12105 28.3.19 496 34 "Each output port of the Clarify. At minimum, Rejected. transmitting STA shall be add at the beginning connected through a cable of the clause or of There is no need to to the Device Under Test". If the sentence clarify. The exact this means that the CCA "Except for the CCA description is in 11md sensitivity requirements in sensitivity subclause for previous version 28.3.19.6 are only (28.3.19.6) ...". 802.11 standards. applicable in a cabled setup, Change causes then the statement is inconsistence and severely problematic. The more confusion. whole point of a CCA requirement is that it places some restriction on the behavior of devices in their normal environment, i.e., wireless operation. How to test such behavior is a separate question. 12014 500 13 "non-primary 20MHz Please clarify. Revised. channel" here is not clear. Does it mean each 11ax editor, please see primary 20MHz channel as the discussion for the counterpart in the HE TB instructions of CID PPDU transmission? IEEE 12014 in doc xxxx. 12106 delete bulletins g) 500 26 Rejected. and h) There is no need to clarify. The exact description is in 11md for previous version 802.11 standards. Change causes inconsistence and more confusion. Discussions for CID 12014: TGax Editor: Please make the following text change (changed texts are in red) in the line 11-15, page 552 of D2.3: For a BQR transmission, CCA-ED shall detect a channel busy condition when the received signal strength exceeds the CCA-ED threshold as given by dot11OFDMEDThreshold for 20 MHz
12105 28.3.19 496 34 "Each output port of the transmitting STA shall be connected through a cable to the Device Under Test". If this means that the CCA sensitivity requirements in 28.3.19.6 are only applicable in a cabled setup, then the statement is severely problematic. The whole point of a CCA requirement is that it places some restriction on the behavior of devices in their normal environment, i.e., wireless operation. How to test such behavior is a separate question. Clarify. At minimum, add at the beginning of the clause or of the sentence "Except for the CCA sensitivity subclause (28.3.19.6) ...". Rejected. There is no need to clarify. The exact description is in 11md for previous version 802.11 standards. Change causes inconsistence and more confusion. 12014 500 13 "non-primary 20MHz channel" here is not clear. Does it mean each 20MHz channel as the counterpart in the HE TB PPDU transmission? Please clarify. Revised. 11ax editor, please see the discussion for instructions of CID 12014 in doc IEEE xxxx. 12106 500 26 delete bulletins g) and h) Rejected. There is no need to clarify. The exact description is in 11md for previous version 802.11 standards. Change causes inconsistence and more confusion. Discussions for CID 12014: TGax Editor: Please make the following text change (changed texts are in red) in the line 11-15, page 552 of D2.3: For a BQR transmission, CCA-ED shall detect a channel busy condition when the received signal strength exceeds the CCA-ED threshold as given by dot11OFDMEDThreshold for primary 20 MHz