3.4.5 Outcome summary table: HIA of plans in non UK high income countries • Evidence of inclusion evidence of inclusion NR Not reported NA Not applicable UC Unclear О No Process outcomes Specific health issues Significant finding comments considered Author, Topic PA MW EHI UI O Year score evidence of validity score issues recommendations adoption Health Health Post Quality Evidence External considered incorporated implementation NB: Evidence of implementation and Post Corburn, J. USA and Bhatia, adoption evidence: NA as ENCHIA R. Rezoning plan ongoing at time of writing. (2007) for the Eastern Neighborhoods ENCHIA has got potential to influence of San policy: Francisco Provides a forum for citizens to enter into and frame planning issues HIA outside but ENCHIA reflects broader political parallel to a • • • • community consensus than at project level - + ++ UC NA NR NR NA planning Trinity and Rincon Hill’s HIAs1) process and its HIA outside EIA can transform formal planning by generating new evidence environmental with impacted stakeholders review Eastern Neighborhoods Community HIA (ENCHIA)
3.4.5 Outcome summary table: HIA of plans in non UK high income countries • Evidence of inclusion О No evidence of inclusion NR Not reported NA Not applicable UC Unclear Process outcomes Specific health issues considered Quality score External validity score Significant finding comments Author, Year Topic Health issues considered Health recommendations incorporated Evidence of implementation Post adoption evidence PA MW EHI UI O Corburn, J. and Bhatia, R. (2007) USA Rezoning plan for the Eastern Neighborhoods of San Francisco HIA outside but parallel to a community planning process and its formal environmental review Eastern Neighborhoods Community HIA (ENCHIA) • UC NA NA • • NR NR • + ++ NB: Evidence of implementation and Post adoption evidence: NA as ENCHIA ongoing at time of writing. ENCHIA has got potential to influence policy: Provides a forum for citizens to enter into and frame planning issues ENCHIA reflects broader political consensus than at project level - Trinity and Rincon Hill’s HIAs1) HIA outside EIA can transform planning by generating new evidence with impacted stakeholders
Spatial_planning_for_Health_Review2_Final_1_April_2010_rev_21_April.docx