mechanism rather than mechanisms. 723 27 55 The TWT Harmonize Revised may be clause signaled to 25.13.2 and Agreed in principle and revised the text to provide the details of contain at this clause to signalling in the TWT element. least one RU use the same for random power save TGax Editor to make the changes as in access. The mechanisms clause for the v0.docx 25.13.2 is random not using access. TWTs to specify when the UL MU Random access is in use. Please harmonize the both clauses to use the same mechanism. 779 67 3 The power Combine the Revised save power save mechanism mechanisms There is no need for 2 separate Cascaded bits as for UL for OFDMA proposed by the Commenter. The save OFDMA random mechanism need not be differentiated for and looks very access and unassociated STAs with respect to random access similar to the TWT. procedure. The value in the TWT Flow Identifier TWT The random subfield in the TWT element distinguishes the TWT mechanism. access is SP for random access operation or for scheduled Why two used by the operation. This subclause is mainly needed to similar illustrate the power save for random access, while mechanisms associated reference is made to TWT element for signalling of are needed? STAs, so it start time of Trigger frames for random access. coudl make sense if there TGax Editor to make the changes as in are two separate access_v0.docx Cascaded bits, one for random access and other for the TWT SPs and trigger frames. 780 67 43 The power Clarify more Revised save rules clearly when when an HE the STA TGax Editor to make the changes as in STA may go should or
mechanism rather than mechanisms. 723 27 55 The TWT may be signaled to contain at least one RU for random access. The clause 25.13.2 is not using TWTs to specify when the UL MU Random access is in use. Please harmonize the both clauses to use the same mechanism. Harmonize clause 25.13.2 and this clause to use the same power save mechanisms for the random access. Revised Agreed in principle and revised the text to provide the details of signalling in the TWT element. TGax Editor to make the changes as in v0.docx 779 67 3 The power save mechanism for UL OFDMA looks very similar to TWT mechanism. Why two similar mechanisms are needed? Combine the power save mechanisms for OFDMA random access and the TWT. The random access is used by the STAs, so it coudl make sense if there are two separate Cascaded bits, one for random access and other for the TWT SPs and trigger frames. Revised There is no need for 2 separate Cascaded bits as proposed by the Commenter. The save mechanism need not be differentiated for associated and unassociated STAs with respect to random access procedure. The value in the TWT Flow Identifier subfield in the TWT element distinguishes the TWT SP for random access operation or for scheduled operation. This subclause is mainly needed to illustrate the power save for random access, while reference is made to TWT element for signalling of start time of Trigger frames for random access. TGax Editor to make the changes as in access_v0.docx 780 67 43 The power save rules when an HE STA may go Clarify more clearly when the STA should or Revised TGax Editor to make the changes as in
11-16-1458-00-00ax-comment-resolution-for-sub-clause-25-13-2.docx