5171 133.04 Since in AP PM RAW, "Same Change the RPS Revised Group Indication"actually definition per the indicates whether the RAW commment -TGah editor to make the group include STAs or not, the changes shown in indication field name should under the not be "Same Group heading CID 5170, 5171. Indication". It should be "Group Presense Indication". In different RAW, "group not presense" has different meaning, e.g. same group as previous RAW or no STAs in the RAW. 5172 134.25 "The RAW Start Time Change the start time Rejected subfield indicates the duration, of RAW absolute time in units of 2 TU, from the end pre TSF time. -The AP only to know of the S1G Beacon or the RAW allocation within the(Short) Probe Response a beacon interval, and the frame transmission that relative indication of RAW includes the RPS element to start time with respect to the start time of the RAW." Beacon/Probe Response in current form is sufficient. The time of transmission of Beacon/Probe Response is not predictable until the real transmission. This means that the AP doesn't exactly know the start time and the end time of the RAW until the transmission of the Beacon/Probe response. This makes the implementation of RAW complicated.
5171 133.04 Since in AP PM RAW, "Same Group Indication"actually indicates whether the RAW group include STAs or not, the indication field name should not be "Same Group Indication". It should be "Group Presense Indication". In different RAW, "group not presense" has different meaning, e.g. same group as previous RAW or no STAs in the RAW. Change the RPS definition per the commment Revised -TGah editor to make the changes shown in under the heading CID 5170, 5171. 5172 134.25 "The RAW Start Time subfield indicates the duration, in units of 2 TU, from the end of the S1G Beacon or the(Short) Probe Response frame transmission that includes the RPS element to the start time of the RAW." The time of transmission of Beacon/Probe Response is not predictable until the real transmission. This means that the AP doesn't exactly know the start time and the end time of the RAW until the transmission of the Beacon/Probe response. This makes the implementation of RAW complicated. Change the start time of RAW absolute time pre TSF time. Rejected -The AP only to know the RAW allocation within a beacon interval, and the relative indication of RAW start time with respect to Beacon/Probe Response in current form is sufficient.
11-14-1567-00-00ah-lb205-comment-resolution-for-subclause-8-4-2-170b.docx