2745 Kudo, 114.39 22.2.2 "1 through As in comment. PHY Accept. See Riichi NUM_USERS-1" 11/954r1 is not correct. "0 through NUM_USERS-1" is correct and this is corresponding to Table 22-5 and other parts of Clause 22. 2365 Hart, Brian 114.40 22.2.2 1 through 0 through Accept. See PHY NUMUSERS-1 NUMUSERS-1 11/954r1 3600 Stephens, 114.40 22.2.2 "values 1 Take a straw Accept in PHY Adrian through poll as to principle. Right whether we like answer is FORTRAN ('77 0..NUM_USERS-1. was the last See 11/954r1 Obviously we version I had a battle learned) or C between the (ANSI C). FORTRAN Then adjust programmers upper or lower and the C bound programmers, accordingly. and they came to a compromize. Those who are Unfortunately, COBOL like writing programmers alternating lines won't of a program in understand this FORTRAN and comment, and C, the are advised to compromise take it easy. does not work. Discussion.The math and usage elsewhere requires that the range be 0 to NUM_USERS-1. See roll-up after next comment for changes Change:
2745 Kudo, Riichi 114.39 22.2.2 "1 through NUM_USERS-1" is not correct. "0 through NUM_USERS-1" is correct and this is corresponding to Table 22-5 and other parts of Clause 22. As in comment. Accept. See 11/954r1 PHY 2365 Hart, Brian 114.40 22.2.2 1 through NUMUSERS-1 0 through NUMUSERS-1 Accept. See 11/954r1 PHY 3600 Stephens, Adrian 114.40 22.2.2 "values 1 through Obviously we had a battle between the FORTRAN programmers and the C programmers, and they came to a compromize. Unfortunately, like writing alternating lines of a program in FORTRAN and C, the compromise does not work. Take a straw poll as to whether we like FORTRAN ('77 was the last version I learned) or C (ANSI C). Then adjust upper or lower bound accordingly. Those who are COBOL programmers won't understand this comment, and are advised to take it easy. Accept in principle. Right answer is 0..NUM_USERS-1. See 11/954r1 PHY Discussion.The math and usage elsewhere requires that the range be 0 to NUM_USERS-1. Change: See roll-up after next comment for changes
11-11-0954-01-00ac-d1-comment-resolution-brianh-part2.docx