Return on equity adjusted from 12.42% to 8.40% based on the following company adjustments to actual results of operations. $ 77,659,000 Rate Base Increase Net Plant in Service $ 8,173,000 Weather Normalization Revenue $ 4,703,000 Weather Normalization Expense $ 6,555,000 Non-recurring Items Expense UGI Utilities, Inc. - Gas Return on equity adjusted from 19.33% to 10.25% based on the following company adjustments to actual results of operations. $ 98,794,000 Rate Base Increase Net Plant in Service $ 21,852,000 Rate Base Increase in Inventory $ (13,603,000) Normalization of Operating Revenue $ 2,958,000 Payroll Expense $ 2,343,000 Depreciation Expense National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation Return on equity adjusted from 13.28% to 10.58% based on the following company adjustments to actual results of operations $ 37,739,000 Rate Base Cash Working Capital Increase $ 19,697,000 Rate Base Increase in Plant $ 17,955,000 Increase in Operating Revenue Attachment C ALLOWED RATES OF RETURN ON COMMON EQUITY This is a historical chart that shows the most recent fully litigated rate cases for select companies in electric, gas, and water. A docket number followed by their final return on equity and year is also given. ELECTRIC Docket Number ROE (%) Year Recent PA PUC Allowed PPL Electric Utilities Corp. - R-2012-2290597 10.40 2012 PECO Energy Company - R-2010-2161575 Settled 2010 West Penn Power Company - R-00942986 11.50 1995 UGI - Electric - R-00932862 10.58 1996 Pennsylvania Electric Company - R-00061367 10.10 2007 Metropolitan Edison Company - R-00061366 10.10 2007 Current Market Indicated ROE as calculated by the 8.06-10.97 Bureau of Technical Utility Services. GAS Recent PA PUC Allowed Columbia Gas of Pa. - R-2010-2215623 Settled 2011
Return on equity adjusted from 12.42% to 8.40% based on the following company adjustments to actual results of operations. $ 77,659,000 Rate Base Increase Net Plant in Service $ 8,173,000 Weather Normalization Revenue $ 4,703,000 Weather Normalization Expense $ 6,555,000 Non-recurring Items Expense UGI Utilities, Inc. - Gas Return on equity adjusted from 19.33% to 10.25% based on the following company adjustments to actual results of operations. $ 98,794,000 Rate Base Increase Net Plant in Service $ 21,852,000 Rate Base Increase in Inventory $ (13,603,000) Normalization of Operating Revenue $ 2,958,000 Payroll Expense $ 2,343,000 Depreciation Expense National Fuel Gas Distribution Corporation Return on equity adjusted from 13.28% to 10.58% based on the following company adjustments to actual results of operations $ 37,739,000 Rate Base Cash Working Capital Increase $ 19,697,000 Rate Base Increase in Plant $ 17,955,000 Increase in Operating Revenue Attachment C ALLOWED RATES OF RETURN ON COMMON EQUITY This is a historical chart that shows the most recent fully litigated rate cases for select companies in electric, gas, and water. A docket number followed by their final return on equity and year is also given. ELECTRIC Docket Number ROE (%) Year Recent PA PUC Allowed PPL Electric Utilities Corp. - R-2012-2290597 10.40 2012 PECO Energy Company - R-2010-2161575 Settled 2010 West Penn Power Company - R-00942986 11.50 1995 UGI - Electric - R-00932862 10.58 1996 Pennsylvania Electric Company - R-00061367 10.10 2007 Metropolitan Edison Company - R-00061366 10.10 2007 Current Market Indicated ROE as calculated by the 8.06-10.97 Bureau of Technical Utility Services. GAS Recent PA PUC Allowed Columbia Gas of Pa. - R-2010-2215623 Settled 2011
1238441.docx