on page 220, line 13-14 5176 220.41 22.3.10.1 Inconsistent use of N_DBPS,u is defined as A Agree N_DBPS N_DBPS for user u. In Table 22-6, it says that N_DBPS is undefined for MU. Delete sentence and replace with "is defined in Table 22-6" Clause 22.3.10.3 CRC calculation for VHT-SIG-B CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resn Resolution Status 5270 221.58 22.3.10.3 NDP PPDUs have no Improve the NDP R Reject. The NDP service field, so the CRC structure to avoid this PPDU is an SU PPDU, detection cannot be done problem. see 22.3.12. A at receivers. The receiver can ignore correctness of the VHT-SIG-B since no bits recovered by information is receivers cannot be guaranteed. The wrong required from it for VHT-SIG-B bits may lead processing an SU to seriously bad PPDU, see 22.3.21. consequences. Therefore no change is necessary. Clause 22.3.10.4 Scrambler CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resn Resolution Status 5177 222.41 22.3.10.4 Use consistent terminoogy Replace "pad parts" A with "PHY pad bits" Clause 22.3.10.5 Coding CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resn Resolution Status
on page 220, line 13-14 5176 220.41 22.3.10.1 Inconsistent use of N_DBPS N_DBPS,u is defined as N_DBPS for user u. In Table 22-6, it says that N_DBPS is undefined for MU. Delete sentence and replace with "is defined in Table 22-6" A Agree Clause 22.3.10.3 CRC calculation for VHT-SIG-B CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resn Status Resolution 5270 221.58 22.3.10.3 NDP PPDUs have no service field, so the CRC detection cannot be done at receivers. The correctness of the bits recovered by receivers cannot be guaranteed. The wrong VHT-SIG-B bits may lead to seriously bad consequences. Improve the NDP structure to avoid this problem. R Reject. The NDP PPDU is an SU PPDU, see 22.3.12. A receiver can ignore VHT-SIG-B since no information is required from it for processing an SU PPDU, see 22.3.21. Therefore no change is necessary. Clause 22.3.10.4 Scrambler CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resn Status Resolution 5177 222.41 22.3.10.4 Use consistent terminoogy Replace "pad parts" with "PHY pad bits" A Clause 22.3.10.5 Coding CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resn Status Resolution
11-12-0250-00-00ac-clause-22-3-10-cids.docx