7250 Sigurd 8.5.23.3 There is no Add appropriate Rejected statement on requirement whether "Membership Status Array" and "User Position Array" should always be present or not. DISCUSSION: The commenter is correct that is no explicit statement regarding the inclusion of the two fields, but inclusion of all fields in other frame formats in 8.5 is assumed unless it is explicitly stated that a field is optional. Therefore, it does not seem that an explicit statement is necessary here. PROPOSED RESOLUTION: Rejected CID Clause Page Comment Proposed Resolution Change 7274 Sigurd 22.3.11.1 Inconsistent use of "spatial Use REVISE. Change “spatial streams" and "space-time streams” on 290.9 to streams". streams”. “space-time streams" Text states: "With SU-MIMO or "spatial beamforming, all spatial streams" streams in the transmitted for both signal are intended for cases reception at a single STA. (either With DL-MU-MIMO works). beamforming, the space-time streams are divided between one or more STAs." Why "spatial streams" in one case (SU) and "space-time streams" in the other (MU)? CID Clause Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution
7250 Sigurd 8.5.23.3 There is no statement on whether "Membership Status Array" and "User Position Array" should always be present or not. Add appropriate requirement Rejected DISCUSSION: The commenter is correct that is no explicit statement regarding the inclusion of the two fields, but inclusion of all fields in other frame formats in 8.5 is assumed unless it is explicitly stated that a field is optional. Therefore, it does not seem that an explicit statement is necessary here. PROPOSED RESOLUTION: Rejected CID Clause Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution 7274 Sigurd 22.3.11.1 Inconsistent use of "spatial streams" and "space-time streams". Text states: "With SU-MIMO beamforming, all spatial streams in the transmitted signal are intended for reception at a single STA. With DL-MU-MIMO beamforming, the space-time streams are divided between one or more STAs." Why "spatial streams" in one case (SU) and "space-time streams" in the other (MU)? Use streams" or "spatial streams" for both cases (either works). REVISE. Change “spatial streams” on 290.9 to “space-time streams”. CID Clause Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution
11-12-1380-00-00ac-lb189-mu-comment-resolution.docx