7226 Katsuo STA behavior after STA behavior Rejected- Yunoki 1 receiving MU DL receiving PPDU should be MU DL The ACK/BA procedure for explained. (e.g. how PPDU should the DL MU is defined in to respond ACK, be explained. section 27.4. There is no Block ACK) (e.g. how to need to repeat same respond information in two places of ACK, Block the spec. ACK) TGax editor makes no changes on CID 7226. 7385 Laurent It is not mentioned on Clarify Rejected- Cariou bandwidth the report is provided, It is already defined in section while the bitmap 9.2.4.6.4.7. depends on the bandwidth TGax editor makes no changes on CID 7385. 7571 Liwen Chu The channel query As in Revised- can be used by both comment UL and DL MU. Move Per proposed resolution for the subclause outside CID 6165, move 27.5.1.3 to of DL MU subclause 27.5.6 making it general to and change the title both UL and DL operation. accordingly. TGax editor changes as shown in 11-17/1286r0 that are marked with CID 7571. 7572 Liwen Chu Add management As in Accepted- frame after QoS Null, comment QoS Data frames TGax editor makes changes as shown in 11-17/1286r0 that are marked with CID 7572. 7647 Liwen Chu The rules about when Add the Revised- 1 the DL MU frame related rules. exchange is Agree in principle. successful is missing from the draft. TGax editor makes changes as shown in 11-17/1286r0 that are marked with CID 7647. 10316 Zhou Lan BQR now is in the Extend BQR Revised- section of DL MU to UL MU operation. However it operation Per proposed resolution for should be useful for CID 6165, move 27.5.1.3 to the AP to make right 27.5.6 making it general to decision on UL MU both UL and DL operation. scheduling as well TGax editor makes changes as shown in 11-17/1286r0 that are marked with CID 10316.
7226 Katsuo Yunoki STA behavior after receiving MU DL PPDU should be explained. (e.g. how to respond ACK, Block ACK) STA behavior receiving MU DL PPDU should be explained. (e.g. how to respond ACK, Block ACK) Rejected- The ACK/BA procedure for the DL MU is defined in section 27.4. There is no need to repeat same information in two places of the spec. TGax editor makes no changes on CID 7226. 7385 Laurent Cariou It is not mentioned on bandwidth the report is provided, while the bitmap depends on the bandwidth Clarify Rejected- It is already defined in section 9.2.4.6.4.7. TGax editor makes no changes on CID 7385. 7571 Liwen Chu The channel query can be used by both UL and DL MU. Move the subclause outside of DL MU subclause and change the title accordingly. As in comment Revised- Per proposed resolution for CID 6165, move 27.5.1.3 to 27.5.6 making it general to both UL and DL operation. TGax editor changes as shown in 11-17/1286r0 that are marked with CID 7571. 7572 Liwen Chu Add management frame after QoS Null, QoS Data frames As in comment Accepted- TGax editor makes changes as shown in 11-17/1286r0 that are marked with CID 7572. 7647 Liwen Chu The rules about when the DL MU frame exchange is successful is missing from the draft. Add the related rules. Revised- Agree in principle. TGax editor makes changes as shown in 11-17/1286r0 that are marked with CID 7647. 10316 Zhou Lan BQR now is in the section of DL MU operation. However it should be useful for the AP to make right decision on UL MU scheduling as well Extend BQR to UL MU operation Revised- Per proposed resolution for CID 6165, move 27.5.1.3 to 27.5.6 making it general to both UL and DL operation. TGax editor makes changes as shown in 11-17/1286r0 that are marked with CID 10316. 1 1
11-17-1286-00-00ax-cr-dl-mu-procedure.docx