Program Review Self-Study Rubric DATE _____ DEPARTMENT: _______________ DEGREE/CERT PROGRAM: _____________ Peer Feedback Administrative Feedback Other 1 2 3 4 Criterion Initial Emerging Developed Highly Developed 1. Mission Fails to link program Superficial Some alignment Strong alignment Alignment to the connections between described between described between the college’s to strategic plan and the the department work the department work department work and the college mission and college mission. and the larger work of and the larger work of larger work of the college the college (strategic the college (strategic (strategic plan and strategic plan plan and mission). plan and mission). mission). Comments: 2. Profile Little to no historical Incomplete Contains essential Contains essential information, information on historical and historical and demographics, and department history, demographic demographic narrative data related to demographics, and narrative information. information. Data and staffing, budget, data related to It may need more descriptions clear and facilities, and college staffing, budget, thorough data support complete; data-supported resources. facilities, and college for staffing, budget, statements of need for resources. facilities, and college staffing, budget, facilities, resources. and college resources. Comments: 3. Program Context No discussion of Some discussion of Good discussion of Thorough discussion of local/regional trends local/regional trends local/regional trends local/regional trends or or issues. No or issues. Limited or issues. External issues. Clear process of acknowledgement of examples of external stakeholder feedback gathering external whether external collected, discussed, stakeholder feedback; stakeholders’
Program Review Self-Study Rubric DATE _____ DEPARTMENT: _______________ DEGREE/CERT PROGRAM: _____________ Peer Feedback Administrative Feedback Other Criterion 1 Initial 2 Emerging 3 Developed 4 Highly Developed 1. Mission Alignment to college mission and strategic plan Fails to link program to the college’s strategic plan and the college mission. Superficial connections between the department work and the larger work of the college (strategic plan and mission). Some alignment described between the department work and the larger work of the college (strategic plan and mission). Strong alignment described between the department work and the larger work of the college (strategic plan and mission). Comments: 2. Profile Little to no historical information, demographics, and data related to staffing, budget, facilities, and college resources. Incomplete information on department history, demographics, and data related to staffing, budget, facilities, and college resources. Contains essential historical and demographic narrative information. It may need more thorough data support for staffing, budget, facilities, and college resources. Contains essential historical and demographic narrative information. Data and descriptions clear and complete; data-supported statements of need for staffing, budget, facilities, and college resources. Comments: 3. Program Context No discussion of local/regional trends or issues. No acknowledgement of whether external Some discussion of local/regional trends or issues. Limited examples of external stakeholders’ Good discussion of local/regional trends or issues. External stakeholder feedback collected, discussed, Thorough discussion of local/regional trends or issues. Clear process of gathering external stakeholder feedback;