results of the results of the the results of the study study Analysis Directions for Provides multiple Provides a few further research Incomplete Further Research directions for further directions for are unclear or discussion of Incomplete 1.5 research. further research. inconsistent further research. with findings. Concise and hypotheses tend Complete yet generally Incomplete to be one-sided Validity/rival concise discussion recognizes most validity/rival with aspects of Incomplete 1.5 hypotheses of the validity/rival aspects of the hypotheses the validity/rival hypotheses validity/rival discussion hypotheses hypotheses missing. Insight/Criticism Generally good Evidence only Original on fact, evidence given somewhat Opinion entirely Incomplete 1.5 insight/Criticism research, or in support of supports unsupported. scholarly authority. opinion. opinion. Incomplete Concise and discussion of Complete yet generally Unclear implications. No concise discussion Implications recognizes implications for connection Incomplete 1.5 of implications of implications for practice. between research on practice practice. research and practice. Writing/Style Only a few Many errors. Free of spelling, errors of minor A number of Poor grammar syntax, and Writing and APA significance with errors. Not well and sentence Incomplete 0 grammatical errors. grammar and edited. structure as well Well-edited APA as APA errors material. APA style
results of the study results of the the results of the study Analysis Further Research Provides multiple directions for further research. Provides a few directions for further research. Directions for further research are unclear or inconsistent with findings. Incomplete discussion of further research. Incomplete 1.5 Validity/rival hypotheses Complete yet concise discussion of the validity/rival hypotheses Concise and generally recognizes most aspects of the validity/rival hypotheses hypotheses tend to be one-sided with aspects of the validity/rival hypotheses missing. Incomplete validity/rival hypotheses discussion Incomplete 1.5 Original insight/Criticism Insight/Criticism on fact, research, or scholarly authority. Generally good evidence given in support of opinion. Evidence only somewhat supports opinion. Opinion entirely unsupported. Incomplete 1.5 Implications Complete yet concise discussion of implications of research on practice Concise and generally recognizes implications for practice. Unclear implications for practice. Incomplete discussion of implications. No connection between research and practice. Incomplete 1.5 Writing/Style Writing and APA Free of spelling, syntax, and grammatical errors. Well-edited material. APA style Only a few errors of minor significance with grammar and APA A number of errors. Not well edited. Many errors. Poor grammar and sentence structure as well as APA errors Incomplete 0