kyle anderson of "entertainment weekly" positively compared the album to the late 90's releases by bad boy and said that big sean easily outshines all the featured artists on the album. at "usa today", edna gunderson called this, an "outstanding second album" that he "occasionally stumbles" in an effort that is a "smart set of slick club thumpers, tear-jerkers and introspective yarns." jon dolan of "rolling stone" commented saying, "the detroit mc gets over on congeniality and crisp delivery, even when his lyrics are pro forma." he also praised the album's production. at "the oakland press", gary graff noted that ""hall of fame" is still a solid, confident and diverse set that shows how much he's grown as both an mc and a writer since 'finally famous' came out in 2011." andrea aguilar of "hiphopdx" summarized the album stating, "as a whole, the feel-good album's set of eclectic beats doesn't disappoint, but it lacks diversity. most of sean's content still teems with predictable material risking leaving listeners disinterested. random skits also slightly interrupt the flow of the album, but if you're looking for motivational music centered on the money, the cars, the clothes and hoes, this album is sure to get plenty of replays on your ipod and local radio stations alike."