3240 10.43.9.7 289 20 Add that the PPDU as in comment that the respodner sends have the tx vector conditions as the one sent by the initiator (lines 3241 10.43.9.7 289 25 "with the Dual add that this field is set to 0 Polarization TRN field in the EDMG BRP Request element." What is this field set to? 3305 10.43.9.7 289 27 The editors note Correct the potential technical Dual points out a flaw issues and add the subsequent polarization and the text to correct or clarify. The TRN technical/protocol Editors satisafaction for the beamforming issues need to be correct change/additions would traini corrected. change my "Must Be Satisfied" to a "No". 3306 10.43.9.7 289 34 The editors note Correct the potential technical Dual points out a flaw issues and add the subsequent polarization and the text to correct or clarify. The TRN technical/protocol Editors satisafaction for the beamforming issues need to be correct change/additions would traini corrected. change my "Must Be Satisfied" to a "No". 3363 10.43.9.7 289 27 There are Editor Please fix broken part of the Notes stating some protocol. issue with the normative behavior described in 10.43.9.7. They need to be clarified before moving to the sponsor ballot. Discussion: The editor is correct that the text is confusing and needs to be revised. Resolution: Revised Replace the text: 12 EDMG STA initiates a dual polarization TRN beamforming training by sending a PPDU with the following “An TXVECTOR parameters setting: DUAL POL_TRAINING set to 1; and 15 EDMG_PACKET_TYPE set to either EDMG-TRN-T-PACKET or EDMG-TRN-R/T-PACKET; and EDMG_TRN_LEN set to a value greater than 0; and EDMG-TRN-N set to either 1 or 3 To request dual polarization TRN beamforming training, an intiating STA shall transmit a frame to a responding STA that
3240 10.43.9.7 289 20 Add that the PPDU that the respodner sends have the tx vector conditions as the one sent by the initiator (lines as in comment 3241 10.43.9.7 289 25 "with the Dual Polarization TRN field in the EDMG BRP Request element." What is this field set to? add that this field is set to 0 3305 10.43.9.7 Dual polarization TRN beamforming traini 289 27 The editors note points out a flaw and the technical/protocol issues need to be corrected. Correct the potential technical issues and add the subsequent text to correct or clarify. The Editors satisafaction for the correct change/additions would change my "Must Be Satisfied" to a "No". 3306 10.43.9.7 Dual polarization TRN beamforming traini 289 34 The editors note points out a flaw and the technical/protocol issues need to be corrected. Correct the potential technical issues and add the subsequent text to correct or clarify. The Editors satisafaction for the correct change/additions would change my "Must Be Satisfied" to a "No". 3363 10.43.9.7 289 27 There are Editor Notes stating some issue with the normative behavior described in 10.43.9.7. They need to be clarified before moving to the sponsor ballot. Please fix broken part of the protocol. Discussion: The editor is correct that the text is confusing and needs to be revised. Resolution: Revised Replace the text: “An EDMG STA initiates a dual polarization TRN beamforming training by sending a PPDU with the 12 following TXVECTOR parameters setting: DUAL POL_TRAINING set to 1; and EDMG_PACKET_TYPE set to either EDMG-TRN-T-PACKET or EDMG-TRN-R/T-PACKET; 15 and EDMG_TRN_LEN set to a value greater than 0; and EDMG-TRN-N set to either 1 or 3 To request dual polarization TRN beamforming training, an intiating STA shall transmit a frame to a responding STA that
11-18-1894-00-00ay-cids-los-determination.docx