5009 135.29 Unit for PRAW Periodicity Please clarify what unit Revised subfield is stated as short should be used when beacon interval, but what short beacon interval is -TGah editor to make the about the cases where short not in use. changes shown in beacon interval is not in use? under the heading CID 5009, 5010. 5010 135.38 Unit for PRAW Start Offset Please clarify what unit Revised subfield is stated as short should be used when beacon interval, but what short beacon interval is -TGah editor to make the about the cases where short not in use. changes in beacon interval is not in use? under the heading CID 5009, 5010. 5169 132.45 "In the first RAW Disallow immeidiate Rejected Assignment, the Start Time RAW after Beacon and Indication equal to 0 indicates Probe Response. - This feature is still useful. that the RAW starts For example, the AP may immediately after the S1G allocate a non-TIM RAW Beacon or the (Short) Probe that does not allow TIM Response frame that includes STA to access immediately the RPS element." after the S1G beacon, possibly in a periodic manner. The decoding of elements are in MAC software. It is difficult to predict the delay between the end of reception of the Beacon/Probe Response and the decodinf of RPS element. So the STAs may miss the allocated slot for them. 5170 133.01 Actually in non-TIM RAW, Change the RPS Revised RAW group doesn't include definition per the any STAs so that no TIM commment -TGah editor to make the STAs will access the dedium changes shown in during the non-TIM RAW. So under the the indication field name heading CID 5170, 5171. should not be "Same Group Indication". It should be "Group Presense Indication". In different RAW, "group not presense" has different meaning, e.g. same group as previous RAW or no STAs in the RAW.
5009 135.29 Unit for PRAW Periodicity subfield is stated as short beacon interval, but what about the cases where short beacon interval is not in use? Please clarify what unit should be used when short beacon interval is not in use. Revised -TGah editor to make the changes shown in under the heading CID 5009, 5010. 5010 135.38 Unit for PRAW Start Offset subfield is stated as short beacon interval, but what about the cases where short beacon interval is not in use? Please clarify what unit should be used when short beacon interval is not in use. Revised -TGah editor to make the changes in under the heading CID 5009, 5010. 5169 132.45 "In the first RAW Assignment, the Start Time Indication equal to 0 indicates that the RAW starts immediately after the S1G Beacon or the (Short) Probe Response frame that includes the RPS element." The decoding of elements are in MAC software. It is difficult to predict the delay between the end of reception of the Beacon/Probe Response and the decodinf of RPS element. So the STAs may miss the allocated slot for them. Disallow immeidiate RAW after Beacon and Probe Response. Rejected - This feature is still useful. For example, the AP may allocate a non-TIM RAW that does not allow TIM STA to access immediately after the S1G beacon, possibly in a periodic manner. 5170 133.01 Actually in non-TIM RAW, RAW group doesn't include any STAs so that no TIM STAs will access the dedium during the non-TIM RAW. So the indication field name should not be "Same Group Indication". It should be "Group Presense Indication". In different RAW, "group not presense" has different meaning, e.g. same group as previous RAW or no STAs in the RAW. Change the RPS definition per the commment Revised -TGah editor to make the changes shown in under the heading CID 5170, 5171.
11-14-1567-00-00ah-lb205-comment-resolution-for-subclause-8-4-2-170b.docx