Proficient Intermediate Beginner Finding 5 papers found. 3-4 papers found. 1-2 papers Missing All printed out. 5 papers found, but some entirely. scientific > 2 papers, but: All are from not printed out. papers None were printed out. Some are not from scientific None are from journals. scientific Task A All are relevant to the journals. scientific chosen topic. Some are not relevant to journals. None are relevant to the the topic. topic. Finding Correctly identified all of Incorrectly identified Did not correctly identify Missing important the parts of a paper that some of the of a any of the of a paper entirely. were requested. paper. that were requested. parts of the Marked and labeled them Marks and/or labels were papers clearly. unclear or illegible. Task B Bibliography Used correct references Did not correctly identify Used incorrect reference Missing style. the journal, authors, title, entirely. Correctly identified the volume, issue, and/or Incorrectly identified the Task C journal, authors, title, page numbers for 1 or 2 journal, authors, title, volume, issue, and page papers. volume, issue, and/or numbers for every paper. page numbers for 3 or more papers. Annotation Summaries of paper, Summaries of paper, Summaries of paper, Missing methods, and discussion methods, and/or methods, and/or entirely. are accurate reflections discussion do not discussion have no Task D of the contents of the accurately reflect the connection to the paper. paper. contents of the paper. Summaries were copied Summaries are in the Summaries appear to be straight from the abstract. student’s own edited versions of the abstracts. Summary quality varies between papers. Interpretation Correctly assessed how Correctly assessed how Does not appear to Missing each paper would be some papers would be understand the contexts in entirely. most useful. most useful, but which a paper will be Task E Correctly assessed the incorrectly assessed most useful. others. Does not appear to importance of each paper Correctly assessed the to overall scientific understand what makes a progress. importance of each paper paper important. Justification of to overall scientific Did not justify importance ranking progress. assessment of papers shows use of reasoning Justification of importance. skills and makes sense importance ranking is scientifically. illogical or does not make sense scientifically.
Proficient Intermediate Beginner Finding scientific papers Task A 5 papers found. All printed out. All are from scientific journals. All are relevant to the chosen topic. 3-4 papers found. 5 papers found, but some not printed out. Some are not from scientific journals. Some are not relevant to the topic. 1-2 papers > 2 papers, but: None were printed out. None are from scientific journals. None are relevant to the topic. Missing entirely. Finding important parts of the papers Task B Correctly identified all of the parts of a paper that were requested. Marked and labeled them clearly. Incorrectly identified some of the of a paper. Marks and/or labels were unclear or illegible. Did not correctly identify any of the of a paper that were requested. Missing entirely. Bibliography Task C Used correct references style. Correctly identified the journal, authors, title, volume, issue, and page numbers for every paper. Did not correctly identify the journal, authors, title, volume, issue, and/or page numbers for 1 or 2 papers. Used incorrect reference Incorrectly identified the journal, authors, title, volume, issue, and/or page numbers for 3 or more papers. Missing entirely. Annotation Task D Summaries of paper, methods, and discussion are accurate reflections of the contents of the paper. Summaries are in the student’s own Summaries of paper, methods, and/or discussion do not accurately reflect the contents of the paper. Summaries appear to be edited versions of the abstracts. Summary quality varies between papers. Summaries of paper, methods, and/or discussion have no connection to the paper. Summaries were copied straight from the abstract. Missing entirely. Interpretation Task E Correctly assessed how each paper would be most useful. Correctly assessed the importance of each paper to overall scientific progress. Justification of importance ranking shows use of reasoning skills and makes sense scientifically. Correctly assessed how some papers would be most useful, but incorrectly assessed others. Correctly assessed the importance of each paper to overall scientific progress. Justification of importance ranking is illogical or does not make sense scientifically. Does not appear to understand the contexts in which a paper will be most useful. Does not appear to understand what makes a paper important. Did not justify assessment of papers importance. Missing entirely.
MOSKALSKI-Annotated-bibliography.docx