DNA*** Presented w/ no errors: 3 (259) 25 (196) Errors: 1 (259) 2 (196) Bite-mark Presented w/ no errors: 0.4 (259) 0 (196) Errors: 2 (259) 2 (196) property near defendant 3 (260) 4 (200) Victim’s Anonymous tip 3 (260) 5 (200) Surveillance/wiretap evidence*** 1 (260) 8 (200) Misleading circumstantial evidence** 35 (260 48 (200) Any victim recanted crime*** 0 (260) 9 (200) Any victim recanted identification*** 0.4 (260) 13 (200) Any non-victim eyewitness recanted*** 5 (260) 22 (200) Any witness recanted crime or ID*** 10 (260) 34 (200) Victim 1 provided description of perp 94 (123) 97 (66) Victim 1 took multiple tries to make ID 13 (145) 7 (68) Victim 1 certain of ID 82 (137) 82 (67) Victim 1 misidentified the defendant* 92 (158) 83 (82) (only cases where victim was alive) Discrepancy b/w victim description and 1’s defendant*** 56 (101) 21 (63) Discrepancy b/w any description victim’s and defendant*** 22 (206) 8 (200) Victim 1 provided unique details of perp* 35 (106) 54 (63) Victim 1 made cross-racial ID* 58 (100) 35 (43) Victim 1 identification method*** Direct: 22 (125) 56 (63)
DNA*** Presented w/ no errors: Errors: 3 (259) 1 (259) 25 (196) 2 (196) Bite-mark Presented w/ no errors: 0.4 (259) 0 (196) Errors: 2 (259) 2 (196) Victim’s property near defendant 3 (260) 4 (200) Anonymous tip 3 (260) 5 (200) Surveillance/wiretap evidence*** 1 (260) 8 (200) Misleading circumstantial evidence** 35 (260 48 (200) Any victim recanted crime*** 0 (260) 9 (200) Any victim recanted identification*** 0.4 (260) 13 (200) Any non-victim eyewitness recanted*** 5 (260) 22 (200) Any witness recanted crime or ID*** 10 (260) 34 (200) Victim 1 provided description of perp 94 (123) 97 (66) Victim 1 took multiple tries to make ID 13 (145) 7 (68) Victim 1 certain of ID 82 (137) 82 (67) Victim 1 misidentified the defendant* (only cases where victim was alive) Discrepancy b/w victim 1’s description and defendant*** Discrepancy b/w any victim’s description and defendant*** Victim 1 provided unique details of perp* Victim 1 made cross-racial ID* Victim 1 identification method*** Direct: 92 (158) 56 (101) 22 (206) 35 (106) 58 (100) 22 (125) 83 (82) 21 (63) 8 (200) 54 (63) 35 (43) 56 (63)