Project 10.1 Design Challenge Rubric Design Elements Weight 5 Points 4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1-0 Points Total Freehand Produces Produces Produces Produces Produces Sketching accurate pictorial marginally marginally freehand incomplete and sketches of sufficient sufficient sketches that sketches. Does the required freehand freehand are difficult to not present design concepts. sketches of sketches of visualize. Lacks concept. Is properly required design required design details in detailed for concepts. Is concepts. Is sketches. effective partially detailed marginally communication. for effective detailed for communication effective communication Consideration Generates at Generates three Generates three Generates Generates one of Alternatives three viable concepts. concepts. three concepts. concept. concepts. Selects Selects an Selects an Selects one most appropriate appropriate appropriate using concept and concept and is concept, but inadequate clearly justifies somewhat able cannot justify the criteria. the choice using to justify the choice. the appropriate choice using criteria. marginally acceptable criteria. Fully meets Meets most most design Meets some Does not meet Design Requirements design design requirements, but requirements, any requirements. requirements not enough to but not enough requirements. and supports the support the to support the design function. design function. design function. Teamwork Both team Showed good Showed good Showed that Did not present members worked team working team working understands any team well together and team working working skills.
Project 10.1 Design Challenge Rubric Design Elements Weight 5 Points 4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1-0 Points Total Freehand Sketching Produces accurate pictorial and sketches of the required design concepts. Is properly detailed for effective communication. Produces marginally sufficient freehand sketches of required design concepts. Is partially detailed for effective communication Produces marginally sufficient freehand sketches of required design concepts. Is marginally detailed for effective communication Produces freehand sketches that are difficult to visualize. Lacks details in sketches. Produces incomplete sketches. Does not present concept. Consideration of Alternatives Generates at three viable concepts. Selects most appropriate concept and clearly justifies the choice using the appropriate criteria. Generates three concepts. Selects an appropriate concept and is somewhat able to justify the choice using marginally acceptable criteria. Generates three concepts. Selects an appropriate concept, but cannot justify the choice. Generates three concepts. Selects one using inadequate criteria. Generates one concept. Design Requirements Fully meets design requirements. Meets most design requirements and supports the design function. most design requirements, but not enough to support the design function. Meets some requirements, but not enough to support the design function. Does not meet any requirements. Teamwork Both team members worked well together and Showed good team working Showed good team working Showed that understands team working Did not present any team working skills.
10.1.p.ru_designchallengesrubric.docx