1)Challenge

Elements Criteria Score

The consent provides a description of the author’s challenge which  includes all important information

The consent describes the author’s challenge which includes some  information

The consent doesn’t provide adequate information on the author’s  challenge

The consent has a detailed description of selected tools which includes all  adequate information(e.g.,what it is and why the author selected it for her/his  challenge--which includes relevant video lecture reference )

The consents tool selections description can be improved by ...

2)Selection

NA

Feedback The consent’s description challenge can be improved by….

The consent describes the selected tool information(e.g.,what it is why the author  selected it for her/his challenge--which includes relevant video lecture reference)

The consent doesn’t provide sufficient describe of the selected tool

Feedback

NA

3)Application

The consent provides detailed description of application selected tool including  all adequate information (eg.,what tool was applied,what the author did  ineffectively/effectively)

The consent describes application of selected tool including  some  information (eg.,what tool was applied,what the author  did and how the tool was applied ineffectively/effectively)

The consent doesn’t describe the application of selected tool

The consent tool application description could be improved through  application Feedback

NA

The consent provides detailed description of the insight gained which includes all  adequate information (eg.,how an insight affects the author thinking about his/her  challenge and broad thinking about design)

The consent provides detailed description of the insight gained includes   adequate information (eg.,how an insight affects the author thinking about  his/her challenge and broad thinking about design)

The consent doesn’t provide sufficient insight gained by the author

The consent insight description can be improved through…  Feedback

4)Insight

NA

5)Approach

Feedback

The consent provides detailed description of an alternative approach including all adequate  information (eg.,Application of same selected tool or different one and stating the reasons  why)

The consent provides detailed description of an alternative approach including somel  adequate information (eg.,Application of same selected tool or different one and stating the  reasons why)

The consent doesn’t provide sufficient alternative approach

The consent approach can be improved by...

6)Organization

The consent is clear captivating distinct descriptions has logical flow

The consent is an sufficient length:descriptions aren’t clear or the flow is not logical

The consent is either worded overly or under developed

NA


1)Challenge Elements Criteria Score The consent provides a description of the author ’s challenge which includes all important information The consent describes the author ’s challenge which includes some information The consent does n’t provide adequate information on the author ’s challenge The consent has a detailed description of selected tools which includes all adequate information(e.g . ,what it is and why the author selected it for her / his challenge -- which includes relevant video lecture reference ) The consents tool selections description can be improved by ... 2)Selection NA Feedback The consent ’s description challenge can be improved by … . The consent describes the selected tool information(e.g . ,what it is why the author selected it for her / his challenge -- which includes relevant video lecture reference ) The consent does n’t provide sufficient describe of the selected tool Feedback NA 3)Application The consent provides detailed description of application selected tool including all adequate information ( eg . ,what tool was applied , what the author did ineffectively / effectively ) The consent describes application of selected tool including some information ( eg . ,what tool was applied , what the author did and how the tool was applied ineffectively / effectively ) The consent does n’t describe the application of selected tool The consent tool application description could be improved through application Feedback NA The consent provides detailed description of the insight gained which includes all adequate information ( eg . ,how an insight affects the author thinking about his / her challenge and broad thinking about design ) The consent provides detailed description of the insight gained includes adequate information ( eg . ,how an insight affects the author thinking about his / her challenge and broad thinking about design ) The consent does n’t provide sufficient insight gained by the author The consent insight description can be improved through … Feedback 4)Insight NA 5)Approach Feedback The consent provides detailed description of an alternative approach including all adequate information ( eg . ,Application of same selected tool or different one and stating the reasons why ) The consent provides detailed description of an alternative approach including somel adequate information ( eg . ,Application of same selected tool or different one and stating the reasons why ) The consent does n’t provide sufficient alternative approach The consent approach can be improved by ... 6)Organization The consent is clear captivating distinct descriptions has logical flow The consent is an sufficient length : descriptions are n’t clear or the flow is not logical The consent is either worded overly or under developed NA