GROUP # _____________ Poor Fair Good Great Disease of interest Currently available therapies List 3 positive aspects of this team’s project: What are the VEGF 1. ligands/VEGFRs? are these receptors located? 2 What are the binding kinetics? Second messenger signaling 3. pathways: downstream molecules activated List 3 things that can be improved: What other computational models exist? 1. What did these models identify? 2. What was modeled? Molecules/Processes? 3. What equations were used? What did the modeling show? Poor Fair Good Great # _____________ How effective was the proposed Disease of interest strategy in comparison to current drugs? Currently available therapies Citations: Is borrowed content cited in slide? What are the VEGF ligands/VEGFRs? Font type/size: Can you read all Slides content? Where are these receptors (Overall) located? Spelling/Grammar: Are there errors? What are the binding kinetics? Titles/Headings: Are they Second messenger signaling descriptive? pathways: downstream molecules activated List 3 positive aspects of this team’s project: What computational models exist? 1. What did these models identify? What was modeled? 2 Molecules/Processes? What equations were used? 3. What did the modeling show? List 3 things that can be improved: How effective was the proposed strategy in comparison to current 1. Citations: Is borrowed content 2. cited in slide? Font type/size: Can you read all Slides 3. content? (Overall) Spelling/Grammar: Are there errors? Titles/Headings: Are they descriptive?
GROUP # _____________ Poor Fair Good Great Disease of interest Currently available therapies What are the VEGF ligands/VEGFRs? are these receptors located? What are the binding kinetics? Second messenger signaling pathways: downstream molecules activated What other computational models exist? What did these models identify? What was modeled? Molecules/Processes? What equations were used? What did the modeling show? How effective was the proposed strategy in comparison to current drugs? Slides (Overall) Citations: Is borrowed content cited in slide? Font type/size: Can you read all content? Spelling/Grammar: Are there errors? Titles/Headings: Are they descriptive? # _____________ Poor Fair Good Great Disease of interest Currently available therapies What are the VEGF ligands/VEGFRs? Where are these receptors located? What are the binding kinetics? Second messenger signaling pathways: downstream molecules activated What computational models exist? What did these models identify? What was modeled? Molecules/Processes? What equations were used? What did the modeling show? How effective was the proposed strategy in comparison to current Slides (Overall) Citations: Is borrowed content cited in slide? Font type/size: Can you read all content? Spelling/Grammar: Are there errors? Titles/Headings: Are they descriptive? List 3 positive aspects of this team’s project: 1. 2 3. List 3 things that can be improved: 1. 2. 3. List 3 positive aspects of this team’s project: 1. 2 3. List 3 things that can be improved: 1. 2. 3.
peer_critique_rubric.docx