CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change 1010 113.27 10.22.2.12 Idle channel In Table 20 is Change "Primary" to "None", "First secondary incorrect. channel" to "Primary channel", "Second secondary channel" to "Primary channel and first secondary channel", and "Third secondary channel" to "Primary channel, first secondary channel and second secondary channel". 1012 114.20 10.22.2.12 If the action d) is allowed Define additional channel-list parameters. For even if secondary or example, define "secondary_secondary1" secondary1 channel is which indicates that the secondary and the busy, for example, secondary1 are busy, and the primary and the primary and secondary2 secondary2 are idle. Similarly, are idle whereas "secondary_secondary2", secondary and secondary1 "secondary1_secondary2" and is busy, the channel-list "secondary_secondary1_secondary2" might parameter should be have to be defined. In that case, the extended to define parameter "secondary" should indicate that busy/idle patterns of all only the secondary 2.16GHz channel is busy, subchannels. i.e. the primary, secondary1 and secondary2 are idle. Alternatively, bitmap-type channel-list parameter may be used, like per20MHzbitmap in 802.11ax-D2.0. Proposed resolution: revised Discussion: There is the mismatch definition of Table 20 (Channels indicated idle by the channel-list parameter) and Table 8-5 (The channel-list parameter elements) in the current draft. Table 8-5 The channel-list parameter elements — channel-list Meaning parameter
CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change 1010 113.27 10.22.2.12 Idle channel In Table 20 is incorrect. Change "Primary" to "None", "First secondary channel" to "Primary channel", "Second secondary channel" to "Primary channel and first secondary channel", and "Third secondary channel" to "Primary channel, first secondary channel and second secondary channel". 1012 114.20 10.22.2.12 If the action d) is allowed even if secondary or secondary1 channel is busy, for example, primary and secondary2 are idle whereas secondary and secondary1 is busy, the channel-list parameter should be extended to define busy/idle patterns of all subchannels. Define additional channel-list parameters. For example, define "secondary_secondary1" which indicates that the secondary and the secondary1 are busy, and the primary and the secondary2 are idle. Similarly, "secondary_secondary2", "secondary1_secondary2" and "secondary_secondary1_secondary2" might have to be defined. In that case, the parameter "secondary" should indicate that only the secondary 2.16GHz channel is busy, i.e. the primary, secondary1 and secondary2 are idle. Alternatively, bitmap-type channel-list parameter may be used, like per20MHzbitmap in 802.11ax-D2.0. Proposed resolution: revised Discussion: There is the mismatch definition of Table 20 (Channels indicated idle by the channel-list parameter) and Table 8-5 (The channel-list parameter elements) in the current draft. Table 8-5 — The channel-list parameter elements channel-list parameter Meaning
11-18-0840-01-00ay-comment-resolutions-for-edmg-channel-access-cids.docx