she acted with robert warwick at the west end theatre, in "the kiss waltz", in march 1912. "the blue envelope" was staged at the cort theatre in march 1916. the comedy was written by frank hatch and robert e. homans. walter jones, beth franklyn, reynolds, and belle theodore were some of the actors in the cast. as "the angel", reynolds was an adventuress whose actions were eventually frustrated. a critic observed that her background in light opera was somewhat of a hindrance in this role. specifically, she sang all her speeches and her very empty laugh sounded discomforting after a while.