Identifiers Comment Proposed change CID 7529 There is no reason Action No Acks can't have Add MICEs to Table 9-39 as in Mark RISON MICEs. While at the moment it may be the Table 9-38 9.3.3.15 case that such frames carry "information [...] 647.8 that is of time critical but transient value" (resolution of CID 6343), this is not a property of Action No Acks per se Discussion: There are ~70 instances of No Ack”. None of them indicate that Action No Acks are only for “Action [...] that is of time critical but transient value”. Indeed, to the contrary, 9.6.20.5 Information “information Response frame format indicates that an Information Response frame (which has a category of DMG, which per Table 9-47 does not receive privacy) may be broadcast in an Action No Ack. Proposed changes: Change Table 9-39—Action No Ack frame body to: Order Information 1 Action Last 1 One or more vendor-specific elements are optionally present. – Last The Management MIC element (MME) is present when management frame protection is enabled at the AP, the frame is a group addressed robust Action No Ack frame, and the category of the Action No Ack frame does not receive privacy as indicated by Table 9-47 (Category values). Proposed resolution: REVISED Make the changes shown under changes” for CID 7529 in <this document>, which effect the requested “Proposed change. Note to the commenter: the information in Information Response frames is not [...] that is of time “information critical but transient value”. Identifiers Comment Proposed change CID 7349 It was stated during D4.0 comment resolution Add a subclause on this CAF Mark (*cough*Adrian*cough*) that "transmission of the Beacon at TBTT is a famously individual and unnamed channel access function" Discussion:
Identifiers Comment Proposed change CID 7529 Mark RISON 9.3.3.15 647.8 There is no reason Action No Acks can't have MICEs. While at the moment it may be the case that such frames carry "information [...] that is of time critical but transient value" (resolution of CID 6343), this is not a property of Action No Acks per se Add MICEs to Table 9-39 as in Table 9-38 Discussion: There are ~70 instances of “Action No Ack”. None of them indicate that Action No Acks are only for “information [...] that is of time critical but transient value”. Indeed, to the contrary, 9.6.20.5 Information Response frame format indicates that an Information Response frame (which has a category of DMG, which per Table 9-47 does not receive privacy) may be broadcast in an Action No Ack. Proposed changes: Change Table 9-39—Action No Ack frame body to: Order Information 1 Action Last – 1 One or more vendor-specific elements are optionally present. Last The Management MIC element (MME) is present when management frame protection is enabled at the AP, the frame is a group addressed robust Action No Ack frame, and the category of the Action No Ack frame does not receive privacy as indicated by Table 9-47 (Category values). Proposed resolution: REVISED Make the changes shown under “Proposed changes” for CID 7529 in <this document>, which effect the requested change. Note to the commenter: the information in Information Response frames is not “information [...] that is of time critical but transient value”. Identifiers Comment Proposed change CID 7349 Mark It was stated during D4.0 comment resolution (*cough*Adrian*cough*) that "transmission of the Beacon at TBTT is a famously individual and unnamed channel access function" Add a subclause on this CAF Discussion:
11-16-0276-02-000m-resolutions-for-some-comments-on-11mc-d5-0-sbmc1.docx