on october 7, 2014, the toronto blue jays acquired schultz from the diamondbacks on waivers. schultz was optioned to the triple-a buffalo bisons on march 25, 2015. he was recalled on may 29. schultz made his debut for the blue jays on june 2, pitching two relief innings against the washington nationals. on july 23, he earned his first mlb save, closing out a 5–2 win over the oakland athletics. schultz ended the year with a 0–1 record, 3.56 era, and 31 strikeouts in 43 total innings.