Accept Proposed resolution: 5119 8.3.1.2 595 61 T Y The The sentence sentence "The TA should be field is the rewritten for address of clarity. the STA Propose transmitting "The TA the RTS field is the frame or a address of bandwidth the STA signaling transmitting TA" gives the RTS the frame, impression except that that for a VHT bandwidth STA this signaling field can be TA is also used as a applicable bandwidth for other signaling types of TA". The STAs, such other as DMG subclauses STA. The should also following be clarified sentence in accordingly. the same paragraph does not help, because it makes no mention to other types of STAs. The same situation happens in 8.3.1.5, 8.3.1.8.1, 8.3.1.9.1 Proposed resolution: Accept 5120 8.7.1 1231 1 T Y The definition of this Insert "When transmitted MPDU Length (14 bits) by a non-DMG STA," at in this para and next is the start of the only applicable to paragraph. Clarify the STAs. same in the next paragraph Proposed resolution: Accept
Proposed resolution: Accept 5119 8.3.1.2 595 61 T Y The sentence "The TA field is the address of the STA transmitting the RTS frame or a bandwidth signaling TA" gives the impression that bandwidth signaling TA is also applicable for other types of STAs, such as DMG STA. The following sentence in the same paragraph does not help, because it makes no mention to other types of STAs. The same situation happens in 8.3.1.5, 8.3.1.8.1, 8.3.1.9.1 The sentence should be rewritten for clarity. Propose "The TA field is the address of the STA transmitting the RTS frame, except that for a VHT STA this field can be used as a bandwidth signaling TA". The other subclauses should also be clarified accordingly. Proposed resolution: Accept 5120 8.7.1 1231 1 T Y The definition of this MPDU Length (14 bits) in this para and next is only applicable to STAs. Insert "When transmitted by a non-DMG STA," at the start of the paragraph. Clarify the same in the next paragraph Proposed resolution: Accept
11-15-0534-00-000m-resolution-to-11ad-related-cids.docx