should be added. 9517 149.10 27.1 "The use of (1) The Revised MAC HCCA and sentence TSPEC are should be TGax Editor to banned at HE modified to: make changes in STAs." "The use of 11-17/1248r2 HCCA is Two thoughts: banned at HE The use of TSPEC (1) This STAs." by HE STAs is sentence is allowed. ambiguous. If (2) Move this we ban HCCA, sentence it will be somewhere in reasonable to 27.2. disallow TSPEC negotiation for HCCA. However the TSPEC negotiation can be used for admission control for the EDCA which will be beneficial for the schduling purpose at the AP. Therefore, I do not think it will be good to disallow all of the TSPEC negotiation. (2) This sentence is not the introduction of HE MAC. It should be stated somewhere in 27.2.
should be added. 9517 149.10 27.1 "The use of HCCA and TSPEC are banned at HE STAs." Two thoughts: (1) This sentence is ambiguous. If we ban HCCA, it will be reasonable to disallow TSPEC negotiation for HCCA. However the TSPEC negotiation can be used for admission control for the EDCA which will be beneficial for the schduling purpose at the AP. Therefore, I do not think it will be good to disallow all of the TSPEC negotiation. (2) This sentence is not the introduction of HE MAC. It should be stated somewhere in 27.2. (1) The sentence should be modified to: "The use of HCCA is banned at HE STAs." (2) Move this sentence somewhere in 27.2. Revised TGax Editor to make changes in 11-17/1248r2 The use of TSPEC by HE STAs is allowed. MAC
11-17-1248-02-00ax-clause-27-1-comment-resolution.docx