Total Score: ______ out of 75 pts (Sections A E) – Date Reviewed: Total Score: ______ out of 100 pts Rating Guidelines Quality Description Indicator Very Comprehensive and thorough with exceptional detail. Submission is highly responsive and Good specific and of outstanding quality. Reasonably comprehensive and includes sufficient detail. It contains many of the Good characteristics of a response that is very good even though it may lack some specificity, support or elaboration in places. Non-specific and lacks focus and detail. The response addresses some of the selection criteria, but not all. Some ideas presented are sound, but others are not responsive to the Fair purpose of the RFP/performance task. Additional information would be needed in order to be reasonably comprehensive and meet the criteria of a response that is good. Does not meet many criteria; provides inaccurate information or provides information that would require substantial clarification as to how the criteria are met; lacks meaningful detail; Poor demonstrates lack of preparation; or otherwise raises substantial concerns about the applicant’s understanding of the issue in concept and/or ability to meet the requirement in practice. ELEMENTS OF THE PROPOSAL NARRATIVE Section A: Program Overview 0-5 6-10 11-13 14- 15
Date Reviewed: Total Score: ______ out of 75 pts (Sections A – E) Total Score: ______ out of 100 pts Rating Guidelines Quality Indicator Description Very Good Comprehensive and thorough with exceptional detail. Submission is highly responsive and specific and of outstanding quality. Good Reasonably comprehensive and includes sufficient detail. It contains many of the characteristics of a response that is very good even though it may lack some specificity, support or elaboration in places. Fair Non-specific and lacks focus and detail. The response addresses some of the selection criteria, but not all. Some ideas presented are sound, but others are not responsive to the purpose of the RFP/performance task. Additional information would be needed in order to be reasonably comprehensive and meet the criteria of a response that is good. Poor Does not meet many criteria; provides inaccurate information or provides information that would require substantial clarification as to how the criteria are met; lacks meaningful detail; demonstrates lack of preparation; or otherwise raises substantial concerns about the applicant’s understanding of the issue in concept and/or ability to meet the requirement in practice. ELEMENTS OF THE PROPOSAL NARRATIVE Section A: Program Overview 0-5 6-10 11-13 14- 15
nysed-rfp-sa-14-vap-round2.docx