between the two duration fields. 6048 208.18 If an HE AP has Please clarify. Rejected: Any HE STA, associated legacy AP or non-AP or non-HE non-AP STAs and STA can send data in the the AP has quiet period following the established quiet channel access rule, as this period, then is the is a best effort feature for AP allowed to interference mitigation. send data to the legacy STAs, or beacons during the quiet period. 6804 207.57 Unclear and Clarify. Duplicated: Resolved in ungrammatical CID 6806, 700r1. text: "can transmit frames belongs to the requested type of STA-to-STA operation". What does this mean? 6805 207.57 Imprecise Add appropriate Rejected: The setup frame (possibly) text to clarify ( defined in 9.4.2.242.1) normative text: when the serves as a paging "When a requester HE function for AP to inform Time Period Setup STA can or may HE STAs that the specific frame is received, transmit peer-to-peer operation the requested(/r) whatever it is identified by the Service HE STA can/may supposed to be Specific Identifier have preference to access the transmit". Isn't the transmitting channel. whole point that under this that these "quiet protocol. Even with repetition, AP times" repeat can still decide whether themselves the preference should give periodidcally up to to the peer-to-peer some limit, operation based on the potentially at loading of the BSS. least? So whatever is being described here, it can't be the period immediately after reception of the setup frame. 6807 207.59 There's something Reword to Duplicated: Resolved in odd about the clarify the role CID 6809, 700r1. entire discussion this subsection in subsection c. plays. Assuming On the surface it that we keep the seems to discuss "should"s in the frames that 27.16.3.1,
between the two duration fields. 6048 208.18 If an HE AP has associated legacy non-AP STAs and the AP has established quiet period, then is the AP allowed to send data to the legacy STAs, or beacons during the quiet period. Please clarify. Rejected: Any HE STA, AP or non-AP or non-HE STA can send data in the quiet period following the channel access rule, as this is a best effort feature for interference mitigation. 6804 207.57 Unclear and ungrammatical text: "can transmit frames belongs to the requested type of STA-to-STA operation". What does this mean? Clarify. Duplicated: Resolved in CID 6806, 700r1. 6805 207.57 Imprecise (possibly) normative text: "When a Time Period Setup frame is received, the requested(/r) HE STA can/may transmit". Isn't the whole point that that these "quiet times" repeat themselves periodidcally up to some limit, potentially at least? So whatever is being described here, it can't be the period immediately after reception of the setup frame. Add appropriate text to clarify when the requester HE STA can or may transmit whatever it is supposed to be transmitting under this protocol. Rejected: The setup frame ( defined in 9.4.2.242.1) serves as a paging function for AP to inform HE STAs that the specific peer-to-peer operation identified by the Service Specific Identifier have preference to access the channel. Even with repetition, AP can still decide whether the preference should give to the peer-to-peer operation based on the loading of the BSS. 6807 207.59 There's something odd about the entire discussion in subsection c. On the surface it seems to discuss the frames that Reword to clarify the role this subsection plays. Assuming that we keep the "should"s in 27.16.3.1, Duplicated: Resolved in CID 6809, 700r1.
11-17-1009-01-00ax-quiet-time-period-part-3-27-26-3-x.docx