1862 4.5.4.2 EDMG AP used in Add definition in clause 3.0 Rejected multiple instances in Definitions This is not the draft and not defined philosophy used in the 802.11 spec. For example, is no definition (in section 3) for HT AP or VHT AP. 1869 12.7.12 SNonce and ANonce are Add Note in the security Revised 16 bit random values. clause that a Snonce and partially The text doesn't call out Anonce are to be used once Duplicated with that the SNonce and per session. CID 1064 ANonce are to be used only once in a session TGay may discuss this with and not repeated on REVmd future sessions. 2011 12.7.2 If FAA is defining a new Define a new AKM for FAA Rejected Key Derivation protocol it and include it in the RSN The AKM for FAA should be a new AKM. AKM table in Section 9. has been defined Update Section 12 as in section appropriate. 9.4.2.23.3 2012 12.12.2 Shared secrets are Adjust FAA to be based on Rejected subject to dictionary SAE and make the Duplicated with attacks. IEEE 802.11 approprate changes in 1440 already includes SAE. Any Clause 12. new "shared secret" security protocol for IEEE 802.11 should be based on SAE.
1862 4.5.4.2 EDMG AP used in multiple instances in draft and not defined Add definition in clause 3.0 Definitions Rejected This is not the philosophy used in the 802.11 spec. For example, is no definition (in section 3) for HT AP or VHT AP. 1869 12.7.12 SNonce and ANonce are 16 bit random values. The text doesn't call out that the SNonce and ANonce are to be used only once in a session and not repeated on future sessions. Add Note in the security clause that a Snonce and Anonce are to be used once per session. TGay may discuss this with REVmd Revised partially Duplicated with CID 1064 2011 12.7.2 If FAA is defining a new Key Derivation protocol it should be a new AKM. Define a new AKM for FAA and include it in the RSN AKM table in Section 9. Update Section 12 as appropriate. Rejected The AKM for FAA has been defined in section 9.4.2.23.3 2012 12.12.2 Shared secrets are subject to dictionary attacks. IEEE 802.11 already includes SAE. Any new "shared secret" security protocol for IEEE 802.11 should be based on SAE. Adjust FAA to be based on SAE and make the approprate changes in Clause 12. Rejected Duplicated with 1440
11-18-1097-01-00ay-comment-resolutions.docx