Criteria 1 2 3 4 A Minimal: some Emerging: Effective: clear Master: clear Inferential evidence of growing evidence of evidence of understanding evidence of understanding understanding the ability to sources (e.g. understanding sources with sources with no understand a ability to sources (e.g. few flaws. apparent flaws. historical recognize bias recognize bias Excellent Excellent source or points of or different capacity to capacity to view.) Often has points of view.) recognize bias recognize bias flaws. or different or different points of view. points of view. B Minimal: able to Emerging: able Effective: clear Master: Diverse show a basic to show a understanding excellent pserspectives-- understanding understanding of a historical understanding showing an of a historical of a historical actorís position of a historical understanding actorís position actorís position with a good actorís of ìmultiple but often has with a better sense of position. Makes perspectivesî flaws sense of "objectivity". objective and and making "objectivity" Makes critical critical judgements judgements judgements only from the only from the evidence evidence C Minimal: tries Emerging: Effective: no Master: no use Avoids to avoid avoids use of use of of presentism. presentism but presentism but presentism. Meanings and allow work often has has some Meanings and values are current day current day current day values are put effectively put views to views views into the correct into the correct interfere with time and place time / place looking at and shows sources excellent judgement D E F
Criteria 1 2 3 4 A Inferential ability to understand a historical source Minimal: some evidence of understanding sources (e.g. the ability to recognize bias or points of view.) Often has flaws. Emerging: growing evidence of understanding sources (e.g. recognize bias or different points of view.) Effective: clear evidence of understanding sources with few flaws. Excellent capacity to recognize bias or different points of view. Master: clear evidence of understanding sources with no apparent flaws. Excellent capacity to recognize bias or different points of view. B Diverse pserspectives-- showing an understanding of ìmultiple perspectivesî and making critical judgements Minimal: able to show a basic understanding of a historical actorís position but often has flaws Emerging: able to show a understanding of a historical actorís position with a better sense of "objectivity" Effective: clear understanding of a historical actorís position with a good sense of "objectivity". Makes judgements only from the evidence Master: excellent understanding of a historical actorís position. Makes objective and critical judgements only from the evidence C Avoids allow current day views to interfere with looking at sources Minimal: tries to avoid presentism but work often has current day views Emerging: avoids use of presentism but has some current day views Effective: no use of presentism. Meanings and values are put into the correct time and place Master: no use of presentism. Meanings and values are effectively put into the correct time / place and shows excellent judgement D E F