Thesis Statement Ideas Word Choice Voice Unique, original details Concise and Descriptive, formal Formal tone understandable Specific information language Writer engaged with topic Main ideas Compelling ideas Carefully chosen words Matches purpose and Avoids cliches Matches Voice audience /15 /15 /15 /15 Organization Sentence Fluency Conventions MLA Format Logically grouped Proper format info. Various sentence types Limited capitalization and punctuation errors In-text citations Flow of ideas Various sentence structures Limited grammar issues Works Cited Page Intro., Body, Supports Voice Conclusion Avoids plagiarism /10 /10 /10 /10 Comments: Appendix S Source: http://www.u.arizona.edu/~eleni/images/PEER%20REVIEW%20RESPONSE%20SHEET.pdf PEER REVIEW RESPONSE SHEET Writer’s Name:______________________________ Reviewer’s Name:____________________________
Thesis Statement Concise and understandable Main ideas /15 Ideas Unique, original details Specific information Compelling ideas Avoids cliches /15 Word Choice Descriptive, formal language Carefully chosen words Matches Voice /15 Voice Formal tone Writer engaged with topic Matches purpose and audience /15 Organization Logically grouped info. Flow of ideas Intro., Body, Conclusion /10 Sentence Fluency Various sentence types Various sentence structures Supports Voice /10 Conventions Limited capitalization and punctuation errors Limited grammar issues /10 MLA Format Proper format In-text citations Works Cited Page Avoids plagiarism /10 Comments: Appendix S Source: http://www.u.arizona.edu/~eleni/images/PEER%20REVIEW%20RESPONSE%20SHEET.pdf PEER REVIEW RESPONSE SHEET Writer’s Name:______________________________ Reviewer’s Name:____________________________