IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Resolutions for CIDs 20082, 20160, 20169 and 20080 on 11ai/D7.0 Date: 2016-05-13 Author(s): Name Company Address Phone email Mark 350 W. Java Dr Ruckus Wireless +1.303.818.8472 Hamilton Sunnyvale, CA 161 Gajeong-dong, Jae Seung ETRI Yuseong-gu, +82 42 860 1326 Lee Daejeon, Korea 350 W. Java Dr Stuart Ruckus Wireless +1.408.348.3171 Sunnyvale, CA 350 W. Java Dr Peat Khoury Ruckus Wireless +1.415.517.8715 Sunnyvale, CA peat@curious-peter-george.com CIDs 20160, 20082, 20080: CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change 20169 98.39 11.1.4.3.2 FILS provides mechanisms to Change "may" to "shall". prevent wasting bandwidth with Throughout the rest of the unnecessary Probe Requests, and document, make it mandatory to Probe Responses that won't be include Max Channel Time field useful to the client STA due to in Probe Requests for FILS STAs. varying criteria. Large bandwidth The onerous implementation costs savings can also be achieved by for Max Channel Time are on the eliminating useless Probe AP, and that has been resolved by Responses that come too late to making the AP response to Max be useful. Channel Time a "should" requirement in the last ballot cycle. 20160 98.39 11.1.4.3.2 Max Channel Time: Change FILS Stay from MAY to SHALL: Comment: FILS provides mechanisms to prevent wasting Make it mandatory to include bandwidth with unnecessary Max Channel Time field in Probe Requests, and Probe Responses Requests for FILS STAs. The that won't be useful to the client onerous implementation costs for STA due to varying criteria. Max Channel Time are on the AP, Large bandwidth savings can also and that has been resolved by be achieved by eliminating making the AP response to Max useless Probe Responses that Channel Time a "should" come too late to be useful. requirement in the last ballot cycle. Align this position throughout the rest of the document.
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Resolutions for CIDs 20082, 20160, 20169 and 20080 on 11ai/D7.0 Date: 2016-05-13 Author(s): Name Company Address Phone email Mark Hamilton Ruckus Wireless 350 W. Java Dr Sunnyvale, CA +1.303.818.8472 Jae Seung Lee ETRI 161 Gajeong-dong, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon, Korea +82 42 860 1326 Stuart Ruckus Wireless 350 W. Java Dr Sunnyvale, CA +1.408.348.3171 Peat Khoury Ruckus Wireless 350 W. Java Dr Sunnyvale, CA +1.415.517.8715 peat@curious-peter-george.com CIDs 20160, 20082, 20080: CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change 20169 98.39 11.1.4.3.2 FILS provides mechanisms to prevent wasting bandwidth with unnecessary Probe Requests, and Probe Responses that won't be useful to the client STA due to varying criteria. Large bandwidth savings can also be achieved by eliminating useless Probe Responses that come too late to be useful. Change "may" to "shall". Throughout the rest of the document, make it mandatory to include Max Channel Time field in Probe Requests for FILS STAs. The onerous implementation costs for Max Channel Time are on the AP, and that has been resolved by making the AP response to Max Channel Time a "should" requirement in the last ballot cycle. 20160 98.39 11.1.4.3.2 Max Channel Time: Comment: FILS provides mechanisms to prevent wasting bandwidth with unnecessary Requests, and Probe Responses that won't be useful to the client STA due to varying criteria. Large bandwidth savings can also be achieved by eliminating useless Probe Responses that come too late to be useful. Change FILS Stay from MAY to SHALL: Make it mandatory to include Max Channel Time field in Probe Requests for FILS STAs. The onerous implementation costs for Max Channel Time are on the AP, and that has been resolved by making the AP response to Max Channel Time a "should" requirement in the last ballot cycle. Align this position throughout the rest of the document.
11-16-0600-03-00ai-resolutions-for-cids-20082-20160-20169-20080.docx