I think people have a tendency to overrate this place because it is the only restaurant of its kind.  Don't get me wrong, the pasties are great, but there are a few reasons why this place isn't a four star restaurant:

1) It's overpriced.  You're paying almost 15 bucks for a lunch originally meant for miners.
2) It's cramped.  Good luck going there with more than one other person.
3) It's a little dingy.  Someone said the atmosphere is great.... Huh?  Not sure why a dark dining room that is six feet wide and crowded can be considered a nice atmosphere, unless maybe you grew up in a sewer.

Also, make sure you get there early if you want a table or food in a reasonable amount of time.