Progress Update Report Rubric Team: ___________________________________ Reviewer:_____________________________________ Criteria or Requirement Comments Points Front Matter Title page revised as required /2 Executive Summary revised and updated including summary of progress to date ToC/LoF/LoT revised and updated Problem Definition /1 Section revised and updated Need Identification /1 Section revised and updated Design Concepts /1 Section revised and updated Concept Evaluation and Selection /1 Section revised and updated Embodiment Design /5 Section revised and updated Progress Ideally includes results, analysis, and discussion of prototype test plan Discussion includes redesign considerations including calculations, modeling, and updated drawings, as necessary /40 At a minimum describes the decision making process from detail design to present capturing decision points, considerations, choices, implementation, and outcomes if available Project Deliverables /1 Section revised and updated Project Management Discussion of progress with respect to the project management plan established in the detail /26 design report Includes detailed plan of execution Budget /1 Section revised and updated References /1 Section revised and updated Appendix - Engineering Drawings /5 Section revised and updated Formatting Figure/table formatting (centered, numbered, captioned, referenced) /5 Justification and pagination Clean and professional appearance Style Strong, logical narrative Correct voice (third person) /10 Appropriate tense consistent with narrative for each section – Grammar and spelling; evidence of proofreading Overall /100
Progress Update Report Rubric Team: ___________________________________ Reviewer:_____________________________________ Criteria or Requirement Comments Points Front Matter Title page revised as required Executive Summary revised and updated including summary of progress to date ToC/LoF/LoT revised and updated /2 Problem Definition Section revised and updated /1 Need Identification Section revised and updated /1 Design Concepts Section revised and updated /1 Concept Evaluation and Selection Section revised and updated /1 Embodiment Design Section revised and updated /5 Progress Ideally includes results, analysis, and discussion of prototype test plan Discussion includes redesign considerations including calculations, modeling, and updated drawings, as necessary At a minimum describes the decision making process from detail design to present capturing decision points, considerations, choices, implementation, and outcomes if available /40 Project Deliverables Section revised and updated /1 Project Management Discussion of progress with respect to the project management plan established in the detail design report Includes detailed plan of execution /26 Budget Section revised and updated /1 References Section revised and updated /1 Appendix - Engineering Drawings Section revised and updated /5 Formatting Figure/table formatting (centered, numbered, captioned, referenced) Justification and pagination Clean and professional appearance /5 Style Strong, logical narrative Correct voice (third person) Appropriate tense – consistent with narrative for each section Grammar and spelling; evidence of proofreading /10 Overall /100
Project%20Guidance%20-%20Design%20AY15%20v3.docx