harmonization issue, but propose to do the contrary. Make the changes as proposed in doc . Graham Figure 27-9 indicates that the TX Delete the shading and change Rejected see CID – Smith power may be less than the simple the on "Allowable 11777. rule and could, in fact, be set to OBSS_Pdlevel" to point at the zero. Seems pretty dumb to me t edge. as it is bad enough already and can one really see devices using less than the permitted power if they were dumb enough to do this anyway? James June RSSI_LEGACY is a relative value Please clarify it. Revised agree – Wang with value to 277. It is not clear with the that it can be used to compare commenter. with OBSS_PD. Suppress the mention to RSSI_legacy and mention receive signal strength, which is used in the receive operation subclause. Apply the changes as in . Yongho "If the bandwidth of the received As in comment. Revised not – Seok PPDU differs from MHz, then certain exactly the value of the OBSS_PDlevel is what the increased by log (bandwidth/20 commenter is MHz)." requesting, but the More exactly, apply a floor to a term bandwidth log. has no reference, so formalizaing that term to CH_BANDWIDTH and removing the units (MHz). Apply the changes proposed in doc . Graham "output of the antenna connector" Replace cited text with "at the Rejected – “output Smith What about printed antennas? input to the antenna" or better of the antenna still check with 11md where this connector” is used has come up. throughout 802.11 2016. Osama The two terms SRG OBSS_PD and as in comment Revised the – Aboulmagd Non-SRG OBSS_PD appear terms are actually suddenly in the middle of page introduced sooner Need to at least introduce the in the section. For terms and why two of them are clarity, the general needed. section is now split in 2 subclauses to clarify the differences between SRG and non-SRG operation. Apply
harmonization issue, but propose to do the contrary. Make the changes as proposed in doc . Graham Smith Figure 27-9 indicates that the TX power may be less than the simple rule and could, in fact, be set to zero. Seems pretty dumb to me t as it is bad enough already and can one really see devices using less than the permitted power if they were dumb enough to do this anyway? Delete the shading and change the on "Allowable OBSS_Pdlevel" to point at the edge. Rejected – see CID 11777. James June Wang RSSI_LEGACY is a relative value with value to 277. It is not clear that it can be used to compare with OBSS_PD. Please clarify it. Revised – agree with the commenter. Suppress the mention to RSSI_legacy and mention receive signal strength, which is used in the receive operation subclause. Apply the changes as in . Yongho Seok "If the bandwidth of the received PPDU differs from MHz, then the value of the OBSS_PDlevel is increased by log (bandwidth/20 MHz)." More exactly, apply a floor to a log. As in comment. Revised – not certain exactly what the commenter is requesting, but the term bandwidth has no reference, so formalizaing that term to CH_BANDWIDTH and removing the units (MHz). Apply the changes proposed in doc . Graham Smith "output of the antenna connector" What about printed antennas? Replace cited text with "at the input to the antenna" or better still check with 11md where this has come up. Rejected – “output of the antenna connector” is used throughout 802.11 2016. Osama Aboulmagd The two terms SRG OBSS_PD and Non-SRG OBSS_PD appear suddenly in the middle of page Need to at least introduce the terms and why two of them are needed. as in comment Revised – the terms are actually introduced sooner in the section. For clarity, the general section is now split in 2 subclauses to clarify the differences between SRG and non-SRG operation. Apply
11-17-1852-06-00ax-cr-for-27-9.docx