CID PP LL Comment Proposed Change Resolution 3083 195 There are cases (like GCR, Add text to clarify that Rejected. FMS) where the traffic is for a when the STA_ID_LIST Discussion: the checking of MAC header to limited set of STAs (i.e., not indicates 'more than one decide whether the frames carried in a DL RU broadcast to all) - in such STA', a STA should is mandatory requirement for all RUs, not just cases, a STA needs to check check the MAC header to for broadcast RUs. The reason is that the BSS the MAC header to see if it is see if it is one of the color + AID in HE SIG-B to identify a DL RU is not unique. one of the intended recipient. intended recipient. 7778 196 2 2047 is used as start of MAC Clarify padding on page 165 line 35 Rejected and here it's used to indicate STAs in all BSS when Discussion: 2047 for MAC padding is used in multiBSS is acviated. How Trigger frame. 2047 for broadcast RU indentification is in HE SIG-B. These two does a STA identify if it's for usage should be ok. start of the MAC padding or for STAs in all BSS? 8724 195 48 Is it correct that the See comment Revised STA_ID_LIST contains one Generally agree with the commenter.
CID PP LL Comment Proposed Change Resolution 3083 195 There are cases (like GCR, FMS) where the traffic is for a limited set of STAs (i.e., not broadcast to all) - in such cases, a STA needs to check the MAC header to see if it is one of the intended recipient. Add text to clarify that when the STA_ID_LIST indicates 'more than one STA', a STA should check the MAC header to see if it is one of the intended recipient. Rejected. Discussion: the checking of MAC header to decide whether the frames carried in a DL RU is mandatory requirement for all RUs, not just for broadcast RUs. The reason is that the BSS color + AID in HE SIG-B to identify a DL RU is not unique. 7778 196 2 2047 is used as start of MAC padding on page 165 line 35 and here it's used to indicate STAs in all BSS when multiBSS is acviated. How does a STA identify if it's for start of the MAC padding or for STAs in all BSS? Clarify Rejected Discussion: 2047 for MAC padding is used in Trigger frame. 2047 for broadcast RU indentification is in HE SIG-B. These two usage should be ok. 8724 195 48 Is it correct that the STA_ID_LIST contains one See comment Revised Generally agree with the commenter.
11-17-1282-00-00ax-lb225-11ax-d1-0-comment-resolution-27-11-1-27-11-2.docx