CID Comment Proposed Change Remark 406 164 41 T The formula seems For 2.16 GHz band, DMG to have an error. specification (i.e. 20.3.1 According to the Channelization) can be formula and the referred. parameters in Annex E, the center For 1.08 GHz band, suggest frequencies of the following formula and channel number parameters: 2,3,5,6,7, and 8 are Channel center frequency = calculated as 63.72, Channel starting frequency + 65.88, 60.48, 61.56, Channel spacing x (Channel 62.64, and 59.40 number mod 32) [GHz] respectively where Channel starting and they don't frequency is 56.70 GHz, match with the Channel spacing = 1080 MHz, figure in and Channel numbers are {35,36,37,38} instead of {5,6,7,8} respectively. This re-numbering enables regular numbering, and also avoids conflict with 11ay channelization seen in SFD). 407 E.1 284 27 T The channel starting frequencies for As the operating class 10 and 11 may be same as incorrect. The channel starting CID 406 frequencies and/or the formula in 25.3.1 (Channelization) should be corrected. Proposed resolution: Accepted. Change the starting frequency from GHz” to GHz” and GHz” to “59.4 “56.16 “59.4 for Operating class 10 and 11 respectively. “56.70” Change the formula in clause 25.3.1 in 11aj is as follows: center frequency = Channel starting frequency + Channel spacing × “Channel (Channel number mod 324)”
CID Comment Proposed Change Remark 406 164 41 T The formula seems to have an error. According to the formula and the parameters in Annex E, the center frequencies of channel number 2,3,5,6,7, and 8 are calculated as 63.72, 65.88, 60.48, 61.56, 62.64, and 59.40 [GHz] respectively and they don't match with the figure in For 2.16 GHz band, DMG specification (i.e. 20.3.1 Channelization) can be referred. For 1.08 GHz band, suggest the following formula and parameters: Channel center frequency = Channel starting frequency + Channel spacing x (Channel number mod 32) where Channel starting frequency is 56.70 GHz, Channel spacing = 1080 MHz, and Channel numbers are {35,36,37,38} instead of {5,6,7,8} respectively. This re-numbering enables regular numbering, and also avoids conflict with 11ay channelization seen in SFD). 407 E.1 284 27 T The channel starting frequencies for operating class 10 and 11 may be incorrect. The channel starting frequencies and/or the formula in 25.3.1 (Channelization) should be corrected. As the same as CID 406 Proposed resolution: Accepted. Change the starting frequency from “59.4 GHz” to “56.16 GHz” and “59.4 GHz” to “56.70” for Operating class 10 and 11 respectively. Change the formula in clause 25.3.1 in 11aj is as follows: “Channel center frequency = Channel starting frequency + Channel spacing × (Channel number mod 324)”
11-16-0972-01-00aj-proposed-resolution-to-cid-401-402-408-416-423-424-427-431-436-437-404-406-407-409-410-411-418-419-422-425-426-and-428-in-lb220.docx