11774 27.9.2.2 291.41 "Adjusting the Delete "Adjusting See 11-17-LLLLrY OBSS_PD and the OBSS_PD level Smith transmit power can and transmit power improve the system level can improve the performance and the system level utilization of the performance and spectrum." It has been the utilization of the shown that this is not spectrum." true, 17/0582 shows pretty clearly that this does not work. If the lobby insists on retaining this feature, then at least avoid alternative truths. Delete 14280 41 291.41 First sentence describes Add description See 11-17-LLLLrY advantages of adjusting about advantage the OBSS_PD level and form the view of the transmit power from the STA like follows; view of system level. The STA which However a STA itself adjusts the can't be aware of system OBSS_PD level level improvement but and transmit power can be aware of only the can ignore STA's performance by transmitted signals itself. Advantages from received from the view of the STA outside the range should be added, which it intends to otherwise there is no execute incentive or motivation communication and for the STA to take gain opportunity to adjusting the OBSS_PD comunicate with level and transmit intended partner. power. This clause provides the as in comment See 11-17-LLLLrY 13063 27.9.2.2 291.46 for adjusting OBSS_PD value. However it doesn't state when this change is requested, i.e. what event does trigger this adjustment? 27.9.2.2 291.47 Equation 27-3 indicates Replace with = See 11-17-LLLLrY 11777 ╘δ± that the TX power may Smith be less than the simple rule and could, in fact, be set to zero. Seems pretty dumb to me to have the < sign there as it is bad enough already and can one really see devices using less than the permitted power if they were dumb enough to do this anyway?
11774 Smith 27.9.2.2 291.41 "Adjusting the OBSS_PD and transmit power can improve the system level performance and the utilization of the spectrum." It has been shown that this is not true, 17/0582 shows pretty clearly that this does not work. If the lobby insists on retaining this feature, then at least avoid alternative truths. Delete Delete "Adjusting the OBSS_PD level and transmit power can improve the system level performance and the utilization of the spectrum." See 11-17-LLLLrY 14280 41 291.41 First sentence describes advantages of adjusting the OBSS_PD level and transmit power from the view of system level. However a STA itself can't be aware of system level improvement but can be aware of only the STA's performance by itself. Advantages from the view of the STA should be added, otherwise there is no incentive or motivation for the STA to take adjusting the OBSS_PD level and transmit power. Add description about advantage form the view of the STA like follows; The STA which adjusts the OBSS_PD level and transmit power can ignore transmitted signals received from outside the range which it intends to execute communication and gain opportunity to comunicate with intended partner. See 11-17-LLLLrY 13063 27.9.2.2 291.46 This clause provides the for adjusting OBSS_PD value. However it doesn't state when this change is requested, i.e. what event does trigger this adjustment? as in comment See 11-17-LLLLrY 11777 Smith 27.9.2.2 291.47 Equation 27-3 indicates that the TX power may be less than the simple rule and could, in fact, be set to zero. Seems pretty dumb to me to have the < sign there as it is bad enough already and can one really see devices using less than the permitted power if they were dumb enough to do this anyway? Replace ╘δ± with = See 11-17-LLLLrY
11-18-0026-02-00ax-cr-srg-and-srp.docx