5835 Huizhao 73.16 Deliver sounding Remove: "Frames Reject nothing in – Wang 0 feedback in TWT SP that are sent as the statements time may impact the part of a sounding here suggest that performance of HE feedback exchange the sounding TxBF. The sounding (see 27.6 (HE frames were sent at feedback carries the sounding any significant time channel matrix protocol))" preceding the information of the delivery of the moment of sounding feedback. It is NDP is received, need much more to timely delivered to probable that the the beamformer TWT is for PS STA without delay, so using which are only TWT SP time to waking at the TWT deliver it will likely SP and therefore, cause extra delays. the sounding PPDUs are transmitted in the same TWT SP as the feedback. Even if sounding were in one SP and FB in a later one, that is an implementation choice. 5836 73.42 Deliver sounding remove: "Frames Reject nothing in Huizhao – Wang 0 feedback in TWT SP that are sent as the statements time may impact the part of a sounding here suggest that performance of HE feedback exchange the sounding TxBF. The sounding (see 27.6 (HE frames were sent at feedback carries the sounding any significant time channel matrix protocol))" preceding the information of the delivery of the moment of sounding feedback. It is NDP is received, need much more to timely delivered to probable that the the beamformer TWT is for PS STA without delay, so using which are only TWT waking at the TWT SP and therefore, the sounding PPDUs are transmitted in the same TWT SP as the feedback. Even if sounding were in one SP and FB in a later one, that is an implementation choice. 5892 James 69.69 Here and elsewhere, As suggested. Revise generally – Yee 0 is 1" should be agree with "field is set to 1" comment - TGax editor shall make the changes shown in 11-17/0777r5 that are marked with CID 5892.
5835 Huizhao Wang 73.16 Deliver sounding feedback in TWT SP time may impact the performance of HE TxBF. The sounding feedback carries the channel matrix information of the moment of sounding NDP is received, need to timely delivered to the beamformer without delay, so using TWT SP time to deliver it will likely cause extra delays. Remove: "Frames that are sent as part of a sounding feedback exchange (see 27.6 (HE sounding protocol))" Reject – nothing in the statements here suggest that the sounding frames were sent at any significant time preceding the delivery of the feedback. It is much more probable that the TWT is for PS STA which are only waking at the TWT SP and therefore, the sounding PPDUs are transmitted in the same TWT SP as the feedback. Even if sounding were in one SP and FB in a later one, that is an implementation choice. 5836 Huizhao Wang 73.42 Deliver sounding feedback in TWT SP time may impact the performance of HE TxBF. The sounding feedback carries the channel matrix information of the moment of sounding NDP is received, need to timely delivered to the beamformer without delay, so using TWT remove: "Frames that are sent as part of a sounding feedback exchange (see 27.6 (HE sounding protocol))" Reject – nothing in the statements here suggest that the sounding frames were sent at any significant time preceding the delivery of the feedback. It is much more probable that the TWT is for PS STA which are only waking at the TWT SP and therefore, the sounding PPDUs are transmitted in the same TWT SP as the feedback. Even if sounding were in one SP and FB in a later one, that is an implementation choice. 5892 James Yee 69.69 Here and elsewhere, is 1" should be "field is set to 1" As suggested. Revise – generally agree with comment - TGax editor shall make the changes shown in 11-17/0777r5 that are marked with CID 5892. 0 0 0
11-17-0777-05-00ax-cr-twt-ie.docx