IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs MAC Comments for Discussion 2018-07-31 Date: Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email 350 W Java Dr Mark Hamilton Ruckus/ARRIS +1.303.818.8472 Sunnyvale, CA 94089 For review by TG: 1281 839.64 64 9.4.1.7 In Table 9-51, Reason codes Please change the Reason 40-44 are not defined. code "45" to "40-45". Discussion: Context: Robert Stacey (ANA coordinator) confirms that these entries were assigned to 802.11e, and were apparently not used. They should be marked as in Table 9-51, and marked appropriately for future use in the ANA “Reserved” database (which Robert will do). By changing the Reason code column from to (as proposed), 40 through 44 will become “45” “40-45” Reserved. Proposed Resolution: Accepted. 1400 2272.22 22 11.38.1 "the STA shall indicate On lines 22 and 23 at the support for MCSs 8(n-1) to referenced page change 8(n-1)+7" should be clearer "MCS" to "HT-MCS" as to what kind of MCS Discussion: Context: Arguably, it should be apparent that setting bits in the Rx MCS Bitmask contained in the HT Capabilites element, would be indicating HT MCS rates. However, this paragraph is already rather confusing with the number of
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs MAC Comments for Discussion Date: 2018-07-31 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Mark Hamilton Ruckus/ARRIS 350 W Java Dr Sunnyvale, CA 94089 +1.303.818.8472 For review by TG: 1281 839.64 64 9.4.1.7 In Table 9-51, Reason codes 40-44 are not defined. Please change the Reason code "45" to "40-45". Discussion: Context: Robert Stacey (ANA coordinator) confirms that these entries were assigned to 802.11e, and were apparently not used. They should be marked as “Reserved” in Table 9-51, and marked appropriately for future use in the ANA database (which Robert will do). By changing the Reason code column from “45” to “40-45” (as proposed), 40 through 44 will become Reserved. Proposed Resolution: Accepted. 1400 2272.22 22 11.38.1 "the STA shall indicate support for MCSs 8(n-1) to 8(n-1)+7" should be clearer as to what kind of MCS On lines 22 and 23 at the referenced page change "MCS" to "HT-MCS" Discussion: Context: Arguably, it should be apparent that setting bits in the Rx MCS Bitmask contained in the HT Capabilites element, would be indicating HT MCS rates. However, this paragraph is already rather confusing with the number of
11-18-0669-03-000m-revmd-mac-comments-assigned-to-hamilton.docx