A reservation established with regard to another party: Modifies for the reserving state in its relations with that other party the provisions of the treaty to which the reservation relates to the extension of the reservation Modifies those provisions to the same extent for that other party in its relations with the reserving state Both will be able to bomb away under the reservation because both accept it B rejects the reservation (X-B) Article 21(3) Does the objecting state also oppose the entry into force of the treaty as between the two States? Yes Then is no treaty relation between them at ALL (BOMB AWAY) No Then the provisions to which the reservation relates simply do not apply as between the two parties (BOMB AWAY) A-B, A-C or B-C Article 21(2) Both will be able to bomb away the reservation C remains silent (X-C) Article 20(5) Unless the treaty otherwise provides a reservation is considered to have been accepted by a State if it shall have raised no objection to the reservation by the end of a period of 12 months after it was notified of the reservation or by the date on which it expressed to be bound by the treaty Both States will be able to bomb away under the reservation UNLESS State C objects and speaks up about Reservations to the Convention on Genocide Issue What happens as a matter of law when on State in a multilateral treaty makes a reservation and another State objects?
A reservation established with regard to another party: Modifies for the reserving state in its relations with that other party the provisions of the treaty to which the reservation relates to the extension of the reservation Modifies those provisions to the same extent for that other party in its relations with the reserving state Both will be able to bomb away under the reservation because both accept it B rejects the reservation (X-B) Article 21(3) Does the objecting state also oppose the entry into force of the treaty as between the two States? Yes Then is no treaty relation between them at ALL (BOMB AWAY) No Then the provisions to which the reservation relates simply do not apply as between the two parties (BOMB AWAY) A-B, A-C or B-C Article 21(2) Both will be able to bomb away the reservation C remains silent (X-C) Article 20(5) Unless the treaty otherwise provides a reservation is considered to have been accepted by a State if it shall have raised no objection to the reservation by the end of a period of 12 months after it was notified of the reservation or by the date on which it expressed to be bound by the treaty Both States will be able to bomb away under the reservation UNLESS State C objects and speaks up about Reservations to the Convention on Genocide Issue What happens as a matter of law when on State in a multilateral treaty makes a reservation and another State objects?
International%20Law%20Final%20-%20Steinhardt%20-%20Fall%202011.docx