according to sarmiento, these elements are crucial to an understanding of the argentine revolution, in which argentina gained independence from spain. although argentina's war of independence was prompted by the influence of european ideas, buenos aires was the only city that could achieve civilization. rural people participated in the war to demonstrate their physical strengths rather than because they wanted to civilize the country. in the end, the revolution was a failure because the barbaric instincts of the rural population led to the loss and dishonor of the civilized city—buenos aires.