paul began dating youtuber and internet personality tana mongeau in april 2019. in june 2019, they were engaged to be married. many people did not believe that the engagement was real. on july 28 of that year, they got married in las vegas. "intouch" later reported that the couple had not gotten a marriage license before the ceremony. they said that it was not a legal marriage. buzzfeed said that paul and mongeau left the ceremony separately. the ceremony, which was available on pay-per-view for $50, was recorded by mtv. mongeau said that the ceremony was something "fun and lighthearted that we're obviously doing for fun and for content." the couple broke up in january 2020.