Structure 28-30 Points 26-27 Points 23-25 Points 1-22 Points 30%: 30 points Writing 19-20 points 17-18 points 16 1-15 points 0 points and Student Student Paper exhibits some Paper Clarity: 20 demonstrates demonstrates writing that would significantly points “professional not be considered deviates from “professional as defined writing” as and the writing” “professional” by DCCC. This mentioned under has some basic requirements would include the writing errors. mentioned in “Proficient” proper sentence column and the construction, “Proficient” paragraph described by column. organization, DCCC. Beyond transitions, and that, writing is logical flow of superb with ideas. excellent flow of ideas and is totally free of errors. Writing 10 points 9 points 8 points 1-7 points 0 points Mechanics and Paper is totally Student largely Paper exhibits a Paper exhibits follows APA for number of numerous free of mechanical 10 formatting, mechanical and deviations from errors and follows points citations, use of APA errors the elements APA fully. quotes, etc. mentioned in the Proficient
Structure 30%: 30 points 28-30 Points 26-27 Points 23-25 Points 1-22 Points Writing and Clarity: 20 points 19-20 points Student demonstrates “professional writing” as mentioned under the “Proficient” column and described by DCCC. Beyond that, writing is superb with excellent flow of ideas and is totally free of errors. 17-18 points Student demonstrates “professional writing” as defined by DCCC. This would include proper sentence construction, paragraph organization, transitions, and logical flow of ideas. 16 Paper exhibits some writing that would not be considered “professional” and has some basic writing errors. 1-15 points Paper significantly deviates from the requirements mentioned in the “Proficient” column. 0 points Writing Mechanics and 10 points 10 points Paper is totally free of mechanical errors and follows APA fully. 9 points Student largely follows APA for formatting, citations, use of quotes, etc. 8 points Paper exhibits a number of mechanical and APA errors 1-7 points Paper exhibits numerous deviations from the elements mentioned in the Proficient 0 points
Enhanced%20Grading%20Rubric%20for%20Journal%20Article%20Reviews%20Revised%205.20.2018.docx