Energy Plan Rubric Teacher Name: Student Name: ________________________________________ CATEGORY Excellent Good Satisfactory Poor Alternative Energy Technologies chosen Technologies chosen Technologies Basic requirements Comparison are appropriate to the are appropriate to chosen are for the pro-con city’s climate and the city’s climate appropriate to the analysis have not topography. Pro-con and topography. city’s climate and been met. analysis for three Pro-con analysis for topography. technologies present. three technologies analysis for Three costs and three present. Two costs technologies benefits have been and two benefits present, but provided for each have been provided minimal detail is technology. for each technology. provided. Assignment All assignment All assignment Final Stage is Final Stage is Requirements requirements have requirements have missing one of the missing more than been satisfied and been satisfied. required one of the required obvious care has components. components. been given to the design of the infographic. Transition Strategy A comprehensive and A series of simple The before and No strategy is incremental plan is steps demonstrating after states of provided for provided. Plan an incremental shift energy generation transitioning the accounts for changes to renewable energy are provided, but city from fossil in technology, is provided. transition details fuels to sustainable government, are lacking. energy. industry, and society. Smart Grid A smart grid is a The concept of a The concept of a The concept of a central component of smart grid is smart grid is smart grid is not the energy plan. It included in the final included in the final included in the has been Stage. It is obvious Stage, but only has final Stage. incorporated in a that the team an “add-on”. thoughtful manner understands the that reflects complete concept of a smart understanding of the grid. technology. Energy Plan Final energy plan Final energy plan energy plan Final energy plan is meets the minimum meets the minimum meets the minimum missing or requirements for the requirements for the requirements for incomplete assignment, provides assignment and the assignment. rationale for the final provides some choices, and attempts rationale for the to provide resiliency final choices for in the face of a energy Stageion. changing climate.
Energy Plan Rubric Teacher Name: Student Name: ________________________________________ CATEGORY Excellent Good Satisfactory Poor Alternative Energy Comparison Technologies chosen are appropriate to the city’s climate and topography. Pro-con analysis for three technologies present. Three costs and three benefits have been provided for each technology. Technologies chosen are appropriate to the city’s climate and topography. Pro-con analysis for three technologies present. Two costs and two benefits have been provided for each technology. Technologies chosen are appropriate to the city’s climate and topography. analysis for technologies present, but minimal detail is provided. Basic requirements for the pro-con analysis have not been met. Assignment Requirements All assignment requirements have been satisfied and obvious care has been given to the design of the infographic. All assignment requirements have been satisfied. Final Stage is missing one of the required components. Final Stage is missing more than one of the required components. Transition Strategy A comprehensive and incremental plan is provided. Plan accounts for changes in technology, government, industry, and society. A series of simple steps demonstrating an incremental shift to renewable energy is provided. The before and after states of energy generation are provided, but transition details are lacking. No strategy is provided for transitioning the city from fossil fuels to sustainable energy. Smart Grid A smart grid is a central component of the energy plan. It has been incorporated in a thoughtful manner that reflects complete understanding of the technology. The concept of a smart grid is included in the final Stage. It is obvious that the team understands the concept of a smart grid. The concept of a smart grid is included in the final Stage, but only has an “add-on”. The concept of a smart grid is not included in the final Stage. Energy Plan Final energy plan meets the minimum requirements for the assignment, provides rationale for the final choices, and attempts to provide resiliency in the face of a changing climate. Final energy plan meets the minimum requirements for the assignment and provides some rationale for the final choices for energy Stageion. energy plan meets the minimum requirements for the assignment. Final energy plan is missing or incomplete
201803EnergyPlanRubric.docx