IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Comment Resolution on OFDM DC relative shift Date: 2018-2-27 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email 600 Saedo-cho, Hiroyuki Motozuka Yokohama, motozuka.hiroyuki@jp.panasonic.com Kanagawa, Japan Takenori Sakamoto sakamoto.takenori@jp.panasonic.com Panasonic Yutaka Murakami murakami.ytk@jp.panasonic.com Lei lei.huang@sg.panasonic.com Gaius Wee yaohuang.wee@sg.panasonic.com Kazu Takahashi takahashi.kazu@jp.panasonic.com CID Clause Page Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution 2092 30.6.1.3 329.10 Unclear why DC Add text to explain Revised needs to be shifted, why the DC needs be please add a note to shifted relative to the TGay editor to make explain to the carrier frequency the changes shown in reader the reason 11-18/0275r0 under for the shift all headings that include CID 2092. 1520 30.6.1.3 329.11 Dc relative shift "The DC relative Accepted should be applied to frequency shift is the TRN field as applied in digital TGay editor to make well since the TRN domain for the changes shown in field for the OFDM EDMG-CEF, Data 11-18/0275r0 under PPDU consists of and TRN fields of an all headings that OFDM symbols. EDMG OFDM mode include CID 1520. PPDU." 1521 30.6.1.3 329.11 There's no text to Mention it in the text. Revised mention or define e.g. "The DC relative the parameter F_DC, shift, F_DC, is TGay editor to make which appears in frequency channel the changes shown in Table 72. dependent and 11-18/0275r0 under defined in Table 72." all headings that include CID 1521. 2138 30.6.1.3 330.07 FCC only As in comment Accepted approved up to 71 GHz, we should TGay editor to make remove rows 7 and the changes shown in 8 from NCB=1 11-18/0275r0 under category from Table all headings that 72. Similar action include CID 2138.
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Comment Resolution on OFDM DC relative shift Date: 2018-2-27 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Hiroyuki Motozuka Panasonic 600 Saedo-cho, Yokohama, Kanagawa, Japan motozuka.hiroyuki@jp.panasonic.com Takenori Sakamoto sakamoto.takenori@jp.panasonic.com Yutaka Murakami murakami.ytk@jp.panasonic.com Lei lei.huang@sg.panasonic.com Gaius Wee yaohuang.wee@sg.panasonic.com Kazu Takahashi takahashi.kazu@jp.panasonic.com CID Clause Page Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution 2092 30.6.1.3 329.10 Unclear why DC needs to be shifted, please add a note to explain to the reader the reason for the shift Add text to explain why the DC needs be shifted relative to the carrier frequency Revised TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0275r0 under all headings that include CID 2092. 1520 30.6.1.3 329.11 Dc relative shift should be applied to the TRN field as well since the TRN field for the OFDM PPDU consists of OFDM symbols. "The DC relative frequency shift is applied in digital domain for EDMG-CEF, Data and TRN fields of an EDMG OFDM mode PPDU." Accepted TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0275r0 under all headings that include CID 1520. 1521 30.6.1.3 329.11 There's no text to mention or define the parameter F_DC, which appears in Table 72. Mention it in the text. e.g. "The DC relative shift, F_DC, is frequency channel dependent and defined in Table 72." Revised TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0275r0 under all headings that include CID 1521. 2138 30.6.1.3 330.07 FCC only approved up to 71 GHz, we should remove rows 7 and 8 from NCB=1 category from Table 72. Similar action As in comment Accepted TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0275r0 under all headings that include CID 2138.
11-18-0275-00-00ay-cr-on-ofdm-dc-relative-shift.docx