APSC-100 (2010 -2011) MEA1: Mersey Venture Elevator Failure 1 2 3 4 Mark (not demonstrated) (marginal) (meets expectations) (outstanding) (/4) Information not identified Some important Identifies known and Information summary expectations plus: properly, no information, information or biases not unknown information, 3.02-FY1: Identify problem or information copied identified, or uncertainties, and biases. Includes information from from assignment. trivial/incorrect authoritative sources to information included. inform process, model, and conclusions. /4 Proposed process No or inadequate Process identified Creates justified process for Meets expectations plus: process misses some important solving problem, suppored 3.02-FY2: Create process factors; some by information. Comprehensive process assumptions left model; comparison with unidentified or other possible approaches. unjustified. /4 No analysis, or Model selected, some Selects and applies Model expectations plus: model/analysis selected errors in analysis or appropriate quantitative 3.02-FY3: Select model is inappropriate inappropriate and MATLAB analysis to Authoritative research assumptions. solve problems, using used to defend reasonable approximations assumptions and and assumptions. approximations made /4 Model results and No evaluation of Superficial evaluation of Evaluates validity of results expectations plus: conclusions solution. solution and model for error, uncertainty Evaluates conclusions and 3.02-FY4: Evalute solution presents potential improvements. /4 No or trivial Some important Makes supported Meets expectations plus: Recommendations recommendations recommendations and recommendations to 3.10-FY3: Describes implications missed. prevent future failures; Information, model, and ethical issues describes implications to conclusions used to make stakeholders. recommendations supported by authoritative information. /4
APSC-100 (2010 -2011) MEA1: Mersey Venture Elevator Failure 1 (not demonstrated) 2 (marginal) 3 (meets expectations) 4 (outstanding) Mark (/4) Information summary 3.02-FY1: Identify problem Information not identified properly, no information, or information copied from assignment. Some important information or biases not identified, or trivial/incorrect information included. Identifies known and unknown information, uncertainties, and biases. expectations plus: Includes information from authoritative sources to inform process, model, and conclusions. /4 Proposed process 3.02-FY2: Create process No or inadequate process Process identified misses some important factors; some assumptions left unidentified or unjustified. Creates justified process for solving problem, suppored by information. Meets expectations plus: Comprehensive process model; comparison with other possible approaches. /4 Model 3.02-FY3: Select model No analysis, or model/analysis selected is inappropriate Model selected, some errors in analysis or inappropriate assumptions. Selects and applies appropriate quantitative and MATLAB analysis to solve problems, using reasonable approximations and assumptions. expectations plus: Authoritative research used to defend assumptions and approximations made /4 Model results and conclusions 3.02-FY4: Evalute solution No evaluation of solution. Superficial evaluation of solution Evaluates validity of results and model for error, uncertainty expectations plus: Evaluates conclusions and presents potential improvements. /4 Recommendations 3.10-FY3: Describes ethical issues No or trivial recommendations Some important recommendations and implications missed. Makes supported recommendations to prevent future failures; describes implications to stakeholders. Meets expectations plus: Information, model, and conclusions used to make recommendations supported by authoritative information. /4