Grounds of review & Procedual Fairness Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 JUDICIAL REVIEW REGIMES Constitutional Common Law Statutory Constitution: Inherent com. law Commonwealth: s75(v) jurisdiction ADJRA – gives Fed. Crt & s75(iii) Gives superior crts of Fed. Mag Crt original Gives the HCrt original record, i.e. SCrts of the jurisdiction jurisdiction States original State – e.g. QLD jurisdiction Judiciary Act s39B(1) & JRA – gives SCrt original s39B(1A)(c) gives Fed Crt statutory jurisdiction original jurisdiction In both cases the HCrt & Crts apply com. law Crts apply the relevant Fed Crt apply com.law remedies, rules, norms & statutory scheme remedies, norms, rules & principles contained in the act principles as modified by the Constitutional or statutory origins of the crt’s power; e.g. certiorari not stated as a remedy in 75(v) and s39B(1)
Grounds of review & Procedual Fairness Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 Module 5 JUDICIAL REVIEW REGIMES Constitutional Common Law Statutory Constitution: s75(v) s75(iii) Gives the HCrt original jurisdiction Judiciary Act s39B(1) & s39B(1A)(c) gives Fed Crt original jurisdiction Inherent com. law jurisdiction Gives superior crts of record, i.e. SCrts of the States original jurisdiction Commonwealth: ADJRA – gives Fed. Crt & Fed. Mag Crt original jurisdiction State – e.g. QLD JRA – gives SCrt original statutory jurisdiction In both cases the HCrt & Fed Crt apply com.law remedies, norms, rules & principles as modified by the Constitutional or statutory origins of the crt’s power; e.g. certiorari not stated as a remedy in 75(v) and s39B(1) Crts apply com. law remedies, rules, norms & principles Crts apply the relevant statutory scheme contained in the act