411 T Insufficient comment Provide a sufficient resolution does not detail resolution for all the changes to the draft, comments of the e.g. "REVISED. previous ballot. A See details in resolution has to corresponding allow a balloter to submission." does not identify clearly the specify the corresponding changes made to the document nor does it draft in response to a specify the changes made specific comment. to the draft Proposed resolution: Revised. The document number of the submission that contains the resolution to a comment is shown in the column in the LB217 comments database 11-16/0193r4. “Submission” As noted in the comment, in order to make the resolution more clear and easy to learn the changes made to the draft, the comments database 11-16/0193r4 for LB217 is updated to 11-16/0193r5. Thanks the commenter’s reminder. CID Comment Proposed Remark Change 418 47 11 T CDMG MCS index range Change "0-35" to should be 0 to 23 because "0-23". Fix the OFDM mode is removed from similar errors 11aj. throughout the draft. Proposed resolution: Accepted. The OFDM mode is removed from 11aj, so the CDMG MCS index range needs to be changed from "0-35" to "0-23". CID Comment Proposed Remark Change
411 T Insufficient comment resolution does not detail the changes to the draft, e.g. "REVISED. See details in corresponding submission." does not specify the corresponding document nor does it specify the changes made to the draft Provide a sufficient resolution for all comments of the previous ballot. A resolution has to allow a balloter to identify clearly the changes made to the draft in response to a specific comment. Proposed resolution: Revised. The document number of the submission that contains the resolution to a comment is shown in the column “Submission” in the LB217 comments database 11-16/0193r4. As noted in the comment, in order to make the resolution more clear and easy to learn the changes made to the draft, the comments database 11-16/0193r4 for LB217 is updated to 11-16/0193r5. Thanks the commenter’s reminder. CID Comment Proposed Change Remark 418 47 11 T CDMG MCS index range should be 0 to 23 because OFDM mode is removed from 11aj. Change "0-35" to "0-23". Fix the similar errors throughout the draft. Proposed resolution: Accepted. The OFDM mode is removed from 11aj, so the CDMG MCS index range needs to be changed from "0-35" to "0-23". CID Comment Proposed Change Remark
11-16-0972-01-00aj-proposed-resolution-to-cid-401-402-408-416-423-424-427-431-436-437-404-406-407-409-410-411-418-419-422-425-426-and-428-in-lb220.docx