Delivery 20 points 15 points 10 points Speaker will do the following Speaker will do the following at Speaker will do the following less at least 90% of the time: least 80% of the time: than 80% of the time: maintain good eye maintain good eye contact maintain good eye contact contact with with audience with audience audience use a clear audible voice use a audible voice use a audible Use an appropriate rate of Use appropriate rate of voice speech speech Use an appropriate use correct pronunciation uses correct pronunciation rate of speech use correct pronunciation Comprehension and 25 points 15 points 5 points Student answers questions Student answers questions from Student is unable to answer Accuracy from audience providing at audience providing at least 1 questions from audience or give any least 2 accurate scientific accurate scientific fact. accurate facts. Quality of 20 points 15 points 5 points Student justifies his best Student justifies his best solution Student is unable to justify his best Individual solution with at least 3 with at 2 accurate facts solution with accurate facts. Explanation accurate facts related to related to materials, time, and materials, time, and costs. costs. Quality of 25 points 20 points 15 points Reasons given for supporting Reasons given for supporting the Reasons given for supporting the Justification the group’s “Best Solution” is group’s “Best Solution” is based on group’s “Best Solution” is not Explanation based on at least 3 accurate at least 2 accurate scientific facts. accurate. scientific facts. Reflection 10 points 5 points 3 points Student will answer all Student answers at least 80% of Student answers less than 80% of Questionnaire questions on the survey. questions on the survey. questions on the survey. Scoring Guide: EX: 90-100 pts. AP: 50-69 pts PR: 70-89 pts. ND: Below 50 pts Alternative Solutions; Solution Analysis: Two “Best” Solution #1: As the Director of Emergency Planning of Palm Beach County I believe that containing the oil spill with booms and collecting it from the water surface using skimmer equipment is the best solution. Spilt oil floats on water and will initially form a slick of a few millimeters thick. There
Delivery 20 points Speaker will do the following at least 90% of the time: maintain good eye contact with audience use a audible voice Use an appropriate rate of speech use correct pronunciation 15 points Speaker will do the following at least 80% of the time: maintain good eye contact with audience use a clear audible voice Use an appropriate rate of speech use correct pronunciation 10 points Speaker will do the following less than 80% of the time: maintain good eye contact with audience use a audible voice Use appropriate rate of speech uses correct pronunciation Comprehension and Accuracy 25 points Student answers questions from audience providing at least 2 accurate scientific facts. 15 points Student answers questions from audience providing at least 1 accurate scientific fact. 5 points Student is unable to answer questions from audience or give any accurate Quality of Individual Explanation 20 points Student justifies his best solution with at least 3 accurate facts related to materials, time, and costs. 15 points Student justifies his best solution with at 2 accurate facts related to materials, time, and costs. 5 points Student is unable to justify his best solution with accurate facts. Quality of Justification Explanation 25 points Reasons given for supporting the group’s “Best Solution” is based on at least 3 accurate scientific facts. 20 points Reasons given for supporting the group’s “Best Solution” is based on at least 2 accurate scientific facts. 15 points Reasons given for supporting the group’s “Best Solution” is not accurate. Reflection Questionnaire 10 points Student will answer all questions on the survey. 5 points Student answers at least 80% of questions on the survey. 3 points Student answers less than 80% of questions on the survey. Scoring Guide: EX: 90-100 pts. AP: 50-69 pts PR: 70-89 pts. ND: Below 50 pts Two Alternative Solutions; “Best” Solution Analysis: Solution #1: As the Director of Emergency Planning of Palm Beach County I believe that containing the oil spill with booms and collecting it from the water surface using skimmer equipment is the best solution. Spilt oil floats on water and will initially form a slick of a few millimeters thick. There
smith-pbl-1-final.docx