I'll give you a question, please answer with step-by-step reasoning process.
Pick which sentence is not logical.\nOptions:\n- Sentence A: "Ariel wanted to surprise Beth by buying her a puppy"\n- Sentence B: "Ariel wanted to surprise Beth by calling her a puppy"\n

Sentence B
Beth would not be surprised by being called a puppy.

.

So, the answer is Sentence B