SECOND ARGUMENT Claim 3 Claim missing Reasoning unclear or does not Evidence #1 with citation 3 demonstrate link to claim from document or text Document(s) not cited Reasoning 4 links Evidence doesn’t support claim evidence/claim Evidence #2 with citation 3 from document or text Reasoning links 4 evidence/claim CLOSING STATEMENT Restatement of Super 2 No conclusion Missing super claim Claim Missing counterclaim Restatement of Best 2 Evidence & reasoning are not Evidence/Reasoning Strong Counterclaim 2 (“Although”)/ with Evidence Refute counterclaim 2 TOTAL SCORE (50):
SECOND ARGUMENT Claim 3 Claim missing Reasoning unclear or does not demonstrate link to claim Document(s) not cited Evidence doesn’t support claim Evidence #1 with citation from document or text 3 Reasoning links evidence/claim 4 Evidence #2 with citation from document or text 3 Reasoning links evidence/claim 4 CLOSING STATEMENT Restatement of Super Claim 2 No conclusion Missing super claim Missing counterclaim Evidence & reasoning are not Strong Restatement of Best Evidence/Reasoning 2 Counterclaim (“Although”)/ with Evidence 2 Refute counterclaim 2 TOTAL SCORE (50):
12DL-Building-a-Mosque-at-Ground-Zero.docx