explains some of discussion, and empirical article the supporting implications). information, clearly separates Summary the core ideas from adequately provides peripheral ideas, the foundation for recognizes the subsequent 2 underlying sections of paper. presuppositions of main points and Article is chosen implications for from list provided. human services counseling 10 points 9 points 8 points 1-7 points 0 points 10 points Student includes Reflection is Student includes Student clearly approximately 1 requirements from some of the deviates from page of text and the elements mentioned the “Proficient” includes: column but also in the requirements “Proficient” initial response, demonstrates column and may mentioned in comments about exceptional insight demonstrate only a the “Proficient” design/methodology and understanding, perfunctory column (if appropriate), insights gained, identifies understanding of reasons for your weaknesses and the article interest in topic, and strengths in the future research article, and offers interest based on unique topic. implications for human services counseling
explains some of the supporting information, clearly separates the core ideas from peripheral ideas, recognizes underlying presuppositions of main points and implications for human services counseling discussion, and implications). Summary adequately provides the foundation for the subsequent 2 sections of paper. Article is chosen from list provided. empirical article 10 points 10 points Student includes requirements from the “Proficient” column but also demonstrates exceptional insight and understanding, identifies weaknesses and strengths in the article, and offers unique implications for human services counseling 9 points Reflection is approximately 1 page of text and includes: initial response, comments about design/methodology (if appropriate), insights gained, reasons for your interest in topic, and future research interest based on topic. 8 points Student includes some of the elements mentioned in the “Proficient” column and may demonstrate only a perfunctory understanding of the article 1-7 points Student clearly deviates from the requirements mentioned in the “Proficient” column 0 points