Table 31 Overview of economic evaluations identified in the literature – Perspective for Publication Country Study design Intervention Comparators Outcome Comments analysis Edfeldt et al. 2014 Sweden Cost-utility VSB None Hospital Utility gain: 0,09 Utility values obtained before and Norway analysis and after implantation rather Cost/QALY: € 7.260 than from a comparator group. Snik et al. 2006 The MEI (VSB, None Healthcare Utility gain: 0,05 Utility values obtained before Netherlands Otologics MET) system/payer 16.085 and after implantation rather Cost/QALY: € analysis than from a comparator group. Outcomes obtained for each MEI are pooled together. Alberta Health and Canada Decision model MEI (VSB, Esteem, HA, BAHA, CI Healthcare Total cost The cost was calculated as an Wellness (2011) Carina) system/payer of MEI over 5 years: average of the inflated cost (5%) $2`677.497 over 5 years. Medical Services Australia MEI (VSB, BAHA, CI limited societal Average cost of All implants deemed as being Advisory Committee Otologics MET, MEI: $23.873 equally effective on primary (2010) analysis Esteem, Rion , outcome. SOUNDTEC, TICA MEIs) Comite d'Evaluation et France Cost analysis per MEI (VSB, None Hospital $19.173/case Information based on executive de Diffusion des case Otologics MET, summary, full text not available Innovations SOUNDTEC) in English. Technologiques (2002)
Table 31 – Overview of economic evaluations identified in the literature Publication Country Study design Intervention Comparators Perspective for analysis Outcome Comments Edfeldt et al. 2014 Sweden and Norway Cost-utility analysis VSB None Hospital Utility gain: 0,09 Cost/QALY: € 7.260 Utility values obtained before and after implantation rather than from a comparator group. Snik et al. 2006 The Netherlands analysis MEI (VSB, Otologics MET) None Healthcare system/payer Utility gain: 0,05 Cost/QALY: € 16.085 Utility values obtained before and after implantation rather than from a comparator group. Outcomes obtained for each MEI are pooled together. Alberta Health and Wellness (2011) Canada Decision model MEI (VSB, Esteem, Carina) HA, BAHA, CI Healthcare system/payer Total cost of MEI over 5 years: $2`677.497 The cost was calculated as an average of the inflated cost (5%) over 5 years. Medical Services Advisory Committee (2010) Australia analysis MEI (VSB, Otologics MET, Esteem, Rion , SOUNDTEC, TICA MEIs) BAHA, CI limited societal Average cost of MEI: $23.873 All implants deemed as being equally effective on primary outcome. Comite d'Evaluation et de Diffusion des Innovations Technologiques (2002) France Cost analysis per case MEI (VSB, Otologics MET, SOUNDTEC) None Hospital $19.173/case Information based on executive summary, full text not available in English.
1365.1-SubmissionBasedAssessmentReport.docx