How effective was the The degree to which issues identified Stakeholder interviews: Identify Test utility of EINRIP M&E program in through various M&E process have a sample of issues and probe EINRIP M&E guiding the successful been subsequently addressed and during interviews as to whether implementation of the resolved these have been addressed. project and demonstrating (DFAT, DGH) the of the EINRIP Document review: Examine approach to stakeholders? annual documents (AQC reports, (S2) M&E surveys) to test for recurrent issues The degree to which data and analysis Stakeholder interviews: Solicit Test influence of generated by EINRIP M&E processes views as to the lessons learned EINRIP M&E has been influential in DGH through EINRIP and how these have been communicated (DGH) Efficiency: Does EINRIP represent for money, both relative to the quality of roads constructed and the institutional gains made? Evaluation question / sub Evidence required Data collection method and Analytical question source approach Was the modality (mix of The extent to which intended outcomes Document review: Identify Map links loans and grant TA) (stated and additional) reflect inputs between grant and loan-funded between grant relevant to intended activities (project completion and loan funded The extent to which grant-funded EINRIP outcomes? (VFM1) report, loan agreement, annual streams activities directly support loan outcomes reports) Stakeholder interviews: Solicit Synthesise views as to the complementarity feedback from of grant and loan-funded activity. stakeholders (DGH, DFAT) What are the early The extent to which EINRIP project roads, Document review: Examine Synthesise data indications of the particularly those completed some time assessments on road conditions on the status of sustainability of both ago, are in good repair (annual reports) EINRIP roads EINRIP-supported Field Visit: Verify condition of a Test for institutional capacity and sample of EINRIP roads resolution of completed roads and identified faults bridges? (VFM2) The extent of maintenance work Document review: Identify Compare required on EINRIP project maintenance expenditure on expenditure EINRIP and non-EINRIP roads levels
How effective was the EINRIP M&E program in guiding the successful implementation of the project and demonstrating the of the EINRIP approach to stakeholders? (S2) The degree to which issues identified through various M&E process have been subsequently addressed and resolved Stakeholder interviews: Identify a sample of issues and probe during interviews as to whether these have been addressed. (DFAT, DGH) Document review: Examine annual documents (AQC reports, M&E surveys) to test for recurrent issues Test utility of EINRIP M&E The degree to which data and analysis generated by EINRIP M&E processes has been influential in DGH Stakeholder interviews: Solicit views as to the lessons learned through EINRIP and how these have been communicated (DGH) Test influence of EINRIP M&E Efficiency: Does EINRIP represent for money, both relative to the quality of roads constructed and the institutional gains made? Evaluation question / sub question Evidence required Data collection method and source Analytical approach Was the modality (mix of loans and grant TA) relevant to intended EINRIP outcomes? (VFM1) The extent to which intended outcomes (stated and additional) reflect inputs The extent to which grant-funded activities directly support loan outcomes Document review: Identify between grant and loan-funded activities (project completion report, loan agreement, annual reports) Map links between grant and loan funded streams Stakeholder interviews: Solicit views as to the complementarity of grant and loan-funded activity. (DGH, DFAT) Synthesise feedback from stakeholders What are the early indications of the sustainability of both EINRIP-supported institutional capacity and completed roads and bridges? (VFM2) The extent to which EINRIP project roads, particularly those completed some time ago, are in good repair Document review: Examine assessments on road conditions (annual reports) Field Visit: Verify condition of a sample of EINRIP roads Synthesise data on the status of EINRIP roads Test for resolution of identified faults The extent of maintenance work required on EINRIP project Document review: Identify maintenance expenditure on EINRIP and non-EINRIP roads Compare expenditure levels
investing-in-roads-einrip-completion-evaluation-report.docx