CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 2251 10.3.2.7 A STA shall not respond add such requirement Revised: DMG DTS to RTS with SU/MU MIMO field set to restriction was inserted: 1 in CT. This interferes with simultaneous CTS from other STAs in the same group Revised Text In order to establish TXOP for transmission of only SISO PPDUs with an EDMG STA, an EDMG STA shall transmit RTS frame with TXVECTOR parameter CH BANDWIDTH set according to rules specified in 10.22.2.12. An EDMG STA transmitting an RTS frame to establish TXOP for the transmission of at least one MIMO PPDU or SISO PPDU with Hybrid BF follows the procedure defined in 10.36.11.4 CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 2253 10.3.2.14 Not clear why add 'or Rejected: Control_trailer' cannot be set to Auther intention is that SISO TXOP Control_trailer shall not be used with Control Trailer and only with Channel_BW. CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 2254 10.3.2.7 How can header-A and CT clarify the Revised: both present? requirement Requirement was removed. To provide complete bandwidth signaling information, the EDMG STA should include a control trailer in the transmitted RTS frame using the procedure specified in 10.36.11.5. An EDMG STA that receives an RTS frame containing a control trailer and that also contains bandwidth signaling in the PHY header shall use the bandwidth signaling contained in the control trailer and ignore the one in the PHY header. CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 1568 10.3.2.14 please add 4.32+4.32 GHz add CBW432+432 Revised: case Definition was changed and doesn’t require the modification 1573 10.3.2.7 please add 4.32+4.32 GHz add CBW432+432 Revised: case
CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 2251 10.3.2.7 A STA shall not respond DMG DTS to RTS with SU/MU MIMO field set to 1 in CT. This interferes with simultaneous CTS from other STAs in the same group add such requirement Revised: restriction was inserted: Revised Text In order to establish TXOP for transmission of only SISO PPDUs with an EDMG STA, an EDMG STA shall transmit RTS frame with TXVECTOR parameter CH BANDWIDTH set according to rules specified in 10.22.2.12. An EDMG STA transmitting an RTS frame to establish TXOP for the transmission of at least one MIMO PPDU or SISO PPDU with Hybrid BF follows the procedure defined in 10.36.11.4 CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 2253 10.3.2.14 Not clear why cannot be set to Control_trailer add 'or Control_trailer' Rejected: Auther intention is that SISO TXOP shall not be used with Control Trailer and only with Channel_BW. CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 2254 10.3.2.7 How can header-A and CT both present? clarify the requirement Revised: Requirement was removed. To provide complete bandwidth signaling information, the EDMG STA should include a control trailer in the transmitted RTS frame using the procedure specified in 10.36.11.5. An EDMG STA that receives an RTS frame containing a control trailer and that also contains bandwidth signaling in the PHY header shall use the bandwidth signaling contained in the control trailer and ignore the one in the PHY header. CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 1568 10.3.2.14 please add 4.32+4.32 GHz case add CBW432+432 Revised: Definition was changed and doesn’t require the modification 1573 10.3.2.7 please add 4.32+4.32 GHz case add CBW432+432 Revised:
11-18-0376-02-00ay-procedures-common-to-the-dcf-and-edcaf-cids.docx