Data plan is suitable to test methodology is largely developed and/or is analytic study hypotheses. incomplete. not feasible. plan Provides appropriate justification for controls. Project is feasible Grammar, clarity, The manuscript is well The manuscript effectively The manuscript The manuscript is and organization written and ideas are well communicates The communicates ideas poorly written and and explained. writing is grammatically adequately. The confusing. Ideas are Sentences and paragraphs correct, but some sections manuscript contains not communicated are grammatically correct. lack clarity. some grammatical effectively. Uses subheadings errors. Many sections appropriately. lack clarity. References and Properly and explicitly Properly cited. May have a The manuscript has The manuscript lacks citations cited. Reference list few instances in which several instances of proper citations or matches citations proper citations are improper use of includes no citations. missing. citations. Contains several statements without appropriately citing. General recommendations for the thesis /dissertation defense: Thesis and Dissertation Defense Evaluation Rubric Component Fully met (3) Met (2) Partially Met (1) Not met (0) Score Thesis/dissertation Effectively and insightfully Develops a set of testable Develops hypotheses. Hypotheses are not overview develops a set of testable, and supportable The manuscript a testable or justifiable. supportable and impactful hypotheses. The clear organizational Focus of the hypotheses. In general manuscript is nicely structure and cohesive manuscript is hard to
Data analytic plan plan is suitable to test study hypotheses. Provides appropriate justification for controls. Project is feasible methodology is largely incomplete. and/or is not feasible. Grammar, clarity, and organization The manuscript is well written and ideas are well developed and explained. Sentences and paragraphs are grammatically correct. Uses subheadings appropriately. The manuscript effectively communicates The writing is grammatically correct, but some sections lack clarity. The manuscript communicates ideas adequately. The manuscript contains some grammatical errors. Many sections lack clarity. The manuscript is poorly written and confusing. Ideas are not communicated effectively. References and citations Properly and explicitly cited. Reference list matches citations Properly cited. May have a few instances in which proper citations are missing. The manuscript has several instances of improper use of citations. Contains several statements without appropriately citing. The manuscript lacks proper citations or includes no citations. General recommendations for the thesis /dissertation defense: Thesis and Dissertation Defense Evaluation Rubric Component Fully met (3) Met (2) Partially Met (1) Not met (0) Score Thesis/dissertation overview Effectively and insightfully develops a set of testable, supportable and impactful hypotheses. In general Develops a set of testable and supportable hypotheses. The manuscript is nicely Develops hypotheses. The manuscript a clear organizational structure and cohesive Hypotheses are not testable or justifiable. Focus of the manuscript is hard to