VIP Innovation Competition: Judging Rubric Spring 2018 Exceeds Inadequate Expectations Category 0 1 2 3 Score Weight Subtotal Does not describe Key points are Details are unclear Describes the need The Need the need that is unclear that is being 3 being addressed addressed The envisioned The envisioned Innovative response is not an response is an Response to 4 innovative response innovative response Need to the need. to the need No evidence of Full solution The Solution progress toward apparent 4 solution It is not known who Sense of who the Idea of who the first It is clear who the First the first customer or first customer or customer or first customer or Customer or audience is audience may be; audience will be; audience is 3 Audience Key points are Details are unclear unclear Disorganized and Clear and well Poster 2 difficult to follow executed Quality Not engaging and Engaging and Effective message not effective delivery 2 Speakers delivered. Questions Answers are not Answers are given; Answers are given; Answers are clearly and given or are off-topic key points are some details are described 2 Answers unclear unclear TOTAL
VIP Innovation Competition: Judging Rubric Spring 2018 Inadequate Exceeds Expectations Category 0 1 2 3 Score Weight Subtotal The Need Does not describe the need that is being addressed Key points are unclear Details are unclear Describes the need that is being addressed 3 Innovative Response to Need The envisioned response is not an innovative response to the need. The envisioned response is an innovative response to the need 4 The Solution No evidence of progress toward solution Full solution apparent 4 First Customer or Audience It is not known who the first customer or audience is Sense of who the first customer or audience may be; Key points are unclear Idea of who the first customer or audience will be; Details are unclear It is clear who the first customer or audience is 3 Poster Quality Disorganized and difficult to follow Clear and well executed 2 Effective Speakers Not engaging and message not delivered. Engaging and effective delivery 2 Questions and Answers Answers are not given or are off-topic Answers are given; key points are unclear Answers are given; some details are unclear Answers are clearly described 2 TOTAL
Poster-Competition-Rubric-v2%20-%20adjust%20weighting.docx