IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs CR for CID 1949 Date: 2018-4-25 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email 202 Bedok South Avenue Wee 1, #02-11, Singapore Panasonic 469332 Hiroyuki Motozuka Solomon Trainin Qualcomm strainin@qti.qualcomm.com Carlos Cordeiro Intel carlos.cordeiro@intel.com CID Page Line Comment Proposed Proposed Change Resolution 1949 39 2 In the draft Keep the Revised text the Figure 9-61 Figure 9-61 as is and Keep figures does not provide cover additional figure that Add text to clarify and the is EDMG that non-EDMG Figure 12 specific STA ignores the makes no that may Unsolicited RSS sense to define B14 Enabled subfield. DMG and Next Also that EDMG devices due A-BFT STA ignores this to only subfield when "Unsolicited received from a RSS non-EDMG STA. Enabled field" that is Additionally, add not text to clarify that backward the compatible IsResponderTXSS subfield is present only when Next A-BFT is zero. Note 1 - the unsolicited RSS as defined in 10.39.6.2 is only performed between two
IEEE P802.11 Wireless LANs CR for CID 1949 Date: 2018-4-25 Author(s): Name Affiliation Address Phone email Wee Panasonic 202 Bedok South Avenue 1, #02-11, Singapore 469332 Hiroyuki Motozuka Solomon Trainin Qualcomm strainin@qti.qualcomm.com Carlos Cordeiro Intel carlos.cordeiro@intel.com CID Page Line Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution 1949 39 2 In the draft text the Figure 9-61 does not cover and the Figure 12 makes no sense to DMG devices due to "Unsolicited RSS Enabled field" that is not backward compatible Keep the Figure 9-61 as is and provide additional figure that is EDMG specific that may define B14 and Next A-BFT only Revised Keep figures Add text to clarify that non-EDMG STA ignores the Unsolicited RSS Enabled subfield. Also that EDMG STA ignores this subfield when received from a non-EDMG STA. Additionally, add text to clarify that the IsResponderTXSS subfield is present only when Next A-BFT is zero. Note 1 - the unsolicited RSS as defined in 10.39.6.2 is only performed between two
11-18-0636-04-00ay-cr-for-cid-1949.docx