packet to report Refer to Doc. the selected 13/1120r0. sector to AP when sectorized operation. It may be better if we can protect those packets in a RAW (report RAW). 878 Yongho 158 3 "A station may Sector ID ACCEPT. Seok optionally use a feedback frame VHT action frame should use a S1G Refer to Doc. (see 8.5.23.4a) Action frame. 13/1120r0. for (solicited and unsolicited) Sector ID feedback." Is there any reason to use a VHT action frame for the Sector ID feedback? Sectorized beam operation is not related with the VHT. Don't use a VHT action frame. Instead, please use a S1G action frame. <Discussion> It may be better to have short packet such as NDP type for fast sectory discovery. NDP PS-POLL canbe easily re-used using the currently defined format with Preferred Sector ID (3 bits) in the Preferred MCS (4bits). TGah editor: modify the D0.2 text from P175L01, as follows 9.32m.4.3 Sector ID feedback A station may optionally use action frame (see 8.5.23) for (solicited and unsolicited) Sector ID feedback. 9.32m.4.4 Fast Sector Discovery When multiple STAs report their Sector ID feedback frames to AP, Sector ID feedback frames may be protected by Sector Report RAW indicated in the beacon to avoid contentions with others. The Sector Report RAW may be assigned after the Sounding RAW for fast sector discovery of multiple STAs. TGah editor: modify the D0.2 text from P226L32, as follows
packet to report the selected sector to AP when sectorized operation. It may be better if we can protect those packets in a RAW (report RAW). Refer to Doc. 13/1120r0. 878 Yongho Seok 158 3 "A station may optionally use a VHT action frame (see 8.5.23.4a) for (solicited and unsolicited) Sector ID feedback." Is there any reason to use a VHT action frame for the Sector ID feedback? Sectorized beam operation is not related with the VHT. Don't use a VHT action frame. Instead, please use a S1G action frame. Sector ID feedback frame should use a S1G Action frame. ACCEPT. Refer to Doc. 13/1120r0. <Discussion> It may be better to have short packet such as NDP type for fast sectory discovery. NDP PS-POLL canbe easily re-used using the currently defined format with Preferred Sector ID (3 bits) in the Preferred MCS (4bits). TGah editor: modify the D0.2 text from P175L01, as follows 9.32m.4.3 Sector ID feedback A station may optionally use action frame (see 8.5.23) for (solicited and unsolicited) Sector ID feedback. 9.32m.4.4 Fast Sector Discovery When multiple STAs report their Sector ID feedback frames to AP, Sector ID feedback frames may be protected by Sector Report RAW indicated in the beacon to avoid contentions with others. The Sector Report RAW may be assigned after the Sounding RAW for fast sector discovery of multiple STAs. TGah editor: modify the D0.2 text from P226L32, as follows
11-13-1120-00-00ah-cc9-mac-comment-resolutions-on-sectorization.docx