CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 196 53.20 20 It is not clear how the secondary Define the secondary channels for channel is defined for EDMG channel bonding supported STAs BSS, especially considering there and channel aggregation supported are two types of communication STAs. Define the related modes: channel bonding and indications for the sencondary channel aggregation. channel. 450 10.01 Figure 3 --The channel-list Add few more figures to illustrate parameter element for 4.32 GHz, missed or provide relevant text 6.48 GHz and 8.64 GHz channel to make it clear. illustrates cases with primary channel on the edge. The primary channel may reside in the middle as well. Discussion: Contribution 11-17/0865 adopted in D0.4 addresses those two comments. With new definition, the issue raised by the comment is resolved as follow: The location of the Secondary, Secondary1, Secondary2 channels depends the location of the Primary channel which is diffrenciate by the indication. EDMG Primary Channel Offset Below are diagram that shows the locations of secondaries channgels in case of channel bonding. The channel-list parameter for 4.32 GHz, 6.48 GHz and 8.64 GHz channel width for EDMG Primary Channel Offset=0 The channel-list parameter for 4.32GHz, 6.48GHz and 8.64GHz channel width when EDMG Primary Channel Offset=1 The channel-list parameter element for 2.16+2.16 GHz and 4.32+4.32 GHz channel width Proposed resolution: Reject CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 212 12.00 9.3.1.3.1 Since the subfield is not used by other BA Replace last sentence Types, then why not leave it as reserved in with "This subfield is those cases. reserved if the BlockAck variant used is not EDMG Multi-TID BlockAck variant" 449 12.04 "The Management ACK subfield is set to "In EDMG Multi-TID one to indicate that frames of type BlockAck variant the Management that are not Action No Ack are Management ACK acknowledged. Otherwise, it is set to zero. If subfield is set to one to
CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 196 53.20 20 It is not clear how the secondary channel is defined for EDMG BSS, especially considering there are two types of communication modes: channel bonding and channel aggregation. Define the secondary channels for channel bonding supported STAs and channel aggregation supported STAs. Define the related indications for the sencondary channel. 450 10.01 Figure 3 --The channel-list parameter element for 4.32 GHz, 6.48 GHz and 8.64 GHz channel illustrates cases with primary channel on the edge. The primary channel may reside in the middle as well. Add few more figures to illustrate missed or provide relevant text to make it clear. Discussion: Contribution 11-17/0865 adopted in D0.4 addresses those two comments. With new definition, the issue raised by the comment is resolved as follow: The location of the Secondary, Secondary1, Secondary2 channels depends the location of the Primary channel which is diffrenciate by the EDMG Primary Channel Offset indication. Below are diagram that shows the locations of secondaries channgels in case of channel bonding. The channel-list parameter for 4.32 GHz, 6.48 GHz and 8.64 GHz channel width for EDMG Primary Channel Offset=0 The channel-list parameter for 4.32GHz, 6.48GHz and 8.64GHz channel width when EDMG Primary Channel Offset=1 The channel-list parameter element for 2.16+2.16 GHz and 4.32+4.32 GHz channel width Proposed resolution: Reject CID Clause Page Comment Proposed change 212 12.00 9.3.1.3.1 Since the subfield is not used by other BA Types, then why not leave it as reserved in those cases. Replace last sentence with "This subfield is reserved if the BlockAck variant used is not EDMG Multi-TID BlockAck variant" 449 12.04 "The Management ACK subfield is set to one to indicate that frames of type Management that are not Action No Ack are acknowledged. Otherwise, it is set to zero. If "In EDMG Multi-TID BlockAck variant the Management ACK subfield is set to one to
11-17-1230-00-00ay-resolution-to-11ay-related-cids.docx