259 Mark 11.46 "When an Add an equivalent Revise TGmd – RISON para for editor to make changes as shown primitive is received in 11-17/1192r4 at the MLME, the that are marked MLME with CID 259 can use the parameters provided in the primitive plus the following information to create estimates of throughput per access category to deliver to the SME in the EstimatedThroughput parameter of the primitive:" -- OK, and how can the MLME determine the to deliver to the SME? 56 11.46 This "Estimated Delete "Entities Revise TGmd – 0 Throughput" is outside the scope editor to make Smith intended to be useful of this standard that changes as in for controlling traffic might control the 11-17/1192r4 that decisions. It does traffic steering are marked with specify how a STA can decision of a device CID 56 slight – inform another STA of benefitby being modifications to the traffic estimates but I able to predict the wording have been am not convinced that throughput that made to reduce the this is of any use for might be obtained expressed level of what it supposed to through a link with certainty of the address. By stating at a STA. Those statements as L51 and L53 that same entities also opposed to the outside entities "need need to know what wholesale deletion to know the current the current proposed by the estimates" we are estimate of commenter, based open to questions of throughput is for on the fact that accuracy and 'how to network selection existing systems do use'. I suggest that purposes (by use parameters these statements are comparing an similar to those removed. estimated listed to make the throughout with decisions described existing in the cited text. throughout)." The commenter intends to bring a related presentation.
259 Mark RISON 11.46 "When an primitive is received at the MLME, the MLME can use the parameters provided in the primitive plus the following information to create estimates of throughput per access category to deliver to the SME in the parameter of the primitive:" -- OK, and how can the MLME determine the to deliver to the SME? Add an equivalent para for Revise – TGmd editor to make changes as shown in 11-17/1192r4 that are marked with CID 259 56 Smith 11.46 This "Estimated Throughput" is intended to be useful for controlling traffic decisions. It does specify how a STA can inform another STA of traffic estimates but I am not convinced that this is of any use for what it supposed to address. By stating at L51 and L53 that outside entities "need to know the current estimates" we are open to questions of accuracy and 'how to use'. I suggest that these statements are removed. Delete "Entities outside the scope of this standard that might control the traffic steering decision of a device benefitby being able to predict the throughput that might be obtained through a link with a STA. Those same entities also need to know what the current estimate of throughput is for network selection purposes (by comparing an estimated throughout with existing throughout)." The commenter intends to bring a related presentation. Revise – TGmd editor to make changes as in 11-17/1192r4 that are marked with CID 56 – slight modifications to the wording have been made to reduce the expressed level of certainty of the statements as opposed to the wholesale deletion proposed by the commenter, based on the fact that existing systems do use parameters similar to those listed to make the decisions described in the cited text. EstimatedThroughput 0
11-17-1192-05-000m-cr-esp.docx