encode all users in detailed proposal from each 20MHz segment the commenter CID 2246 CID Page. Clause Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution Line Number 2246 26.3.9.8.3 The time-domain Remove the part about Rejected encoding of splitting users into two Reason: The is groups and remove the proposed change is inelegant and prone painful process of insufficient in detail. to interoperability figuring out padding The comment requires issues bits as a function of us to revisit the current whether the number of HE-SIG-B users is even or odd. encoding and Encode change it. While the contained in a rationale is to simplify, 20MHz segment it will require us to together with one make substantial tail/CRC. changes to the exisiting design. References: [1] Bin Tian, et. Al., Reduction for HE SIG-B”, IEEE 802.11-16/0619r0 “PAPR
encode all users in each 20MHz segment detailed proposal from the commenter CID 2246 CID Page. Line Clause Number Comment Proposed Change Proposed Resolution 2246 26.3.9.8.3 The time-domain encoding of is inelegant and prone to interoperability issues Remove the part about splitting users into two groups and remove the painful process of figuring out padding bits as a function of whether the number of users is even or odd. Encode contained in a 20MHz segment together with one tail/CRC. Rejected Reason: The proposed change is insufficient in detail. The comment requires us to revisit the current HE-SIG-B encoding and change it. While the rationale is to simplify, it will require us to make substantial changes to the exisiting design. References: [1] Bin Tian, et. Al., “PAPR Reduction for HE SIG-B”, IEEE 802.11-16/0619r0