No Solvo Juries agree with judges most of the time anyway [this card might also help affs argue against arguments from the neg] ‘wrong decision’-type Brooks 04 Thom, prof of law and @ of Jury Res Publica 10, gov’t Durham, “A Defence Nullification,” 2004, [, , ] when held to this standard, juries may be said to make is, ‘correct’ decisions–that Nevertheless, they agree with the decisions of judges–at least seventy five percent of the time.39 This is not to say that juries incorrectly decide one quarter of all cases, but rather that judges would have decided differently in those cases. In these instances, critics charge juries with making mistakes. That is, verdicts delivered by juries that differ from verdicts judges would have delivered are thought to be not only a disagreement between juries and judges, but a disagreement where the judges are thought to be Of course, the decisions of judges are not always correct and, therefore, their correct. decisions cannot provide us with an absolute measure of what a correct decision would be in any particular case.
No Solvo Juries agree with judges most of the time anyway [this card might also help affs argue against ‘wrong decision’-type arguments from the neg] Brooks 04 Thom, prof of law and gov’t @ Durham, “A Defence of Jury Nullification,” Res Publica 10, 2004, [, , ] Nevertheless, when held to this standard, juries may be said to make ‘correct’ decisions–that is, they agree with the decisions of judges–at least seventy five percent of the time.39 This is not to say that juries incorrectly decide one quarter of all cases, but rather that judges would have decided differently in those cases. In these instances, critics charge juries with making mistakes. That is, verdicts delivered by juries that differ from verdicts judges would have delivered are thought to be not only a disagreement between juries and judges, but a disagreement where the judges are thought to be correct. Of course, the decisions of judges are not always correct and, therefore, their decisions cannot provide us with an absolute measure of what a correct decision would be in any particular case.
Premier-Debate-Brief-ND15.docx