IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs PHY Remaining CSD Date: 2018-11-08 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address email Bin Tian Qualcomm btian@qti.qualcomm.com CID P.L Comment Proposed Change Resolution 6GHz PHY operation Add definition of 6GHz PHY Reject— definition is missing. operation 6 The comment is right that the text on 6GHz PHY is missing in D3.0. However, as part of the resolution for 16772, in 18/1841r1 the following text is added: the GHz band, the “In HE PHY is the same as the HE PHY in the 5 GHz band”. The request of comment has already been satisfied. CID P.L Comment Proposed Change Resolution Split bullet "Single spatial See comment stream HE-MCSs 0 to 7 in all supported channel Reject widths and RU sizes for The current text is clear. There HE MU PPDUs (receive) or HE is no technical benefit to split TB PPDUs (transmit)" the bullet into two. into two bullets, one for transmit and one for receive requirement. Discussion A non-AP HE STA shall support the following features: Single spatial stream HE-MCSs 0 to 7 in all supported channel widths and RU sizes for HE — MU PPDUs (receive) or HE TB PPDUs (transmit).
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs PHY Remaining CSD Date: 2018-11-08 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address email Bin Tian Qualcomm btian@qti.qualcomm.com CID P.L Comment Proposed Change Resolution 6GHz PHY operation definition is missing. Add definition of 6GHz PHY operation Reject— The comment is right that the text on 6GHz PHY is missing in D3.0. However, as part of the resolution for 16772, in 18/1841r1 the following text is added: “In the 6 GHz band, the HE PHY is the same as the HE PHY in the 5 GHz band”. The request of comment has already been satisfied. CID P.L Comment Proposed Change Resolution Split bullet "Single spatial stream HE-MCSs 0 to 7 in all supported channel widths and RU sizes for HE MU PPDUs (receive) or HE TB PPDUs (transmit)" into two bullets, one for transmit and one for receive requirement. See comment Reject The current text is clear. There is no technical benefit to split the bullet into two. Discussion A non-AP HE STA shall support the following features: — Single spatial stream HE-MCSs 0 to 7 in all supported channel widths and RU sizes for HE MU PPDUs (receive) or HE TB PPDUs (transmit).
11-18-2017-01-00ax-phy-remaining-cids.docx