APSC-100 (2010 -2011) MEA2: Clay water filter 1 2 3 4 Mark (not demonstrated) (marginal) (meets expectations) (outstanding) (/4) Information summary Information not Some important Identifies known and Meets expectations plus: identified properly, no information or biases unknown information, Includes information from 3.02-FY1: Identify problem information, or not identified, or uncertainties, and biases. authoritative sources to information copied trivial/incorrect inform process, model, and from assignment. information included. conclusions. /4 Proposed process No or inadequate Process identified Creates justified process Meets expectations plus: process misses some important for solving problem, Comprehensive process 3.02-FY2: Create process factors; some including concept map, model; comparison with assumptions left that includes T,S,E,F other possible approaches. unidentified or factors. unjustified. /4 Analysis No analysis, or Model selected, some Uses analysis to make Meets expectations plus: model/analysis errors in analysis or decision on multiple Authoritative research used 3.02-FY3: Select model selected is inappropriate factors reasonable to defend assumptions and inappropriate assumptions. approximations and approximations made assumptions. /4 Model results and No evaluation of Superficial evaluation of Evaluates validity of Meets expectations plus: conclusions solution. solution results and for error, Evaluates conclusions and impact of uncertainty. presents potential 3.02-FY4: Evalute solution improvements. /4 Side effects No or trivial Some important Describes potential side Meets expectations plus: recommendations recommendations and effects of design. Potential side effects 3.10-FY3: Describes ethical implications missed. informed by model, analysis, /4 issues
APSC-100 (2010 -2011) MEA2: Clay water filter 1 (not demonstrated) 2 (marginal) 3 (meets expectations) 4 (outstanding) Mark (/4) Information summary 3.02-FY1: Identify problem Information not identified properly, no information, or information copied from assignment. Some important information or biases not identified, or trivial/incorrect information included. Identifies known and unknown information, uncertainties, and biases. Meets expectations plus: Includes information from authoritative sources to inform process, model, and conclusions. /4 Proposed process 3.02-FY2: Create process No or inadequate process Process identified misses some important factors; some assumptions left unidentified or unjustified. Creates justified process for solving problem, including concept map, that includes T,S,E,F factors. Meets expectations plus: Comprehensive process model; comparison with other possible approaches. /4 Analysis 3.02-FY3: Select model No analysis, or model/analysis selected is inappropriate Model selected, some errors in analysis or inappropriate assumptions. Uses analysis to make decision on multiple factors reasonable approximations and assumptions. Meets expectations plus: Authoritative research used to defend assumptions and approximations made /4 Model results and conclusions 3.02-FY4: Evalute solution No evaluation of solution. Superficial evaluation of solution Evaluates validity of results and for error, impact of uncertainty. Meets expectations plus: Evaluates conclusions and presents potential improvements. /4 Side effects 3.10-FY3: Describes ethical issues No or trivial recommendations Some important recommendations and implications missed. Describes potential side effects of design. Meets expectations plus: Potential side effects informed by model, analysis, /4