chapter five starts with sylvester demanding answers about the condom. they argue, and gwendolyn retorts with her own knowledge of sylvester's infidelity, saying she saw sylvester in the club the night before. he ignores that and demands she name names. she begins talking about friends of hers named tina and roxanne and also mentions chuck and rufus, which confuses sylvester. she then explains that she and cathy were friends in high school, and it was cathy who introduced gwendolyn to the police officer that stopped sylvester, confirming that the police officer was her secret lover.