development proposals Third SEA identified air Same as above Plan: Outcomes measured: comprehensive a) Process outcomes: quality degradation as transport study (i) Health outcomes well as noise pollution considered: Y (ii) Health Method of appraisal: SEA applied too late in recommendations SEA decision-making incorporated in plan: process, once Y development options were already formulated NB: but see results and sanctioned to proceed (iii) Evidence of being implemented: unclear (iv) Post-development SEA has been evaluation: N/R development led, failure to apply SEA at b) Specific outcomes: formulation stage has (i) Physical activity: N/R resulted in limited (ii) Mental wellbeing: N/R development (iii) Air / noise quality etc: alternatives being Y explored to avoid (iv) Unintentional injury: environmental N/R degradation (air and (v) Other health: Y Specify: noise) Cultural heritage c) Knowledge outcome: Planners health SEA has helped to knowledge or skills: N/R integrate and balance environmental d) outcome: N/R concerns with the Specify: ambitious land use and transport development demands of a prosperous and growing population but SEA limited:
development proposals Same as above Plan: Third comprehensive transport study Method of appraisal: SEA Outcomes measured: a) Process outcomes: (i) Health outcomes considered: Y (ii) Health recommendations incorporated in plan: Y NB: but see results (iii) Evidence of being implemented: unclear (iv) Post-development evaluation: N/R b) Specific outcomes: (i) Physical activity: N/R (ii) Mental wellbeing: N/R (iii) Air / noise quality etc: Y (iv) Unintentional injury: N/R (v) Other health: Y Specify: Cultural heritage c) Knowledge outcome: Planners health knowledge or skills: N/R d) outcome: N/R Specify: SEA identified air quality degradation as well as noise pollution SEA applied too late in decision-making process, once development options were already formulated and sanctioned to proceed SEA has been development led, failure to apply SEA at formulation stage has resulted in limited development alternatives being explored to avoid environmental degradation (air and noise) SEA has helped to integrate and balance environmental concerns with the ambitious land use and transport development demands of a prosperous and growing population but SEA limited:
Spatial_planning_for_Health_Review2_Final_1_April_2010_rev_21_April.docx