Content Reflection (15 Points) Thoughtful and insightful Your “Reflection” did not adequately relate to the Reflection is approximately 1 page of text and content of the article. includes: Good connection to core ideas in the article This section was not sufficiently developed (1 page “Initial response to the article was given Good insights min.) Missing/Partial “Design/methodology” was discussed (if More effort needed to “connect” with the concepts appropriate) in the article. Missing/partial “Insights gained” were discussed. Missing/partial “Reasons for interest in topic” were- discussed Missing/partial “Future research interest based on topic” was discussed. Missing/partial Application Application is approximately 1 page of text and Interesting counseling scenario In the future, please describe a specific human includes. services counseling situation (case study, etc.). See More work is needed to incorporate/integrate the my Sample Journal Article Review Student has applied the article’s core ideas to a core ideas of the article into your counseling specific human services counseling situation scenario. For example, the article dealt with In-text citations need to be used for the core ideas (describe the scenario and counseling issue). integration of Scriptures as well as prayer. that you are incorporating into your clinical scenario. Article’s ideas clearly integrated, applied, and cited. Needs more work Core ideas not adequately integrated Core ideas not adequately applied
Content Reflection (15 Points) Reflection is approximately 1 page of text and includes: “Initial response to the article was given Missing/Partial “Design/methodology” was discussed (if appropriate) Missing/partial “Insights gained” were discussed. Missing/partial “Reasons for interest in topic” were- discussed Missing/partial “Future research interest based on topic” was discussed. Missing/partial Thoughtful and insightful Good connection to core ideas in the article Good insights Your “Reflection” did not adequately relate to the content of the article. This section was not sufficiently developed (1 page min.) More effort needed to “connect” with the concepts in the article. Application Application is approximately 1 page of text and includes. Student has applied the article’s core ideas to a specific human services counseling situation (describe the scenario and counseling issue). Article’s ideas clearly integrated, applied, and cited. Needs more work Core ideas not adequately integrated Core ideas not adequately applied Interesting counseling scenario More work is needed to incorporate/integrate the core ideas of the article into your counseling scenario. For example, the article dealt with integration of Scriptures as well as prayer. In the future, please describe a specific human services counseling situation (case study, etc.). See my Sample Journal Article Review In-text citations need to be used for the core ideas that you are incorporating into your clinical scenario.
Enhanced%20Grading%20Rubric%20for%20Journal%20Article%20Reviews%20Revised%205.20.2018.docx