théodore played his fourth and final qmjhl season with the olympiques in 1995–96. although he was named to his second consecutive second all-star team, the olympiques failed to defend their qmjhl title. théodore was injured and missed the first two rounds of the playoffs. he returned later in the semi-final against les harfangs de beauport, who were coached by former hull olympiques' coach alain vigneault. the olympiques were defeated in five games by les harfangs, which were led by future nhl goaltender martin biron. this was redemption for les harfangs and biron, who were defeated by théodore and the olympiques in five games in the previous post-season, in 1994–95.