multiples of include CID the number of 1996. TX sector combinations, Ntsc. 2018 68 21 The part Please clarify Rejected "where the the definition AWV of the AWV The part feedback ID_i when multiple mentioned in indicates the TX antennas the comment is AWV for a are used also applicable TX DMG simultaneously. if the EDMG antenna An easy fix can BRP packet is having its TX be to define the transmitted antenna ID AWVs as through equal to the MIMO AWVs multiple TX antenna ID so the same antennas value, which is value is used simultaneously. used to for the j In this case, a transmit the RX TRN subfield BRP_TX/RX configuration, of EDMG BRP packet" is only when the packet is applicable if bitmap transmitted the BRP indicating the using AWVs of packet was TX mask multiple sent with just contains more antennas one antenna. If than a "1". simultaneously more antennas which have the are used same AWV simultaneously feedback ID this behaviour value. can be ambiguous. 2237 68 19 Not clear why Add a sentence Revised the to describe that antenna id is RX antenna id Agreed in needed by is reserved in principle. transmitter EDMG sector when ID order when TGay editor to reporting included in make the SISO id subset MIMO BF changes shown
multiples of the number of TX sector combinations, Ntsc. include CID 1996. 2018 68 21 The part "where the AWV feedback ID_i indicates the AWV for a TX DMG antenna having its TX antenna ID equal to the TX antenna ID value, which is used to transmit the BRP_TX/RX packet" is only applicable if the BRP packet was sent with just one antenna. If more antennas are used simultaneously this behaviour can be ambiguous. Please clarify the definition of the AWV when multiple TX antennas are used simultaneously. An easy fix can be to define the AWVs as MIMO AWVs so the same value is used for the j configuration, when the bitmap indicating the TX mask contains more than a "1". Rejected The part mentioned in the comment is also applicable if the EDMG BRP packet is transmitted through multiple antennas simultaneously. In this case, a TRN subfield of EDMG BRP packet is transmitted using AWVs of multiple antennas simultaneously which have the same AWV feedback ID value. 2237 68 19 Not clear why the RX antenna id is needed by transmitter when reporting SISO id subset Add a sentence to describe that RX antenna id is reserved in EDMG sector ID order when included in MIMO BF Revised Agreed in principle. TGay editor to make the changes shown
11-18-0430-02-00ay-cr-on-edmg-channel-measurement-feedback.docx