Table 3 - Results reporting patient satisfaction and enablement Tool Study Intervention– students present in GP Comparison– student no SMD¥ 95% CI consultation present PEI Price (Price et al. 2008) PEI mean score PEI mean score -0.077 -0.155 0.001 4.3 (SD 3.9) 4.6 (SD 3.9) PEI Benson (Benson, PEI proportional score PEI proportional score 31.2% 0.054 -0.127 0.234 33.4% (SD 30.4)* (28.9)* Quince, Hibble, Fanshawe, & Emery Converted back to raw score: 3.96 (SD Converted back to raw score: 2005) 3.65) 3.77 (SD 3.468) Pooled effect for PEI -0.0565 -0.128 0.0149 Price (Price, Spencer, & CARE mean score CARE mean score 43.7 (SD 7.2) 0.264 0.083 0.446 CARE 42.7 (SD 8.0) Walker 2008) CSQ Benson (Benson, CSQ proportional score CSQ proportional score -0.131 -0.209 -0.053 80.4 (10.1)* 78.5 (10.5)* Quince, Hibble, Fanshawe, & Emery Converted back to raw score: 72.36 (SD Converted back to raw score: 2005) 9.09) 70.65 (SD 3.85) * The authors expressed scores for the PEI and CSQ as a percentage of the maximum score obtainable (12 for PEI, 90 for CSQ) ¥ GP as intervention, with hospital as comparison group
Table 3 - Results reporting patient satisfaction and enablement Tool Study Intervention– students present in GP consultation Comparison– student no present SMD¥ 95% CI PEI Price (Price et al. 2008) PEI mean score 4.3 (SD 3.9) PEI mean score 4.6 (SD 3.9) -0.077 -0.155 0.001 PEI Benson (Benson, Quince, Hibble, Fanshawe, & Emery 2005) PEI proportional score 33.4% (SD 30.4)* Converted back to raw score: 3.96 (SD 3.65) PEI proportional score 31.2% (28.9)* Converted back to raw score: 3.77 (SD 3.468) 0.054 -0.127 0.234 Pooled effect for PEI -0.0565 -0.128 0.0149 CARE Price (Price, Spencer, & Walker 2008) CARE mean score 42.7 (SD 8.0) CARE mean score 43.7 (SD 7.2) 0.264 0.083 0.446 CSQ Benson (Benson, Quince, Hibble, Fanshawe, & Emery 2005) CSQ proportional score 80.4 (10.1)* Converted back to raw score: 72.36 (SD 9.09) CSQ proportional score 78.5 (10.5)* Converted back to raw score: 70.65 (SD 3.85) -0.131 -0.209 -0.053 * The authors expressed scores for the PEI and CSQ as a percentage of the maximum score obtainable (12 for PEI, 90 for CSQ) ¥ GP as intervention, with hospital as comparison group
humberto-e-plinio.docx