8200 Osama 72.47 Table 9-262k1 seems either provide a Revise generally – to be totally arbitrary rationale for the agree with and is not based on different restrictions comment, table any rationale. Perhaps or simply delete the modified some explanation is in table. My significantly to order. preference is to simplify - TGax delete the table. editor shall make the changes shown in 11-17/0777r5 that are marked with CID 8200. 8591 Sheng 70.50 The terms Scheduling as in comment Reject definitions – Sun STA and Scheduled exist in 27.7.3.1 STA need to be defined 9843 Young 69.63 It is not clear the As in the comment. Revise generally – Hoon meaning when the agree with Kwon Wake TBTT comment - TGax Negotiation subfield is editor shall make set to or 1. Need the changes shown further clarification. in 11-17/0777r5 that are marked with CID 9843. 9971 70.04 The expression "The The Wake TBTT Revise generally Yuchen – Guo Wake TBTT Negotiation subfield agree with Negotiation subfield is is set to 1 in TWT comment - TGax set to in TWT elements editor shall make elements transmitted transmitted by a the changes shown by a responding STA responding STA in 11-17/0777r5 and by a scheduling and by a that are marked STA." is not correct. scheduling STA in with CID 9971. When the TWT the negotiation scheduling STA procedure of wake transmits a TWT TBTT and listen response as a interval, and set to response to a TWT otherwise. request frame in the negotiation procedure of wake TBTT and listen interval, The value of the Wake TBTT Negotiation subfield should be equal to 1. Discussion: TWT IE changes based on CIDs as shown above.
8200 Osama 72.47 Table 9-262k1 seems to be totally arbitrary and is not based on any rationale. Perhaps some explanation is in order. either provide a rationale for the different restrictions or simply delete the table. My preference is to delete the table. Revise – generally agree with comment, table modified significantly to simplify - TGax editor shall make the changes shown in 11-17/0777r5 that are marked with CID 8200. 8591 Sheng Sun 70.50 The terms Scheduling STA and Scheduled STA need to be defined as in comment Reject – definitions exist in 27.7.3.1 9843 Young Hoon Kwon 69.63 It is not clear the meaning when the Wake TBTT Negotiation subfield is set to or 1. Need further clarification. As in the comment. Revise – generally agree with comment - TGax editor shall make the changes shown in 11-17/0777r5 that are marked with CID 9843. 9971 Yuchen Guo 70.04 The expression "The Wake TBTT Negotiation subfield is set to in TWT elements transmitted by a responding STA and by a scheduling STA." is not correct. When the TWT scheduling STA transmits a TWT response as a response to a TWT request frame in the negotiation procedure of wake TBTT and listen interval, The value of the Wake TBTT Negotiation subfield should be equal to 1. The Wake TBTT Negotiation subfield is set to 1 in TWT elements transmitted by a responding STA and by a scheduling STA in the negotiation procedure of wake TBTT and listen interval, and set to otherwise. Revise – generally agree with comment - TGax editor shall make the changes shown in 11-17/0777r5 that are marked with CID 9971. Discussion: TWT IE changes based on CIDs as shown above.
11-17-0777-05-00ax-cr-twt-ie.docx