459 John "WID" needs to be defined The first use of "WID" Revised – Buffington needs to be defined or added to section 3.4. Agree in principle. Though WID is proposed to be removed and adding the acronym for its sibling ID”. “WUR TGba editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/1834r1 under all headings that include CID 459. r1 r1 541 Leif period missing (to be cosistent with e.g. add a period Accepted Wilhelmsson how things are written on page 21. 637 Michael Include reference to the place where Add cross-reference Revised – Fischer "critical update ..." is defined (clause (something like "as 31.7.2). specified in clause 31.7.2") Proposed resolution is to provide a reference to the subclause after "... when a critical that provides the normative behavior related to this counter as update ..." suggested by the commenter. TGba editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/1834r1 under all headings that include CID 637. r1 r1 r1 787 Osama "WID" is not defined. What does it Add WID to Clause 3. Revised – Aboulmagd mean? Agree in principle. Though WID is proposed to be removed and adding the acronym for its sibling ID”. “WUR TGba editor to make the changes in 11-18/1834r1 under all headings that include CID 787. r1 789 Osama It is not clear how a receiving WUR as in comment. Revised – Aboulmagd 8 non-AP STA would differentiate between the different addresses in the The rules are defined in subclause 31.3 where it should be table. specified that these identifiers do not overlap with each other. TGba editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/1834r1 under all headings that include CID 789. r1 r1
459 John Buffington "WID" needs to be defined The first use of "WID" needs to be defined or added to section 3.4. Revised – Agree in principle. Though WID is proposed to be removed and adding the acronym for its sibling “WUR ID”. TGba editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/1834r1 under all headings that include CID 459. r1 r1 541 Leif Wilhelmsson period missing (to be cosistent with e.g. how things are written on page 21. add a period Accepted 637 Michael Fischer Include reference to the place where "critical update ..." is defined (clause 31.7.2). Add cross-reference (something like "as specified in clause 31.7.2") after "... when a critical update ..." Revised – Proposed resolution is to provide a reference to the subclause that provides the normative behavior related to this counter as suggested by the commenter. TGba editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/1834r1 under all headings that include CID 637. r1 r1 r1 787 Osama Aboulmagd "WID" is not defined. What does it mean? Add WID to Clause 3. Revised – Agree in principle. Though WID is proposed to be removed and adding the acronym for its sibling “WUR ID”. TGba editor to make the changes in 11-18/1834r1 under all headings that include CID 787. r1 789 Osama Aboulmagd It is not clear how a receiving WUR non-AP STA would differentiate between the different addresses in the table. as in comment. Revised – The rules are defined in subclause 31.3 where it should be specified that these identifiers do not overlap with each other. TGba editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/1834r1 under all headings that include CID 789. r1 r1 8
11-18-1834-01-00ba-mac-cr-9-10-3-2.docx