Motion #1: CID 331 Resolve CID 331 as “Accepted”. Note this incorporates the changes in 11-17/0871r0 <> as agreed on the 2017-05-30 teleconference Moved: Jouni MALINEN 2nd: Mike MONTEMURRO Results: Motion #1: 18-0-0 Motion #1 passes Motion #2: July session and Telecon CIDs Approve the comment resolutions on the Motion A” tab in doc <> and “PHY the for approving” tab in doc <> except CID 123 “Comments MAC-A” tab in 11-17/0927r4 <> “Motion Moved: Stephen MCCANN 2nd: Emily QI Results Motion #2: 17-0-0 Motion #2 Passes Motion #3 LC TIG Comments Resolve CIDs 332, 333, 334, 335 as with a resolution of “Rejected” Comment is for the LC TIG Comment review not the REVmd Comment Collection. Moved: Jon ROSDAHL 2nd: Mike MONTEMURRO Results: Unanimous Motion #3 Passes – Motion #4: 11ai editorial CIDs – Resolve CIDs 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 16, 347, and 348, as with a “Revised” resolution of the text changes in 11-17/1076r2 <> . These “Incorporate changes resolve the comment in the direction suggested by the commenter.” Moved: Emily QI 2nd: Stephen MCCAAN Results Motion #4: Unanimous Motion #4 Passes – Review Schedule Based on the discussion from Monday, Updated Timeline January 2018 Initial WGLB – September 2018 WGLB Recirculation LB –D2.0 February 2019 Form SB Pool – 2019 MEC/MDR done – April 2019 Initial SB – October 2019 Recirculation SB – July 2020 Final WG/EC approval – September 2020 RevCom/SASB approval – Will require off-month ad-hoc meetings Motion Editor – Motion Editor_2 Comments A Motion will be prepared, but need to do later in the day and then we can consider a motion on Jouni’s submission as well. Return to Submission 11-17-906r3 Jouni MALINEN – Continue the review where we left off about page 7. Figure 9-328 should have been 9-320. After review, some minor changes were captured and an R4 was posted for motion.
Motion #1: CID 331 Resolve CID 331 as “Accepted”. Note this incorporates the changes in 11-17/0871r0 <> as agreed on the 2017-05-30 teleconference Moved: Jouni MALINEN 2nd: Mike MONTEMURRO Results: Motion #1: 18-0-0 Motion #1 passes Motion #2: July session and Telecon CIDs Approve the comment resolutions on the “PHY Motion A” tab in doc <> and the “Comments for approving” tab in doc <> except CID 123 “Motion MAC-A” tab in 11-17/0927r4 <> Moved: Stephen MCCANN 2nd: Emily QI Results Motion #2: 17-0-0 Motion #2 Passes Motion #3 LC TIG Comments Resolve CIDs 332, 333, 334, 335 as “Rejected” with a resolution of Comment is for the LC TIG Comment review not the REVmd Comment Collection. Moved: Jon ROSDAHL 2nd: Mike MONTEMURRO Results: Unanimous – Motion #3 Passes Motion #4: – 11ai editorial CIDs Resolve CIDs 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 16, 347, and 348, as “Revised” with a resolution of “Incorporate the text changes in 11-17/1076r2 <> . These changes resolve the comment in the direction suggested by the commenter.” Moved: Emily QI 2nd: Stephen MCCAAN Results Motion #4: Unanimous – Motion #4 Passes Review Schedule Based on the discussion from Monday, Updated Timeline January 2018 – Initial WGLB September 2018 –D2.0 WGLB Recirculation LB February 2019 – Form SB Pool 2019 – MEC/MDR done April 2019 – Initial SB October 2019 – Recirculation SB July 2020 – Final WG/EC approval September 2020 – RevCom/SASB approval Will require off-month ad-hoc meetings Motion – Editor Motion Editor_2 Comments A Motion will be prepared, but need to do later in the day and then we can consider a motion on Jouni’s submission as well. Return to Submission 11-17-906r3 – Jouni MALINEN Continue the review where we left off about page 7. Figure 9-328 should have been 9-320. After review, some minor changes were captured and an R4 was posted for motion.
11-17-0857-00-000m-minutes-revmd-july-2017-berlin.docx