272 Kenichi 24.3.8.3.2 253 52 k=[[-12:4:-4:4:4:12] Correct vector is Accepted, Mori to be wrong k=[-12 -8 -4 4 8 original text because duplicated 12]. notation is tone numbers are technically written in this correct, but vector and it is proposed different value change is from the section easier to read 3.2.1.2 of the SFD. 273 Kenichi 24.3.8.3.3 254 12 The sentence "The The sentence Counter, Mori generation of the should be The text time domain D-LTF removed. should be symbols...."should fixed to say be removed of “generation because D-LTF is time domain prepared for S1G LTF symbols” greater than or because D-LTF equal to 2MHz long is only for format and this 2MHz Long section is for 1MHz preambles. PHY. Referenced figure is still the right Tx flow. 298 Li Chia 250 40 Typographical error Change line 40 to: Accepted Choo in the description of "For a 4 MHz the 4 MHz verwsion transmission,". of the parameter D(u)k,2 in 24.3.8.2.2.2.4 definition 299 Li Chia 24.3.8.3.4 255 46 The figure Change line 46 to Accepted Choo reference to the 6 "The structure of symbol SIGfield is the 6 symbol SIG missing in field (which carries 24.3.8.3.4 SIG 6 information bits definition. per symbol) is shown in Table 24-18 (Structure of the 6 symbol SIG field of S1G 1MHz PPDU). Note that" Bo Sun 240 45 the B13 in Figure 145 modify it Accepted 24-31 should be doppler field 872 Yongho 24.3.8.2.1.4 234 22 NDP Indication field Change the Tentatively Seok in the SIG field of position of NDP reject, since it short preamble is Indication field is not in SFD not aligned with the with the Doppler yet? Doppler SIG field format of field. always in B13 NDP MAC frame of 2MHz (Figure 24-39). Change the Long/Short position of NDP SIG.
272 Kenichi Mori 24.3.8.3.2 253 52 k=[[-12:4:-4:4:4:12] to be wrong because duplicated tone numbers are written in this vector and it is different value from the section 3.2.1.2 of the SFD. Correct vector is k=[-12 -8 -4 4 8 12]. Accepted, original text notation is technically correct, but proposed change is easier to read 273 Kenichi Mori 24.3.8.3.3 254 12 The sentence "The generation of the time domain D-LTF symbols...."should be removed because D-LTF is prepared for S1G greater than or equal to 2MHz long format and this section is for 1MHz PHY. The sentence should be removed. Counter, The text should be fixed to say “generation of time domain LTF symbols” because D-LTF is only for 2MHz Long preambles. Referenced figure is still the right Tx flow. 298 Li Chia Choo 250 40 Typographical error in the description of the 4 MHz verwsion of the parameter D(u)k,2 in 24.3.8.2.2.2.4 definition Change line 40 to: "For a 4 MHz transmission,". Accepted 299 Li Chia Choo 24.3.8.3.4 255 46 The figure reference to the 6 symbol SIGfield is missing in 24.3.8.3.4 SIG definition. Change line 46 to "The structure of the 6 symbol SIG field (which carries 6 information bits per symbol) is shown in Table 24-18 (Structure of the 6 symbol SIG field of S1G 1MHz PPDU). Note that" Accepted 145 Bo Sun 240 45 the B13 in Figure 24-31 should be doppler field modify it Accepted 872 Yongho Seok 24.3.8.2.1.4 234 22 NDP Indication field in the SIG field of short preamble is not aligned with the SIG field format of NDP MAC frame (Figure 24-39). Change the position of NDP Change the position of NDP Indication field with the Doppler field. Tentatively reject, since it is not in SFD yet? Doppler always in B13 of 2MHz Long/Short SIG.