comment. Any spec changes are not needed. Proposed CID Page Clause Comment Resolution Change 886 For S1G band, the NDP Define a Revised- transmission protocol S1G NDP TGah should be defined. transmission editor to Simply, we can replace protocol. make VHT of section 9.31.6 changes with S1G. shown in under the heading for CID 813, 816, 886 813 the folowing sentence Have a Revised- "For S1G band, the same thorough TGah sounding protocol is revision of editor to applied, with "VHT" the section make replaced by "S1G"" is too and make changes simplistic and if applied sure the shown in generates several desired inconsistencies; e.g. this behavior is would indicate also an clearly under the "S1G NDP defined heading for Announcement", which CID 813, does not exist. Is the VHT 816, 886 NDP announcements used? Similarly for the VHT CompressedBeamforming 816 "9.31.5.2 Rules for VHT Clarify Revised- sounding protocol for S1G TGah sequences" A VHT Sounding editor to beamformer shall not Protocol. make transmit either a VHT changes NDP shown in Announcement+HTC frame or a Beamforming ReportPoll+HTC frame under the that contains an HT heading for variant HT Control field. CID 813, Does S1G supports HTC 816, 886 or VHTC? CID 813, 816, 886 Discussion: For S1G band, the same VHT sounding protocol is applied to a S1G STA.
comment. Any spec changes are not needed. CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resolution 886 For S1G band, the NDP transmission protocol should be defined. Simply, we can replace VHT of section 9.31.6 with S1G. Define a S1G NDP transmission protocol. Revised- TGah editor to make changes shown in under the heading for CID 813, 816, 886 813 the folowing sentence "For S1G band, the same sounding protocol is applied, with "VHT" replaced by "S1G"" is too simplistic and if applied generates several inconsistencies; e.g. this would indicate also an "S1G NDP Announcement", which does not exist. Is the VHT NDP announcements used? Similarly for the VHT CompressedBeamforming Have a thorough revision of the section and make sure the desired behavior is clearly defined Revised- TGah editor to make changes shown in under the heading for CID 813, 816, 886 816 "9.31.5.2 Rules for VHT sounding protocol sequences" A VHT beamformer shall not transmit either a VHT NDP Announcement+HTC frame or a Beamforming ReportPoll+HTC frame that contains an HT variant HT Control field. Does S1G supports HTC or VHTC? Clarify for S1G Sounding Protocol. Revised- TGah editor to make changes shown in under the heading for CID 813, 816, 886 CID 813, 816, 886 Discussion: For S1G band, the same VHT sounding protocol is applied to a S1G STA.
11-13-1086-00-00ah-cc9-cid-813-816-825-826-886-comment-resolution.docx