IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs LB232 CID1543 Proposed Comment Resolution – Date: 2018-09-12 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Marc SELF; Berlin, Germany Emmelmann Koden-TI Hitoshi 2-14-38 Tenjin, Chuo-ku, SRC Software Morioka Fukuoka 810-001 JAPAN CID 1543 CID Clause Page Comment Proposed Change Number(C) 1543 9.4.2.182 1280.01 "The AP verifies that the Delete step 2) at 2301.42 and extracted source MAC address the bullet at 2302.21. In is equal to the source MAC Figure 9-634 delete the address of Source MAC Address and Destination MAC Address the (Re)Association frame. If fields. In 9.4.2.182 delete the these are different, the AP penultimate paragraph. shall discard the FILS HLP Container element;" -- so there's no point passing the source MAC address, since the transmitter will always ensure they are the same (why bother sending something you know the other end will discard?) Discussion Note: P1280.01 refers to D1.0 which is in D1.4 on page 1337. Also, the clause number in D1.4 has changed from xxx.182 to xxx.183. Context: D1.4 P1337
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs LB232 CID1543 – Proposed Comment Resolution Date: 2018-09-12 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Marc Emmelmann SELF; Koden-TI Berlin, Germany Hitoshi Morioka SRC Software 2-14-38 Tenjin, Chuo-ku, Fukuoka 810-001 JAPAN CID 1543 CID Clause Number(C) Page Comment Proposed Change 1543 9.4.2.182 1280.01 "The AP verifies that the extracted source MAC address is equal to the source MAC address of the (Re)Association frame. If these are different, the AP shall discard the FILS HLP Container element;" -- so there's no point passing the source MAC address, since the transmitter will always ensure they are the same (why bother sending something you know the other end will discard?) Delete step 2) at 2301.42 and the bullet at 2302.21. In Figure 9-634 delete the Source MAC Address and Destination MAC Address fields. In 9.4.2.182 delete the penultimate paragraph. Discussion Note: P1280.01 refers to D1.0 which is in D1.4 on page 1337. Also, the clause number in D1.4 has changed from xxx.182 to xxx.183. Context: D1.4 P1337
11-18-1614-01-000m-lb232-cid1543.docx