ign's ed thompson stated "this is by no means a must have album and is not going to be remembered as the band's defining moment by any stretch of the imagination. but what "riot!" will do is serve as a foundation from which the kids can continue to learn, grow and improve." thompson also commented that it shows more maturity compared to similar bands. lewis p. at sputnikmusic described it as the best pop punk album of 2007, commenting "paramore might not be tapping into anything new, but it has finally hit its stride, making pop-punk anthems that match the praise." "alternative press" writer scott heisel commented "considering the median age of the band, the musicianship shown on riot! is mightily impressive...while the record as a whole may not be a home run, it’s solid stand-up double that keeps fueled by ramen’s inning alive for their next clean-up hitter." justin mabee at jesus freak hideout declared "while this new album may lack some of the spiritual depth that rocked their debut, the whole record retains a very positive feeling to it" mabee commented that the band "has come a long way" with the album since they have formed.