14 9.8.3.2 Behaviour of addressed Describe behaviour Revise - TGmd editor to recipient is not clear of the addressed make changes as when it receives PV1 recipient in this shown in 11-18/1724r3 non-A-MPDU frame that scenario. that are marked with is not a fragment and CR14, which modify both originator and table 9-536 by explicitly addressed recipient naming the support fragment BA. case and by explicitly naming STACK, TACK and BAT as response choices and by including references to 10.48.2 (TWT acknowledgement procedure) 15 10.6.6.6 If AP is using 2MHz Provide an Reject the channel to – 18 primary channel it is not explanation of this use for the 1 MHz clear which channel scenario. control response is should be used for clear, but the rule is 1MHz Control response. located elsewhere, see 10.47.1 Basic S1G BSS functionality (i.e. it is restricted to the primary channel) 16 9.9.2.3.1 NDP_1M PS-Poll has Modify NDP_1M Reject the existing PS – Partial AID for TA and PS-Poll so it POLL frame allows for AP cannot uniquely contains full AID so an unambiguous AID determine STA is AP can uniquely value and may be used transmitting the NDP determine which is instead of the NDP PS PS-Poll frame and transmitting STA. POLL, if the therefore cannot send transmitting STA BU. chooses. Additionally, the AP has the ability to indicate that NDP PS POLL transmissions are not allowed within the BSS. While not explicitly specified, it is likely that an AP that permits the use of NDP PS POLL will only do so if it does not assign AID values beyond the carrying capacity of the NDP PS POLL, thereby making the use of the NDP PS POLL unambiguous. 9.9.2.3.2 NDP_2M PS-Poll has Modify NDP_2M Reject the existing PS – Partial AID for TA and PS-Poll frame so it POLL frame allows for AP cannot uniquely contains full AID so an unambiguous AID determine which STA is AP can uniquely value and may be used transmitting the NDP determine which is instead of the NDP PS PS-Poll frame and transmitting STA. POLL, if the therefore cannot send transmitting STA BU. chooses. Additionally, the AP has the ability to indicate that NDP PS
14 9.8.3.2 Behaviour of addressed recipient is not clear when it receives PV1 non-A-MPDU frame that is not a fragment and both originator and addressed recipient support fragment BA. Describe behaviour of the addressed recipient in this scenario. Revise - TGmd editor to make changes as shown in 11-18/1724r3 that are marked with CR14, which modify table 9-536 by explicitly naming the case and by explicitly naming STACK, TACK and BAT as response choices and by including references to 10.48.2 (TWT acknowledgement procedure) 15 10.6.6.6 If AP is using 2MHz primary channel it is not clear which channel should be used for 1MHz Control response. Provide an explanation of this scenario. Reject – the channel to use for the 1 MHz control response is clear, but the rule is located elsewhere, see 10.47.1 Basic S1G BSS functionality (i.e. it is restricted to the primary channel) 16 9.9.2.3.1 NDP_1M PS-Poll has Partial AID for TA and AP cannot uniquely determine STA is transmitting the NDP PS-Poll frame and therefore cannot send BU. Modify NDP_1M PS-Poll so it contains full AID so AP can uniquely determine which is transmitting STA. Reject – the existing PS POLL frame allows for an unambiguous AID value and may be used instead of the NDP PS POLL, if the transmitting STA chooses. Additionally, the AP has the ability to indicate that NDP PS POLL transmissions are not allowed within the BSS. While not explicitly specified, it is likely that an AP that permits the use of NDP PS POLL will only do so if it does not assign AID values beyond the carrying capacity of the NDP PS POLL, thereby making the use of the NDP PS POLL unambiguous. 9.9.2.3.2 NDP_2M PS-Poll has Partial AID for TA and AP cannot uniquely determine which STA is transmitting the NDP PS-Poll frame and therefore cannot send BU. Modify NDP_2M PS-Poll frame so it contains full AID so AP can uniquely determine which is transmitting STA. Reject – the existing PS POLL frame allows for an unambiguous AID value and may be used instead of the NDP PS POLL, if the transmitting STA chooses. Additionally, the AP has the ability to indicate that NDP PS 18