CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resolution 2442 158.34 22.3.11.4.1.2 Add limits for i As in comment AGREE IN PRINCIPLE. See 11/1190r0. Discussion: On top of adding the limits for we should also add the user index i, u. Proposed Text Changes: 22.3.10.5.1.2 Binary convolutional coding and puncturing Change P179L4 (D1.1) as follows: The encoder parser output sequences , will each be encoded by a rate R = ½ convolutional encoder defined in 17.3.5.6 (Convolutional encoder). CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resolution 3035 200.48 22.4.4 The VHT PHY Define AGREE IN characterisitcs for aPPDUMaxTime for PRINCIPLE. See aPPDUMaxTime is VHT PHY keeping in 11/1190r0. inherited from Table mind that the LSIG 19-25 (MIMO PHY LENGTH field is used Characteristics) and for TXTIME indication has the value 10ms. However, given that the LSIG LENGTH can hold only max value of 4095, the max duration of the PPDU is approximately 5.46milli seconds Discussion: Max. L-SIG length = 212 - 1 = 4095 bytes Max. duration in time after L-SIG = (4095 + 3) bytes / 3 bytes/symbol * 4 us/symbol = 5.464 ms Max. PPDU duration = 20 us (L-STF + L-LTF + L-SIG) + 5.464 ms = 5.484 ms Hence, aPPDUMaxTime for a VHT PHY should be set to 5.484 ms. Proposed Text Changes: Change 22.4.4 (D1.1) as follows: 22.4.4 PHY characteristics The static VHT PHY characteristics, provided through the PLME-CHARACTERISTICS service primitive, shall be as shown in Table 19-25 (MIMO PHY characteristics) unless otherwise listed in Table 22-24 (VHT PHY characteristics). The definitions for these characteristics are given in 6.5 (PLME SAP interface). Table 22-24 VHT PHY characteristics – Characteristics Value aCCAMidTime < 25 us
CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resolution 2442 158.34 22.3.11.4.1.2 Add limits for i As in comment AGREE IN PRINCIPLE. See 11/1190r0. Discussion: On top of adding the limits for i, we should also add the user index u. Proposed Text Changes: 22.3.10.5.1.2 Binary convolutional coding and puncturing Change P179L4 (D1.1) as follows: The encoder parser output sequences , will each be encoded by a rate R = ½ convolutional encoder defined in 17.3.5.6 (Convolutional encoder). CID Page Clause Comment Proposed Change Resolution 3035 200.48 22.4.4 The VHT PHY characterisitcs for aPPDUMaxTime is inherited from Table 19-25 (MIMO PHY Characteristics) and has the value 10ms. However, given that the LSIG LENGTH can hold only max value of 4095, the max duration of the PPDU is approximately 5.46milli seconds Define aPPDUMaxTime for VHT PHY keeping in mind that the LSIG LENGTH field is used for TXTIME indication AGREE IN PRINCIPLE. See 11/1190r0. Discussion: Max. L-SIG length = 212 - 1 = 4095 bytes Max. duration in time after L-SIG = (4095 + 3) bytes / 3 bytes/symbol * 4 us/symbol = 5.464 ms Max. PPDU duration = 20 us (L-STF + L-LTF + L-SIG) + 5.464 ms = 5.484 ms Hence, aPPDUMaxTime for a VHT PHY should be set to 5.484 ms. Proposed Text Changes: Change 22.4.4 (D1.1) as follows: 22.4.4 PHY characteristics The static VHT PHY characteristics, provided through the PLME-CHARACTERISTICS service primitive, shall be as shown in Table 19-25 (MIMO PHY characteristics) unless otherwise listed in Table 22-24 (VHT PHY characteristics). The definitions for these characteristics are given in 6.5 (PLME SAP interface). Table 22-24 – VHT PHY characteristics Characteristics Value aCCAMidTime < 25 us
11-11-1190-00-00ac-d1-0-comment-resolution-miscellaneous-phy-comments.docx