Fish Bowl Formal Rubric Student Name: _____________________________________________________ Total Score: _________ Requirement Exemplary Proficient Emerging 20 points 17 points 14 points Student-Generated Questions 3 solid open-ended 2 solid open-ended 1 solid open-ended questions prepared for questions prepared for question prepared for class. Questions show class. Questions show class. Question show thoughtful consideration thoughtful consideration thoughtful consideration of the text. of the text. of the text. 20 points 17 points 14 points Discussion Participation Uses all 2-3 talking Uses 1 - 2 talking Uses 0 - 1 talking tokens to add new tokens to add new tokens to add new information to the information during the information during the discussion. These discussion. These discussion. These should be significant should be significant should be significant and thoughtful, going and thoughtful, going and thoughtful, going beyond just agreeing or beyond just agreeing or beyond just agreeing or asking a question. asking a question. asking a question. Textual Evidence 20 points 17 points 14 points During all 3 talking During 1 - 2 talking During 0 - 1 talking opportunities, student opportunities, student opportunities, student references textual references textual references textual evidence, builds off evidence, builds off evidence, builds off or or or another’s ideas, another’s ideas, another’s ideas, makes direct references makes direct references makes direct references to points made my to points made my to points made my another student. another student. another student. Discussion Etiquette 20 points 17 points 14 points Student adheres to the Student adheres to the Student adheres to the discussion etiquette discussion etiquette discussion etiquette guidelines established guidelines established guidelines established before the Fish Bowl before the Fish Bowl for before the Fish Bowl for throughout the entire most of the discussion. very little of the discussion. discussion. Self-Reflection 20 points 17 points 14 points Student answers all Student answers all Student answers some questions honestly, questions honestly. questions dishonestly. thoughtfully, and in Some sentences are Several sentences are complete sentences. not well thought-out or incomplete.
Fish Bowl Formal Rubric Student Name: _____________________________________________________ Total Score: _________ Requirement Exemplary Proficient Emerging Student-Generated Questions 20 points 3 solid open-ended questions prepared for class. Questions show thoughtful consideration of the text. 17 points 2 solid open-ended questions prepared for class. Questions show thoughtful consideration of the text. 14 points 1 solid open-ended question prepared for class. Question show thoughtful consideration of the text. Discussion Participation 20 points Uses all 2-3 talking tokens to add new information to the discussion. These should be significant and thoughtful, going beyond just agreeing or asking a question. 17 points Uses 1 - 2 talking tokens to add new information during the discussion. These should be significant and thoughtful, going beyond just agreeing or asking a question. 14 points Uses 0 - 1 talking tokens to add new information during the discussion. These should be significant and thoughtful, going beyond just agreeing or asking a question. Textual Evidence 20 points During all 3 talking opportunities, student references textual evidence, builds off another’s ideas, or makes direct references to points made my another student. 17 points During 1 - 2 talking opportunities, student references textual evidence, builds off another’s ideas, or makes direct references to points made my another student. 14 points During 0 - 1 talking opportunities, student references textual evidence, builds off another’s ideas, or makes direct references to points made my another student. Discussion Etiquette 20 points Student adheres to the discussion etiquette guidelines established before the Fish Bowl throughout the entire discussion. 17 points Student adheres to the discussion etiquette guidelines established before the Fish Bowl for most of the discussion. 14 points Student adheres to the discussion etiquette guidelines established before the Fish Bowl for very little of the discussion. Self-Reflection 20 points Student answers all questions honestly, thoughtfully, and in complete sentences. 17 points Student answers all questions honestly. Some sentences are not well thought-out or 14 points Student answers some questions dishonestly. Several sentences are incomplete.
fishbowlformalrubric.docx