Engineering Design I/II - Capstone Design Project Guidance Preliminary Design Presentation Rubric Team: _______________________________________________ Reviewer:____________________________________________ Topic Unsatisfactory Below Expectations Meets Expectations Possible Awarded Project Motivation/ Not included or significantly Included, but insufficient detail for an Problem presented in a clear and 5 Problem Definition incomplete unfamiliar audience concise manner; context understood Not included, significantly incomplete, Included but incomplete or unrevised Well-defined, concise list with Summary of CRs/ECs 5 or unrelated from previous presentation quantitative descriptors Three DCs included but One DC per team member; Not included or significantly Design Concepts prediction insufficient; complete, thoughtful 40 incomplete unclear if meets constraints analysis; shown to meet constraints Concept Evaluation and Not included or significantly Design selected but methods unclear or Design selected; clear description of 20 Selection incomplete of questionable objectivity methods and outcome Missing milestones or unrealistic Optimistic expectations; likely will Key milestones clearly identified; Plans for Completion 5 expectations require significant extra time timely completion expected Insufficient revision/level of detail for Detailed and complete with revised Budget Missing or incomplete 5 conclusive projection cost estimates Communication Clarity Unpracticed, unorganized, and Evidence of preparation but some Obvious preparation; professional 10 and Visual Presentation unengaging; not focused on audience rambling or tangents; slides adequate speech; slides visually stimulating Complete Within Time 10 min < time < 13 min or 10 min > time > 18 min 13 min < time < 15 min 10 Allotted 15 min < time < 18 min Total Score (out of 100) ______ Comments:
Engineering Design I/II - Capstone Design Project Guidance Preliminary Design Presentation Rubric Team: _______________________________________________ Reviewer:____________________________________________ Topic Unsatisfactory Below Expectations Meets Expectations Possible Awarded Project Motivation/ Problem Definition Not included or significantly incomplete Included, but insufficient detail for an unfamiliar audience Problem presented in a clear and concise manner; context understood 5 Summary of CRs/ECs Not included, significantly incomplete, or unrelated Included but incomplete or unrevised from previous presentation Well-defined, concise list with quantitative descriptors 5 Design Concepts Not included or significantly incomplete Three DCs included but prediction insufficient; unclear if meets constraints One DC per team member; complete, thoughtful analysis; shown to meet constraints 40 Concept Evaluation and Selection Not included or significantly incomplete Design selected but methods unclear or of questionable objectivity Design selected; clear description of methods and outcome 20 Plans for Completion Missing milestones or unrealistic expectations Optimistic expectations; likely will require significant extra time Key milestones clearly identified; timely completion expected 5 Budget Missing or incomplete Insufficient revision/level of detail for conclusive projection Detailed and complete with revised cost estimates 5 Communication Clarity and Visual Presentation Unpracticed, unorganized, and unengaging; not focused on audience Evidence of preparation but some rambling or tangents; slides adequate Obvious preparation; professional speech; slides visually stimulating 10 Complete Within Time Allotted 10 min > time > 18 min 10 min < time < 13 min or 15 min < time < 18 min 13 min < time < 15 min 10 Comments: Total Score (out of 100) ______
Project%20Guidance%20-%20Design%20AY15%20v3.docx