Argument OA is more Counter argument The CA and Evaluation –The – – persuasive TA are more persuasive A priori - reason A posteriori - experience Deductive In conclusion, challenges to the ontological argument are convincing.’ Assess this view ‘The Argument the challenges are Counter argument the Evaluation – – – convincing/ effective/persuasive challenges are not convincing/ effective/persuasive Challenges to a priori and However, deductive arguments are deductive arguments logical Gaunilo’s challenge Anselm’s response and challenges to Gaunilo Aquinas’ challenge
Argument –The OA is more persuasive Counter – argument – The CA and TA are more persuasive Evaluation A priori - reason A posteriori - experience Deductive In conclusion, ‘The challenges to the ontological argument are convincing.’ Assess this view Argument – the challenges are convincing/ effective/persuasive Counter – argument – the challenges are not convincing/ effective/persuasive Evaluation Challenges to a priori and deductive arguments However, deductive arguments are logical Gaunilo’s challenge Anselm’s response and challenges to Gaunilo Aquinas’ challenge
1d-e-and-f-deductive-arguments-booklet.docx