Date: Student Progress (Committee Meeting) Rubric Completed by: – (To be completed by each committee member. Please check boxes for all evaluation criteria that you feel are appropriate within each attribute category) Attribute Does Not Meet Expectations Meets Expectations Exceeds Expectations Please provide a short explanation for each attribute that you select in this category Overall quality Poorly organized Clearly organized Well organized of responses Lacks careful, critical thinking skills Responses are adequate Responses are exceptional Does not reflect understanding of subject matter Demonstrates average critical thinking skills Exhibits mature, critical thinking skills and pertinent literature Exhibits understanding of subject matter and Exhibits mastery of subject matter and pertinent Arguments are weak, inconsistent or pertinent literature literature. unconvincing Arguments are coherent Arguments are exceptional Overall breadth Responses reveal critical weaknesses in of Responses reveal some depth of knowledge in Responses reveal exceptional depth of knowledge in knowledge in subject matter of knowledge subject matter subject matter Reponses reflect limited critical thinking skills Reponses reflect above average critical thinking Reponses reflect well developed critical thinking skills skills Quality of Responses are incomplete or require prompting Responses are complete Responses are eloquent Responses to Arguments are well organized Arguments are poorly presented Arguments are skillfully presented Questions Respondent exhibits adequate knowledge in Respondent exhibits lack of knowledge in subject Respondent exhibits superior knowledge in subject subject area area area Overall Does not meet expectations Meets Expectations Exceeds Expectations Assessment Constructive Comments for Student:
Student Progress (Committee Meeting) Rubric – Completed by: Date: (To be completed by each committee member. Please check boxes for all evaluation criteria that you feel are appropriate within each attribute category) Attribute Does Not Meet Expectations Please provide a short explanation for each attribute that you select in this category Meets Expectations Exceeds Expectations Overall quality of responses Poorly organized Lacks careful, critical thinking skills Does not reflect understanding of subject matter and pertinent literature Arguments are weak, inconsistent or unconvincing Clearly organized Responses are adequate Demonstrates average critical thinking skills Exhibits understanding of subject matter and pertinent literature Arguments are coherent Well organized Responses are exceptional Exhibits mature, critical thinking skills Exhibits mastery of subject matter and pertinent literature. Arguments are exceptional Overall breadth of knowledge Responses reveal critical weaknesses in of knowledge in subject matter Reponses reflect limited critical thinking skills Responses reveal some depth of knowledge in subject matter Reponses reflect above average critical thinking skills Responses reveal exceptional depth of knowledge in subject matter Reponses reflect well developed critical thinking skills Quality of Responses to Questions Responses are incomplete or require prompting Arguments are poorly presented Respondent exhibits lack of knowledge in subject area Responses are complete Arguments are well organized Respondent exhibits adequate knowledge in subject area Responses are eloquent Arguments are skillfully presented Respondent exhibits superior knowledge in subject area Overall Assessment Does not meet expectations Meets Expectations Exceeds Expectations Constructive Comments for Student:
DGOA%20EPIB%20MPH%20Rubric%20comps%20prop%20def%20defense%208.18.14.docx