1325 Mark 28.05 "beacon frames Reword in terms of Revised Agree in – RISON containing broadcast "with a TWT element principle with the TWT," -- what does that indicates a comment TGax – this mean? How does broadcast TWT" or editor to make the a beacon contain a similar changes shown in broadcast TWT? under all headings that include CID 1324 1327 Mark 29.04 are 3 blank cells Put "N/A" in each Revised Agree in – RISON in this table principle with the comment note that – one entry is now filled with text that is not N/A TGax editor to – make the changes shown in 11-16/1266r2 under all headings that include CID 1327 1655 Matthew 26.38 The table of TWT Clarify the Revised Agree in – Fischer command values is relationships the principle with the not clear. various command comment TGax – options and provide editor to make the more explanation as changes shown in to how each one is to under all be used. headings that include CID 1655 1721 Osama 26.38 It is not clear to me Delete TWT from the The comment fails to why 11ax should TWT amendment and all identify a technical with no added value. related sections. issue. Please refer to The TWT will attract the contributions that 100 of comments and have discussed this waste lots of energy topic in IEEE for the answering these added value: comments. TargetWakeTime: Scheduled Trigger frames: 2276 Xiaofei 26.43 The definition of remove L43~L56 Revise use of the – Wang Boradcast field is Broadcast bit is unnecessary because extended to allow a if TWT element is broadcast TWT contained in a beacon response to a request frame, it is broadcast for an individual TWT without ambiguity agreement and to allow an explicit request for a broadcast TWT agreement as well as identifying the specific role of the transmitter of a TWT IE. TGax editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 2276
1325 Mark RISON 28.05 "beacon frames containing broadcast TWT," -- what does this mean? How does a beacon contain a broadcast TWT? Reword in terms of "with a TWT element that indicates a broadcast TWT" or similar Revised – Agree in principle with the comment – TGax editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 1324 1327 Mark RISON 29.04 are 3 blank cells in this table Put "N/A" in each Revised – Agree in principle with the comment – note that one entry is now filled with text that is not N/A – TGax editor to make the changes shown in 11-16/1266r2 under all headings that include CID 1327 1655 Matthew Fischer 26.38 The table of TWT command values is not clear. Clarify the relationships the various command options and provide more explanation as to how each one is to be used. Revised – Agree in principle with the comment – TGax editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 1655 1721 Osama 26.38 It is not clear to me why 11ax should TWT with no added value. The TWT will attract 100 of comments and waste lots of energy answering these comments. Delete TWT from the amendment and all related sections. The comment fails to identify a technical issue. Please refer to the contributions that have discussed this topic in IEEE for the added value: TargetWakeTime: Scheduled Trigger frames: 2276 Xiaofei Wang 26.43 The definition of Boradcast field is unnecessary because if TWT element is contained in a beacon frame, it is broadcast without ambiguity remove L43~L56 Revise – use of the Broadcast bit is extended to allow a broadcast TWT response to a request for an individual TWT agreement and to allow an explicit request for a broadcast TWT agreement as well as identifying the specific role of the transmitter of a TWT IE. TGax editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 2276
11-16-1266-02-00ax-cc23-pr-elements.docx