8231 Osama 190.11 27.9.1 what does "SR PPDU" clarify Revise generally – mean? agree with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 9730 Yongho 190.11 27.9.1 "When the conditions Delete the second Revise generally – Seok specified in 27.9 paragraph of agree with (Spatial reuse 27.9.1. comment about operation) are met that definition of SR allow the transmission PPDU, adding a of an SR PPDU, an definition of SR HE STA may transmit PPDU. The an SR PPDU to either restriction as noted an HE STA or a is not quite correct, STA." modified to restrict What is a definition of to STA that are a SR PPDU? capable of acting Also, it is saying that as SR Responder. an HE STA can TGax editor shall transmit a SR PPDU incorporate to all STA (an HE STA changes in or a non-HE STA). Such rule is not needed. From Laurent C. 8087 Matthew 190.1 27.9 SRP is incomplete - Add a way for an Revise generally – Fischer need a control on the SR transmitter with comment, ACK response to an using SRP to TGax editor shall SR transmission - if indicate to the incorporate the DATA frame was recipient that its changes in transmitted under SRP ACK must be conditions, then the conditionalized on ACK should also obey SRP conditions - the SRP conditions - use A-control to tell but the ACK the recipient that transmitter needs to the DATA frame know if the DATA was transmitted frame was transmitted under SRP under SRP conditions conditions because for a generated DATA frame, the ACK has no conditions, and we do not want to impose new conditions on ACKing that were not in the baseline, except for the new case of a DATA frame sent under SRP conditions
8231 Osama 190.11 27.9.1 what does "SR PPDU" mean? clarify Revise – generally agree with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 9730 Yongho Seok 190.11 27.9.1 "When the conditions specified in 27.9 (Spatial reuse operation) are met that allow the transmission of an SR PPDU, an HE STA may transmit an SR PPDU to either an HE STA or a STA." What is a definition of a SR PPDU? Also, it is saying that an HE STA can transmit a SR PPDU to all STA (an HE STA or a non-HE STA). Such rule is not needed. Delete the second paragraph of 27.9.1. Revise – generally agree with comment about definition of SR PPDU, adding a definition of SR PPDU. The restriction as noted is not quite correct, modified to restrict to STA that are capable of acting as SR Responder. TGax editor shall incorporate changes in From Laurent C. 8087 Matthew Fischer 190.1 27.9 SRP is incomplete - need a control on the ACK response to an SR transmission - if the DATA frame was transmitted under SRP conditions, then the ACK should also obey the SRP conditions - but the ACK transmitter needs to know if the DATA frame was transmitted under SRP conditions because for a generated DATA frame, the ACK has no conditions, and we do not want to impose new conditions on ACKing that were not in the baseline, except for the new case of a DATA frame sent under SRP conditions Add a way for an SR transmitter using SRP to indicate to the recipient that its ACK must be conditionalized on SRP conditions - use A-control to tell the recipient that the DATA frame was transmitted under SRP conditions Revise – generally with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in
11-16-1476-19-00ax-cr-for-section-25-9-spatial-reuse-operation-for-he-ppdu.docx