5482 Graham 190.10 27.9.1 "When the conditions Delete cited text Revise generally – Smith specified in 27.9 disagree with (Spatial reuse proposed operation) are met that resolution, but do allow the transmission agree with of an SR PPDU, an comment, rather HE STA may transmit than deleting, a an SR PPDU to either definition of SR an HE STA or a PPDU is provided. STA." What is an TGax editor shall SR PPDU, it is only incorporate mentioned in this changes in sentence. Delete, does not make sense. 5680 190.12 27.9.1 What is SR PPDU? Either define SR Revise generally Guoqing – Li The HE PHY does not PPDU, or clarify agree with define such an PPDU using different comment, TGax format. Seems to me, terminology. editor shall SR PPDU is a PPDU incorporate that can be initaited changes in simultaneously using the SR mechiasm defined here which is otherwise not possible using legacy sensing mechanism. If so, this needs to be clarified since there is such PHY PPDU format called SR PPDU. 10194 190.11 27.9.1 There is no definition Define it on Revise generally Yusuke – Asai of "SR PPDU." Subclause 3.2 or with comment, delete it. TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 9760 Yoshio 190.11 27.9.2.1 SR PPDU' is not Define 'SR PPDU' Revise generally – Urabe defined. in Section 3 agree with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in
5482 Graham Smith 190.10 27.9.1 "When the conditions specified in 27.9 (Spatial reuse operation) are met that allow the transmission of an SR PPDU, an HE STA may transmit an SR PPDU to either an HE STA or a STA." What is an SR PPDU, it is only mentioned in this sentence. Delete, does not make sense. Delete cited text Revise – generally disagree with proposed resolution, but do agree with comment, rather than deleting, a definition of SR PPDU is provided. TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 5680 Guoqing Li 190.12 27.9.1 What is SR PPDU? The HE PHY does not define such an PPDU format. Seems to me, SR PPDU is a PPDU that can be initaited simultaneously using the SR mechiasm defined here which is otherwise not possible using legacy sensing mechanism. If so, this needs to be clarified since there is such PHY PPDU format called SR PPDU. Either define SR PPDU, or clarify using different terminology. Revise – generally agree with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 10194 Yusuke Asai 190.11 27.9.1 There is no definition of "SR PPDU." Define it on Subclause 3.2 or delete it. Revise – generally with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in 9760 Yoshio Urabe 190.11 27.9.2.1 SR PPDU' is not defined. Define 'SR PPDU' in Section 3 Revise – generally agree with comment, TGax editor shall incorporate changes in
11-16-1476-18-00ax-cr-for-section-25-9-spatial-reuse-operation-for-he-ppdu.docx