3.4.2 Outcome summary table: HIA of plans in the UK • Evidence of inclusion evidence of inclusion NR Not reported NA Not applicable UC Unclear О No Process outcomes Specific health issues Significant finding comments considered Author, Topic PA MW EHI UI O Year score of validity issues adoption Quality Health Health Evidence Post External evidence considered recommendations incorporated implementation HIA of can make explicit the health Douglas, M., “HIA Conway, L., Edinburgh consequences of decisions in different Gorman, D., City sectors, including impacts on health Gavin, S., Council’s inequalities. HIA should be done as part Hanlon, P. Local of community planning & other (2001) Transport • • • • • partnership activities & should become + + UC NR NR Strategy. NR part of routine decision making.” Timing is key: must be part of an iterative process & considered at all stages of plan making, in order to influence decision making. Douglas M, HIA of West For all the case studies below: brief Thomson, H, Yorkshire summaries of completed HIAs not – Jepson, R, local critically appraised or evaluated Hurley, F, transport • • • • Higgins M, ++ ++ NR NR NR NR NR plan 2000 HIA recommended to Muirie J, Gorman D Promote physical activity (2007) Work with transport professionals trans[ort plans in NHS HIA of City of HIA Supported high cost scenario (out of Douglas, M, • • • • • • Douglas M, Edinburgh NR ++ ++ NR NR 3 scenarios based on different levels of Thomson, H, Council funding) and made recommendations to
3.4.2 Outcome summary table: HIA of plans in the UK • Evidence of inclusion О No evidence of inclusion NR Not reported NA Not applicable UC Unclear Process outcomes Specific health issues considered Quality External validity score Significant finding comments Author, Year Topic Health issues considered Health recommendations incorporated Evidence of implementation Post adoption evidence PA MW EHI UI O Douglas, M., Conway, L., Gorman, D., Gavin, S., Hanlon, P. (2001) HIA of Edinburgh City Council’s Local Transport Strategy. • UC NR NR • NR • • • + + “HIA can make explicit the health consequences of decisions in different sectors, including impacts on health inequalities. HIA should be done as part of community planning & other partnership activities & should become part of routine decision making.” Timing is key: must be part of an iterative process & considered at all stages of plan making, in order to influence decision making. Douglas M, Thomson, H, Jepson, R, Hurley, F, Higgins M, Muirie J, Gorman D (2007) HIA of West Yorkshire local transport plan 2000 • NR NR NR • NR • • NR ++ ++ For all the case studies below: brief summaries of completed HIAs – not critically appraised or evaluated HIA recommended to Promote physical activity Work with transport professionals trans[ort plans in NHS Douglas, M, Douglas M, Thomson, H, HIA of City of Edinburgh Council • NR NR NR • • • • • ++ ++ HIA Supported high cost scenario (out of 3 scenarios based on different levels of funding) and made recommendations to
Spatial_planning_for_Health_Review2_Final_1_April_2010_rev_21_April.docx