different antennas as defined in 30.4.6.2." 1379 10.36.11.4.3 "The DMG CTS frame should be replace with "The DMG CTS frame transmitted using all SU-MIMO should be transmitted using the sectors, with a small delay between same set of atennas and antenna each sector" - extremely opaque. settings planned to be sued during Small delay is undefined, also the SU-MIMO transmission and a sectors are undefined. CSD between the transmission in different antennas as defined in 30.4.6.2." 1409 10.36.11.4.3 The delay" needs to be clarified. See the advice provided in Similar to what is defined in comment. case, maybe just call it MIMO antenna setting. 1681 10.36.11.4.3 What is a "small delay"? This needs to Define small delay. be defined 1897 10.36.11.4.3 Editor Note: what is a delay"? Address editor comment This needs to be defined. 2005 10.36.11.4.3 It is not for "with a small delay Please clarify it. between each sector". If "small delay" refers to CSD, need to refer to the related subclause. 2182 10.36.11.4.3 calls out small delay between each Define "Small delay”. See note to sector in text. Small delay not defined. editor. 2338 10.36.11.4.3 Please remove "small delay" per Please replace delay" with a Editor's Note. specific value or range of values. Accept the proposed resolution in CID 1378, and see the proposed draft text in this Proposed resolution: document. CID Clause Comment Proposed change 1405 10.36.11.4.4 Similar to what is described in Add statements similar to the first MIMO channel access procedure three paragraphs in the SU-MIMO section, here in MU-MIMO channel channel access procedure section to access procedure section, the use of describe the use of Grant/Grant Ack Ack frame before the frame. channel access initiation should also be stated. Particularly for those STAs whose Grant Required field within the EDMG Capabilities element is set to 1.
different antennas as defined in 30.4.6.2." 1379 10.36.11.4.3 "The DMG CTS frame should be transmitted using all SU-MIMO sectors, with a small delay between each sector" - extremely opaque. Small delay is undefined, also sectors are undefined. replace with "The DMG CTS frame should be transmitted using the same set of atennas and antenna settings planned to be sued during the SU-MIMO transmission and a CSD between the transmission in different antennas as defined in 30.4.6.2." 1409 10.36.11.4.3 The delay" needs to be clarified. Similar to what is defined in case, maybe just call it antenna setting. See the advice provided in comment. 1681 10.36.11.4.3 What is a "small delay"? This needs to be defined Define small delay. 1897 10.36.11.4.3 Editor Note: what is a delay"? This needs to be defined. Address editor comment 2005 10.36.11.4.3 It is not for "with a small delay between each sector". If "small delay" refers to CSD, need to refer to the related subclause. Please clarify it. 2182 10.36.11.4.3 calls out small delay between each sector in text. Small delay not defined. Define "Small delay”. See note to editor. 2338 10.36.11.4.3 Please remove "small delay" per Editor's Note. Please replace delay" with a specific value or range of values. Proposed resolution: Accept the proposed resolution in CID 1378, and see the proposed draft text in this document. CID Clause Comment Proposed change 1405 10.36.11.4.4 Similar to what is described in channel access procedure section, here in MU-MIMO channel access procedure section, the use of Ack frame before the channel access initiation should also be stated. Particularly for those STAs whose Grant Required field within the EDMG Capabilities element is set to 1. Add statements similar to the first three paragraphs in the SU-MIMO channel access procedure section to describe the use of Grant/Grant Ack frame. MIMO MIMO
11-18-0723-03-00ay-resolution-to-cids-related-to-mimo-channel-access.docx