Parameters listed in 28-13 not only apply to Data field but aslo apply to other HE-modulated fields in a non-OFDMA HE PPDU. It is more accurate to rename Table 28-13 to allocation related “Tone constants for the HE-modulated fields in a non-OFDMA HE PPDU” ax editor: please replace Table 28-13 title allocation related constants for the Data field in a “Tone HE PPDU” with allocation related constants for the HE-modulated fields in a “Tone HE PPDU” and change the corresponding references throughout the draft. 11383 Bin Tian 28.3.9 397.13 Remove "and HE TB as in the Revised. comment Change to as in PPDU" since alpha_r the resolution of doesn't apply to TB CID11383 in doc PPDU in eq 28-4 ax editor: please make the following change in D2.0 Clause 28.3.9 On P397L13 (CID #11383): For an HE SU PPDU HE ER SU PPDU, is always set to 1. 11384 Bin Tian 28.3.9 397.23 In equation (28-5), it as in the Revised. comment Change to as in should be |Kr Field| the resolution of instead of Kr Field CID11383 in doc ax editor: please make the following change in D2.0 Clause 28.3.9 On P397L23 (CID #11384): replace for HE modulated fields in an HE TB PPDU” with for HE “, “, modulated fields in an HE TB PPDU” in Equation (28-5). 11385 Bin Tian 28.3.9 398.43 It's better to add a as in the Rejected. comment Subcarrier index k subscript r (i.e. RU id) is a function of RU to the spatial mapping index r. RU index r matrix Q_k_(iseg) and can be inferred Q_k,u_(iseg) since its from subcarrier index k. dimension depends on Nsts_r,total which varies per RU.
Parameters listed in 28-13 not only apply to Data field but aslo apply to other HE-modulated fields in a non-OFDMA HE PPDU. It is more accurate to rename Table 28-13 to “Tone allocation related constants for the HE-modulated fields in a non-OFDMA HE PPDU” ax editor: please replace Table 28-13 title “Tone allocation related constants for the Data field in a HE PPDU” with “Tone allocation related constants for the HE-modulated fields in a HE PPDU” and change the corresponding references throughout the draft. 11383 Bin Tian 28.3.9 397.13 Remove "and HE TB PPDU" since alpha_r doesn't apply to TB PPDU in eq 28-4 as in the comment Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID11383 in doc ax editor: please make the following change in D2.0 Clause 28.3.9 On P397L13 (CID #11383): For an HE SU PPDU HE ER SU PPDU, is always set to 1. 11384 Bin Tian 28.3.9 397.23 In equation (28-5), it should be |Kr Field| instead of Kr Field as in the comment Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID11383 in doc ax editor: please make the following change in D2.0 Clause 28.3.9 On P397L23 (CID #11384): replace “, for HE modulated fields in an HE TB PPDU” with “, for HE modulated fields in an HE TB PPDU” in Equation (28-5). 11385 Bin Tian 28.3.9 398.43 It's better to add a subscript r (i.e. RU id) to the spatial mapping matrix Q_k_(iseg) and Q_k,u_(iseg) since its dimension depends on Nsts_r,total which varies per RU. as in the comment Rejected. Subcarrier index k is a function of RU index r. RU index r can be inferred from subcarrier index k.
11-18-0109-01-00ax-11ax-comment-resolutions-for-phy-mathematical-descriptions.docx