project (maximum 100 Rationale for grouping short items as a single output (maximum 100 words) Reference: Part 2A, paragraph Part 2B, Part 2C, paragraph Part 2D, 49 paragraphs 52-53 60 paragraphs 50, 51, 71 and 75 c. Factual information about the significance of the output (‘guidance on submissions’, paragraph 127b) Panel None In UOAs 11, 12, Factual statement None requirements: 13, 14 and 15: about prizes or Factual statement similar recognition wherever available None in UOAs 7, 8, 9 and 10. Reference: n/a Part 2B, Part 2C, n/a paragraphs 54-57 paragraphs 61-62 d. Outputs that include significant material published prior to 1 January 2008 (Part 1, paragraph 44) Panel All main panels: Statement on how far the earlier work was revised to incorporate requirements: new material Reference: Part 2A, Part 2B, Part 2C, Part 2D, paragraphs 30-31 paragraphs 35-36 paragraphs 40-41 paragraphs 54-55 e. The researcher’s contribution to a co-authored or co-produced output the output is – listed once within the submission (‘guidance on submissions’, paragraph 120-122 and 127d; Part 1, paragraph 45) Panel Affirmation of the In UOA9 only: None None requirements: author’s Statement the contribution to the author’s output (selected contribution only from the there are where statements
project (maximum 100 Rationale for grouping short items as a single output (maximum 100 words) Reference: Part 2A, paragraph 49 Part 2B, paragraphs 52-53 Part 2C, paragraph 60 Part 2D, paragraphs 50, 51, 71 and 75 c. Factual information about the significance of the output (‘guidance on submissions’, paragraph 127b) Panel requirements: None In UOAs 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15: Factual statement wherever available None in UOAs 7, 8, 9 and 10. Factual statement about prizes or similar recognition None Reference: n/a Part 2B, paragraphs 54-57 Part 2C, paragraphs 61-62 n/a d. Outputs that include significant material published prior to 1 January 2008 (Part 1, paragraph 44) Panel requirements: All main panels: Statement on how far the earlier work was revised to incorporate new material Reference: Part 2A, paragraphs 30-31 Part 2B, paragraphs 35-36 Part 2C, paragraphs 40-41 Part 2D, paragraphs 54-55 e. The researcher’s contribution to a co-authored or co-produced output – the output is listed once within the submission (‘guidance on submissions’, paragraph 120-122 and 127d; Part 1, paragraph 45) Panel requirements: Affirmation of the author’s contribution to the output (selected from the statements In UOA9 only: Statement the author’s contribution only where there are None None
panel-criteria-and-working-methods.docx