Resettlement Cost. The full costs of resettlement Budget plan is part of land Resettlement cost is not well LARPF and LARAP activities necessary to achieve acquisition plan but tend not require that costs for described in government the objectives of the project considering the resettlement cost. land acquisition and regulation are included in the total costs resettlement is budgeted of the project. Consultation and Displaced persons should be Consultation to the Project Affected No prior consultation or public LARPF and LARAP Complaint Procedure. meaningfully consulted and People needed to get permit for the consultation before negotiation require consultation and should have opportunities to proposed location of the project. implementation of on option of compensation participate in planning and There is no prior consultation GRM. Overall, the implementing resettlement before negotiation on option of project has GRM in programs (2.b) compensation. The grievance place as a continuation redress mechanism is clearly of the well-functioning Grievance mechanism should described and within the court it GRM system of the take into account availability will follows the court procedure. SIMURP. of judicial recourses and Understanding the limitation and community and traditional over burden of the court system, the dispute settlement mechanism effectiveness of the implementation still in question Monitoring of outcomes. Requirement to carry out Monitoring and evaluation covers Not clear when, how and what LARAP specify the adequate monitoring and the occupation, ownership, correction measure could be requirement of evaluation of all activities set utilization and benefit of the result enforced monitoring of land out in the resettlement plan of land acquisition without clear on acquisition and when, how and what correction resettlement activities. Assess whether the objectives measure could be enforced. Overall, the project is of the resettlement instrument required to monitor and have been achieved, upon report the preparation completion of the project, and implementation of taking account of the baseline LARAP (and ESMPs conditions and the results of and IPPs as well) resettlement monitoring
Resettlement Cost. The full costs of resettlement activities necessary to achieve the objectives of the project are included in the total costs of the project. Budget plan is part of land acquisition plan but tend not considering the resettlement cost. Resettlement cost is not well described in government regulation LARPF and LARAP require that costs for land acquisition and resettlement is budgeted Consultation and Complaint Procedure. Displaced persons should be meaningfully consulted and should have opportunities to participate in planning and implementing resettlement programs (2.b) Grievance mechanism should take into account availability of judicial recourses and community and traditional dispute settlement mechanism Consultation to the Project Affected People needed to get permit for the proposed location of the project. There is no prior consultation before negotiation on option of compensation. The grievance redress mechanism is clearly described and within the court it will follows the court procedure. Understanding the limitation and over burden of the court system, the effectiveness of the implementation still in question No prior consultation or public consultation before negotiation on option of compensation LARPF and LARAP require consultation and implementation of GRM. Overall, the project has GRM in place as a continuation of the well-functioning GRM system of the SIMURP. Monitoring of outcomes. Requirement to carry out adequate monitoring and evaluation of all activities set out in the resettlement plan Assess whether the objectives of the resettlement instrument have been achieved, upon completion of the project, taking account of the baseline conditions and the results of resettlement monitoring Monitoring and evaluation covers the occupation, ownership, utilization and benefit of the result of land acquisition without clear on when, how and what correction measure could be enforced. Not clear when, how and what correction measure could be enforced LARAP specify the requirement of monitoring of land acquisition and resettlement activities. Overall, the project is required to monitor and report the preparation and implementation of LARAP (and ESMPs and IPPs as well)
ESMF-revised.docx