figure. Only and PMD_CBW.ind will be added, as is not in VHT packet. Make changes under heading Figure 22-30 in <this-document> Note see discussion on comment 5236 before approving. – 4109 Adrian 263.11 22.3.21 "Further, through station Add a sentence to A Accepted. management (via the follow cited one: "The PLME) the PHY is set to PHY has also been the appropriate configured with group frequency, as specified information (i.e., group in 22.4 (VHT PLME)." membership and position in group) so This is OK as far as it that it can receive data goes. membership intended for the STA." plays a big part in the MAC-PHY interaction, so it might be good to mention here. 5301 Vinko 263.38 22.3.21 Equation number As in comment. R Revised. Erceg missing in "defined by RXTIME in Equation ().." TGac editor: Add an equation number to RXTIME in D2.1 P262L20. Insert that equation number in D2.1 P261L34. 4111 Adrian 263.41 22.3.21 "An invalid L-SIG Length Alternative suggestions: J Rejected. field value is defined as 1. Add an out-of-band a value not following communication of The meaning of the Equation (35)." TXTIME so that the statement is for receiver can validate it. future-proofing the This is utterly Possible out-of-band CCA. meaningless. Cited mechanisms include: equation determines a) Write it on the back how to calculate the of a post card; b) As currently defined length given the encode in smoke in D2.1 (Equation 35), TXTIME. signals; c) telepathy. Length is modulo 3. The receiver is not party 2. Remove cited Without the to the TXTIME value sentence. sentence an and cannot therefore 3. Correct sentence to validate the L-SIG refer to something the implementer would Length against this receiver can validate. have been able to value. treat a packet with Length not modulo 3 Instead the receiver
figure. Only and PMD_CBW.ind will be added, as is not in VHT packet. Make changes under heading Figure 22-30 in <this-document> Note – see discussion on comment 5236 before approving. 4109 Adrian 263.11 22.3.21 "Further, through station management (via the PLME) the PHY is set to the appropriate frequency, as specified in 22.4 (VHT PLME)." This is OK as far as it goes. membership plays a big part in the MAC-PHY interaction, so it might be good to mention here. Add a sentence to follow cited one: "The PHY has also been configured with group information (i.e., group membership and position in group) so that it can receive data intended for the STA." A Accepted. 5301 Vinko Erceg 263.38 22.3.21 Equation number missing in "defined by RXTIME in Equation ().." As in comment. R Revised. TGac editor: Add an equation number to RXTIME in D2.1 P262L20. Insert that equation number in D2.1 P261L34. 4111 Adrian 263.41 22.3.21 "An invalid L-SIG Length field value is defined as a value not following Equation (35)." This is utterly meaningless. Cited equation determines how to calculate the length given the TXTIME. The receiver is not party to the TXTIME value and cannot therefore validate the L-SIG Length against this value. Instead the receiver Alternative suggestions: 1. Add an out-of-band communication of TXTIME so that the receiver can validate it. Possible out-of-band mechanisms include: a) Write it on the back of a post card; b) encode in smoke signals; c) telepathy. 2. Remove cited sentence. 3. Correct sentence to refer to something the receiver can validate. J Rejected. The meaning of the statement is for future-proofing the CCA. As currently defined in D2.1 (Equation 35), Length is modulo 3. Without the sentence an implementer would have been able to treat a packet with Length not modulo 3