Using metric for savings, efforts will have been PG&E’s A4NR’s effective if the time needed for wet storage is reduced by 2 hours. By contributing to the preference for a 7-year planning Commission’s assumption over asserted 10-year (down from 12 years in the last PG&E’s NDCTP) requirement, reducing costs by nearly $197 million, A4NR’s intervention has already produced ratepayer benefits far in excess of the amount of this compensation request. b. Reasonableness of hours claimed: Due to the limitations A4NR agreed Verified to in the Joint Proposal for the Retirement of Diablo Canyon, A4NR’s participation in this proceeding was surgically focused on remedying inattention to wet storage requirements during the pre-shutdown PG&E’s period. A4NR coordinated its efforts with TURN to avoid duplication, and expended a minimal number of hours to accomplish its carefully targeted objective. c. Allocation of hours by issue: Pre-shutdown study, 80%; PG&E burden Verified of proof, 20%. Specific Claim:* Claimed CPUC Award ATTORNEY, EXPERT, AND ADVOCATE FEES Basis for Item Year Hours Rate $ Rate* Total $ Hours Rate $ Total $ John 2016 19.97 575 D.16-07-010, 11,482.75 19.72 $580.00 $11,437.60 Geesman Res. John 2017 2.56 585 D.16-07-010, 1,497.60 2.56 $590.00 $1,510.40 Geesman Res. Rochelle 2016 1.33 140 D.16-07-010, 186.00 1.33 $140.00 $186.20 Becker Res. Rochelle 2017 .95 145 D.16-07-010, 138.00 .40 $145.00 $58.00 Becker Res. Subtotal: $13,192.20 Subtotal: $ 13,304.35 INTERVENOR COMPENSATION CLAIM PREPARATION ** Item Year Hours Rate $ Basis for Total $ Hours Rate Total $ Rate*
Using PG&E’s metric for savings, A4NR’s efforts will have been if the time needed for wet storage is reduced by 2 hours. By contributing to the Commission’s preference for a 7-year planning assumption over PG&E’s asserted 10-year (down from 12 years in the last NDCTP) requirement, reducing costs by nearly $197 million, A4NR’s intervention has already produced ratepayer benefits far in excess of the amount of this compensation request. b. Reasonableness of hours claimed: Due to the limitations A4NR agreed to in the Joint Proposal for the Retirement of Diablo Canyon, A4NR’s participation in this proceeding was surgically focused on remedying PG&E’s inattention to wet storage requirements during the pre-shutdown period. A4NR coordinated its efforts with TURN to avoid duplication, and expended a minimal number of hours to accomplish its carefully targeted objective. Verified c. Allocation of hours by issue: Pre-shutdown study, 80%; PG&E burden of proof, 20%. Verified Specific Claim:* Claimed CPUC Award ATTORNEY, EXPERT, AND ADVOCATE FEES Item Year Hours Rate $ Basis for Rate* Total $ Hours Rate $ Total $ John Geesman 2016 19.97 575 D.16-07-010, Res. 11,482.75 19.72 $580.00 $11,437.60 John Geesman 2017 2.56 585 D.16-07-010, Res. 1,497.60 2.56 $590.00 $1,510.40 Rochelle Becker 2016 1.33 140 D.16-07-010, Res. 186.00 1.33 $140.00 $186.20 Rochelle Becker 2017 .95 145 D.16-07-010, Res. 138.00 .40 $145.00 $58.00 Subtotal: $ 13,304.35 Subtotal: $13,192.20 INTERVENOR COMPENSATION CLAIM PREPARATION ** Item Year Hours Rate $ Basis for Rate* Total $ Hours Rate Total $ effective
195687121.docx