Final Route 5% Minimizes impacts to Minimizes impacts to 2 of Minimizes impacts to 1 of -- No minimized impacts. natural, built and the 3 environments. the 3 environments. Selection engineered environments. Route 10% Followed the Photo Followed the Photo Followed the Photo Followed the Photo Did not follow the Photo Science tutorial Science tutorial without Science tutorial with Science tutorial with Science tutorial. No Selection completely without assistance. Explained the minimal assistance. major assistance. understanding of the GIS Process assistance. Explained the major outcomes from Explained the major Explained the major siting process. Explanation major outcomes from each step showing a outcomes from each outcomes from each each step showing a complete understanding step, but not having a step, but having only a complete understanding of the GIS siting process. complete understanding minimal understanding of the GIS siting process. of the GIS siting process. of the GIS siting process. Presented graphics from each completed step in the analysis. Addressing 5% States the purpose of States the purpose of States the purpose of -- Does not clearly state the public participation public participation public participation, and purpose of public Public clearly and creatively and clearly and is generally is somewhat thought out. participation, and Participation is extremely well thought well thought out. organization is poor or out. non-existent. Part B: Presentation (Consists of three parts, Organization, Appearance, and Verbal Delivery. The total weight for all three parts is 40% Category Weight 31 – 40 Points 21 – 30 Points 11 – 20 Points 1 – 10 Points 0 Points Organization 13% Extremely well organized. Generally well organized. Somewhat organized. -- Poor or non-existent Introduces the purpose of Introduces the purpose of Introduces the purpose of organization. the presentation clearly the presentation clearly. the presentation. Does not clearly and creatively. Includes transitions to Includes some transitions introduce the purpose of Effectively includes connect key points but to connect key points but the presentation. smooth, clever better transitions from there is difficulty in Uses ineffective transitions which are idea to idea could have following presentation. transitions that rarely succinct but not choppy been used. Jumps around topics. connect points; cannot in order to connect key Presents most Several points are understand presentation points. information in logical confusing. because there is no Presents information in sequence; A few minor sequence for logical, interesting points may be confusing. information.
Final Route Selection 5% Minimizes impacts to natural, built and engineered environments. Minimizes impacts to 2 of the 3 environments. Minimizes impacts to 1 of the 3 environments. -- No minimized impacts. Route Selection Process Explanation 10% Followed the Photo Science tutorial completely without assistance. Explained the major outcomes from each step showing a complete understanding of the GIS siting process. Presented graphics from each completed step in the analysis. Followed the Photo Science tutorial without assistance. Explained the major outcomes from each step showing a complete understanding of the GIS siting process. Followed the Photo Science tutorial with minimal assistance. Explained the major outcomes from each step, but not having a complete understanding of the GIS siting process. Followed the Photo Science tutorial with major assistance. Explained the major outcomes from each step, but having only a minimal understanding of the GIS siting process. Did not follow the Photo Science tutorial. No understanding of the GIS siting process. Addressing Public Participation 5% States the purpose of public participation clearly and creatively and is extremely well thought out. States the purpose of public participation clearly and is generally well thought out. States the purpose of public participation, and is somewhat thought out. -- Does not clearly state the purpose of public participation, and organization is poor or non-existent. Part B: Presentation (Consists of three parts, Organization, Appearance, and Verbal Delivery. The total weight for all three parts is 40% Category Weight 31 – 40 Points 21 – 30 Points 11 – 20 Points 1 – 10 Points 0 Points Organization 13% Extremely well organized. Introduces the purpose of the presentation clearly and creatively. Effectively includes smooth, clever transitions which are succinct but not choppy in order to connect key points. Presents information in logical, interesting Generally well organized. Introduces the purpose of the presentation clearly. Includes transitions to connect key points but better transitions from idea to idea could have been used. Presents most information in logical sequence; A few minor points may be confusing. Somewhat organized. Introduces the purpose of the presentation. Includes some transitions to connect key points but there is difficulty in following presentation. Jumps around topics. Several points are confusing. -- Poor or non-existent organization. Does not clearly introduce the purpose of the presentation. Uses ineffective transitions that rarely connect points; cannot understand presentation because there is no sequence for information.