US v. Brewster (1972) Burger F M allow federal prosecution of official to move forward Frontiero v. Richardson Brennan F M Congress’ view that sex based (1973) classifications are wrong is valued Doe et al v. McMillan F M Speech and debate clause grants (1973) members of Congress immunity; quotes Brewster Memorial Hospital v. Marshall S M quotes Frontiero that Congressional Maricopa County (1974) pronouncements have US v. Richardson (1974) Powell F C Simple reference to Frothingham rule (Powell dislikes Flast test) Schlesinger v. Reservists Douglas F D quotes Frothingham but only to (1974) dismiss it as controlling US v. Nixon (1974) Burger F M dismisses executive privilege claim in this instance Buckley v. Valeo (1976) Per curiam F M Quote amici, dismissing their claim about Congress and appointments US v. Donavan (1977) Burger F C deference to Congress, as it is not violating the 4th Amendment Nixon v. Administrator of Brennan F M Quotes Jackson concurrence in General Services (1977) Youngstown; branches share powers Powell C Dismissive of claim that statute should fall b/c presidency is coequal Burger D three references to coequal; Congress and courts not treating pres. as Davis v. Passman (1979) Burger F D courts can’t a member of coequal branch to employ someone US v. Helstoski (1979) Burger F M speech/debate clause designed to preserve coequality Goldwater v. Carter (1979) Rehnquist F C deciding the issue is moot is better than using political questions b/c it disrupts coequality less US v. Gillock (1980) Burger S M Speech/debate clause does not protect state leg. officials Owen v. City of Brennan S M wrongful termination suit can Independence (1980) proceed; deference to Congress’ judgment that city has no immunity Fullilove v. Klutznick (1980) Burger F M deference to Congress’ determination that minorities require remedy to promote the general welfare US v. Will (1980) Burger F M Congress may cancel pay raises scheduled to take effect
US v. Brewster (1972) Burger F M allow federal prosecution of official to move forward Frontiero v. Richardson (1973) Brennan F M Congress’ view that sex based classifications are wrong is valued Doe et al v. McMillan (1973) F M Speech and debate clause grants members of Congress immunity; quotes Brewster Memorial Hospital v. Maricopa County (1974) Marshall S M quotes Frontiero that Congressional pronouncements have US v. Richardson (1974) Powell F C Simple reference to Frothingham rule (Powell dislikes Flast test) Schlesinger v. Reservists (1974) Douglas F D quotes Frothingham but only to dismiss it as controlling US v. Nixon (1974) Burger F M dismisses executive privilege claim in this instance Buckley v. Valeo (1976) Per curiam F M Quote amici, dismissing their claim about Congress and appointments US v. Donavan (1977) Burger F C deference to Congress, as it is not violating the 4th Amendment Nixon v. Administrator of General Services (1977) Brennan Powell Burger F M C D Quotes Jackson concurrence in Youngstown; branches share powers Dismissive of claim that statute should fall b/c presidency is coequal three references to coequal; Congress and courts not treating pres. as Davis v. Passman (1979) Burger F D courts can’t a member of coequal branch to employ someone US v. Helstoski (1979) Burger F M speech/debate clause designed to preserve coequality Goldwater v. Carter (1979) Rehnquist F C deciding the issue is moot is better than using political questions b/c it disrupts coequality less US v. Gillock (1980) Burger S M Speech/debate clause does not protect state leg. officials Owen v. City of Independence (1980) Brennan S M wrongful termination suit can proceed; deference to Congress’ judgment that city has no immunity Fullilove v. Klutznick (1980) Burger F M deference to Congress’ determination that minorities require remedy to promote the general welfare US v. Will (1980) Burger F M Congress may cancel pay raises scheduled to take effect
Courts%20and%20Coequality%20WPSA%202013.docx