during the hearing, which was presided over by supreme court of british columbia justice elaine adair, with hong kong's chief magistrate tong man (唐文) as co-commissioner, chen confirmed that cecilia cheung, gillian chung, bobo chan and rachel ngan were indeed involved. he testified that the photographs, taken from 2001 to 2006, were consensual, and were only shown to the women involved. he professed his "huge shock" at seeing the images on the internet, citing that he had deleted the images before sending his computer in for repairs in summer of 2006.