IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Resolution to CIDs related to MU BA and RD Date: 2018-07-09 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Ilya Bolotin ilya.bolotin@intel.com Oren CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change 1762 106.17 10.3.2.10 In Figure 84, "QoS Data frame" In Figure 84, replace "QoS Data should be "A-MPDU subframe". frame" with "A-MPDU subframe". Proposed resolution: Revised Discussion: The paragraph the figure says: example of an A-MPDU transmitted in an EDMG MU PPDU is “An shown in Figure 84”. So Figure 84 introduces only an example but not the general case. In this example A-MPDU subframes are QoS Data frames. Clarification for Ack Policy value of QoS Data frames was added (see proposed text below). CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change 1960 37.05 9.3.1.23 EOF field is already presented in Remove EOF in the Figure 11 and the delimiter and provides any remove text in lines 5, 6 on P37 relevant functionality, No need to duplicate the field. (9.7.1 Remove sentence that starts with MPDU format) "The MU-MIMO initiator shall set the EOF..." at P105L38
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs Resolution to CIDs related to MU BA and RD Date: 2018-07-09 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Ilya Bolotin ilya.bolotin@intel.com Oren CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change 1762 106.17 10.3.2.10 In Figure 84, "QoS Data frame" should be "A-MPDU subframe". In Figure 84, replace "QoS Data frame" with "A-MPDU subframe". Proposed resolution: Revised Discussion: The paragraph the figure says: “An example of an A-MPDU transmitted in an EDMG MU PPDU is shown in Figure 84”. So Figure 84 introduces only an example but not the general case. In this example A-MPDU subframes are QoS Data frames. Clarification for Ack Policy value of QoS Data frames was added (see proposed text below). CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change 1960 37.05 9.3.1.23 EOF field is already presented in the delimiter and provides any relevant functionality, No need to duplicate the field. (9.7.1 format) Remove EOF in the Figure 11 and remove text in lines 5, 6 on P37 Remove sentence that starts with "The MU-MIMO initiator shall set the EOF..." at P105L38 MPDU
11-18-0757-02-00ay-resolution-of-cids-related-to-mu-ba-and-rd.docx