Initiative Name: Reviewer: Criteria Low (0-3) Average (4-7) High (8-10) Score How clear and realistic are the Well outlined and convincingly Poorly outlined and/or Partially outlined objectives and the proposed supported; Solid plan with a /10 impractical Somewhat practical plan plan/approach? (Part3d) high chance to succeed What will be the extent of students’ experience of the Minimal Moderate Rich /10 emerging STEM space? (3e) How extensive is the opportunity for original Little opportunity Some opportunity Ample opportunity /10 project-based learning with applicable outcomes? (3f) Will the project encourage Totally; It is designed to be students’ autonomy and Not really Somewhat /10 driven by students accountability? (3g) Follows a prescribed format Will students have the Follows a somewhat flexible Definitely; It is designed to with little flexibility and opportunity to be creative? format with some opportunity offer ample opportunity for /10 opportunity for creative (3g) for creative thinking creative thinking thinking How much interdisciplinary Lots; Effective team work will be involved? Not much A moderate amount teamwork is /10 (3g) critical to the project Extensively; Real-world Will social, environmental, implications and sustainable and other implications of the Only marginally Somewhat /10 practices are central to the project be examined? (3g) design of the project
Initiative Name: Reviewer: Criteria Low (0-3) Average (4-7) High (8-10) Score How clear and realistic are the objectives and the proposed plan/approach? (Part3d) Poorly outlined and/or impractical Partially outlined Somewhat practical plan Well outlined and convincingly supported; Solid plan with a high chance to succeed /10 What will be the extent of students’ experience of the emerging STEM space? (3e) Minimal Moderate Rich /10 How extensive is the opportunity for original project-based learning with applicable outcomes? (3f) Little opportunity Some opportunity Ample opportunity /10 Will the project encourage students’ autonomy and accountability? (3g) Not really Somewhat Totally; It is designed to be driven by students /10 Will students have the opportunity to be creative? (3g) Follows a prescribed format with little flexibility and opportunity for creative thinking Follows a somewhat flexible format with some opportunity for creative thinking Definitely; It is designed to offer ample opportunity for creative thinking /10 How much interdisciplinary team work will be involved? (3g) Not much A moderate amount Lots; Effective teamwork is critical to the project /10 Will social, environmental, and other implications of the project be examined? (3g) Only marginally Somewhat Extensively; Real-world implications and sustainable practices are central to the design of the project /10
geekStarter-Rubric-for-Application-Review.docx