CID PP LL Comment Proposed Change Resolution 16283 154 17 "A-MSDU In A-MPDU Support" Change the field name to Revised is a bad name since this is "A-MSDU In The field name is change to A-MSDU in actually about ack-enabled Acknowledgment Context A-MPDU Support per CID . No In A-MPDU Support" further change is needed. 154 19 "an A-MSDU is carried in Change the cited text to a QoS Data for which no "an A-MSDU is block ack agreement exists." -- transmitted that is not Accepted. an A-MSDU is always carried under a block ack in a QoS Data frame agreement." CID PP LL Comment Proposed Change Resolution 15606 37 20 ambiguous definition clarify if all A-MPDU subframes solicit neither Revised Ack nor BlockAck or if Generally agree with the commenter. only the ones with 0 in the EOF field solicit TGax editor to make changes CID 15606. neither Ack nor BlockAck. 15934 37 17 This definition is getting into Stop the defintion of Revised normative details of _how_, A-MPDU" before Generally agree with the commenter. beyond just the _what_. (without) describing how individual bits are set TGax editor to make changes under CID within one. 15606. 3.2 Definitions specific to IEEE 802.11 TGax editor: make the following change in subclause 3.2: …… ack-enabled aggregate medium access control (MAC) protocol data unit (ack-enabled A-MPDU): An A-MPDU that contains at two A-MPDU subframes . …
CID PP LL Comment Proposed Change Resolution 16283 154 17 "A-MSDU In A-MPDU Support" is a bad name since this is actually about ack-enabled Change the field name to "A-MSDU In Acknowledgment Context In A-MPDU Support" Revised The field name is change to A-MSDU in A-MPDU Support per CID . No further change is needed. 154 19 "an A-MSDU is carried in a QoS Data for which no block ack agreement exists." -- an A-MSDU is always carried in a QoS Data frame Change the cited text to "an A-MSDU is transmitted that is not under a block ack agreement." Accepted. CID PP LL Comment Proposed Change Resolution 15606 37 20 ambiguous definition clarify if all A-MPDU subframes solicit neither Ack nor BlockAck or if only the ones with 0 in the EOF field solicit neither Ack nor BlockAck. Revised Generally agree with the commenter. TGax editor to make changes CID 15606. 15934 37 17 This definition is getting into normative details of _how_, beyond just the _what_. Stop the defintion of A-MPDU" before (without) describing how individual bits are set within one. Revised Generally agree with the commenter. TGax editor to make changes under CID 15606. 3.2 Definitions specific to IEEE 802.11 TGax editor: make the following change in subclause 3.2: …… ack-enabled aggregate medium access control (MAC) protocol data unit (ack-enabled A-MPDU): An A-MPDU that contains at two A-MPDU subframes . …
11-18-2040-02-00ax-11ax-d3-0-comment-resolution-miscellaneous.docx