CID 7031 Comment Proposed Change What is the meaning of "After transmitting the Change from "After transmitting the acknowledgement acknowledgement frame immeidate response frame immeidate response immediate immediate acknowledgement" ? If OMI does not acknowledgement" to "After transmitting the mandate the Ack Policy of the MPDU to be carried, acknowledgement frame". please remove "immediate" term. Discussion: The sentence is broken. Proposed resolution: Accept. CID7202 Comment Proposed Change The channel bandwidth setting should be normative. As in comment Delete "note", Discussion: Similar to CID 5679. Proposed resolution: Accept. CID7247 Comment Proposed Change The text "If an OMI mode change is reported during a Delete "at TXOP then the change should occur at least after that TXOP." is not clear whether OMI mode is changed right after the TXOP or later. Discussion: The comment is similar to CID3218. The OMI mode change is hard to perform in very exact time. The commented text seems to suggest the latest time when the parameter change can be done. Proposed Resolution: Revised. Change the at least to at latest. CID7614 Comment Proposed Change The meaning of the following sentence is not "After Clarify it. transmitting the acknowledgement frame immediate response immediate acknowledgement for the frame containing the OMI A-Control field, the OMI responder may transmit subsequent SU PPDUs or MU PPDUs that are addressed to the OMI initiator." Discussion: The comment is similar to 7031. The sentence is broken. Proposed resolution: Revised. Agree in principle with the commenter. CID7616 Comment Proposed Change Before sending TOMI, the initiator should make sure Change the sentence to "An OMI initiator that is a that the responder can receive OMI Control. Arguablly in STA may indicate changes in its transmit parameters this case the reponder can always receive the OMI by sending a frame Control since the responder is always AP. But the that contains the OMI A-Control field to the OMI sentence is not clear that the responder is always an responder which is an AP." AP.
CID 7031 Comment Proposed Change What is the meaning of "After transmitting the acknowledgement frame immeidate response immediate acknowledgement" ? If OMI does not mandate the Ack Policy of the MPDU to be carried, please remove "immediate" term. Change from "After transmitting the acknowledgement frame immeidate response immediate acknowledgement" to "After transmitting the acknowledgement frame". Discussion: The sentence is broken. Proposed resolution: Accept. CID7202 Comment Proposed Change The channel bandwidth setting should be normative. Delete "note", As in comment Discussion: Similar to CID 5679. Proposed resolution: Accept. CID7247 Comment Proposed Change The text "If an OMI mode change is reported during a TXOP then the change should occur at least after that TXOP." is not clear whether OMI mode is changed right after the TXOP or later. Delete "at Discussion: The comment is similar to CID3218. The OMI mode change is hard to perform in very exact time. The commented text seems to suggest the latest time when the parameter change can be done. Proposed Resolution: Revised. Change the at least to at latest. CID7614 Comment Proposed Change The meaning of the following sentence is not "After transmitting the acknowledgement frame immediate response immediate acknowledgement for the frame containing the OMI A-Control field, the OMI responder may transmit subsequent SU PPDUs or MU PPDUs that are addressed to the OMI initiator." Clarify it. Discussion: The comment is similar to 7031. The sentence is broken. Proposed resolution: Revised. Agree in principle with the commenter. CID7616 Comment Proposed Change Before sending TOMI, the initiator should make sure that the responder can receive OMI Control. Arguablly in this case the reponder can always receive the OMI Control since the responder is always AP. But the sentence is not clear that the responder is always an AP. Change the sentence to "An OMI initiator that is a STA may indicate changes in its transmit parameters by sending a frame that contains the OMI A-Control field to the OMI responder which is an AP."