primary channel. This percentage is computed using the formula, CommentID Subclause Page Line CommentType Comment SuggestedRemedy 3257 8.4.2.102 56 45, 51, 56 T The Forty MHz field, Eighty MHz Utilization field and Hundred Sixty MHz Utilization field are all "defined as the fraction of time". They are not percentages, as described in the Change "percentage" to "fraction" for each of the utilization fields mentioned.
11-11-1018-01-00ac-comments-resolution-cids-section-8-4-2-102-part-1.docx