"::Your comments were not defamatory Askolnick?  What about statements as ""Brian Josephson's charge is a really sleazy lie"" and ""his [Josepshon's] misrepresentation of the facts regarding the statistical cut-off point for the test""?  Surely this can be proven true or false?  What facts do you allege he misrepresented?  I feel I should remind you have been warned by several others to stop your personal attacksand attacking the character of a Nobel Laureate is hardly an exception to Wikipedia policy regarding personal attacks.    

  
 "