Dissertation Assessment –Sheet Total Points: Date: Name/ID Number: ………………………………………………….. Date and Dissertation Title: Initials: ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. Chair/Committee Member: ……………………………………………………………………….. Comments Points proposed Issue 15% Clarity of objectives (0-15) Statement of the problem Relevance/significance of Rationale for study Literature Review 15% Relevance of sources (0-15) Depth of review Critical awareness Conceptual framework Methodology 15% Correct use of appropriate method (0-15) Date collection techniques/data sources Critical awareness of limitations Use of Evidence 15% Valid evidence/Depth of analysis (0-15) Analysis techniques used properly Critical awareness about results Use of Theory 15% Benchmarking (0-15) Relevance Depth of inquiry Attachment to study Conclusions and/or recommendations 15% Plausibility/soundness/produces answers questions (0-15) Relevance to objectives Completeness Structure and Presentation 15% Structure, organization of material. Clarity of (0-15) expression. Use of referencing and bibliography. Use of tables and figures.
Dissertation Assessment –Sheet Total Points: Date: Name/ID Number: ………………………………………………….. Dissertation Title: ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. Chair/Committee Member: ……………………………………………………………………….. Date and Initials: Comments Points proposed Issue Clarity of objectives Statement of the problem Relevance/significance of Rationale for study 15% (0-15) Literature Review Relevance of sources Depth of review Critical awareness Conceptual framework 15% (0-15) Methodology Correct use of appropriate method Date collection techniques/data sources Critical awareness of limitations 15% (0-15) Use of Evidence Valid evidence/Depth of analysis Analysis techniques used properly Critical awareness about results 15% (0-15) Use of Theory Benchmarking Relevance Depth of inquiry Attachment to study 15% (0-15) Conclusions and/or recommendations Plausibility/soundness/produces answers questions Relevance to objectives Completeness 15% (0-15) Structure and Presentation Structure, organization of material. Clarity of expression. Use of referencing and bibliography. Use of tables and figures. 15% (0-15)
CBPM-DPA-Program-review-Draft-10-2-11.docx