Literary Essay Rubric High Medium Low Fluency The essay includes at The includes five The essay does not least five, paragraphs, but they include five paragraphs or paragraphs. are not the choppiness of the The sentences are easy or the language distracts from to follow and help to language is choppy. the meaning. make the essay understandable. Development The includes a The essay includes a The lacks a clear clear claim. It includes relatively clear claim. claim. It lacks evidence or specific, well-chosen Some pieces of does not support the evidence from the text evidence support the claim at all. The that supports that claim. The interpretation does not claim. The interpretation may make sense and does not interpretation makes not make sense or support the claim. sense and clearly does not clearly supports the claim. support the claim. Organization The includes the The essay includes at The essay does not types of body least one of the best include the best types of paragraphs that best types of body body paragraphs to support the claim. The paragraph to provide provide enough support transitions between basic support for the for the claim. examples and claim. The transitions The transitions between paragraphs make for might make the essay examples and between smooth reading easier to read. paragraphs are choppy and distract from meaning. Editing/ The essay is essentially The essay includes The essay includes Correctness error free. There is a occasional errors. multiple errors. Little or sense of careful editing. Some sense of editing no sense of editing is Appropriate format for is obvious. Some present. Rules for literary essay is used. errors in formatting a formatting a literary essay are not followed.
Literary Essay Rubric High Medium Low Fluency The essay includes at least five, paragraphs. The sentences are easy to follow and help to make the essay understandable. The includes five paragraphs, but they are not or the language is choppy. The essay does not include five paragraphs or the choppiness of the language distracts from the meaning. Development The includes a clear claim. It includes specific, well-chosen evidence from the text that supports that claim. The interpretation makes sense and clearly supports the claim. The essay includes a relatively clear claim. Some pieces of evidence support the claim. The interpretation may not make sense or does not clearly support the claim. The lacks a clear claim. It lacks evidence or does not support the claim at all. The interpretation does not make sense and does not support the claim. Organization The includes the types of body paragraphs that best support the claim. The transitions between examples and paragraphs make for smooth reading The essay includes at least one of the best types of body paragraph to provide basic support for the claim. The transitions might make the essay easier to read. The essay does not include the best types of body paragraphs to provide enough support for the claim. The transitions between examples and between paragraphs are choppy and distract from meaning. Editing/ Correctness The essay is essentially error free. There is a sense of careful editing. Appropriate format for literary essay is used. The essay includes occasional errors. Some sense of editing is obvious. Some errors in formatting a The essay includes multiple errors. Little or no sense of editing is present. Rules for formatting a literary essay are not followed.