Poorvi Patel suggested that at a minimum consider adding high-level general discussion to the document similar to Cigre Document. Claude Beauchemin suggested high-level academic/generic mention of data analytic methods to review data be noted in the guide. Jim Dukarm suggested an article in IEEE Transactions addressing data analytics was more appropriate and better suited to cover data analytics. Joe Watson suggested that consideration be given to discussion in the document on collection of data for single device and fleet level data collection and transfer for analytics, and avoiding getting into the details of analytics to be performed. George Forest suggested listing measured parameters by monitoring devices in an and adding a note to the users that there are analytics available to aid in the interpretation of results. Following general discussion and comments a motion was proposed by Luiz Cheim to revise scope to remove guide does not cover interpretation of monitoring results.” “This And add a data analytics section/chapter. After continued discussion this motion was withdrawn, the members present were asked to vote on adding a chapter or Annex Covering Data Analytics. 5 of 44 members present voted yes, majority not in favor of adding a chapter or annex to address Data Analytics. There was also discussion on moving Annexes D and E into the main body of the guide. This will be looked into further by the review teams. Mike Spurlock requested any attendees interested in volunteering for participating in working on current Chapter reviews for revision see him after the meeting. A motion to Adjourn was given by Marcos Ferreira and seconded by Joe Watson, Meeting adjourned at 4:30pm.
Poorvi Patel suggested that at a minimum consider adding high-level general discussion to the document similar to Cigre Document. Claude Beauchemin suggested high-level academic/generic mention of data analytic methods to review data be noted in the guide. Jim Dukarm suggested an article in IEEE Transactions addressing data analytics was more appropriate and better suited to cover data analytics. Joe Watson suggested that consideration be given to discussion in the document on collection of data for single device and fleet level data collection and transfer for analytics, and avoiding getting into the details of analytics to be performed. George Forest suggested listing measured parameters by monitoring devices in an and adding a note to the users that there are analytics available to aid in the interpretation of results. Following general discussion and comments a motion was proposed by Luiz Cheim to revise scope to remove “This guide does not cover interpretation of monitoring results.” And add a data analytics section/chapter. After continued discussion this motion was withdrawn, the members present were asked to vote on adding a chapter or Annex Covering Data Analytics. 5 of 44 members present voted yes, majority not in favor of adding a chapter or annex to address Data Analytics. There was also discussion on moving Annexes D and E into the main body of the guide. This will be looked into further by the review teams. Mike Spurlock requested any attendees interested in volunteering for participating in working on current Chapter reviews for revision see him after the meeting. A motion to Adjourn was given by Marcos Ferreira and seconded by Joe Watson, Meeting adjourned at 4:30pm.
S18-AnnexK-PowerTransformersSC.docx