Yusuke "(including HE Trigger-Based As commented. Revised agree – Tanaka PPDU)" should be "(including an with the comment. HE TB PPDU, expect when the HE Apply the changes TB PPDU is triggered by a Trigger proposed in doc frame having the CS Required 1852r0. subfield set to 0)" kaiying Lv Change to "including HE as comment Revised agree – with the comment. PPDU, except when the HE TB Apply the changes PPDU is triggered by a Trigger proposed in doc frame having the CS Required 1852r0. subfield set to 0" Chu the notes are too weak. Fix the issue mentioned in Rejected this is a – 27 Transferring them to normative comment. note because the requirement. normative text above covers these conditions. These notes are just to clarify the normative text above. Qi Xue Add a normative text to cover the As in the comment Rejected this is a – following two notes: note because the normative text NOTE 1--The STA can increase but above covers not decrease the chosen SRG these conditions – OBSS_PD level or non-SRG see in particular, OBSS_PD level during an OBSS_PD the equation 27-4. SR transmit power restriction These notes are period. just to clarify the NOTE 2--The STA's power is always normative text equal or lower than the minimum above. TXPWRmax among all TXPWRmax from ongoing OBSS_PD SR transmit power restriction periods. Guoqing Li Note 1 is unnecessary. STA should Remove NOTE 1. Revised Agree – be allowed to decrease its that the note is OBSS_PD level to be more confusing. conservative. This restriction does Normative text not not seem necessary. seems clear enough. TGax editor to make changes identified by CID 11812 in doc 1852r0. Qi Xue Repeated Note 1 & Note 2 in lines As in the comment Revised agree – 37-40 and lines 27-31 with the comment. Apply the changes proposed in doc 1852r0.
Yusuke Tanaka "(including HE Trigger-Based PPDU)" should be "(including an HE TB PPDU, expect when the HE TB PPDU is triggered by a Trigger frame having the CS Required subfield set to 0)" As commented. Revised – agree with the comment. Apply the changes proposed in doc 1852r0. kaiying Lv Change to "including HE PPDU, except when the HE TB PPDU is triggered by a Trigger frame having the CS Required subfield set to 0" as comment Revised – agree with the comment. Apply the changes proposed in doc 1852r0. Chu the notes are too weak. Transferring them to normative requirement. Fix the issue mentioned in comment. Rejected – this is a note because the normative text above covers these conditions. These notes are just to clarify the normative text above. Qi Xue Add a normative text to cover the following two notes: NOTE 1--The STA can increase but not decrease the chosen SRG OBSS_PD level or non-SRG OBSS_PD level during an OBSS_PD SR transmit power restriction period. NOTE 2--The STA's power is always equal or lower than the minimum TXPWRmax among all TXPWRmax from ongoing OBSS_PD SR transmit power restriction periods. As in the comment Rejected – this is a note because the normative text above covers these conditions – see in particular, the equation 27-4. These notes are just to clarify the normative text above. Guoqing Li Note 1 is unnecessary. STA should be allowed to decrease its OBSS_PD level to be more conservative. This restriction does not not seem necessary. Remove NOTE 1. Revised – Agree that the note is confusing. Normative text seems clear enough. TGax editor to make changes identified by CID 11812 in doc 1852r0. Qi Xue Repeated Note 1 & Note 2 in lines 37-40 and lines 27-31 As in the comment Revised – agree with the comment. Apply the changes proposed in doc 1852r0. 27
11-17-1852-00-00ax-cr-for-27-9.docx