support for AMSDU. 215 Mark R.7 PPDU_Dur "is the Delete the Reject – RISON expected duration of a definition of PPDU_Dur and single PPDU, in PPDU_Dur and DPDUR are not the seconds". DPDUR "is then change same thing. the Data PPDU PPDU_Dur to DPDUR is the duration target of the DPDUR throughout target duration, but transmitter of the the referenced PPDU_Dur is the PPDUs containing subclause actual duration MPDUs with the Type which can be subfield equal to Data, limited at high data in seconds". Given rates by the equation, aggregation limits, PPDU_Dur is also only for example. for PPDUs with Data MPDUs. So PPDU_Dur is the same thing as DPDUR 216 Mark R.7 "Note that some of the Delete the cited Revise TGmd – RISON parameters of sentence editor to make Equation (R-2) have changes as shown values that are AC in 11-17/1192r4 dependent." -- er, that are marked which? None of them with CID 216, have any dependency noting that the on the AC correct fix for the cited problem is to change the equation number. 217 Mark R.7 It is claimed that one Delete Revise TGmd – Rison can determine editor to make and" in changes as shown and R.7. At the end of in 11-17/1192r4 R.7 add a para that are marked for each AC "The mechanism by with CID 217, of a current or which ESP STAs which generally potential link to determine agree with the another STA using values for nature of the Equation (R-1)", but comment, but Equation (R-1) refers is resolve it by adding to outside the scope language for EST_AirtimeFraction, of the standard." describing which is defined as " a method for the estimated portion estimating the of airtime that is inbound traffic. available for outbound transmissions", so does not work for inbound traffic Discussion:
support for AMSDU. 215 Mark RISON R.7 PPDU_Dur "is the expected duration of a single PPDU, in seconds". DPDUR "is the Data PPDU duration target of the transmitter of the PPDUs containing MPDUs with the Type subfield equal to Data, in seconds". Given the equation, PPDU_Dur is also only for PPDUs with Data MPDUs. So PPDU_Dur is the same thing as DPDUR Delete the definition of PPDU_Dur and then change PPDU_Dur to DPDUR throughout the referenced subclause Reject – PPDU_Dur and DPDUR are not the same thing. DPDUR is the target duration, but PPDU_Dur is the actual duration which can be limited at high data rates by aggregation limits, for example. 216 Mark RISON R.7 "Note that some of the parameters of Equation (R-2) have values that are AC dependent." -- er, which? None of them have any dependency on the AC Delete the cited sentence Revise – TGmd editor to make changes as shown in 11-17/1192r4 that are marked with CID 216, noting that the correct fix for the cited problem is to change the equation number. 217 Mark Rison R.7 It is claimed that one can determine and for each AC of a current or potential link to another STA using Equation (R-1)", but Equation (R-1) refers to EST_AirtimeFraction, which is defined as " the estimated portion of airtime that is available for outbound transmissions", so does not work for inbound traffic Delete and" in R.7. At the end of R.7 add a para "The mechanism by which ESP STAs determine values for is outside the scope of the standard." Revise – TGmd editor to make changes as shown in 11-17/1192r4 that are marked with CID 217, which generally agree with the nature of the comment, but resolve it by adding language for describing a method for estimating the inbound traffic. Discussion: