UPLINK: It matches to Indication” in the PHY SIG field. So, it needs to change its name into “Uplink “UPLINK_INDICATION” It matches to which is included in in the PHY SIG field. COLOR: “COLOR” “ID” 1795 G 240.34 24.2.2 In 24-1, parameter Add ACCEPT. FORMAT should also "S1G_DUP_2M have S1G_DUP_2M in indicates S1G Please refer to Kumar list of enumerated types 2MHz Duplicate doc. 14/XXXXr0. in Value column PPDU format" as the item in the enumerated list in Value Column <Discussion> S1G_DUP_2M could not be shown in the table of draft 1.0~1.2 due to not enough size of the row, though it already has been in the table. So, I tried to make the size of the row enough to have S1G_DUP_2M. 2554 Mitsuru 240.00 24.2.2 Minho Table 20-1 and/or Remove all REJECT. Iwaoka Table 22-1 are referred 'otherwise' rows in in multiple 'otherwise' Table 24-1. rows of Table 24-1. Please refer to They are parameters doc. 14/XXXXr0. for an HT or VHT STA and not applicable to an Including otherwise S1G STA. for other FORMAT The all PPDU format parameter has been supported in the S1G long used in the STA is listed, and no previous drafts such 'otherwise' condition 802.11ac and exists. 802.11af.
UPLINK: It matches to “Uplink Indication” in the PHY SIG field. So, it needs to change its name into “UPLINK_INDICATION” COLOR: It matches to “COLOR” which is included in “ID” in the PHY SIG field. 1795 G Kumar 240.34 24.2.2 In 24-1, parameter FORMAT should also have S1G_DUP_2M in list of enumerated types in Value column Add "S1G_DUP_2M indicates S1G 2MHz Duplicate PPDU format" as the item in the enumerated list in Value Column ACCEPT. Please refer to doc. 14/XXXXr0. <Discussion> S1G_DUP_2M could not be shown in the table of draft 1.0~1.2 due to not enough size of the row, though it already has been in the table. So, I tried to make the size of the row enough to have S1G_DUP_2M. 2554 Mitsuru Iwaoka 240.00 24.2.2 Minho Table 20-1 and/or Table 22-1 are referred in multiple 'otherwise' rows of Table 24-1. They are parameters for an HT or VHT STA and not applicable to an S1G STA. The all PPDU format supported in the S1G STA is listed, and no 'otherwise' condition exists. Remove all 'otherwise' rows in Table 24-1. REJECT. Please refer to doc. 14/XXXXr0. Including otherwise for other FORMAT parameter has been long used in the previous drafts such 802.11ac and 802.11af.
11-14-0597-00-00ah-lb200-phy-comment-resolutions-24-2-2.docx