22. State and There is no contact between managers and neighbouring official or corporate 0 commercial land and water users neighbours There is contact between managers and neighbouring official or corporate 1 land and water users but little or no cooperation Is there co-operation There is contact between managers and neighbouring official or corporate 2 with adjacent land and land and water users, but only some co-operation water users? There is regular contact between managers and neighbouring official or 3 corporate land and water users, and substantial co-operation on management Process 23. Indigenous Indigenous peoples have no input into decisions relating to the management of 0 peoples the Ramsar Site Indigenous peoples have some input into discussions relating to management 1 Do indigenous peoples but no direct role in management resident or regularly Indigenous peoples directly contribute to some relevant decisions relating to 2 using the Ramsar Site management but their involvement could be improved have input to Indigenous peoples directly participate in all relevant decisions relating to 3 management management, e.g. co-management decisions? Process 24. communities Local communities have no input into decisions relating to the management of 0 the Ramsar Site Do local communities Local communities have some input into discussions relating to management 1 resident or near the but no direct role in management Ramsar Site have communities directly contribute to some relevant decisions relating to 2 input to management management but their involvement could be improved decisions? Local communities directly participate in all relevant decisions relating to 3 Process management, e.g. co-management Additional points Indigenous peoples and local communities 24 a. Impact on There is open communication and trust between indigenous peoples and local +1 communities communities, stakeholders and Ramsar Site managers 24b. Impact on Programmes to enhance community welfare, while conserving Ramsar Site +1 communities resources, are being implemented 24c. Impact on Indigenous peoples and communities actively support the Ramsar Site +1 communities 25. Economic benefit The Ramsar Site does not deliver any economic benefits to local communities 0
22. State and commercial neighbours Is there co-operation with adjacent land and water users? Process There is no contact between managers and neighbouring official or corporate land and water users 0 There is contact between managers and neighbouring official or corporate land and water users but little or no cooperation 1 There is contact between managers and neighbouring official or corporate land and water users, but only some co-operation 2 There is regular contact between managers and neighbouring official or corporate land and water users, and substantial co-operation on management 3 23. Indigenous peoples Do indigenous peoples resident or regularly using the Ramsar Site have input to management decisions? Process Indigenous peoples have no input into decisions relating to the management of the Ramsar Site 0 Indigenous peoples have some input into discussions relating to management but no direct role in management 1 Indigenous peoples directly contribute to some relevant decisions relating to management but their involvement could be improved 2 Indigenous peoples directly participate in all relevant decisions relating to management, e.g. co-management 3 24. communities Do local communities resident or near the Ramsar Site have input to management decisions? Process Local communities have no input into decisions relating to the management of the Ramsar Site 0 Local communities have some input into discussions relating to management but no direct role in management 1 communities directly contribute to some relevant decisions relating to management but their involvement could be improved 2 Local communities directly participate in all relevant decisions relating to management, e.g. co-management 3 Additional points Indigenous peoples and local communities 24 a. Impact on communities There is open communication and trust between indigenous peoples and local communities, stakeholders and Ramsar Site managers +1 24b. Impact on communities Programmes to enhance community welfare, while conserving Ramsar Site resources, are being implemented +1 24c. Impact on communities Indigenous peoples and communities actively support the Ramsar Site +1 25. Economic benefit The Ramsar Site does not deliver any economic benefits to local communities 0
cop12_res15_management_effectiveness_e.docx