Below Target (0 Above Target (2 Category At Target (1 point) points) points) Rephrases the Rephrases the Rephrases the Defining the problem with limited problem clearly problem clearly and Problem clarity precisely Brainstorming Contributes few or Contributes a Contributes multiple a Solution implausible ideas plausible idea plausible ideas Contributes ideas Contributes one Contributes multiple plausible idea plausible ideas Produces incomplete sketches Produces marginally Produces accurate Generating accurate pictorial and pictorial and Does not present a Ideas orthographic sketches orthographic concept of design concepts sketches of design concepts Does not restate the Restates the criteria Restates the criteria Identifying criteria clearly and clearly and identifies clearly and precisely Criteria fails to identify several constraints and identifies many constraints constraints Inadequately Satisfactorily analyzes Thoroughly analyzes analyzes the pluses the pluses and the pluses and Exploring and minuses of a minuses of a variety minuses of a variety Possibilities variety of possible of possible solutions of possible solutions solutions Selection of solution Selects a promising Selects a promising is not based on solution based on solution based on a Selecting an consideration of criteria and thorough analysis Approach criteria and criteria and constraints constraints constraints Making a Prototype meets the Prototype meets the Prototype meets the Model or task criteria to a task criteria task criteria in Prototype limited extent insightful ways Testing and Testing and Testing processes Testing and evaluation processes evaluation processes are innovative evaluating the are inadequate are adequate for Design refining the problem solution Refinement based Refinements made Significant on testing and based on testing and improvement in the Refining the evaluation is not evaluation results design is made Design evident based on prototype testing and evaluation
Category Below Target (0 points) At Target (1 point) Above Target (2 points) Defining the Problem Rephrases the problem with limited clarity Rephrases the problem clearly Rephrases the problem clearly and precisely Brainstorming a Solution Contributes few or implausible ideas Contributes a plausible idea Contributes multiple plausible ideas Generating Ideas Contributes ideas Produces incomplete sketches Does not present a concept Contributes one plausible idea Produces marginally accurate pictorial and orthographic sketches of design concepts Contributes multiple plausible ideas Produces accurate pictorial and orthographic sketches of design concepts Identifying Criteria Does not restate the criteria clearly and fails to identify constraints Restates the criteria clearly and identifies several constraints Restates the criteria clearly and precisely and identifies many constraints Exploring Possibilities Inadequately analyzes the pluses and minuses of a variety of possible solutions Satisfactorily analyzes the pluses and minuses of a variety of possible solutions Thoroughly analyzes the pluses and minuses of a variety of possible solutions Selecting an Approach Selection of solution is not based on consideration of criteria and constraints Selects a promising solution based on criteria and constraints Selects a promising solution based on a thorough analysis criteria and constraints Making a Model or Prototype Prototype meets the task criteria to a limited extent Prototype meets the task criteria Prototype meets the task criteria in insightful ways Testing and evaluating the Design Testing and evaluation processes are inadequate Testing and evaluation processes are adequate for refining the problem solution Testing processes are innovative Refining the Design Refinement based on testing and evaluation is not evident Refinements made based on testing and evaluation results Significant improvement in the design is made based on prototype testing and evaluation
Product%20Design%20Rubric.docx