in football, hoyer compiled a 16–7 record (.696) as a two-year starter for head coach chuck kyle. in 2002, he completed 131-of-263 passes (49.8%) for 2,130 yards, 18 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions. in 2003, he completed 258-of-412 passes for 5,570 yards, 45 touchdowns, and 15 interceptions while leading his team to a 9–3 record. he was named "usa today" prep player of the week for his performance against shaker heights high school. he was an associated press division i all-state selection as a senior. he participated in the 2004 ohio all-star classic and the july 24 ohio-pennsylvania big 33 all-star game.