Evidence of Impact Source of evidence Study Type of social Comparison Meeting basic Reducing Health Mental Citation Setting Source of sample Employment design protection needs poverty access health South Africa; 18 children with disabilities or Social assistance, + Berry & Smit Non-recipients with unknown if chronic illness (recruited from targeted and (2011) disabilities rural or urban tertiary care centres) mainstream and 93 experts, including people with + - Goldblatt Social assistance, Qualitative urban South disabilities (recruited from clinics, None No effect (2009) targeted Africa grant offices) + Graham et Mixed Urban South 94 people with disabilities Social assistance, None No effect al (2012) methods Africa (population-based recruitment) targeted Urban and 305 people with cognitive, Jelsma et al Social assistance, Non-recipients with rural South physical or sensory impairments No effect (2008) targeted disabilities Africa (population-based recruitment) + + Levine et al Namibia 2003-2004 Namibia Household Social assistance, Non-recipients with (2011) (national) Income and Expenditures Survey targeted disabilities 826 individuals over 60 either Insurance + Li et al Rural and bedridden or with dementia (pension), None (2013) urban China targeted Social assistance + Loyalka et al China National Survey of Disabled and insurance, None No effect Mixed (2014) (national) Persons (2006) mainstream General Household Surveys All people with - Ecological South Africa Social assistance, Mitra (2008) (2002-06), October Household disabilities in South study (national) targeted Surveys (1998-99) Africa + - South Africa Social assistance, Non-recipients with Mitra (2010) General Household Survey 2005 (national) targeted disabilities Social assistance Palmer et al Vietnam 27 households with a member and insurance None No effect Mixed (2012) (national) with a disability (health), mainstream + Palmer Vietnam 2006 Vietnam Household Living Other recipients Insurance (health) Mixed (2014) (national) Standards Survey without disabilities 241 individuals with bipolar Argentina, - Vazquez et disorder (recruited from Social assistance, Non-recipients with Brazil, al (2011) inpatient/outpatient targeted disabilities Colombia programmes) N.B. spaces indicate that particular study did not assess the given measure. Table 3: Impact of social protection on poverty, employment, health access and mental health
Source of evidence Evidence of Impact Citation Study design Setting Source of sample Type of social protection Comparison Meeting basic needs Reducing poverty Employment Health access Mental health Berry & Smit (2011) South Africa; unknown if rural or urban 18 children with disabilities or chronic illness (recruited from tertiary care centres) Social assistance, targeted and mainstream Non-recipients with disabilities + Goldblatt (2009) Qualitative and urban South Africa 93 experts, including people with disabilities (recruited from clinics, grant offices) Social assistance, targeted None + No effect - Graham et al (2012) Mixed methods Urban South Africa 94 people with disabilities (population-based recruitment) Social assistance, targeted None + No effect Jelsma et al (2008) Urban and rural South Africa 305 people with cognitive, physical or sensory impairments (population-based recruitment) Social assistance, targeted Non-recipients with disabilities No effect Levine et al (2011) Namibia (national) 2003-2004 Namibia Household Income and Expenditures Survey Social assistance, targeted Non-recipients with disabilities + + Li et al (2013) Rural and urban China 826 individuals over 60 either bedridden or with dementia Insurance (pension), targeted None + Loyalka et al (2014) China (national) National Survey of Disabled Persons (2006) Social assistance and insurance, mainstream None + No effect Mixed Mitra (2008) Ecological study South Africa (national) General Household Surveys (2002-06), October Household Surveys (1998-99) Social assistance, targeted All people with disabilities in South Africa - Mitra (2010) South Africa (national) General Household Survey 2005 Social assistance, targeted Non-recipients with disabilities + - Palmer et al (2012) Vietnam (national) 27 households with a member with a disability Social assistance and insurance (health), mainstream None No effect Mixed Palmer (2014) Vietnam (national) 2006 Vietnam Household Living Standards Survey Insurance (health) Other recipients without disabilities Mixed + Vazquez et al (2011) Argentina, Brazil, Colombia 241 individuals with bipolar disorder (recruited from inpatient/outpatient programmes) Social assistance, targeted Non-recipients with disabilities - N.B. spaces indicate that particular study did not assess the given measure. Table 3: Impact of social protection on poverty, employment, health access and mental health
ODS%20Banks_MC_FS_LMB_MC_LMB.docx