9.17b As the calculation result, Remove "one or Revised- 2165 165 different STAs may have the more" from line 35. An S1G SU same PARTIAL_AID but we PPDU can cannot provide the same include PARTIAL_AID to different multiple STAs all the time. Hence it having the seems to be strange to same RA include a case, more than address. Also, one individually addressed the same MPDUs, to use Table 9-19b sentence is or Table 9-19c. also used in 11ac. There is no issue. But, in Table the PAID rule of an individually addressed MPDU needs to specify the exception case of the control frame. TGah editor to make changes shown in CID 2165 Discussion: According Table 9-19c, the Partial AID (PAID) of RTC/CTS frame is set to either (dec(BSSID[39:47])mod(2^9-1))+1 or (dec(AID[0:8])+dec(BSSID[44:47] BSSID[40:43])×2^5)mod 2^6. XOR So, 3rd party STA may filter out RTS/CTS frame because the PAID is not matched. The virtual CS mechanism can not work because 3rd party STA does not set the NAV. The PAID of control frames (e.g., RTS, CTS, ACK, ACK, etc) is set to 0, in order to prevent filtering of the control frames Propose: Revised for CID 2165, per discussion and editing instructions in 11-14/0069r0. TGah editor: Modify Table 9-19c as the following: Group ID, partial AID, UPLINK and Color in S1G PPDUs Settings for the TXVECTOR parameters PARTIAL_AID for non-1MHz
2165 165 9.17b As the calculation result, different STAs may have the same PARTIAL_AID but we cannot provide the same PARTIAL_AID to different STAs all the time. Hence it seems to be strange to include a case, more than one individually addressed MPDUs, to use Table 9-19b or Table 9-19c. Remove "one or more" from line 35. Revised- An S1G SU PPDU can include multiple having the same RA address. Also, the same sentence is also used in 11ac. There is no issue. But, in Table the PAID rule of an individually addressed MPDU needs to specify the exception case of the control frame. TGah editor to make changes shown in CID 2165 Discussion: According Table 9-19c, the Partial AID (PAID) of RTC/CTS frame is set to either (dec(BSSID[39:47])mod(2^9-1))+1 or (dec(AID[0:8])+dec(BSSID[44:47] XOR BSSID[40:43])×2^5)mod 2^6. So, 3rd party STA may filter out RTS/CTS frame because the PAID is not matched. The virtual CS mechanism can not work because 3rd party STA does not set the NAV. The PAID of control frames (e.g., RTS, CTS, ACK, ACK, etc) is set to 0, in order to prevent filtering of the control frames Propose: Revised for CID 2165, per discussion and editing instructions in 11-14/0069r0. TGah editor: Modify Table 9-19c as the following: Group ID, partial AID, UPLINK and Color in S1G PPDUs Settings for the TXVECTOR parameters PARTIAL_AID for non-1MHz