IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs CC28-XDMGz-Comment-Resolution Date: 2018-09-17 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Assaf Kasher Qualcomm akasher@qti.qualcomm.com 86 28.00 16 9.4.2.127.7 "TRN field sent by the replace by "TRN field sent receiver STA" - what by the peer STA" receiver Proposed Resolution: Revised TGaz Editor: Modify the text P24L24-26 as follows: A DMG/EDMG STA sets the AOD Channel Measurement Feedback subfield to 1 to indicate the ability to send a Channel Measurement Feedback element based on measurement on a TRN field sent by the STA, for the purpose of AOD estimation. TGaz Editor: Modify the text in P63L25-27: In a Direction Measurement FTM pair that agreed on I2R AOD, the ISTA shall add a TRN field to the frames in the exchanges specified by the Direction Measurement Density by setting the TRN_LEN to a non-zero value and PACKET_TYPE to 1. 232 29.00 9.4.2.166 "The DMG Direction Measurement Parameters As it says in the subelement is included in the initial FTM request comment to describe the requested set of parameters that the initiator proposes to use and in the initial FTM frame from the responder when either STA is a EDMG STA. " -- only included if both STAs are DMG STAs 233 29.00 9.4.2.166 "The DMG Direction Measurement Parameters As it says in the subelement is included in the initial FTM request comment to describe the requested set of parameters that the initiator proposes to use and in the initial FTM frame from the responder when either STA is a EDMG STA. " -- this is not backward-compatible with existing DMG STAs, which will not include this 235 30.00 9.4.2.166 It seems guaranteed to cause trouble to have fields Swap R2I in different orders for DMG and AOA Request and I2R AOA Request in Figure 9-4.f
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs CC28-XDMGz-Comment-Resolution Date: 2018-09-17 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Assaf Kasher Qualcomm akasher@qti.qualcomm.com 86 28.00 16 9.4.2.127.7 "TRN field sent by the receiver STA" - what receiver replace by "TRN field sent by the peer STA" Proposed Resolution: Revised TGaz Editor: Modify the text P24L24-26 as follows: A DMG/EDMG STA sets the AOD Channel Measurement Feedback subfield to 1 to indicate the ability to send a Channel Measurement Feedback element based on measurement on a TRN field sent by the STA, for the purpose of AOD estimation. TGaz Editor: Modify the text in P63L25-27: In a Direction Measurement FTM pair that agreed on I2R AOD, the ISTA shall add a TRN field to the frames in the exchanges specified by the Direction Measurement Density by setting the TRN_LEN to a non-zero value and PACKET_TYPE to 1. 232 29.00 9.4.2.166 "The DMG Direction Measurement Parameters subelement is included in the initial FTM request to describe the requested set of parameters that the initiator proposes to use and in the initial FTM frame from the responder when either STA is a STA. " -- only included if both STAs are DMG STAs As it says in the comment 233 29.00 9.4.2.166 "The DMG Direction Measurement Parameters subelement is included in the initial FTM request to describe the requested set of parameters that the initiator proposes to use and in the initial FTM frame from the responder when either STA is a STA. " -- this is not backward-compatible with existing DMG STAs, which will not include this As it says in the comment 235 30.00 9.4.2.166 It seems guaranteed to cause trouble to have fields in different orders for DMG and EDMG Swap R2I AOA Request and I2R AOA Request in Figure 9-4.f EDMG
11-18-1728-01-00az-cc28-xdmg-comment-resolution.docx