CID Commenter Clause Page Comment Proposed Resolution Number(C) Change 6394 Bo Sun 8.4.1.48 51.49 it is not clear about Make changes Rejected: the description of agreed upon in Changes Remaining 11/1469r2 agreed upon in segments´╝îthe 11/1469r2 (CID description of 4667) were subfield"Remaining over-ridden by Segments" is the changes in inconsistent with 11/587r2 (in the comment response to resolution for 3476. CID 4667). Discussion: Changes agreed upon in 11/1469r2 (CID 4667) were over-ridden by the changes in 11/587r2 (in response to CID 4667). The description of how to set the fields of the VHT MIMO Control field are now clearly specified in the final paragraph of 8.4.1.47 (VHT MIMO Control field), so there is no need for the table referred to in 11/1469r2. Proposed Resolution: Rejected CID Commenter Clause Page Comment Proposed Resolution Number(C) Change 6526 Sigurd 8.4.1.47 50.49 Unlike other Add sentence to Revised. Schelstraete fields, this section: After last section does not sentence on state where the "The VHT MIMO 50.42, add VHT MIMO Control field sentence "The Control field will shall always be VHT MIMO be used. included in the Control field is VHT included in every Compressed VHT Compressed Beamforming Beamforming frame." frame (see 8.5.23.2)."
CID Commenter Clause Number(C) Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution 6394 Bo Sun 8.4.1.48 51.49 it is not clear about the description of Remaining segments´╝îthe description of subfield"Remaining Segments" is inconsistent with the comment resolution for 3476. Make changes agreed upon in 11/1469r2 Rejected: Changes agreed upon in 11/1469r2 (CID 4667) were over-ridden by the changes in 11/587r2 (in response to CID 4667). Discussion: Changes agreed upon in 11/1469r2 (CID 4667) were over-ridden by the changes in 11/587r2 (in response to CID 4667). The description of how to set the fields of the VHT MIMO Control field are now clearly specified in the final paragraph of 8.4.1.47 (VHT MIMO Control field), so there is no need for the table referred to in 11/1469r2. Proposed Resolution: Rejected CID Commenter Clause Number(C) Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution 6526 Sigurd Schelstraete 8.4.1.47 50.49 Unlike other fields, this section does not state where the VHT MIMO Control field will be used. Add sentence to section: "The VHT MIMO Control field shall always be included in the VHT Compressed Beamforming frame." Revised. After last sentence on 50.42, add sentence "The VHT MIMO Control field is included in every VHT Compressed Beamforming frame (see 8.5.23.2)."
11-12-1155-01-00ac-mu-comment-resolution-part-2.docx