Project 10.1 Design Challenge Rubric Elements 4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1 Points 0 Points Total Produces accurate Produces Produces Produces freehand Produces sketches of the marginally marginally sketches that are incomplete required design sufficient freehand sufficient freehand difficult to visualize. sketches. Does not Freehand concepts. Is properly sketches of sketches of Lacks details in present concept. Sketching detailed for effective required design required design sketches. communication. concepts. Is concepts. Is partially detailed marginally detailed Generates a concept Generates a Generates a Generates a Generates no and clearly justifies concept and concept but cannot concept but cannot concept. Consideration the choice the somewhat justifies justify the choice. justify the choice. of Alternatives appropriate criteria. the choice using acceptable criteria. Fully meets design Meets most design Meets most design Meets some Does not meet any Design requirements. requirements. requirements, but requirements. requirements. Requirements not well. Team members Showed good team Showed good team Understands team Did not present worked well together. working skills the working skills the working skills, but any team working Teamwork majority of the some of the time. does not apply skills. time. well. All of the parts are Most of the parts Some parts are Most of the parts No are drawn and are drawn and draw or are drawn and correctly drawn or Parts dimensioned dimensioned dimensioned dimensioned in dimensioned. correctly. correctly. incorrectly. correctly. Model is completely Model is Model is Some model Model is missing and efficiently inefficiently inefficiently features and most features or constrained. constrained or is constrained or is constraints are constraints. Assembly missing a few missing many missing or constraints. constraints. improper. Dimensions and Supplies most Supplies most many Dimensions or Drawing annotates properly dimensions and dimensions and dimensions or annotations have Dimensions and clearly. annotations. annotations. annotations. Some not been added, and Locates most Locates most mislabeling exists. leaving only Annotation dimensions and dimensions, but
Project 10.1 Design Challenge Rubric Elements 4 Points 3 Points 2 Points 1 Points 0 Points Total Freehand Sketching Produces accurate sketches of the required design concepts. Is properly detailed for effective communication. Produces marginally sufficient freehand sketches of required design concepts. Is partially detailed Produces marginally sufficient freehand sketches of required design concepts. Is marginally detailed Produces freehand sketches that are difficult to visualize. Lacks details in sketches. Produces incomplete sketches. Does not present concept. Consideration of Alternatives Generates a concept and clearly justifies the choice the appropriate criteria. Generates a concept and somewhat justifies the choice using acceptable criteria. Generates a concept but cannot justify the choice. Generates a concept but cannot justify the choice. Generates no concept. Design Requirements Fully meets design requirements. Meets most design requirements. Meets most design requirements, but not well. Meets some requirements. Does not meet any requirements. Teamwork Team members worked well together. Showed good team working skills the majority of the time. Showed good team working skills the some of the time. Understands team working skills, but does not apply well. Did not present any team working skills. Parts All of the parts are drawn and dimensioned correctly. Most of the parts are drawn and dimensioned correctly. Some parts are draw or dimensioned incorrectly. Most of the parts are drawn and dimensioned in correctly. No are correctly drawn or dimensioned. Assembly Model is completely and efficiently constrained. Model is inefficiently constrained or is missing a few constraints. Model is inefficiently constrained or is missing many constraints. Some model features and constraints are missing or improper. Model is missing most features or constraints. Drawing Dimensions and Annotation Dimensions and annotates properly and clearly. Supplies most dimensions and annotations. Locates most dimensions and Supplies most dimensions and annotations. Locates most dimensions, but many dimensions or annotations. Some mislabeling exists. Dimensions or annotations have not been added, leaving only
train_car_design_rubric.docx