Judge’s Score sheet Category and Comments Scoring Criteria - Project Elements Team Documentation & Presentation Score Good balance of Team members recognized A few members doing all Working responsibility the work Together Working --------- --------- --------- Together Team enjoys each Team does what needs to Some discord never conflicts resolved get done, members resolved  Responsibility positively cooperate  Getting along 10 5 0 Scientific approach Plan of approach No plan Engineering evident, leveraging product acknowledged Processes Engineering improvement approaches Processes --------- --------- --------- Generated options when Was able to eventually find Obstacles not handled  Plan obstacles encountered ways around obstacles well Requirements Mgmt 10 5 0 Lean Application  Handling obstacles Clear & concise message, Satisfactory message, Disorganized message, good continuity orderly lacks continuity Product Product --------- --------- --------- High product complexity Limited complexity Narrow complexity with Communication with integrated conclusion requiring some integration minimum integration Material organization 10 5 0 Complexity  Integration Convincing, conclusion Had schedule, partially met Weak conclusion, loose clearly supported by data objectives tie to supporting data Results Results --------- --------- --------- Project resulted in Partial benefits (Industry, No noticeable benefits Accomplishments  significant benefits Society) 0 Leverage replication 10 5 Relative benefits  Schedule performance Clear Industrial Industrial Partners Industry contact Industrial involvement and recognized clearly established Interface Industrial participation Interface --------- --------- --------- Clear evidence of industry Evidence of request for No effort to solicit Involvement  $/material contributions support industry support Support  10 5 0 Documentation Presentation Over size Over 15 minutes Penalties --------- Late entry --------- -5 each occurrence Presentation  Presentation too long --------- Late start Never received  Presentation late start -20 for each occurrence -5 each occurrence  Documentation over size - Documentation late  TOTAL SCORE: RECOMMENDED 50 points possible PLACEMENT:
Judge’s Score sheet Category and Comments Scoring Criteria - Project Elements Team Documentation & Presentation Score Working Together  Responsibility  Getting along Good balance of responsibility --------- Team enjoys each conflicts resolved positively 10 Team members recognized --------- Team does what needs to get done, members cooperate 5 A few members doing all the work --------- Some discord never resolved 0 Working Together Engineering Processes  Plan Requirements Mgmt Lean Application  Handling obstacles Scientific approach evident, leveraging product improvement approaches --------- Generated options when obstacles encountered 10 Plan of approach acknowledged --------- Was able to eventually find ways around obstacles 5 No plan --------- Obstacles not handled well 0 Engineering Processes Product Communication Material organization  Complexity Integration Clear & concise message, good continuity --------- High product complexity with integrated conclusion 10 Satisfactory message, orderly --------- Limited complexity requiring some integration 5 Disorganized message, lacks continuity --------- Narrow complexity with minimum integration 0 Product Results  Accomplishments Leverage replication  Relative benefits Schedule performance Convincing, conclusion clearly supported by data --------- Project resulted in significant benefits 10 Had schedule, partially met objectives --------- Partial benefits (Industry, Society) 5 Weak conclusion, loose tie to supporting data --------- No noticeable benefits 0 Results Industrial Interface  Involvement  Support Clear Industrial involvement and participation --------- Clear evidence of industry $/material contributions 10 Industrial Partners recognized --------- Evidence of request for support 5 Industry contact clearly established --------- No effort to solicit industry support 0 Industrial Interface Penalties  Presentation too long  Presentation late start  Documentation over size  Documentation late Documentation Over size --------- Late entry -5 each occurrence --------- Never received -20 for each occurrence Presentation Over 15 minutes --------- Presentation Late start -5 each occurrence - RECOMMENDED PLACEMENT: TOTAL SCORE: 50 points possible
TT_Team_Tech_Packet.docx