number of occurences. 138 Technical 7.8.5 3364 Descriptions on 7.8.5 are Change the texts of Agreed in principle, Open inconsistent with the 7.8.5 accordingly. but requires more information model on 8.1.2.9. Will be provided in input a separate contribution. 139 Editorial 7.8.7.2 3485 Figure 71 exposes 'TEC' and Rename both, TEI ok Accepted 'TEI' despite text only and TEC to 'TE' to mentioning 'TE'. Distinction align figure to between TEC and TEI is explanatory text. superflous and should be avoided. 140 Editorial 7.8.8 3600 "The following table" is not the Put in a reference ok Accepted correct way to reference a to the table which table. when clicked brings one to the table 141 Editorial 7.8.8 3605 The landscape tables are Use a different Table will be Revised undesireable because they format. It isn't clear divided into 3 make the PDF display as that there is a tables, each narrower than window width beneift to displaying rotated by 90° when using fit to page window. all the entries in a with technologies Also, even though they are one page window stacked on each wide, there are lots of carriage format. Consider a other. Hao will returns in the entries and some subclause per create proposal to attributes in Table 10 are technology type or verify that wrapped with a hyphen. Also, not doing all the approach makes the column widths of the tables specs on one page sense. are wonky rather than evenly width spaced (e.g. wide for 802.22 in table 10 and much narrower for 802.1ag and 802.11.In table 9, one of the IEEE 802.3 entries goes out of its block. Allso applies to Table 8 142 Technical 7.8.8 3605 Spanning Tree is not defined in Change ok Accepted 802.1ag-2007, it is defined in to 802.1Q-2014. Also, is not part of 802.1Q Proposed Text Changes: Please replace clause 7.8 of IEEE802.1CF 1.0 with the following text.
number of occurences. 138 Technical 7.8.5 3364 Descriptions on 7.8.5 are inconsistent with the information model on 8.1.2.9. Change the texts of 7.8.5 accordingly. Will be provided in a separate contribution. Agreed in principle, but requires more input Open 139 Editorial 7.8.7.2 3485 Figure 71 exposes 'TEC' and 'TEI' despite text only mentioning 'TE'. Distinction between TEC and TEI is superflous and should be avoided. Rename both, TEI and TEC to 'TE' to align figure to explanatory text. ok Accepted 140 Editorial 7.8.8 3600 "The following table" is not the correct way to reference a table. Put in a reference to the table which when clicked brings one to the table ok Accepted 141 Editorial 7.8.8 3605 The landscape tables are undesireable because they make the PDF display as narrower than window width when using fit to page window. Also, even though they are wide, there are lots of carriage returns in the entries and some attributes in Table 10 are wrapped with a hyphen. Also, the column widths of the tables are wonky rather than evenly spaced (e.g. wide for 802.22 in table 10 and much narrower for 802.1ag and 802.11.In table 9, one of the IEEE 802.3 entries goes out of its block. Allso applies to Table 8 Use a different format. It isn't clear that there is a beneift to displaying all the entries in a one page window format. Consider a subclause per technology type or not doing all the specs on one page width Table will be divided into 3 tables, each rotated by 90° with technologies stacked on each other. Hao will create proposal to verify that approach makes sense. Revised 142 Technical 7.8.8 3605 Spanning Tree is not defined in 802.1ag-2007, it is defined in 802.1Q-2014. Also, is not part of 802.1Q Change to ok Accepted Proposed Text Changes: Please replace clause 7.8 of IEEE802.1CF 1.0 with the following text.