some sentence ideas stronger variety My response My response My response My response No judgment can be Elaboration provides thorough provides adequate provides uneven or provides minimal made about my use of and and convincing support for my brief support for support for my evidence. Integration of support for my claim claim my claim claim Evidence effectively uses includes sources, has partial or lacks sources, facts, sources, facts, and facts, and details uneven use of and details details sources, facts, and has some depth has minimal, details achieves substantial and specificity absent, or depth that is specific lacks depth irrelevant evidence has smooth and relevant integration of has some evidence has seamless and evidence or sources that is integrated sophisticated smoothly integration of evidence or sources Complexity My response examines My response partially My response My response needs to No judgment can be different perspectives on evaluates the acknowledges a address a made about my the issue, and/or implications and/or counterargument to my counterargument to my understanding of evaluates the implications complications of the position/claim, but I position /claim. complexity. and/or complications of issue and partially need to make it more the issue, and fully responds to developed or clear. responds to counterarguments to my counterarguments to my position. position. My writing shows a Though there may be a My writing displays a few My writing displays No judgment can be Conventions sophisticated use of few minor errors in distracting errors or multiple errors in made about my conventions, complex grammar or usage, my patterns of errors in grammar and usage, understanding of sentence structures, and meaning is clear. grammar and usage that which blur my reader’s conventions. the manipulation of may occasionally blur my understanding, or my punctuation for effect. reader’s understanding. writing is too brief to make an accurate judgment.
some sentence variety ideas stronger Elaboration and Integration of Evidence My response provides thorough and convincing support for my claim effectively uses sources, facts, and details achieves substantial depth that is specific and relevant has seamless and sophisticated integration of evidence or sources My response provides adequate support for my claim includes sources, facts, and details has some depth and specificity has smooth integration of evidence or sources My response provides uneven or brief support for my claim has partial or uneven use of sources, facts, and details lacks depth has some evidence that is integrated smoothly My response provides minimal support for my claim lacks sources, facts, and details has minimal, absent, or irrelevant evidence No judgment can be made about my use of evidence. Complexity My response examines different perspectives on the issue, and/or evaluates the implications and/or complications of the issue, and fully responds to counterarguments to my position. My response partially evaluates the implications and/or complications of the issue and partially responds to counterarguments to my position. My response acknowledges a counterargument to my position/claim, but I need to make it more developed or clear. My response needs to address a counterargument to my position /claim. No judgment can be made about my understanding of complexity. Conventions My writing shows a sophisticated use of conventions, complex sentence structures, and the manipulation of punctuation for effect. Though there may be a few minor errors in grammar or usage, my meaning is clear. My writing displays a few distracting errors or patterns of errors in grammar and usage that may occasionally blur my reader’s understanding. My writing displays multiple errors in grammar and usage, which blur my reader’s understanding, or my writing is too brief to make an accurate judgment. No judgment can be made about my understanding of conventions.
Grade%2010%20DBA%20%232%20Scoring%20Guide%20%2010_4_13.docx