IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs REVmd Assorted Comment Resolutions Date: 2018-09-09 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Menzo Wentink Qualcomm Utrecht, the Netherlands +31-65-183-6231 mwentink@qualcomm.com Abstract This document contains proposed resolutions for several REVmd comments (16): 1267, 1263, 1143, 1142, 1128, 1126, 1124, 1123, 1122, 1110 1090, 1088, 1432, 1438, 1439, 1583 Clause CID Page Comment Proposed Change Proposed Change Line 1267 Joseph 11.23.6.5 Calling a S1G 2, 4, 8, or 16 MHz Remove the (11ah) additions to 11.23.6.5 Rejected - the wideband aspect is relative to the Levy 2143 off-channel TDLS direct link a which added S1G to the wide bandwidth bandwidth of the base channel, and a wideband 20 "wide bandwidth off-channel direct off-channel direct link and add a new direct link is always wider than the base channel. link" seems a bit confusing. I section "11.23.6.6 Setting up a S1G The S1G modifications appear to have been understand the need to allow for an channel direct link" with the S1G added in a fairly natural way, so there would be off-channel direct link for S1G requirements. no need to restructure the clause. STAs, but shouldn't it be called something else. Also the way the feature is implemented in the section 11.23.6.5 seems very awkward. It would be better to add a new set of clauses for the "S1G off-channel direct link", which duplicate 11.23.6.5 with the S1G changes. This would also eliminate the need to keep switching between VHT and S1G requirements.
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs REVmd Assorted Comment Resolutions Date: 2018-09-09 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Menzo Wentink Qualcomm Utrecht, the Netherlands +31-65-183-6231 mwentink@qualcomm.com Abstract This document contains proposed resolutions for several REVmd comments (16): 1267, 1263, 1143, 1142, 1128, 1126, 1124, 1123, 1122, 1110 1090, 1088, 1432, 1438, 1439, 1583 CID Clause Page Line Comment Proposed Change Proposed Change 1267 Joseph Levy 11.23.6.5 2143 20 Calling a S1G 2, 4, 8, or 16 MHz off-channel TDLS direct link a "wide bandwidth off-channel direct link" seems a bit confusing. I understand the need to allow for an off-channel direct link for S1G STAs, but shouldn't it be called something else. Also the way the feature is implemented in the section 11.23.6.5 seems very awkward. It would be better to add a new set of clauses for the "S1G off-channel direct link", which duplicate 11.23.6.5 with the S1G changes. This would also eliminate the need to keep switching between VHT and S1G requirements. Remove the (11ah) additions to 11.23.6.5 which added S1G to the wide bandwidth off-channel direct link and add a new section "11.23.6.6 Setting up a S1G direct link" with the S1G requirements. Rejected - the wideband aspect is relative to the bandwidth of the base channel, and a wideband direct link is always wider than the base channel. The S1G modifications appear to have been added in a fairly natural way, so there would be no need to restructure the clause. channel
11-18-1930-06-000m-assorted-comment-resolutions.docx