Engineering Design I/II - Capstone Design Project Guidance Progress Update Presentation Rubric Team: _______________________________________________ Reviewer:____________________________________________ Topic Unsatisfactory Below Expectations Meets Expectations Possible Awarded Project Motivation/ Not included or significantly Included, but insufficient detail for Problem presented in a clear and 5 Problem Definition incomplete an unfamiliar audience concise manner; context understood Included but incomplete or Not included, significantly Well-defined, concise list with Summary of CRs/ECs unrevised from previous 5 incomplete, or unrelated quantitative descriptors presentation Assembly represented; limited Assembly complete; high level of Not included or significantly Detail Design Overview detail; limited description of detail; concise summary of 5 incomplete form/function form/function Moving forward; correlation Detailed discussion of progress between results, analysis, and capturing results, analysis, and Not included or significantly discussion insufficient or unclear; discussion and/or decision-making Progress 30 incomplete insufficient capture of process. All team members working process. Some together to achieve project social evident. objectives loafing Behind on project management plan On track with established project due largely to avoidable challenges. management plan. Current stage Extremely poor time management; Current stage unclear or Plans for Completion clearly stated, supported with unrealistic expectations. Successful unsupported with evidence. 30 Project management evidence. Detailed plan of completion unlikely. Optimistic expectations for execution for project completion. completion. Likely will require Successful completion likely significant extra time Insufficient revision/level of detail Detailed and complete with revised Budget Missing or incomplete 5 for conclusive projection cost estimates Unpracticed, unorganized, and Evidence of preparation but some Communication clarity Obvious preparation; professional unengaging; not focused on rambling or tangents; slides 10 and visual presentation speech; slides visually stimulating audience adequate Complete within time 10 min < time < 13 min or 10 min > time > 18 min 13 min < time < 15 min 10 allotted 15 min < time < 18 min Total Score (out of 100) ______ Comments:
Engineering Design I/II - Capstone Design Project Guidance Progress Update Presentation Rubric Team: _______________________________________________ Reviewer:____________________________________________ Topic Unsatisfactory Below Expectations Meets Expectations Possible Awarded Project Motivation/ Problem Definition Not included or significantly incomplete Included, but insufficient detail for an unfamiliar audience Problem presented in a clear and concise manner; context understood 5 Summary of CRs/ECs Not included, significantly incomplete, or unrelated Included but incomplete or unrevised from previous presentation Well-defined, concise list with quantitative descriptors 5 Detail Design Overview Not included or significantly incomplete Assembly represented; limited detail; limited description of form/function Assembly complete; high level of detail; concise summary of form/function 5 Progress Not included or significantly incomplete Moving forward; correlation between results, analysis, and discussion insufficient or unclear; insufficient capture of process. Some social loafing evident. Detailed discussion of progress capturing results, analysis, and discussion and/or decision-making process. All team members working together to achieve project objectives 30 Plans for Completion Project management Extremely poor time management; unrealistic expectations. Successful completion unlikely. Behind on project management plan due largely to avoidable challenges. Current stage unclear or unsupported with evidence. Optimistic expectations for completion. Likely will require significant extra time On track with established project management plan. Current stage clearly stated, supported with evidence. Detailed plan of execution for project completion. Successful completion likely 30 Budget Missing or incomplete Insufficient revision/level of detail for conclusive projection Detailed and complete with revised cost estimates 5 Communication clarity and visual presentation Unpracticed, unorganized, and unengaging; not focused on audience Evidence of preparation but some rambling or tangents; slides adequate Obvious preparation; professional speech; slides visually stimulating 10 Complete within time allotted 10 min > time > 18 min 10 min < time < 13 min or 15 min < time < 18 min 13 min < time < 15 min 10 Comments: Total Score (out of 100) ______
Project%20Guidance%20-%20Design%20AY15%20v3.docx