Thesis Grading Rubric Student’s name _________________________________________ Date: _____________________ Evaluated by: ___________________________________________ Thesis title: ___________________________________________________________________________ Please check level for each criterion. Level of Achievement Criteria High Distinction Distinction Pass Fail Follows Thesis perfectly Thesis consistently Thesis generally Thesis fails to thesis adheres to adheres to adheres to adhere to Chicago guidelines Chicago Manual of Chicago Manual of Chicago Manual of Manual of Style and and SHMS Style guidelines Style and SHMS SHMS thesis thesis guidelines and SHMS thesis thesis guidelines. guidelines. (including length of guidelines. 75-100 pages, appropriate citation methods, correct font and layout). Shows a Thesis Thesis Thesis Thesis command demonstrates an demonstrates an demonstrates demonstrates little of the advanced adequate some command of or no command of subject command of the command of the the subject. the subject. subject; thesis subject; thesis makes a demonstrates contribution to the significant ability to field or could easily do research in the be developed into a doctoral level thesis. Shows Thesis Thesis Thesis Thesis fails to appropriate demonstrates demonstrates demonstrates demonstrate use of excellent selection good selection of some appropriate appropriate research of appropriate appropriate selection of selection of sources; sources; sources; sources; fails to demonstrate demonstrates a demonstrates a demonstrates a adequate grasp of strong grasp of good grasp of limited grasp of sources or to use sources; sources; usually the sources; less sources consistently uses makes appropriate consistently appropriately. sources use of sources. makes appropriate appropriately. use of sources.
Thesis Grading Rubric Student’s name _________________________________________ Date: _____________________ Evaluated by: ___________________________________________ Thesis title: ___________________________________________________________________________ Please check level for each criterion. Criteria Level of Achievement High Distinction Distinction Pass Fail Follows thesis guidelines Thesis perfectly adheres to Chicago Manual of and SHMS thesis guidelines (including length of 75-100 pages, appropriate citation methods, correct font and layout). Thesis consistently adheres to Chicago Manual of Style guidelines and SHMS thesis guidelines. Thesis generally adheres to Chicago Manual of Style and SHMS thesis guidelines. Thesis fails to adhere to Chicago Manual of Style and SHMS thesis guidelines. Shows a command of the subject Thesis demonstrates an advanced command of the subject; thesis makes a contribution to the field or could easily be developed into a doctoral level thesis. Thesis demonstrates an adequate command of the subject; thesis demonstrates significant ability to do research in the Thesis demonstrates some command of the subject. Thesis demonstrates little or no command of the subject. Shows appropriate use of research Thesis demonstrates excellent selection of appropriate sources; demonstrates a strong grasp of sources; consistently uses sources appropriately. Thesis demonstrates good selection of appropriate sources; demonstrates a good grasp of sources; usually makes appropriate use of sources. Thesis demonstrates some appropriate selection of sources; demonstrates a limited grasp of the sources; less consistently makes appropriate use of sources. Thesis fails to demonstrate appropriate selection of sources; fails to demonstrate adequate grasp of sources or to use sources appropriately.
Revised%20STL%20Thesis%20Rubric%2C%20REVISED_0.docx