and non-DMG are channel" and avoid DMG is defined in the adjectives, not change to this baseline 802.11 spec see – definition. A comment 11md D1.0. to REVmd might be to Without including DMG as replace "secondary part of this definition, any use channel" with of non-HT in the 802.11 spec "secondary 20 MHz could be interpreted as channel". including DMG. This definition is more general and not specific to secondary channels, hence the proposed resolution does not apply. 1891 3.2 should we also consider modify text " In Rejected the 2.16 + 2.16 channel DMG, a 2.16 GHz and the 4.32 + 4.32 channel associated 2.16 + 2.16 channel and the 4.32 + channels in defining with a primary channel 4.32 channels options are already secondary channels ? used by enhanced defined See Figure 3 on pg 29 directional line 6 for a discussion (EDMG) STAs of secondary channelse for 15 the purpose of I the 2.16 + 2.16 GHz creating a 4.32 GHz, and 4.32+4.32 GHz 6.48 GHz, 8.64 GHz, cases 2.16 + 2.16 GHz or 4.32 + 4.32 channel." 2197 3.2 There is no reason to Change the definition Selection of secondary channels add non-DMG to the to read: was addressed in CID 1708 which beginning of this provided the mechanism to define definition, as the current "secondary channel: A the secondary channels (8.3.5.12.2 definition specifically 20 MHz channel . Semantics of the service primitive) states which non-DMG associated with a The wording "associated with cases it refers to. it is primary channel used primary channel" was adopted only necessary to add by high-throughput from HT and VHT. the new case of a (HT) stations (STAs) secondary DMG for the purpose of channel. creating a 40 MHz channel or used by very high throughput (VHT) STAs for the purpose of creating the primary 40 MHz channel; or a 2.16 GHz channel associated with a primary channel used by enhanced directional (EDMG) STAs for the purpose of creating a 4.32 GHz, 6.48 GHz or 8.64 GHz channel."
and non-DMG are adjectives, not channel" and avoid change to this definition. A comment to REVmd might be to replace "secondary channel" with "secondary 20 MHz channel". DMG is defined in the baseline 802.11 spec – see 11md D1.0. Without including DMG as part of this definition, any use of non-HT in the 802.11 spec could be interpreted as including DMG. This definition is more general and not specific to secondary channels, hence the proposed resolution does not apply. 1891 3.2 should we also consider the 2.16 + 2.16 channel and the 4.32 + 4.32 channels in defining secondary channels ? See Figure 3 on pg 29 line 6 for a discussion of secondary channelse I the 2.16 + 2.16 GHz and 4.32+4.32 GHz cases modify text " In DMG, a 2.16 GHz channel associated with a primary channel used by enhanced directional (EDMG) STAs for 15 the purpose of creating a 4.32 GHz, 6.48 GHz, 8.64 GHz, 2.16 + 2.16 GHz or 4.32 + 4.32 channel." Rejected 2.16 + 2.16 channel and the 4.32 + 4.32 channels options are already defined 2197 3.2 There is no reason to add non-DMG to the beginning of this definition, as the current definition specifically states which non-DMG cases it refers to. it is only necessary to add the new case of a secondary DMG channel. Change the definition to read: "secondary channel: A 20 MHz channel associated with a primary channel used by high-throughput (HT) stations (STAs) for the purpose of creating a 40 MHz channel or used by very high throughput (VHT) STAs for the purpose of creating the primary 40 MHz channel; or a 2.16 GHz channel associated with a primary channel used by enhanced directional (EDMG) STAs for the purpose of creating a 4.32 GHz, 6.48 GHz or 8.64 GHz channel." Selection of secondary channels was addressed in CID 1708 which provided the mechanism to define the secondary channels (8.3.5.12.2 Semantics of the service primitive) . The wording "associated with primary channel" was adopted from HT and VHT.
11-18-1053-00-00ay-comment-resolution-on-cids.docx