PPDU that follows UnassocUoraBSYM is at least 16 UnassocUoraBSYM is ╬╝s. the OFDM symbol of the PPDU that contains either the last bit of SCH when BCC is used to encode the PSDU or the last coded bit of the LDPC codeword that encodes the last bit of SCH when LDPC is used to encode the PSDU, where SCH is the last User Info field with AID12 subfield equal to 2045." The padding of trigger frame is to allow STA to have sufficient time to prepare TB PPDU with high HE rate. However, unassociated STA only use base rate to transmit management frame. 16us is too much overhead that compromise the efficiency. Remove this paragraph or clarify. CID PP LL Comment Proposed Change Resolution 16250 216 37 "A STA indicates in the Maxi- Change Subclause mum A-MPDU Length 10.13.2 to add caveats on Exponent field in its HT the A-MPDU length rules Revised Capabilities, VHT Capabilities for STAs whose and HE Capabilities elements Maximum A-MPDU Generally agree with the commenter. What the maximum length of the Length Exponent the commenter asks is defined in 27.10.1 pre-EOF padding that it Extension is non-zero TGax editor to make changes in 11-18/2040r2 can receive in an HE PPDU." under CID 16250 is not true if the Maximum Length Exponent Extension field is not 0 10.13.2 A-MPDU length limit rules TGax editor: please change the first paragraph in 10.13.2 as follows: A STA indicates in the Maximum AMPDU Length Exponent field in its HT Capabilities element the maximum AMPDU length that it can receive in an HT PPDU. A STA indicates in the Maximum A-MPDU Length Exponent field in its VHT Capabilities element the maximum length of the A-MPDU pre-EOF padding that it can receive in a VHT PPDU. A DMG STA indicates in the Maximum A-MPDU Length Exponent field in its DMG Capabilities element the maximum A-MPDU length that it can receive. A STA indicates in the Maximum A-MPDU Length Exponent field in its HT Capabilities, VHT
PPDU that follows UnassocUoraBSYM is at least 16 ╬╝s. UnassocUoraBSYM is the OFDM symbol of the PPDU that contains either the last bit of SCH when BCC is used to encode the PSDU or the last coded bit of the LDPC codeword that encodes the last bit of SCH when LDPC is used to encode the PSDU, where SCH is the last User Info field with AID12 subfield equal to 2045." The padding of trigger frame is to allow STA to have sufficient time to prepare TB PPDU with high HE rate. However, unassociated STA only use base rate to transmit management frame. 16us is too much overhead that compromise the efficiency. Remove this paragraph or clarify. CID PP LL Comment Proposed Change Resolution 16250 216 37 "A STA indicates in the Maxi- mum A-MPDU Length Exponent field in its HT Capabilities, VHT Capabilities and HE Capabilities elements the maximum length of the pre-EOF padding that it can receive in an HE PPDU." is not true if the Maximum Length Exponent Extension field is not 0 Change Subclause 10.13.2 to add caveats on the A-MPDU length rules for STAs whose Maximum A-MPDU Length Exponent Extension is non-zero Revised Generally agree with the commenter. What the commenter asks is defined in 27.10.1 TGax editor to make changes in 11-18/2040r2 under CID 16250 10.13.2 A-MPDU length limit rules TGax editor: please change the first paragraph in 10.13.2 as follows: A STA indicates in the Maximum AMPDU Length Exponent field in its HT Capabilities element the maximum AMPDU length that it can receive in an HT PPDU. A STA indicates in the Maximum A-MPDU Length Exponent field in its VHT Capabilities element the maximum length of the A-MPDU pre-EOF padding that it can receive in a VHT PPDU. A DMG STA indicates in the Maximum A-MPDU Length Exponent field in its DMG Capabilities element the maximum A-MPDU length that it can receive. A STA indicates in the Maximum A-MPDU Length Exponent field in its HT Capabilities, VHT
11-18-2040-02-00ax-11ax-d3-0-comment-resolution-miscellaneous.docx