6051 Jarkko 69.17 The Trigger field in the Delete the Trigger Reject while there – Kneckt 0 TWT currently controls field in the Request could be an whether the AP shall Type field of the alternative to the send a Trigger to a TWT element. current description STA in TWT SP. The of triggered TWT TWT should not force behavior, the one AP to send Trigger that exists is the frames, the Triggering one that was should be taken into agreed upon, and use when EDCA is not other variations of performing well and TWT SP operation AP should have also exist within the flexibility to control this draft. The current transition. triggered TWT rules do not allow the operation suggested by the commenter because the current rules also recommend that the requesting STA does not send frames outside of the SP. What is being suggested is really, a proposal for a new mode of operation and would need a more complete description to be considered. 6089 74.52 The ax contains Refine the whole Revise generally Jian Yu – description for 11ah paragraph and agree with draft without an clarify which part is comment - TGax clarification. For for ax and which editor shall make example, there is part is for ah. the changes shown description for channel Maybe should also in 11-17/0777r0 width of 1MHz and add ah spec as a that are marked 2MHz for a BSS, whch reference with CID 6089. seems very strange 6349 John 69.59 Superfluous comma: ", Delete comma. Reject an – Coffey 9 otherwise". investigation revealed no reference, no academic imprimatur, no supreme court precedent that supports the proposed change.
6051 Jarkko Kneckt 69.17 The Trigger field in the TWT currently controls whether the AP shall send a Trigger to a STA in TWT SP. The TWT should not force AP to send Trigger frames, the Triggering should be taken into use when EDCA is not performing well and AP should have flexibility to control this transition. Delete the Trigger field in the Request Type field of the TWT element. Reject – while there could be an alternative to the current description of triggered TWT behavior, the one that exists is the one that was agreed upon, and other variations of TWT SP operation also exist within the draft. The current triggered TWT rules do not allow the operation suggested by the commenter because the current rules also recommend that the requesting STA does not send frames outside of the SP. What is being suggested is really, a proposal for a new mode of operation and would need a more complete description to be considered. 6089 Jian Yu 74.52 The ax contains description for 11ah draft without an clarification. For example, there is description for channel width of 1MHz and 2MHz for a BSS, whch seems very strange Refine the whole paragraph and clarify which part is for ax and which part is for ah. Maybe should also add ah spec as a reference Revise – generally agree with comment - TGax editor shall make the changes shown in 11-17/0777r0 that are marked with CID 6089. 6349 John Coffey 69.59 Superfluous comma: ", otherwise". Delete comma. Reject – an investigation revealed no reference, no academic imprimatur, no supreme court precedent that supports the proposed change. 9 0