"excellent" met with positive reception from music critics. at rapzilla, nyon smith rated the album a four out of five stars, stating that propaganda made "something that is life-applicable and life-relatable", but opined that, while a good poet, propaganda should have rapped more. ian harvey of "hm" rated the album four out of five stars, writing that propaganda is setting "the bar higher for the word than imagined." at "ccm magazine", andrew greer rated the album three stars out of five, noting the album's "easy oscillation between rap and spoken poetry." steve hayes of cross rhythms rated the album nine out of ten squares, stating that "the only pity is that it's so short." at jesus freak hideout, scott fryberger rated the album four-and-a-half stars out of five, commenting on the lyrical depth of the album. dwayne lacy of new release tuesday rated the album four stars out of five, saying that the release will leave the listener intellectually stimulated. at indie vision music, jessica cooper rated the album a perfect five stars, considering "excellent" "a superior piece of art stuffed with truth, bursting with originality, not lacking in boldness, that accurately conveys his brilliance as an artist." michael wildes of the christian manifesto rated the album four stars out of five, writing that "excellent is a paradox; it holds up pictures of broken images that we constantly look at throughout life, analyzes them for those values and calls them to a greater standard." at christian music zine, anthony peronto rated the album a perfect five stars, saying that "the poetry will widen your perspective while beautiful eulogy’s original production will surely keep your ears from falling into habituation."