CID Clause Page Line Comment Proposed Change Resolution 12311 491 51 It is important for the AP to Ensure that the spec Rejected. know the Max Power for defines efficient MCS7 or to derive the target operation around it is for HE TB RSSI for max power for Max power for PPDU, the transmit MCS 7 as this is the MCS7 to allow the power of each STA is threshold between 2 AP to force STAs to controlled the AP. different EVM requirements. operate with good There should be an efficient EVM And different way of collecting such immplementations information, or requiring have different max STAs to operate at or below that power level. power for MCS7. The requirement for EVM of other MCSs for HE TB PPDU is just to reduce the inter-user interferences. 3.2 29 42 the definitions of 20MHz mask delete bulletins i), j) Revised. PPDU for i), j) and k) are and k) unnecessary since they are 11ax editor, please see covered by b), c), and d), the discussion for respectively. instructions of CID IEEE 12319 in doc 802.11-18/0475r2. 12320 3.2 30 44 the definitions of 40MHz delete bulletins k) Rejected. mask PPDU for k) and l) are and l) unnecessary since they are In D2.2, item k) and l) covered by a) and f), specify the HE STA, respectively. they are different from a) and f). 12321 3.2 31 21 the definitions of 80MHz delete bulletins f) Revised. mask PPDU for f) and g) are and g). unnecessary since they are 11ax editor, please see covered by a) and b), the discussion for respectively. instructions of CID IEEE 12321 in doc 802.11-18/0475r2.
CID Clause Page Line Comment Proposed Change Resolution 12311 491 51 It is important for the AP to know the Max Power for MCS7 or to derive the target RSSI for max power for MCS 7 as this is the threshold between 2 different EVM requirements. There should be an efficient way of collecting such information, or requiring STAs to operate at or below that power level. Ensure that the spec defines efficient operation around Max power for MCS7 to allow the AP to force STAs to operate with good EVM Rejected. it is for HE TB PPDU, the transmit power of each STA is controlled the AP. And different immplementations have different max power for MCS7. The requirement for EVM of other MCSs for HE TB PPDU is just to reduce the inter-user interferences. 3.2 29 42 the definitions of 20MHz mask PPDU for i), j) and k) are unnecessary since they are covered by b), c), and d), respectively. delete bulletins i), j) and k) Revised. 11ax editor, please see the discussion for instructions of CID 12319 in doc IEEE 802.11-18/0475r2. 12320 3.2 30 44 the definitions of 40MHz mask PPDU for k) and l) are unnecessary since they are covered by a) and f), respectively. delete bulletins k) and l) Rejected. In D2.2, item k) and l) specify the HE STA, they are different from a) and f). 12321 3.2 31 21 the definitions of 80MHz mask PPDU for f) and g) are unnecessary since they are covered by a) and b), respectively. delete bulletins f) and g). Revised. 11ax editor, please see the discussion for instructions of CID 12321 in doc IEEE 802.11-18/0475r2.
11-18-0475-02-00ax-lb230-comment-resolution-on-cids-for-28-3-part-2.docx