Aesthetic Appreciation Rubric Category Emerging Developing Proficient Exemplary 1 2 3 4 Creative Lacks recognition Has difficulty Adequately Clearly recognizes and interpretation of recognizing recognizes and and interprets the Expression the creative interpreting the interprets the complexity and expression in any of creative expression creative expression creative expression the works. in the works. in more than one in a variety of variety of work. works. Analytical Response is not Response is Response is Response is analytical, and is minimally analytical, analytical, and is significantly Response missing concrete and is supported supported with two analytical, and is details, personal with only one of the out of the following supported with all of perceptions and following: concrete three: concrete the following: personal associations details, personal details, personal concrete details, about the work. perceptions or perceptions and personal perceptions personal associations personal associations and personal about the work. about the work. associations about the work. Natural Systems and the Environment Rubric
Category Emerging 1 Developing 2 Proficient 3 Exemplary 4 Creative Expression Lacks recognition and interpretation of the creative expression in any of the works. Has difficulty recognizing interpreting the creative expression in the works. Adequately recognizes and interprets the creative expression in more than one variety of work. Clearly recognizes and interprets the complexity and creative expression in a variety of works. Analytical Response Response is not analytical, and is missing concrete details, personal perceptions and personal associations about the work. Response is minimally analytical, and is supported with only one of the following: concrete details, personal perceptions or personal associations about the work. Response is analytical, and is supported with two out of the following three: concrete details, personal perceptions and personal associations about the work. Response is significantly analytical, and is supported with all of the following: concrete details, personal perceptions and personal associations about the work. Aesthetic Appreciation Rubric Natural Systems and the Environment Rubric
rubric-samples.docx