CID Commenter Clause Page Line Type of Assignee Comment Proposed Change (C) (C) Comment 1280 Stephen 8.4.4.21 14 23 T Stephen What does the "Service Information Create some text defines McCann McCann, Query Response" sub-field provide what the "Service Information SK Yong as extra service information, that is Response" sub-field is. not already present in the "Basic Service Information Descriptor field "? Proposed resolution: Rejected The Basic Service Information Descriptors sub-field is defined in 8.4.2.172, which consists of Advertisment ID, Service Name and Service Status. The basic service information is to provide only a minimal but essential service information for device to make an informed decision to connect or to query for more information. CID Commenter Clause Page Line Type of Assignee Comment Proposed Change (C) (C) Comment 1336 Yongho Seok 8.4.4.21 14 3 T Stephen "The Service Information Response Please address this confliction. McCann, ANQP-element is included in a GAS SK Yong Query Response, sent by the AP to the non-AP STA." In Table 10-16 - ANQP usage, the STA side usage of the Service Information Response is described as "T, R". Which one is correct? If "T,R" is correct, the Service Information Response ANQP-element can be also sent by the non-AP STA to the AP. Proposed resolution: Revised Update the Table 10-16 as follows Service 8.4.4.21 (Service Information Information S T R Response ANQP- element) Response — CID Commenter Clause Page Line Type of Assignee Comment Proposed Change (C) (C) Comment 1347 Lei Wang 8.4.4.21 14 16 T Stephen what's the unit of the field "Service please clarify. Particularly, to McCann, Information Query Response check if we can reduce the SK Yong Length"? Do we really need a 2-byte length field to 1 byte. lenth field, which gives 64K values? Proposed resolution: Rejected Yes. Service information can go beyond 256 and thus 2-bytes length field is needed.
CID Commenter Clause Page (C) Line (C) Type of Comment Assignee Comment Proposed Change 1280 Stephen McCann 8.4.4.21 14 23 T Stephen McCann, SK Yong What does the "Service Information Query Response" sub-field provide as extra service information, that is not already present in the "Basic Service Information Descriptor field "? Create some text defines what the "Service Information Response" sub-field is. Proposed resolution: Rejected The Basic Service Information Descriptors sub-field is defined in 8.4.2.172, which consists of Advertisment ID, Service Name and Service Status. The basic service information is to provide only a minimal but essential service information for device to make an informed decision to connect or to query for more information. CID Commenter Clause Page (C) Line (C) Type of Comment Assignee Comment Proposed Change 1336 Yongho Seok 8.4.4.21 14 3 T Stephen McCann, SK Yong "The Service Information Response ANQP-element is included in a GAS Query Response, sent by the AP to the non-AP STA." In Table 10-16 - ANQP usage, the STA side usage of the Service Information Response is described as "T, R". Which one is correct? If "T,R" is correct, the Service Information Response ANQP-element can be also sent by the non-AP STA to the AP. Please address this confliction. Proposed resolution: Revised Update the Table 10-16 as follows Service Information Response 8.4.4.21 (Service Information Response ANQP- element) S T R — CID Commenter Clause Page (C) Line (C) Type of Comment Assignee Comment Proposed Change 1347 Lei Wang 8.4.4.21 14 16 T Stephen McCann, SK Yong what's the unit of the field "Service Information Query Response Length"? Do we really need a 2-byte lenth field, which gives 64K values? please clarify. Particularly, to check if we can reduce the length field to 1 byte. Proposed resolution: Rejected Yes. Service information can go beyond 256 and thus 2-bytes length field is needed.
11-15-0646-01-00aq-clause-8-4-4-21-comment-resolutions.docx