IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs CR for CID 1949 Date: 2018-- Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email 202 Bedok South Avenue Gaius Wee 1, #02-11, Singapore Panasonic 469332 Hiroyuki Motozuka Solomon Trainin Qualcomm strainin@qti.qualcomm.com CID Page Line Comment Proposed Proposed Change Resolution 1949 39 2 In the draft Keep the Revised text the Figure Figure 9-61 as is The unsolicited does not and RSS as defined in cover provide 10.39.6.2 is only additional performed and the figure between two Figure 12 that is EDMG STAs. A makes no EDMG non-EDMG STA sense to specific does not use this DMG that may subfield. devices due define to B14 and Add text to clarify "Unsolicited Next that non-EDMG RSS only STA ignores this Enabled subfield. field" that is not Also, merge the backward IsResponderTXSS compatible and Unsolicited RSS Enabled subfields as they can coexist in a single beacon interval control field format since its meaning can be determined by the value of the Next A-BFT subfield.
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs CR for CID 1949 Date: 2018-- Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Gaius Wee Panasonic 202 Bedok South Avenue 1, #02-11, Singapore 469332 Hiroyuki Motozuka Solomon Trainin Qualcomm strainin@qti.qualcomm.com CID Page Line Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution 1949 39 2 In the draft text the Figure 9-61 does not cover and the Figure 12 makes no sense to DMG devices due to "Unsolicited RSS Enabled field" that is not backward compatible Keep the Figure as is and provide additional figure that is EDMG specific that may define B14 and Next only Revised The unsolicited RSS as defined in 10.39.6.2 is only performed between two EDMG STAs. A non-EDMG STA does not use this subfield. Add text to clarify that non-EDMG STA ignores this subfield. Also, merge the IsResponderTXSS and Unsolicited RSS Enabled subfields as they can coexist in a single beacon interval control field format since its meaning can be determined by the value of the Next A-BFT subfield.
11-18-0636-01-00ay-cr-for-cid-1949.docx