Counter-argument all the definitions are not contradictory – Evaluation and conclusion to belief in miracles are effective.’ Evaluate this view ‘Challenges Hume, science complete using booklet 3 and pages Challenges to belief in miracles are effective e.g. – 79-81 of the old WJEC textbook David Hume reasoned that it is not possible to prove that miracles occur, as they are a violation of natural laws. His argument may be summarised as: The laws of nature are based on past experience. The reliability of the witness is in The witness is sympathetic to the idea of miracles. Stories of miracles tend to be common amongst ignorant and barbarous communities All religions base their truth claims on the miraculous, but they cannot all be right. In an AO2 answer you need to evaluate and not list each challenge are they effective –
Counter-argument – all the definitions are not contradictory Evaluation and conclusion ‘Challenges to belief in miracles are effective.’ Evaluate this view Challenges to belief in miracles are effective e.g. Hume, science – complete using booklet 3 and pages 79-81 of the old WJEC textbook David Hume reasoned that it is not possible to prove that miracles occur, as they are a violation of natural laws. His argument may be summarised as: The laws of nature are based on past experience. The reliability of the witness is in The witness is sympathetic to the idea of miracles. Stories of miracles tend to be common amongst ignorant and barbarous communities All religions base their truth claims on the miraculous, but they cannot all be right. In an AO2 answer you need to evaluate and not list each challenge – are they effective
2-d-e-and-f-evaluation-booklet.docx