Semipermeable Membranes Project Rubric Criteria 5 (best) 3 1 Points Showed a clear Needed some Needed a lot of Identifying the understanding of teacher direction to teacher direction to problem. the problem to define the problem. define the problem. solve. Worked well Some team Most team together. All team Working as a team members were members were members member occasionally off often off task and participated and task. not cooperating. stayed on task. Team brainstormed many design ideas Team brainstormed and tested and Some team few design ideas improved the Using the design members were and did little testing design. Final design process occasionally off or redesigning. complete or nearly task. Final design lacks complete and clear design ideas. shows creative problem solving. Team gave a strong presentation of its Team gave a basic Team gave a weak solution in creating presentation of its presentation of its the most innovative solution to the solution to the Processing the semipermeable challenge and challenge and science and membrane and showed basic showed little engineering showed clear understanding of understanding of understanding of the science the science the science concepts and concepts and concepts and design process. design process. design process. Total Points /100 (points received x 5) Additional Notes
Semipermeable Membranes Project Rubric Criteria 5 (best) 3 1 Points Identifying the problem. Showed a clear understanding of the problem to solve. Needed some teacher direction to define the problem. Needed a lot of teacher direction to define the problem. Working as a team member Worked well together. All team members participated and stayed on task. Some team members were occasionally off task. Most team members were often off task and not cooperating. Using the design process Team brainstormed many design ideas and tested and improved the design. Final design complete or nearly complete and shows creative problem solving. Some team members were occasionally off task. Team brainstormed few design ideas and did little testing or redesigning. Final design lacks clear design ideas. Processing the science and engineering Team gave a strong presentation of its solution in creating the most innovative semipermeable membrane and showed clear understanding of the science concepts and design process. Team gave a basic presentation of its solution to the challenge and showed basic understanding of the science concepts and design process. Team gave a weak presentation of its solution to the challenge and showed little understanding of the science concepts and design process. Total Points (points received x 5) /100 Additional Notes