8 1.2 1 This is not the approved purpose statement Change verbatim to the approved PAR purpose Yes Thaden Technical Resolved language. from the PAR approved on 3/31/11. 9 3.1.1 4 Definition is incorrect. DP is not a test, it is a Define degree of polymerization. Yes Thaden Technical Resolved value. 10 4 4 Move material not directly dealing with Yes Thaden Technical Unresolved The guide While this clause has a lot of good information, it is not about how to recondition a transformer and is in reconditioning transformers to appendices. title is evaluation and my opinion beyond the scope of the approved reconditioning of a project. The reader has to wade through all this transformer so a risk material to get to clause 6, where he finally gets analysis is a necessary what the title and scope promise. Suggest that this material be placed in an appendix. part of the evaluation. Contact Balloter 11 4.1 5 Another factor is the criticality of the load Add additional consideration. No Thaden Technical Resolved served by the transformer (hospitals, interconnections, major oad centers, etc.) 12 4.2 6 Why is insulation defects (third paragraph) a Delete third paragraph from vintage clause or Yes Thaden Technical Resolved moved to vintage issue? explain how it is a vintage issue.. section 4.4 13 4.4.2 7 This is a vintage issue and should be moved to Move 4.2.2 to 4.2 Yes Thaden Technical resolved; it could be 4.2. incorporated into vintage but it is also part of a general discussion on cellulose. Moved 4.2.2 to 4.2 14 4.7 8 This material is covered in other standards and Simplify the wording of this subclause. No Thaden Editorial Unresolved; include technical papers. Why do all these words need references for a more
8 1.2 1 This is not the approved purpose statement from the PAR approved on 3/31/11. Change verbatim to the approved PAR purpose language. Yes Thaden Technical Resolved 9 3.1.1 4 Definition is incorrect. DP is not a test, it is a value. Define degree of polymerization. Yes Thaden Technical Resolved 10 4 4 While this clause has a lot of good information, it is not about how to recondition a transformer and is in my opinion beyond the scope of the approved project. The reader has to wade through all this material to get to clause 6, where he finally gets what the title and scope promise. Suggest that this material be placed in an appendix. Move material not directly dealing with reconditioning transformers to appendices. Yes Thaden Technical Unresolved The guide title is evaluation and reconditioning of a transformer so a risk analysis is a necessary part of the evaluation. Contact Balloter 11 4.1 5 Another factor is the criticality of the load served by the transformer (hospitals, interconnections, major oad centers, etc.) Add additional consideration. No Thaden Technical Resolved 12 4.2 6 Why is insulation defects (third paragraph) a vintage issue? Delete third paragraph from vintage clause or explain how it is a vintage issue.. Yes Thaden Technical Resolved moved to section 4.4 13 4.4.2 7 This is a vintage issue and should be moved to 4.2. Move 4.2.2 to 4.2 Yes Thaden Technical resolved; it could be incorporated into vintage but it is also part of a general discussion on cellulose. Moved 4.2.2 to 4.2 14 4.7 8 This material is covered in other standards and technical papers. Why do all these words need Simplify the wording of this subclause. No Thaden Editorial Unresolved; include references for a more