401 54.17 9.24.10.3 "A-MSDUs with RA field set Replace "A-MSDUs with RA to the SYNRA": the RA field field set to the SYNRA" with doesn't exist in the A-MSDUs. "A-MSDUs whose MPDU RA field values are the SYNRA". 223 54.23 9.42 Support for 3 modes are Recommend making these Revise: Section rewritten in overly complicated, and will optional, or only mandatory D1.3 with only 1 type that fits tend to be a barrier to fitting in base 48 bit SYNRA in 48 bits. adoption. Especially when w/o extension. If support is AMSDU deaggregation is not indicated by Clients at handled in HW. association, then AP can reject Clients without required support options or replicate as unicast. Instead call out that unsupported SYNRA types must be dropped by receiver. 254 54.34 9.42 Sentence doesn't belong here. Delete "The structure of the Revise: Sections rewritten in SYNRA address, which D1.3. includes a 2-bit SYNRA Type field and a 22-bit SYNRA Control field, is shown in Figure 8-52a (SYNRA structure)." 426 54.34 9.42 The structure of SYNRA Create a new subclause Revise: Sections rewritten in related fields shall be 8.3.2.1.3´╝êSYNRA field) by D1.3. specified in clause 8, not in moving corresponding clause 9. contents from 8.3.2.1.2 and 9.42. 87 54.37 "the Control field Replace by "defined in figure Revise: Also change E/I “The consists of an E/I subfield, an 9-91". Move the figure to subfield is a single bit AID offset subfield, and an occur before the field indicating” -> E/I “The AD bitmap subfield." -- descriptions. Make similar subfield indicates”. Editor to figures are definitive. There is changes to the other SNRA make consistant changes nothing to be gained from Types. throught section. attempting to describe the format also in words.
401 54.17 9.24.10.3 "A-MSDUs with RA field set to the SYNRA": the RA field doesn't exist in the A-MSDUs. Replace "A-MSDUs with RA field set to the SYNRA" with "A-MSDUs whose MPDU RA field values are the SYNRA". 223 54.23 9.42 Support for 3 modes are overly complicated, and will tend to be a barrier to adoption. Especially when AMSDU deaggregation is handled in HW. Recommend making these optional, or only mandatory fitting in base 48 bit SYNRA w/o extension. If support is not indicated by Clients at association, then AP can reject Clients without required support options or replicate as unicast. Instead call out that unsupported SYNRA types must be dropped by receiver. Revise: Section rewritten in D1.3 with only 1 type that fits in 48 bits. 254 54.34 9.42 Sentence doesn't belong here. Delete "The structure of the SYNRA address, which includes a 2-bit SYNRA Type field and a 22-bit SYNRA Control field, is shown in Figure 8-52a (SYNRA structure)." Revise: Sections rewritten in D1.3. 426 54.34 9.42 The structure of SYNRA related fields shall be specified in clause 8, not in clause 9. Create a new subclause 8.3.2.1.3´╝êSYNRA field) by moving corresponding contents from 8.3.2.1.2 and 9.42. Revise: Sections rewritten in D1.3. 87 54.37 "the Control field consists of an E/I subfield, an AID offset subfield, and an AD bitmap subfield." -- figures are definitive. There is nothing to be gained from attempting to describe the format also in words. Replace by "defined in figure 9-91". Move the figure to occur before the field descriptions. Make similar changes to the other SNRA Types. Revise: Also change “The E/I subfield is a single bit indicating” -> “The E/I subfield indicates”. Editor to make consistant changes throught section.
11-15-0795-11-00ak-addressing-comment-resolutions.docx