headings that include CID 5185. 5186 Liwen 144.44 8.4.2.170j "TWT group parameters Clarify it. Reject requesting – Chu that are different from ... STA requests TWT parameters" TWT group parameters, but response can use TWT group Which one is really parameters. talking about TWT group parameters or TWT parameters? 5187 Liwen 144.50 8.4.2.170j Why is the Make the of Revise generally – Chu suggested/demanded agree with commenter, parameter only TWT parameters TGah editor to execute and the responder needs same as the proposed changes to accept a set of accepted found in document parameters? parameters. under all headings that include CID 5187. 5190 Liwen 161.40 8.4.2.170l "...after the transmission Always use Start Reject how long – Chu of the Beacon frame Time subfield. does it take to decode containing the SST the element? There element." are many “correct” answers to this question and the commenter has not The decoding of element provided even one is higher MAC layer. answer to the STAs do not know SST question, so it is element right after impossible to know Beacon carrying SST what minimum Start element. Time value should be mandated. Furthermore, it is possible for any STA interested in the sounding to simply stay awake immediately after the Beacon in case sounding starts and during the sounding, the element decoding can proceed. 5191 Liwen 161.01 8.4.2.170l "...at the end of the Always use Start Reject how long – Chu transmission of the frame Time subfield. does it take to decode containing the SST the element? are element" many “correct” answers to this question and the commenter has not The decoding of element provided even one is higher MAC layer. answer to the STAs do not know SST question, so it is element right after the impossible to know frame containing the what minimum Start SST element. Time value should be mandated. Furthermore, it is possible for any STA interested in the sounding to simply stay awake
headings that include CID 5185. 5186 Liwen Chu 144.44 8.4.2.170j "TWT group parameters that are different from ... TWT parameters" Which one is really talking about TWT group parameters or TWT parameters? Clarify it. Reject – requesting STA requests TWT group parameters, but response can use TWT group parameters. 5187 Liwen Chu 144.50 8.4.2.170j Why is the suggested/demanded parameter only TWT and the responder needs to accept a set of parameters? Make the of parameters same as the accepted parameters. Revise – generally agree with commenter, TGah editor to execute proposed changes found in document under all headings that include CID 5187. 5190 Liwen Chu 161.40 8.4.2.170l "...after the transmission of the Beacon frame containing the SST element." The decoding of element is higher MAC layer. STAs do not know SST element right after Beacon carrying SST element. Always use Start Time subfield. Reject – how long does it take to decode the element? There are many “correct” answers to this question and the commenter has not provided even one answer to the question, so it is impossible to know what minimum Start Time value should be mandated. Furthermore, it is possible for any STA interested in the sounding to simply stay awake immediately after the Beacon in case sounding starts and during the sounding, the element decoding can proceed. 5191 Liwen Chu 161.01 8.4.2.170l "...at the end of the transmission of the frame containing the SST element" The decoding of element is higher MAC layer. STAs do not know SST element right after the frame containing the SST element. Always use Start Time subfield. Reject – how long does it take to decode the element? are many “correct” answers to this question and the commenter has not provided even one answer to the question, so it is impossible to know what minimum Start Time value should be mandated. Furthermore, it is possible for any STA interested in the sounding to simply stay awake
11-15-0083-01-00ah-lb205-twt-sst-cids-not-grouptwt.docx