" 
 :Yes. Because we're concerned with the facts, not what two people who saw the film but did not actually watch it think happened. ""Assume"" is making stuff up, it assumes anything BUT failure happened when third party sources from those involved with the film, the rules and dialogue explicitly said in the film, AND the actions shown in the film establish that by all logic of mice and men she has failed her assessment. She explicitly states this, Dredd explicitly states failing offences, explicitly points out her second failing offence, passing her anyway is his character growth. This is not something that is debatable, this is the fact of what happens, what is explicitly stated, what is explicitly shown within the confines of the film. Anything else is not. And your passive aggressive attempt to divert the term ""hard-headed"" onto your OPPONENT in the discussion, when you have failed to accept the outcome of the previous discussion, even though with Tenebrae here and Triplethreat there, that is three long term editors who all see that ""accept"" is appropriate based on the facts of the film. Nothing you can say is anything more than theory and flies in opposition of fact, so unless either of you can find a source from the director/writer/actor that says she had done anything but fail, this discussion should come to an end.   "