Environmental Restoration Plan Rubric Teacher Name: Student Name: ________________________________________ CATEGORY Excellent Good Satisfactory Poor Technology Technologies Technologies Technologies Basic requirements Comparison chosen are chosen are chosen are for the cost/benefit appropriate to appropriate to appropriate to analysis have not address the address the address the been met. environmental environmental environmental damage. damage. damage. Cost/benefit Cost/benefit Cost/benefit analysis for three analysis for analysis for three technologies technologies technologies present. Three costs present. Two costs present, but minimal and three benefits and two benefits detail is provided. have been provided have been provided for each technology. for each technology. Technology Rationale fully Sufficient rationale A one or two Rationale for Rationale supports the choice has been provided to sentence rationale technology choice is of remediation fully support the has been provided in missing or unrelated technology and choice of support of the to the technology includes an remediation chosen technology. chosen. evidence-based technology. comparison against the other technologies. Legislation Legislation related Legislation related Legislation related Legislation Overview to the environmental to the environmental to the damage is overview is missing damage is and damage is noted and noted, but or unrelated to fully explained. A explained. A basic explanations of environmental detailed analysis of analysis of the connections are not damage in the the benefits and benefits and provided. project. drawbacks is drawbacks of two provided for each pieces of legislation piece of legislation is included. reviewed. New Legislation New legislation New legislation New legislation New legislation is related to the related to the related to the not provided, or environmental environmental environmental legislation provided damage is created damage is created. damage is created. does not relate to the and adequately Adequate Little explanation of environmental explained. An explanation of the the legislation is damage to be explanation for the legislation is provided. addressed. specific benefits of provided. the new legislation is provided. Plan Quality Restoration plan is Restoration plan Restoration plan is Plan is simple and highly detailed and meets basic either too simple or unrealistic or laid out in a requirements for the has not been illogical thoughtful manner. project properly expanded upon
Environmental Restoration Plan Rubric Teacher Name: Student Name: ________________________________________ CATEGORY Excellent Good Satisfactory Poor Technology Comparison Technologies chosen are appropriate to address the environmental damage. Cost/benefit analysis for three technologies present. Three costs and three benefits have been provided for each technology. Technologies chosen are appropriate to address the environmental damage. Cost/benefit analysis for technologies present. Two costs and two benefits have been provided for each technology. Technologies chosen are appropriate to address the environmental damage. Cost/benefit analysis for three technologies present, but minimal detail is provided. Basic requirements for the cost/benefit analysis have not been met. Technology Rationale Rationale fully supports the choice of remediation technology and includes an evidence-based comparison against the other technologies. Sufficient rationale has been provided to fully support the choice of remediation technology. A one or two sentence rationale has been provided in support of the chosen technology. Rationale for technology choice is missing or unrelated to the technology chosen. Legislation Overview Legislation related to the environmental damage is and fully explained. A detailed analysis of the benefits and drawbacks is provided for each piece of legislation reviewed. Legislation related to the environmental damage is noted and explained. A basic analysis of the benefits and drawbacks of two pieces of legislation is included. Legislation related to the damage is noted, but explanations of connections are not provided. Legislation overview is missing or unrelated to environmental damage in the project. New Legislation New legislation related to the environmental damage is created and adequately explained. An explanation for the specific benefits of the new legislation is provided. New legislation related to the environmental damage is created. Adequate explanation of the legislation is provided. New legislation related to the environmental damage is created. Little explanation of the legislation is provided. New legislation is not provided, or legislation provided does not relate to the environmental damage to be addressed. Plan Quality Restoration plan is highly detailed and laid out in a thoughtful manner. Restoration plan meets basic requirements for the project Restoration plan is either too simple or has not been properly expanded upon Plan is simple and unrealistic or illogical