239 6.33 4.3.23.3 "Reasons for such selective Please clarify what situation is Revise: for such “Reasons reception include the MAC assumed here. selective reception include the service requirement that, when MAC service requirement an MSDU is sent, it is not that, when an MSDU is sent, it returned to and processed by is not returned to and the transmitting station." processed by the transmitting station” -> reason for “The such selective reception is to support requirements of It is not clear to me in what 802.1Q bridges, and can situation is assumed here. In include the MAC service the IEEE 802.11-2012 clause requirement that, when an 9.3.6, the transmission MSDU is sent, it is not procedure of group address subsequently received and frames is specified which is processed by the transmitting not consistent with the above station”. Commentor can text. review 11-12/1441r1 for discussions. 258 6.33 4.3.23.3 "Reasons for such selective Please explain clearly what Reject: Dup CID239 reception include the MAC situation is assumed here. service requirement that, when an MSDU is sent, it is not returned to and processed by the transmitting station." Its situation should be clarified. It is not clear if the transmission procedure of group address frames specified in the IEEE clause 9.3.6 is included in the above explanation. 295 8.19 4.3.23.4.3 The subset of STAs to Change "an arbitrary" to "a Revise: GLK AP be able “the received a group addressed is specific". to transmit them so that they not arbitrary, it's a specifc are accepted by an arbitrary subset as defined in the subset of the associated GLK SYNRA. STAs” -> GLK AP must “the be willing to transmit MSDUs so that they are accepted by an arbitrary subset of the associated GLK STAs, as provided by the 802.1Q bridge”.
239 6.33 4.3.23.3 "Reasons for such selective reception include the MAC service requirement that, when an MSDU is sent, it is not returned to and processed by the transmitting station." It is not clear to me in what situation is assumed here. In the IEEE 802.11-2012 clause 9.3.6, the transmission procedure of group address frames is specified which is not consistent with the above text. Please clarify what situation is assumed here. Revise: “Reasons for such selective reception include the MAC service requirement that, when an MSDU is sent, it is not returned to and processed by the transmitting station” -> “The reason for such selective reception is to support requirements of 802.1Q bridges, and can include the MAC service requirement that, when an MSDU is sent, it is not subsequently received and processed by the transmitting station”. Commentor can review 11-12/1441r1 for discussions. 258 6.33 4.3.23.3 "Reasons for such selective reception include the MAC service requirement that, when an MSDU is sent, it is not returned to and processed by the transmitting station." Its situation should be clarified. It is not clear if the transmission procedure of group address frames specified in the IEEE clause 9.3.6 is included in the above explanation. Please explain clearly what situation is assumed here. Reject: Dup CID239 295 8.19 4.3.23.4.3 The subset of STAs to received a group addressed is not arbitrary, it's a specifc subset as defined in the SYNRA. Change "an arbitrary" to "a specific". Revise: “the GLK AP be able to transmit them so that they are accepted by an arbitrary subset of the associated GLK STAs” -> “the GLK AP must be willing to transmit MSDUs so that they are accepted by an arbitrary subset of the associated GLK STAs, as provided by the 802.1Q bridge”.
11-15-0795-09-00ak-addressing-comment-resolutions.docx