James June In Figure 27-10 "S2 max TXPWR is as indicated Revised agree – Wang equal to max (..." should be with the comment. change to "min (... " Apply the changes proposed in doc . Sigurd In Figure 27-10, SR S2 detects all Clarify Revised add – Schelstraete inter-BSS packets and resumes its some text to AIFS/BO processing once it has clarify that S2 does established that SR can be applied. not receive OBSS However, in the figure inter-BSS PPDU from D1’ transmission OBSS PPDU D1'-S1' is and therefore ignored by SR S2, even though the continues AIFS/BO counter has not yet decrementing reached zero. Why is this? backoff. Apply the changes as proposed in . Guoqing Li In this figure It is more reasonable change max (...) to min (...) Revised agree – that the S2 max is equal to with the comment. min (...), not max (...). The STA Apply the changes should honor the power contraint proposed in doc . calculated over all the previous ignored OBSS PPDU. kaiying Lv Change the " max (NON SRG as comment Revised agree – TXPWRmax1, NON SRG with the comment. TXPWRmax 2, SRG Apply the changes TXPWRmax 3)" in the figure to proposed in doc . "min (NON SRG TXPWRmax1, NON SRG TXPWRmax 2, SRG TXPWRmax 3)" Yusuke In Figure 27-10, S2 max TXPWR Change "S2 max is equal to Revised agree – Tanaka should be equal or lower than the max" to "S2 max TXPWR is equal with the comment. minimum TXPWERmax among all to min" in Figure 27-10 Apply the changes TXPWRmax from ongoing proposed in doc . OBSS_PD SR transmit power restriction periods.
James June Wang In Figure 27-10 "S2 max TXPWR is equal to max (..." should be change to "min (... " as indicated Revised – agree with the comment. Apply the changes proposed in doc . Sigurd Schelstraete In Figure 27-10, SR S2 detects all inter-BSS packets and resumes its AIFS/BO processing once it has established that SR can be applied. However, in the figure inter-BSS transmission OBSS PPDU D1'-S1' is ignored by SR S2, even though the AIFS/BO counter has not yet reached zero. Why is this? Clarify Revised – add some text to clarify that S2 does not receive OBSS PPDU from D1’ and therefore continues decrementing backoff. Apply the changes as proposed in . Guoqing Li In this figure It is more reasonable that the S2 max is equal to min (...), not max (...). The STA should honor the power contraint calculated over all the previous ignored OBSS PPDU. change max (...) to min (...) Revised – agree with the comment. Apply the changes proposed in doc . kaiying Lv Change the " max (NON SRG TXPWRmax1, NON SRG TXPWRmax 2, SRG TXPWRmax 3)" in the figure to "min (NON SRG TXPWRmax1, NON SRG TXPWRmax 2, SRG TXPWRmax 3)" as comment Revised – agree with the comment. Apply the changes proposed in doc . Yusuke Tanaka In Figure 27-10, S2 max TXPWR should be equal or lower than the minimum TXPWERmax among all TXPWRmax from ongoing OBSS_PD SR transmit power restriction periods. Change "S2 max is equal to max" to "S2 max TXPWR is equal to min" in Figure 27-10 Revised – agree with the comment. Apply the changes proposed in doc .
11-17-1852-02-00ax-cr-for-27-9.docx