Final Design Report Rubric Criteria or Requirement Comments Points Front Matter Title page revised as required /2 Executive Summary revised and updated including summary of progress to date ToC/LoF/LoT revised and updated Problem Definition /1 Section revised and updated Need Identification /1 Section revised and updated Design Concepts /1 Section revised and updated Concept Evaluation and Selection /1 Section revised and updated Embodiment Design /1 Section revised and updated Prototype Test Plan for each experiment Section revised and updated /30 Includes table of final performance values corresponding to the top five ECs and demonstrates that all design constraints were met Future Work Summary of prototype demonstration to customer(s) Qualitative customer assessment, referenced to each CR /20 Customer requests for future work Discussion of the difference between understood CRs and actual CRs Detailed description of future work from the team standpoint Project Deliverables /1 Section revised and updated Project Management /2 Accurate summary of project; Gantt chart in calendar format included as Appendix Budget /2 Section revised and updated; including all purchases, total project cost, amount remaining References /1 Section revised and updated Appendix - Team Charter /1 Section revised and updated Appendix - Engineering Drawings /5 Section revised and updated Appendix Prototype Test Matrices – /5 Section revised and updated Appendix - Project Management Gantt Chart /1 Section revised and updated; calendar format Appendix - Closeout Memos /10 Included and complete; one for each member of the group; alphabetical order Formatting Figure/table formatting (centered, numbered, captioned, referenced) /5 Justification and pagination Clean and professional appearance Style Strong, logical narrative Correct voice (third person) /10 Appropriate tense consistent with narrative for each section – Grammar and spelling; evidence of proofreading Overall /100
Final Design Report Rubric Criteria or Requirement Comments Points Front Matter Title page revised as required Executive Summary revised and updated including summary of progress to date ToC/LoF/LoT revised and updated /2 Problem Definition Section revised and updated /1 Need Identification Section revised and updated /1 Design Concepts Section revised and updated /1 Concept Evaluation and Selection Section revised and updated /1 Embodiment Design Section revised and updated /1 Prototype Test Plan for each experiment Section revised and updated Includes table of final performance values corresponding to the top five ECs and demonstrates that all design constraints were met /30 Future Work Summary of prototype demonstration to customer(s) Qualitative customer assessment, referenced to each CR Customer requests for future work Discussion of the difference between understood CRs and actual CRs Detailed description of future work from the team standpoint /20 Project Deliverables Section revised and updated /1 Project Management Accurate summary of project; Gantt chart in calendar format included as Appendix /2 Budget Section revised and updated; including all purchases, total project cost, amount remaining /2 References Section revised and updated /1 Appendix - Team Charter Section revised and updated /1 Appendix - Engineering Drawings Section revised and updated /5 Appendix – Prototype Test Matrices Section revised and updated /5 Appendix - Project Management Gantt Chart Section revised and updated; calendar format /1 Appendix - Closeout Memos Included and complete; one for each member of the group; alphabetical order /10 Formatting Figure/table formatting (centered, numbered, captioned, referenced) Justification and pagination Clean and professional appearance /5 Style Strong, logical narrative Correct voice (third person) Appropriate tense – consistent with narrative for each section Grammar and spelling; evidence of proofreading /10 Overall /100
Project%20Guidance%20-%20Design%20AY15%20v3.docx