Construction manager acceptable standard. standard. Qualifications Construction manager (roads/bridges) has limited Qualifications met exceeded requirements. (roads/bridges) has knowledge and requirements. Construction manager excellent knowledge and experience. Performance Construction manger almost experience. Performance was below the acceptable (roads/bridges) on-site at always on-site but always was well above the standard. Qualifications most times but always on-site for critical acceptable standard. did not meet requirements. site for critical operations. operations. Qualifications exceeded Construction manager Design manager has Design manager has good requirements. (roads/bridges) sometimes satisfactory knowledge knowledge and Construction manager off-site for critical and experience. experience. Performance (roads/bridges) always operations. Performance met the was above the acceptable and present at all Design manager has acceptable standard. standard. Qualifications critical operations. limited knowledge and Qualifications met exceeded requirements. Design manager has experience. Performance requirements. Key operational personnel excellent knowledge and was below the acceptable Sufficient key operational have good knowledge, experience. Performance standard. Qualifications personnel. Little difficulty experience and was well above the did not meet requirements. in delivering the contract. performance. acceptable standard. Key operational personnel Insignificant adverse effect Qualifications exceeded Qualifications exceeded have limited knowledge, on processes and requirements. requirements. experience and outcomes. More than sufficient key Key operational personnel performance. Insignificant adverse effect operational personnel. No have excellent knowledge, Qualifications did not meet on progress and quality difficulty in delivering the experience and requirements. caused by turnover on key contract. No adverse performance. Inadequate number of key operational personnel. effect on outcomes and Qualifications exceeded operational personnel. Key operational personnel processes. requirements. Some difficulty in on-site at most but No adverse effect on Exceptional number of key delivering the contract. always for critical progress and quality operational personnel. No Some adverse effects on operations. caused by turnover in key difficulty in delivering an processes and outcomes. operational personnel. excellent contract. A Some adverse effect on Note: Key operational personnel Key operational personnel significant positive effect progress and quality includes: almost always on-site but on processes and caused by turnover in key Project manager always for critical outcomes. operational personnel. Site engineers operations. A positive effect on Senior supervisors progress and quality due Foremen to turnover in key Specialists. operational personnel. Key operational personnel always on-site and present at all critical operations.
Construction manager (roads/bridges) has limited knowledge and experience. Performance was below the acceptable standard. Qualifications did not meet requirements. Construction manager (roads/bridges) sometimes off-site for critical operations. Design manager has limited knowledge and experience. Performance was below the acceptable standard. Qualifications did not meet requirements. Key operational personnel have limited knowledge, experience and performance. Qualifications did not meet requirements. Inadequate number of key operational personnel. Some difficulty in delivering the contract. Some adverse effects on processes and outcomes. Some adverse effect on progress and quality caused by turnover in key operational personnel. acceptable standard. Qualifications met requirements. Construction manger (roads/bridges) on-site at most times but always for critical operations. Design manager has satisfactory knowledge and experience. Performance met the acceptable standard. Qualifications met requirements. Sufficient key operational personnel. Little difficulty in delivering the contract. Insignificant adverse effect on processes and outcomes. Insignificant adverse effect on progress and quality caused by turnover on key operational personnel. Key operational personnel on-site at most but always for critical operations. Note: Key operational personnel includes: Project manager Site engineers Senior supervisors Foremen Specialists. standard. Qualifications exceeded requirements. Construction manager almost always on-site but always on-site for critical operations. Design manager has good knowledge and experience. Performance was above the acceptable standard. Qualifications exceeded requirements. Key operational personnel have good knowledge, experience and performance. Qualifications exceeded requirements. More than sufficient key operational personnel. No difficulty in delivering the contract. No adverse effect on outcomes and processes. No adverse effect on progress and quality caused by turnover in key operational personnel. Key operational personnel almost always on-site but always for critical operations. Construction manager (roads/bridges) has excellent knowledge and experience. Performance was well above the acceptable standard. Qualifications exceeded requirements. Construction manager (roads/bridges) always and present at all critical operations. Design manager has excellent knowledge and experience. Performance was well above the acceptable standard. Qualifications exceeded requirements. Key operational personnel have excellent knowledge, experience and performance. Qualifications exceeded requirements. Exceptional number of key operational personnel. No difficulty in delivering an excellent contract. A significant positive effect on processes and outcomes. A positive effect on progress and quality due to turnover in key operational personnel. Key operational personnel always on-site and present at all critical operations. site
CO503-1_Performance_Rating_of_Contractor_by_DPTI_Feb_2016.docx