That linked comment is really just a description of Scalia&#x27;s stance.  How can one say &quot;here&#x27;s why Scalia is bad&quot; without being called out for being inappropriate?  Even people who&#x27;ve listed their grievances with sources are being downvoted to gray.<p>Am I correct in saying a commenter is only encouraged to praise a person, and if that can&#x27;t be done, to only describe without opinion?<p>edit: and to be clear, this is comment is unrelated to the flamewar above