He was asked to show where the plaintiff had been lying at the time that she was screaming in pain, and he marked with an X on a photograph. He was then asked: Q. that hose would have been in her hand, would it? “So A. It was on the ground lying next to her.” Further, in cross-examination when the witness was told the plaintiff had given an entirely different version as to how the accident had happened, it was put to him: Q. there is a great deal of bad blood between you? “And indeed, A. There is, no doubt about that. Q. Which would go some way to so keen to explaining why you’re come to court here and give evidence that is completely contrary to what Mrs Maley would say? A. Well, I be coming here not to tell bullshit - excuse yeah, wouldn’t – I have got nothing to hide, mate. not gaining nothing if you know I’m what I mean. Q. Are you gaining anything, Mr Brown? A. I got a new fence out of it, about that’s it.” He was later questioned: Q. would you say to someone who has not accused you of “Why anything when you see them later on have been that, ‘You shouldn’t up on the when you see that, and that it is none of your fence’, didn’t fault, why would you use the words, is none of my ‘This fault’? A. Because it is not my fault. Q. But why do you think it was even suggested it was your fault? A. Because I got told I was going to get sued. Q. Who by? A: By her.” Further, he was asked: Q. why do you think she was saying any of this was your fault? “And A. I know, probably because of me (sic) don’t dogs.”
He was asked to show where the plaintiff had been lying at the time that she was screaming in pain, and he marked with an X on a photograph. He was then asked: Q. “So that hose would have been in her hand, would it? A. It was on the ground lying next to her.” Further, in cross-examination when the witness was told the plaintiff had given an entirely different version as to how the accident had happened, it was put to him: Q. “And indeed, there is a great deal of bad blood between you? A. There is, no doubt about that. Q. Which would go some way to explaining why you’re so keen to come to court here and give evidence that is completely contrary to what Mrs Maley would say? A. Well, I wouldn’t be coming here not to tell bullshit - excuse – yeah, I have got nothing to hide, mate. I’m not gaining nothing if you know what I mean. Q. Are you gaining anything, Mr Brown? A. I got a new fence out of it, that’s about it.” He was later questioned: Q. “Why would you say to someone who has not accused you of anything when you see them later on that, ‘You shouldn’t have been up on the fence’, when you didn’t see that, and that it is none of your fault, why would you use the words, ‘This is none of my fault’? A. Because it is not my fault. Q. But why do you think it was even suggested it was your fault? A. Because I got told I was going to get sued. Q. Who by? A: By her.” Further, he was asked: Q. “And why do you think she was saying any of this was your fault? A. I don’t know, probably because of me (sic) dogs.”