Criterion Novice Learner Practitioner Expert Inadequately Adequately Sufficiently Gives detailed Analysing justifies points with justifies opinions justifies opinions justification of Justify examples and and ideas with and ideas with opinions and ideas opinions and ideas, using explanations; some examples examples and with a range of strong examples, evidence may be and explanations; examples and explanations absent or irrelevant explanations; evidence is thorough and to the point; evidence may be appropriate and explanations; terminology commentary is weak; relevant; evidence is strong lacking insight and commentary is commentary and very relevant to understanding basic provides point; commentary sufficient insight provides perceptive insight Using Spells and writes Spell and writes Spells and writes Spells and writes with Language with limited with some with a a high degree of Spell accuracy; errors degree of considerable accuracy; errors are (alphabetic often hinder accuracy; errors degree of minor and languages), communication sometimes accuracy; errors communication is hinder do not hinder effective write communication effective (character languages) communication and pronounce with accuracy
Criterion Novice Learner Practitioner Expert Analysing Justify opinions and ideas, using examples, explanations and terminology Inadequately justifies points with examples and explanations; evidence may be absent or irrelevant to the point; commentary is lacking insight and understanding Adequately justifies opinions and ideas with some examples and explanations; evidence may be weak; commentary is basic Sufficiently justifies opinions and ideas with examples and explanations; evidence is appropriate and relevant; commentary provides sufficient insight Gives detailed justification of opinions and ideas with a range of strong examples and thorough explanations; evidence is strong and very relevant to point; commentary provides perceptive insight Using Language Spell (alphabetic languages), write (character languages) and pronounce with accuracy Spells and writes with limited accuracy; errors often hinder communication Spell and writes with some degree of accuracy; errors sometimes hinder communication Spells and writes with a considerable degree of accuracy; errors do not hinder effective communication Spells and writes with a high degree of accuracy; errors are minor and communication is effective