changes in 10306 Yusuke 282.29 The equation to Change SRP Revise generally – Tanaka agree with define SRP is incorrect definition as comment, TGax from the aspect of follows. editor shall dBm unit. "SRP is the sum of incorporate the value of TX changes in PWRAP and the value of Acceptable Receiver Interference levelAP." Remove "dBm" from Table 28-19. 10305 281.49 Table 28-19 defines Define procedures Revise generally Yusuke – Tanaka with comment, the Spatial Reuse of SR operation TGax editor shall subfield encoding but based on SRP, incorporate no procedures of SR which should changes in operation based on include Tx power SRP is defined in this controlling not only spec. for a Data frame and but Control frames (e.g. RTS/CTS/CF-End). 8568 274.06 Spatial Reuse Field Propose to adopt Revise generally ron – agree with 7 value definition lacks document 1476r8 comment, TGax detail to complete the editor shall definition of the incorporate SRP based spatial changes in reuse feature Revise generally 8920 Sigurd 281.53 The unit of SRP in Remove "dBm" – agree with Table 28-19 can not from the rows of comment, TGax be dBm, given that it the Table editor shall is a sum of two values incorporate expressed in dBm changes in (which is similar to power squared in the linear domain) 8907 Sigurd 274.06 What is the value of Clarify Revise generally – agree with "SR Disallowed"? comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 8908 274.10 "NOTE--This part Consider Revise not Sigurd – certain exactly what needs further decoupling SR from the proposed development." the remainder of resolution but indicates that this the document. rather than the “decoupling”
changes in 10306 Yusuke Tanaka 282.29 The equation to define SRP is incorrect from the aspect of dBm unit. Change SRP definition as follows. "SRP is the sum of the value of TX PWRAP and the value of Acceptable Receiver Interference levelAP." Remove "dBm" from Table 28-19. Revise – generally agree with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 10305 Yusuke Tanaka 281.49 Table 28-19 defines the Spatial Reuse subfield encoding but no procedures of SR operation based on SRP is defined in this spec. Define procedures of SR operation based on SRP, which should include Tx power controlling not only for a Data frame and but Control frames (e.g. RTS/CTS/CF-End). Revise – generally with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 8568 ron 274.06 Spatial Reuse Field value definition lacks detail Propose to adopt document 1476r8 to complete the definition of the SRP based spatial reuse feature Revise – generally agree with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 8920 Sigurd 281.53 The unit of SRP in Table 28-19 can not be dBm, given that it is a sum of two values expressed in dBm (which is similar to power squared in the linear domain) Remove "dBm" from the rows of the Table Revise – generally agree with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 8907 Sigurd 274.06 What is the value of "SR Disallowed"? Clarify Revise – generally agree with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 8908 Sigurd 274.10 "NOTE--This part needs further development." indicates that this Consider decoupling SR from the remainder of the document. Revise – not certain exactly what the proposed resolution but rather than “decoupling” the 7
11-16-1476-17-00ax-cr-for-section-25-9-spatial-reuse-operation-for-he-ppdu.docx