R16 3 3.1 44 Is a mesh root restricted to Explain why, or modify enabling access to just one definition entity? R18 3 3.1 50 mesh tree providing connectivity to what? connectivity R37 10 4.3 38 "A mesh tree is organized Circular characterization into a hierarchical mesh <unnecessary for a tree> tree" R41 10 4.3 52 is allowed by the mesh Explain motivation for the root restriction R42 10 4.3 52 is allowed by the mesh device to decide for root itself R75 21 5.2.1 35 Section cross-reference section 5.4.1.4 needed for discussion R80 23 5.2.1 51 'N' conflicts with rows 9 Pick new variable for one of and 10 of table 3 the 'N's R104 34 5.3.3 14 What reasons are NOT Give some examples, or good reasons for reword sentence. recovery? R113 39 5.4.1.4 15 "E2E Retry Limit are set This makes the individual by the device forwarding payloads NOT E2E. the aggregated frame" R161 53 6.2.1.1 25 "backhaul" is undefined Create definition (or Resolution: AiP CIDs R16, R18: Definition for mesh root should allow for connectivity to one or more services. Replace definition of mesh root as follows: with the 0 in a L2R mesh providing access to a service. It may act as a gateway “Device connecting to one or more external services.” CID R37: Statement is redundant and amounts to a circular definition.
R16 3 3.1 44 Is a mesh root restricted to enabling access to just one entity? Explain why, or modify definition R18 3 3.1 50 mesh tree providing connectivity connectivity to what? R37 10 4.3 38 "A mesh tree is organized into a hierarchical mesh tree" Circular characterization <unnecessary for a tree> R41 10 4.3 52 is allowed by the mesh root Explain motivation for the restriction R42 10 4.3 52 is allowed by the mesh root device to decide for itself R75 21 5.2.1 35 Section cross-reference needed for discussion section 5.4.1.4 R80 23 5.2.1 51 'N' conflicts with rows 9 and 10 of table 3 Pick new variable for one of the 'N's R104 34 5.3.3 14 What reasons are NOT good reasons for recovery? Give some examples, or reword sentence. R113 39 5.4.1.4 15 "E2E Retry Limit are set by the device forwarding the aggregated frame" This makes the individual payloads NOT E2E. R161 53 6.2.1.1 25 "backhaul" is undefined Create definition (or Resolution: AiP CIDs R16, R18: Definition for mesh root should allow for connectivity to one or more services. Replace definition of mesh root as follows: “Device with the 0 in a L2R mesh providing access to a service. It may act as a gateway connecting to one or more external services.” CID R37: Statement is redundant and amounts to a circular definition.
15-15-0466-01-0010-proposed-resolutions-for-miscellaneous-comments-cid-r16-et-al.docx