Completed product Completed portfolio Marking key for sample assessment task 13 – Unit 4 Maximum Allocated Evaluation of completed product possible mark mark Evaluation comments with regards to the specifications and design considerations of needs, values and beliefs of the developer and end user clear comments referring to specific design considerations combined with 9–10 justification of design, fulfilling statement of intent requirements and design brief comments outlining major design considerations, and referring to points within 7–8 statement of intent and/or design brief comments linked to design considerations, expressing personal likes and dislikes 5–6 about finished project 3–4 comments outlining use of product, but little reference to design considerations 1–2 comments reflect superficial evaluation /10 Comments and critical analysis of the manufacturing processes; changes and/or improvements evaluation of all procedures with reference to specific procedures, 5 improvements, with little or no change of process 4 appropriate reporting and/or comment on procedures with some logical evaluation of operations, with minor changes to process 3 comments on procedures with limited evaluation of operations, after major changes to process 2 brief comments with few references to processes 1 /5 comments reflect superficial evaluation Evaluation comments and critical analysis of the design process, including any changes and/or improvements clear comments referring to aesthetics, function and safety influenced by specific 5 design changes and suggested improvements 4 comments suggesting improvements referring to major design considerations 3 comments expressing personal likes and dislikes about improvements 2 brief reference to design changes to improve function or aesthetics 1 few comments/superficial notes on improvements /5 Total /20
Completed product Completed portfolio Marking key for sample assessment task 13 – Unit 4 Evaluation of completed product Maximum possible mark Allocated mark Evaluation comments with regards to the specifications and design considerations of needs, values and beliefs of the developer and end user clear comments referring to specific design considerations combined with justification of design, fulfilling statement of intent requirements and design brief comments outlining major design considerations, and referring to points within statement of intent and/or design brief comments linked to design considerations, expressing personal likes and dislikes about finished project comments outlining use of product, but little reference to design considerations comments reflect superficial evaluation 9–10 7–8 5–6 3–4 1–2 /10 Comments and critical analysis of the manufacturing processes; changes and/or improvements evaluation of all procedures with reference to specific procedures, improvements, with little or no change of process appropriate reporting and/or comment on procedures with some logical evaluation of operations, with minor changes to process comments on procedures with limited evaluation of operations, after major changes to process brief comments with few references to processes comments reflect superficial evaluation 5 4 3 2 1 /5 Evaluation comments and critical analysis of the design process, including any changes and/or improvements clear comments referring to aesthetics, function and safety influenced by specific design changes and suggested improvements comments suggesting improvements referring to major design considerations comments expressing personal likes and dislikes about improvements brief reference to design changes to improve function or aesthetics few comments/superficial notes on improvements 5 4 3 2 1 /5 Total /20