Presentation Rubric Criteria Superior Adequate Poor Delivery 30 points 20 points 10 points Maintains eye contact with Maintains eye Eye contact is audience 90% or more of contact with less than 80%; the time; fluctuations in audience over 80% more than 2 volume and inflection are of the time; 1-2 intended and add to clarity movements; of presentation; no movements; volume inaudible in back movement; is loud enough to be of room more volume is loud enough to heard in the back of than 20% of the be heard in back of room the room 80-89% of time. 90% or more of the time. the time. Comprehension and 20 points 12 points 5 points Accuracy Student answered the Student answered Student failed to NOAA member’s question the NOAA answer question correctly, providing at least member’s question correctly or did 2 accurate scientific facts correctly, providing not provide a at least 1 accurate scientific fact scientific fact Quality of Individual 20 points 12 points 5 points Solution Explanation Individual solution aligns Solution aligns with Solution fails to to all conditions in group all but one condition align with 2 or problem statement more conditions Quality of Individual 20 points 10 points 5 points Justification Reason given for Reason is Reason is not Explanation advocating the group scientifically scientifically “best solution” Is scientifically accurate, but may accurate, but accurate and fiscally not be fiscally may or may not feasible feasible. be fiscally feasible. Reflection 10 points 6 points 0 points Student answers all 5 Student answers reflection questions less than 4
Presentation Rubric Criteria Superior Adequate Poor Delivery 30 points Maintains eye contact with audience 90% or more of the time; fluctuations in volume and inflection are intended and add to clarity of presentation; no movement; volume is loud enough to be heard in back of room 90% or more of the time. 20 points Maintains eye contact with audience over 80% of the time; 1-2 movements; volume is loud enough to be heard in the back of the room 80-89% of the time. 10 points Eye contact is less than 80%; more than 2 movements; inaudible in back of room more than 20% of the time. Comprehension and Accuracy 20 points Student answered the NOAA member’s question correctly, providing at least 2 accurate scientific facts 12 points Student answered the NOAA member’s question correctly, providing at least 1 accurate scientific fact 5 points Student failed to answer question correctly or did not provide a scientific fact Quality of Individual Solution Explanation 20 points Individual solution aligns to all conditions in group problem statement 12 points Solution aligns with all but one condition 5 points Solution fails to align with 2 or more conditions Quality of Individual Justification Explanation 20 points Reason given for advocating the group “best solution” Is scientifically accurate and fiscally feasible 10 points Reason is scientifically accurate, but may not be fiscally feasible. 5 points Reason is not scientifically accurate, but may or may not be fiscally feasible. Reflection 10 points Student answers all 5 reflection questions 6 points 0 points Student answers less than 4
mitchell-pbl.docx