1150 11.44 This "Estimated Delete "Entities Revise TGmd editor – Throughput" is outside the scope to make changes as Fischer intended to be useful of this standard that shown in for controlling traffic might control the that are decisions. It does traffic steering marked with CID 1150 specify how a STA can decision of a device slight modifications – inform another STA of benefitby being to the wording have traffic estimates but I able to predict the been made to reduce am not convinced that throughput that the expressed level of this is of any use for might be obtained certainty of the what it supposed to through a link with statements as address. By stating at a STA. Those opposed to the L51 and L53 that same entities also wholesale deletion these outside entities need to know what proposed by the "need to know the the current commenter, based on current estimates" we estimate of the fact that existing are open to questions throughput is for systems do use of accuracy and 'how network selection parameters similar to to use'. I suggest that purposes (by those listed to make these statements are comparing an the decisions removed. CCCID56 estimated described in the cited throughout with text. existing throughout)." 1151 11.44 Huge paragraph at "If the MLME is Revise TGmd editor – P2049 L13 is in fact incapable of to make changes as Fischer quite simple", but is determining a value shown in repeated for each for the that are parameter and hence marked with CID 1151. becomes diffivult to or These changes break comprehend. If the up the paragraph, but MLME is incapable of do not make the other determining a vale for parameter for any changes suggested. access category, it simply returns a 0. If then the MLME the AverageMSDU shall return a value size in the of 0 for the value of that parameter for that access primitive is -1, then category in the the corresponding the primitive. If the primitive is 0. If the or AverageMSDU size is 0, then the parameter correspondoing for an access EstimatedThroughput category is equal to is calculated using any -1 in the size but recommends 1500B. Can we try to write it simpler? primitive, the CCCID55 STA shall include a value of 0 in the respective or
1150 Fischer 11.44 This "Estimated Throughput" is intended to be useful for controlling traffic decisions. It does specify how a STA can inform another STA of traffic estimates but I am not convinced that this is of any use for what it supposed to address. By stating at L51 and L53 that these outside entities "need to know the current estimates" we are open to questions of accuracy and 'how to use'. I suggest that these statements are removed. CCCID56 Delete "Entities outside the scope of this standard that might control the traffic steering decision of a device benefitby being able to predict the throughput that might be obtained through a link with a STA. Those same entities also need to know what the current estimate of throughput is for network selection purposes (by comparing an estimated throughout with existing throughout)." Revise – TGmd editor to make changes as shown in that are marked with CID 1150 – slight modifications to the wording have been made to reduce the expressed level of certainty of the statements as opposed to the wholesale deletion proposed by the commenter, based on the fact that existing systems do use parameters similar to those listed to make the decisions described in the cited text. 1151 Fischer 11.44 Huge paragraph at P2049 L13 is in fact quite simple", but is repeated for each parameter and hence becomes diffivult to comprehend. If the MLME is incapable of determining a vale for it simply returns a 0. If the AverageMSDU size in the primitive is -1, then the corresponding the primitive is 0. If the AverageMSDU size is 0, then the correspondoing EstimatedThroughput is calculated using any size but recommends 1500B. Can we try to write it simpler? CCCID55 "If the MLME is incapable of determining a value for the or parameter for any access category, then the MLME shall return a value of 0 for the value of that parameter for that access category in the primitive. If the or parameter for an access category is equal to -1 in the primitive, the STA shall include a value of 0 in the respective or Revise – TGmd editor to make changes as shown in that are marked with CID 1151. These changes break up the paragraph, but do not make the other changes suggested.
11-17-1192-22-000m-cr-esp.docx