feedback procedure, it to 10.38.6.4.1 agreed that should be the same for consistency with shall be used procedure as described in the additional between two BRP 10.38.6.4.1 requesting requirement that the frames instead of TXSS sector list. 1st BRP frame SIFS for the SISO However, there are some should contain the feedback procedure. minor differences between feeback to the here and what was responder in addition Also agreed that described in 10.38.6.4.1. to the minimum feedback requirement for both For example, the SISO and MIMO BF requirement of setting should keep Sector ID Order consistency. For this Requested to 1 is not in purpose, it is 10.38.6.4.1, the IFS proposed that between 2 BRP packets is feedback of SIFS in this cause but in minimum 16 sectors 10.38.6.4.1 it is within per TX/RX antenna MBIFS. Minimum 16 pair is required for sector feedback are MIMO BF. required in 10.38.6.4.1 but there is no such TGay editor to make requirement in this clause the changes shown in 11-18/0281r0 under same comment applies to all headings that 10.38.9.2.3.2 include CID 2306. 1133 165 Figure 98 is not very Figure 98 --The Revised- informative and can be SISO feedback removed or modified to procedure of the Agreed in principle include more details on beamforming that Figure 98 is not the SISO procedure, in very informative and addition its title need to be should be removed. fixed TGay editor to make The SISO feedback the changes shown in procedure of the 11-18/0281r0 under beamforming all headings that include CID 1133. 1143 165 4 "are" shall be removed as per comment Accepted- from "The BRP shall have all the subfields within the TGay editor to make FBCK-REQ field are set the changes shown in to 0" 11-18/0281r0 under all headings that include CID 1143. 1144 165 22 "per TX antenna" should as per comment Accepted- be "per TX DMG antenna" TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0281r0 under all headings that include CID 1144.
feedback procedure, it should be the same procedure as described in 10.38.6.4.1 requesting TXSS sector list. However, there are some minor differences between here and what was described in 10.38.6.4.1. For example, the requirement of setting Sector ID Order Requested to 1 is not in 10.38.6.4.1, the IFS between 2 BRP packets is SIFS in this cause but in 10.38.6.4.1 it is within MBIFS. Minimum 16 sector feedback are required in 10.38.6.4.1 but there is no such requirement in this clause same comment applies to 10.38.9.2.3.2 to 10.38.6.4.1 for consistency with the additional requirement that the 1st BRP frame should contain the feeback to the responder in addition to the agreed that shall be used between two BRP frames instead of SIFS for the SISO feedback procedure. Also agreed that minimum feedback requirement for both SISO and MIMO BF should keep consistency. For this purpose, it is proposed that feedback of minimum 16 sectors per TX/RX antenna pair is required for MIMO BF. TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0281r0 under all headings that include CID 2306. 1133 165 Figure 98 is not very informative and can be removed or modified to include more details on the SISO procedure, in addition its title need to be fixed The SISO feedback procedure of the beamforming Figure 98 --The SISO feedback procedure of the beamforming Revised- Agreed in principle that Figure 98 is not very informative and should be removed. TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0281r0 under all headings that include CID 1133. 1143 165 4 "are" shall be removed from "The BRP shall have all the subfields within the FBCK-REQ field are set to 0" as per comment Accepted- TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0281r0 under all headings that include CID 1143. 1144 165 22 "per TX antenna" should be "per TX DMG antenna" as per comment Accepted- TGay editor to make the changes shown in 11-18/0281r0 under all headings that include CID 1144.