connected to the extraction, ecology issues connected human ecology issues ecology issues connected environment and human ecology use, and conservation of the to the extraction, use, and connected to the to the extraction, use, issues. No Philippines' mineral conservation of the extraction, use, conservation of the government resources. It accurately Philippines' mineral conservation of the Philippines' mineral regulation and identifies and presents resources. It accurately Philippines' mineral resources. Some mitigation programs Philippine-based regulation identifies and presents resources. It accurately regulation efforts are are cited. and mitigation efforts very Philippine-based identifies and presents identified but explanation clearly. regulation and mitigation Philippine-based needs a little more clarity. efforts clearly. regulation and mitigation . efforts very clearly. Concepts used in the Concepts used in the Organization of the Organization of the Concepts used in explanation are stated in a explanation are stated in concepts used in the concepts used in the the explanation are Organization and very organized manner. Flow an organized manner. explanation needs a little explanation needs more generally Clarity (x2) of ideas is very logical. Other Flow of ideas is logical. bit more improvement. improvement. Flow of disorganized. Flow relevant information are Other relevant information Flow of ideas is somewhat ideas needs a lot of of ideas is not provided to substantiate are provided to logical but can still be improvement in terms of logical. answer. substantiate answer. improved. coherence. The message strongly The message engages the The message is slightly The message is The message does engages the audience, and audience and enough engaging, and minimal somewhat engaging but not engage the Affectiveness and Persuasiveness appeals to the audience's Philippine-based Philippine-based no graphical/illustrative audience at all. (Delivery) conviction, more than enough graphical/illustrative graphical/illustrative support is provided. (x2) Philippine-based support is provided. support is provided. graphical/illustrative support is provided. TOTAL Position Paper 30 pts. – PT Forms 1-4 - 20 pts. TOTAL - 50 pts.
connected to the extraction, use, and conservation of the Philippines' mineral resources. It accurately identifies and presents Philippine-based regulation and mitigation efforts very clearly. ecology issues connected to the extraction, use, and conservation of the Philippines' mineral resources. It accurately identifies and presents Philippine-based regulation and mitigation efforts clearly. human ecology issues connected to the extraction, use, conservation of the Philippines' mineral resources. It accurately identifies and presents Philippine-based regulation and mitigation efforts very clearly. ecology issues connected to the extraction, use, conservation of the Philippines' mineral resources. Some regulation efforts are identified but explanation needs a little more clarity. . environment and human ecology issues. No government regulation and mitigation programs are cited. Organization and Clarity (x2) Concepts used in the explanation are stated in a very organized manner. Flow of ideas is very logical. Other relevant information are provided to substantiate answer. Concepts used in the explanation are stated in an organized manner. Flow of ideas is logical. Other relevant information are provided to substantiate answer. Organization of the concepts used in the explanation needs a little bit more improvement. Flow of ideas is somewhat logical but can still be improved. Organization of the concepts used in the explanation needs more improvement. Flow of ideas needs a lot of improvement in terms of coherence. Concepts used in the explanation are generally disorganized. Flow of ideas is not logical. Affectiveness and Persuasiveness (Delivery) (x2) The message strongly engages the audience, and appeals to the audience's conviction, more than enough Philippine-based graphical/illustrative support is provided. The message engages the audience and enough Philippine-based graphical/illustrative support is provided. The message is slightly engaging, and minimal Philippine-based graphical/illustrative support is provided. The message is somewhat engaging but no graphical/illustrative support is provided. The message does not engage the audience at all. TOTAL Position Paper – 30 pts. PT Forms 1-4 - 20 pts. TOTAL - 50 pts.