research laboratories, semiconductor Participants in the standard include chip manufacturers, communication equipment vendors, chip designers, technology manufacturers, system integrators and end suppliers, radio frequency (RF) equipment users. manufacturers, infrastructure providers, international wireless carriers/service providers, academic researchers, government research laboratories, semiconductor manufacturers, communication equipment manufacturers, system integrators and consumers. Action: Revise CSD 1.2.4a and b to read as 1.2.4 don’t list the follows. 1.2.4 Technical Feasibility corporations in the CSD, but Each proposed IEEE 802 LMSC standard do cite reference to the Demonstrated system feasibility. shall provide evidence that the project is evidence alluded to. The sequence of link setup, data technically feasible within the time frame of transfer and link release the project. At a minimum, address the occurring within a short duration following items to demonstrate technical has already been demonstrated feasibility: for point-to-point wireless Demonstrated system feasibility. communication systems by a The sequence of link setup, data number of multimedia transfer and link release occurring organizations and universities within a short duration has already such as TU Braunschweig. been demonstrated for wireless communication Proven similar technology via systems by Sony, Toshiba and testing, modeling, simulation, others. etc. Similar main components of the Proven similar technology via technology and signaling are testing, modeling, simulation, etc. being used today in proprietary Similar main components of the commercial systems and in technology and signaling are being research laboratories at used in today’s systems by Sony, University institutions such as Toshiba and others. Hence, the TU Braunschweig. involved testing overhead associated with a commercial development undertaken by manufacturers is known to be reasonable. Consideration of installation 1.2.5c) do not use Action: Accept. Change to “Wi-Fi” “Wi-Fi” The installation of fixed standalone change to or “WLAN” “WLAN” terminals would be similar to that delete of installing Wi-Fi access points and when included in devices like ticket gates would not add to the installation cost of that gate
research laboratories, semiconductor manufacturers, communication equipment manufacturers, system integrators and end users. Participants in the standard include chip vendors, chip designers, technology suppliers, radio frequency (RF) equipment manufacturers, infrastructure providers, international wireless carriers/service providers, academic researchers, government research laboratories, semiconductor manufacturers, communication equipment manufacturers, system integrators and consumers. 1.2.4 don’t list the corporations in the CSD, but do cite reference to the evidence alluded to. 1.2.4 Technical Feasibility Each proposed IEEE 802 LMSC standard shall provide evidence that the project is technically feasible within the time frame of the project. At a minimum, address the following items to demonstrate technical feasibility: Demonstrated system feasibility. The sequence of link setup, data transfer and link release occurring within a short duration has already been demonstrated for wireless communication systems by Sony, Toshiba and others. Proven similar technology via testing, modeling, simulation, etc. Similar main components of the technology and signaling are being used in today’s systems by Sony, Toshiba and others. Hence, the involved testing overhead associated with a commercial development undertaken by manufacturers is known to be reasonable. Action: Revise CSD 1.2.4a and b to read as follows. Demonstrated system feasibility. The sequence of link setup, data transfer and link release occurring within a short duration has already been demonstrated for point-to-point wireless communication systems by a number of multimedia organizations and universities such as TU Braunschweig. Proven similar technology via testing, modeling, simulation, etc. Similar main components of the technology and signaling are being used today in proprietary commercial systems and in research laboratories at University institutions such as TU Braunschweig. 1.2.5c) do not use “Wi-Fi” change to “WLAN” or delete Consideration of installation The installation of fixed standalone terminals would be similar to that of installing Wi-Fi access points and when included in devices like ticket gates would not add to the installation cost of that gate Action: Accept. Change “Wi-Fi” to “WLAN”
15-15-0229-03-003e-par-csd-comments-resolutions.docx