Points 4 3 2 1 0 Slide 1: Map Map is clear, appropriate Map is adequate but Map is missing many Map present but No map supplied scale and contains poor quality, scale essential details, is poor quality, sufficient information; makes it difficult to unclear or lacks unclear and lacks Accurate citation for map read; citation lacking citation. citation. supplied. or incorrect. Slide 2: All points made clearly All points made fairly Some key details Large amounts of No information Geologic and and accurately; accurately but missing; incomplete information supplied Geographic references sources of incomplete sentences sentences and no missing or setting information; uses and missing references references. inaccurate; no complete sentences references. Slide 3: All points made clearly; Sufficient points made Some key details are Large amounts of No information Social and references data; uses fairly accurately but missing, uses information supplied Economic complete sentences incomplete sentences incomplete missing or factors and provides no sentences and inaccurate; no references provides no references. references Slide 4: Describes, in whole Describes hypothetical Description is Very little detail or No scenario Disaster sentences, hypothetical disaster incompletely, general and vague; convincing scenario disaster with convincing incomplete sentences Details are lacking. information in accuracy and scientific and/ or some scenario backing inaccuracy Slide 5: 10 Describes progress and Describes recovery Recovery Very little detail or No scenario years after challenges in convincing progress in general description is convincing terms with detail backed terms with some detail general, brief, and information in by facts lacking vague. Details are scenario lacking.
Points 4 3 2 1 0 Slide 1: Map Map is clear, appropriate scale and contains sufficient information; Accurate citation for map supplied. Map is adequate but poor quality, scale makes it difficult to read; citation lacking or incorrect. Map is missing many essential details, is unclear or lacks citation. Map present but poor quality, unclear and lacks citation. No map supplied Slide 2: Geologic and Geographic setting All points made clearly and accurately; references sources of information; uses complete sentences All points made fairly accurately but incomplete sentences and missing references Some key details missing; incomplete sentences and no references. Large amounts of information missing or inaccurate; no references. No information supplied Slide 3: Social and Economic factors All points made clearly; references data; uses complete sentences Sufficient points made fairly accurately but incomplete sentences and provides no references Some key details are missing, uses incomplete sentences and provides no references Large amounts of information missing or inaccurate; no references. No information supplied Slide 4: Disaster scenario Describes, in whole sentences, hypothetical disaster with convincing accuracy and scientific backing Describes hypothetical disaster incompletely, incomplete sentences and/ or some inaccuracy Description is general and vague; Details are lacking. Very little detail or convincing information in scenario No scenario Slide 5: 10 years after Describes progress and challenges in convincing terms with detail backed by facts Describes recovery progress in general terms with some detail lacking Recovery description is general, brief, and vague. Details are lacking. Very little detail or convincing information in scenario No scenario