3.2. The substantive model of responsibility von Schomberg (2011, a, b; 2013) EC Report (2013) Sutcliffe (2011) Participation/ Consultation for more: Early stakeholder’s involvement helps Meeting societal needs (beyond Meeting societal (beyond deliberation Legitimacy (social to define social desirable products. sole economic constraints). sole economic constraints). acceptability) Leads to collective responsibility. Reducing of market failures. Reducing of market failures Social desirability Social acceptability. Shaping institutions Shaping technology Aims at shaping innovation beyond Aim at co-shaping innovation. (Co-construction ) economic constraints and cost/ benefit analysis). Ethics by design. Production of Substantive Focused on ethical acceptability. Focused on ethical acceptability. norms Substantive normative horizon Substantive normative horizon Substantive normative horizon anchored in EU Norms. anchored in EU Norms. anchored in EU Norms. (ethical relevance) Institutional tools: codes of conduct, Institutional raising Institutional tools: codes of standards. awareness for RRI through EU conduct, standards, scientific funding. committees, etc. Ethical tools: ethical assessment.
3.2. The substantive model of responsibility von Schomberg (2011, a, b; 2013) EC Report (2013) Sutcliffe (2011) Participation/ deliberation Consultation for more: Legitimacy (social acceptability) Social desirability Early stakeholder’s involvement helps to define social desirable products. Leads to collective responsibility. Meeting societal needs (beyond sole economic constraints). Reducing of market failures. Meeting societal (beyond sole economic constraints). Reducing of market failures Social acceptability. Shaping institutions Shaping technology (Co-construction ) Aims at shaping innovation beyond economic constraints and cost/ benefit analysis). Ethics by design. Aim at co-shaping innovation. Production of norms (ethical relevance) Substantive Focused on ethical acceptability. Substantive normative horizon anchored in EU Norms. Institutional tools: codes of conduct, standards. Ethical tools: ethical assessment. Focused on ethical acceptability. Substantive normative horizon anchored in EU Norms. Institutional raising awareness for RRI through EU funding. Substantive normative horizon anchored in EU Norms. Institutional tools: codes of conduct, standards, scientific committees, etc.
Responsible_Innovation_Model_Report_versionforsubmission.docx