5980 Jarkko It is unclear whether Please clarify Rejected- Kneckt BQRP Trigger variant is a STA that that allocates RUs for detects RUs A STA who detects RU that is random access for random allocated for OFDMA random requires that a HE access access in BQRP Trigger trigger-based PPDU required to variant doesn’t have to use transmitted in the RU transmit BQR OFDMA random access if it for random access reports in a has been named in other contains a BQR RUs. information in the PPDU Control field. in a RU TGax editor no changes allocated for on CID 5980. random access. Please clarify is the same requirement used for other Trigger variants as well? 5981 Jarkko The non-AP STA The non-AP Revised- Kneckt should not be forced STAs to perform random transmission Agree in principle. Per access. The use of in the RUs resolution of CID 5182, add random access for allocated for qualifier to regulate when a the BQR transmission random STA can use OFDMA random should be voluntary access access to report the BQR. for the STAs. If all should be STAs are required to optional. TGax editor makes no transmit BQR in Change the changes on CID 5981. random access when wording to a Trigger contains say that if random access RUs, RUs for the power random consumption of hte access are STA increases included a unnecessarily and non-AP STA transmisison may overhead in random respond... access becomes high. 5982 Jarkko The BQR support in delete the Rejected- Kneckt AP and STA is end of hte already described in sentence. BQR is optional function for 35 -39. The Delete:"when AP and STA, it is necessary second bullet has a the AP has to have these sentence to lot of repetition. indicated...". clarify the condition that BQR can be used. TGax makes no changes on CID 5982.
5980 Jarkko Kneckt It is unclear whether BQRP Trigger variant that allocates RUs for random access requires that a HE trigger-based PPDU transmitted in the RU for random access contains a BQR information in the field. Please clarify is a STA that detects RUs for random access required to transmit BQR reports in a PPDU in a RU allocated for random access. Please clarify is the same requirement used for other Trigger variants as well? Rejected- A STA who detects RU that is allocated for OFDMA random access in BQRP Trigger variant doesn’t have to use OFDMA random access if it has been named in other RUs. TGax editor no changes on CID 5980. 5981 Jarkko Kneckt The non-AP STA should not be forced to perform random access. The use of random access for the BQR transmission should be voluntary for the STAs. If all STAs are required to transmit BQR in random access when a Trigger contains random access RUs, the power consumption of hte STA increases unnecessarily and transmisison overhead in random access becomes high. The non-AP STAs transmission in the RUs allocated for random access should be optional. Change the wording to say that if RUs for random access are included a non-AP STA may respond... Revised- Agree in principle. Per resolution of CID 5182, add qualifier to regulate when a STA can use OFDMA random access to report the BQR. TGax editor makes no changes on CID 5981. 5982 Jarkko Kneckt The BQR support in AP and STA is already described in 35 -39. The second bullet has a lot of repetition. delete the end of hte sentence. Delete:"when the AP has indicated...". Rejected- BQR is optional function for AP and STA, it is necessary to have these sentence to clarify the condition that BQR can be used. TGax makes no changes on CID 5982. Control
11-17-1286-01-00ax-cr-dl-mu-procedure.docx