Discussion/Participation Rubric Whole Class Distinguished (3 pts) Proficient/Average (2 pts) Poor (1 pt) Unacceptable (0 pt) Participation: Comments answer Comments answer Comments are No answer given answering questions and questions posed, using vague; improper questions integrate broader proper terminology; little or use of subject areas; making no integration with broader terminology; reference to earlier topics failure to answer discussion or questions introducing a new, relevant topic Participation: Asks probing Asks for clarification of Asks for Asks no asking questions questions, reflecting presentation when explanation of substantive critical evaluation of necessary; asks simple trivial points questions subject matter; questions about topic integrates topics, identifies new relationships Listening Closely follows Follows discussion, Barely follows Pays no attention; discussion, criticizing volunteers answers when discussion, falls asleep in the topic as it is asked unable to follow class developed logic of presentation
Discussion/Participation Rubric Whole Class Distinguished (3 pts) Proficient/Average (2 pts) Poor (1 pt) Unacceptable (0 pt) Participation: answering questions Comments answer questions and integrate broader subject areas; making reference to earlier discussion or introducing a new, relevant topic Comments answer questions posed, using proper terminology; little or no integration with broader topics Comments are vague; improper use of terminology; failure to answer questions No answer given Participation: asking questions Asks probing questions, reflecting critical evaluation of subject matter; integrates topics, identifies new relationships Asks for clarification of presentation when necessary; asks simple questions about topic Asks for explanation of trivial points Asks no substantive questions Listening Closely follows discussion, criticizing the topic as it is developed Follows discussion, volunteers answers when asked Barely follows discussion, unable to follow logic of presentation Pays no attention; falls asleep in class
PLL%20Guidelines%202018.docx