factor 148 5.4.1 23 Frquency Domain Spectroscopy (FDS) Cigré Is this section based on mineral oil or is it Patrick Editorial Unresolved suitable for alternative insulating insulating McShane TB445 Guide for Transformer Maintenance(XX2) liquid s? If the former, it should be so stated. And all references of should be changed “oil” to including Figures 4 and 5. “mineral oil”, 149 5.6 25 (FRA) A repeated font error seems to be inherent in Patrick Editorial Resolved the The first bullets often McShane document’s bullets. have a different font than the following bullets. Maybe just on my screen computer perhaps? 150 5.6.1.5 27 Analysis of Results Recommend rewording this paragraph for Resolved, better clarity and grammar form. 151 5.6.1.5 27 ..a FRA trace rather than Patrick Editorial Resolved … “any” “a”? McShane 152 5.6.1.5 27 ..preictability predictability. This is due to typical frequency Patrick Editorial Resolved … core McShane effects, main…. 153 5.7 28 ..a ..a Patrick Editorial Resolved local breakdown… “localized breakdown”? McShane 154 5.8 29 to electrical signals. I would end the sentence after the word Patrick Editorial Resolved …converted The to electrical McShane “surface”. “.. converted is superfluous. signals” 155 5.8.2.1 30 ..equal to 10 °C Is this (and other limit based Patrick Editorial Resolved, 10C is not … sections’) “10 ºC on 65 ºC rise rated transformers? What McShane based on the about forced oil and/or forced air ratings? transformer rating And is it a valid limit for the new IEEE C57.154 Standard for transformers with High Temp. Insulation Systems and operating at elevated temperature? 156 5.8.2.3 30 Tap changer I assume this pertains to LTCs external to the Patrick Editorial Resolved
factor 148 5.4.1 23 Frquency Domain Spectroscopy (FDS) Cigré TB445 Guide for Transformer Maintenance(XX2) Is this section based on mineral oil or is it suitable for alternative insulating insulating liquid s? If the former, it should be so stated. And all references of “oil” should be changed to “mineral oil”, including Figures 4 and 5. Patrick McShane Editorial Unresolved 149 5.6 25 (FRA) A repeated font error seems to be inherent in the document’s bullets. The first bullets often have a different font than the following bullets. Maybe just on my screen computer perhaps? Patrick McShane Editorial Resolved 150 5.6.1.5 27 Analysis of Results Recommend rewording this paragraph for better clarity and grammar form. Resolved, 151 5.6.1.5 27 ..a FRA trace … “any” rather than “a”? Patrick McShane Editorial Resolved 152 5.6.1.5 27 ..preictability … predictability. This is due to typical frequency core effects, main…. Patrick McShane Editorial Resolved 153 5.7 28 ..a local breakdown… ..a “localized breakdown”? Patrick McShane Editorial Resolved 154 5.8 29 …converted to electrical signals. I would end the sentence after the word “surface”. The “.. converted to electrical signals” is superfluous. Patrick McShane Editorial Resolved 155 5.8.2.1 30 ..equal to 10 °C … Is this (and other sections’) “10 ºC limit based on 65 ºC rise rated transformers? What about forced oil and/or forced air ratings? And is it a valid limit for the new IEEE C57.154 Standard for transformers with High Temp. Insulation Systems and operating at elevated temperature? Patrick McShane Editorial Resolved, 10C is not based on the transformer rating 156 5.8.2.3 30 Tap changer I assume this pertains to LTCs external to the Patrick Editorial Resolved
Straw%20Vote%20Comment_Status%20Draft%205.docx