602 60 29 It is not clear why the parameter Rename Revised. is called OCWmin, if there is no OCWmin or OCWmax introduce An OCWmax OCWmax parameter is added in Beacon frame or Probe response frame. 1198 60 7 For random access UL-OFDMA, Define an Revised OCWmin is defined but not OCWmax OCWmax. This is parameter An OCWmax important to make sure that OCW parameter is added will be upperbounded the same in Beacon frame or way for all 11ax devices. Probe response frame. 2684 60 8 Other parameters for random OCWmax or Revised. access are TBD. Retry Limits are We should define it necessary An OCWmax for a parameter is added retransmission in Beacon frame or procedure of the Probe response UL frame. based random access. 181 78 47 If the OBO counter is 0 or it As in comment Revised. decrements to 0 are the same condition in terms of this They are two procedure (pick one and remove different ways for the other). Also Trigger frame for OBO counter to random access is better referred to get 0. It is better to as a Trigger frame that contains at keep both of them. least a random RU? The sentence is modified to make it clearer. frame for “Trigger random access” is replaced with frame “trigger contains RU(s) assigned for AID value 0”. (IEEE motion passed, slide105 in 440 60 32 initiates begins when the Revised. ... receives. Agree in principle. Although, really it begins when The sentence is the AP sends the deleted. trigger frame frro random access! ..
602 60 29 It is not clear why the parameter is called OCWmin, if there is no OCWmax Rename OCWmin or introduce OCWmax Revised. An OCWmax parameter is added in Beacon frame or Probe response frame. 1198 60 7 For random access UL-OFDMA, OCWmin is defined but not OCWmax. This is important to make sure that OCW will be upperbounded the same way for all 11ax devices. Define an OCWmax parameter Revised An OCWmax parameter is added in Beacon frame or Probe response frame. 2684 60 8 Other parameters for random access are TBD. We should define it OCWmax or Retry Limits are necessary for a retransmission procedure of the UL random access. Revised. An OCWmax parameter is added in Beacon frame or Probe response frame. 181 78 47 If the OBO counter is 0 or it decrements to 0 are the same condition in terms of this procedure (pick one and remove the other). Also Trigger frame for random access is better referred to as a Trigger frame that contains at least a random RU? As in comment Revised. They are two different ways for OBO counter to get 0. It is better to keep both of them. The sentence is modified to make it clearer. “Trigger frame for random access” is replaced with “trigger frame contains RU(s) assigned for AID value 0”. (IEEE motion passed, slide105 in 440 60 32 initiates begins when the ... receives. Although, really it begins when the AP sends the trigger frame frro random access! .. Revised. Agree in principle. The sentence is deleted. based
11-16-1162-02-00ax-comment-resolution-on-retansmission-of-ofdma-random-access.docx