be flexisible in See proposed deployment. change in doc. Suggest to add HE 11-17/0576r2. Beacon Offset in the HE Operation element, or remove this restriction. 9868 Young Hoon 141.38 11.1.3.10 When Beacon As in the Revised. Kwon frames are comment. The Dual transmitted in two Beacon PHY formats, it mechanism is says one of the deleted. format shall be See proposed format. change in doc. However, as 11-17/0576r2. baseline spec. says the beacon frame to be carried in (duplicate) format, it shall be non-HT format instead of non-HE format. Related Comments in Subclause 27.5.2.6.2 5392 Geonjung 173.31 27.5.2.6.2 When an AP uses When an AP uses Revised. Ko the Dual Beacon, a the Dual Beacon, The Dual non-AP STA that the STA should Beacon receives RAPS use the RAPS mechanism is elements from both element from one deleted. Beacon frames of format of Beacon See proposed two PPDU formats frame. change in doc. would initialize its 11-17/0576r2. OBO counter twice. Then the STA may have less probability to access the random access RU than a STA that receives one Beacon frame. 9415 Woojin Ahn 173.31 27.5.2.6.2 A STA might If a STA receives a Revised. receive both normal normal Beacon The Dual Beacon and Dual and a Dual beacon Beacon Beacon. If both of including RAPS mechanism is the two beacons elements, it shall deleted. included RAPS initialize its OBO See proposed elements, the STA and OCW only for change in doc. might reset its OBO the normal Beacon 11-17/0576r2. and OCW twice. Related Comments in Subclause 27.16.2 6179 Jin-Sam 206.39 27.16.2 In case that an AP Please define the Revised. Kwak uses the Dual BSS Color change The Dual Beacon, all of STAs TBTT to be the Beacon associated with the same to all of mechanism is AP should identify STAs in a BSS deleted. the same BSS when the BSS
be flexisible in deployment. Suggest to add HE Beacon Offset in the HE Operation element, or remove this restriction. See proposed change in doc. 11-17/0576r2. 9868 Young Hoon Kwon 141.38 11.1.3.10 When Beacon frames are transmitted in two PHY formats, it says one of the format shall be format. However, as baseline spec. says the beacon frame to be carried in (duplicate) format, it shall be non-HT format instead of non-HE format. As in the comment. Revised. The Dual Beacon mechanism is deleted. See proposed change in doc. 11-17/0576r2. Related Comments in Subclause 27.5.2.6.2 5392 Geonjung Ko 173.31 27.5.2.6.2 When an AP uses the Dual Beacon, a non-AP STA that receives RAPS elements from both Beacon frames of two PPDU formats would initialize its OBO counter twice. Then the STA may have less probability to access the random access RU than a STA that receives one Beacon frame. When an AP uses the Dual Beacon, the STA should use the RAPS element from one format of Beacon frame. Revised. The Dual Beacon mechanism is deleted. See proposed change in doc. 11-17/0576r2. 9415 Woojin Ahn 173.31 27.5.2.6.2 A STA might receive both normal Beacon and Dual Beacon. If both of the two beacons included RAPS elements, the STA might reset its OBO and OCW twice. If a STA receives a normal Beacon and a Dual beacon including RAPS elements, it shall initialize its OBO and OCW only for the normal Beacon Revised. The Dual Beacon mechanism is deleted. See proposed change in doc. 11-17/0576r2. Related Comments in Subclause 27.16.2 6179 Jin-Sam Kwak 206.39 27.16.2 In case that an AP uses the Dual Beacon, all of STAs associated with the AP should identify the same BSS Please define the BSS Color change TBTT to be the same to all of STAs in a BSS when the BSS Revised. The Dual Beacon mechanism is deleted.
11-17-0576-02-00ax-resolutions-for-comments-related-to-extended-range-beacon.docx