Certified Investigation Quality Foundations Peer Review Score Sheet: CI HCSIS/EIM Incident #: Date of Review: CI: Reviewer: Yes 1. Was the investigatory question clearly and objectively stated? No (1 Point) Yes 2. Did the CI interview the victim within 24 hours of being assigned the case? No (1 Point) If No, did the CI provide a documented investigative reason why AND start other Yes No interviews within 24 hours? (1 Point) Yes 3. Was the scene visited by the CI? No (1 If No, did the CI provide a documented investigative reason that it did not occur? Yes No (1 Point) 4. Did the Reviewer identify Physical Evidence that was NOT documented by the CI that may No Yes have affected the final determination by the Administrative Review team? (1 Point) 5. Did the Reviewer identify Demonstrative Evidence that was NOT collected by the CI that No Yes may have affected the final determination by the Administrative Review team? (1 Point) 6. Did the Reviewer identify Testimonial Evidence that was NOT collected by the investigator No Yes that may have affected the final determination by the Administrative Review team? (1 Point) Yes 7. Were all interviews conducted in person by the CI? No (1 Yes If no, did the CI provide a documented investigative reason that this did not occur? No (1 Point) 8. Were all initial interviews completed (or at least attempted) within 10 days of the Yes No investigation being assigned? (1 Point) 9. Did the Reviewer identify documentary evidence that was NOT collected by the investigator No Yes that may have affected the final determination by the Administrative Review team? (1 Yes 10. Did the CI complete all items of the ODP CIR Form Sections I through IV? No (1 Point) Please provide examples for questions 4, 5, 6 & 9 Final Score:
Certified Investigation Quality Foundations Peer Review Score Sheet: CI HCSIS/EIM Incident #: Date of Review: CI: Reviewer: 1. Was the investigatory question clearly and objectively stated? Yes (1 Point) No 2. Did the CI interview the victim within 24 hours of being assigned the case? Yes (1 Point) No If No, did the CI provide a documented investigative reason why AND start other interviews within 24 hours? Yes (1 Point) No 3. Was the scene visited by the CI? Yes (1 No If No, did the CI provide a documented investigative reason that it did not occur? Yes (1 Point) No 4. Did the Reviewer identify Physical Evidence that was NOT documented by the CI that may have affected the final determination by the Administrative Review team? Yes No (1 Point) 5. Did the Reviewer identify Demonstrative Evidence that was NOT collected by the CI that may have affected the final determination by the Administrative Review team? Yes No (1 Point) 6. Did the Reviewer identify Testimonial Evidence that was NOT collected by the investigator that may have affected the final determination by the Administrative Review team? Yes No (1 Point) 7. Were all interviews conducted in person by the CI? Yes (1 No If no, did the CI provide a documented investigative reason that this did not occur? Yes (1 Point) No 8. Were all initial interviews completed (or at least attempted) within 10 days of the investigation being assigned? Yes (1 Point) No 9. Did the Reviewer identify documentary evidence that was NOT collected by the investigator that may have affected the final determination by the Administrative Review team? Yes No (1 10. Did the CI complete all items of the ODP CIR Form Sections I through IV? Yes (1 Point) No Please provide examples for questions 4, 5, 6 & 9 Final Score: