6831 145.52 9.31.5 The sentence here is Clarify if a VHT NDP REVISED not in consistance Announcement with the rule at or a Beamforming See CID 6702 resolution pgl45/ln7 which Report Poll frame reads "A VHT can contain an HT beamformer shall not variant HT Control transmit either a VHT field. NDP Announcement+HTC frame or a Beamforming Report Poll+HTC frame that contains an HT variant HT Control field." 6095 145.53 9.31.5 The sentence here fix the problem. REVISED contradicts with P145L8. See CID 6702 resolution 6702 145.53 9.31.5 A VHT NDP remove the ACCEPTED Announcement frame sentence: A VHT with more than one NDP Announcement STA Info field shall frame with more not carry an HT than one STA Info variant HT Con- field shall not carry an HT variant HT trol field, unless all Con- the STAs listed in the AID field of the STA trol field, unless all Info fields have set the STAs listed in +HTC-HT Support to the AID field of the 1 STA Info fields have set +HTC-HT in the HT Extended Support to 1 Capabilities field. in the HT Extended Capabilities field conflicts with the paragraph earlier in the section P145L8 A VHT beamformer shall not transmit either a VHT NDP Announcement+HTC frame or a Beamforming Re- port Poll+HTC frame that contains an HT variant HT Control field. 6296 145.54 9.31.5 "unless" seems to Harmonize para at REVISED contradict P145L8. P145L53 with Duelling paras? P145L8 See CID 6702 resolution
6831 145.52 9.31.5 The sentence here is not in consistance with the rule at pgl45/ln7 which reads "A VHT beamformer shall not transmit either a VHT NDP Announcement+HTC frame or a Beamforming Report Poll+HTC frame that contains an HT variant HT Control field." Clarify if a VHT NDP Announcement or a Beamforming Report Poll frame can contain an HT variant HT Control field. REVISED See CID 6702 resolution 6095 145.53 9.31.5 The sentence here contradicts with P145L8. fix the problem. REVISED See CID 6702 resolution 6702 145.53 9.31.5 A VHT NDP Announcement frame with more than one STA Info field shall not carry an HT variant HT Con- trol field, unless all the STAs listed in the AID field of the STA Info fields have set +HTC-HT Support to 1 in the HT Extended Capabilities field. conflicts with the paragraph earlier in the section P145L8 A VHT beamformer shall not transmit either a VHT NDP Announcement+HTC frame or a Beamforming Re- port Poll+HTC frame that contains an HT variant HT Control field. remove the sentence: A VHT NDP Announcement frame with more than one STA Info field shall not carry an HT variant HT Con- trol field, unless all the STAs listed in the AID field of the STA Info fields have set +HTC-HT Support to 1 in the HT Extended Capabilities field ACCEPTED 6296 145.54 9.31.5 "unless" seems to contradict P145L8. Duelling paras? Harmonize para at P145L53 with P145L8 REVISED See CID 6702 resolution
11-12-1032-01-00ac-d3-0-sounding-comment-resolutions.docx