46 69 12 "In the SU-MIMO Repalce the text with Revised- subphase, based on the normative behavior on SNRs of the transmit what is sent by the TGay editor to make the sectors collected from inititor and what is changes shown in the responder in the replied by the under all SISO Feedback respodner. It is not headings that include subphase of the SISO necessary for the CID 46. phase, the initiator may initiator to inidcate the select a subset of sectors it will use in candidate transmit advance, only their sectors per DMG numbe, or the MID antenna to reduce the extension may be initiator SMT training used. time. " This whole paragraph describes non normative behavior that is irrelevant to the fileds 47 69 28 "the candidate transmit Remove the list of Accepted- sectors" The list does sectros, it is too long. not have to be know in TGay editor to make the advance, possilby it changes shown in length may be required, under all the sector ID is headings that include transmitted inside each CID 47. packet. 185 70 30 NI undefined, used (N_I) instead of NI Revised- further as N_I TGay editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 185. 51 72 32 "the order if which Remove this from the Accepted- transmit sectors are list trained" - why is this TGay editor to make the necessary, besides being changes shown in long, this has no effect under all on reponders behavior headings that include CID 51. 52 72 34 "the number of receive Replace with "the Revised- training fields based on number of receive the feedback from TRN-Units based on TGay editor to make the responders received at the L-RX field in changes in the SISO phase" - its feedback from under all receive training responders received at headings that include and the L-RX the SISO pahse" CID 52. field in the responses shall be mentioned 395 72 34 It is not clear how does change the sentence to Revised- initiator determine the 'To reduce the number of rx training MIMO training time, TGay editor to make the fields needed at the initiator may select changes shown in responder, based on the a subset of TX sectors under all
46 69 12 "In the SU-MIMO subphase, based on the SNRs of the transmit sectors collected from the responder in the SISO Feedback subphase of the SISO phase, the initiator may select a subset of candidate transmit sectors per DMG antenna to reduce the initiator SMT training time. " This whole paragraph describes non normative behavior that is irrelevant to the fileds Repalce the text with normative behavior on what is sent by the inititor and what is replied by the respodner. It is not necessary for the initiator to inidcate the sectors it will use in advance, only their numbe, or the MID extension may be used. Revised- TGay editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 46. 47 69 28 "the candidate transmit sectors" The list does not have to be know in advance, possilby it length may be required, the sector ID is transmitted inside each packet. Remove the list of sectros, it is too long. Accepted- TGay editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 47. 185 70 30 NI undefined, used further as N_I (N_I) instead of NI Revised- TGay editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 185. 51 72 32 "the order if which transmit sectors are trained" - why is this necessary, besides being long, this has no effect on reponders behavior Remove this from the list Accepted- TGay editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 51. 52 72 34 "the number of receive training fields based on the feedback from responders received at the SISO phase" - its receive training and the L-RX field in the responses shall be mentioned Replace with "the number of receive TRN-Units based on the L-RX field in feedback from responders received at the SISO pahse" Revised- TGay editor to make the changes in under all headings that include CID 52. 395 72 34 It is not clear how does initiator determine the number of rx training fields needed at responder, based on the change the sentence to 'To reduce the training time, the initiator may select a subset of TX sectors Revised- TGay editor to make the changes shown in under all MIMO
11-17-0921-00-00ay-cr-on-su-mimo-and-mu-mimo-bf-setup.docx