CID Commenter Section Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution Use the same 292 Bin Tian 101.13 Why use signficant Rejected. equations and The reason different math to describe the that the equations to describe equation STF, L-LTFwaveform as becomes much from thoise I previous in previous different is to amendments? For amendents. Only handle the example, Eq 26-12 is make necessary HE_TRIG changes to the PPDU different from 22-20 in reflect the delta preamble, in VHT section. In Eq introudced in 11ax which the like boosting and preambles are T_GI_legacypreamble beam_change=0 only term shall be removed. case. transmitted on the same 20MHz channels where data are transmitted. CID Commenter Section Page Comment Proposed Resolution Change 525 Dong Guk 103.35 we agreed that the add the text and Revised. Lim same power per tone as field based on Change to as in the resolution of L-LTF is applied in L-SIG, the PHY Motion CID525 in doc RL-SIG, HE-SIG-A and #144 in IEEE HE-SIG-B fields. But, in D0.1, it does not applied yet. So, It should be applied in description/ equation of L-SIG, HE-SIG-A and fields 904 Junghoon 101.49 The first column of Q in Revised. Suh 3 Change to as in matrix is always used in -->m the resolution of Eqn (26-14) should be 0? CID904 in doc Because the 1st column of Q matrix is always used here, and N_STS,total is always 1 906 Junghoon 102.33 The first column of Q in Revised. Suh Change to as in matrix is always used in -->m the resolution of Eqn (26-16) should be 0? CID906 in doc Because the 1st column of Q matrix is always used here, and N_STS,total is always 1
CID Commenter Section Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution 292 Bin Tian 101.13 Why use signficant different math equations to describe L-LTFwaveform from thoise I previous amendments? For example, Eq 26-12 is different from 22-20 in VHT section. In Eq the T_GI_legacypreamble term shall be removed. Use the same equations and to describe the as in previous amendents. Only make necessary changes to the reflect the delta introudced in 11ax like boosting and beam_change=0 case. Rejected. The reason that the equation becomes much different is to handle the HE_TRIG PPDU preamble, in which preambles are only transmitted on the same 20MHz channels where data are transmitted. CID Commenter Section Page Comment Proposed Change Resolution 525 Dong Guk Lim 103.35 we agreed that the same power per tone as L-LTF is applied in L-SIG, RL-SIG, HE-SIG-A and HE-SIG-B fields. But, in D0.1, it does not applied yet. So, It should be applied in description/ equation of L-SIG, HE-SIG-A and fields add the text and field based on the PHY Motion #144 in IEEE Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID525 in doc 904 Junghoon Suh 101.49 The first column of Q matrix is always used in Eqn (26-14) in -->m should be 0? Because the 1st column of Q matrix is always used here, and N_STS,total is always 1 Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID904 in doc 906 Junghoon Suh 102.33 The first column of Q matrix is always used in Eqn (26-16) in -->m should be 0? Because the 1st column of Q matrix is always used here, and N_STS,total is always 1 Revised. Change to as in the resolution of CID906 in doc STF, 3
11-16-0937-04-00ax-11ax-comment-resolutions-for-clauses-26-3-2-26-3-9-3-26-3-9-4-26-3-9-5-26-3-10-2-26-3-10-13.docx