Appropriate background inadequate background information No background information information Well phrased & specific Well phrased, broad Poorly phrased, Poorly phrased, & too No hypothesis Hypothesis Hypothesis Specific Hypothesis broad Appropriate materials & Appropriate materials, Appropriate materials, Inappropriate materials, Unapproved materials construction substandard construction poor construction poor construction (i.e. fungus, mold, & live specimens) Complete & thorough Complete, vague Incomplete, thorough Incomplete, vague No listing of procedures procedures procedures procedures procedures Clear explanation of Complete, accurate Explanation, but no Incomplete listing of No explanation, no experiment, including all listing of variables variables listed. variables variables variables Complete & thorough Data Complete, data Incomplete, thorough Incomplete, vague data No data data Correctly used, accurate Inaccurate graph or Incomplete graph No graph graph Conclusion supported by Conclusion supported by Conclusion only Conclusion does not cite No conclusion data data, grammar & vaguely supported by data at all. punctuation errors. data. Conclusion relevant to Conclusion relevant to Conclusion only Conclusion is not No conclusion hypothesis hypothesis, grammar & vaguely makes relevant to hypothesis at punctuation errors. reference to hypothesis all. Original topic or approach Original approach Overused topic, unoriginal approach Clarity of overall project Vaguely answers the question Does not answer the question Complete & thorough steps Complete, vague steps of Incomplete, thorough Incomplete, vague steps No steps of sci method of sci. method sci method steps of sci method of sci method Comments: Presentation Grade
Appropriate background information inadequate background information No background information Well phrased & specific Hypothesis Well phrased, broad Hypothesis Poorly phrased, Specific Hypothesis Poorly phrased, & too broad No hypothesis Appropriate materials & construction Appropriate materials, substandard construction Appropriate materials, poor construction Inappropriate materials, poor construction Unapproved materials (i.e. fungus, mold, & live specimens) Complete & thorough procedures Complete, vague procedures Incomplete, thorough procedures Incomplete, vague procedures No listing of procedures Clear explanation of experiment, including all variables Complete, accurate listing of variables Explanation, but no variables listed. Incomplete listing of variables No explanation, no variables Complete & thorough Data Complete, data Incomplete, thorough data Incomplete, vague data No data Correctly used, accurate graph Inaccurate graph or Incomplete graph No graph Conclusion supported by data Conclusion supported by data, grammar & punctuation errors. Conclusion only vaguely supported by data. Conclusion does not cite data at all. No conclusion Conclusion relevant to hypothesis Conclusion relevant to hypothesis, grammar & punctuation errors. Conclusion only vaguely makes reference to hypothesis Conclusion is not relevant to hypothesis at all. No conclusion Original topic or approach Original approach Overused topic, unoriginal approach Clarity of overall project Vaguely answers the question Does not answer the question Complete & thorough steps of sci. method Complete, vague steps of sci method Incomplete, thorough steps of sci method Incomplete, vague steps of sci method No steps of sci method Comments: Presentation Grade