Ghent-Belgium 1maj 2maj P=0,176 P=0,673 P=0,008 P=NS 19min 18min 29 22 2(6,8%) 4(18,2%) 603 ± 525 655 ± 569 236 ± 135 220 ± 61 8.8 ± 4.4 13 ± 9.2 Cai(99) Benign 2007 26min 0 0 1(3,3%) - - 1(3,4%) 1(3,4%) - - Hangzhou-China P=0,424 P=0,737 P=0,589 P=0,045 3maj 2maj 241 100 No P values as no Koffron(100) comparisons Malign + 20(6%) to 2007 175min 49min 0 0 9,3% 22% 100 325 0 8% 95 182 1,7 5,4 2(0,8%) 4(4%) - - Benign H-assisted Illinois-USA Included in Rao et al. 2012 51maj 17 288(50-150) 485 2,8 4,5 2,9 (1-14) 6,5 100 Malign + Included in Rao 2004 5maj 1(5,8%) - - 4(23%) - - - 1(5,8%) - - - Benign et al. 2012 Ohio-USA ¿ P<0,05 P<0,05 P<0,05 16min Primary Shelat resection 19 -/ Potential Malign + 2014 - 0 - 0 1(5,2%) - 100 (50-275) - - - 165 (90-203) - 4(1-8) - 0 - -1(5,2%) - duplication in Benign (102) Ref. 153. 2 major resections 2maj -/ excluded from Southampton-UK analysis Repeat lap liver SERIES resection on Shelat same population 20 -/ CLINICAL as before Malign + 400 285 2014 - 0 - 3 (15%) 2(10%) - - - - - 4(1-57) - 1(5%) - -2(10%) - Potential Benign (102) duplication in Ref. 153. 6 major 6maj -/ resections Southampton-UK excluded from analysis
Ghent-Belgium 1maj 19min 2maj 18min P=0,176 P=0,673 P=0,008 P=NS Cai(99) Hangzhou-China 2007 29 26min 3maj 22 2maj Benign 0 0 1(3,3%) 2(6,8%) 4(18,2%) 603 ± 525 655 ± 569 - - 236 ± 135 220 ± 61 8.8 ± 4.4 13 ± 9.2 1(3,4%) 1(3,4%) - - P=0,424 P=0,737 P=0,589 P=0,045 Koffron(100) Illinois-USA 2007 241 175min 100 49min 51maj Malign + Benign 0 0 20(6%) to H-assisted 9,3% 22% 100 325 0 8% 95 182 1,7 5,4 2(0,8%) 4(4%) - - No P values as no comparisons Included in Rao et al. 2012 Ohio-USA 2004 17 5maj 16min 100 ¿ Malign + Benign 1(5,8%) - - 4(23%) - 288(50-150) 485 - - 2,8 4,5 2,9 (1-14) 6,5 1(5,8%) - - - Included in Rao et al. 2012 P<0,05 P<0,05 P<0,05 CLINICAL SERIES Shelat (102) Southampton-UK 2014 19 2maj - Malign + Benign 0 - 0 1(5,2%) - 100 (50-275) - - - 165 (90-203) - 4(1-8) - 0 - -/ -1(5,2%) -/ - Primary resection Potential duplication in Ref. 153. 2 major resections excluded from analysis Shelat (102) Southampton-UK 2014 20 6maj - Malign + Benign 0 - 3 (15%) 2(10%) - 400 - - - 285 - 4(1-57) - 1(5%) - -/ -2(10%) -/ - Repeat lap liver resection on same population as before Potential duplication in Ref. 153. 6 major resections excluded from analysis
SLA_2015_03_13_WAKABAYASHI_1402188_SDC2.docx