14285 27.9.2.3 294.04 We should consider the Two suggestion. See 11-17-LLLLrY case a STA queue 1. OBSS_PD SR is empty ignored an transmit power inter-BSS PPDU for restriction period receiving opportunity. shall be applied to The STA does not intend only a STA which transmission which starts countdown of would cause backoff. interference, so the 2. Define upper OBSS_PD SR transmit limit of OBSS_PD power restriction period SR transmit power should not be applied to restriction period. the STA. Otherwise the restriction period for such a STA, e.g. a light traffic device, is going to be unreasonably long. 11942 27.9.2.3 294.06 Should have a maximum Recommend to See 11-17-LLLLrY (such as maximum change to --- This June allowable TXOP OBSS_PD SR Wang duration) for OBSS_PD transmit SR transmit power restriction period restriction period shall be terminated regardless when STA at the end of the gains TXOP its backoff TXOP reaches zero. Since it that the STA gains might take a long time once its backoff for backoff to reach zero reaches zero or in some cases. TBD duration whichever is sooner". 11940 27.9.2.3 294.07 Note 1 and Note 2 Change to See 11-17-LLLLrY should be nomative text. nomative text June Wang 11781 27.9.2.3 294.11 "TXP-Wrmax" should not Delete "-" See 11-17-LLLLrY have the "-" Smith
14285 27.9.2.3 294.04 We should consider the case a STA queue is empty ignored an inter-BSS PPDU for receiving opportunity. The STA does not intend transmission which would cause interference, so the OBSS_PD SR transmit power restriction period should not be applied to the STA. Otherwise the restriction period for such a STA, e.g. a light traffic device, is going to be unreasonably long. Two suggestion. 1. OBSS_PD SR transmit power restriction period shall be applied to only a STA which starts countdown of backoff. 2. Define upper limit of OBSS_PD SR transmit power restriction period. See 11-17-LLLLrY 11942 June Wang 27.9.2.3 294.06 Should have a maximum (such as maximum allowable TXOP duration) for OBSS_PD SR transmit power restriction period regardless when STA gains TXOP its backoff reaches zero. Since it might take a long time for backoff to reach zero in some cases. Recommend to change to --- This OBSS_PD SR transmit restriction period shall be terminated at the end of the TXOP that the STA gains once its backoff reaches zero or TBD duration whichever is sooner". See 11-17-LLLLrY 11940 June Wang 27.9.2.3 294.07 Note 1 and Note 2 should be nomative text. Change to nomative text See 11-17-LLLLrY 11781 Smith 27.9.2.3 294.11 "TXP-Wrmax" should not have the "-" Delete "-" See 11-17-LLLLrY