Not Yet Emerging Competently Expertly rudimentary and generally competent; substantial rich in context; offers superficial; no information lacks information; insight extensive insight and analysis or insight analysis; offers and analysis are analysis; offers Critical Thinking displayed; might straightforward offered; offers complex answers to offer inconsistent answers to the interesting and the questions answers to the questions thoughtful answers to questions the questions no connections are limited if any connections are made; clear connections to made; off topic connections; vague perhaps not content/ to real life Connections generalities significantly situations developed no new ideas; "I few if any new ideas new ideas or new ideas and/or agree with..." or connections connections made; connections; contains Uniqueness statements without limited depth and/or depth and detail further development detail Word choice is Word choice is Writing has minimal Writing is flowing informal in tone. occasionally informal number of awkward and easy to follow. Style and Writing is choppy, in tone. Writing has or unclear passages Style is engaging and Communication with many awkward some awkward or and ideas are easy to eloquent. or unclear passages. unclear passages. discern. Writing is clear. Grammatical, Occasional Few grammatical, Grammatical, spelling & grammatical, spelling spelling & spelling & Grammar & punctuation errors or punctuation errors; punctuation errors; do punctuation errors are Mechanics substantial; detract might interfere with not detract from rare; appears from meaning meaning meaning carefully edited
Not Yet Emerging Competently Expertly Critical Thinking rudimentary and superficial; no analysis or insight displayed; might offer inconsistent answers to the questions generally competent; information lacks analysis; offers straightforward answers to the questions substantial information; insight and analysis are offered; offers interesting and thoughtful answers to the questions rich in context; offers extensive insight and analysis; offers complex answers to the questions Connections no connections are made; off topic limited if any connections; vague generalities connections are made; perhaps not significantly developed clear connections to content/ to real life situations Uniqueness no new ideas; "I agree with..." statements without further development few if any new ideas or connections new ideas or connections made; limited depth and/or detail new ideas and/or connections; contains depth and detail Style and Communication Word choice is informal in tone. Writing is choppy, with many awkward or unclear passages. Word choice is occasionally informal in tone. Writing has some awkward or unclear passages. Writing has minimal number of awkward or unclear passages and ideas are easy to discern. Writing is clear. Writing is flowing and easy to follow. Style is engaging and eloquent. Grammar & Mechanics Grammatical, spelling & punctuation errors substantial; detract from meaning Occasional grammatical, spelling or punctuation errors; might interfere with meaning Few grammatical, spelling & punctuation errors; do not detract from meaning Grammatical, spelling & punctuation errors are rare; appears carefully edited