Montreal-Canada 44LLS 29LLS Malign Included in + P=0,001 P=0,28 P=0,08 P=0,001 Rao et al. Benign 2012 -14(1-20) Carswell(17) 10 10 10% 20% 6 9 - 0 Malign Included in - 0 2009 + 0 0 1(10%) 2(20%) 2(20%) - - 0 0 Rao et al. Benign 2012 London-UK 10LLS 10LLS - / - / P=0,782 P=0,315 P=0,005 P=0,669 - 8,2±2 - 8,5±1,3 122.5 ± 299,6 ± - 4(13%) 7(16%) 201 ± 15 172 ± 12 3.2 ± 1 6.8 ± 0.7 - 1(3%) 45.4 33,6 2(18%) Included in 31 43 Rao et al. Tsinberg(18) - / Malign - / 2012 2009 8BiS + 0 0 0 - - 0 0 Benign Cleveland-USA Has financial - P=0,9 23S 28S analysis P=0,7 P=0,002 P=0,1 P=0,004 - / - / Included in 470 80 180 155 Rao et al. 13% 25% 3,5 (1-6) 7 (3-12) -12(4-40) 2012. Abu 24 20 Malign 2008 + 0 0 0 - - 0 0 Duplicated in Benign Southampton-UK 24LLS 20LLS Ref. 6. All cases P=0,541 P=0,002 P=0,885 P<0,001 P=1 excluded form the count 165 ± Well-matched 2(10%) 5(25%) 214 ± 47 260±50 220±30 4.5 ± 0.6 5.8 ± 1.6 -11±3 -13±5 43 cohorts Included in Rao et al. Aldrighetti(20) 20 20 Malign 2012 2008 + 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Benign Milan-Italy 20LLS 20LLS Duplicated P=NS P=0,001 P=NS P=0,003 P=NS paper in Ref 12. Excluded 16 cases from open(8) and lap(8)
Montreal-Canada 44LLS 29LLS Malign + Benign Included in Rao et al. 2012 P=0,001 P=0,28 P=0,08 P=0,001 Carswell(17) London-UK 2009 10 10LLS 10 10LLS Malign + Benign 0 0 1(10%) 2(20%) 2(20%) - - 10% 20% 6 9 0 0 - 0 - / -14(1-20) - 0 - / Included in Rao et al. 2012 P=0,782 P=0,315 P=0,005 P=0,669 Tsinberg(18) Cleveland-USA 2009 31 8BiS 23S 43 28S Malign + Benign 0 0 0 4(13%) 7(16%) 122.5 ± 45.4 299,6 ± 33,6 - - 201 ± 15 172 ± 12 3.2 ± 1 6.8 ± 0.7 0 0 - 8,2±2 - 2(18%) - / - 8,5±1,3 - 1(3%) - / Included in Rao et al. 2012 Has financial analysis P=0,7 P=0,002 P=0,1 P=0,004 - P=0,9 - / - / Abu Southampton-UK 2008 24 24LLS 20 20LLS Malign + Benign 0 0 0 13% 25% 80 470 - - 180 155 3,5 (1-6) 7 (3-12) 0 0 -12(4-40) Included in Rao et al. 2012. Duplicated in Ref. 6. All cases excluded form the count P=0,541 P=0,002 P=0,885 P<0,001 P=1 Aldrighetti(20) Milan-Italy 2008 20 20LLS 20 20LLS Malign + Benign 0 0 0 2(10%) 5(25%) 165 ± 43 214 ± 47 0 0 260±50 220±30 4.5 ± 0.6 5.8 ± 1.6 0 0 -11±3 -13±5 Well-matched cohorts Included in Rao et al. 2012 Duplicated paper in Ref 12. Excluded 16 cases from open(8) and lap(8) P=NS P=0,001 P=NS P=0,003 P=NS
SLA_2015_03_13_WAKABAYASHI_1402188_SDC2.docx