2052 Asai, 112.21 22.2.2 CBW160 and Change Agree. See PHY Yusuke CBW80+80 are "CBW160/80+80" 11/954r1 individually defined to "CBW160, or and there is no CBW80+80". definition of "CBW160/80+80". 3391 Rosdahl, 112.21 22.2.2 Are CBW160 and Clarify Agree. See PHY Jon CBW80+80 really 11/954r1 intended to be merged in the enum here, unlike everywhere else? Change: CH_BANDWIDTH_IN_NON_HT FORMAT is When present, Y Y NON_HT indicates the channel of the transmitted packet which is signalled via the scrambling sequence. Enumerated type: CBW20, CBW40, CBW80, CBW16080+80 Otherwise Not present N N 2305 Grandhi, 112.38 22.2.2 The Replace line Accept in principle. PHY Sudheer LENGTH with "This Reorder the language so Value is parameter is the NDP/non-NDP placed in placed in the choice happens first, the VHT-SIG-B then a Length field TXVECTOr/RXVECTOR Length rounded up to choice, then updated field for all a 4 octet details of the frames boundary with parameters. See except the the low order 11/954r1 NDP two bits frame. removed except in the case of an NDP frame".
2052 Asai, Yusuke 112.21 22.2.2 CBW160 and CBW80+80 are individually defined and there is no definition of "CBW160/80+80". Change "CBW160/80+80" to "CBW160, or CBW80+80". Agree. See 11/954r1 PHY 3391 Rosdahl, Jon 112.21 22.2.2 Are CBW160 and CBW80+80 really intended to be merged in the enum here, unlike everywhere else? Clarify Agree. See 11/954r1 PHY Change: CH_BANDWIDTH_IN_NON_HT FORMAT is NON_HT When present, indicates the channel of the transmitted packet which is signalled via the scrambling sequence. Enumerated type: CBW20, CBW40, CBW80, CBW16080+80 Y Y Otherwise Not present N N 2305 Grandhi, Sudheer 112.38 22.2.2 The LENGTH Value is placed in the Length field for all frames except the NDP frame. Replace line with "This parameter is placed in the VHT-SIG-B Length field rounded up to a 4 octet boundary with the low order two bits removed except in the case of an NDP frame". Accept in principle. Reorder the language so the NDP/non-NDP choice happens first, then a TXVECTOr/RXVECTOR choice, then updated details of the parameters. See 11/954r1 PHY
11-11-0954-01-00ac-d1-comment-resolution-brianh-part2.docx