See the instructions to the TGax editor in doc. 11-18/0890. Chunyu Hu 79.43 In "An HE AP that as in the comment Rejected. transmits a Multi-STA As normative BlockAck frame with requirements are different values of the not allowed in AID11 subfield in Per clause 9, “should” AID TID Info subfields cannot be used sets the RA field to the here. broadcast address.", change "sets the RA" to "should set RA". 13525 Stephen 79.43 In the cited sentence Either define "AID11" Rejected. McCann "AID11" is not defined. in the definitions It is said in the cited clause or insert a sentence that the forward reference to AID11 subfield is in Figure 9-38d where it the Per AID TID Info is defined. subfield and it is clear that the Per AID TID info subfield carries the AID TID Info subfield and the AID TID Info subfield carries the AID11 subfield, if read patiently. 14340 Zhou Lan 79.43 "An HE AP that as in the comment Rejected. transmits a Multi-STA Please see NOTE 1 BlockAck frame with after the 8th different values of the paragraph in this AID11 subfield in Per subclause. Different AID TID Info subfields values of the AID11 sets the RA field to the subfield means not broadcast address. An just multiple AID11 HE AP that transmits a subfields. There can Multi-STA BlockAck be a case when the frame with a single Per AID TID Info AID TID Info subfield subfield is repeated or with the same multiple times with values of the AID11 the AID11 subfields subfield in Per AID TID all the same but the Info subfields sets the TID subfields being RA field to the address different. In such of the recipient case, the RA will be that solicited the an unicast address. BlockAck frame." what Also, cannot “shall” does it mean by saying be used here as "different values of the normative AID11 subfield"? If it is requirements are mean to be multiple not allowed in AID11 subfield then clause 9. please state in that way. Also change "sets the RA" to "Shall set".
See the instructions to the TGax editor in doc. 11-18/0890. Chunyu Hu 79.43 In "An HE AP that transmits a Multi-STA BlockAck frame with different values of the AID11 subfield in Per AID TID Info subfields sets the RA field to the broadcast address.", change "sets the RA" to "should set RA". as in the comment Rejected. As normative requirements are not allowed in clause 9, “should” cannot be used here. 13525 Stephen McCann 79.43 In the cited sentence "AID11" is not defined. Either define "AID11" in the definitions clause or insert a forward reference to Figure 9-38d where it is defined. Rejected. It is said in the cited sentence that the AID11 subfield is in the Per AID TID Info subfield and it is clear that the Per AID TID info subfield carries the AID TID Info subfield and the AID TID Info subfield carries the AID11 subfield, if read patiently. 14340 Zhou Lan 79.43 "An HE AP that transmits a Multi-STA BlockAck frame with different values of the AID11 subfield in Per AID TID Info subfields sets the RA field to the broadcast address. An HE AP that transmits a Multi-STA BlockAck frame with a single Per AID TID Info subfield or with the same values of the AID11 subfield in Per AID TID Info subfields sets the RA field to the address of the recipient that solicited the BlockAck frame." what does it mean by saying "different values of the AID11 subfield"? If it is mean to be multiple AID11 subfield then please state in that way. Also change "sets the RA" to "Shall set". as in the comment Rejected. Please see NOTE 1 after the 8th paragraph in this subclause. Different values of the AID11 subfield means not just multiple AID11 subfields. There can be a case when the AID TID Info subfield is repeated multiple times with the AID11 subfields all the same but the TID subfields being different. In such case, the RA will be an unicast address. Also, “shall” cannot be used here as normative requirements are not allowed in clause 9.
11-18-0890-01-00ax-resolutions-to-lb230-comments-submitted-to-subclauses-9-3-1-9-3-and-9-3-1-9-7.docx