after getting cut in 1918, meyers joined the buffalo bisons of the international league; he batted .328 in 65 games. in 1919, meyers was hired as player-manager of the new haven weissmen in the eastern league; he batted .301 in 84 games. after getting replaced by danny murphy, meyers' last stop in baseball was catching for a semipro team in san diego in 1920. after getting booed at a semipro game, meyers decided to quit baseball and became a police chief for the mission indian agency.