5391 Geonjung 95.24 9.4.2.222 When an AP uses When an AP uses Revised. Ko the Dual Beacon, the Dual Beacon, The Dual even if the STA a value of 0 Beacon receives any indicates that the mechanism is Beacon frame switch occurs at deleted. between Beacon the current TBTT if See proposed frames of two the element is change in doc. PPDU formats, all carried in a 11-17/XXXX. STAs in the BSS format Beacon shall start to use the frame or at the BSS Color at the next TBTT of a same time. e.g. at non-HE format the TBTT of non-HE Beacon frame if format Beacon the element is not frame. Need a carried in a nonHE clarification on a format Beacon setting of the Color frame. Switch Countdown field. Related Comments in Subclause 11.1.3.10 3055 Abhishek 141.00 11.1.3.10 Only HE STAs can Add a sentence Revised. Patil understand an HE which implies that The Dual Beacon in Extended an HE beacon Beacon PPDU format. Such may not include mechanism is beacon need not fields/IEs that deleted. carry information apply only to See proposed that is relevant to legacy STAs. change in doc. non-HE/legacy 11-17/XXXX. STAs. This will help reduce the size of HE Beacon. 5797 Huizhao 141.50 11.1.3.10 Need detail Please add detail Revised. Wang description of description The Dual different element Beacon sets may be mechanism is included in beacons deleted. in non-HE and See proposed HE_EXT_SU change in doc. formats. If they are 11-17/XXXX. carrying different set of elements, then in order to avoid any ambiguity, need to list out which elements may differ, and the reasons behind them. 5905 James Yee 141.50 11.1.3.10 Rather than stating As suggested. Revised. different elements The Dual may be carried, it Beacon should be specified mechanism is what are identical deleted. elements and See proposed contents that must change in doc. be carried in both 11-17/XXXX.
5391 Geonjung Ko 95.24 9.4.2.222 When an AP uses the Dual Beacon, even if the STA receives any Beacon frame between Beacon frames of two PPDU formats, all STAs in the BSS shall start to use the BSS Color at the same time. e.g. at the TBTT of non-HE format Beacon frame. Need a clarification on a setting of the Color Switch Countdown field. When an AP uses the Dual Beacon, a value of 0 indicates that the switch occurs at the current TBTT if the element is carried in a format Beacon frame or at the next TBTT of a non-HE format Beacon frame if the element is not carried in a nonHE format Beacon frame. Revised. The Dual Beacon mechanism is deleted. See proposed change in doc. 11-17/XXXX. Related Comments in Subclause 11.1.3.10 3055 Abhishek Patil 141.00 11.1.3.10 Only HE STAs can understand an HE Beacon in Extended PPDU format. Such beacon need not carry information that is relevant to non-HE/legacy STAs. This will help reduce the size of HE Beacon. Add a sentence which implies that an HE beacon may not include fields/IEs that apply only to legacy STAs. Revised. The Dual Beacon mechanism is deleted. See proposed change in doc. 11-17/XXXX. 5797 Huizhao Wang 141.50 11.1.3.10 Need detail description of different element sets may be included in beacons in non-HE and HE_EXT_SU formats. If they are carrying different set of elements, then in order to avoid any ambiguity, need to list out which elements may differ, and the reasons behind them. Please add detail description Revised. The Dual Beacon mechanism is deleted. See proposed change in doc. 11-17/XXXX. 5905 James Yee 141.50 11.1.3.10 Rather than stating different elements may be carried, it should be specified what are identical elements and contents that must be carried in both As suggested. Revised. The Dual Beacon mechanism is deleted. See proposed change in doc. 11-17/XXXX.
11-17-0576-00-00ax-resolutions-for-comments-related-to-extended-range-beacon.docx