changes shown in under all headings that include CID 391 392 34.36 "shall also declare .. / how are these Revised Agree in – Hart Class A/B" classes declared? principle with the Add comment TGax – editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 392 457 Daewon 32.01 Combined minimum Clarify that combined Reject – Lee total duration of the minimum discussion, PHY post-FEC padding and duration of the experts agree that the packet extension padding and commenter is incorrect requirement for an HE packet extension PPDU for 242 tone RU requirement for an can be either for BCC HE PPDU is intended encoded PPDU or for LDPC encoded LDPC encoded PPDU. PPDUs. BCC However, the required encoded PDDUs do total duration for not have such different encoder types requirement for are different. The STAs. specification is not clear whether the same required duration capability applies for both BCC and LDPC or the required duration capability only applies for LDPC. 571 32.32 It is not defined the Replace "for NNSx" Reject the value – exact NNS value for with "for NSS=x" NSS=1 is by definition every PPET16 PPET8 present if the field is field present. The value n represents the highest NSS value. The definition of the field does not allow for skipping of some NSS values. It is questionable whether the bit savings for this once-per association frame is enough justification to change the format to use a bitmask for the NSS values. 572 32.19 If the RU Count Explain in the Revised Agree in – subfield has the standard or change principle with the reserved values of 0 the size to 1 bit comment TGax – and 3, why is it 2 bit editor to make the long but not 1 bit long? changes shown in under all headings that include
changes shown in under all headings that include CID 391 392 Hart 34.36 "shall also declare .. Class A/B" / how are these classes declared? Add Revised – Agree in principle with the comment – TGax editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include CID 392 457 Daewon Lee 32.01 Combined minimum total duration of the post-FEC padding and packet extension requirement for an HE PPDU for 242 tone RU can be either for BCC encoded PPDU or LDPC encoded PPDU. However, the required total duration for different encoder types are different. The specification is not clear whether the same required duration capability applies for both BCC and LDPC or the required duration capability only applies for LDPC. Clarify that combined minimum duration of the padding and packet extension requirement for an HE PPDU is intended for LDPC encoded PPDUs. BCC encoded PDDUs do not have such requirement for STAs. Reject – discussion, PHY experts agree that the commenter is incorrect 571 32.32 It is not defined the exact NNS value for every PPET16 PPET8 field Replace "for NNSx" with "for NSS=x" Reject – the value NSS=1 is by definition present if the field is present. The value n represents the highest NSS value. The definition of the field does not allow for skipping of some NSS values. It is questionable whether the bit savings for this once-per association frame is enough justification to change the format to use a bitmask for the NSS values. 572 32.19 If the RU Count subfield has the reserved values of 0 and 3, why is it 2 bit long but not 1 bit long? Explain in the standard or change the size to 1 bit Revised – Agree in principle with the comment – TGax editor to make the changes shown in under all headings that include
11-16-1266-02-00ax-cc23-pr-elements.docx