Support 2. Issue an alternative writ of Services Public mandate directing Authority respondent Superior Court to show cause why it should not be so directed, and upon return to the alternative writ, issue a peremptory writ as set forth in paragraph 1, above. 3. Award petitioner her costs and attorneys' fees incurred in this petition. Oral arguments were scheduled 11/14/2012. Court records do not show action on disposition of the case. 09-958 Whether Medicaid recipients Oct 3 2011 Argued. Transcript online at: Toby Douglas, Director, California and providers may maintain Department of Lower a cause of action under the This case was consolidated with: Health Care court case Supremacy Clause to Toby Douglas, Director, California Department of Health Services, Petitioner number: enforce § 1396a(a)(30)(A) Care Services, Petitioner v. California Pharmacists 08-56422, by asserting that the Association, et al. (case #09-1158) v. Independent Living Center of 08-56554 provision preempts a state Toby Douglas, Director, California Department of Health Southern California, law reducing reimbursement Care Services, Petitioner v. Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital, Inc., et al. rates? et al. (case #10-283 Case decided Feb 22, 2012: Mar 26 2012: JUDGMENT ISSUED. Held: The judgments are vacated and the cases are remanded, thereby permitting the parties to argue before the Ninth Circuit in the first instance the question whether respondents may maintain Supremacy Clause actions now that CMS has approved the state statutes. Given the present posture of the cases, the Court does not address whether the Ninth Circuit properly recognized a Supremacy Clause action to enforce the federal law before the agency took final action. To
Support Services Public Authority 2. Issue an alternative writ of mandate directing respondent Superior Court to show cause why it should not be so directed, and upon return to the alternative writ, issue a peremptory writ as set forth in paragraph 1, above. 3. Award petitioner her costs and attorneys' fees incurred in this petition. Oral arguments were scheduled 11/14/2012. Court records do not show action on disposition of the case. Toby Douglas, Director, California Department of Health Care Services, Petitioner v. Independent Living Center of Southern California, Inc., et al. 09-958 Lower court case number: 08-56422, 08-56554 Whether Medicaid recipients and providers may maintain a cause of action under the Supremacy Clause to enforce § 1396a(a)(30)(A) by asserting that the provision preempts a state law reducing reimbursement rates? Oct 3 2011 Argued. Transcript online at: This case was consolidated with: Toby Douglas, Director, California Department of Health Care Services, Petitioner v. California Pharmacists Association, et al. (case #09-1158) Toby Douglas, Director, California Department of Health Care Services, Petitioner v. Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital, et al. (case #10-283 Case decided Feb 22, 2012: Mar 26 2012: JUDGMENT ISSUED. Held: The judgments are vacated and the cases are remanded, thereby permitting the parties to argue before the Ninth Circuit in the first instance the question whether respondents may maintain Supremacy Clause actions now that CMS has approved the state statutes. Given the present posture of the cases, the Court does not address whether the Ninth Circuit properly recognized a Supremacy Clause action to enforce the federal law before the agency took final action. To
CAPA-Litigation-Chart-as-of-1-18-13.docx