3512 12.25 3.1 Can there be more than Clarify. Suggest that one Portal? (See definition 802.11 assume there is of infrastructure, and Annex only one portal (logically), Q, in particular) If no, how so the DS can be well does an 802.11 LAN defined, and not require connect to more than one 802.1Q functions. Change non-802.11 LAN (or the definition of VLANs, see Figure V-1)? "infrastrcture" and "WLAN (Is a bridge required?) If system" to say "zero or one yes, how does the DS know portal". Change Annex Q how to route outbound to match. Add a bridge in traffic - does the DS Figure V-1 to connect to the perform 802.1Q multiple VLANs. functionality? Could the DS create a "bridge" between the non-802.11 LANs, independent of the WLAN, and can it result in loops, etc? Discussion: The cited text is below: Discussion with Mark Hamilton: Discussions underway in ARC and 11ak; potentially have agreement on number of portals in November. Reference: from Mark Rison on 3314, 3493, 3141, 3394, 3292: use of the Dual CTS mechanism is deprecated” is probably most consistent with text. Similarly, “The “Dual CTS operation” is not a term which appears in the current draft (it's either dual CTS mechanism or dual CTS protection mechanism) Also 824.62, 1881.12, 1910.37 (D3.2) 2 instances of STA” (no A after RSN) in baseline too “RSN Well, except that there’s the statement replaces in 4.3.13 and 23.5 is about ““TVHT-MCS” “VHT-MCS”” for TVHT MCSs” “Parameters missing hyphen It’s more than unusual, it violates IEEE Std 802. Hence I think there should be a NOTE. Don’t ask me why, but like takes a hyphen “ANQP-element”, “RLQP-element” CID 3087 (GEN)
3512 12.25 3.1 Can there be more than one Portal? (See definition of infrastructure, and Annex Q, in particular) If no, how does an 802.11 LAN connect to more than one non-802.11 LAN (or VLANs, see Figure V-1)? (Is a bridge required?) If yes, how does the DS know how to route outbound traffic - does the DS perform 802.1Q functionality? Could the DS create a "bridge" between the non-802.11 LANs, independent of the WLAN, and can it result in loops, etc? Clarify. Suggest that 802.11 assume there is only one portal (logically), so the DS can be well defined, and not require 802.1Q functions. Change the definition of "infrastrcture" and "WLAN system" to say "zero or one portal". Change Annex Q to match. Add a bridge in Figure V-1 to connect to the multiple VLANs. Discussion: The cited text is below: Discussion with Mark Hamilton: Discussions underway in ARC and 11ak; potentially have agreement on number of portals in November. Reference: from Mark Rison on 3314, 3493, 3141, 3394, 3292: “The use of the Dual CTS mechanism is deprecated” is probably most consistent with text. Similarly, “Dual CTS operation” is not a term which appears in the current draft (it's either dual CTS mechanism or dual CTS protection mechanism) Also 824.62, 1881.12, 1910.37 (D3.2) 2 instances of “RSN STA” (no A after RSN) in baseline too Well, except that there’s the statement ““TVHT-MCS” replaces “VHT-MCS”” in 4.3.13 and 23.5 is about “Parameters for TVHT MCSs” missing hyphen It’s more than unusual, it violates IEEE Std 802. Hence I think there should be a NOTE. Don’t ask me why, but like “ANQP-element”, “RLQP-element” takes a hyphen CID 3087 (GEN)
11-14-1041-10-000m-lb202-assigned-comments.docx