redress exist to address functioning, is lacking about requests for mechanisms requests for addressing their functioning. information related to land information and requests for and/or resolving use resolve information and grievances grievances resolving related to land grievances use do not exist. related to land use. (public reports demonstrate that the mechanisms are functioning). 4.5.2 The vast majority The majority Grievances are 2 Guidance (please delete): This rating should be assessed through Grievances are of grievances are (more than 50%) rarely resolved. confidential surveys of people in all stakeholder groups (including resolved in a resolved with of grievances are all levels and relevant departments of government, relevant private timely way with redress where resolved with sector organizations, and small producers, local communities redress appropriate redress where and indigenous peoples where present) involved in land use. The within the appropriate but justification should provide information on the number of people timeframe set for often not within surveyed from different stakeholder groups and organizations and the mechanism. the set should explain how bias was avoided and confidentiality timeframe. maintained. 4.6 Labor 4.6.1 Laws and Laws and Laws and Laws and 1 rights, forced regulations ban regulations exist regulations exist regulations do and child labor forced and child banning forced banning child or not exist or no labor and child labor forced labor but evidence of with evidence of not both or no enforcement. effective evidence of enforcement. effective enforcement. 4.6.2 Laws and Regulations Laws and Laws and 1 regulations concerning regulations exist regulations do promote worker safety are but do not cover not exist or no worker safety in place with all land use evidence of evidence of workers (such as enforcement. effective enforcement. agricultural workers) or no evidence of effective enforcement.
redress mechanisms related to land use exist to address requests for information and resolve grievances functioning, addressing requests for information and resolving grievances related to land use. (public reports demonstrate that the mechanisms are functioning). is lacking about their functioning. requests for information and/or resolving grievances related to land use do not exist. 4.5.2 Grievances are resolved in a timely way with redress The vast majority of grievances are resolved with redress where appropriate within the timeframe set for the mechanism. The majority (more than 50%) of grievances are resolved with redress where appropriate but often not within the set timeframe. Grievances are rarely resolved. 2 Guidance (please delete): This rating should be assessed through confidential surveys of people in all stakeholder groups (including all levels and relevant departments of government, relevant private sector organizations, and small producers, local communities and indigenous peoples where present) involved in land use. The justification should provide information on the number of people surveyed from different stakeholder groups and organizations and should explain how bias was avoided and confidentiality maintained. 4.6 Labor rights, forced and child labor 4.6.1 Laws and regulations ban forced and child labor Laws and regulations exist banning forced and child labor with evidence of effective enforcement. Laws and regulations exist banning child or forced labor but not both or no evidence of effective enforcement. Laws and regulations do not exist or no evidence of enforcement. 1 4.6.2 Laws and regulations promote worker safety Regulations concerning worker safety are in place with evidence of effective enforcement. Laws and regulations exist but do not cover all land use workers (such as agricultural workers) or no evidence of effective enforcement. Laws and regulations do not exist or no evidence of enforcement. 1