CRITERIA Superior: 5 Adequate: 3 Poor: 1 Oral Delivery Maintains eye contact Maintains eye Eye contact is less with audience 90% or contact with than 80%; more more of the time; audience over 80% than 2 fluctuations in volume of the time but less and inflection are than 90%; 1-2 movements; intended and add to inaudible in back clarify of presentation; movements; of room more than no non-purposeful volume is loud 20% of the time. movement; volume is enough to be heard loud enough to be in the back of the heard in back of room room 80-89% of the 90% or more of the time. time. Quality of Comprehension Student answered Student answered Student failed to and Accurate Content audience member’s audience member’s answer the question correctly question correctly question correctly providing at least 2 providing at least 1 or could not accurate scientific facts accurate scientific provide a scientific for each question. fact for each fact for either question. question. Quality of Justification Student’s reason for Student’s reason Student fails to Explanation advocating the group’s for advocating the advocate the best solution is based group’s best group’s best on 2 accurate scientific solution is based solution with an facts and is financially on at least 1 accurate scientific feasible. accurate scientific fact, OR the fact and is reason may not be financially feasible. financially feasible. Reflection Student answers all 5 Student answers 3 Student answered questions. questions. less than 3 questions. Scoring Guide: Points Grade 20 A 19-15 B 14-10 C Below 10 F
CRITERIA Superior: 5 Adequate: 3 Poor: 1 Oral Delivery Maintains eye contact with audience 90% or more of the time; fluctuations in volume and inflection are intended and add to clarify of presentation; no non-purposeful movement; volume is loud enough to be heard in back of room 90% or more of the time. Maintains eye contact with audience over 80% of the time but less than 90%; 1-2 movements; volume is loud enough to be heard in the back of the room 80-89% of the time. Eye contact is less than 80%; more than 2 movements; inaudible in back of room more than 20% of the time. Quality of Comprehension and Accurate Content Student answered audience member’s question correctly providing at least 2 accurate scientific facts for each question. Student answered audience member’s question correctly providing at least 1 accurate scientific fact for each question. Student failed to answer the question correctly or could not provide a scientific fact for either question. Quality of Justification Explanation Student’s reason for advocating the group’s best solution is based on 2 accurate scientific facts and is financially feasible. Student’s reason for advocating the group’s best solution is based on at least 1 accurate scientific fact and is financially feasible. Student fails to advocate the group’s best solution with an accurate scientific fact, OR the reason may not be financially feasible. Reflection Student answers all 5 questions. Student answers 3 questions. Student answered less than 3 questions. Scoring Guide: Points Grade 20 A 19-15 B 14-10 C Below 10 F
borgen-pbl-1-final.docx