IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Comment Resolution on OFDM data rate Date: 2018-1-15 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone 600 Saedo-cho, Hiroyuki Motozuka Yokohama, motozuka.hiroyuki@jp.panasonic.com Kanagawa, Japan Takenori Sakamoto sakamoto.takenori@jp.panasonic.com Panasonic Yutaka Murakami murakami.ytk@jp.panasonic.com Lei Huang lei.huang@sg.panasonic.com Gaius Wee yaohuang.wee@sg.panasonic.com Kazu Takahashi takahashi.kazu@jp.panasonic.com CID Clause Page Comment Proposed Proposed Resolution Change 1527 30.6.7 347.01 Typo in Table 78, N_SD=336, As per Accepted MCS3, Normal GI: comment TGay editor to make the "094.20" should be "1094.20"; changes shown in or more acculately, "1094.21" under all headings that include CID 1527. 1528 30.6.7 347.01 The second decimals of the Correct Revised data rates look inaccurate in the values Table 78 and Table 79. TGay editor to make the changes shown in For example, for N_SD=366, under all MCS 5 and Normal GI, the data headings that include CID rate is 1276.578..., then it 1528. should be denoted as 1276.58 instead of 1276.60. Discussion The data rate tables for the DMG SC mode in IEEE802.11-2016 and the EDMG SC mode in P802.11ay D1.0 have resolution of 0.01 Mbps. We propose to align the vanues in the table for EDMG OFDM mode with the above mentioned resolution. The current values are accurate only on the first 5 digits, and may be inaccurate in case the rate exceeds 1000 Mbps. Proposed changes to D1.0
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Comment Resolution on OFDM data rate Date: 2018-1-15 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone Hiroyuki Motozuka Panasonic 600 Saedo-cho, Yokohama, Kanagawa, Japan motozuka.hiroyuki@jp.panasonic.com Takenori Sakamoto sakamoto.takenori@jp.panasonic.com Yutaka Murakami murakami.ytk@jp.panasonic.com Lei Huang lei.huang@sg.panasonic.com Gaius Wee yaohuang.wee@sg.panasonic.com Kazu Takahashi takahashi.kazu@jp.panasonic.com CID Clause Page Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution 1527 30.6.7 347.01 Typo in Table 78, N_SD=336, MCS3, Normal GI: "094.20" should be "1094.20"; or more acculately, "1094.21" As per comment Accepted TGay editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 1527. 1528 30.6.7 347.01 The second decimals of the data rates look inaccurate in Table 78 and Table 79. For example, for N_SD=366, MCS 5 and Normal GI, the data rate is 1276.578..., then it should be denoted as 1276.58 instead of 1276.60. Correct the values Revised TGay editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 1528. Discussion The data rate tables for the DMG SC mode in IEEE802.11-2016 and the EDMG SC mode in P802.11ay D1.0 have resolution of 0.01 Mbps. We propose to align the vanues in the table for EDMG OFDM mode with the above mentioned resolution. The current values are accurate only on the first 5 digits, and may be inaccurate in case the rate exceeds 1000 Mbps. Proposed changes to D1.0
11-18-0188-00-00ay-cr-on-ofdm-data-rate.docx