IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Suggested resolution to MIB comments Date: 2018-09-12 Author(s): Name Company Address Phone email Kazuyuki Sakoda Sony Kazuyuki.Sakoda (at) sony (dot) com Comment: CID Comment Proposed Change Suggested Resolution 1247 dot11STACivicLocation is a control variable, Please clarify. REVISED: but its MAX-ACCESS is not-accessible. Why Adopt changes we cannot access it? proposed in doc11-18/1636. Discussion: MAX-ACCESS of the dot11STACivicLocation is supposed to be read-write, as it is a control variable written by an external management entity or the SME. FYI, there are some more issue with the MIB variable. There is no reference to dot11STACivicLocation in main body of the standard. The same thing apply to dot11STACivicLocationType. Furthermore, it seems that is poorly defined and probably does not pass MIB dot11STACivicLocationConfigTable compilation. In description of there is a reference to “dot11RMCivicConfigured”, However, is not defined anywhere. dot11STACivicLocationEntry. dot11STACivicLocationEntry
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Suggested resolution to MIB comments Date: 2018-09-12 Author(s): Name Company Address Phone email Kazuyuki Sakoda Sony Kazuyuki.Sakoda (at) sony (dot) com Comment: CID Comment Proposed Change Suggested Resolution 1247 dot11STACivicLocation is a control variable, but its MAX-ACCESS is not-accessible. Why we cannot access it? Please clarify. REVISED: Adopt changes proposed in doc11-18/1636. Discussion: MAX-ACCESS of the dot11STACivicLocation is supposed to be read-write, as it is a control variable written by an external management entity or the SME. FYI, there are some more issue with the MIB variable. There is no reference to dot11STACivicLocation in main body of the standard. The same thing apply to dot11STACivicLocationType. Furthermore, it seems that dot11STACivicLocationConfigTable is poorly defined and probably does not pass MIB compilation. In description of “dot11RMCivicConfigured”, there is a reference to dot11STACivicLocationEntry. However, dot11STACivicLocationEntry is not defined anywhere.
11-18-1636-01-000m-suggested-resolution-to-mib-comments.docx