Strongly and clearly Clearly states a how this States how poem reflects Thesis is not easily Opening states the themes of poem(s) reflects identity. identity but may be understood with little or Statement and identity. Previews Previews the supporting confusing or basic. no reference to the Conclusion the supporting reasons. Supporting reasons may or question. reasons. may not be previewed. Intro may be basic. Intro and/or conclusion is Creative and Conclusion wraps up and/or conclusion weak or absent insightful argument but could be does not wrap up thesis. stronger. Conclusion is strong. Provides strong Provides details, reasons Provides some reasons Provides little or Supporting details, reasons and/or examples in support of and/or example in support no support of the opinion. Details (quotes and/or examples in the thesis. Evidence fits to the of the thesis. Evidence Support is weak or and evidence support of the thesis. argument. May be slightly may be weak or not irrelevant. from poems) irrelevant to thesis or weak argument. Quotes are very relevant and strong Insightful, intelligent Argument is intelligent. Argument is correct but Argument is simple but Argument argument about Understands the big ideas. could be more mature or correct. Could be more identity. insightful. You may have mature or insightful. missed some key ideas A mature understanding of the subject. Use of Quotes Quotes are integrated Quotes are integrated but Quotes could be integrated seamlessly. could be integrated smoother better. Some quote bombs Formatting is flawless Formatting may or may not be Formatting to be Bombs and flawless but obvious effort is improved Formatting made to try Sentences and Sentences are varied and Sentences are sometimes Little or no evidence of Format/ paragraphs are complex. Paragraph structure varied and complex. sentence or paragraph Organization complete, well written is generally correct. Paragraph structure is structure. and varied. generally correct. Essay is organized regardless Essay could be Essay is organized of essay type Essay may not be organized better. regardless of essay organized as well as it type should There are no errors in Few errors in grammar, Some errors in grammar, Many errors in grammar, Mechanics and grammar, spelling or spelling or mechanics spelling and mechanics spelling and mechanics Grammar mechanics Needs to be proofread and Needs to be proofread edited. and edited.
Opening Statement and Conclusion Strongly and clearly states the themes of identity. Previews the supporting reasons. Creative and insightful Conclusion is strong. Clearly states a how this poem(s) reflects identity. Previews the supporting reasons. Intro may be basic. Conclusion wraps up argument but could be stronger. States how poem reflects identity but may be confusing or basic. Supporting reasons may or may not be previewed. and/or conclusion does not wrap up thesis. Thesis is not easily understood with little or no reference to the question. Intro and/or conclusion is weak or absent Supporting Details (quotes and evidence from poems) Provides strong details, reasons and/or examples in support of the thesis. Quotes are very relevant and strong Provides details, reasons and/or examples in support of the thesis. Evidence fits to the argument. May be slightly irrelevant to thesis or weak Provides some reasons and/or example in support of the thesis. Evidence may be weak or not argument. Provides little or no support of the opinion. Support is weak or irrelevant. Argument Insightful, intelligent argument about identity. A mature understanding of the subject. Argument is intelligent. Understands the big ideas. Argument is correct but could be more mature or insightful. You may have missed some key ideas Argument is simple but correct. Could be more mature or insightful. Use of Quotes Bombs and Formatting Quotes are integrated seamlessly. Formatting is flawless Quotes are integrated but could be integrated smoother Formatting may or may not be flawless but obvious effort is made to try Quotes could be integrated better. Some quote bombs Formatting to be improved Format/ Organization Sentences and paragraphs are complete, well written and varied. Essay is organized regardless of essay type Sentences are varied and complex. Paragraph structure is generally correct. Essay is organized regardless of essay type Sentences are sometimes varied and complex. Paragraph structure is generally correct. Essay may not be organized as well as it should Little or no evidence of sentence or paragraph structure. Essay could be organized better. Mechanics and Grammar There are no errors in grammar, spelling or mechanics Few errors in grammar, spelling or mechanics Some errors in grammar, spelling and mechanics Needs to be proofread and edited. Many errors in grammar, spelling and mechanics Needs to be proofread and edited.
compare-and-contrast-essay-poetry-updated1-178do4h.docx