DETAILED DESIGN REVIEW RUBRIC Team Name: ________________________________ Date: _________________ Developing Satisfactory Exemplary Competency Sub-Score 1 2 3 4 5 Superficial Adequate Insightful Formulation Formulation Formulation - – – Problem Some relevant Most relevant All relevant factors Definition factors identified, factors considered, considered, many few measurable, some measurable, measurable Developed - Underdeveloped Highly Developed - Some evidence of Concept of Extensive evidence of engineering Development disconnected and engineering analysis and analysis and unexamined ideas synthesis of ideas synthesis of ideas Missing No mention Satisfactory – Complete Focused data – Proof of of modeling, testing, data without with relevant Concept or prototyping at any specified purpose and conclusions scale or application Basic Broad – Thorough - Proposed Missing No overall concept of a design – solution(s) directly system architecture or with a basic idea of addresses client needs System Design knowledge how how it satisfies and specifications; subsystems relate to client needs; subsystems well one another interfaces integrated still being defined Well Planned Specific – Disorganized Developed –Vague – vendors and model idea of components to Selection of numbers ready for be purchased and how purchased order; tooling and fixture parts fit together; in progress; Implementation needs well understood; largely unaware how materials identified complete set of design to fabricate needed but may not be docs and mfg plans parts; design docs optimal; drawing drafted and reviewed by largely incomplete package underway shop manager Cognizant Client Fully Considered Client – – Unaddressed Does – concerns concerns and Client Needs not address client but not addressed in a needs or concerns fully resolved comprehensive manner Insightful – Wistful Path to Appropriate – – Project Contingencies completion unclear; Credible timeline Management considered in managing budget uncertain and budget given time and budget Comments: Total Score:____________
DETAILED DESIGN REVIEW RUBRIC Team Name: ________________________________ Date: _________________ Competency Developing Satisfactory Exemplary 1 2 3 4 5 Sub-Score Problem Definition Superficial Formulation – Some relevant factors identified, few measurable, Adequate Formulation – Most relevant factors considered, some measurable, Insightful Formulation - All relevant factors considered, many measurable Concept Development Underdeveloped of disconnected and unexamined ideas Developed - Some evidence of engineering analysis and synthesis of ideas Highly Developed - Extensive evidence of engineering analysis and synthesis of ideas Proof of Concept Missing – No mention of modeling, testing, or prototyping at any scale Satisfactory data without specified purpose or application Complete – Focused data with relevant and conclusions System Design Missing – No overall system architecture or knowledge how subsystems relate to one another Basic – Broad concept of a design with a basic idea of how it satisfies client needs; interfaces still being defined Thorough - Proposed solution(s) directly addresses client needs and specifications; subsystems well integrated Implementation Disorganized –Vague idea of components to be purchased and how parts fit together; largely unaware how to fabricate needed parts; design docs largely incomplete Developed – Selection of purchased in progress; materials identified but may not be optimal; drawing package underway Well Planned – Specific vendors and model numbers ready for order; tooling and fixture needs well understood; complete set of design docs and mfg plans drafted and reviewed by shop manager Client Needs Unaddressed – Does not address client needs or concerns Cognizant – Client concerns but not fully resolved Fully Considered – Client concerns and addressed in a comprehensive manner Project Management Wistful – Path to completion unclear; budget uncertain Appropriate – Credible timeline and budget given Insightful – Contingencies considered in managing time and budget Comments: Total Score:____________
Detailed%20Design%20Review%20Form.docx