IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Clause 8.4.2.172 Comment Resolutions 2 Date: 2015-08-24 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email SK Yong Apple Inc CID Commenter Clause Page Line Type of Assignee Comment Proposed Change (C) (C) Comment Lei Wang 10 23 T SK What's the usage of the Please specify how the Yong Advertisement ID? Advertisement ID is Searched the entire used. Also, please 11aq/D1.0 doc, did not check if it really needs find any descriptions to be of 4 bytes long. about it, except for the line 23 on page 10. In addition, within one AP, do we really need a 4-byte Advertisement ID? Filip 10 10 E SK "The Service Change to "The Service 1 Mestanov Yong Advertisement element is Advertisement element included in the Probe is included in a Probe Response returned by the Response frame AP in response to a Probe returned by the AP in Request from a non-AP response to a Probe STA" Request frame from a non-AP STA" Filip 10 23 T SK Why is the Reduce the size of the Mestanov Yong "Advertisement ID" a 4 Advertisement ID to 2 octed value? Do we need octets. so many octets? Stephen 10 23 T SK What is the Create some text to McCann Yong "Advertisement ID" as it is define "Advertisment not defined anywhere. It ID" appears to be similar to a service name. Jing-Rong 10 23 T SK "The Advertisement ID 2 octets for 65536 Hsieh Yong field is a 4-octet unsigned services should be integer assigned by the enough. AP." 4-octet seems to be
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Clause 8.4.2.172 Comment Resolutions 2 Date: 2015-08-24 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email SK Yong Apple Inc CID Commenter Clause Page (C) Line (C) Type of Comment Assignee Comment Proposed Change Lei Wang 10 23 T SK Yong What's the usage of the Advertisement ID? Searched the entire 11aq/D1.0 doc, did not find any descriptions about it, except for the line 23 on page 10. In addition, within one AP, do we really need a 4-byte Advertisement ID? Please specify how the Advertisement ID is used. Also, please check if it really needs to be of 4 bytes long. Filip Mestanov 10 10 E SK Yong "The Service Advertisement element is included in the Probe Response returned by the AP in response to a Probe Request from a non-AP STA" Change to "The Service Advertisement element is included in a Probe Response frame returned by the AP in response to a Probe Request frame from a non-AP STA" Filip Mestanov 10 23 T SK Yong Why is the "Advertisement ID" a 4 octed value? Do we need so many octets? Reduce the size of the Advertisement ID to 2 octets. Stephen McCann 10 23 T SK Yong What is the "Advertisement ID" as it is not defined anywhere. It appears to be similar to a service name. Create some text to define "Advertisment ID" Jing-Rong Hsieh 10 23 T SK Yong "The Advertisement ID field is a 4-octet unsigned integer assigned by the AP." 4-octet seems to be 2 octets for 65536 services should be enough. 1
11-15-1157-00-00aq-clause8-4-4-21-comment-resolutions.docx