RESOLUTION: OPTION A REJECT The set of data rates in the OperationalRateSet and the BSSBasicRateSet are limited to the rates as per Table 6.5.5.2 which is a superset of the dot11SupportedDataRatesRXTable. This is stated in the text for “9.4.2.3 Supported Rates and BSS Membership Selectors element” and Extended Supported Rates and BSS “9.4.2.13 Membership Selectors element” where the supported rates are provided. Hence, further clarification is not necessary. OPTION B P201.54 Add the following to the Range” entry of “Valid “BSSBasicRateSet”: data rates present in dot11SupportedDataRatesRxTable and dot11SupportedDataRatesTxTable may be “Only present” Identifiers Comment Proposed change CID 7292 "The delay, in microseconds, from a point in Change to "The delay, in time specified by the PHY to the issuance of microseconds, from the start of the Mark Rison the PHY-RXSTART.indication primitive." -- PPDU at the receiver's antenna to 6.5.4.2 none of the PHYs do so the issuance of the 534.28 primitive." Discussion: A search for a point in time” indeed shows that this is the only place in the Standard this expression is used. “from RESOLUTION: ACCEPT Identifiers Comment Proposed change CID 7360 "Except where modified by the pifs attribute, Append "or RIFS" frames are separated by a SIFS" -- so no Mark Rison frame exchange sequences involving RIFS are G.2 allowable? 3402.42 Discussion: Basic sequences “G.2 The allowable frame exchange sequence is defined by the rule frame-exchange-sequence. Except where modified by the attribute, frames are separated by a SIFS.” pifs 10.3.2.3.2 RIFS The use of RIFS is obsolete, and support for such use might be subject to removal in a future revision of the standard. A VHT STA shall not transmit frames separated by a RIFS. RIFS is a means of reducing overhead and thereby increasing network efficiency. RIFS may be used in place of SIFS to separate multiple transmissions from a single transmitter,
RESOLUTION: OPTION A REJECT The set of data rates in the OperationalRateSet and the BSSBasicRateSet are limited to the rates as per Table 6.5.5.2 which is a superset of the dot11SupportedDataRatesRXTable. This is stated in the text for “9.4.2.3 Supported Rates and BSS Membership Selectors element” and “9.4.2.13 Extended Supported Rates and BSS Membership Selectors element” where the supported rates are provided. Hence, further clarification is not necessary. OPTION B P201.54 Add the following to the “Valid Range” entry of “BSSBasicRateSet”: “Only data rates present in dot11SupportedDataRatesRxTable and dot11SupportedDataRatesTxTable may be present” Identifiers Comment Proposed change CID 7292 Mark Rison 6.5.4.2 534.28 "The delay, in microseconds, from a point in time specified by the PHY to the issuance of the PHY-RXSTART.indication primitive." -- none of the PHYs do so Change to "The delay, in microseconds, from the start of the PPDU at the receiver's antenna to the issuance of the primitive." Discussion: A search for “from a point in time” indeed shows that this is the only place in the Standard this expression is used. RESOLUTION: ACCEPT Identifiers Comment Proposed change CID 7360 Mark Rison G.2 3402.42 "Except where modified by the pifs attribute, frames are separated by a SIFS" -- so no frame exchange sequences involving RIFS are allowable? Append "or RIFS" Discussion: “G.2 Basic sequences The allowable frame exchange sequence is defined by the rule frame-exchange-sequence. Except where modified by the pifs attribute, frames are separated by a SIFS.” 10.3.2.3.2 RIFS The use of RIFS is obsolete, and support for such use might be subject to removal in a future revision of the standard. A VHT STA shall not transmit frames separated by a RIFS. RIFS is a means of reducing overhead and thereby increasing network efficiency. RIFS may be used in place of SIFS to separate multiple transmissions from a single transmitter,
11-16-0237-00-000m-resolutions-for-cids-assigned-to-graham-d5.docx