Introduction Thesis Arguments Evidence Conclusion 5 Clear and Takes a clear Each argument relates All evidence relates Restates the engaging; position; directly to the thesis; directly to the thesis and provides insightful, follow a natural order argument; uses arguments; detailed specific, and (chronological, escalating specific clear and background compelling. significance, etc.); sourced facts; compelling; information. helpfully summarize and thoroughly offers further move past defends each suggestion or counter-arguments. argument. insight. 3 Clear or Takes a clear Most arguments relate Evidence mostly Restates the engaging; position; directly to the thesis; relates to the thesis and provides includes seem to be well-ordered; argument; uses arguments; some some detail; make mention of some specific clear or background is possible facts; compelling. information. interesting. arguments. defends most 1 Unclear; Position not Arguments are not Evidence relates Restates a part provides entirely clearly related to the only peripherally to of the thesis and little clear; little thesis; little evidence of the argument; uses arguments. background evidence of organization; little few sourced facts; information. insight or evidence of little defense of detail. arguments.
Introduction Thesis Arguments Evidence Conclusion 5 Clear and engaging; provides detailed background information. Takes a clear position; insightful, specific, and compelling. Each argument relates directly to the thesis; follow a natural order (chronological, escalating significance, etc.); helpfully summarize and move past All evidence relates directly to the argument; uses specific facts; thoroughly defends each argument. Restates the thesis and arguments; clear and compelling; offers further suggestion or insight. 3 Clear or engaging; provides some background information. Takes a clear position; includes some detail; is interesting. Most arguments relate directly to the thesis; seem to be well-ordered; make mention of possible counter-arguments. Evidence mostly relates to the argument; uses some specific sourced facts; defends most arguments. Restates the thesis and arguments; clear or compelling. 1 Unclear; provides little background information. Position not entirely clear; little evidence of insight or detail. Arguments are not clearly related to the thesis; little evidence of organization; little evidence of Evidence relates only peripherally to the argument; uses few sourced facts; little defense of arguments. Restates a part of the thesis and arguments.