the clearview regional high school district had an extracurricular club that produced the "pioneer press" student newspaper. brien desilents, a student member of the club, submitted movie reviews for "mississippi burning" and "rain man" but the school principal blocked them from being printed, not because the reviews themselves were problematic, but because the underlying movies were r-rated. the student's mother then filed suit in state court claiming violations of both the federal and state constitution. the new jersey supreme court did find that the school paper was not a public forum. however, because they held that the school did not have a consistent policy related to "pedagogical concerns" they felt that in this circumstance censorship was not warranted. the student press law center explains it best. "in desilets v. clearview regional board of education the new jersey supreme court rejected school officials’ justifications