Nothing seems to ever require its presence Proposed Text: Change the sentence in Section 10.1.4.3.2 of TGai D6.2 as follows: (P96L39) A FILS STA may indicate its MaxChannelTime in the Max Channel Time field of the FILS Request Parameters element of the Probe Request frame to prevent the responding STA from transmitting the Probe Response after the time indicated by the MaxChannelTime is elapsed. When the Max Channel Time field of the FILS Request Parameters element of the Probe Request frame is Present, the The Max Channel Time shall be set to the MaxChannelTime of the primitive as defined in 8.4.2.173 (FILS Request Parameters element). Comments (CID 10448) CID Clause Comment Proposed Proposed Change Resolution 10448 8.4.2.173 67 55 "of units of 200 [micro replace 200 --> Rejected seconds]" --- why is 200 100 used as a basis. This seems akward. 100 See the rationale would feel more natural in 11-13/1431 and would make calculations much more easier Discussion on CID 10448 The Max Channel Time field is just 1 octet. If we use units of 100 then the Max Channel Time field can indicate up to 25.5 ms. μs, If we use units of 200 then the Max Channel Time field can indicate up to 51.0 ms. μs, In a very dense environment, it will take more time for channel access by the AP to transmit Probe Responses, and STA may not find some APs if we limit the Max Channel time value less than or equal to 25.5 ms. It is safe to use a little bit larger range, up to 51.0 ms for such dense environment. It is better to use units of 200 to allow enough range for Max Channel Time. μs Comments (CID 10236) CID Clause Comment Proposed Proposed Change Resolution
Nothing seems to ever require its presence Proposed Text: Change the sentence in Section 10.1.4.3.2 of TGai D6.2 as follows: (P96L39) A FILS STA may indicate its MaxChannelTime in the Max Channel Time field of the FILS Request Parameters element of the Probe Request frame to prevent the responding STA from transmitting the Probe Response after the time indicated by the MaxChannelTime is elapsed. When the Max Channel Time field of the FILS Request Parameters element of the Probe Request frame is Present, the The Max Channel Time shall be set to the MaxChannelTime of the primitive as defined in 8.4.2.173 (FILS Request Parameters element). Comments (CID 10448) CID Clause Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution 10448 8.4.2.173 67 55 "of units of 200 [micro seconds]" --- why is 200 used as a basis. This seems akward. 100 would feel more natural and would make calculations much more easier replace 200 --> 100 Rejected See the rationale in 11-13/1431 Discussion on CID 10448 The Max Channel Time field is just 1 octet. If we use units of 100 μs, then the Max Channel Time field can indicate up to 25.5 ms. If we use units of 200 μs, then the Max Channel Time field can indicate up to 51.0 ms. In a very dense environment, it will take more time for channel access by the AP to transmit Probe Responses, and STA may not find some APs if we limit the Max Channel time value less than or equal to 25.5 ms. It is safe to use a little bit larger range, up to 51.0 ms for such dense environment. It is better to use units of 200 μs to allow enough range for Max Channel Time. Comments (CID 10236) CID Clause Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution
11-15-1431-00-00ai-d6-0-comment-resolutions-on-some-cids-in-8-4-2-173-and-10-1-4-3.docx